The AAA+ superfamily of functionally diverse proteins

The AAA+ superfamily is a large and functionally diverse superfamily of NTPases that are characterized by a conserved nucleotide-binding and catalytic module, the AAA+ module. Members are involved in an astonishing range of different cellular processes, attaining this functional diversity through additions of structural motifs and modifications to the core AAA+ module.     

AAA proteins

AAA proteins have entered the molecular realm after being known primarily for their wide range of different functions. Structural studies have highlighted the organization of their constituent ATPase domains and indicate that hexamerization in combination with unfoldase activity is a common underlying feature of this ubiquitous protein family.     

ClpP: a structurally dynamic protease regulated by AAA+ proteins

Proteolysis is an important process for many aspects of bacterial physiology. Clp proteases carry out a large proportion of protein degradation in bacteria. These enzymes assemble in complexes that combine the protease ClpP and the unfoldase, ClpA or ClpX. ClpP oligomerizes as two stacked heptameric rings enclosing a central chamber containing the proteolytic sites. ClpX and ClpA assemble into hexameric rings that bind both axial surfaces of the ClpP tetradecamer forming a barrel-like complex. ClpP requires association with ClpA or ClpX to unfold and thread protein substrates through the axial pore into the inner chamber where degradation occurs. A gating mechanism regulated by the ATPase exists at the entry of the ClpP axial pore and involves the N-terminal regions of the ClpP protomers. These gating motifs are located at the axial regions of the tetradecamer but in most crystal structures they are not visible. We also lack structural information about the ClpAP or ClpXP complexes. Therefore, the structural details of how the axial gate in ClpP is regulated by the ATPases are unknown. Here, we review our current understanding of the conformational changes that ClpA or ClpX induce in ClpP to open the axial gate and increase substrate accessibility into the degradation chamber. Most of this knowledge comes from the recent crystal structures of ClpP in complex with acyldepsipeptides (ADEP) antibiotics. These small molecules are providing new insights into the gating mechanism of this protease because they imitate the interaction of ClpA/ClpX with ClpP and activate its protease activity.     

Broad yet high substrate specificity: the challenge of AAA+ proteins

AAA+ proteins remodel target substrates in an ATP-dependent manner, an activity that is of central importance for a plethora of cellular processes. While sharing a similar hexameric structure AAA+ proteins must exhibit differences in substrate recognition to fulfil their diverse biological functions. Here we describe strategies of AAA+ proteins to ensure substrate specificity. AAA domains can directly mediate substrate recognition, however, in general extra domains, added to the core AAA domain, control substrate interaction. Such extra domains may either directly recognize substrates or serve as a platform for adaptor proteins, which transfer bound substrates to their AAA+ partner proteins. The positioning of adaptor proteins in substrate recognition can enable them to control the activity of their partner proteins by coupling AAA+ protein activation to substrate availability.     

Phylogenetic analysis of AAA proteins

AAA ATPases form a large protein family with manifold cellular roles. They belong to the AAA+ superfamily of ringshaped P-loop NTPases, which exert their activity through the energy-dependent unfolding of macromolecules. Phylogenetic analyses have suggested the existence of five major clades of AAA domains (proteasome subunits, metalloproteases, domains D1 and D2 of ATPases with two AAA domains, and the MSP1/katanin/spastin group), as well as a number of deeply branching minor clades. These analyses however have been characterized by a lack of consistency in defining the boundaries of the AAA family. We have used cluster analysis to delineate unambiguously the group of AAA sequences within the AAA+ superfamily. Phylogenetic and cluster analysis of this sequence set revealed the existence of a sixth major AAA clade, comprising the mitochondrial, membrane-bound protein BCS1 and its homologues. In addition, we identified several deep branches consisting mainly of hypothetical proteins resulting from genomic projects. Analysis of the AAA N-domains provided direct support for the obtained phylogeny for most branches, but revealed some deep splits that had not been apparent from phylogenetic analysis and some unexpected similarities between distant clades. It also revealed highly degenerate D1 domains in plant MSP1 sequences and in at least one deeply branching group of hypothetical proteins (YC46), showing that AAA proteins with two ATPase domains arose at least three times independently.     

