A critical assessment of the use of lipophilic cations as membrane potential probes

A critical review has been made of the literature on the use of lipophilic cations, such as triphenylmethyl phosphonium (TPMP⁺) as membrane potential probes in prokaryotes, uekaryote organelles in vitro, and eukaryote cells. An ideal lipophilic cation should be capable of penetrating through a biological membrane and obey the Nernst equation between a membrane bound phase and its environment. Many different forms of the Nernst equation are presented, useful in the calculation equilibrium potentials of lipophilic cations across membranes. Lipophilic cations appear to behave as valid membrane potential probes in prokaryotes and eukaryote organelles in vitro and even in vivo although some technical difficulties may be involved. On the other hand in valid forms of the Nernst equation have often been used to calculate the equilibrium potential of lipophilic cations across the plasma membranes of eukaryotic cells. In particular, the problem of intracellular compartmentation of lipophilic cations has often not been appreciated. Lipophilic cations do not appear to behave as reliable plasma membrane potential probes in eukaryotic cells. Some other avenues are discussed which might be useful in the determination of the plasma membrane potentials of small eukaryotic cells, e.g. the use of lipophilic anions as membrane potential probes.     

Fluorescent probes for bioimaging applications

Fluorescent probes based on small organic molecules have become indispensable tools in modern biology because they provide dynamic information concerning the localization and quantity of the molecules of interest, without the need of genetic engineering of the sample. In this review, following a brief outline of the principle of fluorescence imaging, we recount some recent achievements in the field of small-molecular fluorescent probes. First, probes for metal cations, including those suitable for two-photon imaging, are introduced. Next, methodologies to visualize proteases are discussed, with special emphasis on activity-based probes for use in vivo. All these probes have been confirmed to be applicable to cellular or in vivo imaging.     

Reactivity of essential thiols of myosin. Chemical probes of the activated state.

14C-Labeled fluorodinitrobenzene and N-ethylmaleimide have been used as chemical probes of the conformational states of myosin induced by the binding of MgADP and MgATP. The results indicate that in the high-energy conformation, MMgADP-Pi, the essential thiols are protected from modification but their diminished reactivity does not result from depletion of the reagent by reaction at nonessential thiols. The binding of MgADP to myosin exposes the essential thiols as reflected by an increased rate of their modification. The influence of the divalent cations Mg2+ and Ca2+ on the conformation of the M species has also been investigated. By monitoring the incorporation of fluorodinitrobenzene, the conformations of the M state in the presence of these cations can be clearly discerned.     

Effects of aluminum and other cations on the structure of brain and liver chromatin

The reactivity of aluminum and several other divalent and trivalent metallic cations toward chromatin from rat brain and liver has been investigated. Two criteria are used to determine the relative reactivity of these cations toward chromatin. The first involves the ability of the ions to compact the chromatin fibers to the point where chromatin precipitates. The second criterion measures the ability of cations to interfere with the accessibility of exogenous structural probes (nucleases) to chromatin. Of the divalent cations tested, nickel, cobalt, zinc, cadmium, and mercury were the most reactive toward chromatin, on the basis of their ability to induce precipitation of chromatin in the micromolar concentration range. The divalent cations magnesium, calcium, copper, strontium, and barium were much less effective, although all cations precipitate chromatin if their concentration is increased. Of the trivalent cations tested, aluminum, indium, and gallium were very effective precipitants, whereas iron and scandium were without effect at the concentrations tested. Of all the cations tested, aluminum was the most reactive. Aluminum's ability to alter the structure of chromatin was investigated further by testing its ability to interfere with nuclease accessibility. This test confirmed that aluminum does induce considerable changes in chromatin structure at micromolar concentrations. Furthermore, chromatin from cortical areas of the brain was much more sensitive to aluminum than chromatin from liver. These results are discussed in light of the known toxicity of these cations, with particular emphasis on the possible role of aluminum in Alzheimer's disease.     

