Structure of calmodulin bound to a calcineurin peptide: a new way of making an old binding mode

Calcineurin is a calmodulin-binding protein in brain and the only serine/threonine protein phosphatase under the control of Ca2+/calmodulin (CaM), which plays a critical role in coupling Ca2+ signals to cellular responses. CaM up-regulates the phosphatase activity of calcineurin by binding to the CaM-binding domain (CBD) of calcineurin subunit A. Here, we report crystal structural studies of CaM bound to a CBD peptide. The chimeric protein containing CaM and the CBD peptide forms an intimate homodimer, in which CaM displays a native-like extended conformation and the CBD peptide shows alpha-helical structure. Unexpectedly, the N-terminal lobe from one CaM and the C-terminal lobe from the second molecule form a combined binding site to trap the peptide. Thus, the dimer provides two binding sites, each of which is reminiscent of the fully collapsed conformation of CaM commonly observed in complex with, for example, the myosin light chain kinase (MLCK) peptide. The interaction between the peptide and CaM is highly specific and similar to MLCK.     

Investigating the disorder–order transition of calmodulin binding domain upon binding calmodulin using molecular dynamics simulation

We have studied the conformational transition of the calmodulin binding domains (CBD) in several calmodulin‐binding kinases, in which CBD changes from the disordered state to the ordered state when binding with calmodulin (CaM). Targeted molecular dynamics simulation was used to investigate the binding process of CaM and CBD of CaM‐dependent kinase I (CaMKI–CBD). The results show that CaMKI–CBD began to form an α‐helix and the interaction free energy between CaM and CaMKI–CBD increased once CaM fully encompassed CaMKI–CBD. Two series of CaM/CBD complex systems, including the complexes of CaM with the initially disordered and the final ordered CBD, were constructed to study the interaction using molecular dynamics simulations. Our analyses suggest that the VDW interaction plays a dominant role in CaM/CBD binding and is a key factor in the disorder–order transition of CBD. Additionally, the entropy effect is not in favor of the formation of the CaM/CBD complex, which is consistent with the experimental evidence. Based on the results, it appears that the CBD conformational change from a non‐compact extended structure to compact α‐helix is critical in gaining a favorable VDW interaction and interaction free energy. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Structural basis of calcineurin activation by calmodulin

Calcineurin is the only known calmodulin (CaM) activated protein phosphatase, which is involved in the regulation of numerous cellular and developmental processes and in calcium-dependent signal transduction. Although commonly assumed that CaM displaces the autoinhibitory domain (AID) blocking substrate access to its active site, the structural basis underlying activation remains elusive. We have created a fused ternary complex (CBA) by covalently linking three polypeptides: CaM, calcineurin regulatory B subunit (CnB) and calcineurin catalytic A subunit (CnA). CBA catalytic activity is comparable to that of fully activated native calcineurin in the presence of CaM. The crystal structure showed virtually no structural change in the active site and no evidence of CaM despite being covalently linked. The asymmetric unit contains four molecules; two parallel CBA pairs are packed in an antiparallel mode and the large cavities in crystal packing near the calcineurin active site would easily accommodate multiple positions of AID-bound CaM. Intriguingly, the conformation of the ordered segment of AID is not altered by CaM; thus, it is the disordered part of AID, which resumes a regular α-helical conformation upon binding to CaM, which is displaced by CaM for activation. We propose that the structural basis of calcineurin activation by CaM is through displacement of the disordered fragment of AID which otherwise impedes active site access.     

