The refined crystal structure of subtilisin Carlsberg at 2.5 A resolution

We report here the X-ray crystal structure of native subtilisin Carlsberg, solved at 2.5 A resolution by molecular replacement and refined by restrained least squares to a crystallographic residual (Formula see text): of 0.206. we compare this structure to the crystal structure of subtilisin BPN'. We find that, despite 82 amino acid substitutions and one deletion in subtilisin Carlsberg relative to subtilisin BPN', the structures of these enzymes are remarkably similar. We calculate an r.m.s. difference between equivalent alpha-carbon positions in subtilisin Carlsberg and subtilisin BPN' of only 0.55 A. This confirms previous reports of extensive structural homology between these two subtilisins based on X-ray crystal structures of the complex of eglin-c with subtilisin Carlsberg [McPhalen, C.A., Schnebli, H.P. and James, M.N.G. (1985) FEBS Lett., 188, 55; Bode, W., Papamokos, E. and Musil, D. (1987) Eur. J. Biochem., 166, 673-692]. In addition, we find that the native active sites of subtilisins Carlsberg and BPN' are virtually identical. While conservative substitutions at residues 217 and 156 may have subtle effects on the environments of substrate-binding sites S1' and S1 respectively, we find no obvious structural correlate for reports that subtilisins Carlsberg and BPN' differ in their recognition of model substrates. In particular, we find no evidence that the hydrophobic binding pocket S1 in subtilisin Carlsberg is 'deeper', 'narrower' or 'less polar' than the corresponding binding site in subtilisin BPN'.     

Crystal structure of the alkaline proteinase Savinase from Bacillus lentus at 1.4 A resolution.

Savinase (EC3.4.21.14) is secreted by the alkalophilic bacterium Bacillus lentus and is a representative of that subgroup of subtilisin enzymes with maximum stability in the pH range 7 to 10 and high activity in the range 8 to 12. It is therefore of major industrial importance for use in detergents. The crystal structure of the native form of Savinase has been refined using X-ray diffraction data to 1.4 A resolution. The starting model was that of subtilisin Carlsberg. A comparison to the structures of the closely related subtilisins Carlsberg and BPN' and to the more distant thermitase and proteinase K is presented. The structure of Savinase is very similar to those of homologous Bacillus subtilisins. There are two calcium ions in the structure, equivalent to the strong and the weak calcium-binding sites in subtilisin Carlsberg and subtilisin BPN', well known for their stabilizing effect on the subtilisins. The structure of Savinase shows novel features that can be related to its stability and activity. The relatively high number of salt bridges in Savinase is likely to contribute to its high thermal stability. The non-conservative substitutions and deletions in the hydrophobic binding pocket S1 result in the most significant structural differences from the other subtilisins. The different composition of the S1 binding loop as well as the more hydrophobic character of the substrate-binding region probably contribute to the alkaline activity profile of the enzyme. The model of Savinase contains 1880 protein atoms, 159 water molecules and two calcium ions. The crystallographic R-factor [formula; see text].     

Calcium binding to thermitase. Crystallographic studies of thermitase at 0, 5, and 100 mM calcium

The three-dimensional crystal structure of thermitase complexed with eglin-c in the presence of 100 mM calcium has been determined and refined at 2.0-A resolution to a R-factor of 16.8%. This crystal structure is compared with previously determined structures of thermitase at 0 and 5 mM calcium concentration. In the presence of 100 mM calcium all three calcium binding sites in thermitase are fully occupied. At 100 mM CaCl2 the "weak" calcium binding is occupied by a calcium ion, which is chelated by three protein ligands and four water molecules in a pentagonal bipyramid geometry. Thermitase has, apparently, a monovalent and divalent cation binding position at 2.5-A distance from each other at this site. At low calcium concentrations the monovalent-ion position is occupied by a sodium or potassium ion. The "medium strength" binding site shows in the presence of 100 mM CaCl2 a square antiprism arrangement with eight ligands, of which seven are donated by the protein. At low calcium concentrations we observe a distorted pentagonal bipyramid coordination at this site. The largest difference between these two conformations is observed for ligand Asp-60, which has two conformations with 0.8-A difference in C alpha positions. The "strong" calcium binding site has a pentagonal bipyramid coordination and is fully occupied in all three structures. Structural changes on binding calcium to the weak and "medium strength" calcium binding sites of thermitase are limited to the direct surroundings of these sites. Thermitase resembles in this respect subtilisin BPN' and does not exhibit long-range shifts as have been reported for proteinase K.     

