Bilayer balance and regulation of red cell shape changes

Discocytic human red cells undergo discocyte-echinocyte and discocytestomatocyte transformations under the action of a wide variety of lipid-soluble anionic and cationic agents respectively. These shape transformations are explained by the bilayer couple hypothesis of Sheetz and Singer to be the result of preferential distribution of the anionic agents in the outer half of the bilayer and the cationic agents in the inner half of the bilayer. We demonstrate that echinocytogenic effects indeed occur when the naturally occurring phospholipid lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) is localized in the outer half of the bilayer, and stomatocytogenic effects occur when LPC is in the inner half. However, in contrast to the bilayer couple hypothesis, our results show that simple equivalent membrane surface area expansion on each layer is insufficient to maintain the discocytic shape and there exists a differential concentration effect of LPC on the two halves of the bilayer.     

Amphiphile induced echinocyte-spheroechinocyte transformation of red blood cell shape

A possible physical explanation of the echinocyte-spheroechinocyte red blood cell (RBC) shape transformation induced by the intercalation of amphiphilic molecules into the outer layer of the RBC plasma membrane bilayer is given. The stable RBC shape is determined by the minimization of the membrane elastic energy, consisting of the bilayer bending energy, the bilayer relative stretching energy and the skeleton shear elastic energy. It is shown that for a given relative cell volume the calculated number of echinocyte spicula increases while their size decreases as the number of the intercalated amphiphilic molecules in the outer layer of the cell membrane bilayer is increased, which is in agreement with experimental observations. Further, it is shown that the equilibrium difference between the outer and the inner membrane leaflet areas of the stable RBC shapes increases if the amount of the intercalated amphiphiles is increased, thereby verifying theoretically the original bilayer couple hypothesis of Sheetz and Singer (1974) and Evans (1974). Received: 22 August 1997 / Revised version: 25 November 1997 / Accepted: 11 February 1998     

Analysis of integral membrane protein contributions to the deformability and stability of the human erythrocyte membrane

Three major hypotheses have been proposed to explain the role of membrane-spanning proteins in establishing/maintaining membrane stability. These hypotheses ascribe the essential contribution of integral membrane proteins to (i) their ability to anchor the membrane skeleton to the lipid bilayer, (ii) their capacity to bind and stabilize membrane lipids, and (iii) their ability to influence and regulate local membrane curvature. In an effort to test these hypotheses in greater detail, we have modified both the membrane skeletal and lipid binding interactions of band 3 (the major membrane-spanning and skeletal binding protein of the human erythrocyte membrane) and have examined the impact of these modifications on erythrocyte membrane morphology, deformability, and stability. The desired changes in membrane skeletal and protein-lipid interactions were induced by 1) reaction of the cells with 4,4'-diisothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (DIDS), an inhibitor of band 3-mediated anion transport that dissociates band 3 into dimers (increasing its surface area in contact with lipid) and severs band 3 linkages to the membrane skeleton; 2) a fragment of ankyrin that ruptures the same ankyrin-band 3 bridge to the membrane skeleton, but drives the band 3 subunit equilibrium toward the tetramer (i.e. decreasing the band 3 surface area in contact with lipid); and 3) an antibody to the ankyrin-binding site on band 3 that promotes the same changes in band 3 skeletal and lipid interactions as the ankyrin fragment. We observed that although DIDS induced echinocytic morphological changes in the treated erythrocytes, it had little impact on either membrane deformability or stability. In contrast, resealing of either the ankyrin fragment or anti-band 3 IgG into erythrocytes caused spontaneous membrane fragmentation and loss of deformability/stability. Because these and other new observations cannot all be reconciled with any single hypothesis on membrane stability, we suggest that more than one hypothesis may be operative and provide an explanation of how each might individually contribute to net membrane stability.     

Biological membranes as bilayer couples. III. Compensatory shape changes induced in membranes

We have previously proposed the hypothesis that asymmetric membranes behave like bilayer couples: the two layers of the bilayer membrane can respond differently to a particular perturbation. Such a perturbation, for example, can result in the expansion of one layer relative to the other, thereby producing a curvature of that membrane. In experiments with erythrocytes and lymphocytes, we now demonstrate that different membrane perturbations which have opposite effects on membrane curvature can compensate and neutralize one another, as expected from the bilayer couple hypothesis. This provides a rational basis, for example, for understanding the effects of amphipathic drugs on a variety of cellular phenomena which involve shape changes of membranes.     

