Susceptibility of sheep for scrapie as assessed by in vitro conversion of nine naturally occurring variants of PrP

Polymorphisms in the prion protein (PrP) gene are associated with phenotypic expression differences of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in animals and humans. In sheep, at least 10 different mutually exclusive polymorphisms are present in PrP. In this study, we determined the efficiency of the in vitro formation of protease-resistant PrP of nine sheep PrP allelic variants in order to gauge the relative susceptibility of sheep for scrapie. No detectable spontaneous protease-resistant PrP formation occurred under the cell-free conditions used. All nine host-encoded cellular PrP (PrP(C)) variants had distinct conversion efficiencies induced by PrP(Sc) isolated from sheep with three different homozygous PrP genotypes. In general, PrP allelic variants with polymorphisms at either codon 136 (Ala to Val) or codon 141 (Leu to Phe) and phylogenetic wild-type sheep PrP(C) converted with highest efficiency to protease-resistant forms, which indicates a linkage with a high susceptibility of sheep for scrapie. PrP(C) variants with polymorphisms at codons 171 (Gln to Arg), 154 (Arg to His), and to a minor extent 112 (Met to Thr) converted with low efficiency to protease-resistant isoforms. This finding indicates a linkage of these alleles with a reduced susceptibility or resistance for scrapie. In addition, PrP(Sc) with the codon 171 (Gln-to-His) polymorphism is the first variant reported to induce higher conversion efficiencies with heterologous rather than homologous PrP variants. The results of this study strengthen our views on polymorphism barriers and have further implications for scrapie control programs by breeding strategies.     

Polymorphic distribution of the ovine prion protein (PrP) gene in scrapie-infected sheep flocks in which embryo transfer was used to circumvent the transmissions of scrapie

The genetic sequence of the ovine prion protein (PrP) gene between codons 102 and 175 with emphasis on ovine PrP gene codons 136 and 171 was determined, and the polymorphic distribution of the ovine PrP gene in the scrapie-exposed Suffolk embryo donors and offspring from these donors that were transferred to scrapie-free recipient ewes was investigated in this study. The most common genotype was AA(136)QQ(171) (70% and 63% in the donor and offspring flocks, respectively), which is considered a high risk genotype in US Suffolk sheep. Although embryos were collected from scrapie-positive donors and many embryos had the high risk genotype, no scrapie occurred in the resulting offspring. Based upon the results of this study, we conclude that vertical transmission of scrapie can be circumvented using embryo transfer procedures even when the offspring have the high risk genotype.     

The PrPC C1 fragment derived from the ovine A136R154R171 PRNP allele is highly abundant in sheep brain and inhibits fibrillisation of full-length PrPC protein in vitro

Expression of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) is crucial for the development of prion diseases. Resistance to prion diseases can result from reduced availability of the prion protein or from amino acid changes in the prion protein sequence. We propose here that increased production of a natural PrP α-cleavage fragment, C1, is also associated with resistance to disease. We show, in brain tissue, that ARR homozygous sheep, associated with resistance to disease, produced PrP^C comprised of 25% more C1 fragment than PrP^C from the disease-susceptible ARQ homozygous and highly susceptible VRQ homozygous animals. Only the C1 fragment derived from the ARR allele inhibits in-vitro fibrillisation of other allelic PrP^C variants. We propose that the increased α-cleavage of ovine ARR PrP^C contributes to a dominant negative effect of this polymorphism on disease susceptibility. Furthermore, the significant reduction in PrP^C β-cleavage product C2 in sheep of the ARR/ARR genotype compared to ARQ/ARQ and VRQ/VRQ genotypes, may add to the complexity of genetic determinants of prion disease susceptibility.     