Rapid uptake of lipophilic triphenylphosphonium cations by mitochondria in vivo following intravenous injection: Implications for mitochondria-specific therapies and probes

Background

Mitochondrial dysfunction contributes to a range of pathologies, consequently there is a need to monitor mitochondrial function and to intervene pharmacologically to prevent mitochondrial damage. One approach to this is to deliver antioxidants, probes and pharmacophores to mitochondria by conjugation to the lipophilic triphenylphosphonium (TPP) cation that is taken up selectively by mitochondria driven by the membrane potential.

Conclusions

Oral administration of TPP-conjugated antioxidants protects against mitochondrial damage in vivo. However, there is also a need to deliver molecules rapidly to mitochondria to respond quickly to pathologies and for the real-time assessment of mitochondrial function.

Methods

To see if this was possible we investigated how rapidly TPP cations were taken up by mitochondria in vivo following intravenous (iv) administration.

Results

AlkylTPP cations were accumulated selectively by mitochondria within mice within 5 min of iv injection. The extent of uptake was enhanced 10–30-fold relative to simple alkylTPP cations by attaching functional groups to the TPP cation via long, hydrophobic alkyl chains. Conclusions: Mitochondria-targeted antioxidants, probes and pharmacophores can be delivered into mitochondria within minutes of iv administration.

General significance

These findings greatly extend the utility of mitochondria-targeted lipophilic cations as therapies and probes.     

二价金属离子对嵌有线粒体H~+-ATP酶的脂酶体不同层次脂质流动性的影响

本文报道用荧光偏振及顺磁共振两种方法研究Mg~(2+)及其它二价金属离子对嵌有H~+-ATP酶的脂酶体不同层次脂质流动性的影响。 (1)顺磁标记探剂5-、12-、16-氮氧基硬脂酸测定结果表明Mg~(2+)和其它二价金属离子都能降低膜脂双分子层表层的流动性。降低流动性的顺序为Mg~(2+)=Ca~(2+)>Sr~(2+)>Cd~(2+)。较深层脂则无明显变化。 (2)荧光探剂7-、12-(9-蒽酰)硬脂酸及16-(9-蒽酰)棕榈酸的测定结果也表明Mg~(2+)和其它二价金属离子降低了膜脂表层的流动性,尤以Mn~(2+)、Ca~(2+)降低流动性最显著,流动性降低的顺序为;Mn~(2+) Ca>Sr~(2+) Mg~(2+) Cd~(2+)。除Mn~(2+)、Ca~(2+)还能影响膜脂深层的流动性外,其它与对照无明显差异。     

In vitro fusion of plant Golgi membranes can be influenced by divalent cations

The fusogenic activity of plant Golgi membranes was studied in a cell-free system by assaying lipid mixing and content leakages of fluorescence probes. Golgi membranes from mung bean (Vigna radiata L.) hypocotyl cells fused to liposomes in the absence of any cytosolic proteins and nucleotides. It was demonstrated that the fusion was mediated by integral membrane protein(s), and was influenced by divalent cations (mm). Mg(2+), Ca(2+), and Mn(2+) ions enhanced the lipid mixing by reducing repulsive forces between membranes. In the content leakage assay, Mg(2+) ions also showed a stimulative effect. However, other divalent cations were inhibitory. It is suggested that the fusion system of Golgi membranes comprises at least two components: one that mediates the formation of fusion intermediates prior to pore opening, and one that mediates the subsequent processes. The latter must be sensitive to divalent cations at millimolar concentrations. The fusion of Golgi and biological membranes was induced by divalent cations. We speculated about the biological role of the fusion system studied here.     

