Competition between solution and cell surface receptors for ligand. Dissociation of hapten bound to surface antibody in the presence of solution antibody.

We present a joint theoretical and experimental study on the effects of competition for ligand between receptors in solution and receptors on cell surfaces. We focus on the following experiment. After ligand and cell surface receptors equilibrate, solution receptors are introduced, and the dissociation of surface bound ligand is monitored. We derive theoretical expressions for the dissociation rate and compare with experiment. In a standard dissociation experiment (no solution receptors present) dissociation may be slowed by rebinding, i.e., at high receptor densities a ligand that dissociates from one receptor may rebind to other receptors before separating from the cell. Our theory predicts that rebinding will be prevented when S much greater than N2Kon/(16 pi 2D a4), where S is the free receptor site concentration in solution, N the number of free surface receptor sites per cell, Kon the forward rate constant for ligand-receptor binding in solution, D the diffusion coefficient of the ligand, and a the cell radius. The predicted concentration of solution receptors needed to prevent rebinding is proportional to the square of the cell surface receptor density. The experimental system used in these studies consists of a monovalent ligand, 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP)-aminocaproyl-L-tyrosine (DCT), that reversibly binds to a monoclonal anti-DNP immunoglobulin E (IgE). This IgE is both a solution receptor and, when anchored to its high affinity Fc epsilon receptor on rat basophilic leukemia (RBL) cells, a surface receptor. For RBL cells with 6 x 10(5) binding sites per cell, our theory predicts that to prevent DCT rebinding to cell surface IgE during dissociation requires S much greater than 2,400 nM. We show that for S = 200-1,700 nM, the dissociation rate of DCT from surface IgE is substantially slower than from solution IgE where no rebinding occurs. Other predictions are also tested and shown to be consistent with experiment.     

N-formyl peptide receptors cluster in an active raft-associated state prior to phosphorylation

In response to ligand binding, G protein-coupled receptors undergo phosphorylation and activate cellular internalization machinery. An important component of this process is the concentration of receptors into clusters on the plasma membrane. Aside from organizing the receptor in anticipation of internalization, little is known of the function of ligand-mediated G protein-coupled receptor clustering, which has traditionally been thought of as being a phosphorylation-dependent event prior to receptor internalization. We now report that following receptor activation, the N-formyl peptide receptor (FPR) forms distinct membrane clusters prior to its association with arrestin. To determine whether this clustering is dependent upon receptor phosphorylation, we used a mutant form of the FPR, DeltaST-FPR, which lacks all phosphorylation sites in the carboxyl-terminal domain. We found that activation of the signaling-competent DeltaST-FPR resulted in rapid receptor clustering on the plasma membrane independent of Gi protein activation. This clustering required receptor activation since the D71A mutant receptor, which binds ligand but is incapable of transitioning to an active state, failed to induce receptor clustering. Furthermore we demonstrated that FPR-mediated clustering and signaling were cholesterol-dependent processes, suggesting that translocation of the active receptor to lipid rafts may be required for maximal signaling activity. Finally we showed that FPR stimulation in the absence of receptor phosphorylation resulted in translocation of FPR to GM1-rich clusters. Our results demonstrate for the first time that formation of a clustered activated receptor state precedes receptor phosphorylation, arrestin binding, and internalization.     

