DNA cleavage reactions by type II restriction enzymes that require two copies of their recognition sites

Several type II restriction endonucleases interact with two copies of their target sequence before they cleave DNA. Three such enzymes, NgoMIV, Cfr10I and NaeI, were tested on plasmids with one or two copies of their recognition sites, and on catenanes containing two interlinked rings of DNA with one site in each ring. The enzymes showed distinct patterns of behaviour. NgoMIV and NaeI cleaved the plasmid with two sites faster than that with one site and the catenanes at an intermediate rate, while Cfr10I gave similar steady-state rates on all three substrates. Both Cfr10I and NgoMIV converted the majority of the substrates with two sites directly to the products cut at both sites, while NaeI cleaved just one site at a time. All three enzymes thus synapse two DNA sites through three-dimensional space before cleaving DNA. With Cfr10I and NgoMIV, both sites are cleaved in one turnover, in a manner consistent with their tetrameric structures, while the cleavage of a single site by NaeI indicates that the second site acts not as a substrate but as an activator, as reported previously. The complexes spanning two sites have longer lifetimes on catenanes with one site in each ring than on circular DNA with two sites, which indicates that the catenanes have more freedom for site juxtaposition than plasmids with sites in cis.     

Diversity of type II restriction endonucleases that require two DNA recognition sites

Orthodox Type IIP restriction endonucleases, which are commonly used in molecular biological work, recognize a single palindromic DNA recognition sequence and cleave within or near this sequence. Several new studies have reported on structural and biochemical peculiarities of restriction endonucleases that differ from the orthodox in that they require two copies of a particular DNA recognition sequence to cleave the DNA. These two sites requiring restriction endonucleases belong to different subtypes of Type II restriction endonucleases, namely Types IIE, IIF and IIS. We compare enzymes of these three types with regard to their DNA recognition and cleavage properties. The simultaneous recognition of two identical DNA sites by these restriction endonucleases ensures that single unmethylated recognition sites do not lead to chromosomal DNA cleavage, and might reflect evolutionary connections to other DNA processing proteins that specifically function with two sites.     

Studies on sequence recognition by type II restriction and modification enzymes

Type II DNA restriction and modification systems are ideally suited for analysis of mechanisms by which proteins specifically recognize unique DNA sequences. Each system is comprised of a unique DNA recognition site and two enzymes, which in those cases examined in detail, are comprised of distinct polypeptide chains. Thus, not only are the DNA substrates extremely well defined, but each system affords the opportunity to compare distinct proteins which interact with a common DNA sequence. This review will focus only on those Type II systems which have been examined in sufficient molecular detail to permit some insight into modes of specific DNA-protein interaction.     

Many type IIs restriction endonucleases interact with two recognition sites before cleaving DNA.

Type IIs restriction endonucleases recognize asymmetric DNA sequences and cleave both DNA strands at fixed positions, typically several base pairs away from the recognition site. These enzymes are generally monomers that transiently associate to form dimers to cleave both strands. Their reactions could involve bridging interactions between two copies of their recognition sequence. To examine this possibility, several type IIs enzymes were tested against substrates with either one or two target sites. Some of the enzymes cleaved the DNA with two target sites at the same rate as that with one site, but most cut their two-site substrate more rapidly than the one-site DNA. In some cases, the two sites were cut sequentially, at rates that were equal to each other but that exceeded the rate on the one-site DNA. In another case, the DNA with two sites was cleaved rapidly at one site, but the residual site was cleaved at a much slower rate. In a further example, the two sites were cleaved concertedly to give directly the final products cut at both sites. Many type IIs enzymes thus interact with two copies of their recognition sequence before cleaving DNA, although via several different mechanisms.     

Cleavage of DNA.RNA hybrids by type II restriction enzymes.

