Effect of stress on protein degradation: role of the ubiquitin system.

Many factors which induce the stress response (heat shock protein synthesis) in eukaryotes also cause the formation of aberrant proteins. Such aberrant proteins are usually rapidly and selectively degraded in cells. Temperature step-up accelerates the degradation of a subset of normally stable proteins. This effect is transient and is confined to a narrow range of heat shock temperatures above which proteolysis is inhibited. The time course and extent of proteolysis elicited by a mild heat shock is consistent with data on the thermal transitions of cellular proteins. Biochemical and genetic evidence strongly supports the view that the ubiquitin system is primarily responsible for heat- or stress-damaged protein degradation in eukaryotic cells. It still remains to be determined how stress-damaged proteins are recognized by the ubiquitin system and selected for degradation. Ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3's) which attach multi-ubiquitin chains to proteins are thought to be responsible for the selection of proteins for degradation. Several species of E3 have recently been characterized. However, none of the known E3's seems to fulfil the role of selecting aberrant proteins for breakdown. Heat shock proteins which are thought to repair unfolded or misfolded proteins probably have a complementary function to the ubiquitin system which destroys damage proteins. The relationship between the ubiquitin system and the regulation of heat shock protein synthesis, which is still not understood, is discussed.     

Microinjection of ubiquitin: changes in protein degradation in HeLa cells subjected to heat-shock

Ubiquitin was radiolabeled by reaction with 125I-Bolton-Hunter reagent and introduced into HeLa cells using erythrocyte-mediated microinjection. The injected cells were then incubated at 45 degrees C for 5 min (reversible heat-shock) or for 30 min (lethal heat-shock). After either treatment, there were dramatic changes in the levels of ubiquitin conjugates. Under normal culture conditions, approximately 10% of the injected ubiquitin is linked to histones, 40% is found in conjugates with molecular weights greater than 25,000, and the rest is unconjugated. After heat-shock, the free ubiquitin pool and the level of histone-ubiquitin conjugates decreased rapidly, and high molecular weight conjugates predominated. Formation of large conjugates did not require protein synthesis; when analyzed by two-dimensional electrophoresis, the major conjugates did not co-migrate with heat-shock proteins before or after thermal stress. Concomitant with the loss of free ubiquitin, the degradation of endogenous proteins, injected hemoglobin, BSA, and ubiquitin was reduced in heat-shocked HeLa cells. After reversible heat-shock, the decrease in proteolysis was small, and both the rate of proteolysis and the size of the free ubiquitin pool returned to control levels upon incubation at 37 degrees C. In contrast, neither proteolysis nor free ubiquitin pools returned to control levels after lethal heat-shock. However, lethally heat-shocked cells degraded denatured hemoglobin more rapidly than native hemoglobin and ubiquitin-globin conjugates formed within them. Therefore, stabilization of proteins after heat-shock cannot be due to the loss of ubiquitin conjugation or inability to degrade proteins that form conjugates with ubiquitin.     

Induction of heat shock protein and thermal sensitivity of mammalian cells maintained at low culture temperature.

Effects of low culture temperature on the induction of heat shock proteins in FM3A cells by a heat shock and on the thermal sensitivity of the cells were examined. FM3A cells maintained at 33 degrees C could not induce hsp70 during continuous heating or after a short heat shock at either 39, 42, or 45 degrees C, although FM3A cells maintained at a normal culture temperature of 37 degrees C can induce the synthesis of hsp70. Furthermore, the cells maintained at 33 degrees C were more sensitive to the subsequent heat shock than the cells maintained at 37 degrees C. Thus, the culture temperature of the mammalian cells may be an important factor for the induction of hsp70, and hsp70 may play an important role to protect or repair the thermal damage of cells.     

