Combined staining procedures for cytophotometry of protein and DNA Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S and dinitrofluorobenzene-Feulgen

A comparison has been made between dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) and Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) as protein stains in combination with the pararosaniline-SO2 Feulgen procedure. Chicken erythrocytes were used as test cells. Cytophotometric measurements were made using a Zeiss scanning stage cytophotometer coupled to a PDP 11/10 minicomputer using the BICOSCAN program to obtain values for protein per cell, protein per "nuclear area' and DNA per nucleus. With 5N HCl as the Feulgen hydrolysis agent, DNFB staining, applied before the Feulgen procedure, was found to be unaffected by hydrolysis conditions required to give optimum Feulgen staining and showed only small losses after longer hydrolysis times. On the other hand measurements of NYS staining, of necessity applied after the Feulgen procedure, seem to be susceptible to the duration of Feulgen hydrolysis. This susceptibility is probably due to the interaction of the DNA phosphates with the basic amino acid residues, potential binding sites for NYS. Since the degree of this interaction may be variable, it is argued that NYS binding will measure the available basicity of proteins at the time of staining but no specific protein fraction. DNFB binding is unaffected by DNA-protein interactions and therefore can give a more reliable measure of "nuclear' protein, particularly in conjunction with Feulgen-DNA measurements.     

Combined staining procedures for cytophotometry of protein and DNA Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S and dinitrofluorobenzene-Feulgen

Summary A comparison has been made between dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) and Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) as protein stains in combination with the pararosaniline-SO₂ Feulgen procedure. Chicken erythrocytes were used as test cells. Cytophotometric measurements were made using a Zeiss scanning stage cytophotometer coupled to a PDP 11/10 minicomputer using the BICOSCAN program to obtain values for protein per cell, protein per nuclear area and DNA per nucleus. With 5N HCl as the Feulgen hydrolysis agent, DNFB staining, applied before the Feulgen procedure, was found to be unaffected by hydrolysis conditions required to give optimum Feulgen staining and showed only small losses after longer hydrolysis times. On the other hand measurements of NYS staining, of necessity applied after the Feulgen procedure, seem to be susceptible to the duration of Feulgen hydrolysis. This susceptibility is probably due to the interaction of the DNA phosphates with the basic amino acid residues, potential binding sites for NYS. Since the degree of this interaction may be variable, it is argued that NYS binding will measure the available basicity of proteins at the time of staining but no specific protein fraction. DNFB binding is unaffected by DNA-protein interactions and therefore can give a more reliable measure of nuclear protein, particularly in conjunction with Feulgen-DNA measurements.     

Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S cytophotometry of liver cells. The effect of formaldehyde induced shrinkage on nuclear Naphthol Yellow S binding.

1. In isolated liver cells, fixed in 4 per cent formaldehyde (NFS) for Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S (F-NYS) staining of DNA and protein, nuclear shrinkage increases the nuclear concentration of solids to 46 per cent (w/v) before the start of the NYS staining. 2. When a fixative mixture of methanol:acetic acid:formalin (85:5:10 by volume; MAF) is used, the concentration of nuclear solids during NYS staining remain at a physiological level of 19 per cent. 3. By exposing liver cells to NFS for 10 to 120 seconds before fixation in MAF, increasing nuclear shrinkage can be induced with increasing pretreatment in NFS. Nuclear NYS binding decreases in parallel with the decreasing nuclear volume in cells thus treated. As the shrinkage induced reduction in NYS binding may vary with the net charge of nuclear non-histone proteins, MAF fixation must be preferred for quantitative determinations of nuclear non-histone protein in F-NYS stained, isolated cells. 4. Fixation in MAF offers the same advantages as NFS fixation as regards the small loss of proteins during the Feulgen staining procedure and the excellent reproducibility of the F-NYS staining. Storage of MAF fixed cells in the fixative for a few days does not alter their F-NYS staining properties. 5. In MAF fixed, F-NYS stained cells there is no NYS binding to histone basic amino acid residues.     

Adaptation of the naphthol yellow S staining for objects with high protein content

Summary In measuring isolated rat liver cells stained with Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) at optimal conditions of pH (2.8), the absorbances measured at the absorption peak of 430 nm appeared to be far too high locally to enable accurate cytophotometric measurements. In order to bring down these absorbances, different techniques for flattening the cells, off-peak measurement and NYS staining at non-optimal pH levels have been applied respectively. Using albumin incorporated in polyacrylamide model films, the reliability of off-peak measurements and the quantitative aspects of the modified protein staining procedures have been investigated. It was found that the NYS procedure can be used as a quantitative protein staining not only at pH 2.8, but also at pH 2.0, 3.5 and 4.0 respectively. The problem with regard to the cytophotometric measuring of isolated liver cells could only be solved, however, by combining a specially developed flattening procedure (by centrifuging small drops of suspension) with staining at non-optimal pH levels. In contrast to the model film results, off-peak measurements applied in situ appeared to give rather unreliable results. In cases of a combined Feulgen-NYS staining, the Feulgen-DNA values were not significantly influenced by any of the modifications of the original NYS staining procedure.     