Binding of lipophilic cations to the liposomal membrane: thermodynamic analysis

Lipophilic ions are widely used as probes for measuring membrane potentials. Since binding of the probes to the membrane interferes with the accurate estimation of the membrane potential, it is necessary to clarify the characteristics of probe binding to membranes. The present paper deals with the binding of lipophilic cations to liposomes. The results can be summarized as follows: (1) The binding of triphenylmethylphosphonium, its homologues and tetraphenylphosphonium to liposomes of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine followed the Langmuir adsorption isotherm. (2) Spin-labeled lipophilic cations were synthesized and the binding to liposomes of egg phosphatidylcholine was examined. The binding also followed the Langmuir adsorption isotherm. The dissociation constant (the concentration giving half-maximal binding), K, was independent of the temperature, indicating that the binding is entropy-driven. (3) The binding was influenced by the fluidity of the membrane. Except in the case of triphenylmethylphosphonium (TPMP+), K and A (maximum amounts of binding) increased above the transition temperature. In other words, above the phase transition temperature the binding affinity is decreased, while maximum amounts of binding are increased for all phosphoniums used except TPMP+.     

Partitioning of triphenylalkylphosphonium homologues in gel bead-immobilized liposomes: chromatographic measurement of their membrane partition coefficients

Unilamellar liposomes of small or large size, SUVs and LUVs, respectively, were stably immobilized in the highly hydrophilic Sepharose 4B or Sephacryl S-1000 gel beads as a membrane stationary phase for immobilized liposome chromatography (ILC). Lipophilic cations of triphenylmethylphosphonium and tetraphenylphosphonium (TPP+) have been used as probes of the membrane potential of cells. Interaction of TPP+ and triphenylalkylphosphonium homologues with the immobilized liposomal membranes was shown by their elution profiles on both zonal and frontal ILC. Retardation of the lipophilic cations on the liposome gel bed was increased as the hydrophobicity of the cations increased, indicating the partitioning of lipophilic cations into the hydrocarbon region of the membranes. The cations did not retard on the Sepharose or Sephacryl gel bed without liposomes, confirming that the cations only interact with the immobilized liposomes. Effects of the solute concentration, flow rate, and gel-matrix substance on the ILC were studied. The stationary phase volume of the liposomal membranes was calculated from the volume of a phospholipid molecule and the amount of the immobilized phospholipid, which allowed us to determine the membrane partition coefficient (KLM) for the lipophilic cations distributed between the aqueous mobile and membrane stationary phases. The values of KLM were generally increased with the hydrophobicity of the solutes increased, and were higher for the SUVs than for the LUVs. The ILC method described here can be applied to measure membrane partition coefficients for other lipophilic solutes (e.g., drugs).     

pH determination by pyranine: medium-related artifacts and their correction

Pyranine (8-hydroxypyrene-1,3,6-trisulfonic acid) is a water-soluble, membrane-impermeable fluorophore having fluorescent excitation and emission spectra that are highly dependent on medium pH. This combination makes it one of the most commonly used pH-sensitive fluorescent probes to monitor pH and pH changes in biochemical and biophysical research. The pK(a) of this probe is reported to be approximately 7.3, but several studies (including the current one) have shown that this value varies with medium composition. If this is not taken into account, pH determinations based on pyranine may be misleading. We found that in the presence of salts, pK(a) is shifted downward to lower values; therefore, the calculated pH is shifted upward relative to the actual pH as determined by a pH meter. This shift is a consequence of both the type and the concentration of anions and cations that form the salt. Divalent cations cause a larger upward shift in the calculated pH than do monovalent cations. Of all the salts tested, ammonium sulfate has the least effect, and calcium perchlorate has the largest effect, on the pH value calculated by pyranine. Salts are not the only species that affect the pK(a) of pyranine. The presence of the polymer polyethylene glycol (PEG) induces an effect opposite to that of salt (i.e., an upward pK(a) shift), which is expressed as pH being more acidic than that measured by a pH meter. Another nonelectrolyte, dextrose, has no such effect. The effect of both cations and anions can be explained based on their order in the Hofmeister series, whereas the effect of PEG is explained by its high water-binding capacity. Both the ions and PEG change the structure of water and its interaction with pyranine, thereby changing pyranine's apparent pK(a).     

Kinetics of sulfate uptake by yeast.

