Novel nickel transport mechanism across the bacterial outer membrane energized by the TonB/ExbB/ExbD machinery

Nickel is a cofactor for various microbial enzymes, yet as a trace element, its scavenging is challenging. In the case of the pathogen Helicobacter pylori, nickel is essential for the survival in the human stomach, because it is the cofactor of the important virulence factor urease. While nickel transport across the cytoplasmic membrane is accomplished by the nickel permease NixA, the mechanism by which nickel traverses the outer membrane (OM) of this Gram-negative bacterium is unknown. Import of iron-siderophores and cobalamin through the bacterial OM is carried out by specific receptors energized by the TonB/ExbB/ExbD machinery. In this study, we show for the first time that H. pylori utilizes TonB/ExbB/ExbD for nickel uptake in addition to iron acquisition. We have identified the nickel-regulated protein FrpB4, homologous to TonB-dependent proteins, as an OM receptor involved in nickel uptake. We demonstrate that ExbB/ExbD/TonB and FrpB4 deficient bacteria are unable to efficiently scavenge nickel at low pH. This condition mimics those encountered by H. pylori during stomach colonization, under which nickel supply and full urease activity are essential to combat acidity. We anticipate that this nickel scavenging system is not restricted to H. pylori, but will be represented more largely among Gram-negative bacteria.     

The tonB gene of Serratia marcescens: sequence, activity and partial complementation of Escherichia coli tonB mutants

The TonB protein plays a key role in the energy-coupled transport of iron siderophores, of vitamin B12, and of colicins of the B-group across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. In order to obtain more data about which of its particular amino acid sequences are necessary for TonB function, we have cloned and sequenced the tonB gene of Serratia marcescens. The nucleotide sequence predicts an amino acid sequence of 247 residues (Mr 27,389), which is unusually proline-rich and contains the tandem sequences (Glu-Pro)5 and (Lys-Pro)5. In contrast to the TonB proteins of E. coli and Salmonella typhimurium, translation of the S. marcescens TonB protein starts at the first methionine residue of the open reading frame, which is the only amino acid removed during TonB maturation and export. Only the N-terminal sequence is hydrophobic, suggesting its involvement in anchoring the TonB protein to the cytoplasmic membrane. The S. marcescens tonB gene complemented an E. coli tonB mutant with regard to uptake of iron siderophores, and sensitivity to phages T1 and phi 80, and to colicins B and M. However, an E. coli tonB mutant transformed with the S. marcescens tonB gene remained resistant to colicins Ia and Ib, to colicin B derivatives carrying the amino acid replacements Val/Ala and Val/Gly at position 20 in the TonB box, and they exhibited a tenfold lower activity with colicin D. In addition, the S. marcescens TonB protein did not restore T1 sensitivity of an E. coli exbB tolQ double mutant, as has been found for the overexpressed E. coli TonB protein, indicating a lower activity of the S. marcescens TonB protein. Although the S. marcescens TonB protein was less prone to proteolytic degradation, it was stabilized in E. coli by the ExbBD proteins. In E. coli, TonB activity of S. marcescens depended either on the ExbBD or the TolQR activities.     

Genetic suppression demonstrates interaction of TonB protein with outer membrane transport proteins in Escherichia coli.

Energy-coupled reactions of the Escherichia coli outer membrane transport proteins BtuB and Cir require the tonB product. Some point mutations in a region of btuB and cir that is highly conserved in TonB-dependent transport proteins led to loss of TonB-coupled uptake of vitamin B12 and colicin Ia, whereas binding was unaffected. Most other point mutations in this region had no detectable effect on transport activity. Mutations in tonB that suppressed the transport defect phenotype of these btuB mutations were isolated. All carried changes of glutamine 165 to leucine, lysine, or proline. The various tonB mutations differed markedly in their suppression activities on different btuB or cir mutations. This allele specificity of suppression indicates that TonB interacts directly with the outer membrane transport proteins in a manner that recognizes the local conformation but not specific side chains within this conserved region. An effect of the context of the remainder of the protein was seen, since the same substitution (valine 10----glycine) in btuB and cir responded differently to the suppressors. This finding supports the proposal that TonB interacts with more of the transport proteins than the first conserved domain alone.     

