Feulgen Reaction for Thymonucleic Acid

The importance of thymonucleic acid in tissues is discussed briefly. The technic of the Feulgen reaction which has been employed in photometric histochemical observations in tumors is described. The evidence for the specificity of the Feulgen reaction is reviewed and additional experimental observations are reported. The staining of tissues by the Feulgen reaction is compared with that of hematoxylin, basic fuchsia, and fuchsin-sulfurous-acid reagent in which the color had been developed by the addition of formaldehyde. The stains were compared with respect to (1) the selective staining of the cytologic components of the tissues, (2) the staining of tissues following varying intervals of acid hydrolysis and (3) the photometric determination of the fading of the stained tissue by a carbon arc light. The photometric apparatus employed is suitable for the study of many problems on the staining of tissues. Staining by the Feulgen reaction is different from that of both the basic fuchsin from which the fuchsin-sulfurous-acid was prepared and from that of the product of the fuchsin-sulfurous-acid which had reacted with an aldehyde. Under carefully controlled conditions, the Feulgen technic is a relatively specific histochemical reaction for thymonucleic acid.     

Basic Fuchsin as A Nuclear Stain

Five distinct nuclear stains and staining procedures which utilize basic fuchsin as the dye have been studied, compared and tested on a Feulgen-weak fungus, Blastomyces dermatitidis, and other fungi.

Aqueous basic fuchsin has been shown to be an excellent, though impermanent, stain with which to study the nuclei of this and other fungi. The conditions under which formaldehyde acts as a mordant for basic fuchsin and produces a permanent nuclear stain have been established.

Comparison of crystal violet and basic fuchsin suggests that the mordanting action of the aldehyde operates through the para-amino groups of the dye. Certain other basic dyes were not mordanted by formaldehyde.

Gentle acid hydrolysis of the tissues has been found to be essential both to the specificity of the dye as a nuclear stain and to the mordanting effect of the aldehyde.

The possible relationship of these observations to the Feulgen reaction is discussed. A protocol for the method developed is presented.     

Double Staining for Comparative Measurements in Squash Preparations

Comparative measurements of nuclei or chromosomes following different treatments are seldom made on squash preparations, since variations which arise during preparation of the slides may easily mask genuine treatment differences. This drawback may be overcome by making use of dyes which, when substituted for basic fuchsin in Schiff's reagent, will give a Feulgen-type reaction with chromatin. By selecting dyes of contrasting colours, it is possible to intermingle cells from different treatments in the same squash preparation, and to perform comparative measurements on adjacent cells.

Suitable dyes which contrast well with basic fuchsin are toluidine blue, or azure A (which stain chromatin blue) and chrysoidin yellow (which stains chromatin yellow). These dyes are made up and used in the same manner as ordinary Feulgen reagent.

Samples of cells from the two treatments to be compared are fixed, washed and hydrolysed in 1 N HCl at 60 C. One sample is stained in regular Feulgen reagent, the other in the contrast dye, then both are macerated and thoroughly mixed on the same slide in a single drop of 45% acetic acid. A coverslip is added, and the preparation flattened to the required amount and made permanent after dry-ice removal of the cover. This technique may also be utilised for comparative grain counts in autoradiography, provided that the contrast dye does not cause chemical fogging of the film.     

Peculiarities of cytochemical properties of cancer cells as revealed by study of deoxyribonucleoprotein susceptibility to Feulgen hydrolysis.

Chromatin of human squamous carcinoma cells reacts more intensively to short (1-2 min) acid hydrolysis in the Feulgen reaction and is, after such treatment, more intensively stained by Schiff reagent than chromatin of normal cells of the same origin. To reveal this difference in chromatin properties the use of a fluorescence variant of the Feulgen reaction is necessary because nuclei-binding of Schiff reagent after such short hydrolysis is so weak that the amount of the stain bound by means of absorption technique is hardly possible. The use of increased sensitivity of cancer cells chromatin to acid hydrolysis for cancer cytodiagnosis is suggested, especially for the diagnosis of so called diploid cancers for which detection on the basis of deoxyribonucleic acid content determination is impossible.     

