Freezing avoidance mechanism of primordial shoots of conifer buds

Excised winter buds of very hardy fir supercooled to —30or — 35?C, though primordial shoots excised from thesewinter buds (freezing point: about —5.5?C) supercooledonly to —12 to — 14?C. Also, excised primordialshoots did not tolerate freezing, but were rather resistantto desiccation. Differential thermal analysis (DTA) of primordialshoots revealed that the capability of supercooling increasedwith decreasing water content and that no exotherm could bedetected in the primordial shoots with a water content belowabout 20%. When excised whole buds were cooled very slowly,the exotherm temperature shifted markedly to a lower value andthe exotherm became much smaller. Also, masses of needle icewere observed, mainly beneath the crown of the primordial shoot.From these results, it may be concluded that most of the waterin primordial shoots gradually migrates out through the crownand freezes as the temperature decreases (extraorgan freezing),which enables primordial shoots to survive at very low temperatures.Winter buds of Abies balsamea held at — 20?C for 30 daysand then slowly cooled down to —50 or —60?C remainedalive. Thus, there seems to be no low temperature limit to thisfrost avoidance mechanism, if the primordial shoots can resistintensive freeze-dehydration. Low temperature exotherms wereobserved in all genera which belong to Abietoideae and Laricoideaeof Pinaceae, all of which have a crown in the primordial shoots,but not in other conifers. ¹ Contribution No. 2037 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received June 25, 1979; )     

Freezing Tolerance of Shoot and Flower Primordia of Coniferous Buds by Extraorgan Freezing

Shoot and flower primordia of vegetative and flower buds ofextremely or very hardy conifers belonging to the subfamilyAbietoideae of the Pinaceae, survived between –40 and–70?C by extraorgan freezing, which differed greatly dependingupon species. The water in these organs gradually froze outwith decreasing temperatures when cooled very slowly, whichenabled these organs to survive %40?C or below. The same icesegregation in shoot and flower primordia by extraorgan freezingwas observed in most of the temperate conifers belonging toTaxaceae, Cephalotaxaceae, Taxodiaceae and Cuppressaceae, makingthem resistant to temperatures between –15 and –25?C.In these conifers, scales acted as an ice sink, unlike the conifersof Abietoideae. The rates of cooling and exosmosis of waterin the shoot or flower primordia, their size, and their abilityto tolerate freeze-dehydration or its related stress play animportant role in determining whether death is caused by freeze-dehydrationor intraorgan freezing. Even in very hardy conifers, low temperature exotherms fromfreezing within the shoot primordia appeared between –30and –35?C on the DTA profiles when cooled continuouslyunder laboratory conditions from 5?C to –50?C at 2 to5?C/h. Appearance of low temperature exotherms always resultedin death. However, in the coldest area of Hokkaido, where theair temperature cools down to –40?C or below nearly everyyear, such an intraorgan freezing seems seldom to occur, especiallyin natural stands. On the other hand, low temperatures below–25?C seldom occur in warm-temperate climates. Thus, itmay be considered that in both boreal and temperate coniferstheir shoot and flower primordia seem to tolerate freeze dehydrationby extraorgan freezing under natural conditions. ¹ Contribution No. 2431 from the rnstitute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received March 27, 1982; Accepted August 12, 1982)     

Supercooling characteristics of isolated peach flower bud primordia

The amount of unfrozen water in dormant peach (Prunus persica [L.] Batsch, cv Redhaven) flower buds, isolated primordia, and bud axes was determined during freezing using pulse nuclear magnetic resonance methods. Differential thermal analysis studies were conducted on whole buds and isolated primordia in the presence of ice nucleation. The results showed that some of the water in isolated primordia remained supercooled in the presence of ice nucleation. Although most tissue water froze (57.5%) following ice nucleation at −2.5°C, a considerable amount of water was found to supercool. In the presence of ice nucleation, increased hydration of isolated primordia resulted in the elimination of the supercooling characteristic. The structural integrity of isolated primordia appeared to be essential for supercooling.     