Insights into molecular interactions between CaM and its inhibitors from molecular dynamics simulations and experimental data

In order to contribute to the structural basis for rational design of calmodulin (CaM) inhibitors, we analyzed the interaction of CaM with 14 classic antagonists and two compounds that do not affect CaM, using docking and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, and the data were compared to available experimental data. The Ca²⁺-CaM-Ligands complexes were simulated 20 ns, with CaM starting in the “open” and “closed” conformations. The analysis of the MD simulations provided insight into the conformational changes undergone by CaM during its interaction with these ligands. These simulations were used to predict the binding free energies (ΔG) from contributions ΔH and ΔS, giving useful information about CaM ligand binding thermodynamics. The ΔG predicted for the CaM’s inhibitors correlated well with available experimental data as the r² obtained was 0.76 and 0.82 for the group of xanthones. Additionally, valuable information is presented here: I) CaM has two preferred ligand binding sites in the open conformation known as site 1 and 4, II) CaM can bind ligands of diverse structural nature, III) the flexibility of CaM is reduced by the union of its ligands, leading to a reduction in the Ca²⁺-CaM entropy, IV) enthalpy dominates the molecular recognition process in the system Ca²⁺-CaM-Ligand, and V) the ligands making more extensive contact with the protein have higher affinity for Ca²⁺-CaM. Despite their limitations, docking and MD simulations in combination with experimental data continue to be excellent tools for research in pharmacology, toward a rational design of new drugs.     

Novel aspects of calmodulin target recognition and activation.

Several crystal and NMR structures of calmodulin (CaM) in complex with fragments derived from CaM-regulated proteins have been reported recently and reveal novel ways for CaM to interact with its targets. This review will discuss and compare features of the interaction between CaM and its target domains derived from the plasma membrane Ca2+-pump, the Ca2+-activated K+-channel, the Ca2+/CaM-dependent kinase kinase and the anthrax exotoxin. Unexpected aspects of CaM/target interaction observed in these complexes include: (a) binding of the Ca2+-pump domain to only the C-terminal part of CaM (b) dimer formation with fragments of the K+-channel (c) insertion of CaM between two domains of the anthrax exotoxin (d) binding of Ca2+ ions to only one EF-hand pair and (e) binding of CaM in an extended conformation to some of its targets. The mode of interaction between CaM and these targets differs from binding conformations previously observed between CaM and peptides derived from myosin light chain kinase (MLCK) and CaM-dependent kinase IIalpha (CaMKIIalpha). In the latter complexes, CaM engulfs the CaM-binding domain peptide with its two Ca2+-binding lobes and forms a compact, ellipsoid-like complex. In the early 1990s, a model for the activation of CaM-regulated proteins was developed based on this observation and postulated activation through the displacement of an autoinhibitory or regulatory domain from the target protein upon binding of CaM. The novel structures of CaM-target complexes discussed here demonstrate that this mechanism of activation may be less general than previously believed and seems to be not valid for the anthrax exotoxin, the CaM-regulated K+-channel and possibly also not for the Ca2+-pump.     

Crystal structures of apocalmodulin and an apocalmodulin/SK potassium channel gating domain complex

Small conductance Ca2+-activated K+ channels (SK channels) are composed of the pore-forming alpha subunit and calmodulin (CaM). CaM binds to a region of the alpha subunit called the CaM binding domain (CaMBD), located intracellular and immediately C-terminal to the inner helix gate, in either the presence or absence of Ca2+. SK gating occurs when Ca2+ binds the N lobe of CaM thereby transmitting the signal to the attached inner helix gate to open. Here we present crystal structures of apoCaM and apoCaM/SK2 CaMBD complex. Several apoCaM crystal forms with multiple (12) packing environments reveal the same EF hand domain-swapped dimer providing potentially new insight into CaM regulation. The apoCaM/SK2 CaMBD structure, combined with our Ca2+/CaM/CaMBD structure suggests that Ca2+ binding induces folding and dimerization of the CaMBD, which causes large CaMBD-CaM C lobe conformational changes, including a >90 degrees rotation of the region of the CaMBD directly connected to the gate.     