The stability and aggregation of ovine prion protein associated with classical and atypical scrapie correlates with the ease of unwinding of helix-2

Susceptibility to scrapie disease in sheep, the archetypal prion disease, correlates with polymorphisms within the ovine PrP (prion-related protein) gene. The VRQ (Val136Arg154Gln171) and AL141RQ (Ala136Leu141Arg154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with classical scrapie, whereas the ARR (Ala136Arg154Arg171), AF141RQ (Ala136Phe141Arg154Gln171) and AHQ (Ala136His154Gln171) allelic variants are associated with atypical scrapie. Recent studies have suggested that there are differences in the stability of PrPSc (abnormal disease-specific conformation of PrP) associated with these different forms of scrapie. To address which structural features of ovine PrP may contribute to this difference, in the present study we have investigated the conformational stability and susceptibility to aggregation of allelic variants of ovine PrP associated with classical or atypical scrapie. We find that the melting temperature of ovine recombinant VRQ and AL141RQ PrP is higher than that of AF141RQ, AHQ and ARR. In addition, monoclonal-antibody studies show that the region around helix-1 of VRQ and AL141RQ is less accessible compared with other ovine PrP allelic variants. Furthermore, the extent of both the structural change to copper-ion-treatment and denaturant-induced aggregation was reduced in PrP associated with atypical scrapie compared with PrP associated with classical scrapie. Through the use of molecular dynamics simulations we have found that these biochemical and biophysical properties of ovine PrP correlate with the ease of unwinding of helix-2 and a concurrent conformational change of the helix-2-helix-3 loop. These results reveal significant differences in the overall stability and potential for aggregation of different allelic variants of ovine PrP and consequently have implications for the differences in stability of PrPSc associated with classical and atypical scrapie.     

Allelic frequencies of an ovine scrapie susceptibility gene

Abstract

The allelic frequencies of an ovine gene associated with susceptibility to scrapie was analyzed in a sample of 30 scrapie affected sheep and 545 clinically normal sheep from 12 flocks. The allele encoding glutamine at codon 171 occurred at a frequency of 0.76 in the overall population. All 30 scrapie affected sheep were homozygous for glutamine at codon 171. This genotype was observed in 56.5% of the clinically normal sheep. None of the 30 scrapie affected sheep carried the allele encoding Valine at codon 136 although this allele was observed in 2/12 flocks sampled.     

In vitro amplification of scrapie and chronic wasting disease PrPres using baculovirus-expressed recombinant PrP as substrate

Protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) is an in vitro simulation of prion replication, which relies on the use of normal brain homogenate derived from host species as substrate for the specific amplification of abnormal prion protein, PrP^Sc. Studies showed that recombinant cellular PrP, PrP^C, expressed in Escherichia coli lacks N-glycosylation and an glycophosphatidyl inositol anchor (GPI) and therefore may not be the most suitable substrate in seeded PMCA reactions to recapitulate prion conversion in vitro. In this study, we expressed 2 PRNP genotypes of sheep, V₁₃₆L₁₄₁R₁₅₄Q₁₇₁ and A₁₃₆F₁₄₁R₁₅₄Q₁₇₁, and one genotype of white-tailed deer (Q₉₅G₉₆, X₁₃₂,Y₂₁₆) using the baculovirus expression system and evaluated their suitability as substrates in seeded-PMCA. It has been reported that host-encoded mammalian RNA molecules and divalent cations play a role in the pathogenesis of prion diseases, and RNA molecules have also been shown to improve the sensitivity of PMCA assays. Therefore, we also assessed the effect of co-factors, such as prion-specific mRNA molecules and a divalent cation, manganese, on protein conversion. Here, we report that baculovirus-expressed recombinant PrP^C shows a glycoform and GPI-anchor profile similar to mammalian brain-derived PrP^C and supports amplification of PrP^Sc and PrP^CWD derived from prion-affected animals in a single round of seeded PMCA in the absence of exogenous co-factors. Addition of species-specific in vitro transcribed PrP mRNA molecules stimulated the conversion efficiency resulting in increased PrP^Sc or PrP^CWD production. Addition of 2 to 20 μM of manganese chloride (MnCl₂) to unseeded PMCA resulted in conversion of recombinant PrP^C to protease-resistant PrP. Collectively, we demonstrate, for the first time, that baculovirus expressed sheep and deer PrP can serve as a substrate in protein misfolding cyclic amplification for sheep and deer prions in the absence of additional exogenous co-factors.     

