Clonal analysis of early mammalian development

Various extrinsic markers have been used to label single cells in the early mouse embryo. However, they are appropriate only for short-term experiments because of their susceptibility to dilution. Studies on cell lineage and commitments have therefore depended mainly on exploiting genes as markers by combining cells from embryos that differ in genotype at particular loci. Tissue recombination and transplantation experiments using such indelible intrinsic markers have enabled the fate of different cell populations in the blastocyst to be determined with reasonable precision. The trophectoderm and inner cell mass (i.c.m.) give rise to distinct complementary groups of tissues in the later conceptus, as do the primitive endodermal and primitive ectodermal components of the more mature i.c.m. When cloned by blastocyst injection, single i.c.m. cells colonize only those parts of host conceptuses that are derived from their tissue of origin. Thus, while clonal descendants of early i.c.m. cells can contribute to all tissues other than those of trophectodermal origin, primitive endodermal and primitive ectodermal clones are restricted, respectively, to the extraembryonic endoderm versus all i.c.m. derivatives except the extraembryonic endoderm. Interestingly, individual primitive ectoderm cells can include both germ cells and somatic cells among their mitotic descendants. By using the genetically determined presence versus absence of cytoplasmic malic enzyme activity as a cell marker, the deployment of clones has been made visible in situ in whole-mount preparations of extraembryonic membranes. Very little mixing of donor and host cells was seen in either the endoderm of the visceral yolk sac or the mesodermal and ectodermal layers of the amnion. In contrast, mosaicism in the parietal endoderm was so fine grained that, in all except 1 of 15 fields from several specimens that were analysed, the arrangement of donor and host cells did not differ significantly from that expected on the basis of their random association.     

Quantitative analysis of mid-gestation mouse aggregation chimaeras: non-random composition of the placenta

Mouse chimaeras were produced by aggregating eight-cell embryos from two different F₂ matings, abbreviated to AF₂ and BF₂ respectively: (C57BL/ OIa.AKR-Gpi-1s ^a, c/Ws female × BALB/c male)F₂ and (C57BL/Ws female × CBA/Ca male)F₂. Quantitative electrophoresis of glucose phosphate isomerase (GPI-1) was used to estimate the proportions of the two cell populations in different tissues of the 12 day chimàeric conceptuses, with the % GPI-1A indicating the percentage of cells derived from the AF₂ embryos. The % GPI-1A was found to be highly positively correlated within the primitive ectoderm lineage (between the fetus, amnion and yolk sac mesoderm) and within the primitive endoderm lineage (between the yolk sac endoderm and the parietal endoderm) but no correlation (either positive or negative) was seen between the two lineages. This confirms the results of a previous,study of chimaeras made between partially congenic strains and suggests the original conclusions have general validity. The % GPI-1A in the placenta was corrected for the expected contribution of maternal GPI-1, based on control experiments involving transfer of homozygous Gpi-1s ^b /Gpi-1s ^b embryos to the uteri of Gpi-1s ^a /Gpi-1s ^a pseudopregnant females. The corrected % GPI- lA in the placenta was positively correlated with that in each of the three primitive ectoderm derivatives. This suggests either (1) exchange of cells between the polar trophectoderm and the underlying part of the inner cell mass that forms the primitive ectoderm or (2) cells are incompletely mixed in the chimaeric blastocyst and patches of AF₂ and BF₂ cells straddle the boundary between the polar trophectoderm and the underlying primitive ectoderm. The second explanation does not imply the existence of shared developmental lineages between trophectoderm and primitive ectoderm in non-chimaeric embryos. Unlike that of any other tissue, the distribution of placental GPI-1A was U-shaped; in 17/28 placenta samples the proportion of the minor component was 10% or less. This suggests that the placental trophoblast is derived from a small number of coherenct clones of polar trophectoderm cells (either a small number of polar trophectoderm cells or a larger number if the two cell populations are not finely intermingled). Thus, although as a population the placentas of chimaeric conceptuses are balanced with respect to the % GPI-1A (mean close to 50%), individually most placentas are extremely unbalanced in their chimaeric composition (< 10% or > 90% GPI-IA). This non-random composition of the chimaeric placentas is in contrast to the widely held assumption that the distribution of cells in chimaeric conceptuses is normally random. Correspondence to: J.D. West     

A system to enrich for primitive streak-derivatives, definitive endoderm and mesoderm, from pluripotent cells in culture