Domain Swapping and Different Oligomeric States for the Complex Between Calmodulin and the Calmodulin-Binding Domain of Calcineurin A

Background

Calmodulin (CaM) is a ubiquitously expressed calcium sensor that engages in regulatory interactions with a large number of cellular proteins. Previously, a unique mode of CaM target recognition has been observed in the crystal structure of a complex between CaM and the CaM-binding domain of calcineurin A.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We have solved a high-resolution crystal structure of a complex between CaM and the CaM-binding domain of calcineurin A in a novel crystal form, which shows a dimeric assembly of calmodulin, as observed before in the crystal state. We note that the conformation of CaM in this complex is very similar to that of unliganded CaM, and a detailed analysis revels that the CaM-binding motif in calcineurin A is of a novel ‘1-11’ type. However, using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), we show that the complex is fully monomeric in solution, and a structure of a canonically collapsed CaM-peptide complex can easily be fitted into the SAXS data. This result is also supported by size exclusion chromatography, where the addition of the ligand peptide decreases the apparent size of CaM. In addition, we studied the energetics of binding by isothermal titration calorimetry and found them to closely resemble those observed previously for ligand peptides from CaM-dependent kinases.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results implicate that CaM can also form a complex with the CaM-binding domain of calcineurin in a 1∶1 stoichiometry, in addition to the previously observed 2∶2 arrangement in the crystal state. At the structural level, going from 2∶2 association to two 1∶1 complexes will require domain swapping in CaM, accompanied by the characteristic bending of the central linker helix between the two lobes of CaM.     

The complex structure of calmodulin bound to a calcineurin peptide

The activity of the protein phosphatase calcineurin (CN) is regulated by an autoinhibition mechanism wherein several domains from its catalytic A subunit, including the calmodulin binding domain (CaMBD), block access to its active site. Upon binding of Ca2+ and calmodulin (Ca2+/CaM) to CaMBD, the autoinhibitory domains dissociate from the catalytic groove, thus activating the enzyme. To date, the structure of the CN/CaM/Ca2+ complex has not been determined in its entirety. Previously, we determined the structure of a fusion protein consisting of CaM and a 25-residue peptide taken from the CaMBD, joined by a 5-glycine linker. This structure revealed a novel CaM binding motif. However, the presence of the extraneous glycine linker cast doubt on the authenticity of this structure as an accurate representation of CN/CaM binding in vivo. Thus, here, we have determined the crystal structure of CaM complexed with the 25-residue CaMBD peptide without the glycine linker at a resolution of 2.1 A. The structure is essentially identical to the fusion construction which displays CaM bound to the CaMBD peptide as a dimer with an open, elongated conformation. The N-lobe from one molecule and C-lobe from another encompass and bind the CaMBD peptide. Thus, it validates the existence of this novel CaM binding motif. Our experiments suggest that the dimeric CaM/CaMBD complex exists in solution, which is unambiguously validated using a carefully-designed CaM-sepharose pull-down experiment. We discuss structural features that produce this novel binding motif, including the role of the CaMBD peptide residues Arg-408, Val-409, and Phe-410, which work to provide rigidity to the otherwise flexible central CaM helix joining the N- and C-lobes, ultimately keeping these lobes apart and forcing "head-to-tail" dimerization to attain the requisite N- and C-lobe pairing for CaMBD binding.     

A renewed model of CNA regulation involving its C-terminal regulatory domain and CaM

Calcineurin is composed of a catalytic subunit (CNA) and a regulatory subunit (CNB). CNA contains the catalytic domain and three regulatory domains: a CNB-binding domain (BBH), a C-terminal calmodulin-binding domain (CBD), and an autoinhibitory domain (AID). We constructed a series of mutants of CNA to explore the regulatory role of its C-terminal regulatory domain and CaM. We demonstrated a more precise mechanism of CNA regulation by C-terminal residues 389-511 in the presence of CNB. First, we showed that residues 389-413, which were identified in previous work as constituting a CaM binding domain (CBD), also have an autoinhibiting function. We also found that residues 389-413 were not sufficient for CaM binding and that the CBD comprises at least residues 389-456. In conclusion, two distinct segments of the C-terminal regulatory region (389-511) of CNA inhibit enzyme activity: residues 389-413 interact with the CNB binding helix (BBH), and residues 457-482 with the active center of CNA.     

