Routine colposcopic survey of patients with squamous atypia. A method for identifying cases with false-negative smears

Routine colposcopy was performed on 376 women with cervical squamous atypia (originally reported as "inflammatory atypia"). Colposcopy showed no abnormalities in 240 cases and a lesion in 136 cases; the latter were sampled by colposcopy-guided biopsy. The biopsy samples showed evidence of human papillomavirus (HPV) infection and/or grade I cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN I) in 42 cases (11.1%), CIN II in 4 cases (1.1%) and CIN III in 5 cases (1.3%); the other 85 biopsied cases were histologically negative. Most cases of HPV/CIN I (35 of 42) and all of the cases of CIN II-III occurred in women under the age of 40. The detection rates were 4.4% for CIN II-III in women under the age of 40, 4.0% for HPV/CIN I in women 40 and older and 17.2% for HPV/CIN I in women under the age of 40 (P less than .001). It thus appears that women under the age of 40 who show cytologic evidence of squamous atypia would benefit from colposcopic examination.     

Is it possible to define a better ASCUS class in cervicovaginal screening? A review of 187 cases

OBJECTIVE: To try to better define the cytologic diagnosis of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) in a cervical screening protocol. STUDY DESIGN: Smears from 187 patients with cytologic diagnoses of ASCUS and histologic or two years' cytologic/colposcopic follow-up were reviewed. When an ASCUS diagnosis was confirmed, it was done strictly on the basis of the morphologic criteria recommended by the Regione Emilia Romagna Screening Protocol in 1997, trying also to subclassify ASCUS into favor reactive or favor neoplasia. RESULTS: Seventy ASCUS cases were negative (37.4%). Three cases (1.6%) were low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion, and seven (3.8%) were high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion. One hundred seven ASCUS cases (57.2%) were confirmed. Among the 70 negative cases, 36 (51.4%) had reactive changes on biopsy, 30 (42.9%) koilocytosis, 3 cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN 1) and one CIN not otherwise specified (5.7% total). CONCLUSION: Reclassification of ASCUS cases using tighter criteria reduced them to a rate of 57.2% but missed 30 patients with histologic diagnoses of koilocytosis and 4 with histologic diagnoses of CIN.     

The suitability of digital colposcopy for telematic applications]

Since carcinoma of the cervix is one of the most common cancers in women, screening of the cervix has acquired considerable importance. Colposcopy is a simple diagnostic method of detecting suspicious changes at an early stage. Shortcomings of this method are its low specificity and high inter- and intra-observer variability. A clinical pilot study was therefore carried out to investigate the advantages of a digital colposcopic system comprising a binocular colposcope coupled to a CCD camera and a computer. The aim of the study was to evaluate the reliability of diagnostic findings of the cervix obtained with digital colposcopy in comparison with standard binocular colposcopy, and to assess its suitability for telematic applications (teleconsultation, telediagnostics, treaching). A total of 315 patients were examined and statistically analysed. The patients were first submitted to a conventional colposcopic examination and a diagnosis was established. During the colposcopic examination camera images were stored on a computer, on the basis of which a second physician experienced in colposcopy reviewed the initial diagnosis. The primary and secondary findings of each patient were classified into 4 categories and compared following the Rome classification system. Agreement between the primary and secondary diagnosis was established in 69% of the cases (kappa = 0.60 +/- 0.03). No bias was observed in terms of under- or overrating. The percentage of non-assessable colposcopic examinations was 9.2%. Digital colposcopy is therefore suitable for reproducing diagnostic findings on the computer, given adequate digital image quality and a suitable classification model. The method has clear advantages with regard to follow-up, internal quality control of the diagnosis, and the training and further education of physicians and students. In the future, telecolposcopy may open up new opportunities in gynaecology.     

