Different measures of “genome-wide” DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues

DNA methylation of CpGs located in two types of repetitive elements—LINE1 (L1) and Alu—is used to assess “global” changes in DNA methylation in studies of human disease and environmental exposure. L1 and Alu contribute close to 30% of all base pairs in the human genome and transposition of repetitive elements is repressed through DNA methylation. Few studies have investigated whether repetitive element DNA methylation is associated with DNA methylation at other genomic regions, or the biological and technical factors that influence potential associations. Here, we assess L1 and Alu DNA methylation by Pyrosequencing of consensus sequences and using subsets of probes included in the Illumina Infinium HumanMethylation27 BeadChip array. We show that evolutionary age and assay method affect the assessment of repetitive element DNA methylation. Additionally, we compare Pyrosequencing results for repetitive elements to average DNA methylation of CpG islands, as assessed by array probes classified into strong, weak and non-islands. We demonstrate that each of these dispersed sequences exhibits different patterns of tissue-specific DNA methylation. Correlation of DNA methylation suggests an association between L1 and weak CpG island DNA methylation in some of the tissues examined. We caution, however, that L1, Alu and CpG island DNA methylation are distinct measures of dispersed DNA methylation and one should not be used in lieu of another. Analysis of DNA methylation data is complex and assays may be influenced by environment and pathology in different or complementary ways.     

Response to “Different measures of ‘genome-wide’ DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues”

I found the research paper “Different measures of ‘genome-wide’ DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues” by Price ME and colleagues in the June 2012 issue of Epigenetics to be an interesting read, but it contains errors in regards to the use of the MethylFlash Methylated DNA Quantification Kit. The text contained in the “Global DNA Methylation” paragraph under the “Methods” section of the paper claims that the kit was used by “following the manufacturer’s protocol.” I find that this is quite misleading to the reader as we have identified, based on the original electronic publication ahead of print, that the steps had not been correctly carried out.

The original text was the following: “DNA was hybridized to wells treated to have a high affinity for DNA. The wells were washed with a 5-mC-specific capture antibody followed by a detection antibody. The absorbance (or optical density) of each well was measured using a microplate spectrophotometer. Correlation of technical replicates was poor (r = 0.09, p = 0.72) using this kit.” However, the user guide of this kit clearly states that DNA is bound, not hybridized, to the strip wells and that the wells should be washed with the included Wash Buffer rather than a “5-mC-specific capture antibody.”

Therefore, it is not surprising that the result or correlation of replicates was poor and that the authors’ “results were variable” due to improper use of the kit. Based on our quality control tests and feedback from the vast amount of users of this popular kit, the variation between replicates should be less than 10% with R value > 0.9 (p < 0.01), assuming proper user performance according to the product manual.

I hope this helps to correct the misinformation presented in the paper as I feel that it is important to promote accuracy on behalf of the epigenetic research community. I also kindly encourage any users of an Epigentek product to work with our very knowledgeable technical support team should they have any difficulties.     

Response to: “Response to Different measures of 'genome-wide' DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues

We are responding to a Letter to the Editor addressing the Method section of our paper “Different measures of ‘genome-wide’ DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues.” The letter raised concerns that the protocol for Epigentek’s MethylFlash kit was followed incorrectly based on the wording of an online publication of our article. We admittedly made an error in the language used to describe the MethylFlash protocol in our initial submission and thus this was corrected as soon as it was brought to our attention. However, the error was only in language and not procedure. We are confident that the protocol was followed as stated in the insert provided with the MethylFlash^TM Methylated DNA Quantification kit (Colorimetric).We are responding to a Letter to the Editor addressing the Method section of our paper “Different measures of ‘genome-wide’ DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues” (Price ME, Cotton AM, PeÒaherrera MS, McFadden DE, Kobor MS, Robinson WP. Different measures of “genome-wide” DNA methylation exhibit unique properties in placental and somatic tissues. Epigenetics 2012; 7: 652–63; PMID: 22531475; 10.4161/epi.20221). The letter raised concerns that the protocol for Epigentek’s MethylFlash kit was followed incorrectly based on the wording of an online publication of our article. We admittedly made an error in the language used to describe the MethylFlash protocol in our initial submission and thus this was corrected as soon as it was brought to our attention. However, the error was only in language and not procedure. We are confident that the protocol was followed as stated in the insert provided with the MethylFlash^TM Methylated DNA Quantification kit (Colorimetric).     