Crystal structure of thermitase at 1.4 A resolution

The crystal structure of thermitase, a subtilisin-type serine proteinase from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris, was determined by X-ray diffraction at 1.4 A resolution. The structure was solved by a combination of molecular and isomorphous replacement. The starting model was that of subtilisin BPN' from the Protein Data Bank, determined at 2.5 A resolution. The high-resolution refinement was based on data collected using synchrotron radiation with a Fuji image plate as detector. The model of thermitase refined to a conventional R factor of 14.9% and contains 1997 protein atoms, 182 water molecules and two Ca ions. The tertiary structure of thermitase is similar to that of the other subtilisins although there are some significant differences in detail. Comparison with subtilisin BPN' revealed two major structural differences. The N-terminal region in thermitase, which is absent in subtilisin BPN', forms a number of contacts with the tight Ca2+ binding site and indeed provides the very tight binding of the Ca ion. In thermitase the loop of residues 60 to 65 forms an additional (10) beta-strand of the central beta-sheet and the second Ca2+ binding site that has no equivalent in the subtilisin BPN' structure. The observed differences in the Ca2+ binding and the increased number of ionic and aromatic interactions in thermitase are likely sources of the enhanced stability of thermitase.     

The crystal structures of the psychrophilic subtilisin S41 and the mesophilic subtilisin Sph reveal the same calcium-loaded state

We determine and compare the crystal structure of two proteases belonging to the subtilisin superfamily: S41, a cold-adapted serine protease produced by Antarctic bacilli, at 1.4 A resolution and Sph, a mesophilic serine protease produced by Bacillus sphaericus, at 0.8 A resolution. The purpose of this comparison was to find out whether multiple calcium ion binding is a molecular factor responsible for the adaptation of S41 to extreme low temperatures. We find that these two subtilisins have the same subtilisin fold with a root mean square between the two structures of 0.54 A. The final models for S41 and Sph include a calcium-loaded state of five ions bound to each of these two subtilisin molecules. None of these calcium-binding sites correlate with the high affinity known binding site (site A) found for other subtilisins. Structural analysis of the five calcium-binding sites found in these two crystal structures indicate that three of the binding sites have two side chains of an acidic residue coordinating the calcium ion, whereas the other two binding sites have either a main-chain carbonyl, or only one acidic residue side chain coordinating the calcium ion. Thus, we conclude that three of the sites are of high affinity toward calcium ions, whereas the other two are of low affinity. Because Sph is a mesophilic subtilisin and S41 is a psychrophilic subtilisin, but both crystal structures were found to bind five calcium ions, we suggest that multiple calcium ion binding is not responsible for the adaptation of S41 to low temperatures.     

The 0.93A crystal structure of sphericase: a calcium-loaded serine protease from Bacillus sphaericus

We have previously isolated sphericase (Sph), an extracellular mesophilic serine protease produced by Bacillus sphaericus. The Sph amino acid sequence is highly homologous to two cold-adapted subtilisins from Antarctic bacilli S39 and S41 (76% and 74% identity, respectively). Sph is calcium-dependent, 310 amino acid residues long and has optimal activity at pH 10.0. S41 and S39 have not as yet been structurally analysed.In the present work, we determined the crystal structure of Sph by the Eu/multiwavelength anomalous diffraction method. The structure was extended to 0.93A resolution and refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 9.7%. The final model included all 310 amino acid residues, one disulfide bond, 679 water molecules and five calcium ions. Although Sph is a mesophilic subtilisin, its amino acid sequence is similar to that of the psychrophilic subtilisins, which suggests that the crystal structure of these subtilisins is very similar.The presence of five calcium ions bound to a subtilisin molecule, as found here for Sph, has not been reported for the subtilisin superfamily. None of these calcium-binding sites correlates with the well-known high-affinity calcium-binding site (site I or site A), and only one site has been described previously. This calcium-binding pattern suggests that a reduction in the flexibility of the surface loops of Sph by calcium binding may be responsible for its adaptation to mesophilic organisms.     

Effects of eglin-c binding to thermitase: three-dimensional structure comparison of native thermitase and thermitase eglin-c complexes.