Adaptation of the Naphthol Yellow S staining for objects with high protein content.

In measuring isolated rat liver cells stained with Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) at optimal conditions of pH (2.8), the absorbances measured at the absorption peak of 430 nm appeared to be far too high locally to enable accurate cytophotometric measurements. In order to bring down these absorbances, different techniques for flattening the cells, off-peak measurement and NYS staining at non-optimal pH levels have been applied respectively. Using albumin incorporated in polyacrylamide model films, the reliability of off-peak measurements and the quantitative aspects of the modified protein staining procedures have been investigated. It was found that the NYS procedure can be used as a quantitative protein staining not only at pH 2.8, but also at pH 2.0, 3.5 and 4.0 respectively. The problem with regard to the cytophotometric measuring of isolated liver cells could only be solved, however, by combining a specially developed flattening procedure (by centrifuging small drops of suspension) with staining at non-optimal pH levels. In contrast to the model film results, off-peak measurements applied in situ appeared to give rather unreliable results. In cases of a combined Feulgen-NYS staining, the Fuelgen-DNA values were not significantly influenced by any of the modifications of the original NYS staining procedure.     

Senescence vs. changes in nuclear DNA, protein and dry mass contents in leaf mesophyll of two species differing in occurrence of endomitotic polyploidy

DNA and Naphtol yellow S-staining (F-NYS) protein contents were measured cytophotometrically using the Feulgen method in the nuclei of the mesophyll from the basal and apical zone of young and old leaves in two perennial monocotyledonous species: Rhoeo discolor and Clivia miniata, differing in presence or absence of DNA endoreplication. Dry mass content was determined interferometrically using an uniform field with large image shearing method. It has been shown that nuclei with 2C DNA and below 2C DNA content dominate in old leaves. The decrease in dry mass content of nuclei correlated with the decrease in NYS protein content. Parallelly a significant increase in NYS protein and DNA contents observed in chromocenters Rhoeo discolor was proportional to the increase in their dry mass. The decrease in nuclear DNA content in mesophyll of old leaves in endoreplicating species was the same as in non-edoreplicating one, however the senescence was more intensive in endoreplicating species.     

Feulgen staining of rat liver fixed in different fixatives.

In the present study rat liver pieces fixed in 1) 10 per cent buffered neutral formalin, 2) 4 per cent glutaraldehyde, 3) Heidenhain's-Susa fixative and 4) Flemming's fluid, and following hydrolysis in 1-0 N HC1 at 60degreesC for varying time periods have been stained with the UV Feulgen procedure. The results of this study reveal that following hydrolysis for different time periods the tissue material fixed in formalin show the same staining pattern as those fixed in glutaraldehyde. The material fixed in Heidenhain's-Susa displays an intense Feulgen staining after two different times of hydrolysis, and that fixed in Flemming's fluid shows particular staining intensity for a prolonged time period thus indicating better preservation of DNA than in the materials fixed in the other three fixtatives.     

Combined protein and DNA measurements by the ninhydrin-Schiff and Feulgen techniques

Summary Feulgen nuclear staining with pararosanilin-SO₂ was combined with the ninhydrin-Schiff technique. The aldehyde groups converted from primary amino groups are stained with an acriflavine-Schiff reaction. This results in a red nuclear fluorescence and a bright yellow cytoplasmic and nuclear fluorescence. The combined fluorescence staining facilitates cytofluorometric determination of total protein and DNA in the same cell.The ninhydrin-Schiff reaction is affected by the fixation procedure and the duration of the ninhydrin reaction. Investigations with a model system showed that proportionality beween the fluorescence intensity of acriflavine and the amount of protein stained by the procedure was obtained after fixation with a fixation mixture suggested by Böhm et al. (1968) and a reaction with ninhydrin at 37° C for 10 h.The ninhydrin-Schiff reaction has no effect on the fluorescence intensity of cells previously treated with pararosanilin-Feulgen staining and it is not affected itself by this previous procedure.Testing this double fluorescence staining on cytology specimens taken from patients with gastric carcinoma and uterine cervial carcinoma, cancer cells were shown to have markedly increased protein and DNA contents compared with those of normal cells.Partly supported by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), grant Nr. Bo 395/4     

