Unfolding of a Small Protein Proceeds via Dry and Wet Globules and a Solvated Transition State

Dissecting a protein unfolding process into individual steps can provide valuable information on the forces that maintain the integrity of the folded structure. Solvation of the protein core determines stability, but it is not clear when such solvation occurs during unfolding. In this study, far-UV circular dichroism measurements suggest a simplistic two-state view of the unfolding of barstar, but the use of multiple other probes brings out the complexity of the unfolding reaction. Near-UV circular dichroism measurements show that unfolding commences with the loosening of tertiary interactions in a native-like intermediate, N^∗. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements show that N^∗ then expands rapidly but partially to form an early unfolding intermediate I_E. Fluorescence spectral measurements indicate that both N^∗ and I_E have retained native-like solvent accessibility of the core, suggesting that they are dry molten globules. Dynamic quenching measurements at the single tryptophan buried in the core suggest that the core becomes solvated only later in a late wet molten globule, I_L, which precedes the unfolded form. Fluorescence anisotropy decay measurements show that tight packing around the core tryptophan is lost when I_L forms. Of importance, the slowest step is unfolding of the wet molten globule and involves a solvated transition state.     

Hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin forms a molten globule conformation at acidic pH

The conformational properties of hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin (Val26 to Ala mutation) in an acidic solution were studied. The intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence emission spectrum, far-UV and near-UV circular dichroic spectra, the fluorescence emission spectrum of 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid in the presence of V26A ubiquitin, and urea-induced unfolding measurements indicate this variant ubiquitin to be in the partially folded molten globule conformation in solution at pH 2. The folding kinetics from molten globule to the native state was nearly identical to those from the unfolded state to the native state. This observation suggests that the equilibrium molten globule state of hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin is an on-pathway folding intermediate.     

Hexafluoroacetone hydrate as a structure modifier in proteins: characterization of a molten globule state of hen egg-white lysozyme.

A molten globule-like state of hen egg-white lysozyme has been characterized in 25% aqueous hexafluoroacetone hydrate (HFA) by CD, fluorescence, NMR, and H/D exchange experiments. The far UV CD spectra of lysozyme in 25% HFA supports retention of native-like secondary structure while the loss of near UV CD bands are indicative of the overall collapse of the tertiary structure. The intermediate state in 25% HFA exhibits an enhanced affinity towards the hydrophobic dye, ANS, and a native-like tryptophan fluorescence quenching. 1-D NMR spectra indicates loss of native-like tertiary fold as evident from the absence of ring current-shifted 1H resonances. CD, fluorescence, and NMR suggest that the transition from the native state to a molten globule state in 25% HFA is a cooperative process. A second structural transition from this compact molten globule-like state to an "open" helical state is observed at higher concentrations of HFA (> or = 50%). This transition is characterized by a dramatic loss of ANS binding with a concomitant increase in far UV CD bands. The thermal unfolding of the molten globule state in 25% HFA is sharply cooperative, indicating a predominant role of side-chain-side-chain interactions in the stability of the partially folded state. H/D exchange experiments yield higher protection factors for many of the backbone amide protons from the four alpha-helices along with the C-terminal 3(10) helix, whereas little or no protection is observed for most of the amide protons from the triple-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet domain. This equilibrium molten globule-like state of lysozyme in 25% HFA is remarkably similar to the molten globule state observed for alpha-lactalbumin and also with the molten globule state transiently observed in the kinetic refolding experiments of hen lysozyme. These results suggest that HFA may prove generally useful as a structure modifier in proteins.     

