Etiology of retinoic acid-induced cleft palate varies with the embryonic stage

Retinoic acid (RA) has been shown to be teratogenic in many species, and 13-cis-RA is teratogenic in humans. Exposure to RA during embryonic morphogenesis produced a variety of malformations including limb defects and cleft palate. The type and severity of malformation depended on the stage of development exposed. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of RA exposure in vivo on different stages of palate development. These results were compared to effects observed after exposure in organ culture. The vehicle used in RA dosing was also shown to be a major factor in the incidence of RA-induced cleft palate. For the in vivo studies, RA (100 mg/kg) in 10 ml corn oil/kg was given p.o. on gestation day (GD) 10 or 12, and the embryos were examined on GD 14 and 16. Exposure to RA in an oil:DMSO vehicle resulted in much higher incidences of cleft palate than were observed after dosing with RA in oil only. After exposure on GD 10, to RA, small palatal shelves formed which did not make contact and fuse on GD 14. The medial cells did not undergo programmed cell death. Instead, the medial cells differentiated into a stratified, squamous, oral-like epithelium. The RA-exposed medial cells did not incorporate 3H-TdR on GD 14 or 16, but the cells expressed EGF receptors and bound 125I-EGF. In contrast, RA-induced clefting after exposure on GD 12 did not involve growth inhibition. Shelves of normal size formed and made contact, but because of altered medial cell differentiation did not fuse. Medial cells differentiated into a pseudostratified, ciliated, nasal-like epithelium. This response was produced in vivo at exposure levels which produced cleft palate, and after exposure of palatal shelves to RA in vitro from GD 12-15. The medial cells exposed on GD 12 incorporated 3H-TdR on GD 14, expressed EGF receptors, and bound 125I-EGF. The responses to RA which lead to cleft palate differed after exposure on GD 10 or 12, and the pathways of differentiation which the medial cells followed depended on the developmental stage exposed.     

Retinoids and epidermal growth factor alter embryonic mouse palatal epithelial and mesenchymal cell differentiation in organ culture

The mechanism by which retinoids (RA) induce cleft palate is not known. During normal palatogenesis, the medial epithelia of opposing palatal shelves cease DNA synthesis, come into contact, adhere, and undergo programmed cell death (PCD). In organ cultures of day 12 embryonic mouse palatal shelves, epidermal growth factor (EGF) blocks PCD, and DNA synthesis continues. In the present study, the effects of trans-RA, 13-cis-RA, EGF, and combinations of EGF and RA on surface morphology, DNA synthesis, and cellular ultrastructure are determined for CD-1 embryonic mouse palatal shelves cultured on day 12 of gestation. DNA synthesis in the medial cells was sustained and PCD was blocked by EGF, trans-RA, and 13-cis-RA. Exposure to trans-RA, but not to 1-cis-RA, induced the medial epithelia to undergo hyperplasia, and addition of EGF enhanced the effect. In the presence of RA, particularly trans-RA, medial epithelial cells acquired nasal cell characteristics, and EGF enhanced this effect. Expansion of the mesenchymal extracellular spaces was blocked by trans-RA and to a lesser degree by 13-cis-RA. The RA-induced alterations in normal epithelial and mesenchymal cell differentiation may be relevant to the etiology of RA-induced cleft palate in vivo.     

Retinoic acid alters epithelial differentiation during palatogenesis.

Retinoids are teratogenic in humans and animals, producing a syndrome of craniofacial malformations that includes cleft palate. This study investigates the mechanism through which retinoic acid induces cleft palate. Murine palatogenesis after exposure to retinoic acid in utero is compared to normal development and to alterations observed after exposure in organ culture to retinoic acid or epidermal growth factor (EGF). Human embryonic palatal shelves were placed in the organ culture system and the responses to retinoic acid and EGF were compared to those of the murine palatal shelves. Growth factors play a role in normal development and are found in the embryonic palate. In other cell culture systems, retinoids alter the expression of EGF receptors. Our results suggest that in the medial epithelial cells of the palate, retinoic acid sustains the expression of the EGF receptor and the binding of EGF at a time when the expression in control medial cells has declined, and these control cells subsequently undergo programmed cell death. The continued DNA synthesis, proliferation, survival, and shift in phenotype of the medial cells is believed to interfere with the adhesion and fusion of opposing palatal shelves, resulting in cleft palate.     