Ubiquitin in Chlamydomonas reinhardii. Distribution in the cell and effect of heat shock and photoinhibition on its conjugate pattern

Ubiquitin, a highly conserved 76-amino-acid protein, is involved in the response of many types of eukaryotic cells to stress but little is known about its role in lower plants. In the present study we have investigated the distribution of ubiquitin in the unicellular alga Chlamydomonas reinhardii as well as the effect of heat and light stress on its conjugation to cellular proteins. Immunoelectron microscopy shows that ubiquitin is located in the chloroplast, nucleus, cytoplasm, pyrenoid and on the plasma membrane. The location of ubiquitin within chloroplasts has not been observed previously. In immunoblots of whole cell extracts with an antibody to ubiquitin a prominent conjugate band with an apparent molecular mass of 29 kDa and a broad region of high-molecular-mass conjugates (apparent molecular mass greater than 45 kDa) were observed. Exposure of cells to a 41.5 degrees C heat shock in both the dark and light caused the disappearance of the 29-kDa conjugate and an increase in the high-molecular-mass conjugates. After step down to 25 degrees C the 29-kDa conjugate reappeared while the levels of high-molecular-mass conjugates decreased. In light, the recovery of the 29-kDa band was more rapid than in the dark. Photoinhibition alters the ubiquitin conjugation pattern similarly to heat shock, but to a lesser degree. These observations imply that, in Chlamydomonas, ubiquitin has a role in the chloroplast and in the response to heat and light stress.     

Purification, characterization, and rapid inactivation of thermolabile ubiquitin-activating enzyme from the mammalian cell cycle mutant ts85

Conjugation of ubiquitin to certain proteins can trigger their degradation in the in vitro reticulocyte system. In order to determine whether ubiquitin conjugation serves as an intermediate step in the turnover of cellular proteins in vivo, it is necessary to isolate proteolytic intermediates, i.e. ubiquitin-protein adducts of specific cellular proteins. While the steady-state level of conjugates of rapidly turning over proteins is relatively high, that of long-lived proteins is presumably extremely low, and therefore undetectable. Therefore, mutant cell lines with conditionally altered function(s) of the ubiquitin system can serve as powerful tools in studying the degradation of stable cellular proteins. We have characterized a temperature sensitive cell cycle arrest mutant cell (ts85) with a thermolabile ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1; Finley, D., Ciechanover, A., and Varshavsky, A. (1984) Cell 37, 43-55). Following incubation at the restrictive temperature (39.5 degrees C), these cells fail to degrade short-lived proteins (Ciechanover, A., Finley, D., and Varshavsky, A. (1984) Cell 37, 57-66). However, involvement of the ubiquitin system in the turnover of long-lived proteins has not been addressed in these cells. A slow rate of inactivation of E1 in vivo, and significant rate of cell death following long incubation periods at the restrictive temperature, make this question difficult to address experimentally. In the present study we show that incubation of the cells for 1 h at 43 degrees C leads to rapid inactivation of ubiquitin conjugation in the intact mutant cell. Following heat treatment, the cells can be incubated at 39.5 degrees C for at least 6 h in order to study the possible involvement of the system in the turnover of long-lived cellular proteins. The viability of the cells is excellent at the end of the incubation. Following extraction, we have shown that inactivation occurs much more rapidly in the cell lysate in vitro than in the intact cell (t1/2 of 10 min compared to 4 h at 39.5 degrees C). The enzyme from both the mutant cell and the wild-type cell was purified to homogeneity. The molecular mass of the native enzyme from both cells is approximately 220 kDa with a subunit molecular mass of about 108 kDa. The structure of the enzyme is therefore very similar to that purified from rabbit reticulocytes. At the permissive temperature, the enzymes from both cells catalyze ATP-PPi and ATP-AMP exchange in similar kinetics. However, at the high temperature, the mutated enzyme is at least 7-fold less stable than the wild-type enzyme.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

A Chinese hamster cell cycle mutant arrested at G2 phase has a temperature-sensitive ubiquitin-activating enzyme, E1