Trichloroacetic acid-induced molten globule state of aminoacylase from pig kidney

The trichloroacetic acid (TCA)-induced unfolding of aminoacylase was investigated by measurement of aggregation, enzyme activity, intrinsic fluorescence, 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) binding, circular dichroism, and native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The results showed that TCA caused inactivation and unfolding of aminoacylase. Intrinsic fluorescence results demonstrated that the TCA-induced transition of aminoacylase was characterized by two distinct stages during which the fluorescence emission maxima first redshifted to 338 nm and then blueshifted to 332 nm, close to that of native protein. ANS binding measurements revealed that TCA-denatured aminoacylase had a large hydrophobic area for TCA concentration near 2 mM. Comparison of the relative changes in wavelength shift and in the ANS intensity suggested the formation of a stable molten globule state of aminoacylase with a slightly disrupted tertiary structure and more hydrophobic surface than the native protein. Far-UV circular dichroism results provided further support that TCA induced the formation of two partially folded intermediates each with an enhanced native-like secondary structure. The results collectively suggest that a TCA-induced molten globule state is formed and stabilized during unfolding of aminoacylase and that association of the molten globule state may account for precipitation of the protein when denatured by TCA.     

The molten globule state of a chimera of human alpha-lactalbumin and equine lysozyme.

The molten globule state of equine lysozyme is more stable than that of alpha-lactalbumin and is stabilized by non-specific hydrophobic interactions and native-like hydrophobic interactions. We constructed a chimeric protein which is produced by replacing the flexible loop (residues 105-110) in human alpha-lactalbumin with the helix D (residues 109-114) in equine lysozyme to investigate the possible role of the helix D for the high stability and native-like packing interaction in the molten globule state of equine lysozyme. The stability of the molten globule state formed by the chimeric protein to guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding is the same as that of equine lysozyme and is substantially greater than that of human alpha-lactalbumin, although only six residues come from equine lysozyme. Our results also suggest that the non-native interaction in the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin changes to the native-like packing interaction due to helix substitution. The solvent-accessibility of the Trp residues in the molten globule state of the chimeric protein is similar to that in the molten globule state of equine lysozyme in which packing interaction around the Trp residues in the native state is partially preserved. Therefore, the helix D in equine lysozyme is one of the contributing factors to the high stability and native-like packing interaction in the molten globule state of equine lysozyme. Our results indicate that the native-like packing interaction can stabilize the rudimentary intermediate which is stabilized by the non-specific hydrophobic interactions.     

Denatured collapsed states in protein folding: example of apomyoglobin.

Experimental approaches, including circular dichroism, small angle X-ray scattering, steady-state fluorescence, and fluorescence energy transfer, were applied to study the 3D-structure of apomyolgobin in different conformational states. These included the native and molten globules, along with either less ordered conformations induced by the addition of anions or completely unfolded states. The results show that the partially folded forms of apomyoglobin stabilized by KCl and/or Na(2)SO(4) under unfolding conditions (pH 2) exhibit a significant amount of secondary structure (circular dichroism), low packing density of protein molecules (SAXS), and native-like dimensions of the AGH core (fluorescence energy transfer). This finding indicates that a native-like tertiary fold of the polypeptide chain, i.e., the spatial organization of secondary structure elements, most likely emerges prior to the formation of the molten globule state.     

Structural and thermodynamic consequences of removal of a conserved disulfide bond from equine beta-lactoglobulin

A disulfide bond between cysteine 66 and cysteine 160 of equine beta-lactoglobulin was removed by substituting cysteine residues with alanine. This disulfide bond is conserved across the lipocalin family. The conformation and stability of the disulfide-deleted mutant protein was investigated by circular dichroism. The mutant protein assumes a native-like structure under physiological conditions and assumes a helix-rich molten globule structure at acid pH or at moderate concentrations of urea as the wild-type protein does. The urea-induced unfolding experiment shows that the stability of the native conformation was reduced but that of the molten globule intermediate is not significantly changed at pH 4 by removal of the disulfide bond. On the other hand, the molten globule at acid pH was destabilized by removal of the disulfide bond. This difference in the stabilizing effect of the disulfide bond was interpreted by the effect of the disulfide in keeping the molecule compact against the electrostatic repulsion at acid pH. In contrast to the wild-type protein, the circular dichroism spectrum in the molten globule state at acid pH depends on anion concentration, suggesting that the expansion of the molecule through electrostatic repulsion induces alpha-helices as observed in the cold denatured state of the wild-type protein.     