Theory of cation-phospholipid-induced shape changes in a lipid bilayer couple

A quantitative model of ion binding and molecular interactions in the lipid bilayer membrane is proposed and found to be useful in examining the factors underlying such membrane characteristics as shape, sidedness, stability and vesicle size at various cation concentrations. The lipid membrane behaves as a bilayer couple whose preferential radius of curvature depends on the expansion or contraction of one monolayer relative to the other. It is proposed that molecular packing may be altered by electrostatic repulsion of adjacent like-charged phospholipid headgroups, or by bringing two headgroups closer together by divalent cation crossbridging. The surface concentrations of each type of cation-phospholipid complex can be described by simple binding equilibria and the Gouy-Chapman-Stern formulation for the surface potential in a diffuse double layer. The asymmetric distribution of acidic phospholipids in most biological membranes can account for the differential effects of identical ionic environments on either side of the bilayer. The fraction of vesicle material which tends to have a right-side-out orientation may be approximated by a normal distribution about the mean curvature. The theory generates vesicle sidedness distributions that, when fitted to experimental results from human erythrocyte membranes, provide an alternative method of estimating intrinsic cationphospholipid dissociation constants and other molecular parameters of the bilayer. The results also corroborate earlier suggestions that the Gouy-Chapman theory tends to overestimate free counter-ion concentrations at the surface under large surface potentials.     

Bending stiffness of lipid bilayers. I. Bilayer couple or single-layer bending?

To describe the resistance of a bilayer to changes in curvature two mechanisms are distinguished which are termed bilayer couple bending and single-layer bending. In bilayer couple bending, the resistance arises from the 2-D isotropic elasticity of the two layers and their fixed distance. Single-layer bending covers the intrinsic bending stiffness of each monolayer. The two mechanisms are not independent. Even so, the distinction is useful since bilayer couple bending can relax by a slip between the layers from the local to the global fashion. Therefore, the bending stiffness of a bilayer depends on the time scale and on the extent of the deformation imposed on the membrane. Based on experimental data, it is shown by order of magnitude estimates that (a) the bending stiffness determined from thermally induced shape fluctuations of almost spherical vesicles is dominated by single-layer bending; (b) in the tether experiment on lipid vesicles and on red cells, a contribution of local bilayer couple bending can not be excluded; and (c) at the sharp corners at the leading and the trailing edge of tanktreading red cells, local bilayer couple bending appears to be important.     

The influence of membrane lateral pressures on simple geometric models of protein conformational equilibria

The function of many intrinsic membrane proteins requires a conformational transition that is often strongly influenced by the molecular composition of the bilayer in which the protein is embedded. Recently, a mechanism for this shift in conformational equilibrium was suggested, in which it is argued that a shift in distribution of lateral pressures of the bilayer resulting from a change in lipid composition alters the amount of mechanical work of the protein conformational transition, if the change in the cross-sectional area profile of the protein varies with depth within the bilayer. As there is little information on the change in shape of the transmembrane region of any protein, various simple geometric models are considered. For both a generic model, and more specific models that approximate likely cooperative rearrangements of alpha-helices in bundles, it is found that the conformational equilibrium depends on the first and second integral moments of the lateral pressure distribution. In addition to revealing the possible physical underpinnings of the well-known correlation between protein activity and the 'nonlamellar' tendency of bilayer lipids, this dependence on moments of the pressure profile allows for prediction of the relative effects of different lipid compositional changes even in the absence of information on specific protein shape changes. Effects of variation in acyl chain length, degree and position of cis-unsaturation, and addition of cholesterol and small interfacially-active solutes (n-alkanols) are compared.     

Amphiphile-induced antihaemolysis is not causally related to shape changes and vesiculation.

A wide variety of structurally different antihaemolytic amphiphiles were tested for their ability to induce exovesiculation (acetylcholinesterase (AChE) release, transmission electron microscopic (TEM) studies), endovesiculation (fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugated dextran (FITC-dextran) internalization, TEM studies) and shape changes in human erythrocytes at concentrations where they exert maximum protection against hypotonic haemolysis. The results show that vesiculation is a common phenomenon induced by amphiphiles in erythrocytes. Sphero-echinocytogenic amphiphiles induced exovesiculation, whereas stomatocytogenic amphiphiles induced endovesiculation. The antihaemolytic potency of the amphiphiles was not related to their ability to induce exo- or endovesiculation, or to the type or extent of shape changes induced, and it could not be ascribed to any molecular feature of the amphiphiles or to their charge. It is proposed that amphiphiles, when intercalated into the lipid bilayer of the membrane, rapidly induce rearrangements within the bilayer and that these rearrangements are associated with an increase in the permeability of the membrane; it is suggested that a rapid efflux of ions decreases the difference in osmotic pressure between cell interior and hypotonic buffer, thereby protecting cells from being lysed.     