The action of a number of restriction enzymes on DNA.RNA hybrids has been examined using hybrids synthesised with RNAs of cucumber mosaic virus as templates. The enzymes EcoRI, HindII, SalI, MspI, HhaI, AluI, TaqI and HaeIII cleaved the DNA strand of the hybrids (and possible also the RNA strand) into specific fragments. For four of these enzymes, HhaI, AluI, TaqI and HaeIII, comparison of the restriction fragments produced with the known sequences of the viral RNAs confirmed that they were recognising and cleaving the DNA strand of the hybrids at their correct recognition sequences. It is likely that the ability to utilise DNA.RNA hybrids as substrates is a general property of Type II restriction enzymes.     

DNA recognition by a new family of type I restriction enzymes: a unique relationship between two different DNA specificities.

The DNA sequences recognized by the allelic type I restriction enzymes EcoR124 and EcoR124/3 were determined. EcoR124 recognizes 5'-GAA(N6)RTCG-3' and EcoR124/3 recognizes 5'-GAA(N7)RTCG-3'. These are typical of sequences recognized by type I recognition enzymes in that they consist of two specific domains separated by a non-specific spacer sequence. For these two enzymes, the specific sequences are identical but the length of the non-specific spacer is different. The specific domains of EcoR124/3 are thus 3.4 A further apart than those of EcoR124 and rotated with respect to each other through a further 36 degrees.     

DNA looping and translocation provide an optimal cleavage mechanism for the type III restriction enzymes

EcoP15I is a type III restriction enzyme that requires two recognition sites in a defined orientation separated by up to 3.5 kbp to efficiently cleave DNA. The mechanism through which site-bound EcoP15I enzymes communicate between the two sites is unclear. Here, we use atomic force microscopy to study EcoP15I-DNA pre-cleavage complexes. From the number and size distribution of loops formed, we conclude that the loops observed do not result from translocation, but are instead formed by a contact between site-bound EcoP15I and a nonspecific region of DNA. This conclusion is confirmed by a theoretical polymer model. It is further shown that translocation must play some role, because when translocation is blocked by a Lac repressor protein, DNA cleavage is similarly blocked. On the basis of these results, we present a model for restriction by type III restriction enzymes and highlight the similarities between this and other classes of restriction enzymes.     

Reactions of type II restriction endonucleases with 8-base pair recognition sites

Type II restriction endonucleases usually recognize 4-6-base pair (bp) sites on DNA and cleave each site in a separate reaction. A few type II endonucleases have 8-bp recognition sites, but these seem unsuited for restriction, since their sites are rare on most DNA. Moreover, only one endonuclease that recognizes a target containing 8 bp has been examined to date, and this enzyme, SfiI, needs two copies of this site for its DNA cleavage reaction. In this study, several endonucleases with 8-bp sites were tested on plasmids that have either one or two copies of the relevant sequence to determine if they also need two sites. SgfI, SrfI, FseI, PacI, PmeI, Sse8781I, and SdaI all acted through equal and independent reactions at each site. AscI cleaved the DNA with one site at the same rate as that with two sites but acted processively on the latter. In contrast, SgrAI showed a marked preference for the plasmid with two sites and cleaved both sites on this DNA in a concerted manner, like SfiI. Endonucleases that require two copies of an 8-bp sequence may be widespread in nature, where, despite this seemingly inappropriate requirement, they may function in DNA restriction.     

Codification and evolution of experimentally observed specific recognition sites for restriction enzymes on DNA