Expression of the epidermal growth factor receptor in developing fetal mouse palates: an immunohistochemical study

Epidermal growth factor (EGF) stimulates the growth of various tissues and, therefore, EGF receptor expression in fetal tissues may play a key role in organogenesis. We have examined immunohistochemically the ontogeny and localization of the EGF receptor in the fetal mouse palate during in vivo and in vitro palatogenesis using the anti-human EGF receptor rabbit antibody. Immunoreactive products against the EGF receptor were observed in the palatal tissue examined on days 12, 13, and 14 of gestation. On days 12 and 13, the immunoreactive products were predominantly positive on the oral and medial edge epithelia but were minimal on the epithelium of the vertical shelf. The EGF receptor immunoreactivity was less intense in the posterior palate as compared with the midpalatal region. In the fusing palate of day 14 fetuses, the cells forming the midline epithelial seam were continuously positive for EGF-R immunoreactivity. The mesenchyme of palatal shelves also showed regional heterogeneity and temporal sequence in EGF receptor expression. The localization of the EGF receptor in fetal mouse palates cultured in a serumless medium generally simulated that observed in vivo.     

Human embryonic palatal epithelial differentiation is altered by retinoic acid and epidermal growth factor in organ culture

Reports of adverse human pregnancy outcomes including cleft palate have increased as the clinical use of isotretinoin (13-cis-retinoic acid) and other retinoic acid (RA) derivatives have increased, but the mechanisms by which their effects are exerted are not understood. Research in craniofacial development is generally performed in rodents, and mouse palatal shelves exposed in organ cultures to retinoids and epidermal growth factor (EGF) display altered medial epithelial cell morphology blocking normal union of apposing shelves. In the present study, precontacting human palatal shelves were maintained in organ culture for 2, 3, or 6 days and exposed to labeled thymidine (3H-TdR) during the last 16 hr. Retinoids and EGF were included in the media so that each shelf was exposed to one of the following: control, EGF, trans-RA at 10(-5)M, cis-RA at 10(-7) or 10(-9) M, or RA + EGF. After exposure of cultured human embryonic palatal shelves to 13-cis-RA and trans-RA with or without EGF, medial epithelial cells do not degenerate, cell surface morphology shifts toward a nasal type, glycogen deposits decrease, smooth endoplasmic reticulum (SER) increases, and basal lamina appear altered. In shelves exposed to EGF and trans-RA early in their development, DNA synthesis appears to terminate prematurely as compared to shelves cultured in control media, and this effect is accompanied by excessive mesenchymal extracellular space expansion. Exposure of shelves to EGF alone is sufficient to block degeneration and induce hyperplasia of the medial epithelial cells but does not induce other ultrastructural changes seen with both EGF and RA. The observed alterations in medial cell morphology could interfere with adhesion of the palatal shelves and may play a role in retinoid-induced cleft palate in the human embryo.     

Comparisons of the effects of TCDD and hydrocortisone on growth factor expression provide insight into their interaction in the embryonic mouse palate.