Freezing behaviours in wintering Cornus florida flower bud tissues revisited using MRI

How plant tissues control their water behaviours (phase and movement) under subfreezing temperatures through adaptative strategies (freezing behaviours) is important for their survival. However, the fine details of freezing behaviours in complex organs and their regulation mechanisms are poorly understood, and non‐invasive visualization/analysis is required. The localization/density of unfrozen water in wintering Cornus florida flower buds at subfreezing temperatures was visualized with high‐resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). This allowed tissue‐specific freezing behaviours to be determined. MRI images revealed that individual anthers and ovules remained stably supercooled to ?14 to ?21 °C or lower. The signal from other floral tissues decreased during cooling to ?7 °C, which likely indicates their extracellular freezing. Microscopic observation and differential thermal analyses revealed that the abrupt breakdown of supercooled individual ovules and anthers resulted in their all‐or‐nothing type of injuries. The distribution of ice nucleation activity in flower buds determined using a test tube‐based assay corroborated which tissues primarily froze. MRI is a powerful tool for non‐invasively visualizing unfrozen tissues. Freezing events and/or dehydration events can be located by digital comparison of MRI images acquired at different temperatures. Only anthers and ovules preferentially remaining unfrozen are a novel freezing behaviour in flower buds. Physicochemical and biological mechanisms/implications are discussed.     

Supercooling in overwintering azalea flower buds

Differential thermal analysis and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy experiments on whole flower buds and excised floral primordia of azalea (Rhododendron kosterianum, Schneid.) proved that supercooling is the mode of freezing resistance (avoidance) of azalea flower primordia. Increase in the linewidth of nuclear magnetic resonance spectra for water upon thawing supports the view that injury to the primordia occurs at the moment of freezing. Nonliving primordia freeze at the same temperatures as living primordia, indicating that morphological features of primordial tissues are a key factor in freezing avoidance of dormant azalea flower primordia. Differential thermal analyses was used to study the relationship of cooling rate to the freezing points of floral primordia in whole flower buds. At a cooling rate of 8.5 C per hour, primordia in whole buds froze at about the same subfreezing temperatures as did excised primordia cooled at 37 C per hour. At more rapid cooling rates primordia in intact buds froze at higher temperatures.     

Supercooling in overwintering azalea flower buds: additional freezing parameters

Results of calorimetric, nuclear magnetic resonance, and low temperature light microscopic studies on supercooled azalea (Rhododendron kosterianum, Schneid.) floral primordia are reported. Heat release during freezing of the supercooled floral primordia is in the range predicted for supercooled pure water. Spin-lattice and spin-spin relaxation times measured by pulsed nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy decreased after freezing, suggesting that a redistribution of tissue water is associated with injury to the floral primordium. The calorimetric and low temperature microscopy studies showed no detectable ice formation in floral primordia until the major freezing event at low temperature. No resistance to ice growth is found to exist in the primordium tissues, indicating that a freezing barrier or thermodynamic equilibrium exists between the unfrozen primordium and other flower bud parts which contain ice at subfreezing temperatures.     

Cryo-scanning electron microscopic study on freezing behaviors of tissue cells in dormant buds of larch (Larix kaempferi)

The freezing behavior of dormant buds in larch, especially at the cellular level, was examined by a Cryo-SEM. The dormant buds exhibited typical extraorgan freezing. Extracellular ice crystals accumulated only in basal areas of scales and beneath crown tissues, areas in which only these living cells had thick walls unlike other tissue cells. By slow cooling (5 °C/day) of dormant buds to −50 °C, all living cells in bud tissues exhibited distinct shrinkage without intracellular ice formation detectable by Cryo-SEM. However, the recrystallization experiment of these slowly cooled tissue cells, which was done by further freezing of slowly cooled buds with LN and then rewarming to −20 °C, confirmed that some of the cells in the leaf primordia, shoot primordia and apical meristem, areas in which cells had thin walls and in which no extracellular ice accumulated, lost freezable water with slow cooling to −30 °C, indicating ability of these cells to adapt by extracellular freezing, whereas other cells in these tissues retained freezable water with slow cooling even to −50 °C, indicating adaptation of these cells by deep supercooling. On the other hand, all cells in crown tissues and in basal areas of scales, areas in which cells had thick walls and in which large masses of ice accumulated, had the ability to adapt by extracellular freezing. It is thought that the presence of two types of cells exhibiting different freezing adaptation abilities within a bud tissue is quite unique and may reflect sophisticated freezing adaptation mechanisms in dormant buds.     