Thermitase is a thermostable member of the subtilisin family of serine proteases. Four independently determined crystal structures of the enzyme are compared in this study: a high resolution native one and three medium resolution complexes of thermitase with eglin-c, grown from three different calcium concentrations. It appeared that the B-factors of the thermitase eglin complex obtained at 100 mM CaCl2 and elucidated at 2.0 A resolution are remarkably similar to those of the 1.4 A native structure: the main chain atoms have an rms difference of only 2.3 A2; for all atoms this difference is 4.6 A2. The rms positional differences between these two structures of thermitase are 0.31 A for the main chain atoms and 0.58 A for all atoms. There results show that not only atomic positions but also temperature factors can agree well in X-ray structures determined entirely independently by procedures which differ in virtually every possible technical aspect. A detailed comparison focussed on the effects of eglin binding on the structure of thermitase. Thermitase can be considered as consisting of (1) a central core of 94 residues, plus (2) four segments of 72 residues in total which shift as rigid bodies with respect to the core, plus (3) the remaining 113 residues which show small changes but, however, cannot be described as rigid bodies. The central cores of native thermitase and the 100 mM CaCl2 thermitase:eglin complex have an rms deviation of 0.13 A for 376 main chain atoms. One of the segments, formed by loops of the strong calcium binding site, shows differences up to 1.0 A in C alpha positions. These are probably due to crystal packing effects. The three other segments, comprising 51 residues, are affected conformational changes upon eglin binding so that the P1 to P3 binding pockets of thermitase broaden by 0.4 to 0.7 A. The residues involved in these changes correspond with residues which change position upon inhibitor binding in other subtilisins. This suggests that an induced fit mechanism is operational during substrate recognition by subtilisins.     

Crystal and molecular structure of the inhibitor eglin from leeches in complex with subtilisin Carlsberg

The crystal structure of the molecular complex of eglin, a serine proteinase inhibitor from leeches, with subtilisin Carlsberg has been determined at 2.0 A resolution by the molecular replacement method. The complex has been refined by restrained-parameter least-squares. The present crystallographic R factor (Formula: see text) is 0.183. Eglin is a member of the potato inhibitor 1 family, a group of serine proteinase inhibitors lacking disulfide bonds. Eglin shows strong structural homology to CI-2, a related inhibitor from barley seeds. The structure of subtilisin Carlsberg in this complex is very similar to the known structure from barley seeds. The structure of subtilisin Carlsberg in this complex is very similar to the known structure of subtilisin novo, despite changes of 84 out of 274 amino acids.     

Crystal structure of an alkaline protease from Bacillus alcalophilus at 2.4 A resolution

The crystal structure of an alkaline protease from Bacillus alcalophilus has been determined by X-ray diffraction at 2.4 A resolution. The enzyme crystallizes in space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with lattice constants a = 53.7, b = 61.6, c = 75.9 A. The structure was solved by molecular replacement using the structure of subtilisin Carlsberg as search model. Refinement using molecular dynamics and restrained least squares methods results in a crystallographic R-factor of 0.185. The tertiary structure is very similar to that of subtilisin Carlsberg. The greatest structural differences occur in loops at the surface of the protein.     

X-ray structure determination and comparison of two crystal forms of a variant (Asn115Arg) of the alkaline protease from Bacillus alcalophilus refined at 1.85 A resolution.

The X-ray structure determination, refinement and comparison of two crystal forms of a variant (Asn115Arg) of the alkaline protease from Bacillus alcalophilus is described. Under identical conditions crystals were obtained in the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) (form I) and the rhombohedral space group R32 (form II). For both space groups the structures of the protease were solved by molecular replacement and refined at 1.85 A resolution. The final R-factors are 17.9% and 17.1% for form I and form II, respectively. The root-mean-square deviation between the two forms is 0.48 A and 0.86 A for main-chain and side-chain atoms, respectively. Due to differences in crystal lattice contacts and packing, the structures of the two crystal forms differ in intermolecular interaction affecting the local conformation of three flexible polypeptide sequences (Ser50-Glu55, Ser99-Gly102, Gly258-Ser259) at the surface of the protein. While the two overall structures are very similar, the differences are significantly larger than the errors inherent in the structure determination. As expected, the differences in the temperature factors in form I and II are correlated with the solvent accessibility of the corresponding amino acid residues. In form II, two symmetry-related substrate binding sites face each other, forming a tight intermolecular interaction. Some residues contributing to this intermolecular interaction are also found to be involved in the formation of the complex between subtilisin Carlsberg and the proteinaceous inhibitor eglin C. This demonstrates that the two symmetry-related molecules interact with each other at the same molecular surface area that is used for binding of substrates and inhibitors.     

