The vertebrate skeletal muscle thick filaments are not three-stranded. Reinterpretation of some experimental data

Computer simulation of mass distribution within the model and Fourier transforms of images depicting mass distribution are explored for verification of two alternative modes of the myosin molecule arrangement within the vertebrate skeletal muscle thick filaments. The model well depicting the complete bipolar structure of the thick filament and revealing a true threefold-rotational symmetry is a tube covered by two helices with a pitch of 2 x 43 nm due to arrangement of the myosin tails along a helical path and grouping of all myosin heads in the crowns rotated by 240 degrees and each containing three cross-bridges separated by 0 degrees, 120 degrees, and 180 degrees. The cross-bridge crown parameters are verified by EM images as well as by optical and low-angle X-ray diffraction patterns found in the literature. The myosin tail arrangement, at which the C-terminus of about 43-nm length is near-parallel to the filament axis and the rest of the tail is quite strongly twisted around, is verified by the high-angle X-ray diffraction patterns. A consequence of the new packing is a new way of movement of the myosin cross-bridges, namely, not by bending in the hinge domains, but by unwrapping from the thick filament surface towards the thin filaments along a helical path.     

The structure of thick filaments on longitudinal sections of rabbit psoas muscle

By means of electron microscopy the longitudinal sections of chemically skinned fibres of rigorised rabbit psoas muscle have been examined at pH of rigorising solutions equal to 6, 7, 8 (I = 0.125) and ionic strengths equal to 0.04, 0.125, 0.34 (pH 7.0). It has been revealed that at pH 6.0 the bands of minor proteins localization in A-disks were seen very distinctly, while at pH 7.0 and I = 0.125 these bands can be revealed only by means of antibody labelling technique. At the ionic strength of 0.34 (pH 7.0) the periodicity of 14.3 nm in thick filaments was clearly observed, which was determined by packing of the myosin rods into the filament shaft and of the myosin heads (cross-bridges) on the filament surface. The number of cross-bridge rows in the filament equals 102. A new scheme of myosin cross-bridge distribution in thick filaments of rabbit psoas muscle has been suggested according to which two rows of cross-bridges at each end of a thick filament are absent. The filament length equals 1.64 +/- 0.01 micron. It has been shown that the length of thick filament as well as the structural organization of their end regions in rabbit psoas muscle and frog sartorius one are different.     

Movement of myosin fragments in vitro: domains involved in force production

We have used the Nitella-based movement assay to localize the site of force production in myosin. Methods were developed to use nonfilamentous myosin or proteolytic fragments of myosin in place of the thick filaments used in the original assay. In the experiments described here, the tail of myosin or its subfragments is anchored via antibodies to the surface of small particles. Nonfilamentous myosin or its subfragments move along Nitella actin cables at speeds similar to those obtained with filamentous myosin. We generated short HMM, a myosin fragment containing the heads and only 400 A of the tail. Although short HMM lacks the "hinge" region proposed by Harrington to be the site of force generation, and is incapable of forming thick filaments, it moves along actin at speeds above 1 micron/sec. Therefore, neither a thick filament nor the carboxy-terminal 1100 A of the tail is required for movement along actin. The results indicate that force production occurs in or near the myosin heads.     

Straightening Out the Elasticity of Myosin Cross-Bridges

In a contracting muscle, myosin cross-bridges extending from thick filaments pull the interdigitating thin (actin-containing) filaments during cyclical ATP-driven interactions toward the center of the sarcomere, the structural unit of striated muscle. Cross-bridge attachments in the sarcomere have been reported to exhibit a similar stiffness under both positive and negative forces. However, in vitro measurements on filaments with a sparse complement of heads detected a decrease of the cross-bridge stiffness at negative forces attributed to the buckling of the subfragment 2 tail portion. Here, we review some old and new data that confirm that cross-bridge stiffness is nearly linear in the muscle filament lattice. The implications of high myosin stiffness at positive and negative strains are considered in muscle fibers and in nonmuscle intracellular cargo transport.     