Uptake of sulfate by yeast requires the presence of a metabolic substrate and is dependent on the time during which the cells have been metabolizing in the absence of sulfate. At low concentrations of sulfate, uptake can be described by simple saturation kinetics. Uptake of sulfate is accompanied by a net proton influx of 3 H+ and an efflux of 1 K+ for each sulfate ion taken up. Divalent cations stimulate sulfate uptake at low concentrations of sulfate; the maximal rate of uptake is not significantly affected but Km is lowered. Stimulation by divalent cations shows an optimum at a cation concentration of about 4 mM. Monovalent cations are less effective, trivalent cations are more effective in stimulating sulfate uptake. The results are qualitatively in accordance with the notion, that the effect of cations is due to an effect via the surface potential.     

Nitrogenous cations as probes of permeation channels

Summary Nitrogenous cations may provide information-rich probes of cation-selective channels. Hence, for 52 nitrogenous cations we have used dilution potentials and biionic potentials to measure relative permeability coefficients (P's) across gallbladder epithelia of frog and rabbit, and have also determined the free-solution mobilities. MeasuredP's of most cations are uninfluenced by the presence of the neutral form. The main permeation pathway for most hydrophilic cations is across the tight junctions.P's decrease with molecular size and increase with number of donor protons available for hydrogen-bond formation. Selectivity isotherms have been constructed from variation inP's due to pH or due to differences among individual animals. Both types of variation are consistent with the pattern expected from variation in electrostatic field strength of cation-binding sites. The isotherms permitP's to be re-expressed in a way that largely eliminates effects of species differences in field strength. Remaining species differences inP's are well fitted by a model of steric restriction, provided that one takes into account the effect of hydrogen bonding on molecular size. Rabbit gallbladder behaves as if it has narrower permeation channels than frog gallbladder. After correction for these steric effects,P is found to increase with number of donor protonsn _H up to four protons, with a steeper slope in rabbit than in frog gallbladder, but is independent ofn _H from four to at least nine. Two groups of cations appear to permeate significantly via pathways other than tight junctions: oxycations, via polar pathways in epithelial cell membranes of rabbit but not frog gallbladder; and lipid-soluble cations, via membrane lipid.The results suggest that the cation-binding sites of gallbladder tight junction are acidic proton-acceptors that discriminate more sharply among proton donors than does water. Proton-rich solutes tend to be more permeant for two reasons: stronger binding energies to membrane proton-acceptor sites, and smaller effective size in a proton-acceptor environment. As deduced from comparisons of nitrogenous cation selectivity patterns, the permeation channel through gallbladder tight junction differs from nerve's sodium channel and artificial carriers and channels in its higher hydration and lower range of selectivity. Based on the steric analysis of nitrogenous cation permeation, one can correct alkali cation permeability coefficients for the effect of steric restriction.     

Quantitative determination of conformations of flexible molecules in solution using lanthanide ions as nuclear magnetic resonance probes: application to adenosine-5'-monophosphate

A procedure is described here whereby the conformation, of a flexible molecule in solution can be found. The method depends on the study of the nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of the molecule in the presence of perturbations due to specifically bound lanthanide cations. The magnetic perturbations are of two kinds: shifts of nuclear magnetic resonance spectral lines in the presence of cations such as Eu³⁺ and changes in relaxation rates of the nuclear magnetic resonance excitations in the presence of cations such as Gd³⁺. Suitable expressions are given for the relation between the magnitude of the perturbations and the geometry of the lanthanide complex in the absence of through-bond perturbations and for an axially symmetric system. It is proved that the spectral changes described here are not due to through-bond (contact) effects. The circumstances, in which the anisotropy of the magnetic susceptibility tensor, as seen in the nuclear magnetic resonance spectra, is of axial symmetry, are defined. The experimental systems described are of this kind. A computer program has been devised that searches for the conformations of the molecule which fit the nuclear magnetic resonance data.We outline here the principles of the method and how we have used a combination of relaxation and shift probes to obtain the conformation of adenosine-5′-monophosphate at pH 2. It is shown that a small family of closely related conformations fit the nuclear magnetic resonance data. These conformations are very similar to that of the crystal structure of AMP.     