Cleft palate (CP) can be induced in embryonic mice by a wide range of compounds, including glucocorticoids and 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD). Hydrocortisone (HC), a glucocorticoid, retards embryonic growth producing small palatal shelves, while TCDD exposure blocks the fusion of normally sized shelves. TCDD induction of CP involves altered differentiation of the medial epithelial cells. Recent studies indicate that growth factors such as EGF, TGF-alpha, TGF-beta 1, and TGF-beta 2 are involved in palatogenesis, regulating proliferation, differentiation, and extracellular matrix production. A synergism has been observed between HC and TCDD in which doses too low to induce CP alone are able to produce greater than 90% incidence when coadministered. In the present study a standard teratology protocol was performed in C57BL/6N mice to examine the synergism at doses lower than those previously published. Data from this study indicate synergistic interactions at doses as low as 3 micrograms TCDD/kg + 1 mg HC/kg. This extreme sensitivity suggests the involvement of a receptor-mediated mechanism possibly resulting in altered regulation of gene expression. Mechanisms of interaction were further studied by comparing growth of the shelves, fate of the medial epithelium, and expression of growth factor mRNAs and peptides. Pregnant mice were dosed on GDs 10-13 with HC (100 mg/kg sc) or with HC (25 mg/kg sc) + TCDD (3 micrograms/kg orally), doses producing 30% and 99% CP, respectively. The interaction between HC and TCDD results in a small HC-like palate, rather than the morphology typical of TCDD-induced clefting. Both compounds inhibited programmed cell death of the medial epithelium, which instead differentiated into an oral-like epithelium. The alterations in growth factor expression after HC or HC + TCDD were similar. Expression of EGF, TGF-beta 1, TGF-beta 2, and EGF receptor increased in specific palatal regions. Increased levels of mRNA were observed only for TGF-beta 1. The effect of TCDD alone on growth factor expression differ from those seen with HC or HC + TCDD. These divergent effects on growth factor expression may contribute to the differences in shelf size and thus to the different mechanisms of HC and TCDD clefting. Thus the synergism between HC and TCDD may involve similar and potentially additive effects on regulators of proliferation and differentiation in the palate, but additional contributing factors cannot be excluded.     

Processes involved in retinoic acid production of small embryonic palatal shelves and limb defects

All-trans-retinoic acid (RA) is teratogenic to the embryonic mouse, producing malformations in many developing systems, including the limb bud and palate. High incidences of limb defects and cleft palate are induced at doses which are not maternally toxic and do not increase resorptions. Exposure to RA on gestational day (GD) 10 results in small palatal shelves, which fail to make contact on GD 14. The formation of small shelves could be a consequence of increased cell death, reduced proliferation, a combination of these effects, or some other effect such as inhibition of extracellular matrix production. After exposure to 100 mg RA/kg on GD 10, proliferation in mesenchymal cells of the palatal shelves was not reduced from GD 12 to GD 14 and the levels of cell death in control and treated shelves did not differ when observed by light and electron microscopy. The present study examines the effects of RA on cell death and proliferation from GDs 10-12 and compares the effects in palatal shelves and limb buds. Embryonic mice were exposed to RA suspended in corn oil (100 mg/kg on GD 10), a dose that was teratogenic but not maternally toxic or embryolethal. Embryos were collected at 4, 12, 24, 36, or 48 hr postexposure, and tissues which form the palate or limb were dissected from the embryos, stained by a modified Feulgen procedure, and whole mounted on slides. Mitotic index (MI) and percentage dead cells were determined for mesenchymal cells of the first visceral arch, maxillary process, or palatal shelf (depending on stage of development) and forelimb buds. In the palatal tissues from GD 10 to GD 12, RA did not significantly alter MI and percentage dead cells was significantly increased only at 4 hr postexposure. Some whole embryos were prepared for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). At 48 hr (GD 12) a reduction in the size of the shelves was not apparent on SEM. In the limb buds, RA did not increase percentage dead cells, but MI was significantly decreased. A decreasing rate of proliferation was detected in control facial tissues as development progressed, and this agrees with findings in rat and chick. Thus it appears that mesenchymal cell death and reduced proliferation are not responsible for the small palatal shelves seen on GD 14. RA did not increase cell death but inhibited proliferation in the limb bud, and this effect may contribute to the retarded development and malformations occurring in the limb.     