Improved Histology for the Chick-Quail Chimera

A simple modification of nuclear staining after acid hydrolysis has been made which provides easy identification of quail nuclear markings in a chick-quail chimera. This method also improves the histologic detail normally seen with hematoxylin and eosin when compared to the more commonly used Feulgen reaction. Embryonic tissues can be fixed in Zenker's or Helly's solution and the sections obtained are hydrolyzed in acid (3.5 N HCl at 37 C for 40-50 min). After acid hydrolysis the sections are stained with hematoxylin and eosin rather than Schiff reagent and fast green. The interphase nuclei of chick cells show homogeneous or mottled purplish blue staining, while quail nuclei contain a dark blue spot. This staining corresponds to the reddish purple staining of the quail's heterochromatin seen adjacent to the nucleolus in the standard Feulgen stain. This new technique facilitates identification of quail cell types in the chick host and provides superior histology of the chick tissues by demonstrating cytoplasmic detail.     

Standardization of the Feulgen reaction: the influence of chromatin condensation on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis.

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the influence of chromatin compactness on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis in the Feulgen reaction in cytology. Tissue imprints of rabbit liver, of human bronchial carcinoma and of human blood smears, fixed with alcohol, formaldehyde or with B?hm's solution with and without prior air drying, were stained with a standardized pararosanilin-Feulgen reagent. The time for hydrolysis varied between 7.5 and 120 min. The integrated optical density (IOD) of the cell nuclei was measured with an image analyzer (IBAS 2000). Cells with condensed chromatin (lymphocytes, small cell carcinoma, formaldehyde fixed cells) showed a slow increase of staining intensity and late plateau phase as compared with cells with decondensed chromatin. DNA in condensed nuclei was less susceptible to acid hydrolysis. The degree of chromatin compactness which determines the sensitivity of DNA to hydrolysis is influenced by the type of fixation, cell type and by the functional status of the cell. The conclusion is that Feulgen staining intensities of cells with different degrees of chromatin compactness cannot be compared unless measured in the respective plateau phases of the relevant hydrolysis curves which must be determined individually for each cell type.     

A Combined Stain for Identifying Epithelial Cells of the Gastric Mucosa

New techniques are proposed for differentiating each type of gastric epithelial cell in the same tissue section. The techniques combine the following stains: A) paradoxical concanavalin A staining (PCS) to identify mucous neck cells, B) periodic acid Schiff-concana-valin A staining to distinguish mucous neck cells from surface mucous cells, and C) a modified Bowie's stain to demonstrate zymogen granules of chief cells. Feulgen hydrolysis preceding the Bowie stain was found to remove most of the nonspecific coloration encountered with the original Bowie method. The results obtained by the new sequences were as follows: 1) Feulgen hydroIysis-PCS-Bowie staining: mucous neck cells stained brown and chief cell zymogen granules deep blue. The other mucin-secreting cells remained unstained; 2) Feulgen hydrolysis-PAS-concanavalin A-Bowic staining: mucous neck cells stained brown, zymogen granules stained deep blue to purplish blue and surface mucous cells stained purplish red.     

A combined stain for identifying epithelial cells of the gastric mucosa

New techniques are proposed for differentiating each type of gastric epithelial cell in the same tissue section. The techniques combine the following stains: paradoxical concanavalin A staining (PCS) to identify mucous neck cells, periodic acid Schiff-concanavalin A staining to distinguish mucous neck cells from surface mucous cells, and a modified Bowie's stain to demonstrate zymogen granules of chief cells. Feulgen hydrolysis preceding the Bowie stain was found to remove most of the nonspecific coloration encountered with the original Bowie method. The results obtained by the new sequences were as follows: Feulgen hydrolysis-PCS-Bowie staining: mucous neck cells stained brown and chief cell zymogen granules deep blue. The other mucin-secreting cells remained unstained; Feulgen hydrolysis-PAS-concanavalin A-Bowie staining: mucous neck cells stained brown, zymogen granules stained deep blue to purplish blue and surface mucous cells stained purplish red.     