The effect of restrictive temperature on ubiquitin conjugation activity has been studied in cells of ts20, a temperature-sensitive cell cycle mutant of the Chinese hamster cell line E36. Ts20 is arrested in early G2 phase at nonpermissive temperature. Immunoblotting with antibodies to ubiquitin conjugates shows that conjugates disappear rapidly at restrictive temperatures in ts20 mutant but not in wild type E36 cells. The incorporation of 125I-ubiquitin into permeabilized ts20 cells is temperature-sensitive. Addition of extracts of another G2 phase mutant, FM3A ts85, with a temperature-sensitive ubiquitin activation enzyme (E1), to permeabilized ts20 cells at restrictive temperatures fails to complement their ubiquitin ligation activity. This indicates that the lesions in the two mutants are similar. Purified E1 from reticulocytes restores the conjugation activity of heat-inactivated permeabilized ts20 cells. Ubiquitin conjugation activity of cell-free extracts of ts20 cells was temperature-sensitive and could be restored by adding purified reticulocyte E1. Purified reticulocyte E2 or E3, on the other hand, did not restore the ubiquitin conjugation activity of heat-treated ts20 extracts. These results are consistent with the conclusion that ts20 has temperature-sensitive ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1). The fact that two E1 mutants (ts20 and ts85) derived from different cell lines are arrested at the S/G2 boundary at restrictive temperatures strongly indicates that ubiquitin ligation is necessary for passage through this part of the cell cycle. The temperature thresholds of heat shock protein synthesis of ts20 and wild type E36 cells were identical. The implications of these findings with respect to a suggested role of ubiquitin in coupling between protein denaturation and the heat shock response are discussed.     

Heat-shock responses in two leguminous plants: a comparative study

Relative growth rates, basal and acclimated thermotolerance, membrane damage, fluorescence emission, and relative levels of free and conjugated ubiquitin and HSP70 were compared after 2 h of treatment at different temperatures between Prosopis chilensis and Glycine max (soybean), cv. McCall, to evaluate if the thermotolerance of these two plants was related to levels of accumulation of heat shock proteins. Seedlings of P. chilensis germinated at 25 degrees C and at 35 degrees C and grown at temperatures above germination temperature showed higher relative growth than soybean seedlings treated under the same conditions. The lethal temperature of both species was 50 degrees C after germination at 25 degrees C. However, they were able to grow at 50 degrees C after germination at 35 degrees C. Membrane damage determinations in leaves showed that P. chilensis has an LT(50) 6 degrees C higher than that of soybean. There were no differences in the quantum yield of photosynthesis (F(v)/F(m)), between both plants when the temperatures were raised. P. chilensis showed higher relative levels of free ubiquitin, conjugated ubiquitin and HSP70 than soybean seedlings when the temperatures were raised. Time-course studies of accumulation of these proteins performed at 40 degrees C showed that the relative accumulation rates of ubiquitin, conjugated ubiquitin and HSP70 were higher in P. chilensis than in soybean. In both plants, free ubiquitin decreased during the first 5 min and increased after 30 min of heat shock, conjugated ubiquitin increased after 30 min and HSP70 began to increase dramatically after 20 min of heat shock. From these data it is concluded that P. chilensis is more tolerant to acute heat stress than soybean.     

The ubiquitin-activating enzyme, E1, is required for stress-induced lysosomal degradation of cellular proteins.