Localization of receptors in lipid rafts can inhibit signal transduction

Processes of cell survival, division, differentiation, and death are guided by the binding of signal molecules to receptors, which activates intracellular signaling networks and ultimately elicits genetic, biochemical, or biomechanical responses within the cell. While intracellular mechanisms for these processes have been well studied, little attention has been given to the role extracellular ligand transport and binding may play in signal initiation. Recent studies have found that the localization of receptors in lipid rafts is critical for the functions of many signaling pathways. By concentrating membrane components, rafts may promote essential interactions for signaling. Lipid rafts can also have negative effects on signaling, but mechanisms remain elusive. We propose that raft-mediated receptor clustering can reduce signaling by prolonging the diffusion of ligands to their receptors. We quantify this effect using a simple diffusion-limited binding model that accounts for the spatial distribution of lipid rafts and receptors on the cell surface. We find that receptor clustering can reduce the apparent rate of receptor binding by up to 80%, consistent with observed increases in epidermal growth factor (EGF) binding by up to 100% following disruption of lipid rafts (Pike and Casey 2002 Biochemistry 41:10315-10322; Roepstorff et al. 2002 J Biol Chem 277:18954-18960). Failure to account for the effects of receptor clustering on rates of ligand binding can skew the interpretation of current methods of cancer diagnosis and treatment. Finally, we discuss how the activation of particular signaling pathways can change over time, depending, in part, on the overall level and spatial distribution of the receptors.     

Cytoskeleton-mediated death receptor and ligand concentration in lipid rafts forms apoptosis-promoting clusters in cancer chemotherapy

While investigating the mechanism of action of the novel antitumor drug Aplidin, we have discovered a potent and novel cell-killing mechanism that involves the formation of Fas/CD95-driven scaffolds in membrane raft clusters housing death receptors and apoptosis-related molecules. Fas, tumor necrosis factor-receptor 1, and tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosis-inducing ligand receptor 2/death receptor 5 were clustered into lipid rafts in leukemic Jurkat cells following Aplidin treatment, the presence of Fas being essential for apoptosis. Preformed membrane-bound Fas ligand (FasL) as well as downstream signaling molecules, including Fas-associated death domain-containing protein, procaspase-8, procaspase-10, c-Jun amino-terminal kinase, and Bid, were also translocated into lipid rafts, connecting death receptor extrinsic and mitochondrial intrinsic apoptotic pathways. Blocking Fas/FasL interaction partially inhibited Aplidin-induced apoptosis. Aplidin was rapidly incorporated into membrane rafts, and drug uptake was inhibited by lipid raft disruption. Actin-linking proteins ezrin, moesin, RhoA, and RhoGDI were conveyed into Fas-enriched rafts in drug-treated leukemic cells. Disruption of lipid rafts and interference with actin cytoskeleton prevented Fas clustering and apoptosis. Thus, Aplidin-induced apoptosis involves Fas activation in both a FasL-independent way and, following Fas/FasL interaction, an autocrine way through the concentration of Fas, membrane-bound FasL, and signaling molecules in membrane rafts. These data indicate a major role of actin cytoskeleton in the formation of Fas caps and highlight the crucial role of the clusters of apoptotic signaling molecule-enriched rafts in apoptosis, acting as concentrators of death receptors and downstream signaling molecules and as the linchpin from which a potent death signal is launched.     

Monte Carlo simulations of receptor dynamics: Insights into cell signaling

Many receptor-level processes involve the diffusion and reaction of receptors with other membrane-localized molecules. Monte Carlo simulation is a powerful technique that allows us to track the motions and discrete reactions of individual receptors, thus simulating receptor dynamics and the early events of signal transduction. In this paper, we discuss simulations of two receptor processes, receptor dimerization and G-protein activation. Our first set of simulations demonstrates how receptor dimerization can create clusters of receptors via partner switching and the relevance of this clustering for receptor cross-talk and integrin signaling. Our second set of simulations investigates the activation and desensitization of G-protein coupled receptors when either a single agonist or both an agonist and an antagonist are present. For G-protein coupled receptor systems in the presence of an agonist alone, the dissociation rate constant of agonist is predicted to affect the ratio of G-protein activation to receptor phosphorylation. Similarly, this ratio is affected by the antagonist dissociation rate constant when both agonist and antagonist are present. The relationship of simulation predictions to experimental findings and potential applications of our findings are also discussed.     