Why fluorescent probes for endoplasmic reticulum are selective: an experimental and QSAR-modelling study

The basis of the selectivity of fluorochromes routinely used to visualize the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in live cells remains obscure. To clarify this, interactions of living cells with fluorochromes of varied physicochemical properties were analyzed experimentally and numerically using a quantitative structure activity relationship analysis (QSAR). Routine selective ER probes were found to be amphipathic, lipophilic cations with moderate-sized conjugated systems. The moderately lipophilic character permits probe uptake by passive diffusion without nonspecific accumulation in biomembranes. The moderately amphipathic character favors uptake into the ER, perhaps owing to its high concentration of zwitterionic lipid head-groups. The QSAR model rationalizes the impractical character of some ER probes mentioned in the literature, and could permit design of novel ER probes with different emission colors. The possibility of using the QSAR model as a tool to predict the accumulation of xenobiotics in the ER of living cells is illustrated by the localization of certain antipsychotic drugs in cultured cells.     

The Staphylococcal Pore-forming Leukotoxins Open Ca2+ Channels in the Membrane of Human Polymorphonuclear Neutrophils

The ability of leukotoxins secreted by Staphylococcus aureus to modify the permeability of the membrane of human polymorphonuclear neutrophils has been studied by spectrofluorometry and appropriate fluorescent probes. This family of bicomponent leukotoxins is constituted by, at least, three pairs of proteins: LukS-PV/LukF-PV, HlgA/HlgB, HlgC/HlgB. After binding of both components to the membrane, each pair induces influxes of divalent cations and ethidium in polymorphonuclear neutrophils, although with different intensities. The influx of divalent cations appears sooner than the influx of ethidium. The pathway for divalent cations is not permeable to monovalent cations (Na⁺, K⁺, ethidium⁺) and is blocked by Ca²⁺ channel inhibitors that do not block the fluxes of ethidium and monovalent cations. It is concluded that the leukotoxins bind to a receptor linked to a divalent cation-selective channel or to the channel itself which is activated. Then, the leukotoxins open a second pathway by insertion into the membrane and subsequent formation of aspecific pores allowing an influx of ethidium. Received: 8 May 1997/Revised: 22 December 1997     

Mitochondrial accumulation of a lipophilic cation conjugated to an ionisable group depends on membrane potential, pH gradient and pK a: implications for the design of mitochondrial probes and therapies

Mitochondria play key roles in a broad range of biomedical situations, consequently there is a need to direct bioactive compounds to mitochondria as both therapies and probes. A successful approach has been to target compounds to mitochondria by conjugation to lipophilic cations, such as triphenylphosphonium (TPP), which utilize the large mitochondrial membrane potential (Δψ_m, negative inside) to drive accumulation. This has proven effective both in vitro and in vivo for a range of bioactive compounds and probes. However so far only neutral appendages have been targeted to mitochondria in this way. Many bioactive functional moieties that we would like to send to mitochondria contain ionisable groups with pK _a in the range that creates an assortment of charged species under physiological conditions. To see if such ionisable compounds can also be taken up by mitochondria, we determined the general requirements for the accumulation within mitochondria of a TPP cation conjugated to a carboxylic acid or an amine. Both were taken up by energised mitochondria in response to the protonmotive force. A lipophilic TPP cation attached to a carboxylic acid was accumulated to a greater extent than a simple TPP cation due to the interaction of the weakly acidic group with the pH gradient (ΔpH). In contrast, a lipophilic TPP cation attached to an amine was accumulated less than the simple cation due to exclusion of the weakly basic group by the ΔpH. From these data we derived a simple equation that describes the uptake of lipophilic cations containing ionisable groups as a function of Δψ_m, ΔpH and pK _a. These findings may facilitate the rational design of additional mitochondrial targeted probes and therapies.     

