Clingy genes: Why were genes for ribosomal proteins retained in many mitochondrial genomes?

Why mitochondria still retain their own genome is a puzzle given the enormous effort to maintain a mitochondrial translation machinery. Most mitochondrially encoded proteins are membrane-embedded subunits of the respiratory chain. Their hydrophobicity presumably impedes their import into mitochondria. However, many mitochondrial genomes also encode protein subunits of the mitochondrial ribosome. These proteins lack transmembrane domains and hydrophobicity cannot explain why their genes remained in mitochondria. In this review, we provide an overview about mitochondrially encoded subunits of mitochondrial ribosomes of fungi, plants and protists. Moreover, we discuss and evaluate different hypotheses which were put forward to explain why (ribosomal) proteins remained mitochondrially encoded. It seems likely that the synthesis of ribosomal proteins in the mitochondrial matrix is used to regulate the assembly of the mitochondrial ribosome within mitochondria and to avoid problems that mitochondrial proteins might pose for cytosolic proteostasis and for the assembly of cytosolic ribosomes.     

A partially assembled complex I in NAD4-deficient mitochondria of maize

The proton-translocating NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (respiratory complex I) consists of at least 32 subunits in higher plants, nine of which are mitochondrially encoded (NAD 1–7, NAD4L, NAD9). Complex I (CI) has been analyzed from a mitochondrial mutant of maize, NCS2, that carries a deletion for the 3′ end of the nad4 gene. Mitochondria from highly defective, near-homoplasmic mutant plants have only trace amounts of the normal complex I. Instead, a reduced amount of a smaller complex, which also exhibits NADH dehydrogenase activity, is detected on ‘blue-native’ polyacrylamide gels. Subunits of 76 kDa, 40 kDa and 55 kDa, as well as NAD7 and NAD9, have been identified in the subcomplex by their cross-reactivity with heterologous antisera. The corresponding subunits in Neurospora are localized in a ‘peripheral arm’ of CI, which is known to assemble independently of a ‘membrane arm’. The maize NCS2 CI subcomplex is loosely bound to the membrane and is missing several subunits that could be membrane components. Thus, the mutant CI subcomplex may consist of a peripheral arm. A reduction in the steady-state levels of NAD7 and NAD9 in NCS2 mitochondria occurs despite normal rates of biosynthesis and there is a concomitant decrease of the nuclear encoded 76 kDa subunit. The reduction in CI-associated NADH dehydrogenase activity in the nad4 -deficient NCS2 mutant mitochondria is not associated with a compensatory increase in the activities or amounts of the putative ‘exogenous’ NAD(P)H dehydrogenases that are found in plant mitochondria.     

Synthesis of cytochrome oxidase in isolated rat hepatocytes

1. The synthesis of cytochrome oxidase was studied in isolated rat hepatocytes labeled in vitro. Labeled whole cells, isolated mitochondria, microsomes and the post microsomal supernatant were treated with antisera to rat liver holo-cytochrome oxidase, and the subunits were adsorbed onto Sepharose-protein A. 2. Seven peptides, corresponding to subunits of rat liver cytochrome oxidase, were immunoabsorbed from mitochondria isolated from cells labeled in the absence of inhibitors. Two peptides, corresponding to subunits I (45 500 daltons) and II (26 000 daltons), were labeled in mitochondria isolated from cycloheximide-treated cells. Labeling of these peptides was inhibited by chloramphenicol. Peptides I and II correspond to the two most heavily labeled mitochondrial translation products found in submitochondrial particles. Possible explanations for the lack of labeling of a third mitochondrially translated subunit are discussed. Labeling of the five smallest peptides was inhibited by cyclohexamide but not by chloramphenicol. 3. Peptide I appears in the holoenzyme later than the other six peptides after a pulse-chase. It is not labeled in the immunoabsorbed cytochrome oxidase after a 30 min pulse with [35S]-methionine, but appears after a 3 h chase with unlabeled methionine. Labeling of the other subunits showed no further increase after the chase.     

A cold-sensitive cytoplasmic mutation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae affecting assembly of the mitochondrial 50S ribosomal subunit.