Two lineages of endoderm develop during mammalian embryogenesis, the primitive endoderm in the pre-implantation blastocyst and the definitive endoderm at gastrulation. This complexity of endoderm cell populations is mirrored during pluripotent cell differentiation in vitro and has hindered the identification and purification of the definitive endoderm for use as a substrate for further differentiation. The aggregation and differentiation of early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, resulting in the formation of EPL-cell derived embryoid bodies (EPLEBs), is a model of gastrulation that progresses through the sequential formation of primitive streak-like intermediates to nascent mesoderm and more differentiated mesoderm populations. EPL cell-derived EBs have been further analysed for the formation of definitive endoderm by detailed morphological studies, gene expression and a protein uptake assay. In comparison to embryoid bodies derived from ES cells, which form primitive and definitive endoderm, the endoderm compartment of embryoid bodies formed from EPL cells was comprised almost exclusively of definitive endoderm. Definitive endoderm was defined as a population of squamous cells that expressed Sox17, CXCR4 and Trh, which formed without the prior formation of primitive endoderm and was unable to endocytose horseradish peroxidase from the medium. Definitive endoderm formed in EPLEBs provides a substrate for further differentiation into specific endoderm lineages; these lineages can be used as research tools for understanding the mechanisms controlling lineage establishment and the nature of the transient intermediates formed. The similarity between mouse EPL cells and human ES cells suggests EPLEBs can be used as a model system for the development of technologies to enrich for the formation of human ES cell-derived definitive endoderm in the future.     

Use of triple tissue blastocyst reconstitution to study the development of diploid parthenogenetic primitive ectoderm in combination with fertilization-derived trophectoderm and primitive endoderm

Diploid mouse conceptuses lacking a paternal genome can form morphologically normal but small fetuses of up to 25 somites, but they invariably fail to develop beyond mid-gestation. Such conceptuses differ from normal most notably in the poor development of extra-embryonic tissues which are largely of trophectodermal and primitive endodermal origin. However, it is not clear whether the demise of diploid parthenogenetic (P) or gynogenetic (G) conceptuses is attributable entirely to the defective development of these two tissues or whether differentiation of the primitive ectoderm, the precursor of the foetus, extra-embryonic mesoderm and amnion, is also impaired by the absence of a paternal genome. Therefore, a new blastocyst reconstitution technique was used which enabled primitive ectoderm from P blastocysts to be combined with primitive endoderm and trophectoderm from fertilization-derived (F) blastocysts. One third of the 'triple tissue' reconstituted blastocysts that implanted yielded foetuses. However, all foetuses recovered on the 11th or 12th day of gestation were small and, with one exception, either obviously retarded or arrested in development. The exception was a living 44 somite specimen which is the most advanced P foetus yet recorded. Foetuses were invariably degenerating in conceptuses recovered on the 13th day. In contrast, at least 16% of control reconstituted blastocysts with primitive ectoderm as well as primitive endoderm and trophectoderm of F origin developed normally on the 13th day of gestation or to term. Hence, the presence of a paternal genome seems to be essential for normal differentiation of all 3 primary tissues of the mouse blastocyst. The P foetuses that developed from reconstituted blastocysts were so closely invested by their membranes that they often showed abnormal flexure of the posterior region of the body. Several also showed a deficiency of allantoic tissue. Therefore, the possibility that the defect in development of P primitive ectoderms resided in their extra-embryonic tissues was investigated by analysing a series of chimaeras produced by injecting them into intact F blastocysts. The foregoing anomalies were not discernible even when P cells made a large contribution to the extra-embryonic mesoderm or amnion plus umbilical cord. Furthermore, selection against P cells was no greater in extra-embryonic derivatives of the primitive ectoderm than in the foetus itself.     

Depletion of Suds3 reveals an essential role in early lineage specification

Preimplantation development culminates with the emergence of three distinct populations: the inner cell mass, primitive endoderm and trophectoderm. Here, we define the mechanisms underlying the requirement of Suds3 in pre/peri-implantation development. Suds3 knockdown blastocysts exhibit a failure of both trophectoderm proliferation as well as a conspicuous lack of primitive endoderm. Expression of essential lineage factors Nanog, Sox2, Cdx2, Eomes, Elf5 and Sox17 are severely reduced in the absence of Suds3. Importantly, we document deficient FGF4/ERK signaling and show that exogenous FGF4 rescues primitive endoderm formation and trophectoderm proliferation in Suds3 knockdown blastocysts. We also show that Hdac1 knockdown reduces Sox2/FGF4/ERK signaling in blastocysts. Collectively, these data define a role for Suds3 in activation of FGF4/ERK signaling and determine an essential molecular role of Suds3/Sin3/HDAC complexes in lineage specification in vivo.     