Calcium-mediated thermostability in the subtilisin superfamily: the crystal structure of Bacillus Ak.1 protease at 1.8 A resolution

Proteins of the subtilisin superfamily (subtilases) are widely distributed through many living species, where they perform a variety of processing functions. They are also used extensively in industry. In many of these enzymes, bound calcium ions play a key role in protecting against autolysis and thermal denaturation. We have determined the crystal structure of a highly thermostable protease from Bacillus sp. Ak.1 that is strongly stabilized by calcium. The crystal structure, determined at 1.8 A resolution (R=0. 182, Rfree=0.247), reveals the presence of four bound cations, three Ca(2+) and one Na(+). Two of the Ca(2+) binding sites, Ca-1 and Ca-2, correspond to sites also found in thermitase and the mesophilic subtilisins. The third calcium ion, however, is at a novel site that is created by two key amino acid substitutions near Ca-1, and has not been observed in any other subtilase. This site, acting cooperatively with Ca-1, appears to give substantially enhanced thermostability, compared with thermitase. Comparisons with the mesophilic subtilisins also point to the importance of aromatic clusters, reduced hydrophobic surface and constrained N and C termini in enhancing the thermostability of thermitase and Ak.1 protease. The Ak.1 protease also contains an unusual Cys-X-Cys disulfide bridge that modifies the active site cleft geometry.     

Incorporation of a stabilizing Ca(2+)-binding loop into subtilisin BPN'.

A rational approach was taken to improve the stability of subtilisin BPN' to autoproteolysis. Two sites of autoproteolysis were identified by isolation of early autolysis products and amino-terminal sequence analysis. These studies showed that subtilisin rapidly cleaves Ala48-Ser49 and Ser163-Thr164 peptide bonds at elevated temperatures. These two sites appear in regions of high mobility as estimated from crystallographic B-factors and are in extended surface loops. To improve the resistance to thermal-induced autolysis, we replaced sequences around these two sites with sequences derived from a thermophilic homologue of subtilisin, thermitase. Thermitase contains a Ca(2+)-binding site in the region surrounding Ser49. When the Ca(2+)-binding segment of thermitase corresponding to residues 45-63 of subtilisin BPN' was installed into subtilisin BPN', the chimeric protein gained the ability to bind another Ca2+ with moderate affinity (Kd approximately 100 microM). This enzyme had the same kcat as wild-type, had a KM value 8-fold larger than wild-type, and was slightly less stable to thermal inactivation in EDTA. However, in 10 mM CaCl2, the mutant subtilisin BPN' was 10-fold more stable to irreversible inactivation at 60 degrees C than wild-type subtilisin BPN' as measured by residual activity against the substrate sAAPF-pna. Next, mutations and deletions derived from thermitase were introduced near the second autolysis loop in subtilisin BPN' (residues 158-165). However, all of these mutants were less stable than wild-type subtilisin. Thus, some (but not all) mutations derived from a thermophilic homologue near sites of autolysis can be stabilizing to a mesophilic protease.     

Thermitase, a thermostable subtilisin: comparison of predicted and experimental structures and the molecular cause of thermostability

The Subtilisin family of proteases has four members of known sequence and structure: subtilisin Carlsberg, Subtilisin novo, proteinase K, and thermitase. Using thermitase as a test case, we ask two questions. How good are methods for model building a three-dimensional structure of a protein based on sequence homology to a known structure? And what are the molecular causes of thermostability? First, we compare predicted models of thermitase, refined by energy minimization and varied by molecular dynamics, with the preliminary crystal structure. The predictions work best in the conserve structural core and less well in seven loop regions involving insertions and deletions relative to Subtilisin. Here, variation of loop regions by molecular dynamics simulation in vacuo followed by energy minimization does not improve the prediction since we find no correlation between in vacuo energy and correctness of structure when comparing local energy minima. Second, in order to identify the molecular case of thermostability we confront hypotheses erived by calculation of the details of interatomic interactions with inactivation experiments. As a result, we can exclude salt bridges and hydrophobic interactions as main cause of thermostability. Based on a combination of theoretical and experimental evidence, the unusually tight binding of calcium by thermitase emerges as the most likely single influence responsible for its increased thermostability.     