Characterization of acid-induced unfolding intermediates of glucose/xylose isomerase.

Acid-induced unfolding of the tetrameric glucose/xylose isomerase (GXI) from Streptomyces sp. NCIM 2730 has been investigated using intrinsic fluorescence, fluorescence quenching, second derivative spectroscopy, hydrophobic dye (1-anilino-8-naphthalene-sulfonate) binding and CD techniques. The pH dependence of tryptophanyl fluorescence of GXI at different temperatures indicated the presence of two stable intermediates at pH 5.0 and pH 3.0. The pH 3.2 intermediate was a dimer and exhibited molten globule-like characteristics, such as the presence of native-like secondary structure, loss of tertiary structure, increased exposure of hydrophobic pockets, altered microenvironment of tyrosine residues and increased accessibility to quenching by acrylamide. Fluorescence and CD studies on GXI at pH 5.0 suggested the involvement of a partially folded intermediate state in the native to molten globule state transition. The partially folded intermediate state retained considerable secondary and tertiary structure compared to the molten globule state. This state was characterized by its hydrophobic dye binding capacity, which is smaller than the molten globule state, but was greater than that of the native state. This state shared the dimeric status of the molten globule state but was prone to aggregate formation as evident by the Rayleigh light scattering studies. Based on these results, the unfolding pathway of GXI can be illustrated as: N-->PFI-->MG-->U; where N is the native state at pH 7.5; PFI is the partially folded intermediate state at pH 5.0; MG is the molten globule state at pH 3.2 and U is the monomeric unfolded state of GXI obtained in the presence of 6 M GdnHCl. Our results demonstrate the existence of a partially folded state and molten globule state on the unfolding pathway of a multimeric alpha/beta barrel protein.     

An evidence for the equilibrium unfolding intermediates of ribonuclease A by tritium labeling method

A formation of a molten globule in the unfolding of ribonuclease A could be considered as an evidence supporting a hypothesis on the existence of such intermediates on the pathway of a protein folding. Using a novel technique (tritium labeling method) we have showed that the ribonuclease A equilibrium unfolding in urea and guanidinium chloride (GuCl) solutions proceeds through a formation of intermediates whose properties (compactness, retention of the larger part hydrophobic core, secondary structure, and native-like folding pattern) correspond to the fundamental characteristics of the molten globule state. The both intermediates are the “wet” molten globules (the globule interior contains the water molecules). The results reveal the noticeable distinctions in intermediates structure, first of all, in the extent of their compactness. The urea intermediate is less compact than that in GuCl. It is shown that the refolding of the protein denatured by GuCl results in the formation of the intermediate which enzyme activity is virtually the same as the activity of the native protein.     

How Ala-->Gly mutations in different helices affect the stability of the apomyoglobin molten globule

The apomyoglobin molten globule has a complex, partly folded structure with a folded A[B]GH subdomain; the factors determining its stability are not yet known in detail. Ala-->Gly mutations, made at solvent-exposed positions, are used to probe the role of helix propensity of individual helices in stabilizing the molten globule. Molten globule stability is measured by reversible urea unfolding, monitored both by circular dichroism and by tryptophan fluorescence. Two-state unfolding is tested by superposition of these two unfolding curves, and stability data are reported only for variants which satisfy the superposition test. Results for sites Q8 in the A helix and E109 in the G helix confirm that the helix propensities of the A and G helices both strongly affect molten globule stability, in contrast to results for the G65A/G73A double mutant which show that changing the helix propensity of the E-helix sequence has no significant stabilizing effect. Changing the helix propensity of the B-helix sequence with the G23A/G25A double mutant affects molten globule stability to an intermediate extent, confirming an earlier report that this mutant has increased stability. These results are consistent with the bipartite structure for the molten globule in which the A, G, and H helices are stably folded, while the long E helix is unfolded and the B helix has intermediate stability. Some differences are found in the shapes of the unfolding curves of different mutants even though they satisfy the superposition test for two-state unfolding, and possible explanations are discussed.     