Standardization of the Feulgen-Schiff technique. Staining characteristics of pure fuchsin dyes; a cytophotometric investigation

Four fuchsin analogues (Pararosaniline, Rosaniline. Magenta II and New Fuchsin) usually found in Basic Fuchsin have been applied as chemically pure dyes to the Feulgen-technique. Total nuclear absorption and wavelength of the absorption maximum were measured by microspectrophotometry in Feulgen stained cytological and plastic embedded histological liver samples, and in lymphocyte nuclei in human peripheral blood smears; absorption spectra of Feulgen stained DNA-polyacrylamide films were determined by spectrophotometry. The grey value distribution of tetraploid liver cell nuclei was calculated with an image analyzer. The staining characteristics of the pure dyes were compared to commercial fuchsin samples from various suppliers. Reverse phase thin layer chromatography was used for characterization and qualitative separation of commercial batches. Pure fuchsin analogues were all equally suitable for Feulgen staining: with respect of staining intensity all pure fuchsin dyes gave nearly identical results with a bathochromic shift of the absorption maximum from Pararosaniline to New Fuchsin of about 8 microns. Differences in staining results observed among the commercial dyes were due to varying dye content, contamination with an acridine-like fluorescent compound or simply mislabelling of samples. Pure Pararosaniline is recommended for a standard Feulgen technique.     

Staining Chromosomes in Sections of Germinal Vesicles of Sarcoptid Mites by a Schiff Reagent

Chromosomes of oocytes, especially early prophase I stages, of Acaridae and Anoetidae species are difficult to stain by procedures using hematoxylin, Feulgen and aceto-orcein. Hematoxylin stains are intensely polychromatic in oocytes; the standard Feulgen procedure is negative with chromosomes during diffuse prophase stages. Satisfactory staining can be obtained with a supersensitive Schiff reagent (Tobie, W. C., Ind. Eng. Chem., Anal. Ed., 14: 405—406, 1942) made by reducing basic fuchsin with gaseous SO₂. Routinely prepared paraffin sections of mites fixed in Carnoy's 6:3:1 mixture were hydrolysed 5-8 min in 1 N HCl, washed well, and stained in this reagent: 1-2 hr for prophase oocytes, 10-20 min for condensed chromosomes. A second staining in a 0.5% aqueous solution of toluidine blue 0, adjusted to pH 5.3-5.5 with a citrate buffer, served to darken the original Feulgen stain. Counterstaining with 0.1-0.2% fast green FCF in the last fluid of the dehydrating series enhanced contrast between chromosomes and cytoplasm. This staining technic is also suitable for preparing whole mounts of mites.     

Differentiation of Nucleic Acids by Staining at Controlled pH and by A Schiff-Methylene Blue Sequence

Fixation with Bouin's fluid preserves cytoplasmic and nucleolar ribonucleic acid (UNA) particularly well. RNA may be demonstrated preferentially in Bouin fixed tissue by staining with 0.02% thiazine dye in aqueous McIIvaine phosphate-citrate buffer between pH 3 and 4. Methylation blockage of basophilia other than that of nucleic acids permits staining of RNA with thiazine dyes near neutrality. The deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) of chromatin undergoes a Feulgen type hydrolysis in the tissue block during 24 hr fixation with Bouin's fluid. This hydrolysis by picric acid permits Schiff staining of the DNA wthout further acid hydrolysis. Consequently after Bouin fixation it is possible to demonstrate DNA and RNA specifically by a Schiff-methylene blue sequence. Thus a Schiff stain without further acid hydrolysis followed by 0.02% methylene blue in phosphate-citrate buffer at pH 3.0 to 3.5 colors DNA magenta in contrast to the blue of RNA.     