The list of published restriction endonucleases along with their substrates provides an excellent data base for the evaluation of the evolution and codification of the key elements for specific recognition sites on the DNA. In this paper the considerations will be limited to palindromic tetramer-, pentamer-, and hexamer-sequences. It is basically assumed that each base pair within these sequences has to be recognized by directionally unique bidentate hydrogen bonds either within the plane of the base pair or by bridging the appropriate H-bond donor/acceptor groups of the neighbouring bases of the same strand. Thus sequence specificity is mediated by twelve (eight) H-bonds, originating from the protein recognition modules. Besides a pronounced preference for GC base pairs expressed by their high frequency in the most abundant sequences, serving the need of maximal thermodynamic stability of the double helical substrates, it can also be shown that the stacking of consecutive bases within the recognition site sequences plays a major role in shaping the particular DNA/protein interface. Finally it will be demonstrated that the full set of sequences discussed in this paper can readily be derived by stepwise expanding the vocabulary of three simple tetrameric sequences by inserting single base pairs into the centre of a minimal sequence, thus creating all the published pentameric restriction sites, or by inserting/adding two GC base pairs in a palindromic way, thus creating the known multiplicity of hexameric sites.     

The type IIs restriction endonuclease BspMI is a tetramer that acts concertedly at two copies of an asymmetric DNA sequence.

Type IIs endonucleases recognize asymmetric DNA sequences and cleave both strands at fixed positions downstream of the sequence. Many type IIs enzymes, including BspMI, cleave substrates with two sites more rapidly than those with one site. They usually act sequentially on DNA with two sites, but BspMI converted such a substrate directly to the final products cut at both sites. The BspMI endonuclease was found to be a tetramer, in contrast to the monomeric structures for many type IIs enzymes. No change in subunit association occurred during the BspMI reaction. Plasmids with two BspMI sites were cleaved in cis, in reactions spanning sites in the same DNA, even when the sites were separated by just 38 bp. Plasmids with one BspMI site were cleaved in trans, with the enzyme bridging sites in separate DNA molecules: these slow reactions could be accelerated by adding a second DNA with the recognition sequence. Thus, whereas many type IIs enzymes dimerize before cleaving DNA, a process facilitated by two recognition sites in cis, the BspMI tetramer binds two copies of its recognition sequence before cleaving the DNA in both strands at both sites.     

Reactions of BglI and other type II restriction endonucleases with discontinuous recognition sites

Type II restriction enzymes generally recognize continuous sequences of 4-8 consecutive base pairs on DNA, but some recognize discontinuous sites where the specified sequence is interrupted by a defined length of nonspecific DNA. To date, a mechanism has been established for only one type II endonuclease with a discontinuous site, SfiI at GGCCNNNNNGGCC (where N is any base). In contrast to orthodox enzymes such as EcoRV, dimeric proteins that act at a single site, SfiI is a tetramer that interacts with two sites before cleaving DNA. BglI has a similar recognition sequence (GCCNNNNNGGC) to SfiI but a crystal structure like EcoRV. BglI and several other endonucleases with discontinuous sites were examined to see if they need two sites for their DNA cleavage reactions. The enzymes included some with sites containing lengthy segments of nonspecific DNA, such as XcmI (CCANNNNNNNNNTGG). In all cases, they acted at individual sites. Elongated recognition sites do not necessitate unusual reaction mechanisms. Other experiments on BglI showed that it bound to and cleaved DNA in the same manner as EcoRV, thus further delineating a distinct group of restriction enzymes with similar structures and a common reaction mechanism.     

Restriction endonucleases that bridge and excise two recognition sites from DNA

Most restriction endonucleases bridge two target sites before cleaving DNA: examples include all of the translocating Type I and Type III systems, and many Type II nucleases acting at their sites. A subset of Type II enzymes, the IIB systems, recognise bipartite sequences, like Type I sites, but cut specified phosphodiester bonds near their sites, like Type IIS enzymes. However, they make two double-strand breaks, one either side of the site, to release the recognition sequence on a short DNA fragment; 34 bp long in the case of the archetype, BcgI. It has been suggested that BcgI needs to interact with two recognition sites to cleave DNA but whether this is a general requirement for Type IIB enzymes had yet to be established. Ten Type IIB nucleases were tested against DNA substrates with one or two copies of the requisite sequences. With one exception, they all bridged two sites before cutting the DNA, usually in concerted reactions at both sites. The sites were ideally positioned in cis rather than in trans and were bridged through 3-D space, like Type II enzymes, rather than along the 1-D contour of the DNA, as seen with Type I enzymes. The standard mode of action for the restriction enzymes that excise their recognition sites from DNA thus involves concurrent action at two DNA sites.     