Cold denaturation of alpha-lactalbumin

We have investigated the thermal unfolding of bovine alpha-lactalbumin by means of circular dichroism spectroscopy in the far- and near-ultraviolet regions, and shown that the native alpha-lactalbumin undergoes heat and cold denaturation. The guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding of alpha-lactalbumin was also investigated by circular dichroism spectroscopy at various temperatures from 261 to 318 K. It is shown that the population of the molten globule state is strongly dependent on temperature and that the molten globule state does not accumulate during the guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding transition at 261 K. Our results indicate that the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin undergoes cold denaturation as the native alpha-lactalbumin does, and that the heat capacity change of unfolding from the molten globule to the unfolded state is positive and significant. The present results further support the idea that the molten globule and the unfolded states do not belong to the same thermodynamic state, and that the native, molten globule and unfolded states are sufficient for interpreting the guanidine hydrochloride-induced unfolding behavior of alpha-lactalbumin.     

pH-Dependent Conformational Transitions in Conalbumin (Ovotransferrin), a Metalloproteinase from Hen Egg White

Acid unfolding pathway of conalbumin (CA), a monomeric glycoprotein from hen egg white, has been investigated using far- and near-UV CD spectroscopy, intrinsic fluorescence emission, extrinsic fluorescence probe 1-anilino-8-napthalene sulfonate (ANS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS). We observe pH-dependent changes in secondary and tertiary structure of CA. It has native-like α-helical secondary structure at pH 4.0 but loss structure at pH 3.0. The CA existed exclusively as a pre-molten globule state and molten globule state in solution at pH 4.0 and pH 3.0, respectively. The effect of pH on the conformation and thermostability of CA points toward its heat resistance at neutral pH. DLS results show that MG state existed as compact form in aqueous solutions with hydrodynamic radii of 4.7 nm. Quenching of tryptophan fluorescence by acrylamide further confirmed the accumulation of an intermediate state, partly unfolded, in-between native and unfolded states.     

Equilibrium unfolding of <Emphasis Type="Italic">A. niger</Emphasis> RNase: pH dependence of chemical and thermal denaturation

Equilibrium unfolding of A. niger RNase with chemical denaturants, for example GuHCl and urea, and thermal unfolding have been studied as a function of pH using fluorescence, far-UV, near-UV, and absorbance spectroscopy. Because of their ability to affect electrostatic interactions, pH and chemical denaturants have a marked effect on the stability, structure, and function of many globular proteins. ANS binding studies have been conducted to enable understanding of the folding mechanism of the protein in the presence of the denaturants. Spectroscopic studies by absorbance, fluorescence, and circular dichroism and use of K2D software revealed that the enzyme has α + β type secondary structure with approximately 29% α-helix, 24% β-sheet, and 47% random coil. Under neutral conditions the enzyme is stable in urea whereas GuHCl-induced equilibrium unfolding was cooperative. A. niger RNase has little ANS binding even under neutral conditions. Multiple intermediates were populated during the pH-induced unfolding of A. niger RNase. Urea and temperature-induced unfolding of A. niger RNase into the molten globule-like state is non-cooperative, in contrast to the cooperativity seen with the native protein, suggesting the presence of two parts/domains, in the molecular structure of A. niger RNase, with different stability that unfolds in steps. Interestingly, the GuHCl-induced unfolding of the A state (molten globule state) of A. niger RNase is unique, because a low concentration of denaturant not only induces structural change but also facilitates transition from one molten globule like state (A_MG1) into another (I_MG2).     

Alpha-lactalbumin forms a compact molten globule in the absence of disulfide bonds.

Human alpha-lactalbumin (alpha-LA) is a four disulfide-bonded protein that adopts partially structured conformations under a variety of mildly denaturing conditions. At low pH, the protein is denatured but compact, with a high degree of secondary structure and a native-like fold. This is commonly referred to as a molten globule. A variant of alpha-LA, in which all eight cysteines have been mutated to alanine (all-Ala alpha-LA), has been studied using NMR spectroscopy. At low pH all-Ala alpha-LA is nearly as compact as wild type alpha-LA. Urea-induced unfolding experiments reveal that the residues that remain compact in the absence of disulfide bonds are those that are most resistant to unfolding in the wild-type alpha-LA molten globule. This is particularly remarkable because this stable core is formed by segments of the polypeptide chain from both the N- and C-termini. These results show that the overall architecture of the protein fold of alpha-LA is determined by the polypeptide sequence itself, and not as the result of cross-linking by disulfide bonds, and provide insight into the way in which the sequence codes for the fold.     