The kinetics of FGF-2 binding to heparan sulfate proteoglycans and MAP kinase signaling

Binding of growth factors to specific cell surface receptors is the first step in initiating cell signaling cascades that ultimately result in diverse activities such as proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis. Dimerization and phosphorylation of tyrosine kinase transmembrane receptors is the typical paradigm for this activation but, for many growth factors, cell surface interactions are not limited to a single receptor type. In particular, heparin-binding growth factors, such as fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF-2), bind to heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG) on the cell surface and within the extracellular matrix (ECM), and these molecules have been viewed as accessory co-receptors serving to facilitate tyrosine kinase receptor binding. Recent studies, however, have indicated that HSPG can directly participate in signal transduction in response to FGF-2 binding. Thus, in the present study, we used mathematical modeling to examine whether the kinetics of formation of the various FGF-2 bound complexes on the cell surface correlate with the activation of the downstream mediators of FGF-2 response, Erk1/2. We find that FGF-2 binding to its receptor correlates well with Erk1/2 activation and that HSPG can modulate this response through its ability to stabilize these ligand receptor complexes. Moreover, we also observed that FGF-2 binding to HSPG correlates strongly with Erk1/2 activation under conditions where there is a loss of receptor activity, and we demonstrate that the relative amounts of signaling and non-signaling HSPG on the cell surface, as well as the presence of competing HSPG in the ECM, can impact the signal potential via this pathway. Thus, the selective regulation of specific HSPG might provide a mechanism for fine tuned modulation of heparin-binding growth factor signaling in cells where signal intensity and duration could direct cellular response toward growth, migration or differentiation.     

Exclusion of lipid rafts and decreased mobility of CD94/NKG2A receptors at the inhibitory NK cell synapse

CD94/NKG2A is an inhibitory receptor expressed by most human natural killer (NK) cells and a subset of T cells that recognizes human leukocyte antigen E (HLA-E) on potential target cells. To elucidate the cell surface dynamics of CD94/NKG2A receptors, we have expressed CD94/NKG2A-EGFP receptors in the rat basophilic leukemia (RBL) cell line. Photobleaching experiments revealed that CD94/NKG2A-EGFP receptors move freely within the plasma membrane and accumulate at the site of contact with ligand. The enriched CD94/NKG2A-EGFP is markedly less mobile than the nonligated receptor. We observed that not only are lipid rafts not required for receptor polarization, they are excluded from the site of receptor contact with the ligand. Furthermore, the lipid raft patches normally observed at the sites where FcepsilonR1 activation receptors are cross-linked were not observed when CD94/NKG2A was coengaged along with the activation receptor. These results suggest that immobilization of the CD94/NKG2A receptors at ligation sites not only promote sustenance of the inhibitory signal, but by lipid rafts exclusion prevent formation of activation signaling complexes.     

Self-consistent theory of reversible ligand binding to a spherical cell

Ligand binding to receptors is the initial event in many signaling processes, and a quantitative understanding of this interaction is important for modeling cell behavior. In this paper, we study the kinetics of reversible ligand binding to receptors on a spherical cell surface using a self-consistent stochastic theory. Binding, dissociation, diffusion and rebinding of ligands are incorporated into the theory in a systematic manner. We derive explicitly the time evolution of the ligand-bound receptor fraction p(t) in various regimes. Contrary to the commonly accepted view, we find that the well-known Berg-Purcell scaling for the association rate is modified as a function of time. Specifically, the effective on-rate changes non-monotonically as a function of time and equals the intrinsic rate at very early as well as late times, while being approximately equal to the Berg-Purcell value at intermediate times. The effective dissociation rate, as it appears in the binding curve or measured in a dissociation experiment, is strongly modified by rebinding events and assumes the Berg-Purcell value except at very late times, where the decay is algebraic and not exponential. In equilibrium, the ligand concentration everywhere in the solution is the same and equals its spatial mean, thus ensuring that there is no depletion in the vicinity of the cell. Implications of our results for binding experiments and numerical simulations of ligand-receptor systems are also discussed.     