Bulging medial edge epithelial cells and palatal fusion

The surface of the medial edge epithelium of embryonic day 12, 13 and 14 mouse palatal shelves was observed utilising Environmental Scanning Electron Microscopy (ESEM). This technique offers the advantage of visualisation of biological samples after short fixation times in their natural hydrated state. Bulging epithelial cells were observed consistently on the medial edge epithelium prior to palatal shelf fusion. Additionally, we have used ESEM to compare the morphology and surface features of palatal shelves from embryonic day 13 to 16 mouse embryos that are homozygous null (TGF-beta3 -/-), heterozygous (TGF-beta3 +/-) or homozygous normal (TGF-beta3 +/+) for transforming growth factor beta-3 (TGF-beta3). At embryonic day 15 and 16 most TGF-beta3 +/- and +/+ embryos showed total palatal fusion, whilst all TGF-beta3 null mutants had cleft palate: the middle third of the palatal shelves had adhered, leaving an anterior and posterior cleft. From embryonic day 14 to 16 abundant cells were observed bulging on the medial edge epithelial surface of palates from the TGF-beta3 +/- and +/+ embryos. However, they were never seen in the TGF-beta3 null embryos, suggesting that these surface bulges might be important in palatal fusion and that their normal differentiation is induced by TGF-beta3. The expression pattern of E-Cadherin, beta-catenin, chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan, beta-Actin and vinculin as assayed by immunocytochemistry in these cells shows specific variations that suggest their importance in palatal shelf adhesion.     

TGF-beta3-induced palatogenesis requires matrix metalloproteinases

Cleft lip and palate syndromes are among the most common congenital malformations in humans. Mammalian palatogenesis is a complex process involving highly regulated interactions between epithelial and mesenchymal cells of the palate to permit correct positioning of the palatal shelves, the remodeling of the extracellular matrix (ECM), and subsequent fusion of the palatal shelves. Here we show that several matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), including a cell membrane-associated MMP (MT1-MMP) and tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase-2 (TIMP-2) were highly expressed by the medial edge epithelium (MEE). MMP-13 was expressed both in MEE and in adjacent mesenchyme, whereas gelatinase A (MMP-2) was expressed by mesenchymal cells neighboring the MEE. Transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta3-deficient mice, which suffer from clefting of the secondary palate, showed complete absence of TIMP-2 in the midline and expressed significantly lower levels of MMP-13 and slightly reduced levels of MMP-2. In concordance with these findings, MMP-13 expression was strongly induced by TGF-beta3 in palatal fibroblasts. Finally, palatal shelves from prefusion wild-type mouse embryos cultured in the presence of a synthetic inhibitor of MMPs or excess of TIMP-2 failed to fuse and MEE cells did not transdifferentiate, phenocopying the defect of the TGF-beta3-deficient mice. Our observations indicate for the first time that the proteolytic degradation of the ECM by MMPs is a necessary step for palatal fusion.     

Temporal and Spatial Expression of Hoxa-2 During Murine Palatogenesis

1. Mice homozygous for a targeted mutation of the Hoxa-2 gene are born with a bilateral cleft of the secondary palate associated with multiple head and cranial anomalies and these animals die within 24 hr of birth (Gendron-Maguire et al., 1993; Rijli et al., 1993; Mallo and Gridley, 1996). We have determined the spatial and temporal expression of the Hoxa-2 homeobox protein in the developing mouse palate at embryonic stages E12, E13, E13.5, E14, E14.5, and E15.2. Hoxa-2 is expressed in the mesenchyme and epithelial cells of the palate at E12, but is progressively restricted to the tips of the growing palatal shelves at E13.3. By the E13.5 stage of development, Hoxa-2 protein was found to be expressed throughout the palatal shelf. These observations correlate with palatal shelf orientation and Hoxa-2 protein may play a direct or indirect role in guiding the palatal shelves vertically along side the tongue, starting with the tips of the palatal shelves at E13, followed by the entire palatal shelf at E13.5.4. As development progresses to E14, the stage at which shelf elevation occurs, Hoxa-2 protein is downregulated in the palatal mesenchyme but remains in the medial edge epithelium. Expression of Hoxa-2 continues in the medial edge epithelium until the fusion of opposing palatal shelves.5. By the E15 stage of development, Hoxa-2 is downregulated in the palate and expression is localized in the nasal and oral epithelia.6. In an animal model of phenytoin-induced cleft palate, we report that Hoxa-2 mRNA and protein expression were significantly decreased, implicating a possible functional role of the Hoxa-2 gene in the development of phenytoin-induced cleft palate.7. A recent report by Barrow and Capecchi (1999), has illustrated the importance of tongue posture during palatal shelf closure in Hoxa-2 mutant mice. This along with our new findings of the expression of the Hoxa-2 protein during palatogenesis has shed some light on the putative role of this gene in palate development.     