Type IIE and IIF restriction endonucleases interacting with two recognition sites in DNA

Recently, it was revealed that restriction endonucleases widely used in genetic engineering and molecular biology are diverse not only in DNA sequence specificities but also in mechanisms of their interaction with DNA. In the review type IIE and IIF restriction endonucleases which require the simultaneous interaction with two copies of their recognition sequence for effective hydrolysis of DNA are considered. Crystal structures of these enzymes and their complexes with DNA as well as stepwise interaction with DNA, mechanisms of catalysis and enzyme-mediated DNA looping are discussed. A novel type of DNA-protein recognition was found for type IIE endonucleases when two copies of the same DNA sequence specifically interact with two different amino acid sequences and two structural motifs located in one polypeptide chain.     

Two type I restriction enzymes from Salmonella species. Purification and DNA recognition sequences

We have purified the type I restriction enzymes SB and SP from Salmonella typhimurium and S. potsdam, respectively, and determined the DNA sequences that they recognize. These sequences resemble those previously determined for the type I enzymes, EcoB, EcoK and EcoA, in that the specific part of the sequence is divided into two domains by a spacer of non-specific sequence that has a fixed length for each enzyme. Two main differences from the previously determined sequences are seen. Both of the new sequences are degenerate and one of them, SB, has one trinucleotide and one pentanucleotide-specific domain rather than the trinucleotide and tetranucleotide domains seen for all of the other enzymes. The only conserved features of the recognition sequences are the adenosyl residues that are methylated in the modification reaction. For all of the enzymes these are situated ten or 11 base-pairs apart, one on each strand of the DNA. This suggests that the enzymes bind to DNA along one face of the double helix making protein-DNA interaction in two successive major grooves with most of the non-specific spacer sequence in the intervening minor groove.     

II-Q restriction endonucleases--new class of type II enzymes

Unique restriction endonucleases Bpu 10l and Bsil have been isolated from Bacillus pumilas and Bacillus sphaericus, respectively. The recognition sequences and cleavage points of these enzymes have been determinated as 5'-CC1TNAGC-3'/3'-GGANT1CG-5' for Bpu 10l and 5'-C1TCGTG-3'/3'-GAGCA1C-5' for Bsil. Restriction endonucleases Bpu 10l and Bsil represent a new class of enzymes which recognize non-palindromic nucleotide sequences and hydrolize DNA within the recognition sequence. Bpu 10l and Bsil recognition sequences may be regarded as quasipalindromic and the enzymes may be designated as type II-Q restriction endonucleases.     

Real-time observation of DNA looping dynamics of Type IIE restriction enzymes NaeI and NarI

Many restriction enzymes require binding of two copies of a recognition sequence for DNA cleavage, thereby introducing a loop in the DNA. We investigated looping dynamics of Type IIE restriction enzymes NaeI and NarI by tracking the Brownian motion of single tethered DNA molecules. DNA containing two endonuclease recognition sites spaced a few 100 bp apart connect small polystyrene beads to a glass surface. The position of a bead is tracked through video microscopy. Protein-mediated looping and unlooping is then observed as a sudden specific change in Brownian motion of the bead. With this method we are able to directly follow DNA looping kinetics of single protein–DNA complexes to obtain loop stability and loop formation times. We show that, in the absence of divalent cations, NaeI induces DNA loops of specific size. In contrast, under these conditions NarI mainly creates non-specific loops, resulting in effective DNA compaction for higher enzyme concentrations. Addition of Ca²⁺ increases the NaeI-DNA loop lifetime by two orders of magnitude and stimulates specific binding by NarI. Finally, for both enzymes we observe exponentially distributed loop formation times, indicating that looping is dominated by (re)binding the second recognition site.     