BMP4 induces primitive endoderm but not trophectoderm in monkey embryonic stem cells

Monkey embryonic stem (ES) cells share similar characteristics to human ES cells and provide a primate model of allotransplantation, which allows to validate efficacy and safety of cell transplantation therapy in regenerative medicine. Bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4) is known to promote trophoblast differentiation in human ES cells in contrast to mouse ES cells where BMP4 synergistically maintains self-renewal with leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), which represents a significant difference in signal transduction of self-renewal and differentiation between murine and human ES cells. As the similarity of the differentiation mechanism between monkey and human ES cells is of critical importance for their use as a primate model system, we investigated whether BMP4 induces trophoblast differentiation in monkey ES cells. Interestingly, BMP4 did not induce trophoblast differentiation, but instead induced primitive endoderm differentiation. Prominent downregulation of Sox2, which plays a pivotal role not only in pluripotency but also placenta development, was observed in cells treated with BMP4. In addition, upregulation of Hand1, Cdx2, and chorionic gonadotropin beta (CG-beta), which are markers of trophoblast, was not observed. In contrast, BMP4 induced significant upregulation of Gata6, Gata4, and LamininB1, suggesting differentiation into the primitive endoderm, visceral endoderm, and parietal endoderm, respectively. The threshold of BMP4 activity was estimated as about 10 ng/mL. These findings suggest that BMP4 induced differentiation into the primitive endoderm lineage but not into trophoblast in monkey ES cells.     

Parietal and visceral endoderm differ in their expression of intermediate filaments

Two layers of extra-embryonic endoderm, viz. the parietal endoderm (PE) and the visceral endoderm (VE), arise in the mouse embryo shortly after implantation. Both cell populations apparently originate from the primitive endoderm of the blastocyst. While the endoderm differentiation has been studied both in the embryo and in the embryonal carcinoma model system, the investigation has been hampered by the paucity of unequivocal markers of differentiation, especially in the case of the PE. Here we show that the PE and VE of mouse conceptuses differ in their expression of intermediate filaments: while both cell types contain cytokeratin, expression of vimentin was only revealed in the cells of the PE. The association between the differentiation of PE and the appearance of vimentin filaments is discussed.     

The roles of FGF and MAP kinase signaling in the segregation of the epiblast and hypoblast cell lineages in bovine and human embryos

At the blastocyst stage of mammalian pre-implantation development, three distinct cell lineages have formed: trophectoderm, hypoblast (primitive endoderm) and epiblast. The inability to derive embryonic stem (ES) cell lines in a variety of species suggests divergence between species in the cell signaling pathways involved in early lineage specification. In mouse, segregation of the primitive endoderm lineage from the pluripotent epiblast lineage depends on FGF/MAP kinase signaling, but it is unknown whether this is conserved between species. Here we examined segregation of the hypoblast and epiblast lineages in bovine and human embryos through modulation of FGF/MAP kinase signaling pathways in cultured embryos. Bovine embryos stimulated with FGF4 and heparin form inner cell masses (ICMs) composed entirely of hypoblast cells and no epiblast cells. Inhibition of MEK in bovine embryos results in ICMs with increased epiblast precursors and decreased hypoblast precursors. The hypoblast precursor population was not fully ablated upon MEK inhibition, indicating that other factors are involved in hypoblast differentiation. Surprisingly, inhibition of FGF signaling upstream of MEK had no effects on epiblast and hypoblast precursor numbers in bovine development, suggesting that GATA6 expression is not dependent on FGF signaling. By contrast, in human embryos, inhibition of MEK did not significantly alter epiblast or hypoblast precursor numbers despite the ability of the MEK inhibitor to potently inhibit ERK phosphorylation in human ES cells. These findings demonstrate intrinsic differences in early mammalian development in the role of the FGF/MAP kinase signaling pathways in governing hypoblast versus epiblast lineage choices.     