Standardization of the Feulgen-Schiff technique

Summary Four fuchsin analogues (Pararosaniline, Rosaniline, Magenta II and New Fuchsin) usually found in Basic Fuchsin have been applied as chemically pure dyes to the Feulgen-technique. Total nuclear absorption and wavelength of the absorption maximum were measured by microspectrophotometry in Feulgen stained cytological and plastic embedded histological liver samples, and in lymphocyte nuclei in human peripheral blood smears; absorption spectra of Feulgen stained DNA-polyacrylamide films were determined by spectrophotometry. The grey value distribution of tetraploid liver cell nuclei was calculated with an image analyzer. The staining characteristics of the pure dyes were compared to commercial fuchsin samples from various suppliers. Reverse phase thin layer chromatography was used for characterization and qualitative separation of commercial batches.Pure fuchsin analogues were all equally suitable for Feulgen staining: with respect of staining intensity all pure fuchsin dyes gave nearly identical results with a bathochromic shift of the absorption maximum from Pararosaniline to New Fuchsin of about 8 m.Differences in staining results observed among the commercial dyes were due to varying dye content, contamination with an acridine-like fluorescent compound or simply mislabelling of samples. Pure Pararosaniline is recommended for a standard Feulgen technique.     

Improving the Technic of the Feulgen Stain

A study has been made of the Feulgen stain, in which the staining fluid is a decolorized basic fuchsin. Particular attention has been given to the variation in behavior of different fuchsin samples, the reagent to be employed in decolorizing the dye, the acidity of solutions, and the value of several counter-stains. A modified procedure is suggested, the details of which are given in the paper. The principle modifications of earlier procedures which are recommended are as follows: the use of a specially purified pararosanilin as a dye; the employment of K₂S₂O₅ instead of NaHSO₃ as a decolorizing agent; and counterstaining with fast green in the case of plant tissue or with orange G for animal material.     

Differentiation of bone and soft tissues in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue by using methylene blue/acid fuchsin stain

OBJECTIVE: To find a staining method for formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue that would distinguish bone from surrounding soft tissues, including muscle, periosteal tissue and bone marrow. STUDY DESIGN: A variety of stains were tested and compared with hematoxylin-eosin. The potential value of any given stain was evaluated based on its ability to stain bone and soft tissues different colors or shades that could be readily identified in photomicrographs. Stains were evaluated using both endochondral (tibia) and intramembranous bone (calvaria) samples. RESULTS: In contrast to standard hematoxylin-eosin stain, which stains both bone and soft tissues pink, the methylene blue/acid fuchsin stain demonstrates remarkable contrast between bone and other tissues. Methylene blue/acid fuchsin stained bone bright pink and the surrounding soft tissues blue-purple. CONCLUSION: In addition to the superior staining properties of methylene blue/acid fuchsin, other benefits of this stain include its stability, ease of use and low cost. This stain has many potential applications in the study of erosive bone disease in humans and also in animal models for research.     

A CHROMATOGRAPHIC STUDY OF HYDROLYSIS IN THE FEULGEN NUCLEAL REACTION

In a study on Feulgen hydrolysis of frozen-dried alcohol-fixed lily anthers, a chromatographic technique was developed to analyze the acid hydrolysate for some of the degradation products of nucleic acid. Hydrolysis was accomplished by 10 per cent perchloric acid at 20°C., and a typical hydrolysis time-Feulgen intensity curve was obtained, with maximum staining occurring at 19 hours. Microphotometric measurements indicated that the amount of stain per nucleus was no different from amount in nuclei fixed and hydrolyzed by more conventional procedures. Uracil-containing material (from ribonucleic acid) was almost completely separated from thymine-containing material (deoxyribonucleic acid) of tissue sections by acid treatment for 1½ hours. Adenine (purines), as the base, was effectively all removed from the deoxyribonucleic acid at the time of optimum hydrolysis. Detectable amounts of thymine-containing material appeared in the hydrolysate shortly after the onset of hydrolysis; and the amount increased rapidly with increased hydrolysis time. At the time of optimum hydrolysis approximately two-thirds of the total deoxyribonucleic acid thymine was lost. The removal of these thymine-containing fragments was linear with respect to time during the first 24 hours and occurred at a relatively high rate. Removal after 24 hours was also linear but was at a markedly lower rate. These results would suggest that two kinds of deoxyribonucleic acid exist in lily anthers; an acid-labile fraction amounting to approximately three-fourths of the total, and an acid-resistant fraction making up the remainder. In the Feulgen procedure much of the labile fraction is lost by the time of optimum hydrolysis and is not stained; most of the stable fraction remains in the tissue and is stained. In light of these findings the use of the Feulgen method as a means of determining cytochemically relative amounts of deoxyribonucleic acid in nuclei by measuring their Feulgen dye content was discussed.     