Peptide diazomethyl ketones are inhibitors of subtilisin-type serine proteases

Peptide diazomethyl ketones, well known as specific cysteine protease inhibitors are also potent inhibitors of the microbial serine proteases thermitase (EC 3.4.21.14) and subtilisin Carlsberg (EC 3.4.21.14). The affinity of the enzymes towards the synthetic inhibitors Z-Ala(n)-PheCHN2 (n = 0, 1, 2) depends on the chain length and is in the same range as for the corresponding chloromethyl ketones. Both kinds of inhibitors react irreversibly in a 1:1 ratio with the enzymes and covalently bind to the active site histidine of both subtilisin Carlsberg and thermitase despite the fact that thermitase contains an active-site cysteinyl residue. The mechanism of the inhibition reaction is discussed.     

Refined 1.2 A crystal structure of the complex formed between subtilisin Carlsberg and the inhibitor eglin c. Molecular structure of eglin and its detailed interaction with subtilisin.

The crystal structure of the complex formed between eglin c, an elastase inhibitor from the medical leech, and subtilisin Carlsberg has been determined at 1.2 A resolution by a combination of Patterson search methods and isomorphous replacement techniques. The structure has been refined to a crystallographic R-value of 0.18 (8-1.2 A). Eglin consists of a four-stranded beta-sheet with an alpha-helical segment and the protease-binding loop fixed on opposite sides. This loop, which contains the reactive site Leu45I--Asp46I, is mainly held in its conformation by unique electrostatic/hydrogen bond interactions of Thr44I and Asp46I with the side chains of Arg53I and Arg51I which protrude from the hydrophobic core of the molecule. The conformation around the reactive site is similar to that found in other proteinase inhibitors. The nine residues of the binding loop Gly40I--Arg48I are involved in direct contacts with subtilisin. In this interaction, eglin segment Pro42I--Thr44I forms a three-stranded anti-parallel beta-sheet with subtilisin segments Gly100--Gly102 and Ser125--Gly127. The reactive site peptide bond of eglin is intact, and Ser221 OG of the enzyme is 2.81 A apart from the carbonyl carbon.     

Amino acid sequence of the small cyanogen bromide peptide of thermitase, a thermostable serine proteinase from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris. Relation to the subtilisins

The following amino acid sequence of the small cyanogen bromide peptide (mol. wt. 5399) of thermitase from Thermoactinomyces vulgaris has been determined: Ala-Thr-Pro-His-Val-Ala-Gly-Val-Ala-Gly-Leu-Leu-Ala-Ser-Gln-Gly-Arg-Ser-Ala-Ser -Asn-Ile-Arg-Ala-Ala-Ile-Glu-Asn-Thr-Ala-Asp-Lys-Ile-Ser-Gly-Thr-Gly-Thr-Tyr-Trp-Ala-Lys-Gly-Arg-Val-Asn-Ala-Tyr-Lys-Ala-Val-Gln-Tyr. The results obtained support the classification of the enzyme as a serine proteinase of the subtilisin type as proposed in a previous paper (1). This partial sequence extending from the serine residue involved in the active site to the C-terminal amino acid of the enzyme shows a 40% homology with the corresponding part of the subtilisin BPN' or subtilisin Carlsberg molecule but a 56% homology as regards conservative amino acid replacements. The secondary structure of this polypeptide fragment, predicted from the data obtained by the method of Chou & Fasman (2) agrees fairly well, within the limit or error of the method, with the structure of the corresponding part of the subtilisin BPN' molecule. Therefore, as expected, no dramatic changes in the spatial structure appear to account for the higher thermostability of thermitase, at least in this area of the polypeptide chain.     

Crystal structure of the high-alkaline serine protease PB92 from Bacillus alcalophilus.

The crystal structure of a serine protease from the alkalophilic strain Bacillus alcalophilus PB92 has been determined by X-ray diffraction at 1.75 A resolution. The structure has been solved by molecular replacement using the atomic model of subtilisin Carlsberg. The model of the PB92 protease has been refined to an R-factor of 14.0% and contains 1882 protein atoms, two calcium ions and 188 water molecules. The overall folding of the polypeptide chain closely resembles that of the subtilisins. Furthermore, almost all of the secondary structure elements found in subtilisin Carlsberg are also present in the PB92 protease. The major differences between the two structures are located around the deletion regions (residues 37 and 158-161 in subtilisin Carlsberg) and in two loops which are known to be the most variable parts of subtilisin structures. Flexibility of one of these loops (residues 126-130 in the PB92 protease) is believed to account for the induced-fit mechanism of substrate binding.     