Intracellular segregation of asialoglycoproteins and their receptor: a prelysosomal event subsequent to dissociation of the ligand-receptor complex

Rat hepatocytes in monolayer culture rapidly internalized asialoglycoproteins and the receptors to which they are bound. Subsequent to endocytosis, the receptor-ligand complex is dissociated within an acidic endosome (Harford, J., K. Bridges, G. Ashwell, and R. D. Klausner, 1983, J. Biol. Chem. 258:3191-3197; Harford, J., A. W. Wolkoff, G. Ashwell, and R. D. Klausner, 1983, J. Cell Biol. 96:1824- 1828). Here we show that addition of the proton ionophore monensin to the cells after dissociation has occurred results in intracellular rebinding of ligand molecules. With increasing time inside the cell, the ability of ligand to reassociate with receptor progressively decreases consistent with a segregation of receptor and ligand. The combination of colchicine and cytochalasin B appears to retard the process of segregation. In contrast, removal of sodium from the medium, while inhibiting degradation of ligand, does not affect the decrease in monensin-mediated rebinding. Nonetheless, both sodium deprivation and treatment with colchicine plus cytochalasin B result in the ligand remaining in a low density, nonlysosomal subcellular fraction. Thus, segregation, like dissociation, appears to occur in a pre-lysosomal endocytic compartment. Perturbation of the endocytic pathway by reduced temperature (18 degrees C) was also explored. Our data are consistent with two temperature-sensitive steps: receptor-ligand dissociation is inhibited and there is an independent temperature-sensitive step involved in delivery of ligand to lysosomes. This second effect was localized as being beyond the point in the pathway sensitive to sodium deprivation.     

Membrane sorting of toll-like receptor (TLR)-2/6 and TLR2/1 heterodimers at the cell surface determines heterotypic associations with CD36 and intracellular targeting

Toll-like receptors (TLRs) are receptors of the innate immune system responsible for recognizing pathogen-associated molecular patterns. TLR2 seems to be the most promiscuous TLR receptor able to recognize the most diverse set of pathogen-associated patterns. Its promiscuity has been attributed to its unique ability to heterodimerize with TLRs 1 and 6 and, most recently, to its association with CD36 in response to diacylated lipoproteins. Thus, it seems that TLR2 forms receptor clusters in response to different microbial ligands. In this study we investigated TLR2 cell surface heterotypic interactions in response to different ligands as well as internalization and intracellular trafficking. Our data show that TLR2 forms heterodimers with TLR1 and TLR6 and that these heterodimer pre-exist and are not induced by the ligand. Upon stimulation by the specific ligand, these heterodimers are recruited within lipid rafts. In contrast, heterotypic associations of TLR2/6 with CD36 are not preformed and are ligand-induced. All TLR2 receptor clusters accumulate in lipid rafts and are targeted to the Golgi apparatus. This localization and targeting is ligand-specific. Activation occurs at the cell surface, and the observed trafficking is independent of signaling.     

Impact of receptor clustering on ligand binding

Background  

Cellular response to changes in the concentration of different chemical species in the extracellular medium is induced by ligand binding to dedicated transmembrane receptors. Receptor density, distribution, and clustering may be key spatial features that influence effective and proper physical and biochemical cellular responses to many regulatory signals. Classical equations describing this kind of binding kinetics assume the distributions of interacting species to be homogeneous, neglecting by doing so the impact of clustering. As there is experimental evidence that receptors tend to group in clusters inside membrane domains, we investigated the effects of receptor clustering on cellular receptor ligand binding.     

Concentration sensing in crowded environments

Signal transduction within crowded cellular compartments is essential for the physiological function of cells. Although the accuracy with which receptors can probe the concentration of ligands has been thoroughly investigated in dilute systems, the effect of macromolecular crowding on the inference of concentration remains unclear. In this work, we develop an algorithm to simulate reversible reactions between reacting Brownian particles. Our algorithm facilitates the calculation of reaction rates and correlation times for ligand-receptor systems in the presence of macromolecular crowding. Using this method, we show that it is possible for crowding to increase the accuracy of estimated ligand concentration based on receptor occupancy. In particular, we find that crowding can enhance the effective association rates between small ligands and receptors to a degree sufficient to overcome the increased chance of rebinding due to caging by crowding molecules. For larger ligands, crowding decreases the accuracy of the receptor’s estimate primarily by decreasing the microscopic association and dissociation rates.     