Fluorescence and FTIR study of pressure-induced structural modifications of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase (HLADH).

The process of pressure-induced modification of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase (HLADH) was followed by measuring in situ catalytic activity (up to 250 MPa), intrinsic fluorescence (0.1-600 MPa) and modifications of FTIR spectra (up to 1000 MPa). The tryptophan fluorescence measurements and the kinetic data indicated that the pressure-induced denaturation of HLADH was a process involving several transitions and that the observed transient states have characteristic properties of molten globules. Low pressure (< 100 MPa) induced no important modification in the catalytic efficiency of the enzyme and slight conformational changes, characterized by a small decrease in the centre of spectral mass of the enzyme's intrinsic fluorescence: a native-like state was assumed. Higher pressures (100-400 MPa) induced a strong decrease of HLADH catalytic efficiency and further conformational changes. At 400 MPa, a dimeric molten globule-like state was proposed. Further increase of pressure (400-600 MPa) seemed to induce the dissociation of the dimer leading to a transition from the first dimeric molten globule state to a second monomeric molten globule. The existence of two independent structural domains in HLADH was assumed to explain this transition: these domains were supposed to have different stabilities against high pressure-induced denaturation. FTIR spectroscopy was used to follow the changes in HLADH secondary structures. This technique confirmed that the intermediate states have a low degree of unfolding and that no completely denatured form seemed to be reached, even up to 1000 MPa.     

Contribution of the 6-120 disulfide bond of alpha-lactalbumin to the stabilities of its native and molten globule states.

The unfolding and refolding of a derivative of alpha-lactalbumin, in which the disulfide bond between Cys6 and Cys120 is selectively reduced and S-carboxymethylated, are investigated by equilibrium and kinetic circular dichroism measurements. The native conformation of this derivative is known to be essentially identical to that of intact alpha-lactalbumin. The equilibrium unfolding of the derivative involves a stable intermediate, which is also similar to the molten globule state of the disulfide intact protein. The results of stopped-flow circular dichroism experiments show that the same intermediate is formed rapidly as a transient intermediate in kinetic refolding. The conformational stabilities for the native and intermediate states have been estimated and compared with the stabilities for the corresponding states of intact alpha-lactalbumin. The stabilization of the native state by the disulfide has been interpreted in terms of a decrease in chain entropy in the unfolded state and elimination of the strain imposed on the disulfide bond in the native state. The molten globule state is also stabilized by the disulfide bond, although the degree of stabilization of the molten globule state is smaller than of the native state. The results suggest that, in the molten globule state, some ordered structures are present within the loop moiety formed by the 6-120 disulfide.     

Detection and characterization of an ovine placental lactogen stable intermediate in the urea-induced unfolding process.

The urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of ovine placental lactogen, purified from ovine placenta, was followed by size-exclusion chromatography, far-UV CD, and intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. The data obtained by each of these methods showed a poor fit to a two-state model involving only a native and an unfolded form. A satisfactory fit required, instead, a model that involved a stable, partially folded form in addition to the native and unfolded ones. The results obtained from the best-fitting theoretical curves for the three-state model indicated that this intermediate state, which is the predominant species in solution at 3.6 M of urea activity, is compact, largely alpha-helical, and changes considerably the native-like tertiary packing around its tryptophan residues. These findings suggest that this stable intermediate exhibits properties similar to those that characterize the molten globule state.     