Conserved arginine residues implicated in ATP hydrolysis, nucleotide-sensing, and inter-subunit interactions in AAA and AAA+ ATPases

Arginines are a recurrent feature of the active sites and subunit interfaces of the ATPase domains of AAA and AAA+ proteins. In particular family members these residues occupy two or more, of four key sites in the vicinity of the ATP cofactor, where they transduce the chemical events of ATP binding and hydrolysis into a mechanochemical outcome. Structural and biochemical analyses have led to the proposal of molecular mechanisms in which these conserved arginines play crucial roles. Comparative studies, however, point to functional divergence for each of these conserved arginines. In this review, we will discuss what is known about these critical arginines and what can be concluded about their role in the function of AAA and AAA+ proteins.     

Motors and switches: AAA+ machines within the replisome

Clamp loaders are required to load the ring-shaped clamps that tether replicative DNA polymerases onto DNA. Recently solved crystal structures, along with a series of biochemical studies, have provided a detailed understanding of the clamp loading reaction. In particular, studies of the Escherichia coli clamp loader--an AAA+ machine--have provided insights into the architecture of clamp loaders from eukaryotes, bacteriophage T4 and archaea. Other AAA+ proteins are also involved in the initiation of DNA replication, and studies of the E. coli clamp loader indicate mechanisms by which these proteins might function.     

Altered specificity of a AAA+ protease

ClpXP, an ATP-dependent protease, degrades hundreds of different intracellular proteins. ClpX chooses substrates by binding peptide tags, typically displayed at the N or C terminus of the protein to be degraded. Here, we identify a ClpX mutant that displays a 300-fold change in substrate specificity, resulting in decreased degradation of ssrA-tagged substrates but improved degradation of proteins with other classes of degradation signals. The altered-specificity mutation occurs within "RKH" loops, which surround the entrance to the central pore of the ClpX hexamer and are highly conserved in the ClpX subfamily of AAA+ ATPases. These results support a major role for the RKH loops in substrate recognition and suggest that ClpX specificity represents an evolutionary compromise that has optimized degradation of multiple types of substrates rather than any single class.     

Structural properties of substrate proteins determine their proteolysis by the mitochondrial AAA+ protease Pim1

The protease Pim1/LON, a member of the AAA+ family of homo-oligomeric ATP-dependent proteases, is responsible for the degradation of soluble proteins in the mitochondrial matrix. To establish the molecular parameters required for the specific recognition and proteolysis of substrate proteins by Pim1, we analyzed the in organello degradation of imported reporter proteins containing different structural properties. The amino acid composition at the amino-terminal end had no major effect on the proteolysis reaction. However, proteins with an amino-terminal extension of less than 60 amino acids in front of a stably folded reporter domain were completely resistant to proteolysis by Pim1. Substrate proteins with a longer amino-terminal extension showed incomplete proteolysis, resulting in the generation of a defined degradation fragment. We conclude that Pim1-mediated protein degradation is processive and is initiated from an unstructured amino-terminal segment. Resistance to degradation and fragment formation was abolished if the folding state of the reporter domain was destabilized, indicating that Pim1 is not able to unravel folded proteins for proteolysis. We propose that the requirement for an exposed, large, non-native protein segment, in combination with a limited unfolding capability, accounts for the selectivity of the protease Pim1 for damaged or misfolded polypeptides.     

Reverse-chaperoning activity of an AAA+ protein

Speed and processivity of replicative DNA polymerases can be enhanced via coupling to a sliding clamp. Due to the closed ring shape of the clamp, a clamp loader protein, belonging to the AAA+ class of ATPases, needs to open the ring-shaped clamp before loading it to DNA. Here, we developed real-time fluorescence assays to study the clamp (PCNA) and the clamp loader (RFC) from the mesophilic archaeon Methanosarcina acetivorans. Unexpectedly, we discovered that RFC can assemble a PCNA ring from monomers in solution. A motion-based DNA polymerization assay showed that the PCNA assembled by RFC is functional. This PCNA assembly activity required the ATP-bound conformation of RFC. Our work demonstrates a reverse-chaperoning activity for an AAA+ protein that can act as a template for the assembly of another protein complex.