Three-dimensional image reconstruction of insect flight muscle. I. The rigor myac layer

We have obtained detailed three-dimensional images of in situ cross-bridge structure in insect flight muscle by electron microscopy of multiple tilt views of single filament layers in ultrathin sections, supplemented with data from thick sections. In this report, we describe the images obtained of the myac layer, a 25-nm longitudinal section containing a single layer of alternating myosin and actin filaments. The reconstruction reveals averaged rigor cross-bridges that clearly separate into two classes constituting lead and rear chevrons within each 38.7-nm axial repeat. These two classes differ in tilt angle, size and shape, density, and slew. This new reconstruction confirms our earlier interpretation of the lead bridge as a two-headed cross-bridge and the rear bridge as a single-headed cross-bridge. The importance of complementing tilt series with additional projections outside the goniometer tilt range is demonstrated by comparison with our earlier myac layer reconstruction. Incorporation of this additional data reveals new details of rigor cross-bridge structure in situ which include clear delineation of (a) a triangular shape for the lead bridge, (b) a smaller size for the rear bridge, and (c) density continuity across the thin filament in the lead bridge. Within actin's regular 38.7-nm helical repeat, local twist variations in the thin filament that correlate with the two cross-bridge classes persist in this new reconstruction. These observations show that in situ rigor cross-bridges are not uniform, and suggest three different myosin head conformations in rigor.     

Myosin head configuration in relaxed insect flight muscle: x-ray modeled resting cross-bridges in a pre-powerstroke state are poised for actin binding

Low-angle x-ray diffraction patterns from relaxed insect flight muscle recorded on the BioCAT beamline at the Argonne APS have been modeled to 6.5 nm resolution (R-factor 9.7%, 65 reflections) using the known myosin head atomic coordinates, a hinge between the motor (catalytic) domain and the light chain-binding (neck) region (lever arm), together with a simulated annealing procedure. The best head conformation angles around the hinge gave a head shape that was close to that typical of relaxed M*ADP*Pi heads, a head shape never before demonstrated in intact muscle. The best packing constrained the eight heads per crown within a compact crown shelf projecting at approximately 90 degrees to the filament axis. The two heads of each myosin molecule assume nonequivalent positions, one head projecting outward while the other curves round the thick filament surface to nose against the proximal neck of the projecting head of the neighboring molecule. The projecting heads immediately suggest a possible cross-bridge cycle. The relaxed projecting head, oriented almost as needed for actin attachment, will attach, then release Pi followed by ADP, as the lever arm with a purely axial change in tilt drives approximately 10 nm of actin filament sliding on the way to the nucleotide-free limit of its working stroke. The overall arrangement appears well designed to support precision cycling for the myogenic oscillatory mode of contraction with its enhanced stretch-activation response used in flight by insects equipped with asynchronous fibrillar flight muscles.     

Myosin degradation fragments in skeletal muscle

Myosin heavy chain degradation fragments produced in vivo have been identified in chicken pectoralis muscle. The fragments were identified by electrophoresis of unfractionated extracts of chicken pectoralis muscle on sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gels followed by immunoblotting on nitrocellulose sheets. Monoclonal antibodies directed against the S2 and light meromyosin subfragments as well as type II myosin-specific polyclonal antibodies directed against the entire myosin heavy chain were used to characterize the fragments, which range in molecular weight from approximately 80,000 to 180,000. All fragments contain the extreme carboxy-terminal portion of the molecule and are distinct from the classical proteolytic fragments such as heavy and light meromyosin, S1, S2 or rod. These fragments appear to be produced in vivo by proteolytic cleavage of peptides from the amino-terminal (S1) end of the heavy chain while the myosin molecule is still embedded in the thick filament. Fragment concentrations are estimated to be approximately 5 to 10% of that of the intact myosin heavy chain. These fragments are not the result of artifactual damage to myosin, e.g. proteolysis or hydrodynamic shear. The techniques described in this paper provide a probe into the early stages of myosin and thick filament degradation in vivo.     