Asymmetric conformational changes in a GPCR dimer controlled by G-proteins

G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are key players in cell communication. Although long considered as monomeric, it now appears that these heptahelical proteins can form homo- or heterodimers. Here, we analyzed the conformational changes in each subunit of a receptor dimer resulting from agonist binding to either one or both subunits by measuring the fluorescent properties of a leukotriene B(4) receptor dimer with a single 5-hydroxytryptophan-labeled protomer. We show that a receptor dimer with only a single agonist-occupied subunit can trigger G-protein activation. We also show that the two subunits of the receptor dimer in the G-protein-coupled state differ in their conformation, even when both are liganded by the agonist. No such asymmetric conformational changes are observed in the absence of G-protein, indicating that the interaction of the G-protein with the receptor dimer brings specific constraints that prevent a symmetric functioning of this dimer. These data open new options for the differential signaling properties of GPCR dimers.     

Calcineurin B- and calmodulin-binding preferences identified with phage-displayed peptide libraries

Calcineurin B (CnB) and calmodulin (CaM) are two structurally similar but functionally distinct 'EF-hand' Ca2+-binding proteins. CnB is the regulatory subunit of the CaM-stimulated protein phosphatase, calcineurin. CaM is a unique multifunctional protein that interacts with and modulates the activity of many target proteins. CnB and CaM are both required for the full activation of the phosphatase activity of calcineurin and are not interchangeable. The two proteins recognize distinct binding sites on calcineurin A subunit (CnA) and perform different functions. Phage-displayed peptide libraries (pIII and pVIII libraries) were screened with CnB and CaM to isolate peptides that could then be compared to determine if there were binding preferences of the two proteins. The Ca2+-dependent binding of phage-displayed peptides to CnB and CaM is specifically blocked by synthetic peptides derived from the CnB-binding domain of CnA and the CaM-binding domain of myosin light chain kinase respectively. Both CnB- and CaM-binding peptides have a high content of tryptophan and leucine, but CnB-binding peptides are more hydrophobic than CaM-binding peptides. CnB-binding peptides are negatively charged with clusters of hydrophobic residues rich in phenylalanine, whereas the CaM-binding peptides are positively charged and often contain an Arg/Lys-Trp motif. The binding preferences identified with peptide libraries are consistent with the features of the CnB-binding domains of all CnA isoforms and the CaM-binding domains of CaM targets.     

Circular dichroism and fluorescence analysis of the interaction of Pf1 gene 5 protein with poly(dT)

Circular dichroism (c.d.) and fluorescence spectroscopy have been used to investigate the interaction of the gene 5 protein of the filamentous bacteriophage Pf1 with single-stranded DNA. The c.d. spectrum of the Pf1 gene 5 protein is consistent with the absence of any significant alpha-helical content. The negative c.d. peak in the region of 210 nm, which arises from the protein, is diminished in the complex with poly(dT). Likewise, the c.d. peak at 265 nm arising from the poly(dT) decreases when the Pf1 gene 5 protein is bound, c.d. titrations of poly(dT) with Pf1 gene 5 protein indicate strong binding with a stoichiometry (n) of four nucleotides per protein subunit. In contrast, when the titrations were done using fluorescence anisotropy or fluorescence spectral shifts to follow binding, apparent stoichiometries between n = 2 and n = 4 were observed, often in the same experiment, depending on precise conditions. The results are interpreted in terms of two distinct modes of binding, in which either one or two subunits of the protein dimer are bound to the polynucleotide lattice, but still retaining the same local interaction with the DNA, with each binding site covering four nucleotides. The apparent stoichiometry of 2 results from the interaction of only one subunit of the dimer with the nucleic acid lattice, when protein is in excess. The second, unfilled, subunit of the dimer is nevertheless incorporated into the complex, resulting in the maximum possible fluorescence change when only half the sites are filled, since the fluorescence properties of the complex arise from protein-protein contacts associated with co-operative binding to the lattice. Further experiments in which the order of addition of components is changed, and the concentration of MgCl2 is varied, show that both of these factors are important in determining the dominant binding mode. In the absence of salt, dissociation and redistribution of the polynucleotide can occur following the addition of excess protein. This transition is suppressed in the presence of greater than 3 mM-MgCl2.     