Freezing stress and membrane injury of Norway spruce (Picea abies) tissues

Effects of sub-zero temperatures (−5 to −35°C) on the tissues of needles, buds and shoots of Norway spruce [ Picea abies (L.) Karst.] were studied. The freezing caused increased efflux of cellular electrolytes. Freezing injury of the primordial shoots and 1-year-old shoots was the result of the spontaneous freezing of a deep supercooled cellular water. The crystallization injures the cellular membranes leading to the loss of semipermeability and to the drastic efflux of K⁺. In the needles there was no deep supercooling of water and two patterns of changes in the membranes, depending upon the range of the applied temperatures, could be distinguished. At 0 to – 25°C, which do not kill the cells, we observed a disturbance in the membrane semipermeability as monitored by electrolytes efflux within a few hours after thawing of the needles. At lower temperatures (−35°C) we observed irreversible loss of the membrane semipermeability, and death of the tissue. Those changes occurred 10 h after thawing and were probably caused by the released lytic enzymes and some toxic compounds, which acted on the cellular membranes.     

The state of water in acclimating vegetative buds from Malus and Amelanchier and its relationship to winter hardiness

The relationship between freezable water and cold hardiness during acclimation was studied using vegetative buds from several apple ( Malus domestica Borkh) cultivars and from one saskatoonberry ( Amelanchier alnifolia Nutt. cv. Smoky) cultivar. According to leakage data and visual assessments of cortical browning, vegetative buds of all cultivars were most tolerant to subfreezing temperatures in January. The hardy condition was also associated with maximum tolerance to desiccation. Qualitative features of freezing exotherms (number of peaks and temperature of the transition) were not correlated with the hardy condition in the tissues. However, the amount of unfrozen water, determined by quantifying the energy of the exotherms, increased with increasing hardiness. In buds that survived exposure to −45°C, freezing reduced the intracellular water content, but only to levels above the critical moisture content for desiccation damage. In buds that did not survive exposure to −45°C, freezing reduced the water content to levels equal to or less than the critical moisture content for desiccation damage. These observations suggest that the freezing of water in nonhardy tissue dried the tissue to moisture levels at which severe dehydration damage occurred. It appears that acclimation of vegetative apple buds involves at least two processes: (1) an increase in tolerance to dehydration and (2) an increase in the level of unfreezable water.     

Low temperature exotherms of winter buds of hardy conifers

Differential thermal analysis (DTA) of winter buds and the excisedprimordial shoots of sub-alpine or sub-cold firs revealed thatthese buds had all low temperature exotherms around –30?C.However, no low temperature exotherm below –15?C was detectedin the spring buds. In the winter bud of Abies firma, a temperatefir native to Japan, a low temperature exotherm was detectedaround –20?C, which is higher by 10?C than that of sub-alpineor sub-cold firs. The low temperature exotherms of these firsoccurred at nearly the same temperatures that result in thedeath of these primordial shoots. On the other hand, littleor no low temperature exotherm was detected in the winter budsof sub-cold spruces. In larch winter buds, numerous small exothermswere observed, which are probably due to the many leaf primordiain the buds. Unlike many temperate deciduous broad-leaved trees,no low temperature exotherm was detected below –15?C inwinter twig xylem of conifers such as Abies, Picea, Pinus, Larixand Pseudotsuga. Thus, very hardy coniferous twigs can tolerateextracellular freezing to –70?C. ¹ Contribution No. 1907 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received June 8, 1978; )     

Freezing Events within Overwintering Buds of Blackcurrant (Ribes nigrum L.)