Assessment of the genetic susceptibility of sheep to scrapie by protein misfolding cyclic amplification and comparison with experimental scrapie transmission studies

The susceptibility of sheep to scrapie is influenced mainly by the prion protein polymorphisms A136V, R154H, and Q171R/H. Here we analyzed the ability of protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) to model the genetic susceptibility of sheep to scrapie. For this purpose, we studied the efficiency of brain homogenates from sheep with different PrP genotypes to support PrP^Sc amplification by PMCA using an ARQ/ARQ scrapie inoculum. The results were then compared with those obtained in vivo using the same sheep breed, genotypes, and scrapie inoculum. Genotypes associated with susceptibility (ARQ/ARQ, ARQ/AHQ, and AHQ/ARH) were able to sustain PrP^Sc amplification in PMCA reactions, while genotypes associated with resistance to scrapie (ARQ/ARR and ARR/ARR) were unable to support the in vitro conversion. The incubation times of the experimental infection were then compared with the in vitro amplification factors. Linear regression analysis showed that the efficiency of in vitro PrP^Sc amplification of the different genotypes was indeed inversely proportional to their incubation times. Finally, the rare ARQK₁₇₆/ARQK₁₇₆ genotype, for which no in vivo data are available, was studied by PMCA. No amplification was obtained, suggesting ARQK₁₇₆/ARQK₁₇₆ as an additional genotype associated with resistance, at least to the isolate tested. Our results indicate a direct correlation between the ability of different PrP genotypes to undergo PrP^C-to-PrP^Sc conversion by PMCA and their in vivo susceptibility and point to PMCA as an alternative to transmission studies and a potential tool to test the susceptibility of numerous sheep PrP genotypes to a variety of prion sources.     

Allelic Origin of Protease-Sensitive and Protease-Resistant Prion Protein Isoforms in Gerstmann-Str?ussler-Scheinker Disease with the P102L Mutation

Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker (GSS) disease is a dominantly inherited prion disease associated with point mutations in the Prion Protein gene. The most frequent mutation associated with GSS involves a proline-to-leucine substitution at residue 102 of the prion protein, and is characterized by marked variability at clinical, pathological and molecular levels. Previous investigations of GSS P102L have shown that disease-associated pathological prion protein, or PrP^Sc, consists of two main conformers, which under exogenous proteolysis generates a core fragment of 21 kDa and an internal fragment of 8 kDa. Both conformers are detected in subjects with spongiform degeneration, whereas only the 8 kDa fragment is recovered in cases lacking spongiosis. Several studies have reported an exclusive derivation of protease-resistant PrP^Sc isoforms from the mutated allele; however, more recently, the propagation of protease-resistant wild-type PrP^Sc has been described. Here we analyze the molecular and pathological phenotype of six GSS P102L cases characterized by the presence of 21 and 8 kDa PrP fragments and two subjects with only the 8 kDa PrP fragment. Using sensitive protein separation techniques and Western blots with antibodies differentially recognizing wild-type and mutant PrP we observed a range of PrP^Sc allelic conformers, either resistant or sensitive to protease treatment in all investigated subjects. Additionally, tissue deposition of protease-sensitive wild-type PrP^Sc molecules was seen by conventional PrP immunohistochemistry and paraffin-embedded tissue blot. Our findings enlarge the spectrum of conformational allelic PrP^Sc quasispecies propagating in GSS P102L thus providing a molecular support to the spectrum of disease phenotypes, and, in addition, impact the diagnostic role of PrP immunohistochemistry in prion diseases.     