Conformational and orientation studies of artificial ion channels incorporated into lipid bilayers

The conformational and orientation studies in lipid bilayers of 21 amino acid peptides bearing six crown ethers are reported. The compounds were designed to form artificial ion channels by stacking the crown rings, and were shown to be functional in bilayer membranes. We used Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and CD spectropolarimetry to study the conformation of the peptides in solution and in lipid bilayers. These studies revealed that hexacrown peptides retain their alpha-helical conformation when incorporated in a lipid bilayer environment. Attenuated total reflectance spectroscopy was used to investigate the orientation of the peptides in a lipid bilayer. Results demonstrated that the peptides are not oriented at a fixed angle in membrane, but rather are in incorporation equilibrium between an active state parallel to the lipid chain and an inactive state adsorbed at the surface of the bilayer. From these results, we propose a model for the channel activity and the gating mechanism of these hexacrown peptides in bilayer membranes.     

GABA(A) receptor function is regulated by lipid bilayer elasticity

Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and other polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) promote GABA(A) receptor [(3)H]-muscimol binding, and DHA increases the rate of GABA(A) receptor desensitization. Triton X-100, a structurally unrelated amphiphile, similarly promotes [(3)H]-muscimol binding. The mechanism(s) underlying these effects are poorly understood. DHA and Triton X-100, at concentrations that affect GABA(A) receptor function, increase the elasticity of lipid bilayers measured as decreased bilayer stiffness using gramicidin channels as molecular force transducers. We have previously shown that membrane protein function can be regulated by amphiphile-induced changes in bilayer elasticity and hypothesized that GABA(A) receptors could be similarly regulated. We therefore studied the effects of four structurally unrelated amphiphiles that decrease bilayer stiffness (Triton X-100, octyl-beta-glucoside, capsaicin, and DHA) on GABA(A) receptor function in mammalian cells. All the compounds promoted GABA(A) receptor [(3)H]-muscimol binding by increasing the binding capacity of high-affinity binding without affecting the associated equilibrium binding constant. A semiquantitative analysis found a similar quantitative relation between the effects on bilayer stiffness and [(3)H]-muscimol binding. Membrane cholesterol depletion, which also decreases bilayer stiffness, similarly promoted [(3)H]-muscimol binding. In whole-cell voltage-clamp experiments, Triton X-100, octyl-beta-glucoside, capsaicin, and DHA all reduced the peak amplitude of the GABA-induced currents and increased the rate of receptor desensitization. The effects of the amphiphiles did not correlate with the expected changes in monolayer spontaneous curvature. We conclude that GABA(A) receptor function is regulated by lipid bilayer elasticity. PUFAs may generally regulate membrane protein function by affecting the elasticity of the host lipid bilayer.     

Insertion of amphiphilic molecules into membranes is catalyzed by a high molecular weight non-ionic surfactant

We have employed an amphiphilic fluorescent probe to elucidate the mechanism by which a class of oxyethylene-oxypropylene copolymers catalyzes the insertion of hydrophobic or amphiphilic molecules into membranes. The rate of binding can be accelerated by over two orders of magnitude in the presence of the catalyst which does not itself disrupt the lipid bilayer. The rate of probe binding to lipid vesicles does not depend on the lipid concentration in the presence or absence of catalyst but is linearly related to the concentration of the catalyst. Probe binding to the polyol surfactant appears to be a component of the catalytic mechanism and equilibrium binding parameters can be determined; these are used to indirectly establish quantitative binding parameters for the probe to the vesicle membrane. The polyol surfactant is also shown to catalyze insertion of the probe into the outer leaflet of a hemispherical lipid bilayer and the plasma membrane of HeLa cells. The latter were also stained by catalyzed transfer of a fluorescent lipid from lipid vesicles. The permeability of the cell membrane is not significantly altered under any of the catalytic conditions. These data, taken together, suggest that the polyol surfactant extracts a monomeric substrate molecule from its aggregate or microcrystal and passes it to the membrane via a loose and transient contact.     