Aggregation of IgE-receptor complexes on rat basophilic leukemia cells does not change the intrinsic affinity but can alter the kinetics of the ligand-IgE interaction.

The aggregation of IgE anchored to high-affinity Fc epsilon receptors on rat basophilic leukemia (RBL) cells by multivalent antigens initiates transmembrane signaling and ultimately cellular degranulation. Previous studies have shown that the rate of dissociation of bivalent and multivalent DNP ligands from RBL cells sensitized with anti-DNP IgE decreases with increasing ligand incubation times. One mechanism proposed for this effect is that when IgE molecules are aggregated, a conformational change occurs that results in an increase in the intrinsic affinity of IgE for antigen. This possibility was tested by measuring the equilibrium constant for the binding of monovalent DNP-lysine to anti-DNP IgE under two conditions, where the cell-bound IgE is dispersed and where it has been aggregated into visible patches on the cell surface using anti-IgE and a secondary antibody. No difference in the equilibrium constant in these two cases was observed. We also measured the rate of dissociation of a monovalent ligand from cell surface IgE under these two conditions. Whereas the affinity for monovalent ligand is not altered by IgE aggregation, we observe that the rate of ligand dissociation from IgE in clusters is slower than the rate of ligand dissociation from unaggregated IgE. These results are discussed in terms of recent theoretical developments concerning effects of receptor density on ligand binding to cell surfaces.     

Forward rate constants for receptor clusters. Variational methods for upper and lower bounds

We are interested in the effect of receptor clustering on k+, the diffusion-limited forward rate constant for the binding of a ligand to a cell surface receptor. Here we estimate the reduction in k+ when receptors are clustered in various configurations. We obtain two alternative expressions for the flux of ligands into receptors distributed on a surface. Next we show through a variational principle that these provide both upper and lower bounds on the flux when evaluated for trial concentration functions which satisfy only the boundary conditions of the Laplace equation. We use an analogy with electrostatics to calculate rigorous bounds within approx. 10% of the exact result for a variety of planar clusters of hemispherical receptor sites. We also obtain an exact result for the flux into a spheroidal receptor and use this result to obtain bounds on the flux into certain receptor clusters.     

CD14 signalling in lipid rafts: new ligands and co-receptors

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Lipid rafts on monocytes/macrophages provide a dynamic microenvironment for an integrated lipopolysaccharide receptor (CD14)-dependent clustering of a set of receptors involved in innate immunity and clearance of atherogenic lipoproteins. The purpose of this review is to summarize the recent advances in our understanding of CD14-dependent receptor clustering and its relevance in atherogenesis. RECENT FINDINGS: Upon binding of various ligands, CD14 as a multiligand pattern recognition receptor induces specific coassembly of additional receptors present on circulating monocytes. SUMMARY: The composition of the receptor cluster and thus the associated signalling pathways defines a ligand specific cellular response, linking endogenous and exogenous host defense to a common recognition platform in rafts.     

The influence of cell surface receptor clustering on the thermodynamics of ligand binding and the kinetics of its dissociation.

We show that an equilibrium model for the clustering, by divalent ligand, of homogeneous plasma membrane-bound divalent receptors that do not change conformation predicts Scatchard plots with positive second derivatives (concave up). The result is thermodynamically indistinguishable from predictions based upon receptors that are heterogeneous for ligand, or that change conformation in a negatively cooperative way when ligand binds. A more general formulation of the theory, which allows application to dissociation kinetics, predicts that the dissociation of labeled ligand is accelerated in the presence of excess cold ligand and, moreover, that the accelerated dissociation has at least two components. The theory is briefly illustrated by fitting five different sets of data, at several temperatures for two different systems, with parameter values that are well within physically meaningful ranges. The model presented is the simplest and least ad hoc explanation thus far proposed as the basis for the kinetic phenomena, and raises the possibility that the numerous experiments in which such data are observed are primarily minifestations of cell surface clustering.     