Lambs with scrapie susceptible genotypes have higher postnatal survival

Background

Prion protein (PrP) alleles associated with scrapie susceptibility persist in many sheep populations even with high frequencies despite centuries of selection against them. This suggests that scrapie susceptibility alleles have a pleiotropic effect or are associated with fitness or other traits that have been subject to selection.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We genotyped all lambs in two scrapie-free Scottish Blackface sheep flocks for polymorphisms at codons 136, 154 and 171 of the PrP gene. We tested potential associations of the PrP genotype with lamb viability at birth and postnatal survival using a complementary log-log link function and a Weibull proportional hazard model, respectively. Here we show there is an association between PrP genotype, as defined by polymorphisms at codons 154 ad 171, and postnatal lamb survival in the absence of scrapie. Sheep carrying the wild-type ARQ allele have higher postnatal survival rates than sheep carrying the more scrapie-resistant alleles (ARR or AHQ).

Conclusion

The PrP genotypes associated with higher susceptibility to scrapie are associated with improved postnatal survival in the absence of the disease. This association helps to explain the existence, and in many instances the high frequency, of the ARQ allele in sheep populations.     

Prion protein—Semisynthetic prion protein (PrP) variants with posttranslational modifications

Deciphering the pathophysiologic events in prion diseases is challenging, and the role of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) such as glypidation and glycosylation remains elusive due to the lack of homogeneous protein preparations. So far, experimental studies have been limited in directly analyzing the earliest events of the conformational change of cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc) that further propagates PrP^C misfolding and aggregation at the cellular membrane, the initial site of prion infection, and PrP misfolding, by a lack of suitably modified PrP variants. PTMs of PrP, especially attachment of the glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor, have been shown to be crucially involved in the PrP^Sc formation. To this end, semisynthesis offers a unique possibility to understand PrP behavior invitro and invivo as it provides access to defined site‐selectively modified PrP variants. This approach relies on the production and chemoselective linkage of peptide segments, amenable to chemical modifications, with recombinantly produced protein segments. In this article, advances in understanding PrP conversion using semisynthesis as a tool to obtain homogeneous posttranslationally modified PrP will be discussed.     

Structural differences between allelic variants of the ovine prion protein revealed by molecular dynamics simulations

We have modeled ovine prion protein (residues 119-233) based on NMR structures of PrP from other mammalian species. Modeling of the C-terminal domain of ovine PrP predicts three helices: helix-1 (residues 147-155), flanked by two short beta-strands; helix-2 (residues 176-197), and helix-3 (residues 203-229). Molecular dynamics simulations on this model of ovine PrP have determined structural differences between allelic variants. At neutral pH, limited root mean-squared (RMS) fluctuations were seen in the region of helix-1; between beta-strand-2 and residue 171, and the loop connecting helix-2 and helix-3. At low pH, these RMS fluctuations increased and showed allelic variation. The extent of RMS fluctuation between beta-strand 2 and residue 171 was ARR > ARQ > VRQ. This order was reversed for the loop region connecting helix-2 and helix-3. Although all three variants have the potential to display an extended helix at the C-terminal region of helix-1, the major influence of the VRQ allele was to restrict the conformations of the Asn162 and Arg139 side-chains. Variations observed in the simulations in the vicinity of helix-1 correlated with reactivity of C-terminal specific anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies with peripheral blood cells from scrapie-susceptible and -resistant genotypes of sheep: cells from VRQ homozygous sheep showed uniform reactivity, while cells from ARQ and ARR homozygous sheep showed variable binding. Our data show that molecular dynamics simulations can be used to determine structural differences between allelic variants of ovine PrP. The binding of anti-PrP monoclonal antibodies to ovine blood cells may validate these structural predictions.     