Colposcopy of patients with cytologic inflammatory epithelial changes

Of 3,308 cervical cytologies performed at a university health service between September 1986 and September 1987, 371 were reported as showing inflammatory epithelial changes (IECs). Colposcopy was offered to all patients with this diagnosis and was actually performed on 200 (54%). Of these women, 44 had an atypical transformation zone; of the 33 who were biopsied, 23 had histologic diagnoses ranging from human papillomavirus (HPV) infection (4 cases) to grade III cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN; 4 cases). Most biopsies showed CIN I. In our clinic, the 95% confidence limits for the histologic diagnosis of HPV or CIN in women with a cytologic diagnosis of IEC are 8.5% to 23.5%. Colposcopic examination of women with IEC may be able to detect patients with CIN who are missed by standard cytologic screening. Concerns about a potential bias from false-positive histology reports must be resolved before such an approach can be recommended.     

Impact of introduction of colposcopy to a district general hospital.

During the first 18 months of operation of a new colposcopy clinic, established in a district general hospital, 608 women were seen. Most (568 (93.0%] were referred from within the local district, on the whole by their general practitioner. In 466 cases a repeat cervical smear was taken, and all women underwent colposcopic examination together with directed punch biopsy of any abnormal area. Positive cytology was seen in 356 women, but 85 (23.9%) of these were found to have no histological evidence of malignancy or premalignancy and were consequently discharged from the clinic. Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia was confirmed histologically in 379 women, of whom 259 were under 35 and 175 nulliparous. As a result of the use of colposcopy and local destructive methods of treatment only 42 patients (11.1%) were required to undergo cone biopsy. The initial overall incidence of success in the treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia was 86.2% for cone biopsy, 88.5% for diathermy, and 81.1% for laser ablative treatment. Colposcopy has an important role in the management of cervical neoplasia in the district general hospital.     

Comparison of two preparation methods for endocervical evaluation

OBJECTIVE: To assess the validity of SurePath liquid-based preparation method for examination of endocervical brush specimens as a substitute for conventionally prepared cytology methods for evaluating the endocervical canal during colposcopic examination and biopsy. STUDY DESIGN: Paired SurePath liquid-based test slides and conventional smears were obtained using an endocervical brush in a split sample protocol before biopsy at the time of colposcopy. The level of agreement between cytologic results obtained was assessed. Accuracy and operating characteristics were evaluated compared to histologic follow-up. RESULTS: Agreement between cytology results for the methods was excellent. The overall kappa was 0.924 (p = 0.0000). There was exact agreement on interpretation between the methods in 283 of 299 cases (94.6%). Cytohistologic follow-up results correlation were: SurePath liquid-based Pap test results and conventional smear results agreed with histology results in 47.8% and 49.2% of cases, respectively. Allowing for a discrepancy within 1 level of severity of cytologic grade, agreements were 76.6% and 77.2%, respectively. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the SurePath method is equivalent to conventional endocervical brush cytology preparation and performs well for detection of cervical intraepithelial lesions and cancer. SurePath is acceptable for endocervical evaluation as a substitute for endocervical curettage at colposcopic biopsy.     

A thin-layer,liquid-based pap test for mass screening in an area of China with a high incidence of cervical carcinoma. A cross-sectional,comparative study

OBJECTIVE: To confirm the accuracy of the ThinPrep Pap Test (Cytyc Corp., Boxborough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) on the basis of histologic diagnosis by biopsy and the detection of human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA in mass screening. STUDY DESIGN: A total of 1,997 women residing in Xiangyuan County, Shanxi Province, P.R.C., an area with a high incidence of cervical carcinoma, were enrolled in this study. We collected exfoliative cervical samples from all subjects into a liquid buffer (Preserv-Cyt [Cytyc]) and utilized for both cytologic screening using the ThinPrep Pap Test and HPV DNA testing. Subsequent colposcopic biopsies were taken on all subjects. All the tests were performed in an independent and blinded fashion. We compared the ThinPrep Pap test with colposcopic biopsy and HPV test. RESULTS: High grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL) (CIN 2/3) were identified in 74 (3.7%) of 1,993 women adequately assessed, and there were 12 cases of squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). The false negative rate of ThinPrep cytology was 3.2% for biopsy-confirmed CIN 3 and 9.3% for CIN 2. Twenty-seven (87%) of the 31 women with biopsy-confirmed CIN 3 and 12 (100%) of 12 with biopsy-confirmed SCC had a diagnosis of either HSIL or greater abnormalities on ThinPrep cytology. In addition, the HPV DNA detection rates offered a good correlation between cytology and biopsy. CONCLUSION: The ThinPrep Pap performed extremely well in this primary screening trial. We found a good correlation between ThinPrep cytology and colposcopic biopsy on detection of HSIL and SCC; cervical specimens collected in ThinPrep liquid buffer serve as a direct test for HPV as well.     