Why fluorescent probes for endoplasmic reticulum are selective: an experimental and QSAR-modelling study

The basis of the selectivity of fluorochromes routinely used to visualize the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in live cells remains obscure. To clarify this, interactions of living cells with fluorochromes of varied physicochemical properties were analyzed experimentally and numerically using a quantitative structure activity relationship analysis (QSAR). Routine selective ER probes were found to be amphipathic, lipophilic cations with moderate-sized conjugated systems. The moderately lipophilic character permits probe uptake by passive diffusion without nonspecific accumulation in biomembranes. The moderately amphipathic character favors uptake into the ER, perhaps owing to its high concentration of zwitterionic lipid head-groups. The QSAR model rationalizes the impractical character of some ER probes mentioned in the literature, and could permit design of novel ER probes with different emission colors. The possibility of using the QSAR model as a tool to predict the accumulation of xenobiotics in the ER of living cells is illustrated by the localization of certain antipsychotic drugs in cultured cells.     

Uptake of safranine and other lipophilic cations into model membrane systems in response to a membrane potential

Lipophilic cations such as safranine and methyltriphenylphosphonium (MTPP⁺) are commonly employed to obtain measures of the membrane potential (Δψ) exhibited by energized biological membrane systems. These probes reflect the presence of Δψ (inside negative) by accumulating in the interior of the membrane bound system to achieve transmembrane distributions dictated by the Nernst equation. In this work, we characterize the ability of model membrane large unilamellar vesicle systems to accumulate safranine and other biologically active lipophilic cations in response to a K⁺ diffusion potential (interior negative) across the large unilamellar vesicle membrane. We show that safranine, MTPP⁺, chlorpromazine and vinblastine can be rapidly accumulated to achieve interior lipophilic cation concentrations which may be more than two orders of magnitude higher than exterior concentrations. In the case of safranine, for example, incubation of 2 mM safranine with large unilamellar vesicle systems exhibiting a Δψ of −100 mV or more can lead to interior safranine concentrations in excess of 120 mM. This accumulation appears to proceed as an antiport K⁺-safranine exchange process, and the optical ‘safranine response’ observed can be attributed to precipitation of the dye inside the vesicle as the interior concentrations of safranine exceeds its solubility (96 mM). These observations are discussed in terms of the utility of probes such as safranine and MTPP⁺ for determinations of Δψ as well as their implications for the equilibrium transbilayer distributions of biologically active lipophilic cations in vivo.     

Interaction of a protein, BSA, and a fluorescent probe, Mag-Indo-1, influence of EDTA and calcium on the equilibrium.

Recent findings indicate that ion-chelator probes with tetracarboxylate structure bind proteins. It was suggested that these fluorescent probes are valuable tools to gain information on protein structure through the energy transfer from tryptophans to the bound probe. Here, the binding of the fluorescent probe Mag-Indo-1 to bovine serum albumin (BSA) was investigated. Mag-Indo-1 was reported previously to serve as a probe for magnesium cations (Kd = 2.8 x 10(-4) M for zero ionic strength) which can also interact with calcium cations (Kd = 7.5 x 10(-7) M). Probe complexation with protein results in a shift of the emission fluorescence spectrum of the probe from 480 to 457 nm. We used emission fluorescence techniques to monitor this interaction. Computational resolution of the complex fluorescence spectra and a new software to test the theoretical model were developed in our laboratory. This enabled us to calculate the number of interacting sites and the dissociation constants. The fluorescent probe Mag-Indo-1 binds at a singular site with high affinity (Kd = 1.8 x 10(-7) M) to bovine serum albumin (BSA). Since proteins are known to bind several compounds unspecifically, we have studied the influence of EDTA as a competitor of the probe. Our findings suggest that the BSA binding site is identical for both Mag-Indo-1 and EDTA. We found that EDTA binds the protein with Kd = 0.4 x 10(-3) M. We studied the influence of calcium and found that Mag-Indo-1 does not bind the calcium free Apo-protein anymore.