Regulation of cAMP concentration by calmodulin-dependent cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase

Bovine brain contains two major calmodulin (CaM) dependent phosphodiesterase isozymes which are homodimeric proteins with subunit molecular masses of 60 and 63 kilodaltons (kDa), respectively. The 60-kDa subunit isozyme can be phosphorylated by cAMP-dependent protein kinase, resulting in a decrease in the enzyme affinity towards CaM. The phosphorylation is blocked by Ca2+ and CaM and reversed by the CaM-stimulated phosphatase (calcineurin). The 63-kDa subunit isozymes can also be phosphorylated, but in this case by a CaM-dependent protein kinase(s). This phosphorylation is also accompanied by a decrease in the isozyme affinity towards CaM and can be reversed by the CaM-dependent phosphatase. Analysis of the complex regulatory properties of the phosphodiesterase isozymes has led to the suggestion that fluxes of cAMP and Ca2+ during cell activations are closely coupled and that the CaM-dependent phosphodiesterase isozymes play key roles in this signal coupling phenomenon.     

Immunophilins interact with calcineurin in the absence of exogenous immunosuppressive ligands.

The peptidyl-prolyl isomerases FKBP12 and cyclophilin A (immunophilins) form complexes with the immunosuppressants FK506 and cyclosporin A that inhibit the phosphatase calcineurin. With the yeast two hybrid system, we detect complexes between FKBP12 and the calcineurin A catalytic subunit in both the presence and absence of FK506. Mutations in FKBP12 surface residues or the absence of the calcineurin B regulatory subunit perturb the FK506-dependent, but not the ligand-independent, FKBP12-calcineurin complex. By affinity chromatography, both FKBP12 and cyclophilin A bind calcineurin A in the absence of ligand, and FK506 and cyclosporin A respectively potentiate these interactions. Both in vivo and in vitro, the peptidyl-prolyl isomerase active sites are dispensable for ligand-independent immunophilin-calcineurin complexes. Lastly, by genetic analyses we demonstrate that FKBP12 modulates calcineurin functions in vivo. These findings reveal that immunophilins interact with calcineurin in the absence of exogenous ligands and suggest that immunosuppressants may take advantage of the inherent ability of immunophilins to interact with calcineurin.     

Interactions of calmodulin with metal ions and with its target proteins revealed by conformation-sensitive monoclonal antibodies

Two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) raised against bovine calmodulin (CaM), CAM1 and CAM4, enable one to monitor conformational changes that occur in the molecule. The interaction of CAM1 with CaM depends on the Ca2+ occupancy of its Ca(2+)-binding sites. CAM4, in contrast, interacts with CaM in a Ca(2+)-independent manner, interacting with both holoCaM and EGTA-treated CaM to a similar extent. Their interaction with various CaMs, CaM tryptic fragments and chemically modified CaM, as well as molecular graphics, led to identification of the CAM1 and CAM4 epitopes on the C- and N-terminal lobes of CAM respectively. The two mAbs were used as macromolecular probes to detect conformational changes occurring in the CaM molecule upon binding of metal ions and target proteins and peptides. MAb CAM1 successfully detected changes associated with Al3+ binding even in the presence of Ca2+, indicating that Al3+ and Ca2+ ions may bind to the protein simultaneously, leading to a new conformation of the molecule. MAbs CAM1 and CAM4 were used to follow the interactions of CaM with its target peptides and proteins. Complexes with melittin, mastoparan, calcineurin and phosphodiesterase showed different immunological properties on an immuno-enzyme electrode, indicating unique structural properties for each complex.     

Calmodulin inhibits the phosphorylation of spectrin in vitro

In vitro phosphorylation of purified spectrin dimer was studied in the presence of Ca2+-calmodulin (CaM). CaM inhibited autophosphorylation of the beta subunit of spectrin. The inhibitory effect (65% at a 32-fold molar excess) appeared to be due to a weak interaction of CaM with spectrin. CaM was similarly effective in a phosphatase-stimulated autothiophosphorylation of the beta subunit with [gamma-35S]ATP. Hence, its inhibitory effect was not due to stimulation of a spectrin-associated phosphatase activity. Phosphorylation of spectrin by the catalytic subunit of a cAMP-dependent protein kinase occurred in both subunits (1984, FEBS Lett. 169, 323). CaM selectively inhibited a cAMP-dependent phosphorylation of the alpha subunit of spectrin to 30% at two CaM per spectrin. It was ineffective on the cAMP-dependent phosphorylation of the beta subunit up to a 32-fold molar excess. These results yield functional evidence for a CaM-spectrin interaction. They further suggest that CaM can regulate the extent of a cAMP-dependent phosphorylation of the alpha subunit of spectrin.     