Summary A cytoplasmic mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (E23-1) has been isolated that is resistant to erythromycin and cold sensitive for growth on nonfermentable carbon sources at 18°. Genetic analysis has shown that both of these properties probably result from a single mutation at the rib2 locus which maps close to or within the gene for the 21S rRNA of the mitochondrial 50S ribosomal subunit. Electrophoresis of total RNA extracted from purified mitochondria demonstrated that the 21S and 14S rRNA species from both mutant and wild-type cells were present in roughly equimolar quantities regardless of growth temperature. The mutant is therefore not defective in the synthesis of the 21S rRNA. Sucrose gradient analysis of the mitochondrial ribosomes in Mg²⁺-containing buffers revealed that approximate values for the ratio of 50S to 37S subunits were 1:1 for wild-type cells grown at either 18° or 32°, 0.5:1 for the mutant grown at 32° and 0.2:1 for the mutant grown at 18°. The subunit ratios were approximately 1:1 when Ca²⁺-containing buffers were used, however, In alls cases, 50S particles from the mutant grown at 18° lacked or contained markedly reduced amounts of two distinctive protein components that were present in the mutant at 32° and in the wild-type at both temperatures. In addition, no intact 21S RNA could be recovered from the mitochondrial ribosomes of the mutant grown at the restrictive temperature, even in the presence of Ca²⁺. These findings indicate that mitochondrial 50S ribosomal subunits produced by the mutant at 18° are structurally defective and raise the possibility that the defect results from an alteration in the gene for 21S rRNA.A preliminary report of this work was presented at the meeting on The Molecular Biology of Yeast, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, August 18–22, 1977     

The diabetes-associated 3243 mutation in the mitochondrial tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene causes severe mitochondrial dysfunction without a strong decrease in protein synthesis rate.

Cells harboring patient-derived mitochondria with an A-to-G transition at nucleotide position 3243 of their mitochondrial DNA display severe loss of respiration when compared with cells containing the wild-type adenine but otherwise identical mitochondrial DNA sequence. The amount and degree of leucylation of tRNA(Leu(UUR)) were both found to be highly reduced in mutant cells. Despite the low level of leucyl-tRNA(Leu(UUR)), the rate of mitochondrial translation was not seriously affected by this mutation. Therefore, decrease of mitochondrial protein synthesis as such does not appear to be a necessary prerequisite for loss of respiration. Rather, the mitochondrially encoded proteins seem subject to elevated degradation, leading to a severe reduction in their steady state levels. Our results favor a scheme in which the 3243 mutation causes loss of respiration through accelerated protein degradation, leading to a disequilibrium between the levels of mitochondrial and nuclear encoded respiratory chain subunits and thereby a reduction of functional respiratory chain complexes. The possible mechanisms underlying the pathogenesis of mitochondrial diabetes is discussed.     

Mammalian mitochondrial initiation factor 2 supports yeast mitochondrial translation without formylated initiator tRNA

Initiation of protein synthesis in mitochondria and chloroplasts is widely believed to require a formylated initiator methionyl-tRNA (fMet-tRNAfMet) in a process involving initiation factor 2 (IF2). However, yeast strains disrupted at the FMT1 locus, encoding mitochondrial methionyl-tRNA formyltransferase, lack detectable fMet-tRNAfMet but exhibit normal mitochondrial function as evidenced by normal growth on non-fermentable carbon sources. Here we show that mitochondrial translation products in Saccharomyces cerevisiae were synthesized in the absence of formylated initiator tRNA. ifm1 mutants, lacking the mitochondrial initiation factor 2 (mIF2), are unable to respire, indicative of defective mitochondrial protein synthesis, but their respiratory defect could be complemented by plasmid-borne copies of either the yeast IFM1 gene or a cDNA encoding bovine mIF2. Moreover, the bovine mIF2 sustained normal respiration in ifm1 fmt1 double mutants. Bovine mIF2 supported the same pattern of mitochondrial translation products as yeast mIF2, and the pattern did not change in cells lacking formylated Met-tRNAfMet. Mutant yeast lacking any mIF2 retained the ability to synthesize low levels of a subset of mitochondrially encoded proteins. The ifm1 null mutant was used to analyze the domain structure of yeast mIF2. Contrary to a previous report, the C terminus of yeast mIF2 is required for its function in vivo, whereas the N-terminal domain could be deleted. Our results indicate that formylation of initiator methionyl-tRNA is not required for mitochondrial protein synthesis. The ability of bovine mIF2 to support mitochondrial translation in the yeast fmt1 mutant suggests that this phenomenon may extend to mammalian mitochondria as well.     

Neurospora crassa cytoplasmic ribosomes: cold-sensitive mutant defective in ribosomal ribonucleic acid synthesis.