ts85, a cell line that harbors a mutant thermolabile ubiquitin-activating enzyme, E1, fails to degrade short lived proteins at the restrictive temperature (Ciechanover, A., Finley, D., and Varshavsky, A. (1984) Cell 37, 57-66). However, the involvement of the ubiquitin system in the degradation of long lived proteins (most cellular proteins fall in this category) has not been addressed. In the present study we show that upon shifting the mutant cells to the restrictive temperature, there is no change in the rate of degradation of long lived proteins. In contrast, shifting the wild-type cells (FM3A) to the high temperature is accompanied by a 2-fold increase in the rate of proteolysis of this group of proteins. This heat-induced accelerated degradation can be inhibited completely by NH4Cl and chloroquine. Similarly, exposure of the cells to starvation, a stimulus that activates the autophagic-lysosomal pathway, has no effect on the degradation of long lived proteins in the mutant cells after inactivation of E1. Under the same conditions, the degradation rate in the wild-type cells increases almost 4-fold. Analogous results were obtained using a different cell line that also harbors a thermolabile E1 (ts20 (Kulka, R. G., Raboy, B., Schuster, R., Parag, H. A., Diamond, G., Ciechanover, A., and Marcus, M. (1988) J. Biol. Chem. 263, 15726-15731)). Cycloheximide and 3-methyladenine, known inhibitors of formation of autophagic vacuoles, inhibit the heat-induced accelerated degradation of long lived proteins in wild-type cells. Taken together, the results suggest that 1) heat stress induces enhanced degradation of intracellular proteins; 2) the process occurs most probably in autophagic vacuoles; and 3) activation of ubiquitin is required for the formation of these vacuoles. As there is no change in the basal rate of degradation of intracellular proteins in the mutant cells at the restrictive temperature, it appears that the ubiquitin system is not involved in their breakdown.     

Thermoinduced radioresistance of Escherichia coli cells and heat shock proteins

Radioresistance of E. coli cells is slightly increased (dose modification factor (DMF) = 1.2) with temperature elevated from 4 degrees to 43 degrees C at the time of gamma-irradiation. However, an appreciable effect of the thermoinduced radioresistance (DMF = 1.7) was observed when the wild-type cells were exposed to gamma-radiation at 15-43 degrees C (but not at 4 degrees C) after 30-min preincubation at 43 degrees C. This effect was absent in htpR mutants, defective in induction of heat shock proteins, and coupled with the decreased post-irradiation DNA degradation in gamma-irradiated htpR+ cells. It is suggested that heat shock proteins are involved in the thermoinduced radioresistance.     

Relationship between thermal tolerance and protein degradation in temperature-sensitive mouse cells.

The induction of thermotolerance was studied in a temperature sensitive mouse cell line, ts85, and results were compared with those for the wild-type FM3A cells. At the nonpermissive temperature of 39 degrees C, ts85 cells are defective in the degradation of short-lived abnormal proteins, apparently because of loss of activity of a ubiquitin-activating enzyme. The failure of the ts85 cells to develop thermotolerance to 41-43 degrees C after incubation at the nonpermissive temperature of 39 degrees C correlated with the failure of the cells to degrade short-lived abnormal proteins at 39 degrees C. However, the failure of the ts85 cells to develop thermotolerance to 43 degrees C during incubation at 33 degrees C after either arsenite treatment or heating at 45.5 degrees C for 6 or 10 min did not correlate with protein degradation rates. Although the rate of degrading abnormal protein was reduced after heating at 45.5 degrees C for 10 min, the rates were normal after arsenite treatment or heating at 45.5 degrees C for 6 min. In addition, when protein synthesis was inhibited with cycloheximide both during incubation at 33 degrees C or 39 degrees C and during heating at 41-43 degrees C, resistance to heating was observed, but protein degradation rates at 39 degrees C or 43 degrees C were not altered by the cycloheximide treatment. Therefore, there is apparently no consistent relationship between rates of degrading abnormal proteins and the ability of cells to develop thermotolerance and resistance to heating in the presence of cycloheximide.     

Degradation of ornithine decarboxylase in mammalian cells is ATP dependent but ubiquitin independent

Ornithine decarboxylase (ODC), a key enzyme in the biosynthesis of polyamines in mammalian cells is characterized by an extremely short half-life. In the present study, ODC degradation was investigated in 653-1 mouse myeloma cells that overproduce ODC and in ts85 cells that are thermosensitive for conjunction of ubiquitin to target proteins. Addition of 2-deoxyglucose and dinitrophenol (agents that efficiently deplete cellular ATP) to the growth medium of these cells inhibited ODC degradation. In contrast, chloroquine and leupeptin, inhibitors of intralysosomal proteolysis, did not affect ODC degradation. Shifting ts85 cells to 42 degrees C (a non-permissive temperature that inhibited conjugation of ubiquitin to target proteins) did not prevent ODC degradation. The ATP-dependent degradation of ODC in 653-1 cells was inhibited substantially by N alpha-tosyl-L-lysine chloromethane (TosPheMeCl), iodoacetamide and o-phenanthroline. These results suggest that ODC degradation occurs via a non-lysosomal. ATP-requiring and ubiquitin-independent cellular proteolytic mechanism, and that serine proteases and enzymes containing sulphydryl groups and metalloenzyme(s) may be involved in this process.     