Energy-coupled transport across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli: ExbB binds ExbD and TonB in vitro, and leucine 132 in the periplasmic region and aspartate 25 in the transmembrane region are important for ExbD activity.

Ferric siderophores, vitamin B12, and group B colicins are taken up through the outer membranes of Escherichia coli cells by an energy-coupled process. Energy from the cytoplasmic membrane is transferred to the outer membrane with the aid of the Ton system, consisting of the proteins TonB, ExbB, and ExbD. In this paper we describe two point mutations which inactivate ExbD. One mutation close to the N-terminal end of ExbD is located in the cytoplasmic membrane, and the other mutation close to the C-terminal end is located in the periplasm. E. coli CHO3, carrying a chromosomal exbD mutation in which leucine at position 132 was replaced by glutamine, was devoid of all Ton-related activities. A plasmid-encoded ExbD derivative, in which aspartate at position 25, the only changed amino acid in the predicted membrane-spanning region of ExbD, was replaced by asparagine, failed to restore the Ton activities of strain CHO3 and negatively complemented ExbD+ strains, indicating an interaction of this mutated ExbD with wild-type ExbD or with another component. This component was shown to be ExbB. ExbB that was labeled with 6 histidine residues at its C-terminal end and that bound to a nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid agarose column retained ExbD and TonB specifically; both were eluted with the ExbB labeled with 6 histidine residues, demonstrating interaction of ExbB with ExbD and TonB. These data further support the concept that TonB, ExbB, and ExbD form a complex in which the energized conformation of TonB opens the channels in the outer membrane receptor proteins.     

TonB interacts with nonreceptor proteins in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli TonB protein serves to couple the cytoplasmic membrane proton motive force to active transport of iron-siderophore complexes and vitamin B(12) across the outer membrane. Consistent with this role, TonB has been demonstrated to participate in strong interactions with both the cytoplasmic and outer membranes. The cytoplasmic membrane determinants for that interaction have been previously characterized in some detail. Here we begin to examine the nature of TonB interactions with the outer membrane. Although the presence of the siderophore enterochelin (also known as enterobactin) greatly enhanced detectable cross-linking between TonB and the outer membrane receptor, FepA, the absence of enterochelin did not prevent the localization of TonB to the outer membrane. Furthermore, the absence of FepA or indeed of all the iron-responsive outer membrane receptors did not alter this association of TonB with the outer membrane. This suggested that TonB interactions with the outer membrane were not limited to the TonB-dependent outer membrane receptors. Hydrolysis of the murein layer with lysozyme did not alter the distribution of TonB, suggesting that peptidoglycan was not responsible for the outer membrane association of TonB. Conversely, the interaction of TonB with the outer membrane was disrupted by the addition of 4 M NaCl, suggesting that these interactions were proteinaceous. Subsequently, two additional contacts of TonB with the outer membrane proteins Lpp and, putatively, OmpA were identified by in vivo cross-linking. These contacts corresponded to the 43-kDa and part of the 77-kDa TonB-specific complexes described previously. Surprisingly, mutations in these proteins individually did not appear to affect TonB phenotypes. These results suggest that there may be multiple redundant sites where TonB can interact with the outer membrane prior to transducing energy to the outer membrane receptors.     

Quantification of known components of the Escherichia coli TonB energy transduction system: TonB, ExbB, ExbD and FepA

The TonB-dependent energy transduction system couples cytoplasmic membrane proton motive force to active transport of iron-siderophore complexes across the outer membrane in Gram-negative bacteria. In Escherichia coli, the primary players known in this process to date are: FepA, the TonB-gated transporter for the siderophore enterochelin; TonB, the energy-transducing protein; and two cytoplasmic membrane proteins with less defined roles, ExbB and ExbD. In this study, we report the per cell numbers of TonB, ExbB, ExbD and FepA for cells grown under iron-replete and iron-limited conditions. Under iron-replete conditions, TonB and FepA were present at 335 +/- 78 and 504 +/- 165 copies per cell respectively. ExbB and ExbD, despite being encoded from the same operon, were not equimolar, being present at 2463 +/- 522 and 741 +/- 105 copies respectively. The ratio of these proteins was calculated at one TonB:two ExbD:seven ExbB under all four growth conditions tested. In contrast, the TonB:FepA ratio varied with iron status and according to the method used for iron limitation. Differences in the method of iron limitation also resulted in significant differences in cell size, skewing the per cell copy numbers for all proteins.     