Experiments were conducted to characterize further the biochemical defects of crib-1 (PJ30201), a coldsensitive mutant strain of Neurospora crassa with a defect in ribosome biosynthesis. The results are as follows. (i) The critical temperature for the expression of the mutant growth and ribosome phenotypes is in the range of 18 to 20 C. (ii) No preferential breakdown of 37S cytoplasmic ribosomal subunits synthesized by crib-1 at 25 C occurs after a shift to 10 C. (iii) Ribosomal subunits synthesized by crib-1 at 25 C function normally in in vivo protein synthesis at 10 C. (iv) Whereas wild type synthesizes both ribosomal subunits in a coordinate manner after either a temperature shift-down (25 to 10 C) of a shift-up (10 to 25 C), noncoordinate synthesis of ribosomal subunits owing to underproduction of 37S subunits occurs in the crib-1 strain immediately after a temperature shift-down. (v) After a shift from 10 to 25 C crib-1 exhibits a 12-h lag before the growth rate and the rate of synthesis of 37S subunits begin to increase significantly. (vi) At 10 C crib-1 synthesizes unequal amounts of 25S and 17S ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) molecules, resulting from a greatly reduced accumulation of stable 17S rRNA. The mutant phenotypes of crib-1 are proposed to be the result of a defect in rRNA processing.     

Role of the mitochondrial DnaJ homolog Mdj1p as a chaperone for mitochondrially synthesized and imported proteins.

Mdj1p, a DnaJ homolog in the mitochondria of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is involved in the folding of proteins in the mitochondrial matrix. In this capacity, Mdj1p cooperates with mitochondrial Hsp70 (mt-Hsp70). Here, we analyzed the role of Mdj1p as a chaperone for newly synthesized proteins encoded by mitochondrial DNA and for nucleus-encoded proteins as they enter the mitochondrial matrix. A series of conditional mutants of mdj1 was constructed. Mutations in the various functional domains led to a partial loss of Mdj1p function. The mutant Mdj1 proteins were defective in protecting the tester protein firefly luciferase against heat-induced aggregation in isolated mitochondria. The mitochondrially encoded var1 protein showed enhanced aggregation after synthesis in mdj1 mutant mitochondria. Mdj1p and mt-Hsp70 were found in a complex with nascent polypeptide chains on mitochondrial ribosomes. Mdj1p was not found to interact with translocation intermediates of imported proteins spanning the two membranes and exposing short segments into the matrix, in accordance with the lack of requirement of Mdj1p in the mt-Hsp70-mediated protein import into mitochondria. On the other hand, precursor proteins in transit which had further entered the matrix were found in a complex with Mdj1p. Our results suggest that Mdj1p together with mt-Hsp70 plays an important role as a chaperone for mitochondrially synthesized polypeptide chains emerging from the ribosome and for translocating proteins at a late import step.     

Mrpl36 Is Important for Generation of Assembly Competent Proteins during Mitochondrial Translation

The complexes of the respiratory chain represent mosaics of nuclear and mitochondrially encoded components. The processes by which synthesis and assembly of the various subunits are coordinated remain largely elusive. During evolution, many proteins of the mitochondrial ribosome acquired additional domains pointing at specific properties or functions of the translation machinery in mitochondria. Here, we analyzed the function of Mrpl36, a protein associated with the large subunit of the mitochondrial ribosome. This protein, homologous to the ribosomal protein L31 from bacteria, contains a mitochondria-specific C-terminal domain that is not required for protein synthesis per se; however, its absence decreases stability of Mrpl36. Cells lacking this C-terminal domain can still synthesize proteins, but these translation products fail to be properly assembled into respiratory chain complexes and are rapidly degraded. Surprisingly, overexpression of Mrpl36 seems to even increase the efficiency of mitochondrial translation. Our data suggest that Mrpl36 plays a critical role during translation that determines the rate of respiratory chain assembly. This important function seems to be carried out by a stabilizing activity of Mrpl36 on the interaction between large and small ribosomal subunits, which could influence accuracy of protein synthesis.     

Hyaloraphidium curvatum: a linear mitochondrial genome, tRNA editing, and an evolutionary link to lower fungi