TGF-beta(3)-induced chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan mediates palatal shelf adhesion

In mammals, the adhesion and fusion of the palatal shelves are essential mechanisms in the development of the secondary palate. Failure of any of these processes leads to the formation of cleft palate. The mechanisms underlying palatal shelf adhesion are poorly understood, although the presence of filopodia on the apical surfaces of the superficial medial edge epithelial (MEE) cells seems to play an important role in the adhesion of the opposing MEE. We demonstrate here the appearance of chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan (CSPG) on the apical surface of MEE cells only immediately prior to contact between the palatal shelves. This apical CSPG has a functional role in palatal shelf adhesion, as either the alteration of CSPG synthesis by beta-D-Xyloside or its specific digestion by chondroitinase AC strikingly alters the in vitro adhesion of palatal shelves. We also demonstrate the absence of this apical CSPG in the clefted palates of transforming growth factor beta 3 (TGF-beta(3)) null mutant mice, and its induction, together with palatal shelf adhesion, when TGF-beta(3) is added to TGF-beta(3) null mutant palatal shelves in culture. When chick palatal shelves (that do not adherein vivo nor express TGF-beta(3), nor CSPG in the MEE) are cultured in vitro, they do not express CSPG and partially adhere, but when TGF-beta(3) is added to the media, they express CSPG and their adhesion increases strikingly. We therefore conclude that the expression of CSPG on the apical surface of MEE cells is a key factor in palatal shelf adhesion and that this expression is regulated by TGF-beta(3).     

Retinoic acid alters EGF receptor expression during palatogenesis

Various growth factors are necessary for normal embryonic development and EGF receptors are present in developing palatal shelves of embryonic/fetal mice at least from day 12 of gestation. The medial epithelium of the palatal shelf undergoes a series of developmental events which do not occur in the oral and nasal epithelia. In utero and in organ culture, the control palatal medial epithelium shows a developmental decline in EGF receptors, demonstrated both by a decrease in the binding of antibody to EGF receptors and a decrease in the binding of 125I-EGF; decreases which are not observed in cells of the adjacent oral or nasal epithelium. During this period, medial cells cease DNA synthesis and undergo programmed cell death. Medial epithelial cells exposed to all-trans-retinoic acid continue to express EGF receptors, bind EGF, proliferate, fail to undergo programmed cell death and exhibit a morphology typical of nasal cells. The data suggest that this disturbance by retinoic acid of EGF receptor localization and subsequent alterations in differentiation of the epithelial cells plays a role in the retinoic-acid-mediated induction of cleft palate.     

Pathogenesis of cleft palate in TGF-beta3 knockout mice.