Role of FGFs in skeletal muscle and limb development

Fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) are a family of nine proteins that bind to three distinct types of cell surface molecules: (i) FGF receptor tyrosine kinases (FGFR-1 through FGFR-4); (ii) a cysteine-rich FGF receptor (CFR); and (iii) heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPGs). Signaling by FGFs requires participation of at least two of these receptors: the FGFRs and HSPGs form a signaling complex. The length and sulfation pattern of the heparan sulfate chain determines both the activity of the signaling complex and, in part, the ligand specificity for FGFR-1. Thus, the heparan sulfate proteoglycans are likely to play an essential role in signaling. We have recently identified a role for FGF in limb bud development in vivo. In the chick limb bud, ectopic expression of the 18 kDa form of FGF-2 or FGF-2 fused to an artificial signal peptide at its amino terminus causes skeletal duplications. These data, and the observations that FGF-2 is localized to the subjacent mesoderm and the apical ectodermal ridge in the early developing limb, suggest that FGF-2 plays an important role in limb outgrowth. We propose that FGF-2 is an apical ectodermal ridgederived factor that participates in limb outgrowth and patterning. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Raft coalescence and FcγRIIA activation upon sphingomyelin clustering induced by lysenin

Activation of immunoreceptor FcγRIIA by cross-linking with antibodies is accompanied by coalescence of sphingolipid/cholesterol-rich membrane rafts leading to the formation of signaling platforms of the receptor. In this report we examined whether clustering of the raft lipid sphingomyelin can reciprocally induce partition of FcγRIIA to rafts. To induce sphingomyelin clustering, cells were exposed to non-lytic concentrations of GST-lysenin which specifically recognizes sphingomyelin. The lysenin/sphingomyelin complexes formed microscale assemblies composed of GST-lysenin oligomers engaging sphingomyelin of rafts. Upon sphingomyelin clustering, non-cross-linked FcγRIIA associated with raft-derived detergent-resistant membrane fractions as revealed by density gradient centrifugation. Pretreatment of cells with GST-lysenin also increased the size of detergent-insoluble molecular complexes of activated FcγRIIA. Sphingomyelin clustering triggered tyrosine phosphorylation of the receptor and its accompanying proteins, Cbl and NTAL, in the absence of receptor ligands and enhanced phosphorylation of these proteins in the ligand presence. These data indicate that clustering of plasma membrane sphingomyelin induces coalescence of rafts and triggers signaling events analogous to those caused by FcγRIIA activation.     

Lipid rafts regulate cellular CD40 receptor localization in vascular endothelial cells

Cholesterol enriched lipid rafts are considered to function as platforms involved in the regulation of membrane receptor signaling complex through the clustering of signaling molecules. In this study, we tested whether these specialized membrane microdomains affect CD40 localization in vitro and in vivo. Here, we provide evidence that upon CD40 ligand stimulation, endogenous and exogenous CD40 receptor is rapidly mobilized into lipid rafts compared with unstimulated HAECs. Efficient binding between CD40L and CD40 receptor also increases amounts of CD40 protein levels in lipid rafts. Deficiency of intracellular conserved C terminus of the CD40 cytoplasmic tail impairs CD40 partitioning in raft. Raft disorganization after methyl-beta-cyclodextrin treatment diminishes CD40 localization into rafts. In vivo studies show that elevation of circulating cholesterol in high-cholesterol fed rabbits increases the cholesterol content and CD40 receptor localization in lipid rafts. These findings identify a physiological role for membrane lipid rafts as a critical regulator of CD40-mediated signal transduction and raise the possibility that certain pathologic conditions may be treated by altering CD40 signaling with drugs affecting its raft localization.