TonB protein appears to transduce energy by shuttling between the cytoplasmic membrane and the outer membrane in Escherichia coli

The energy source for active transport of iron–siderophore complexes and vitamin B12 across the outer membrane in Gram-negative bacteria is the cytoplasmic membrane proton-motive force (pmf). TonB protein is required in this process to transduce cytoplasmic membrane energy to the outer membrane. In this study, Escherichia coli TonB was found to be distributed in sucrose density gradients approximately equally between the cytoplasmic membrane and the outer membrane fractions, while two proteins with which it is known to interact, ExbB and ExbD, as well as the NADH oxidase activity characteristic of the cytoplasmic membrane, were localized in the cytoplasmic membrane fraction. Neither the N-terminus of TonB nor the cytoplasmic membrane pmf, both of which are essential for TonB activity, were required for TonB to associate with the outer membrane. When the TonB C-terminus was absent, TonB was found associated with the cytoplasmic membrane, suggesting that the C-terminus was required for outer membrane association. When ExbB and ExbD, as well as their cross-talk-competent homologues TolQ and TolR, were absent, TonB was found associated with the outer membrane. TetA–TonB protein, which cannot interact with ExbB/D, was likewise found associated with the outer membrane. These results indicated that the role of ExbB/D in energy transduction is to bring TonB that has reached the outer membrane back to associate with the cytoplasmic membrane. Two possible explanations exist for the observations presented in this study. One possibility is that TonB transduces energy by shuttling between membranes, and, at some stages in the energy-transduction cycle, is associated with either the cytoplasmic membrane or the outer membrane, but not with both at the same time. This hypothesis, together with the alternative interpretation that TonB remains localized in the cytoplasmic membrane and changes its affinity for the outer and cytoplasmic membrane during energy transduction, are incorporated with previous observations into two new models, consistent with the novel aspects of this system, that describe a mechanism for TonB-dependent energy transduction.     

Pleiotropic transport mutants of Escherichia coli lack porin, a major outer membrane protein.

Summary Four pleiotropic transport mutants of Escherichia coli B/r with decreased affinity for the uptake of most nutrients were found to lack a major outer membrane protein of 36,500 daltons (porin) previously shown to produce transmembrane diffusion channels in in vitro reconstitution experiments. Consequent decrease in outer membrane permeability was confirmed by measuring the transmembrane diffusion rate of 6-aminopenicillanic acid. Quantitative considerations on the porin-dependent permeability of the outer membrane show that (a) there may be very large differences in the actual rates of penetration, even among the permeable substances and (b) the numbers of porin molecules present in wild type cells is several orders of magnitude higher than that necessary for the uptake of rapidly diffusing substrates such as glocose from ordinary culture media. The absence of porin and the pleiotropic transport defect were always contransduced, and the mutation was mapped at 73.7 min between aroB and malT by P1 transduction. When revertants able to grow on low concentrations of lactose were selected, in addition to true revertants suppressor strains with increased amounts of non-porin membrane proteins were isolated.This paper corresponds to paper XVI of the series dealing with the bacterial outer membrane from the laboratory of H.N. The preceding paper in the series is Nikaido, Bavoil, and Hirota, J. Bacteriol., in press     

Transport across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K12 via the FhuA receptor is regulated by the TonB protein of the cytoplasmic membrane