Cell fate and cell lineage in the endoderm of the presomite mouse embryo, studied with an intracellular tracer

The fate of the embryonic endoderm (generally called visceral embryonic endoderm) of midstreak to neural plate stages of the mouse embryo was studied by microinjecting horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into single axial endoderm cells in situ, and tracing the labeled descendants to early somite stages in vitro. Axial endoderm cells along the anterior fifth of the late streak/neural plate stage embryo contributed descendants either to the yolk sac endoderm or to the anterior intestinal portal. Cells of the exposed head process contributed to the trunk endoderm and notochord; neighboring endoderm cells contributed to the dorsal foregut. Contributions to the ventral foregut came from endoderm at, and anterior to, the distal tip of the younger, midstreak embryo (in which the head process was not yet exposed). Endoderm over the primitive streak contributed to the postsomite endoderm. We argue from these results and those in the literature that during gastrulation the axial embryonic endoderm is of mixed lineage: (1) an anterior population of cells is derived from primitive endoderm and contributes to the yolk sac endoderm; (2) a population at, and anterior to, the distal tip of the midstreak embryo, extending more anteriorly at late streak/neural plate stages, is presumed to emerge from primitive ectoderm at the beginning of gastrulation and contributes to the foregut and anterior intestinal portal; (3) the axial portion of the head process that begins to incorporate into the ventral surface at the late streak stage contributes to notochord and trunk endoderm. Cells or their descendants that were destined to die within 24 hr were evident at the midstreak stage. There was a linear trend in the incidence of cell death among labeled cells at the late streak/neural plate stages, ranging from 27% caudal to the node to 57% in the anterior fifth of the embryo. The surviving axial endoderm cells divided sufficiently fast to double the population in 24 hr.     

A Comparative Analysis of Extra-Embryonic Endoderm Cell Lines

Prior to gastrulation in the mouse, all endodermal cells arise from the primitive endoderm of the blastocyst stage embryo. Primitive endoderm and its derivatives are generally referred to as extra-embryonic endoderm (ExEn) because the majority of these cells contribute to extra-embryonic lineages encompassing the visceral endoderm (VE) and the parietal endoderm (PE). During gastrulation, the definitive endoderm (DE) forms by ingression of cells from the epiblast. The DE comprises most of the cells of the gut and its accessory organs. Despite their different origins and fates, there is a surprising amount of overlap in marker expression between the ExEn and DE, making it difficult to distinguish between these cell types by marker analysis. This is significant for two main reasons. First, because endodermal organs, such as the liver and pancreas, play important physiological roles in adult animals, much experimental effort has been directed in recent years toward the establishment of protocols for the efficient derivation of endodermal cell types in vitro. Conversely, factors secreted by the VE play pivotal roles that cannot be attributed to the DE in early axis formation, heart formation and the patterning of the anterior nervous system. Thus, efforts in both of these areas have been hampered by a lack of markers that clearly distinguish between ExEn and DE. To further understand the ExEn we have undertaken a comparative analysis of three ExEn-like cell lines (END2, PYS2 and XEN). PYS2 cells are derived from embryonal carcinomas (EC) of 129 strain mice and have been characterized as parietal endoderm-like [1], END2 cells are derived from P19 ECs and described as visceral endoderm-like, while XEN cells are derived from blastocyst stage embryos and are described as primitive endoderm-like. Our analysis suggests that none of these cell lines represent a bona fide single in vivo lineage. Both PYS2 and XEN cells represent mixed populations expressing markers for several ExEn lineages. Conversely END2 cells, which were previously characterized as VE-like, fail to express many markers that are widely expressed in the VE, but instead express markers for only a subset of the VE, the anterior visceral endoderm. In addition END2 cells also express markers for the PE. We extended these observations with microarray analysis which was used to probe and refine previously published data sets of genes proposed to distinguish between DE and VE. Finally, genome-wide pathway analysis revealed that SMAD-independent TGFbeta signaling through a TAK1/p38/JNK or TAK1/NLK pathway may represent one mode of intracellular signaling shared by all three of these lines, and suggests that factors downstream of these pathways may mediate some functions of the ExEn. These studies represent the first step in the development of XEN cells as a powerful molecular genetic tool to study the endodermal signals that mediate the important developmental functions of the extra-embryonic endoderm. Our data refine our current knowledge of markers that distinguish various subtypes of endoderm. In addition, pathway analysis suggests that the ExEn may mediate some of its functions through a non-classical MAP Kinase signaling pathway downstream of TAK1.     