Overwintering buds of blackcurrant cultivars 'Ben Lomond' and'Ben More' were examined by differential thermal analysis (DTA).Photographic evidence relates the first (primary) exotherm tothe freezing of water in the basal pith and bud scales. Thenumber of secondary exotherms either matched, or was fewer than,the number of floral racemes within the bud. There is evidencein the structure of the secondary exotherms that the freezingof individual primordia was being recorded.Copyright 1993, 1999Academic Press Differential thermal analysis, freezing injury, buds, Ribes nigrum, blackcurrant     

Determination of resistance to low temperatures of winter buds on lateral shoot present in Karaerik (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Vitis vinifera</Emphasis> L.) grape cultivar

This study aims to determine the low temperature resistance of dormant buds at nodes with or without lateral shoots of Karaerik grape cultivar, and explain the relationship between the resistance and biochemical parameters in this grape cultivar. In this study, the mean values of high temperature exotherms (HTEs), low temperature exotherms (LTEs), water, reducing sugar, total soluble protein contents and antioxidant enzyme activities of dormant buds taken from nodes with or without lateral shoots were determined. The experiment has been found that buds in nodes with lateral shoots showed HTE and LTE at higher temperatures (HTE average ?6.7 °C and LTE average ?8.3 °C) than buds (HTE average ?7.9 °C and LTE average ?11.5 °C) in nodes without lateral shoots; therefore, buds in nodes with lateral shoots had less tolerance to low temperature. Additionally, lower sugar (average 41.05 mg g^?1), protein (average 1.61 mg g^?1), superoxide dismutase (average 425.27 EU g^?1 tissue), peroxidase (average 2516.1 EU g^?1 tissue) and polyphenol oxidase (average 7283.1 EU g^?1 tissue) were determined for buds taken from nodes with lateral shoots. Due to the fact that dormant buds taken from nodes with lateral shoots decreased the resistance to low temperatures, this research suggests that these lateral shoots should be excised with the summer pruning at the regions, where low temperatures caused the damages.     

Ultrastructural Evidence That Intracellular Ice Formation and Possibly Cavitation Are the Sources of Freezing Injury in Supercooling Wood Tissue of Cornus florida L

Although cellular injury in some woody plants has been correlated with freezing of supercooled water, there is no direct evidence that intracellular ice formation is responsible for the injury. In this study we tested the hypothesis that injury to xylem ray parenchyma cells in supercooling tissues is caused by intracellular ice formation. The ultrastructure of freezing-stress response in xylem ray parenchyma cells of flowering dogwood (Cornus florida L.) was determined in tissue prepared by freeze substitution. Wood tissue was collected in the winter, spring, and summer of 1992. Specimens were cooled from 0 to -60[deg]C at a rate of 5[deg]C h-1. Freezing stress did not affect the structural organization of wood tissue, but xylem ray parenchyma cells suffered severe injury in the form of intracellular ice crystals. The temperatures at which the ice crystals were first observed depended on the season in which the tissue was collected. Intracellular ice formation was observed at -20, -10, and -5[deg]C in winter, spring, and summer, respectively. Another type of freezing injury was manifested by fragmented protoplasm with indistinguishable plasma membranes and damaged cell ultrastructure but no evidence of intracellular ice. Intracellular cavitation may be a source of freezing injury in xylem ray parenchyma cells of flowering dogwood.     

Exogenous Abscisic Acid Mimics Cold Acclimation for Cacti Differing in Freezing Tolerance

The responses to low temperature were determined for two species of cacti sensitive to freezing, Ferocactus viridescens and Opuntia ficus-indica, and a cold hardy species, Opuntia fragilis. Fourteen days after shifting the plants from day/night air temperatures of 30/20[deg]C to 10/0[deg]C, the chlorenchyma water content decreased only for O. fragilis. This temperature shift caused the freezing tolerance (measured by vital stain uptake) of chlorenchyma cells to be enhanced only by about 2.0[deg]C for F. viridescens and O. ficus-indica but by 14.6[deg]C for O. fragilis. Also, maintenance of high water content by injection of water into plants at 10/0[deg]C reversed the acclimation. The endogenous abscisic acid (ABA) concentration was below 0.4 pmol g-1 fresh weight at 30/20[deg]C, but after 14 d at 10/0[deg]C it increased to 84 pmol g-1 fresh weight for O. ficus-indica and to 49 pmol g-1 fresh weight for O. fragilis. Four days after plants were sprayed with 7.5 x 10-5 M ABA at 30/20[deg]C, freezing tolerance was enhanced by 0.5[deg]C for F. viridescens, 4.1[deg]C for O. ficus-indica, and 23.4[deg]C for O. fragilis. Moreover, the time course for the change in freezing tolerance over 14 d was similar for plants shifted to low temperatures as for plants treated with exogenous ABA at moderate temperatures. Decreases in plant water content and increases in ABA concentration may be important for low-temperature acclimation by cacti, especially O. fragilis, which is widely distributed in Canada and the United States.     