Summary Point mutations in the “TonB box” offhuA were suppressed by point mutations in thetonB gene, suggesting both a functional and physical interaction between the FhuA receptor protein in the outer membrane and the TonB protein in the cytoplasmic membrane ofEscherichia coli K12. Mutations influA were classified into four types according to the extent by which they impaired mutant cells in their growth on ferrichrome as sole iron source and in their sensitivity to the antibiotic albomycin and to colicin M. ThetonB mutation with a glutamine to leucine replacement at position 165 was less efficient in restoring the FhuA functions than the glutamine to lysine exchange at the same position. The better the coupling between FhuA and TonB the poorer was the inhibition of phage T1 binding to FhuA by ferrichrome. A working model is proposed in which the TonB protein assumes different conformations in response to the energized state of the cytoplasmic membrane and thereby allosterically regulates the activity of the FhuA receptor. This model implies an intermembrane coupling between two proteins in adjacent membranes.     

Suppression of the btuB451 mutation by mutations in the tonB gene suggests a direct interaction between TonB and TonB-dependent receptor proteins in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

In cells of Escherichia coli, the function of the tonB gene is needed for energy-dependent transport processes mediated by the outer-membrane receptors for iron siderophore complexes and vitamin B12. The btuB451 mutation has the same effect on vitamin B12 transport as does a tonB mutation. When a btuB451 strain carried a plasmid with the intact tonB gene, partial revertant strains were isolated which had acquired the ability to grow on 5 nM vitamin B12. This suppression activity was associated with the plasmid, suggesting that a mutation within the tonB gene on the plasmid allowed the mutant BtuB receptor to function in the transport of the vitamin. The nucleotide sequence of the entire tonB gene of ten independently isolated suppressing plasmids was determined. Only a single nucleotide change had occurred in each of the cases. The same codon was always affected resulting in the conversion of glutamine-165 to a leucine in seven of the ten isolates and to a lysine in the other three. The phenotype of strains carrying both types of altered tonB genes showed the retention of their function for other TonB-dependent processes in addition to their suppressor properties with respect to the btuB451 mutation. The fact that mutations suppressing the btuB451 mutation occurred in the tonB gene suggests that there is a direct interaction between TonB and TonB-dependent receptors in the outer membrane of E. coli.     

In vivo evidence of TonB shuttling between the cytoplasmic and outer membrane in Escherichia coli

Gram-negative bacteria are able to convert potential energy inherent in the proton gradient of the cytoplasmic membrane into active nutrient transport across the outer membrane. The transduction of energy is mediated by TonB protein. Previous studies suggest a model in which TonB makes sequential and cyclic contact with proteins in each membrane, a process called shuttling. A key feature of shuttling is that the amino-terminal signal anchor must quit its association with the cytoplasmic membrane, and TonB becomes associated solely with the outer membrane. However, the initial studies did not exclude the possibility that TonB was artifactually pulled from the cytoplasmic membrane by the fractionation process. To resolve this ambiguity, we devised a method to test whether the extreme TonB amino-terminus, located in the cytoplasm, ever became accessible to the cys-specific, cytoplasmic membrane-impermeant molecule, Oregon Green(R) 488 maleimide (OGM) in vivo. A full-length TonB and a truncated TonB were modified to carry a sole cysteine at position 3. Both full-length TonB and truncated TonB (consisting of the amino-terminal two-thirds) achieved identical conformations in the cytoplasmic membrane, as determined by their abilities to cross-link to the cytoplasmic membrane protein ExbB and their abilities to respond conformationally to the presence or absence of proton motive force. Full-length TonB could be amino-terminally labelled in vivo, suggesting that it was periplasmically exposed. In contrast, truncated TonB, which did not associate with the outer membrane, was not specifically labelled in vivo. The truncated TonB also acted as a control for leakage of OGM across the cytoplasmic membrane. Further, the extent of labelling for full-length TonB correlated roughly with the proportion of TonB found at the outer membrane. These findings suggest that TonB does indeed disengage from the cytoplasmic membrane during energy transduction and shuttle to the outer membrane.     

Transport of vitamin B12 in tonB mutants of Escherichia coli.