Improved Histology for the Chick-Quail Chimera

A simple modification of nuclear staining after acid hydrolysis has been made which provides easy identification of quail nuclear markings in a chick-quail chimera. This method also improves the histologic detail normally seen with hematoxylin and eosin when compared to the more commonly used Feulgen reaction. Embryonic tissues can be fixed in Zenker's or Helly's solution and the sections obtained are hydrolyzed in acid (3.5 N HCl at 37 C for 40-50 min). After acid hydrolysis the sections are stained with hematoxylin and eosin rather than Schiff reagent and fast green. The interphase nuclei of chick cells show homogeneous or mottled purplish blue staining, while quail nuclei contain a dark blue spot. This staining corresponds to the reddish purple staining of the quail's heterochromatin seen adjacent to the nucleolus in the standard Feulgen stain. This new technique facilitates identification of quail cell types in the chick host and provides superior histology of the chick tissues by demonstrating cytoplasmic detail.     

INTRAMITOCHONDRIAL FIBERS WITH DNA CHARACTERISTICS : II. Enzymatic and Other Hydrolytic Treatments

The effects of proteolytic enzymes, ribonuclease, and deoxyribonuclease upon a fibrous component of chick embryo mitochondria, which was previously shown to have many fixation and staining properties characteristic of the bacterial nucleoplasm, are reported. Pepsin digestion of formaldehyde-fixed tissues removed the membranes and matrices of mitochondria, but a pepsin-resistant fibrous material remained which was heavily stained by uranyl and lead ions. Experiments on a DNA "model system" showed that DNA treated with osmium tetroxide can be depolymerized by deoxyribonuclease. Zinc ions strongly inhibited the depolymerization of DNA. Digestion of osmium tetroxide-fixed tissues (fixed only briefly) with deoxyribonuclease for 1 hour greatly reduced the Feulgen staining of the nuclei, and after 4 hours the Feulgen reaction was completely abolished. The reduction and the disappearance of the Feulgen reaction in nuclei was paralleled by partial to complete digestion of the mitochondrial fibers in the regions studied (after 1 and 4 hours, respectively), without any other obvious changes in cellular structures. When deoxyribonuclease was inhibited by the addition of zinc ions, the nuclear Feulgen reaction was not diminished, nor were the mitochondrial fibers removed. Buffer control incubations for deoxyribonuclease and ribonuclease did not alter the structure or staining properties of the mitochondrial fibers, nor did incubation with ribonuclease. The latter reaction digested the cytoplasmic and nucleolar ribosomes after a 4-hour incubation period, in parallel with the abolishment of toluidine blue staining. The results contribute further evidence that these mitochondria contain deoxyribonucleic acid.     

Nuclear location of hormone-free estrogen receptors by monoclonal antibodies could be a tissue-fixation dependent artifact

The 'two-step' model proposed by Jensen and his collaborators for explaining estrogen action conceptualized hormone-free estrogen receptors (ER) to be cytoplasmic, and hormone-filled, transformed ER to be nuclear. Applying monoclonal antibodies which recognized epitopes in ER and formaldehyde-fixed tissues, King et al demonstrated exclusively nuclear staining in target tissues utilizing immunoperoxidase technique. Recently these antibodies have become commercially available enabling other investigators to conduct studies. In this report, using these monoclonal antibodies we have demonstrated that a change in the concentration of formaldehyde alters the staining pattern yielding cytoplasmic instead of nuclear staining in calf uterus, MCF-7 cells, and ER(+) human breast cancer. In addition, neutralization of the antibody activity was not achieved with freshly prepared ER(+) cytosols. Formaldehyde-treated cytosols were essential. These results ought to caution investigators in determining in vivo location of antigens based on the staining pattern obtained in fixed tissues. Furthermore, this effect of formaldehyde on estrogen receptors may be applicable to other steroid hormone receptors.     