The high-resolution X-ray crystal structure of the complex formed between subtilisin Carlsberg and eglin c, an elastase inhibitor from the leech Hirudo medicinalis. Structural analysis, subtilisin structure and interface geometry

Triclinic crystals of the complex formed by eglin with subtilisin Carlsberg were analyzed by X-ray diffraction. The crystal and molecular structure of this complex was determined with data that extended to 0.12-nm resolution by a combination of Patterson search methods and isomorphous replacement techniques. Its structure was refined to a crystallographic R value of 0.178 (1.0-0.12 nm) using an energy-restraint least-squares procedure. The complete subtilisin molecule could be traced without ambiguity in the refined electron density. The eglin component, from which an amino-terminal segment is cleaved off, is only defined from Lys8I (i.e. the lysine residue 8 of the inhibitor) onwards. Per unit cell, 436 fixed solvent molecules and 2 calcium ions were located. In spite of 84 amino acid replacements and one deletion, subtilisin Carlsberg exhibits a very similar polypeptide fold to subtilisin BPN'. The root-mean-square deviations of all alpha-carbon atoms (excluding those at the deletion site) from models of subtilisin BPN' [Alden, R. A., Birktoft, J. J., Kraut, J., Robertus, J. D. & Wright, C. S. (1971) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 45, 337-344] and subtilisin Novo [Drenth, J., Hol, W. G. J., Jansonius, J. N. & Kockoek, R. (1972) Eur. J. Biochem. 25, 177-181] are 0.077 nm and 0.103 nm. Most of these deviations result from global shifts rather than changes of the local geometry. The single-residue deletion at position 56 affects only the surrounding conformation. Two sites of high electron density and close distances to surrounding oxygen ligands have been found in the Carlsberg enzyme which are probably occupied by calcium ions. Eglin consists of a twisted four-stranded beta-sheet flanked by an alpha-helix and by an exposed proteinase binding loop on opposite sides. Around the reactive site, Leu45I-Asp46I, this loop is mainly stabilized by electrostatic/hydrogen bond interactions with the side chains of two arginine residues which project from the hydrophobic core [Bode, W., Papamokos, E., Musil, D., Seemüller, W. & Fritz, H. (1986) EMBO J. 5, 813-818]. The reactive site loop conformation resembles that found in other 'small' proteinase inhibitors. The scissile peptide bond is not cleaved but its carbonyl group is slightly distorted from planar geometry. Most of the intermolecular contacts are contributed by the nine residues of the reactive-site loop Gly40I-Arg48I.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Kinetic specificities of BPN' and Carlsberg subtilisins. Mapping the aromatic binding site.

The kinetic specificities of BPN' and Carlsberg subtilisins [EC 3.4.21.14] were examined with various nucleus-substituted derivatives of Nalpha-acetylated aromatic amino acid methyl esters for mapping their hydrophobic binding sites in comparison with that of alpha-chymotrypsin. The Carlsberg enzyme was generally much more reactive than the BPN' enzyme due to the larger kcat value. The fact that the two sutilisins hydrolyzed Ac-Tyr(PABz)-OMe, which is a derivative of tyrosine bearing a planar trans-p-phenylazobenzoyl group at the OH-function, with the smallest Km value showed that these enzymes possess a more extended aromatic binding site than has so far been demonstrated. Ac-Phe(4-NO2)-OMe was remarkable in being hydrolyzed with a particularly large kcat value (5,500 +/- 700 s-1 at pH 7.8 for Carlsberg subtilisin). Ac-Phe(4-NO2)-OMe and Ac-Tyr-OMe were distinguished by Carlsberg subtilisin in terms of kcat but not by BPN' subtilisin, suggesting that the specificity site of the former is more sensitive to a small change in size of substituent than that of the latter. Ac-Trp(NCps)-OMe and Ac-Trp(NCps)-OH were bound to the enzyme's active site but in a competitive manner. A difference in the standard free energies of binding between the two enzymes may indicate that the hydrophobic cleft of Carlsberg subtilisin is somewhat deeper and/or narrower than that of BPN' subtilisin.