Characterization of a prion protein (PrP) gene from rabbit; a species with apparent resistance to infection by prions

The prion protein gene (PrP) encodes a cellular protein of unknown function. A conformational isoform of this protein is involved in the neurodegenerative prion diseases. To facilitate the identification of structurally and antigenically important regions within the PrP molecule, the rabbit PrP open reading frame (ORF) was cloned and characterised. There is 82–87% identity at the nucleotide sequence level and 88–93% identity at the amino acid (aa) sequence level, between the rabbit gene and PrP sequences of other mammals. The rabbit gene shares structural and organisational features common to all known PrP genes signifying that it is the rabbit PrP gene. Comparison of the rabbit PrP aa sequence with PrP aa sequences from different species revealed several potential epitopes. Two anti-ovine PrP peptide Ab raised in rabbits, 168-92 and 98-92, confirmed that two separate cross-reacting epitopes segregate with single aa differences between rabbit and sheep PrP at positions 43 and 99 of the rabbit PrP polypeptide. The presence of these epitopes correlates with the species recognition patterns of previously published Ab. The usefulness of the rabbit PrP gene sequence in predicting antigenic regions within the PrP proteins of various species is illustrated. The structure of the rabbit PrP protein in relation to rabbits' apparent resistance to infection by prions is discussed.     

Scrapie

Scrapie and other transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are characterized by similar pathology, biochemistry and genetics. The PrP protein and its conversion to the disease-related isoform, PrP^sc, are crucial for the development of all TSEs. Although scrapie is more often studied in laboratory rodents, it is not a natural disease of these animals, and much can be learned from the normal hosts, sheep. Disease incidence is linked to polymorphisms and mutations of the PrP gene. The complex relationships between PrP genotype and the survival of sheep subjected to scrapie infection are now being investigated in terms of the different structure of the PrP protein molecules produced by each allele. It is these structures and their differing abilities to convert to PrP^sc that hold the key to understanding why TSEs occur.     

Tissue- and cell type-specific modification of prion protein (PrP)-like protein Doppel, which affects PrP endoproteolysis

A prion protein (PrP)-like protein, Doppel (Dpl) is a homologue of cellular PrP (PrP^C). Immunoblotting revealed heterogeneous glycosylation patterns of Dpl and PrP^C in several cell lines and tissues, including brain and testis. To investigate whether the glycosylation and modification of Dpl and PrP^C could influence each other, PrP gene (Prnp)-deficient neuronal cells, transfected with Prnp and/or the Dpl gene (Prnd), were analyzed by deglycosylation with peptide N-glycosidase F. The modification of Dpl was not influenced by PrP^C, whereas an N-terminally truncated fragment of PrP^C was reduced by Dpl expression. These results indicated that Dpl was glycosylated in a cell type- and tissue-specific manner regardless of PrP^C, while PrP^C endoproteolysis was modulated by Dpl expression.     

Lack of Prion Accumulation in Lymphoid Tissues of PRNP ARQ/ARR Sheep Intracranially Inoculated with the Agent of Scrapie

Sheep scrapie is a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy that can be transmitted horizontally. The prion protein gene (PRNP) profoundly influences the susceptibility of sheep to the scrapie agent and the tissue levels and distribution of PrP^Sc in affected sheep. The purpose of this study was to compare the survival time and PrP^Sc tissue distribution in sheep with highly resistant and highly susceptible PRNP genotypes after intracranial inoculation of the agent of scrapie. Five sheep each of genotype VRQ/VRQ, VRQ/ARR or ARQ/ARR were inoculated. Sheep were euthanized when clinical signs of scrapie became severe. Clinical signs, microscopic lesions, and western blot profiles were uniform across genotypes and consistent with manifestations of classical scrapie. Mean survival time differences were associated with the 171 polymorphic site with VRQ/VRQ sheep surviving 18 months, whereas VRQ/ARR and ARQ/ARR sheep survived 60 and 56 months, respectively. Labeling of PrP^Sc by immunohistochemistry revealed similar accumulations in central nervous system tissues regardless of host genotype. Immunoreactivity for PrP^Sc in lymphoid tissue was consistently abundant in VRQ/VRQ, present but confined to tonsil or retropharyngeal lymph node in 4/5 VRQ/ARR, and totally absent in ARQ/ARR sheep. The results of this study demonstrate the susceptibility of sheep with the ARQ/ARR genotype to scrapie by the intracranial inoculation route with PrP^Sc accumulation in CNS tissues, but prolonged incubation times and lack of PrP^Sc in lymphoid tissue.     