Response of Xylem Ray Parenchyma Cells of Red Osier Dogwood (Cornus sericea L.) to Freezing Stress (Microscopic Evidence of Protoplasm Contraction)

Freezing behavior of wood tissue of red osier dogwood (Cornus sericea L.) cannot be explained by current concepts of freezing resistance. Previous studies indicated that water in wood tissue presumably froze extracellularly. However, it was observed that xylem ray parenchyma cells within these tissues could survive temperatures as low as -80[deg]C and the walls of these cells did not collapse during freezing (S.R. Malone and E.N. Ashworth [1991] Plant Physiol 95: 871-881). This observation was unexpected and is inconsistent with the current hypothesis of cell response during freezing. Hence, the objective of our study was to further examine the mechanism of freezing resistance of wood tissue of red osier dogwood. We studied freezing stress response of xylem ray parenchyma cells of red osier dogwood using freeze substitution and transmission electron microscopy. Wood samples were collected in winter, spring, and summer of 1992. Specimens were cooled from 0[deg]C to -60[deg]C at 5[deg]C/h. Freezing stress did not affect the structural organization of wood tissue. However, the xylem ray parenchyma cells showed two unique responses to a freezing stress: protoplasm contraction and protoplasm fragmentation. Protoplasm contraction was evident at all freezing temperatures and in tissues collected at different times of the year. Cells with fragmented protoplasm, however, were noticed only in tissues collected in spring and summer. Protoplasm contraction in winter tissue occurred without apparent damage to the protoplasm. In contrast, protoplasm contraction in spring and summer tissues was accompanied by substantial damage. No evidence of intracellular ice formation was observed in parenchyma cells exposed to freezing stress. Differences in protoplasm contraction and appearance of cells with fragmented protoplasm likely indicated seasonal changes in cold hardiness of the wood tissue of red osier dogwood. We speculate that the appearance of fragmented protoplasm may indicate that cells are being injured by an alternative mechanism in spring and summer.     

Winter bud content according to position in 3-year-old branching systems of 'Granny Smith' apple

An investigation was made of the number of preformed organs in winter buds of 3-year-old reiterated complexes of the 'Granny Smith' cultivar. Winter bud content was studied with respect to bud position: terminal buds were compared on both long shoots and spurs according to branching order and shoot age, while axillary buds were compared between three zones (distal, median and proximal) along 1-year-old annual shoots in order 1. The percentage of winter buds that differentiated into inflorescences was determined and the flowers in each bud were counted for each bud category. The other organ categories considered were scales and leaf primordia. The results confirmed that a certain number of organs must be initiated before floral differentiation occurred. The minimum limit was estimated at about 15 organs on average, including scales. Total number of lateral organs formed was shown to vary with both bud position and meristem age, increasing from newly formed meristems to 1- and 2-year-old meristems on different shoot types. These differences in bud organogenesis depending on bud position, were consistent with the morphogenetic gradients observed in apple tree architecture. Axillary buds did not contain more than 15 organs on average and this low organogenetic activity of the meristems was related to a low number of flowers per bud. In contrast, the other bud categories contained more than 15 differentiated organs on average and a trade-off was observed between leaf and flower primordia. The ratio between the number of leaf and flower primordia per bud varied with shoot type. When the terminal buds on long shoots and spurs were compared, those on long shoots showed more flowers and a higher ratio of leaf to flower primordia.     