Staining of interphase nuclei and mitotic figures in cultured cells with alcian blue 8GX

Cultured endothelial cells derived from bovine calf pulmonary artery were subjected to a variety of fixatives and stained with 1% Alcian blue 8GX at pH 2.59 to 3.26. Within this range of pH, interphase nuclei and especially mitotic figures were (a) strongly stained in cells fixed with 10% formalin (phosphate buffered or unbuffered) or 2.5% buffered glutaraldehyde, (b) weakly stained or unstained in cells fixed in formaldehyde containing divalent cations, and (c) unstained in cells fixed in acetic acid-containing fluids. However, optimal nuclear staining with Alcian blue under the conditions of this study was judged to be achieved after fixation with neutral phosphate buffered 10% formalin. Endothelial cell cytoplasm exhibited a similar fixative-dependent staining. At pH 2.59 the cytoplasm of interphase cells fixed in formaldehyde (containing no divalent cations) or glutaraldehyde remained unstained; however, at higher pH cytoplasmic staining did occur and it increased as pH increased. In contrast, when these latter fixatives were employed the cytoplasm of mitotic cells stained at all pH levels tested. In cultured endothelial cells after appropriate fixation, 1% Alcian blue 8GX (pH 2.59) was found to possess the ability to stain nuclei with a selectivity and intensity that compared favorably to those of the Feulgen reaction of Heidenhain iron hematoxylin but without the latters' length and complexity. Therefore, this procedure may provide a rapid, simple, and selective method for visualizing interphase nuclei or mitotic figures, or both in the majority of cultured cells.     

The Specificity of the Feulgen Reaction for Thymonucleic Acid

The results of experiments on the specificity of the Feulgen reaction for thymonucleic acid do not substantiate the observations of Carr. The staining is not localized in the nucleus because of the destruction of cytoplasmic constituents following acid hydrolysis or because of the absorbing power of chromatin, since the cytoplasm and nucleolus can still be stained by numerous dyes. The effects of factors such as the acid hydrolysis and sulfurous acid washing baths upon the cytologic distribution of dye were studied on tissues stained with (1) fuchsin-sulfurous-acid (Feulgen) reagent, (2) fuchsin-sulfurous-acid reagent colorized by the addition of formaldehyde, (3) basic fuchsin in one-tenth normal HCl, and (4) basic fuchsin in distilled water. Under comparable conditions, important differences between these stains were found in the effects of preliminary hydrolysis; rapidity of staining and destaining; extractability of dye from tissues by water, alcohol, and sulfurous acid solution; rate of fading from exposure to light; localization of stain in tissues; and differences in hue. After treating tissues with desoxyribonuclease, an enzyme which acts only upon thymonucleic acid, cells do not stain with the Feulgen technic. Following removal of nucleic acid from chromatin by hydrolysis, attempts to demonstrate an absorption of thymonucleic acid upon the residual nuclear protein were unsuccessful.

The evidence for and against the specificity is discussed. In agreement with most other investigators, on the basis of the evidence in the literature as well as these experiments, it is concluded that when properly controlled the Feulgen reaction is relatively specific for thymonucleic acid.     

Quantification of nuclear DNA and intracellular glycogen in a single cell by fluorescent double-staining

Summary It was found that intracellular glycogen is stabilized against acid treatment when it is stored under dry conditions for three months after methanol fixation. This stabilization allowed quantitative double fluorescence staining, for nuclear DNA and intracellular glycogen, in a single cell. A Feulgen nucleal reaction with acriflavine-Schiff's reagent following 5 N HCl hydrolysis at 25°C for 4 min, was followed by a pararosanilin-Schiff PAS reaction for glycogen. This short term hydrolysis was found to be sufficient for the performance of a acriflavine-Schiff's Feulgen nucleal reaction and to provide good preservation of intracellular glycogen. Quantification of nuclear DNA and intracellular glycogen was consecutively carried out with a digital microfluorometer on a single ascites cancer cell of the AH-13 line stained by this method. It was found that there is a positive linear correlation between the amount of DNA and glycogen in this cell line.This work was partly supported by a Grant-in-Aid for Cancer Research from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan     

Simultaneous quantification of nucleoproteins and comparison of methyl green-pyronin Y and Feulgen staining in sections of oral squamous cell carcinoma,dysplastic lesions and normal mucosa

A fundamental difference between normal cells and tumor cells is the proliferative activity of the nucleus and nucleolus, which increases progressively from normal to oral dysplastic mucosa to oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC). This activity is evaluated routinely using hematoxylin and eosin (H & E) staining, but in some cases, inter-observer variability occurs among pathologists. We evaluated cellular proliferation by staining sections with the methyl green-pyronin Y procedure and the Feulgen reaction. We also compared the efficacy of methyl green-pyronin Y and Feulgen staining for studying nuclear and nucleolar features in oral dysplastic mucosa and in different grades of OSCC. Sections cut from formalin fixed, paraffin embedded blocks of five normal mucosa, 15 dysplastic mucosa, 10 well-differentiated OSCC, 10 moderately differentiated OSCC and five poorly differentiated OSCC cases were stained with Hematoxylin and Eosin, methyl green-pyronin Y and the Feulgen reaction. The mean diameters of the nuclei and number of nucleoli showed significant differences. A progressive increase in diameter of the nucleus and number of nucleoli was observed from normal mucosa through poorly differentiated OSCC. We observed that methyl green-pyronin Y stain is more useful than Feulgen and hematoxylin and eosin for simultaneous quantitative assessment of both RNA and DNA. The simplicity of this technique makes it a valuable tool even for daily routine examination.     