We have sequenced the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of Hyaloraphidium curvatum, an organism previously classified as a colorless green alga but now recognized as a lower fungus based on molecular data. The 29.97-kbp mitochondrial chromosome is maintained as a monomeric, linear molecule with identical, inverted repeats (1.43 kbp) at both ends, a rare genome architecture in mitochondria. The genome encodes only 14 known mitochondrial proteins, 7 tRNAs, the large subunit rRNA and small subunit rRNA (SSU rRNA), and 3 ORFs. The SSU rRNA is encoded in two gene pieces that are located 8 kbp apart on the mtDNA. Scrambled and fragmented mitochondrial rRNAs are well known from green algae and alveolate protists but are unprecedented in fungi. Protein genes code for apocytochrome b; cytochrome oxidase 1, 2, and 3, NADH dehydrogenase 1, 2, 3, 4, 4L, 5, and 6, and ATP synthase 6, 8, and 9 subunits, and several of these genes are organized in operon-like clusters. The set of seven mitochondrially encoded tRNAs is insufficient to recognize all codons that occur in the mitochondrial protein genes. When taking into account the pronounced codon bias, at least 16 nuclear-encoded tRNAs are assumed to be imported into the mitochondria. Three of the seven predicted mitochondria-encoded tRNA sequences carry mispairings in the first three positions of the acceptor stem. This strongly suggests that these tRNAs are edited by a mechanism similar to the one seen in the fungus Spizellomyces punctatus and the rhizopod amoeba Acanthamoeba castellanii. Our phylogenetic analysis confirms with overwhelming support that H. curvatum is a member of the chytridiomycete fungi, specifically related to the Monoblepharidales.     

Mutations Affecting a Yeast Mitochondrial Inner Membrane Protein, Pnt1p, Block Export of a Mitochondrially Synthesized Fusion Protein from the Matrix

The machinery that inserts mitochondrially encoded proteins into the inner membrane and translocates their hydrophilic domains through the membrane is poorly understood. We have developed a genetic screen for Saccharomyces cerevisiae mutants defective in this export process. The screen is based on the fact that the hydrophilic polypeptide Arg8(m)p is exported from the matrix if it is synthesized within mitochondria as a bifunctional Cox2p-Arg8(m)p fusion protein. Since export of Arg8(m)p causes an Arg(-) phenotype, defective mutants can be selected as Arg(+). Here we show that mutations in the nuclear gene PNT1 block the translocation of mitochondrially encoded fusion proteins across the inner membrane. Pnt1p is a mitochondrial integral inner membrane protein that appears to have two hydrophilic domains in the matrix, flanking a central hydrophobic hairpin-like anchor. While an S. cerevisiae pnt1 deletion mutant was more sensitive to H(2)O(2) than the wild type was, it was respiration competent and able to export wild-type Cox2p. However, deletion of the PNT1 orthologue from Kluyveromyces lactis, KlPNT1, caused a clear nonrespiratory phenotype, absence of cytochrome oxidase activity, and a defect in the assembly of KlCox2p that appears to be due to a block of C-tail export. Since PNT1 was previously described as a gene affecting resistance to the antibiotic pentamidine, our data support a mitochondrial target for this drug.     

Relationship between cytoplasmic and mitochondrial apparatus of protein synthesis in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

A conditional respiratory deficiency in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is expressed as a result of a nuclear mutation in sup1 and sup2 genes (II and IV chromosomes, respectively), coding for a component of cytoplasmic ribosomes (Ter-Avanesyan et al. 1982). One such strain is studied here in detail. The strain is temperature-dependent and expresses a respiratory deficient phenotype at 20 degrees C but not at 30 degrees C. Moreover, the strain is simultaneously chloramphenicol-dependent and is able to grow on media containing glycerol or ethanol as a sole carbon source only in the presence of the drug. Chloramphenicol has a differential effect on protein synthesis in mitochondria of the parent strain and the mutant. Since chloramphenicol is a ribosome-targeting antibiotic we suggest that the differential effect of the drug on parent and mutant mitochondrial protein synthesis is due to the altered properties of mito-ribosomes of the mutant compared to those of the parent strain. Mitochondria of the mutant synthesize all the mitochondrially encoded polypeptides, however, in significantly lowered amounts. A suggestion is put forward for the existence of a common component (a ribosomal protein) for mito and cyto-ribosomes.     

Nuclear mutants of Neurospora crassa temperature-sensitive for the synthesis of cytochrome aa3. Mitochondrial protein synthesis and analysis of the polypeptide composition of cytochrome c oxidase.