α-Satellite DNA methylation in normal individuals and in ICF patients: heterogeneous methylation of constitutive heterochromatin in adult and fetal tissues

The methylation profile of ten α-satellites was investigated in normal individuals and in ICF (Immunodeficiency, Centromeric instability, Facial abnormalities) patients. Two out of three ICF patients showed modified methylation of these sequences, reproducing a placental profile. CENP-B boxes, the binding sites of centromeric protein B, were always skewed toward nonmethylation. Unexpected results were observed in normal individuals: in somatic adult tissues the methylation pattern of α-satellite DNA varied between chromosomes, and in fetal tissues these satellites were homogeneously undermethylated. Detailed methylation analysis of CENP-B boxes revealed that unmethylated α-satellite units coexist with thoroughly methylated regions. These observations showed that the two major components of constitutive heterochromatin are differently methylated in normal somatic and fetal tissues, since classical satellites are consistently methylated. The definite changes in the methylation profile of heterochromatin in somatic chromosomes and the asynchronous timing of methylation of classical and α-satellites during development may reflect specific roles of highly repeated sequences in genomic organization. Received: 29 October 1996 / Revised: 17 December 1996     

DNA methylation in the human γδβ-globin locus in erythroid and nonerythroid tissues

We have analyzed DNA modification in the human γδβ-globin gene region at 17 cleavage sites of restriction endonucleases which are unable to cleave DNA if 5-methylcytosine is present at certain positions in their respective cleavage sites. Using this criterion, all sites tested in the globin gene region are fully modified in the germ line (sperm) DNA. In somatic tissues, however, methyl groups are absent at specific sites in the globin gene region. In tissues not expressing the genes, these losses range from one of these cleavage sites in lymphocyte DNA to essentially all of these sites in the entire region in placental DNA. In the DNA of tissues expressing the globin genes, the region surrounding and including the genes expressed shows a low level of modification, whereas the neighboring DNA regions have a high level of modification. The data suggest that a low level of DNA methylation may be a necessary, but not a sufficient, condition for gene expression in higher eucaryotes.     

Adaptations of placental and cord blood ABCA1 DNA methylation profile to maternal metabolic status

In utero environmental perturbations have been associated with epigenetic changes in the offspring and a lifelong susceptibility to cardiovascular diseases (CVD). DNA methylation at the ATP-binding cassette transporter A1 (ABCA1) gene was previously associated with CVD, but whether these epigenetic marks respond to changes in the maternal environment is unknown. This study was undertaken to assess the associations between the maternal metabolic profile and ABCA1 DNA methylation levels in placenta and cord blood. Placenta and cord blood samples were obtained at delivery from 100 women including 26 with impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) diagnosed following a 75 g-oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) between week 24 and 28 of gestation. ABCA1 DNA methylation and mRNA levels were measured using bisulfite pyrosequencing and quantitative real-time PCR, respectively. We report that ABCA1 DNA methylation levels on the maternal side of the placenta are correlated with maternal high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) levels (r < –0.21; P < 0.04) and glucose levels 2 h post-OGTT (r = 0.25; P = 0.02). On the fetal side of the placenta, ABCA1 DNA methylation levels are associated with cord blood triglyceride levels (r = –0.28; P = 0.01). ABCA1 DNA methylation variability on both sides of the placenta are also associated with ABCA1 mRNA levels (r < –0.35; P = 0.05). As opposed to placenta, cord blood DNA methylation levels are negatively correlated with maternal glucose 2 h post-OGTT (r = –0.26; P = 0.02). In conclusion, the epivariations observed in placenta and cord blood likely contribute to an optimal materno–fetal cholesterol transfer. These in utero epigenetics adaptations may also potentially trigger the long-term susceptibility of the newborn to dyslipidemia and CVD.     

Influences of geometrical and mechanical properties of bone tissues in mandible behaviour – experimental and numerical predictions

The properties and geometry of bone in the mandible play a key role in mandible behaviour during a person’s lifetime, and attention needs to be paid to the influence of bone properties. We analysed the effect of bone geometry, size and bone properties in mandible behaviour, experimenting on cadaveric mandibles and FE models. The study was developed using the geometry of a cadaveric mandible without teeth. Three models of cadaveric condyles were experimentally tested with instrumented with four rosettes, and a condyle reaction of 300 N. Four finite element models were considered to validate the experiments and analyse mandible behaviour. One numeric model was simulated with 10 muscles in a quasi-static condition. The experimental results present different condyle stiffness’s, of 448, 215 and 254 N/mm. The values presented in the rosettes are influenced by bone geometry and bone thickness; maximum value was ?600 με in rosette #4, and the maximum strain difference between mandibles was 111%. The numerical results show that bone density decreases and strain distribution increases in the thinner mandible regions. Nevertheless, the global behaviour of the structure remains similar, but presents different strain magnitudes. The study shows the need to take into account bone characteristics and their evolutions in order to improve implant design and fixation throughout the patient life. The change in bone stiffness promotes a change in maximum strain distribution with same global behaviour.     