AppppA-binding protein E89 is the Escherichia coli heat shock protein ClpB.

Dinucleotide AppppA (5',5''-P1,P4-diadenosine tetraphosphate) is rapidly synthesized in Escherichia coli cells during heat shock. apaH mutants lack AppppN hydrolase activity and, therefore, contain constitutively levels of AppppA, which affect several cellular processes. However, the precise role of AppppA remains undetermined. Photo-crosslinking experiments with radioactively labelled azido-AppppA have shown that a number of proteins, including heat shock proteins DnaK and GroEL, specifically bind to AppppA. Several other unidentified proteins (C40, C45, and E89) also bind strongly to AppppA. In this work, we have identified the AppppA-binding protein E89 as heat shock protein ClpB. In addition, since ClpB belongs to a family of proteins implicated in proteolysis, we have examined the effects of apaH mutants on protein degradation. Constitutively elevated levels of AppppA stimulate lon-independent proteolysis only in heat-shocked cells. We also show that overproduction of ClpB from a plasmid rescues apaH mutants from sensitivity to killing by heat.     

Characterization of a Tetrahymena thermophila mutant strain unable to develop normal thermotolerance.

For Tetrahymena thermophila cells to survive extended periods of time at 43 degrees C, they must continuously synthesize heat shock proteins. For its translational machinery to function at 43 degrees C, T. thermophila requires either prior nonlethal heat shock treatment or brief treatment with partially inhibiting doses of cycloheximide or emetine. We have identified and characterized a mutant strain of T. thermophila (MC-3) in which prior nonlethal heat shock does not prevent protein synthesis inactivation at 43 degrees C. In addition, treatment of MC-3 cells with either of the antibiotics that normally confer 43 degrees C thermoprotection on wild-type cells elicited no similar thermoprotective response in these cells. Despite these phenotypic characteristics, by other criteria MC-3 synthesized a normal, functional array of heat shock proteins at 40 degrees C, a nonlethal heat shock protein-inducing temperature. The mutation in MC-3 which prevents the thermostabilization of protein synthesis by nonlethal heat shock is, by genetic criteria, most likely the same one which prevents the induction of thermotolerance by drug treatments. We present evidence that this mutation may affect some ribosome-associated functions.     

ATP-stimulated degradation of endogenous proteins in cell-free extracts of BHK 21/C13 fibroblasts. A key role for the proteinase, macropain, in the ubiquitin-dependent degradation of short-lived proteins.

Baby hamster kidney (BHK) 21/C13 cell proteins, labeled with [35S]methionine, [14C]leucine or [3H]leucine in intact cells, were degraded in soluble, cell-free extracts by an ATP-stimulated process. The stimulatory effect of ATP appeared to require ATP hydrolysis and was mediated to a large extent by ubiquitin. Although the cell extracts contained endogenous ubiquitin, supplementation with exogenous ubiquitin increased ATP-dependent proteolysis by up to 2-fold. Furthermore, antibodies against the E1 ubiquitin conjugating enzyme specifically inhibited both conjugation of [125I]ubiquitin to endogenous proteins and ATP/ubiquitin-dependent proteolysis. Addition of purified E1 to antibody-treated extracts restored conjugation and proteolysis. Proteins containing the amino acid analogues canavanine and azatryptophan were also degraded in vitro by an ATP/ubiquitin-dependent process but at a rate up to 2-fold faster than normal proteins. These results indicate that soluble, cell-free extracts of BHK cells can selectively degrade proteins whose rates of degradation are increased in intact cells. Treatment of cell-free extracts with antibodies against the high molecular weight proteinase, macropain, also greatly inhibited the ATP/ubiquitin-dependent degradation of endogenous proteins. Proteolysis was specifically restored when purified macropain L was added to the antibody-treated extracts. Treatment of cell extracts with both anti-macropain and anti-E1 antibodies reduced ATP/ubiquitin-dependent proteolysis to the same extent as treatment with either antibody alone. Furthermore, proteolysis could be restored to the double antibody treated extracts only after addition of both purified E1 and macropain. These results provide strong evidence for an important role for macropain in the ATP/ubiquitin-dependent degradation of endogenous proteins in BHK cell extracts.     