Autoradiographic thymidine-3H activity after successive steps of the Feulgen reaction.

Autoradiographs were prepared of sections of the ovary of Dytiscus marginalis labelled with thymidine-3H after each successive step of the Feulgen reaction and after treatment with each separate component of the Schiff's reagent. Results of grain counts over ovarian nurse cells showed that losses of thymidine-3H activity occur not only during hydrolysis but also during the successive steps of the Feulgen reaction. It is suggested that the latter decrease in radioactivity may depend on the extraction of fragments of apurinic acid from the sections. An emulsion desensitizing effect has also been observed in sections stained with basic fuchsin alone; this effect appears, however, to be strongly counteracted by the metabisulphite present in the Schiff's reagent.     

Some Evidence for the Specificity of the Feulgen Reaction

Carr has attacked the specificity of the Feulgen reaction on three grounds: that the chromosomes are adsorbents capable of regenerating the color of the Schiff reagent; that selectivity for the nucleus depends on destruction of cytoplasm by acid hydrolysis preceding staining; and that the reaction is not blocked by SO₂ water, as he says it should be if staining occurs by a chemical reaction. The first point was tested by staining chromosomes treated with nuclease. They were Feulgen negative, but their protein basis remained intact. The second point was tested by hydrolyzing fixed tissues, washing off solutes, drying, and comparing weight loss with controls. As differences were negligible, the fixed cytoplasm must not have been made soluble by hydrolysis. Carr's third point was not tested experimentally. It is concluded that these objections to specificity of the Feulgen reaction are not valid.     

Simplified Manufacture and Histochemical Use of the Schiff Reagent

Schiff reagents were made by two methods. The first procedure gave a Schiff reagent of pH 1.8-2.4. It was accomplished by passing sulfur dioxide into 0.5% aqueous fuchsin solution at room temperature, stopping at reddish violet, and decolorizing allowed to occur on standing. In another method, 1.5 ml. of 5.6% sulfurous acid was added to 100 ml. 0.5% fuchsin solution and the mixture produced in several hours a colorless Schiff reagent of pH 3. The solution remained unchanged for some weeks when kept stoppered in a refrigerator.

To test these Schiff reagents, histochemical examinations were carried out with Feulgen and McManus reaction in various pH ranges. These experiments showed that the Feulgen reaction was optimum at pH 3, the McManus reaction at pH 2.4.     

Rapid Staining of Nuclei and Chromosomes in Root Tips

Feulgen reagent quickly heated to and maintained at 60 C just before immersion of plant material, basic fuchsin in acid alcohol at room temperature, and pinacyanol at room temperature will stain hydrolyzed root tip nuclei and chromosomes in one minute or less. This technic, coupled with fast fixation, can be utilized when uncertainties exist as to when to begin sampling plant meristem cells for mitoses or when time does not allow for standard fixation and Schiff staining.     

Acid Orcein-Iron and Acid Orcein-Copper Stains for Elastin

Paraffin sections of formol-fixed tissues stained 4-18 hr in 70% alcohol containing 1% orcein and 1% of concentrated (12 N) HCl by volume yield the familiar purple brown elastin and red nuclei on a pink background. When sections so stained are transferred directly from the stain to 70% alcohol containing 0.02% ferric chloride (FeCl₃·6 H₂O) or 0.02% copper sulfate (CuSO₄·5 H₂O) for a 15 sec to 3 min period, elastin coloration is changed to black or reddish black and chromatin staining to reddish black. The procedure can be counterstained with picro-methyl blue to yield blue collagen and reticulum or with our flavianic acid, ferric chloride, acid fuchsin mixture to give deep yellow background and deep red collagen.