The state of DNA methylation of human ϵ-globin gene in erythroid and non-erythroid cells

The extent of DNA methylation within the embryonic human ϵ-globin gene domain was studied in erythroid and non-erythroid cell lines. The results obtained show that the human ϵ-globin gene is totally methylated at all sites tested in tissues where it is not expressed, i.e. blood leucocytes. In the erythroid cell lines, K562 and PUTKO, both forced to embryonic differentiation by induction with haemin, the level of methylation is reduced compared with that observed in blood leucocytes. In the nonerythroid cell lines HeLa and Raji, where the human ϵ-globin gene is not expressed, the overall level of methylation in all sites tested is lower compared with that in erythroid cell lines.     

Global DNA methylation profile at LINE-1 repeats and promoter methylation of genes involved in DNA damage response and repair pathways in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells in response to γ-radiation

Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry - DNA methylation is an epigenetic mechanism, which plays an important role in gene regulation. The present study evaluated DNA methylation profile of LINE1...     

N-Acetyl-β-d-hexosaminidase component A. Different forms in human tissues and fluids

1. Hexosaminidase A of human serum was resolved into two components, a minor form with properties identical with those of the single hexosaminidase A component of human liver, and a major form with significantly different properties. 2. The major serum hexosaminidase A form was eluted from a DEAE-cellulose column at a lower salt concentration than that required to elute the liver form. 3. A multiple-pass technique was used to elute the major serum enzyme A from a Sephadex G-150 column before that of liver enzyme A. 4. Clostridium perfringens neuraminidase converted the major component of serum hexosaminidase A into a form that was held less tightly by DEAE-cellulose, but the minor component of the A enzyme of serum, and the A enzyme of liver were not affected. 5. The hexosaminidase A from tears was similar to the A enzyme from serum, whereas those from several human tissues and from urine and lymph were similar to the liver form. 6. The A enzyme from serum may be derived from the A enzyme from liver by glycosylation before secretion.     

Increased detectability of somatic changes in the DNA from human tumours after probing with “synthetic” and “genome-derived” hypervariable multilocus probes

Summary DNA fingerprinting with two minisatellite (33.15, M13) and two simple repeat probes [(GACA)₄, (CAC)₄/ (GTG)₅] was performed to screen for somatic changes in the DNA from various solid human tumours in comparison with constitutional DNA from the same patient. Loss of bands or changes in band intensitities were observed. Together the probes 33.15 and (CAC)₅/(GTG)₅ detected deviating fingerprint patterns in 63% of the colorectal carcinomas investigated. In mammary and stomach carcinomas, only 1/11 and 2/11 tumours, respectively, showed differences with either of the three probes, 33.15, (GACA)₄ and (CAC)₅/(GTG)₅.     

Association of cigarette smoking and CRP levels with DNA methylation in α-1 antitrypsin deficiency

Alpha-1 antitrypsin (AAT) deficiency and tobacco smoking are confirmed risk factors for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. We hypothesized that variable DNA methylation would be associated with smoking and inflammation, as reflected by the level of C-Reactive Protein (CRP) in AAT-deficient subjects. Methylation levels of 1,411 autosomal CpG sites from the Illumina GoldenGate Methylation Cancer Panel I were analyzed in 316 subjects. Associations of five smoking behaviors and CRP levels with individual CpG sites and average methylation levels were assessed using non-parametric testing, linear regression and linear mixed effect models, with and without adjustment for age and gender. Univariate linear regression analysis revealed that methylation levels of 16 CpG sites significantly associated with ever-smoking status. A CpG site in the TGFBI gene was the only site associated with ever-smoking after adjustment for age and gender. No highly significant associations existed between age at smoking initiation, pack-years smoked, duration of smoking, and time since quitting smoking as predictors of individual CpG site methylation levels. However, ever-smoking and younger age at smoking initiation associated with lower methylation level averaged across all sites. DNA methylation at CpG sites in the RUNX3, JAK3 and KRT1 genes associated with CRP levels. The most significantly associated CpG sites with gender and age mapped to the CASP6 and FZD9 genes, respectively. In summary, this study identified multiple potential candidate CpG sites associated with ever-smoking and CRP level in AAT-deficient subjects. Phenotypic variability in Mendelian diseases may be due to epigenetic factors.