Confinement and clearance of OCT4 in the porcine embryo at stereomicroscopically defined stages around gastrulation

In the areas of developmental biology and embryonic stem cell research, reliable molecular markers of pluripotency and early lineage commitment are sparse in large animal species. In this study, we present morphological and immunohistochemical findings on the porcine embryo in the period around gastrulation, days 8-17 postinsemination, introducing a stereomicroscopical staging system in this species. In embryos at the expanding hatched blastocyst stage, OCT4 is confined to the inner cell mass. Following detachment of the hypoblast, and formation of the embryonic disk, this marker of pluripotency was selectively observed in the epiblast. A prominent crescent-shaped thickening at the posterior region of the embryonic disk marked the first polarization within this structure reflecting incipient cell ingression. Following differentiation of the epiblast, clearance of OCT4 from the three germ layers was observed at defined stages, suggesting correlations to lineage specification. In the endoderm, clearance of OCT4 was apparent from early during its formation at the primitive streak stage. The endoderm harbored progenitors of the "fourth germ layer," the primordial germ cells (PGCs), the only cells maintaining expression of OCT4 at the end of gastrulation. In the ectodermal and mesodermal cell lineages, OCT4 became undetectable at the neural groove and somite stage, respectively. As in the mouse, PGCs showed onset of c-kit expression when located in extraembryonal compartments. They appeared to follow the endoderm during extraembryonal allocation and the mesoderm on return to the genital ridge.     

A Requirement for FGF Signalling in the Formation of Primitive Streak-Like Intermediates from Primitive Ectoderm in Culture

Background

Embryonic stem (ES) cells hold considerable promise as a source of cells with therapeutic potential, including cells that can be used for drug screening and in cell replacement therapies. Differentiation of ES cells into the somatic lineages is a regulated process; before the promise of these cells can be realised robust and rational methods for directing differentiation into normal, functional and safe cells need to be developed. Previous in vivo studies have implicated fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signalling in lineage specification from pluripotent cells. Although FGF signalling has been suggested as essential for specification of mesoderm and endoderm in vivo and in culture, the exact role of this pathway remains unclear.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Using a culture model based on early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells we have investigated the role of FGF signalling in the specification of mesoderm. We were unable to demonstrate any mesoderm inductive capability associated with FGF1, 4 or 8 signalling, even when the factors were present at high concentrations, nor any enhancement in mesoderm formation induced by exogenous BMP4. Furthermore, there was no evidence of alteration of mesoderm sub-type formed with addition of FGF1, 4 or 8. Inhibition of endogenous FGF signalling, however, prevented mesoderm and favoured neural differentiation, suggesting FGF signalling was required but not sufficient for the differentiation of primitive ectoderm into primitive streak-like intermediates. The maintenance of ES cell/early epiblast pluripotent marker expression was also observed in cultures when FGF signalling was inhibited.

Conclusions/Significance

FGF signalling has been shown to be required for the differentiation of primitive ectoderm to neurectoderm. This, coupled with our observations, suggest FGF signalling is required for differentiation of the primitive ectoderm into the germ lineages at gastrulation.     

Extraembryonic Endoderm cells as a model of endoderm development

In recent years the multipotent extraembryonic endoderm (XEN) stem cells have been the center of much attention. In vivo, XEN cells contribute to the formation of the extraembryonic endoderm, visceral and parietal endoderm and later on, the yolk sac. Recent data have shown that the distinction between embryonic and extraembryonic endoderm is not as strict as previously thought due to the integration, and not the displacement, of the visceral endoderm into the definitive embryonic endoderm. Therefore, cells from the extraembryonic endoderm also contribute to definitive endoderm. Many research groups focused on unraveling the potential and ability of XEN cells to both support differentiation and/or differentiate into endoderm‐like tissues as an alternative to embryonic stem (ES) cells. Moreover, the conversion of ES to XEN cells, shown recently without genetic manipulations, uncovers significant and novel molecular mechanisms involved in extraembryonic endoderm and definitive endoderm development. XEN cell lines provide a unique model for an early mammalian lineage that complements the established ES and trophoblast stem cell lines. Through the study of essential genes and signaling requirements for XEN cells in vitro, insights will be gained about the developmental program of the extraembryonic and embryonic endodermal lineage in vivo. This review will provide an overview on the current literature focusing on XEN cells as a model for primitive endoderm and possibly definitive endoderm as well as the potential of using these cells for therapeutic applications.     

Molecular studies of parental origin and mosaicism in 45,X conceptuses

Summary The present report summarizes molecular studies of parental origin and sex chromosome mosaicism in forty-one 45,X conceptuses, consisting of 29 spontaneous abortions and 12 liveborn individuals with Turner syndrome. Our studies indicate that most 45,X conceptuses have a single, maternally derived X chromosome, regardless of whether the conceptus is liveborn or spontaneously aborted. In studies of mosaicism, our identification of X- and Y-chromosome mosaics among 45,X spontaneous abortions indicates that mosaicism does not ensure survival to term of 45,X fetuses. However, the incidence of sex chromosmome mosaicism is substantially higher in liveborn than in aborted 45,X conceptuses, indicating that the presence of a second cell line increases the likelihood of survival to term.     