Three previously isolated mutants of Neurospora crassa, temperature-sensitive for the production of cytochrome aa3, have been further analyzed. These mutants have a slightly reduced capacity for mitochondrial protein synthesis when grown at 41 degrees C, although this relative deficiency appeared to be no greater than the deficiency in other cytochrome-aa3-deficient mutants. Thermolability studies revealed that the cytochrome c oxidase purified from each of the mutants grown at 23 degrees C is no more sensitive to heat inactivation than the enzyme isolated from wild-type cells. Sodium dodecylsulfate gel electrophoresis of immunoprecipitates obtained from the mitochondria of each of the mutants grown at 23 degrees C, using antiserum directed against holocytochrome c oxidase, indicated that all the subunits of cytochrome c oxidase were present in relative amounts similar to those found in mitochondria from wild-type cultures. However, when the mitochondria from mutant cultures grown at 41 degrees C were examined in the above fashion, only subunits 5 and 6 of the oxidase were detected. Nonetheless, the mitochondrially synthesized subunit 1, 2 and 3 polypeptides could be immunoprecipitated from mitochondria isolated from mutant cells grown at 41 degrees C and labelled with [3H]leucine in medium containing cycloheximide. Although subunits 4 and 7 could not be detected, because a suitable antibody was not available, the fact that five of the seven subunits were present, but not associated with each other, suggested that the genetic defects in these mutants may affect the process of cytochrome c oxidase assembly.     

The site of synthesis of the iron-sulfur subunits of the flavoprotein and iron-protein fractions of human NADH dehydrogenase

The site of synthesis of the iron-sulfur subunits of the flavoprotein and iron-protein fractions of the human respiratory chain NADH dehydrogenase has been investigated to test the possibility that any of them is synthesized in mitochondria. For this purpose, antibodies specific for individual subunits of the bovine enzyme, which cross-reacted with the homologous human subunits in immunoblot assays, were tested against HeLa cell mitochondrial proteins labeled in vivo with [35S]methionine in the absence or presence of inhibitors of mitochondrial or cytoplasmic protein synthesis. The results clearly indicated that all the iron-sulfur subunits of the flavoprotein and iron-protein fractions of human complex I are synthesized in the cytosol and are, therefore, encoded in nuclear genes.     

A temperature sensitive mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae defective in pre-rRNA processing.

A recessive temperature sensitive mutant has been isolated that is defective in ribosomal RNA processing. By Northern analysis, this mutant was found to accumulate three novel rRNA species: 23S', 18S' and 7S', each of which contains sequences from the spacer region between 25S and 18S rRNA. 35S pre-rRNA accumulates, while the level of the 20S and 27S rRNA processing intermediates is depressed. Pulse-chase analysis demonstrates that the processing of 35S pre-rRNA is slowed. The defect in the mutant appears to be at the first processing step, which generates 20S and 27S rRNA. 7S' RNA is a form of 5.8S RNA whose 5' end is extended by 149 nucleotides to a position just 5 nucleotides downstream of the normal cleavage site that produces 20S and 27S rRNA. 7S' RNA can assemble into 60S ribosomal subunits, but such subunits are relatively ineffective in joining polyribosomes. A single lesion is responsible for the pre-rRNA processing defect and the temperature sensitivity. The affected gene is designated RRP2.     

Mitochondrial ribosome assembly in Neurospora crassa. Chloramphenicol inhibits the maturation of small ribosomal subunits.

Recent results suggest that, in Neurospora crassa, one small subunit mitochondrial ribosomal protein (S-4a, M_r 52,000) is synthesized intramitochondrially (Lambowitz et al., 1976). We now find that, when wild-type cells are treated with chloramphenicol to block mitochondrial protein synthesis, the maturation of 30 S mitochondrial ribosomal subunits is rapidly inhibited and there is an accumulation of CAP-30 S particles which sediment slightly behind mature small subunits. Electrophoretic analysis suggests that the CAP-30 S particles are deficient in several proteins including S-4a and that they are enriched in a precursor RNA species that is slightly longer than 19 S RNA. Chloramphenicol also appears to inhibit the maturation of 50 S ribosomal subunits, but this effect is much less pronounced. Continued incubation in chloramphenicol leads to a decrease in the proportion of total mitochondrial ribonucleoprotein present as monomers, possibly reflecting the depletion of competent subunits. After long-term (17 h) growth in chloramphenicol, mitochondrial ribosome profiles from wild-type cells show decreased ratios of small to large subunits, a feature which is also characteristic of the poky (mi-1) mutant. Pulse-labeling experiments combined with electrophoretic analysis show that the synthesis of mitochondrial ribosomal RNAs is relatively unaffected by chloramphenicol and that, despite the deficiency of small subunits, 19 S and 25 S RNA are present in normal ratios in whole mitochondria. By contrast, 19 S RNA in poky mitochondria is rapidly degraded leading to a decreased ratio of 19 S to 25 S RNA. The significance of these results with respect to the etiology of the poky mutation is discussed and a model of mitochondrial ribosome assembly that incorporates all available data is presented.