Functionally Relevant Domains of the Prion Protein Identified In Vivo

The prion consists essentially of PrP^Sc, a misfolded and aggregated conformer of the cellular protein PrP^C. Whereas PrP^C deficient mice are clinically healthy, expression of PrP^C variants lacking its central domain (PrP_ΔCD), or of the PrP-related protein Dpl, induces lethal neurodegenerative syndromes which are repressed by full-length PrP. Here we tested the structural basis of these syndromes by grafting the amino terminus of PrP^C (residues 1–134), or its central domain (residues 90–134), onto Dpl. Further, we constructed a soluble variant of the neurotoxic PrP_ΔCD mutant that lacks its glycosyl phosphatidyl inositol (GPI) membrane anchor. Each of these modifications abrogated the pathogenicity of Dpl and PrP_ΔCD in transgenic mice. The PrP-Dpl chimeric molecules, but not anchorless PrP_ΔCD, ameliorated the disease of mice expressing truncated PrP variants. We conclude that the amino proximal domain of PrP exerts a neurotrophic effect even when grafted onto a distantly related protein, and that GPI-linked membrane anchoring is necessary for both beneficial and deleterious effects of PrP and its variants.     

Molecular cloning and polymorphism analysis of the prion protein gene in Tan sheep of Ningxia, China

The resistance or susceptibility of sheep to scrapie is associated with polymorphisms of the prion protein gene (PRNP), particularly, single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in amino acid positions 136, 154 and 171. The prion protein (PrP) gene sequence and the deduced amino acid alignment of prion protein in Tan sheep, a local Chinese sheep breed traditionally raised in Ningxia, northwestern China, were determined and variability of the PrP amino acids sequence was analyzed in this study. The PrP nucleic acids and amino acids sequences of 112 Tan sheep were highly homogenous, although polymorphism of the PrP gene was detected at several sites, particularly codons 106, 154, and 171. The analysis of both sequences revealed that the most predominant allele at codons 136, 154 and 171 in Tan sheep was ARQ, which was known to be associated with high susceptibility to scrapie in sheep. The result suggests that Tan sheep is potentially susceptible to scrapie. Our findings provide valuable information for future breeding projects to scrapie resistance in Tan sheep.     

A novel anti‐prion protein monoclonal antibody and its single‐chain fragment variable derivative with ability to inhibit abnormal prion protein accumulation in cultured cells

mAbs T1 and T2 were established by immunizing PrP gene ablated mice with recombinant MoPrP of residues 121–231. Both mAbs were cross‐reactive with PrP from hamster, sheep, cattle and deer. A linear epitope of mAb T1 was identified at residues 137–143 of MoPrP and buried in PrP^C expressed on the cell surface. mAb T1 showed no inhibitory effect on accumulation of PrP^Sc in cultured scrapie‐infected neuroblastoma (ScN2a) cells. In contrast, mAb T2 recognized a discontinuous epitope ranged on, or structured by, residues 132–217 and this epitope was exposed on the cell surface PrP^C. mAb T2 showed an excellent inhibitory effect on PrP^Sc accumulation in vitro at a 50% inhibitory concentration of 0.02 μg/ml (0.14 nM). The scFv form of mAb T2 (scFv T2) was secreted in neuroblastoma (N2a58) cell cultures by transfection through eukaryotic secretion vector. Coculturing of ScN2a cells with scFv T2‐producing N2a58 cells induced a clear inhibitory effect on PrP^Sc accumulation, suggesting that scFv T2 could potentially be an immunotherapeutic tool for prion diseases by inhibition of PrP^Sc accumulation.