Embryonic stem cells: hepatic differentiation and regenerative medicine for the treatment of liver disease

Hepatocyte transplantation is considered a potential treatment for liver diseases and a bridge for patients awaiting liver transplantation, but its application has been hampered by a limited supply of hepatocytes. Embryonic stem (ES) cells established from early mouse and human embryos are pluripotent, and proliferate indefinitely in an undifferentiated state in vitro. Since differentiation from ES cells seems to recapitulate early embryonic development, if hepatocytes could be efficiently generated in vitro, ES cells might become a source of transplantable hepatocytes for cell replacement therapy. Hepatocytes have been generated from ES cells in vitro, and the hepatocytes differentiated from ES cells have been found to express many hepatocyte-related genes and perform hepatic functions. However, it remains unclear whether the hepatocytes differentiated from ES cells are derived from definitive endoderm or primitive endoderm. Because visceral endoderm, which expresses many hepatocyte-related genes, is derived from primitive endoderm and is fated to form extraembryonic yolk sac tissues, not to form hepatocytes, ES cells must be directed to a definitive endoderm lineage in vitro. This article discusses the differentiation of ES cells into hepatocytes in vitro in comparison with early embryogenesis, and describes the efficacy of ES cell-derived hepatocyte transplantation.     

Otx2 is required for visceral endoderm movement and for the restriction of posterior signals in the epiblast of the mouse embryo

Genetic and embryological experiments have demonstrated an essential role for the visceral endoderm in the formation of the forebrain; however, the precise molecular and cellular mechanisms of this requirement are poorly understood. We have performed lineage tracing in combination with molecular marker studies to follow morphogenetic movements and cell fates before and during gastrulation in embryos mutant for the homeobox gene Otx2. Our results show, first, that Otx2 is not required for proliferation of the visceral endoderm, but is essential for anteriorly directed morphogenetic movement. Second, molecules that are normally expressed in the anterior visceral endoderm, such as Lefty1 and Mdkk1, are not expressed in Otx2 mutants. These secreted proteins have been reported to antagonise, respectively, the activities of Nodal and Wnt signals, which have a role in regulating primitive streak formation. The visceral endoderm defects of the Otx2 mutants are associated with abnormal expression of primitive streak markers in the epiblast, suggesting that anterior epiblast cells acquire primitive streak characteristics. Taken together, our data support a model whereby Otx2 functions in the anterior visceral endoderm to influence the ability of the adjacent epiblast cells to differentiate into anterior neurectoderm, indirectly, by preventing them from coming under the influence of posterior signals that regulate primitive streak formation.     

Paracrine promotion of cardiomyogenesis in embryoid bodies by LIF modulated endoderm

In the vertebrate embryo the heart is the first organ to form. Embryonic and extra-embryonic tissues are supposed to contribute to cardiac lineage commitment before and during gastrulation in a paracrine fashion. Evidence has accumulated that factors secreted by the anterior lateral endoderm and extra-embryonic endoderm contribute to cardiomyogenesis. Here we exploit in vitro differentiation of embryonic stem cells in embryoid bodies to study differentiation of the extraembryonic endodermal lineage, gastrulation-like processes, and the influence of endoderm on cardiomyogenesis. We demonstrate that in embryoid bodies primitive endoderm differentiates to visceral and parietal endoderm and that parietal endoderm influences onset of cardiomyogenesis in a concentration-dependent manner. Both increased concentrations of leukemia inhibitory factor and its absence in lif-/- embryoid bodies hampered parietal endoderm formation. Reduced differentiation of parietal endoderm correlated with an attenuation of cardiomyogenesis even in the presence of LIE These and previous results suggest that leukemia inhibitory factor is directly and indirectly, via endoderm formation, involved in the regulation of cardiomyogenesis. Increased proliferation of parietal endoderm in lifr -/- embryoid bodies and addition of conditioned lif -/- cell culture supernatant promoted cardiomyogenesis, demonstrating for the first time that parietal endoderm also contributes to cardiomyogenesis in embryoid bodies in a paracrine and leukemia inhibitory factor and its receptor independent pathway. New factors signaling independently of the leukemia inhibitory-factor receptor pathway may sustain cardiomyocyte cell proliferation and thus be a future target for gene therapy of cardiomyopathies and cell therapy of the myocardium.