Equilibrium and kinetics of the folding and unfolding of canine milk lysozyme

The equilibrium and kinetics of canine milk lysozyme folding/unfolding were studied by peptide and aromatic circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy. The Ca2+-free apo form of the protein exhibited a three-state equilibrium unfolding, in which the molten globule state is well populated as an unfolding intermediate. A rigorous analysis of holo protein unfolding, including the data from the kinetic refolding experiments, revealed that the holo protein also underwent three-state unfolding with the same molten globule intermediate. Although the observed kinetic refolding curves of both forms were single-exponential, a burst-phase change in the peptide ellipticity was observed in both forms, and the burst-phase intermediates of both forms were identical to each other with respect to their stability, indicating that the intermediate does not bind Ca2+. This intermediate was also shown to be identical to the molten globule state observed at equilibrium. The phi-value analysis, based on the effect of Ca2+ on the folding and unfolding rate constants, showed that the Ca2+-binding site was not yet organized in the transition state of folding. A comparison of the result with that previously reported for alpha-lactalbumin indicated that the folding initiation site is different between canine milk lysozyme and alpha-lactalbumin, and hence, the folding pathways must be different between the two proteins. These results thus provide an example of the phenomenon wherein proteins that are very homologous to each other take different folding pathways. It is also shown that the native state of the apo form is composed of at least two species that interconvert.     

Differential chemical and thermal unfolding pattern of Rv3588c and Rv1284 of Mycobacterium tuberculosis — A comparison by fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy

The thermal and chemical unfolding pathways of two β carbonic anhydrases, Rv3588c and Rv1284 of Mycobacterium tuberculosis have been compared by fluorescence and circular dichroism. Chemical and thermal denaturation of the tertiary and secondary structures of these two ubiquitous enzymes of the pathogen reveals that the unfolding of Rv3588c is mediated through the formation of a molten globule intermediate with depleted tertiary structure. However, Rv1284 directly unfolds from the native to the unfolded state. Calculation of the thermodynamic parameters suggest that overall Rv3588c is more stable than Rv1284. Stern–Volmer analysis together with the fluorescence spectra of the proteins suggest that Trp115 in Rv1284 is more buried than Trp10 in Rv3588c. The tryptophan residues in both the proteins are surrounded by positively charged amino acid residues.     

Molecular mechanism underlying the thermal stability and pH-induced unfolding of CHABII

The 37-residue alpha/beta protein CHABII was previously demonstrated to undergo a gradual pH-induced unfolding. It has been shown that even at pH 4.0 CHABII still retained a highly native-like secondary structure and tertiary topology although its tight side-chain packing was severely disrupted, typical of the molten globule state. Here, we have expressed and refolded the recombinant proteins of CHABII and its mutant [Phe21]-CHABII, and subsequently conducted extensive CD and NMR characterizations. The results indicated: (1) replacement of His21 by Phe in [Phe21]-CHABII eliminated the pH-induced unfolding from pH 6.5 to 4.0, indicating that His21 was responsible for the observed pH-induced unfolding of CHABII. Further examinations revealed that although the pH-induced unfolding of CHABII was also triggered by the protonation of the His residue as previously uncovered for apomyoglobin, their molecular mechanisms are different. (2) Monitoring the pH-induced unfolding by 1H-15N HSQC spectroscopy allowed us to visualize the gradual development of the CHABII molten globule. At pH 4.0, the HSQC spectrum of CHABII was poorly dispersed with dispersions of approximately 1 ppm over proton dimension and 10 ppm over 15N dimension, characteristic of severely or even "completely unfolded" proteins. One the other hand, unambiguous assignments of the NOESY spectra of CHABII led to the identification of the persistent medium and long-range NOEs at pH 4.0, which define a highly native-like secondary structure and tertiary packing. This implies that the degree of the native-like topology might be underestimated in the previous characterization of partially folded and even completely unfolded proteins. (3) Replacement of His21 by Phe with higher side-chain hydrophobicity only caused a minor structural rearrangement but considerably enhanced the packing interaction of the hydrophobic core, as evident from a dramatic increase in NOE contacts in [Phe21]-CHABII. The enhancement led to an increase of the thermal stability of [Phe21]-CHABII by approximately 17 deg. C.