Modeling rigor cross-bridge patterns in muscle I. Initial studies of the rigor lattice of insect flight muscle.

We have undertaken some computer modeling studies of the cross-bridge observed by Reedy in insect flight muscle so that we investigate the geometric parameters that influence the attachment patterns of cross-bridges to actin filaments. We find that the appearance of double chevrons along an actin filament indicates that the cross-bridges are able to reach 10--14 nm axially, and about 90 degrees around the actin filament. Between three and five actin monomers are therefore available along each turn of one strand of actin helix for labeling by cross-bridges from an adjacent myosin filament. Reedy's flared X of four bridges, which appears rotated 60 degrees at successive levels on the thick filament, depends on the orientation of the actin filaments in the whole lattice as well as on the range of movement in each cross-bridge. Fairly accurate chevrons and flared X groupings can be modeled with a six-stranded myosin surface lattice. The 116-nm long repeat appears in our models as "beating" of the 14.5-nm myosin repeat and the 38.5-nm actin period. Fourier transforms of the labeled actin filaments indicate that the cross-bridges attach to each actin filament on average of 14.5 nm apart. The transform is sensitive to changes in the ease with which the cross-bridge can be distorted in different directions.     

Studies of the interaction between titin and myosin

The interaction of titin with myosin has been studied by binding assays and electron microscopy. Electron micrographs of the titin-myosin complex suggest a binding site near the tip of the tail of the myosin molecule. The distance from the myosin head-tail junction to titin indicates binding 20-30 nm from the myosin COOH terminus. Consistent with this, micrographs of titin-light meromyosin (LMM) show binding near the end of the LMM molecule. Plots of myosin- and LMM-attachment positions along the titin molecule show binding predominantly in the region located in the A band in situ, which is consistent with the proposal that titin regulates thick filament assembly. Estimates of the apparent dissociation constant of the titin-LMM complex were approximately 20 nM. Assays of LMM cyanogen bromide fragments also suggested a strong binding site near the COOH terminus. Proteolysis of a COOH-terminal 17.6-kD CNBr fragment isolated from whole myosin resulted in eight peptides of which only one, comprising 17 residues, bound strongly to titin. Two isoforms of this peptide were detected by protein sequencing. Similar binding data were obtained using synthetic versions of both isoforms. The peptide is located immediately COOH- terminal of the fourth "skip" residue in the myosin tail, which is consistent with the electron microscopy. Skip-4 may have a role in determining thick filament structure, by allowing abrupt bending of the myosin tail close to the titin-binding site.     

Multiple structures of thick filaments in resting cardiac muscle and their influence on cross-bridge interactions.

Based on two criteria, the tightness of packing of myosin rods within the backbone of the filament and the degree of order of the myosin heads, thick filaments isolated from a control group of rat hearts had three different structures. Two of the structures of thick filaments had ordered myosin heads and were distinguishable from each other by the difference in tightness of packing of the myosin rods. Depending on the packing, their structure has been called loose or tight. The third structure had narrow shafts and disordered myosin heads extending at different angles from the backbone. This structure has been called disordered. After phosphorylation of myosin-binding protein C (MyBP-C) with protein kinase A (PKA), almost all thick filaments exhibited the loose structure. Transitions from one structure to another in quiescent muscles were produced by changing the concentration of extracellular Ca. The probability of interaction between isolated thick and thin filaments in control, PKA-treated preparations, and preparations exposed to different Ca concentrations was estimated by electron microscopy. Interactions were more frequent with phosphorylated thick filaments having the loose structure than with either the tight or disordered structure. In view of the presence of MgATP and the absence of Ca, the interaction between the myosin heads and the thin filaments was most likely the weak attachment that precedes the force-generating steps in the cross-bridge cycle. These results suggest that phosphorylation of MyBP-C in cardiac thick filaments increases the probability of cross-bridges forming weak attachments to thin filaments in the absence of activation. This mechanism may modulate the number of cross-bridges generating force during activation.     