We previously reported that mutation of the transforming growth factor-beta3 (TGF-beta3) gene caused cleft palate in homozygous null (-/-) mice. TGF-beta3 is normally expressed in the medial edge epithelial (MEE) cells of the palatal shelf. In the present study, we investigated the mechanisms by which TGF-beta3 deletions caused cleft palate in 129 x CF-1 mice. For organ culture, palatal shelves were dissected from embryonic day 13.5 (E13.5) mouse embryos. Palatal shelves were placed singly or in pairs on Millipore filters and cultured in DMEM/F12 medium. Shelves were placed in homologous (+/+ vs +/+, -/- vs -/-, +/- vs +/-) or heterologous (+/+ vs -/-, +/- vs -/-, +/+ vs +/-) paired combinations and examined by macroscopy and histology. Pairs of -/- and -/- shelves failed to fuse over 72 hours of culture whereas pairs of +/+ (wild-type) and +/+ or +/- (heterozygote) and +/-, as well as +/+ and -/- shelves, fused within the first 48 hour period. Histological examination of the fused +/+ and +/+ shelves showed complete disappearance of the midline epithelial seam whereas -/- and +/+ shelves still had some seam remnants. In order to investigate the ability of TGF-beta family members to rescue the fusion between -/- and -/- palatal shelves in vitro, either recombinant human (rh) TGF-beta1, porcine (p) TGF-beta2, rh TGF-beta3, rh activin, or p inhibin was added to the medium in different concentrations at specific times and for various periods during the culture. In untreated organ culture -/- palate pairs completely failed to fuse, treatment with TGF-beta3 induced complete palatal fusion, TGF-beta1 or TGF-beta2 near normal fusion, but activin and inhibin had no effect. We investigated ultrastructural features of the surface of the MEE cells using SEM to compare TGF-beta3-null embryos (E 12. 5-E 16.5) with +/+ and +/- embryos in vivo and in vitro. Up to E13.5 and after E15.5, structures resembling short rods were observed in both +/+ and -/- embryos. Just before fusion, at E14.5, a lot of filopodia-like structures appeared on the surface of the MEE cells in +/+ embryos, however, none were observed in -/- embryos, either in vivo or in vitro. With TEM these filopodia are coated with material resembling proteoglycan. Interestingly, addition of TGF-beta3 to the culture medium which caused fusion between the -/- palatal shelves also induced the appearance of these filopodia on their MEE surfaces. TGF-beta1 and TGF-beta2 also induced filopodia on the -/- MEE but to a lesser extent than TGF-beta3 and additionally induced lamellipodia on their cell surfaces. These results suggest that TGF-beta3 may regulate palatal fusion by inducing filopodia on the outer cell membrane of the palatal medial edge epithelia prior to shelf contact. Exogenous recombinant TGF-beta3 can rescue fusion in -/- palatal shelves by inducing such filopodia, illustrating that the effects of TGF-beta3 are transduced by cell surface receptors which raises interesting potential therapeutic strategies to prevent and treat embryonic cleft palate.     

Rescue of an in vitro palate nonfusion model using interposed embryonic mesenchyme

The authors previously established an in vitro palate nonfusion model on the basis of a spatial separation between prefusion embryonic day 13.5 mouse palates (term gestation, 19.5 days). They found that an interpalatal separation distance of 0.48 mm or greater would consistently result in nonfusion after 4 days in organ culture. In the present study, they interposed embryonic palatal mesenchymal tissue between embryonic day 13.5 mouse palatal shelves with interpalatal separation distances greater than 0.48 mm in an attempt to "rescue" this in vitro palate nonfusion phenotype. Because no medial epithelial bilayer (i.e., medial epithelial seam) could potentially form, palatal fusion in vitro was defined as intershelf mesenchymal continuity with resolution of the medial edge epithelia bilaterally. Forty-two (n = 42) palatal shelf pairs from embryonic day 13.5 CD-1 mouse embryos were isolated and placed on cell culture inserts at precisely graded distances (0, 0.67, and 0.95 mm). Positive controls consisted of shelves placed in contact (n = 6). Negative controls consisted of shelves placed at interpalatal separation distances of 0.67 mm (n = 6) and 0.95 mm (n = 7) with no interposed mesenchyme. Experimental groups consisted of embryonic day 13.5 palatal shelves separated by 0.67 mm (n = 11) and 0.95 mm (n = 12) with interposed lateral palatal mesenchyme isolated at the time of palatal shelf harvest. Specimens were cultured for 4 days (n = 19) or 10 days (n = 23), harvested, and evaluated histologically. All positive controls at 4 and 10 days in culture showed complete histologic palatal fusion. All negative controls at 4 days and 10 days in culture remained unfused. Five of six palatal shelves separated at 0.67 mm interpalatal separation distance with interposed mesenchyme were fused at 4 days, and all five were fused at 10 days. At an interpalatal separation distance of 0.95 mm with interposed mesenchyme (n = 12), no palates (zero of four) were fused at 4 days, but seven of eight were fused at 10 days. These data suggest that nonfused palatal shelves can be "rescued" with an interposed graft of endogenous embryonic mesenchyme to induce fusion in vitro.     