It is known that the tonB mutation in Escherichia coli is responsible for a defect in the transport of iron chelates. These are transported by systems that involve outer membrane components. We found that tonB mutants were also deficient in the secondary, energy-dependent phase of vitamin B12 transport, although the mutants have normal levels of B12 receptors on their cell surface. In addition, tonB mutants derived from vitamin B12 auxotrophs required elevated levels of B12 for normal growth. Maltose uptake, mediated by another transport system involving an outer membrane component, was unaffected by the tonB mutation.     

Reconstitution of maltose transport in malB mutants of Escherichia coli through calcium-induced disruptions of the outer membrane.

The barrier function of the Escherichia coli outer membrane against low concentrations of maltose in strains missing the lambda receptor was partially overcome by treating the cells for 3 h with 25 mM Ca2+. Kinetic analysis of maltose-transport revealed a Ca2+-induced shift of the apparent Km of the system from about 100 microM in cells pretreated with Tris to about 15 microM in cells pretreated with Tris plus Ca2+. In contrast to maltose transport in untreated cells, that of Ca2+-treated lamB cells was inhibited by molecules with a high molecular weight, such as amylopectin (molecular weight, 20,000), and anti-maltose-binding protein antibodies. In addition, lysozyme was shown to attack Ca2+-treated cells in contrast to untreated cells. The Ca2+-induced permeability increase of the outer membrane allowed reconstitution of maltose transport in a mutant missing the maltose-binding protein with osmotic shock fluid containing the maltose-binding protein. Even though Ca2+-treatment allowed the entry of large molecules, the release of the periplasmic maltose-binding protein or alkaline phosphatase was negligible.     

A requirement for calcium in the transport of cobalamin across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

Cobalamin (Cbl) transport across the outer membrane of cells of Escherichia coli consists of high affinity Cbl binding to the btuB protein of the Cbl receptor, followed by the proton motive force- and tonB-dependent release of the Cbl into the periplasmic space. During a search for experimental conditions that would mimic this release in vitro with isolated cell envelope particles, we found that calcium was required for the high affinity Cbl binding, and subsaturating calcium concentrations resulted in the decreased affinity of the Cbl receptor for Cbl. The apparent affinity of the Cbl receptor for calcium (KD, approximately 30 nM at pH 6.6) decreased with decreasing pH, resulting in decreased affinity for Cbl at lower pH values. With suboptimal levels of calcium, Cbl binding was decreased by millimolar levels of magnesium.     

Relationship between the tonB locus and iron transport in Escherichia coli.

When a strain (arcB-) of Escherichia coli, unable to synthesize the iron transport compound enterochelin, was transduced to tonB-, it became resistant to phage phi80 and simultaneously lost the growth response to enterochelin and the ability to transport its iron complex. However, enterochelin precursors (shikimate and 2,3-dihydroxybenzoate) still supported growth, via the synthesis of enterochelin. Dihydroxybenzoate was a better growth factor at a low concentration than it was at higher levels. The evidence suggests that tonB- strains lack an outer membrane component necessary both for the uptake of ferric-enterochelin and for the adsorption of phage phi80. Thus, although ferric-enterochelin cannot penetrate the cell surface from outside, the complex that is formed within the envelope is transported normally into the cell. The aroB-, tonB- mutant also lacked growth reponses to citrate and various hydroxamate siderochromes, which supported growth in the tonB+ parent strain via inducible transport systems for their ferric complexes. The aroB-, tonB- mutant was unable to transport iron in the presence of citrate, but the low-affinity uptake of uncomplexed iron and the transport of amino acids and phosphate were unimpaired. The tonB locus, thus, affects all the known active transport systems for iron, possibly indicating that they share some common outer membrane component.     