Axial arrangement of the myosin rod in vertebrate thick filaments: immunoelectron microscopy with a monoclonal antibody to light meromyosin

A monoclonal antibody, MF20, which has been shown previously to bind the myosin heavy chain of vertebrate striated muscle, has been proven to bind the light meromyosin (LMM) fragment by solid phase radioimmune assay with alpha-chymotryptic digests of purified myosin. Epitope mapping by electron microscopy of rotary-shadowed, myosin-antibody complexes has localized the antibody binding site to LMM at a point approximately 92 nm from the C-terminus of the myosin heavy chain. Since this epitope in native thick filaments is accessible to monoclonal antibodies, we used this antibody as a high affinity ligand to analyze the packing of LMM along the backbone of the thick filament. By immunofluorescence microscopy, MF20 was shown to bind along the entire A-band of chicken pectoralis myofibrils, although the epitope accessibility was greater near the ends than at the center of the A-bands. Thin-section, transmission electron microscopy of myofibrils decorated with MF20 revealed 50 regularly spaced, cross-striations in each half A-band, with a repeat distance of approximately 13 nm. These were numbered consecutively, 1-50, from the A-band to the last stripe, approximately 68 nm from the filament tips. These same striations could be visualized by negative staining of native thick filaments labeled with MF20. All 50 striations were of a consecutive, uninterrupted repeat which approximated the 14-15-nm axial translation of cross-bridges. Each half M-region contained five MF20 striations (approximately 13 nm apart) with a distance between stripes 1 and 1', on each half of the bare zone, of approximately 18 nm. This is compatible with a packing model with full, antiparallel overlap of the myosin rods in the bare zone region. Differences in the spacings measured with negatively stained myofilaments and thin-sectioned myofibrils have been shown to arise from specimen shrinkage in the fixed and embedded preparations. These observations provide strong support for Huxley's original proposal for myosin packing in thick filaments of vertebrate muscle (Huxley, H. E., 1963, J. Mol. Biol., 7:281-308) and, for the first time, directly demonstrate that the 14-15-nm axial translation of LMM in the thick filament backbone corresponds to the cross-bridge repeat detected with x-ray diffraction of living muscle.     

Distribution of mass within native thick filaments of vertebrate skeletal muscle

The distribution of mass within the vertebrate skeletal thick filament has been determined by scanning transmission electron microscopy. Thick and thin filaments from fresh rabbit muscle were mixed with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), fixed with formaldehyde, dried onto thin carbon films and viewed in a computer-linked microscope. Electron scattering data from both TMV and thick filaments were analysed with reference to the long axis of the particles so that the distribution of mass within the particles could be determined. While TMV appeared to be a uniform rod at the resolution employed (4.3 nm), the thick filament was clearly differentiated along its length. M-line remnants at the centre of the filament were flanked by regions of low mass per unit length, corresponding to the bare zone of the filament, and then by the more massive cross-bridge regions. The mass per unit length was approximately constant through most of the cross-bridge zone and declined at the filament tips, in a manner consistent with a constant number of myosin molecules per 14.3 nm interval (crown) throughout the cross-bridge zone. Fourier analysis of the data failed to detect the expected 43 nm periodicity of C-protein. The total mass of the thick filament was 184 Mdalton (s.e.m., 1.6 X 10(6); n = 70). The mass of adhering M-line proteins was highly variable but, on average, was about 4 Mdalton. The total mass of the filament and the mass distribution in the cross-bridge zone are consistent with three myosin molecules per crown.     