Rapid method to obtain high quality nuclear and chromosome images directly from living cells in the Characeae

This study focused on a method based on the capacity of cationic dyes to stain only the nucleus and chromosomes in cells subjected to either acid or alkaline hydrolysis. The method and the squash were optimized for the Characeae and were described in detail. Nuclei from vegetative shoot apices and antheridial filament cells of unfixed, fixed and herbarium material of Nitella opaca were investigated using the Azure A or Toulidine Blue stains. Comparisons with some other staining methods, used in the previous studies, were also reported. The Azure A/Toulidine Blue method is useful to obtain clear images of chromosome morphology comparable or higher to that obtained with Feulgen or Aceto‐Orcein. It requires little time and a less complicated procedure in comparison with other staining methods.     

Some Evidence for the Specificity of the Feulgen Reaction

Carr has attacked the specificity of the Feulgen reaction on three grounds: that the chromosomes are adsorbents capable of regenerating the color of the Schiff reagent; that selectivity for the nucleus depends on destruction of cytoplasm by acid hydrolysis preceding staining; and that the reaction is not blocked by SO₂ water, as he says it should be if staining occurs by a chemical reaction. The first point was tested by staining chromosomes treated with nuclease. They were Feulgen negative, but their protein basis remained intact. The second point was tested by hydrolyzing fixed tissues, washing off solutes, drying, and comparing weight loss with controls. As differences were negligible, the fixed cytoplasm must not have been made soluble by hydrolysis. Carr's third point was not tested experimentally. It is concluded that these objections to specificity of the Feulgen reaction are not valid.     

Comparative studies of Feulgen hydrolysis for DNA. I. Influence of different fixatives and polyethylene glycols

We compared the Feulgen hydrolysis curves (37 degrees C, 5 M HCl) of human blood lymphocytes fixed by the following four methods: 96% ethanol, 60 min at 20 degrees C; ethanol-acetone, 1:1, 120 min at 4 degrees C; ethanol-glacial acetic acid mixture (3:1), containing 2% of formaldehyde (EAF), 90 min at 20 degrees C; and ethanol-glacial acetic acid (3:1), 60 min followed by 5% chrome alum solution for 360 min at 20 degrees C. The best results were obtained with EAF-fixation, with respect to the highest amount of DNA-Schiff complex at the peak point of the curve, the longest "plateau" region and the smallest scattering of DNA-Schiff amount values along the "plateau". With other types of fixation the addition of polyethylene glycol (PEG) 6,000 to the hydrolysis solution resulted in modification of the shape of the hydrolysis curve so that it became nearly similar to the EAF-curve. The effect of PEG6000 on the EAF-curve was minimal. Slides fixed by ethanol were used for a comparison of polyethylene glycols with m.w. 1,500, 6,000 and 20,000. The longest "plateau" was obtained with PEG6000. The only effect of PEG1500 was a dramatic increase of DNA-Schiff amount at the peak point. PEG20000 had no significant effect on the shape of the hydrolysis curve. The results are discussed in terms of Kjellstrand's "chain with a stable structure" model of Feulgen hydrolysis.     

Nonspecific ("pseudo-plasmal") dye-binding in the Feulgen nuclear stain and its blocking by azocarmin G

In Feulgen nuclear staining nonspecific dye-binding due to the "pseudo-plasmal reaction" is intensified in isolated cells with intact cytoplasm, and cannot be eliminated by the post-irradiation method. Fluorescence intensity in the cytoplasm sometimes exceeds that of specific nuclear fluorescence, especially in brain and heart muscle cells, and it was almost impossible to perform cytofluorometric DNA quantification on such specimens. Various kinds of aldehyde-blocking agents such as sodium borohydride, 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine, aniline, and sodium pyrosulfite were effective in reducing the "pseudo-plasmal reaction". But the blocking effects were not complete because of additional release of reactive aldehyde groups during subsequent Feulgen hydrolysis. Acidic azocarmin G produced a complete block of all "pseudo-plasmal reaction" in acriflavine-Feulgen nuclear staining, allowing accurate DNA-cytofluorometry to be carried out.