Specific DNA recognition by the type II restriction endonuclease MunI: the effect of pH.

To investigate the effect of pH on sequence-specific binding, a thermodynamic characterization of the interaction of the protein MunI with a specific, and a nonspecific, oligonucleotide was performed. MunI is a type II restriction endonuclease which is able to bind specifically, but loses its enzymatic activity in the absence of magnesium ions. Comparison of the specific and nonspecific interactions at 10 and 25 degrees C shows that the latter is accompanied by a small change in enthalpy, and a negligible change in constant pressure heat capacity. On going through the pH range 5.75-9.0 at 25 degrees C, the affinity of specific complex formation is reduced by 20-fold. The interaction is accompanied by the protonation of groups assumed to be on the protein. Based on the simplest model that will fit the data, two distinct protonation events are observed. At low pH, two groups per protein molecule undergo protonation with a pK(a) of 6.0 and 6.9 in the free and bound forms, respectively. At high pH, a further independent protonation occurs involving two groups with pK(a) values of 8.9 and approximately 10.7 in the free and bound forms, respectively. The change in heat capacity ranges from -2.7 to -1.7 kJ mol(-1) K(-1) in going from pH 6.5 to 8.5. This range of variation of change in heat capacity can be accounted for by the effects of protonation of the interacting molecules. The change in heat capacity, calculated from surface area burial using a previously established relationship (1.15 kJ mol(-1) K(-1)), does not correlate well with the experimentally determined values.     

Fidelity of DNA sequence recognition by the SfiI restriction endonuclease is determined by communications between its two DNA-binding sites

The SfiI restriction endonuclease is a tetramer in which two subunits form a dimeric unit that contains one DNA binding cleft and the other two subunits contain a second cleft on the opposite side of the protein. Full activity requires both clefts to be filled with its recognition sequence: SfiI has low activity when bound to one site. The ability of SfiI to cleave non-cognate sites, one base pair different from the true site, was initially tested on substrates that lacked specific sites but which contained either one or multiple non-cognate sites. No cleavage of the DNA with one non-cognate site was detected, while a small fraction of the DNA with multiple sites was nicked. The alternative sequences were, however, cleaved in both strands, albeit at low levels, when the DNA also carried either a recognition site for SfiI or the termini generated by SfiI. Further tests employed a mutant of SfiI, altered at the dimer interface, which was known to be more active than wild-type SfiI when bound to a single site. This mutant similarly failed to cleave DNA with one non-cognate site, but cleaved the substrates with multiple non-cognate sites more readily than did the native enzyme. To cleave additional sites, SfiI thus needs to interact concurrently with either two non-cognate sites or one non-cognate and one cognate site (or the termini thereof), yet this arrangement is still restrained from cleaving the alternative site unless the communication pathway between the two DNA-binding clefts is disrupted.     

A prediction of the amino acids and structures involved in DNA recognition by type I DNA restriction and modification enzymes.

The S subunits of type I DNA restriction/modification enzymes are responsible for recognising the DNA target sequence for the enzyme. They contain two domains of approximately 150 amino acids, each of which is responsible for recognising one half of the bipartite asymmetric target. In the absence of any known tertiary structure for type I enzymes or recognisable DNA recognition motifs in the highly variable amino acid sequences of the S subunits, it has previously not been possible to predict which amino acids are responsible for sequence recognition. Using a combination of sequence alignment and secondary structure prediction methods to analyse the sequences of S subunits, we predict that all of the 51 known target recognition domains (TRDs) have the same tertiary structure. Furthermore, this structure is similar to the structure of the TRD of the C5-cytosine methyltransferase, Hha I, which recognises its DNA target via interactions with two short polypeptide loops and a beta strand. Our results predict the location of these sequence recognition structures within the TRDs of all type I S subunits.