Mechanics and models of the myosin motor

In striated muscles, shortening comes about by the sliding movement of thick filaments, composed mostly of myosin, relative to thin filaments, composed mostly of actin. This is brought about by cyclic action of 'cross-bridges' composed of the heads of myosin molecules projecting from a thick filament, which attach to an adjacent thin filament, exert force for a limited time and detach, and then repeat this cycle further along the filament. The requisite energy is provided by the hydrolysis of a molecule of adenosine triphosphate to the diphosphate and inorganic phosphate, the steps of this reaction being coupled to mechanical events within the cross-bridge. The nature of these events is discussed. There is good evidence that one of them is a change in the angle of tilt of a 'lever arm' relative to the 'catalytic domain' of the myosin head which binds to the actin filament. It is suggested here that this event is superposed on a slower, temperature-sensitive change in the orientation of the catalytic domain on the actin filament. Many uncertainties remain.     

Purification of native myosin filaments from muscle

Analysis of the structure and function of native thick (myosin-containing) filaments of muscle has been hampered in the past by the difficulty of obtaining a pure preparation. We have developed a simple method for purifying native myosin filaments from muscle filament suspensions. The method involves severing thin (actin-containing) filaments into short segments using a Ca(2+)-insensitive fragment of gelsolin, followed by differential centrifugation to purify the thick filaments. By gel electrophoresis, the purified thick filaments show myosin heavy and light chains together with nonmyosin thick filament components. Contamination with actin is below 3.5%. Electron microscopy demonstrates intact thick filaments, with helical cross-bridge order preserved, and essentially complete removal of thin filaments. The method has been developed for striated muscles but can also be used in a modified form to remove contaminating thin filaments from native smooth muscle myofibrils. Such preparations should be useful for thick filament structural and biochemical studies.     

Geometrical correspondence identified and a new interaction unit suggested in striated muscle

It has long been believed that the periodic structure of the myosin helix is a consequence only of compressing the actin-myosin interaction sites. Here, we identify a length correspondence between the smallest helical unit on the thick filament and the helical pitch of the actin filaments in two different contractile muscles. This suggests a rotation/swing of the filaments that creates a new interaction unit in addition to the single interaction between an actin filament and a myosin head. Numerical characteristics of the single interaction are estimated from discussion about an in vivo interaction utilizing the new unit. The estimated twisted angle of the actin filaments is consistent with that calculated from its torsion rigidity and the evaluated step sizes per cross-bridge can be performed by a single bend of a myosin head. By comparing our evaluated step sizes with experimental results, we conclude that the most plausible mechanism at the force-recovery stage involves swings or rotations of both filaments in the same direction (clockwise).     

Packing of myosin molecules in muscle thick filaments

The backbone of the myosin filament is an aggregate of alpha-helical coiled coil myosin rods. Its surface forms a three-stranded helix composed of myosin heads. Currently there is no adequate model to describe the organization of the myosin filament. It is proposed here that, in cross-section the light meromyosin (LMM) of 18 myosin molecules form an outer tube, with nine S2 forming the interior core. At the surface of the thick filament, myosin heads are arranged in three rows, giving the filament a periodicity of 14.3 nm per three myosin molecules. Two of these molecules are organized at an angle of 120 degrees to each other on the same level, while the third is shifted 7.2 nm along the filament axis. This packing gives a striation pattern of 7.2 nm by electron microscopy. An alternative model is also possible, in which the heads of the myosin molecules are uniformly spaced at an interval of 14.3 nm along the filament axis. The packing of individual molecules within the myosin filament is based on a regular pattern of charge on the 28 amino-acid repeat in the rod domain.     

Cross-bridge action: present views, prospects, and unknowns

When the sliding filament hypothesis was proposed in 1953-1954, existing evidence showed that (1) contributions to tension were given by active sites uniformly distributed within each zone of filament overlap and (2) each site functioned cyclically. These sites were identified by electron microscopy as cross-bridges between the two filaments, formed of the heads of myosin molecules projecting from a thick filament and attaching to a thin filament. The angle of these cross-bridges was found to be different at rest and in rigor, suggesting that the event causing relative motion of the filaments was a change of the angle of the cross-bridges. At first, it seemed likely that the whole cross-bridge rotated about its attachment to actin, but when the atomic structures of actin and myosin were obtained by X-ray crystallography, a possible hinge was found between the "catalytic domain" which attaches to the actin filament and the "light-chain domain" which appears to act as a lever arm. Two attitudes of the lever arm are now well established, the transition between them being driven by a conformational change coupled to some step in the hydrolysis of ATP, but several recent observations suggest that this is not the whole story: a third attitude has been shown by X-ray crystallography; a non-muscle myosin has been shown to produce its working stroke in two steps; and there are suggestions that an additional displacement of the filaments is produced by a change in the attitude of the catalytic domain on the thin filament.     