Energy-coupled colicin transport through the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K-12: mutated TonB proteins alter receptor activities and colicin uptake

Abstract The current model of TonB-dependent colicin transport through the outer membrane of Escherichia coli proposes initial binding to receptor proteins, vectorial release from the receptors and uptake into the periplasm from where the colicins, according to their action, insert into the cytoplasmic membrane or enter the cytoplasm. The uptake is energy-dependent and the TonB protein interacts with the receptors as well as with the colicins. In this paper we have studied the uptake of colicins B and Ia, both pore-forming colicins, into various tonB point mutants. Colicin Ia resistance of the tonB mutant (G186D, R204H) was consistent with a defective Cir receptor-TonB interaction while colicin Ia resistance of E. coli expressing TonB of Serratia marcescens , or TonB of E. coli carrying a C-terminal fragment of the S. marcescens TonB, seemed to be caused by an impaired colicin Ia-TonB interaction. In contrast, E. coli tonB (G174R, V178I) was sensitive to colicin Ia and resistant to colicin B unless TonB, ExbB and ExbD were overproduced which resulted in colicin B sensitivity. The differential effects of tonB mutations indicate differences in the interaction of TonB with receptors and colicins.     

Involvement of outer membrane proteins in enterochelin-mediated iron uptake in Escherichia coli.

Escherichia coli K-12 grown in iron-deficient media contained a large amount of outer membrane proteins O-2a, O-2b, and O-3, while cells grown in iron-supplemented media contained far smaller amounts of these proteins. The iron uptake by the iron-deficient cells was significantly stimulated in the presence of enterochelin, while that by the iron-rich cells was not. The outer membrane isolated from cells grown in the iron-deficient media showed enterochelin-stimulated binding of iron, while the outer membrane from iron-rich cells and cytoplasmic membranes from both types of cells did not show such binding activity. The amount of iron bound by the outer membrane was almost equivalent to the amount of O-2a, O2b, or O-3, irrespective of the amount of these proteins in the outer membrane, which is controlled by the amount of iron in the medium. Small particles rich in these proteins were prepared from cells by EDTA extraction. The particles were active in enterochelin-mediated iron binding and the amount of iron bound was equivalent to the amount of each of these proteins in the particles. Although the outer membrane of E. coli B was as active in iron binding as that of E. coli K-12, it did not possess an appreciable amount of O-2a. Gel electrophoretic analysis revealed that 9-2b and 9-3 were identical with the proteins missing mutants feuB and feuA, respectively.     

Observations on the calcium dependence and reversibility of cobalamin transport across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli

The calcium dependence of cobalamin (Cbl) binding to the BtuB protein of Escherichia coli and the reversibility of its function in the transport of Cbl across the outer membrane have been examined. The results show that the two calcium-binding sites in BtuB that were identified previously by others are responsible for the calcium dependence of high affinity Cbl binding. The affinity of the pure BtuB protein for Cbl was approximately 1000-fold higher in the presence of saturating levels of calcium than in its absence. The affinities of BtuB for both Cbl and calcium were decreased by insertion of alanine residues at position 51 of the mature protein and were increased by several mutations and deletions in the TonB box. Experiments on the uptake of Cbl into the periplasmic space showed that this process is reversible and that the exit of Cbl back into the medium does not require the protonmotive force. Our interpretation of these results is that the role of the TonB-ExbB-ExbD complex, potentiated by the protonmotive force, is to reduce the affinity of the Cbl-binding site, thus increasing the rate of Cbl release into the periplasmic space. The evidence also indicates that access of the Cbl-binding site of BtuB to the periplasmic space does not require removal of the hatch domain from the barrel.     

Involvement of inner and outer membrane components in the transport of iron and in colicin B action in Escherichia coli.

Spheroplasts of Escherichia coli mutants were used to investigate the roles of the inner and outer membranes in the transport of iron. tonA mutants, known to be defective in an outer membrane component of the ferrichrome transport system, regained the ability to transport ferrichrome when converted to spheroplasts. On the other hand, the tonB mutant was unable to transport ferric enterochelin in either whole cells or spheroplasts. This implies that an element of the inner membrane is affected. fep mutants were also unable to transport ferric enterochelin, and fell into two classes, fepA and fepB. Spheroplasts of the former class transported ferric enterochelin, and those of the latter did not. This implies that the fepA mutants are defective in ferric enterochelin transport across the outer membrane, and that fepB mutants probably lack the facility to transport ferric enterochelin across the inner membrane. Colicin B action on fepA mutants was found to differ from that on fepB mutants.