TCDD exposure of human embryonic palatal shelves in organ culture alters the differentiation of medial epithelial cells

The highly toxic, polychlorinated aromatic compound 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) occurs as a contaminant throughout the environment. Epidemiology studies of populations accidentally exposed to TCDD have failed to identify TCDD as a human teratogen, but these studies are limited by the small numbers of exposed pregnancies and imprecise estimates of exposure. TCDD is highly teratogenic in mice, inducing cleft palate and hydronephrosis. TCDD exposure in vivo of embryonic mice alters the differentiation and expression of growth factors in the medial epithelial palatal cells. These alterations also occur in rat and mouse palates exposed to TCDD in organ culture. In the present study, human embryonic palatal shelves were cultured in the rodent organ culture system. In order to achieve in vitro the developmental stage at which fusion would normally occur, GD 52 shelves were cultured for 4 days, GD 53 shelves were cultured for 3 days, and GD 54 shelves were cultured for 3 days. Three of four palatal shelves exposed to 5 x 10(-11) M TCDD were identical to their homologous controls (right shelf cultured with control medium; left shelf cultured with TCDD-containing medium). TCDD at 1 x 10(-7) M produced cytotoxicity detected by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Exposure to 1 x 10(-8) M TCDD resulted in continued incorporation of thymidine ([3H]-TdR detected autoradiographically) by palatal medial cells, failure of the medial peridermal cells to degenerate as observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and differentiation into a stratified, squamous epithelium. These alterations are identical to those induced by TCDD in vitro in rat and mouse palatal cells. The main difference between these species is the level of TCDD required to elicit the responses. Cultured mouse palates respond to 5 x 10(-11) M TCDD with altered medial cell differentiation, and 1 x 10(-10) M TCDD is cytotoxic. The rat shelves respond with altered differentiation at 1 x 10(-8) M and cytotoxicity at 1 x 10(-7) M. All the human shelves respond at 1 x 10(-8) M TCDD with altered differentiation, 1 out of 4 responded at 5 x 10(-11) M, and cytotoxicity occurred at 1 x 10(-7) M. The present data suggest human embryonic palates are less sensitive than those of the C57BL/6N mouse, and that exposure to high levels of TCDD would be required to elicit altered differentiation in the palatal shelf.     

Differential expression of TGF beta isoforms in murine palatogenesis

We have studied the expression of genes encoding transforming growth factors (TGFs) beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 during development of the secondary palate in the mouse from 11.5 to 15.5 days postcoitum using in situ hybridisation. The RNA detected at the earliest developmental stage is TGF beta 3, which is localised in the epithelial component of the vertical palatal shelf. This expression continues in the horizontal palatal shelf, predominantly in the medial edge epithelium, and is lost as the epithelial seam disrupts, soon after palatal shelf fusion. TGF beta 1 RNA is expressed with the same epithelial pattern as TGF beta 3, but is not detectable until the horizontal palatal shelf stage. TGF beta 2 RNA is localised to the palatal mesenchyme underlying the medial edge epithelia in the horizontal shelves and in the early postfusion palate. The temporal and spatial distribution of TGF beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 RNAs in the developing palate, together with a knowledge of in vitro TGF beta biological activities, suggests an important role for TGF beta isoforms in this developmental process.     

Immunodetection of the transforming growth factors beta 1 and beta 2 in the developing murine palate.