Intermolecular versus intramolecular interactions of Dictyostelium myosin: possible regulation by heavy chain phosphorylation

Dictyostelium myosin has been examined under conditions that reveal intramolecular and intermolecular interactions that may be important in the process of assembly and its regulation. Rotary shadowed myosin molecules exhibit primarily two configurations under these conditions: straight parallel dimers and folded monomers. All of the monomers bend in a specific region of the 1860-A-long tail that is 1200 A from the head-tail junction. Molecules in parallel dimers are staggered by 140 A, which is a periodicity in the packing of myosin molecules originally observed in native thick filaments of muscle. The most common region for interaction in the dimers is a segment of the tail about 200-A-long, extending from 900 to 1100 A from the head-tail junction. Parallel dimers form tetramers by way of antiparallel interactions in their tail regions with overlaps in multiples of 140 A. The folded configuration of the myosin molecules is promoted by phosphorylation of the heavy chain by Dictyostelium myosin heavy chain kinase. It appears that the bent monomers are excluded from filaments formed upon addition of salt while the dimeric molecules assemble. These results may provide the structural basis for primary steps in myosin filament assembly and its regulation by heavy chain phosphorylation.     

Periodically arranged interactions within the myosin filament backbone revealed by mechanical unzipping

Numerous types of biological motion are driven by myosin thick filaments. Although the exact structure of the filament backbone is not known, it has long been hypothesized that periodically arranged charged regions along the myosin tail are the main contributors to filament stability. Here we provide a direct experimental test of this model by mechanically pulling apart synthetic myosin thick filaments. We find that unzipping is accompanied by broad force peaks periodically spaced at 4-, 14- and 43-nm intervals. This spacing correlates with the repeat distance of highly charged regions along the myosin tail. Lowering ionic strength does not change force-peak periodicity but increases the forces necessary for unzipping. The force peaks are partially reversible, indicating that the interactions are rapidly re-established upon mechanical relaxation. Thus, the zipping together of myosin tails via consecutive formation of periodically spaced bonds may be the underlying mechanism of spontaneous thick filament formation.     

The active cross-bridge motions of isolated thick filaments from myosin-regulated muscles detected by quasi-elastic light scattering.

Intensity fluctuation spectroscopy has been used successfully as a probe that can detect an increase in high-frequency internal motions of isolated thick filaments of Limulus muscle upon the addition of calcium ions. We have attributed such motions to cross-bridge motion instead of to an increase in the flexibility of the filament backbone. Here we show that after cleavage of the S-1 and then the S-2 moieties with papain, cross-linking the myosin heads to the filament backbone, or heat denaturation (42 degrees C, 10 min), the increase in the high frequency internal motions in the thick filaments no longer occurs. Congo Red, which has been shown to induce shortening of isolated myofibrils, also increases the high-frequency motions of the isolated filaments. Furthermore, the increase is suppressed by treating the filaments with a myosin ATPase inhibitor such as vanadate ions (10 mM) or by replacing ATP with either an equimolar CrADP or the nonhydrolyzable ATP analogue beta, gamma-imido-adenine-5'-triphosphate (AMP-PNP). Calcium ions have a similar effect on isolated thick filaments from scallop muscle, where the myosin is known to be regulatory. Calcium ions have no such effect on thick filaments isolated from frog muscle, which is believed not to be regulated by calcium binding to myosin. These results confirm our earlier supposition that the additional high frequency internal motions of the thick filaments isolated from striated muscle of Limulus are related to the energy dependent, active cross-bridge motions.