Different effects of lipid chain length on the two sides of a membrane and the lipid annulus of MscL

Quenching of the fluorescence of Trp residues in a membrane protein by lipids with bromine-containing fatty acyl chains provides a powerful technique for measuring lipid-protein binding constants. Single Trp residues have been placed on the periplasmic and cytoplasmic sides of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis to measure, separately, lipid binding constants on the two faces of MscL. The chain-length dependence of lipid binding was found to be different on the two sides of MscL, the chain-length dependence being more marked on the cytoplasmic than on the periplasmic side. To determine if lipid binding constants are affected by the properties of the lipid molecules not in direct contact with MscL (the bulk lipid), the amount of bulk lipid present in the system was varied. The binding constant of the short-chain phospholipid didodecylphosphatidylcholine was found to be independent of the molar ratio of lipid/MscL pentamer over the range 500:1-50:1, suggesting that lipid binding constants are determined largely by the properties of the lipid molecules interacting directly with MscL. These results point to a model in which lipid molecules located on the transmembrane surface of a membrane protein (the annular lipid molecules), by playing a dominant role in the interaction between a membrane protein and the surrounding lipid bilayer, could effectively buffer the membrane protein from changes in the properties of the bulk lipid bilayer.     

Protein-Mediated Transformation of Lipid Vesicles into Tubular Networks

Key cellular processes are frequently accompanied by protein-facilitated shape changes in the plasma membrane. N-BAR-domain protein modules generate curvature by means of complex interactions with the membrane surface. The way they assemble and the mechanism by which they operate are largely dependent on their binding density. Although the mechanism at lower densities has recently begun to emerge, how membrane scaffolds form at high densities remains unclear. By combining electron microscopy and multiscale simulations, we show that N-BAR proteins at high densities can transform a lipid vesicle into a 3D tubular network. We show that this process is a consequence of excess adhesive energy combined with the local stiffening of the membrane, which occurs in a narrow range of mechanical properties of both the membrane and the protein. We show that lipid diffusion is significantly reduced by protein binding at this density regime and even more in areas of high Gaussian curvature, indicating a potential effect on molecular transport in cells. Finally, we reveal that the breaking of the bilayer topology is accompanied by the nematic arrangement of the protein on the surface, a structural motif that likely drives the formation of reticular structures in living cells.     

Protein-Mediated Transformation of Lipid Vesicles into Tubular Networks

Key cellular processes are frequently accompanied by protein-facilitated shape changes in the plasma membrane. N-BAR-domain protein modules generate curvature by means of complex interactions with the membrane surface. The way they assemble and the mechanism by which they operate are largely dependent on their binding density. Although the mechanism at lower densities has recently begun to emerge, how membrane scaffolds form at high densities remains unclear. By combining electron microscopy and multiscale simulations, we show that N-BAR proteins at high densities can transform a lipid vesicle into a 3D tubular network. We show that this process is a consequence of excess adhesive energy combined with the local stiffening of the membrane, which occurs in a narrow range of mechanical properties of both the membrane and the protein. We show that lipid diffusion is significantly reduced by protein binding at this density regime and even more in areas of high Gaussian curvature, indicating a potential effect on molecular transport in cells. Finally, we reveal that the breaking of the bilayer topology is accompanied by the nematic arrangement of the protein on the surface, a structural motif that likely drives the formation of reticular structures in living cells.     

Regulation of erythrocyte ghost membrane mechanical stability by chlorpromazine

Chlorpromazine (CPZ), a widely used tranquilizer, is known to induce stomatocytic shape changes in human erythrocytes. However, the effect of CPZ on membrane mechanical properties of erythrocyte membranes has not been documented. In the present study we show that CPZ induces a dose-dependent increase in mechanical stability of erythrocyte ghost membrane. Furthermore, we document that spectrin specifically binds to CPZ intercalated into inside-out vesicles depleted of all peripheral proteins. These findings imply that CPZ-induced mechanical stabilization of the erythrocyte ghost membranes may be mediated by direct binding of spectrin to the bilayer. Membrane active drugs that partition into lipid bilayer can thus induce cytoskeletal protein interactions with the membrane and modulate membrane material properties.     

Morphological changes in asymmetric erythrocyte membranes induced by electrolytes

Washed human erythrocyte membranes are made permanently leaky to cations by EDTA. These ghosts can exhibit the stomatocyte-disc-echinocyte sequence of shape changes in response to electrolytes in the medium. The changes are instantaneous and reversible. The observations can be explained on the basis of the known effects of cations on charged phospholipids together with the bilayer couple hypothesis.     