Simultaneous binding of the N- and C-terminal cytoplasmic domains of aquaporin 4 to calmodulin

Aquaporin 4 (AQP4) is a water transporting, transmembrane channel protein that has important regulatory roles in maintaining cellular water homeostasis. Several other AQP proteins exhibit calmodulin (CaM)-binding properties, and CaM has recently been implicated in the cell surface localization of AQP4. The objective of the present study was to assess the CaM-binding properties of AQP4 in detail. Inspection of AQP4 revealed two putative CaM-binding domains (CBDs) in the cytoplasmic N- and C-terminal regions, respectively. The Ca²⁺-dependent CaM-binding properties of AQP4 CBD peptides were assessed using fluorescence spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry, and two-dimensional ¹H, ¹⁵N-HSQC NMR with ¹⁵N-labeled CaM. The N-terminal CBD of AQP4 predominantly interacted with the N-lobe of CaM with a 1:1 binding ratio and a K_d of 3.4 μM. The C-terminal AQP4 peptide interacted with both the C- and N-lobes of CaM (2:1 binding ratio; K_d1: 3.6 μM, K_d2: 113.6 μM, respectively). A recombinant AQP4 protein domain (recAQP4^CT, containing the entire cytosolic C-terminal sequence) bound CaM in a 1:1 binding mode with a K_d of 6.1 μM. A ternary bridging complex could be generated with the N- and C-lobes of CaM interacting simultaneously with the N- and C-terminal CBD peptides. These data support a unique adapter protein binding mode for CaM with AQP4.     

Conformational flexibility of neurophysin as investigated by local motions of fluorophores. Relationships with neurohypophyseal hormone binding

Flexibility of various structural domains of neurophysin and neurophysin-neurohypophyseal hormone complexes has been investigated through the fast rotational motion of fluorophores in highly viscous medium. Despite seven intrachain disulfide links, it is shown that some domains of neurophysin remain highly flexible. Dimerization of neurophysin does not affect the structural integrity of the individual subunits, each subdomain being conformationally equivalent within each protomer of the unliganded dimer. The absence of heterogeneous fluorescence anisotropy precludes the existence of a dimer tautomerization equilibrium. Binding of the hormonal ligands to neurophysin dimer promotes a large conformational change over the whole protein structure as assessed by differential alterations of the flexibility-rigidity and intrasegmental interaction properties of domains that do not participate directly to the dimerization/binding areas. The order of free-energy coupling between ligand binding and protein subunit association has been evaluated. Data are consistent with a model in which the first mole of bound ligand stabilizes the dimer by increasing the intersubunit contacts while the second mole of ligand induces most of the described conformational change. Accordingly, the positive cooperativity between the two dimeric binding sites is linked mainly to the binding of the second ligand. The induced structural change is perceived differently by each subunit as assessed by opposite local motions of Tyr49 in each liganded protomer and leads to the formation of a dimeric complex with a global pseudospherical symmetry although containing domains of local asymmetry.     

Phosphorylation of calcineurin: effect on calmodulin binding

The effect of phosphorylation of calcineurin on calmodulin (CaM) binding was examined using a synthetic peptide which contains the CaM-binding domain and the serine phosphorylation site. The peptide, corresponding to residues 391-414 of brain calcineurin A subunit, was rapidly phosphorylated by protein kinase C and Ca2+/CaM-dependent protein kinase II but not by cAMP-dependent protein kinase. Phosphorylation of peptide 391-414 did not significantly alter the binding of CaM when compared to the non-phosphorylated peptide.