The inhibitory effect of gibberellic acid on flowering in Citrus

The application of gibberellic acid (GA₃) at any time from early November until bud sprouting, resulted in a significant inhibition of flowering in the sweet orange [ C. sinensis (L.) Osbeck] and the Satsuma ( C. unshiu Marc.) and Clementine ( C. reticulata Blanco) mandarins. Two response peaks were evident: the first occurred when the application was timed to the translocation of an unknown flowering signal from the leaves to the buds. The second occurred during bud sprouting, at the time the flower primordia were differentiating. From the pattern of flowering, it appears that the mechanism of inhibition was similar irrespective of the timing of GA₃ application. There was an initial reduction in bud sprouting affecting selectively those buds originating leafless inflorescences. An additional inhibition resulted in a reduction in the number of leafy inflorescences with an increase in the number of vegetative shoots, suggesting the reversion of a floral to a vegetative apex. The inhibited buds sprouted readily in vitro but invariably vegetative shoots were formed. A continuous influence of the sustaining branch is necessary to keep the flowering commitment of the buds; irreversible commitment occurs when the petal primordia are well differentiated.     

Evidence that cytokinin controls bud size and branch form in Norway spruce

Shoot elongation in many coniferous species is predetermined during bud formation the year before the shoot extends. This implies that formation of the primordial shoot within the bud is the primary event in annual shoot growth. Hormonal factors regulating bud formation are consequently of utmost importance. We followed the levels of the endogenous cytokinins zeatin riboside (ZR) and isopentenyladenosine (iPA) in terminal buds, whorl buds and lower lateral buds of the uppermost current-year whorl shoots of 15- to 20-year-old trees of Norway spruce [ Picea abies (L.) Karst.] from June to September. Cytokinins were isolated with affinity chromatography columns, purified by high performance liquid chromatography, and quantified by ELISA. The level of ZR was low in June but increased gradually in all buds until September. Throughout the measurement period, the ZR level was highest in terminal buds and lowest in the scattered lateral, buds, with the whorl buds intermediate. The level of iPA peaked in July and decreased later without any consistent differences among the three classes of buds. The development of different kinds of buds was followed by scanning electron microscopy. We found that bud growth was greatest during August and September. The final size of primordial shoots within the buds varied considerably and the weight of the terminal bud was three times that of the whorl buds and more than five times that of the other lateral buds.
We conclude that the increase in ZR level during the period of active bud development is indicative of the importance of cytokinin for this process. Furthermore, the positive correlation between the level of ZR and bud growth during the period of predetermination of next year's branch growth suggests that this hormone indirectly controls the form of single branches in the spruce tree.     

Evidence that cytokinin controls bud size and branch form in Norway spruce

Shoot elongation in many coniferous species is predetermined during bud formation the year before the shoot extends. This implies that formation of the primordial shoot within the bud is the primary event in annual shoot growth. Hormonal factors regulating bud formation are consequently of utmost importance. We followed the levels of the endogenous cytokinins zeatin riboside (ZR) and isopentenyladenosine (iPA) in terminal buds, whorl buds and lower lateral buds of the uppermost current-year whorl shoots of 15- to 20-year-old trees of Norway spruce [ Picea abies (L.) Karst.] from June to September. Cytokinins were isolated with affinity chromatography columns, purified by high performance liquid chromatography, and quantified by ELISA. The level of ZR was low in June but increased gradually in all buds until September. Throughout the measurement period, the ZR level was highest in terminal buds and lowest in the scattered lateral, buds, with the whorl buds intermediate. The level of iPA peaked in July and decreased later without any consistent differences among the three classes of buds. The development of different kinds of buds was followed by scanning electron microscopy. We found that bud growth was greatest during August and September. The final size of primordial shoots within the buds varied considerably and the weight of the terminal bud was three times that of the whorl buds and more than five times that of the other lateral buds.
We conclude that the increase in ZR level during the period of active bud development is indicative of the importance of cytokinin for this process. Furthermore, the positive correlation between the level of ZR and bud growth during the period of predetermination of next year's branch growth suggests that this hormone indirectly controls the form of single branches in the spruce tree.     

Estimation of cold hardiness of Douglas-fir and Engelmann spruce seedlings by differential thermal analysis of buds*

Low temperature freezing points of conifer buds were determined by differential thermal analysis and were compared to results obtained in whole plant freezing tests of the same seedlings. To obtain well-defined, meaningful exotherms, it was necessary to nucleate buds externally. The low temperature exotherms for buds occurred at temperatures very close to the lowest which seedlings tolerate with no visible injury. Thus, for Engelmann spruce and Douglas-fir, differential thermal analysis may provide a convenient prediction of containerised tree seedling hardiness.