Using fluorine nuclear magnetic resonance to probe changes in the structure and dynamics of membrane-active peptides interacting with lipid bilayers

The antimicrobial peptide MSI-78 serves as a model system for studying interactions of bioactive peptides with membranes. Using a series of MSI-78 peptides that incorporate l-4,4,4-trifluoroethylglycine, a small and sensitive (19)F nuclear magnetic resonance probe, we investigated how the local structure and dynamics of the peptide change when it binds to the lipid bilayer. The fluorinated MSI-78 analogues exhibited position-specific changes in (19)F chemical shift ranging from 1.28 to -1.35 ppm upon binding to lipid bicelles. The largest upfield shifts are associated with the most hydrophobic positions in the peptide. Changes in solvent isotope effects (H(2)O/D(2)O) on (19)F chemical shifts were observed for the peptides that are consistent with the MSI-78 solvent-inaccessible hydrophobic core upon binding bicelles. Transverse relaxation measurements of the (19)F nucleus, using the Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill pulse sequence, were used to examine changes in the local mobility of MSI-78 that occur upon binding to the lipid bilayer. Positions in the hydrophobic core of peptide-membrane complex show the greatest decrease in mobility upon binding of the lipid bilayer, whereas residues that interact with lipid headgroups are more mobile. The most mobile positions are at the N- and C-termini of the peptide. These results provide support for the proposed mechanism of membrane disruption by MSI-78 and reveal new details about the dynamic changes that accompany membrane binding.     

Plasmon resonance studies of agonist/antagonist binding to the human delta-opioid receptor: new structural insights into receptor-ligand interactions

Structural changes accompanying the binding of ligands to the cloned human delta-opioid receptor immobilized in a solid-supported lipid bilayer have been investigated using coupled plasmon-waveguide resonance spectroscopy. This highly sensitive technique directly monitors mass density, conformation, and molecular orientation changes occurring in anisotropic thin films and allows direct determination of binding constants. Although both agonist binding and antagonist binding to the receptor cause increases in molecular ordering within the proteolipid membrane, only agonist binding induces an increase in thickness and molecular packing density of the membrane. This is a consequence of mass movements perpendicular to the plane of the bilayer occurring within the lipid and receptor components. These results are consistent with models of receptor function that involve changes in the orientation of transmembrane helices.     

Lipid composition and the lateral pressure profile in bilayers

The mechanisms by which variations in the lipid composition of cell membranes influence the function of membrane proteins are not yet well understood. In recent work, a nonlocal thermodynamic mechanism was suggested in which changes in lipid composition cause a redistribution of lateral pressures that in turn modulates protein conformational (or aggregation) equilibria. In the present study, results of statistical thermodynamic calculations of the equilibrium pressure profile and bilayer thickness are reported for a range of lipids and lipid mixtures. Large redistributions of lateral pressure are predicted to accompany variation in chain length, degree and position of chain unsaturation, head group repulsion, and incorporation of cholesterol and interfacially active solutes. Combinations of compositional changes are found that compensate with respect to bilayer thickness, thus eliminating effects of hydrophobic mismatch, while still effecting significant shifts of the pressure profile. It is also predicted that the effect on the pressure profile of addition of short alkanols can be reproduced with certain unnatural lipids. These results suggest possible roles of cholesterol, highly unsaturated fatty acids and small solutes in modulating membrane protein function and suggest unambiguous experimental tests of the pressure profile hypothesis. As a test of the methodology, calculated molecular areas and area elastic moduli are compared with experimental and simulation results.     

Effects of membrane lipids on ion channel structure and function

Biologic membranes are not simply inert physical barriers, but complex and dynamic environments that affect membrane protein structure and function. Residing within these environments, ion channels control the flux of ions across the membrane through conformational changes that allow transient ion flux through a central pore. These conformational changes may be modulated by changes in transmembrane electrochemical potential, the binding of small ligands or other proteins, or changes in the local lipid environment. Ion channels play fundamental roles in cellular function and, in higher eukaryotes, are the primary means of intercellular signaling, especially between excitable cells such as neurons. The focus of this review is to examine how the composition of the bilayer affects ion channel structure and function. This is an important consideration because the bilayer composition varies greatly in different cell types and in different organellar membranes. Even within a membrane, the lipid composition differs between the inner and outer leaflets, and the composition within a given leaflet is both heterogeneous and highly dynamic. Differential packing of lipids (and proteins) leads to the formation of microdomains, and lateral diffusion of these microdomains or "lipid rafts" serve as mobile platforms for the clustering and organization of bilayer constituents including ion channels. The structure and function of these channels are sensitive to specific chemical interactions with neighboring components of the membrane and also to the biophysical properties of their membrane microenvironment (e.g., fluidity, lateral pressure profile, and bilayer thickness). As specific examples, we have focused on the K+ ion channels and the ligand-gated nicotinicoid receptors, two classes of ion channels that have been well-characterized structurally and functionally. The responsiveness of these ion channels to changes in the lipid environment illustrate how ion channels, and more generally, any membrane protein, may be regulated via cellular control of membrane composition.