Hyperthermia-induced heat shock response and thermotolerance in postimplantation rat embryos

Postimplantation stage rat embryos (6-10 somites) undergo abnormal development after exposure to a temperature of 43 degrees C for 30 min. A heat shock of 43 degrees C for 30 min also induces the synthesis of a set of eight heat shock proteins (hsps) with molecular masses ranging from 28,000 to 82,000 Da. The synthesis of these hsps is rapidly induced after the heat shock is applied and rapidly decays after embryos are returned to 37 degrees C. A heat shock of 42 degrees C for 30 min has no effect on rat embryo growth and development, but does induce the synthesis of three hsps. The most prominent of these three is believed to be the typical mammalian 70 kDa hsp. Furthermore, a 42 degrees C, 30-min heat shock followed by a 43 degrees C 30-min heat shock leads to partial protection from the embryotoxic effects of a single exposure at 43 degrees C, i.e., thermotolerance.     

Vanadate inhibits the ATP-dependent degradation of proteins in reticulocytes without affecting ubiquitin conjugation

Reticulocytes contain a nonlysosomal, ATP-dependent system for degrading abnormal proteins and normal proteins during cell maturation. Vanadate, which inhibits several ATPases including the ATP-dependent proteases in Escherichia coli and liver mitochondria, also markedly reduced the ATP-dependent degradation of proteins in reticulocyte extracts. At low concentrations (K1 = 50 microM), vanadate inhibited the ATP-dependent hydrolysis of [3H]methylcasein and denatured 125I-labeled bovine serum albumin, but it did not reduce the low amount of proteolysis seen in the absence of ATP. This inhibition by vanadate was rapid in onset, reversed by dialysis, and was not mimicked by molybdate. Vanadate inhibits proteolysis at an ATP-stimulated step which is independent of the ATP requirement for ubiquitin conjugation to protein substrates. When the amino groups on casein and bovine serum albumin were covalently modified so as to prevent their conjugation to ubiquitin, the derivatized proteins were still degraded by an ATP-stimulated process that was inhibited by vanadate. In addition, vanadate did not reduce the ATP-dependent conjugation of 125I-ubiquitin to endogenous reticulocyte proteins, although it markedly inhibited their degradation. In intact reticulocytes vanadate also inhibited the degradation of endogenous proteins and of abnormal proteins containing amino acid analogs. This effect was rapid and reversible; however, vanadate also reduced protein synthesis and eventually lowered ATP levels in the intact cells. Vanadate (10 mM) has also been reported to decrease intralysosomal proteolysis in hepatocytes. However, in liver extracts this effect on lysosomal proteases required high concentrations of vanadate (K1 = 500 microM) and was also observed with molybdate, unlike the inhibition of ATP-dependent proteolysis in reticulocytes.     

No heat shock protein synthesis is required for induced thermostabilization of translational machinery.

For Tetrahymena thermophila cells to survive at 43 degrees C, a normally lethal temperature, they require a pretreatment which either elicits the synthesis of heat shock proteins or one which brings about a change in the translational machinery of the cell such that is is not inactivated when transferred to 43 degrees C. In this report I present evidence showing that the latter modification can occur in the complete absence of protein synthesis, indicating that heat shock protein production is not required for the induced thermostabilization of the translational machinery.