The expression of some members of the TGF beta family of genes in embryonic craniofacial tissue suggests a functional role for these molecules in orofacial development. In other systems, TGF beta 1 and TGF beta 2 have been shown to regulate cell proliferation and extracellular matrix metabolism, processes critical to normal development of the secondary palate. We have thus determined the amount and tissue distribution of both TGF beta 1 and TGF beta 2 in embryonic palatal tissue. Cellular extracts of murine embryonic palatal tissue from days 12, 13 and 14 of gestation were assayed for the presence of TGF beta 1 and TGF beta 2 by immunoprecipitation. Physiological levels, ranging from 0.05-20 ng/micrograms protein, of both growth factors were detected in all tissues examined. Immunostaining with antibodies directed against either TGF beta 1 or TGF beta 2 demonstrated the presence of these growth factors in palatal epithelium and mesenchyme early during palatal development (gestational day [GD] 12) a period characterized by tissue growth. On GDs 13 and 14, characterized by palate epithelial differentiation, immunostaining for both growth factors predominated in epithelial tissue. Immunostaining for TGF beta 1 and TGF beta 2 was also intense in mesenchyme surrounding tooth germs and in perichondrium. Chondrocytes and cartilage extracellular matrix did not stain for either TGF beta 1 or beta 2. Combined with existing evidence for the presence of functional receptors for the transforming growth factor-beta s in the developing palate, these results provide rationale for studies designed to clarify a specific role for these signalling molecules in palate epithelial differentiation and/or epithelial-mesenchymal interactions.     

Midline fusion in the formation of the secondary palate anticipated by upregulation of keratin K5/6 and localized expression of vimentin mRNA in medial edge epithelium.

Secondary palatal fusion is dependent on targeted removal of the epithelium between the palatal shelves. Aseptically delivered rat embryos 15 through 18 days post coitum (dpc) were probed with DIG-labeled antisense and sense ssDNA probes for spliced exon sequences flanking intron E of cytokeratins K5/6 and spliced exon sequences flanking intron F of vimentin. Cytokeratin K5/6 expression was upregulated in the medial edge epithelium (MEE) prior to rotation of the palatal shelves and in the vomerine epithelium in the region of fusion with the palate. K5/6 expression continued in the medial epithelial seam (MES) and in epithelial islands during breakdown of the MES. Vimentin expression was not detected in the MEE prior to rotation but was specifically upregulated in the MEE following rotation and prior to midline contact and continued in the MES and in epithelial cells identifiable during the breakdown of the MES. Initiation of vimentin upregulation in the MEE prior to contact of the palatal shelves was tested by serum-free organ culture of palates from embryos at 15.5 dpc with the shelves separated by a biocompatible membrane. Vimentin upregulation occurred in the epithelium specifically in the region of anticipated contact. These results are interpreted as indicating that i) cytokeratin K5/6 expression may play a critical role in the integration of the epithelial layers of the MES to ensure subsequent merging of the mesenchyme and ii) epithelial cells in the MEE are specifically 'primed' to upregulate expression of mesenchymal genes prior to integration into and breakdown of the MES.     

Role of ERK1/2 signaling during EGF-induced inhibition of palatal fusion

During mammalian palatal fusion, the medial edge epithelial (MEE) cells must stop DNA synthesis prior to the initial contact of opposing palatal shelves and thereafter selectively disappear from the midline. Exogenous EGF has been shown to inhibit the cessation of DNA synthesis and induce cleft palate; however, the precise intracellular mechanism has not been determined. We hypothesized that EGF signaling acting via ERK1/2 would maintain MEE DNA synthesis and cell proliferation and consequently inhibit the process of palatal fusion. Palatal shelves from E13 mouse embryos were maintained in organ cultures and stimulated with EGF. EGF-treated palates failed to fuse with intact MEE and had significant ERK1/2 phosphorylation. Both EGF-induced ERK1/2 phosphorylation and BrdU-incorporation were localized in the nucleus of MEE cells. Subsequent inhibition assays using U0126, a specific inhibitor of ERK1/2 phosphorylation, were conducted. U0126 inhibited EGF-induced ERK1/2 phosphorylation in a dose-dependent manner and consequently MEE cells stopped proliferation. The threshold of ERK1/2 inactivation to stop MEE DNA synthesis coincides with the level required to rescue the EGF-induced cleft palate phenotype. These results indicate that EGF-induced inhibition of palatal fusion is dependent on nuclear ERK1/2 activation and that this mechanism must be tightly regulated during normal palatal fusion.