Comparison of suspicious and positive colposcopic, cytologic and histologic findings in the uterine cervix

One hundred thirty-five cases of suspicious or positive colposcopic or cytologic findings were histologically analyzed. In cases of colposcopically detectable atypical changes or suspicious findings as well as of cytologic dysplasias or carcinomas, the histologic diagnoses were almost the same. The results demonstrated that colposcopy and cytology with a quick staining method are of value. Biopsy can quickly follow in cases of suspicious findings.     

Improving the sensitivity of cervical cytologic screening. A comparison of duplicate smears and colposcopic examination of patients with cytologic inflammatory epithelial changes

During a ten-month period, 264 cervical cytologic specimens were submitted in duplicate to two separate cytology laboratories. An attempt was made to perform colposcopy on all 45 patients reported as having an abnormality by either laboratory. All but one patient with a cytologic diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) underwent colposcopy, as did 68% of the patients with a diagnosis of nondysplastic atypia (inflammatory epithelial changes [IEC]). Five cases of histologically verified CIN were found by colposcopic study of patients with a cytologic diagnosis of CIN; two additional cases were found by colposcopic study of patients with a cytologic diagnosis of IEC. On the assumption that patients not colposcoped were not systematically different from the others with IEC, the screening sensitivities for both laboratories and for cytology followed by colposcopy of IEC cases were estimated. A statistically significant improvement in screening sensitivity was achieved by colposcopic examination of patients with IEC. This conclusion was tempered by a Bayesian analysis that suggested that some of the apparent improved sensitivity could be due to falsely positive biopsy reports. Despite potential benefits, it is premature to recommend universal colposcopic examination of patients with cytologic reports of inflammatory epithelial changes.     

Urethral cytology of Cytobrush specimens. A new technique for detecting subclinical human papillomavirus infection in men

Cytologic examination of urethral smears prepared with the Cytobrush and colposcopic examination of the penis were performed in 53 male partners of women with cervical human papillomavirus (HPV) infections and in 14 healthy controls. A diagnosis of HPV infection was recorded in 28 subjects (52.8%). Cytology was positive in 26 cases (49%) and colposcopy was positive in 5 cases, with both tests positive in 3 cases. No controls were positive by cytology or colposcopy. These findings suggest that urethral cytology and colposcopic examination should be routinely performed in partners of women with HPV infections to detect inapparent infections. The Cytobrush should be employed for the urethral cytologic sampling; smears prepared by other techniques (urine collection or urethral swabbing) yield lower detection rates.     

阴道镜及宫颈活组织检查对早期宫颈上皮内瘤变诊断价值分析

目的:探究阴道镜及宫颈活组织检查对早期宫颈上皮内瘤变(cervicalintraepithelialneoplasia,CIN)的诊断价值。方法:选择2015年3月至2018年5月于我院接受诊治的543例疑似宫颈上皮瘤变患者,分别对其实施阴道镜及宫颈活组织检查,以病理学检测结果为金标准,分别评估两种方式单独检测及联合检测对早期CIN的诊断一致性、灵敏度和特异度,并进行组间对比。结果:(1)543例疑似CIN患者病理诊断早期CIN阳性患者168例,阴性患者375例,诊断率为30.94%;阴道镜对早期CIN诊断发现阳性患者有143例,良性患者有400例,诊断率为26.34%;宫颈活组织检测对早期CIN诊断发现阳性患者有159例,良性患者有384例,诊断率为29.28%;阴道镜联合颈活组织检测对早期CIN诊断发现阳性患者有163例,良性患者有380例,诊断率为30.02%。(2)检测发现,阴道镜对早期CIN诊断一致性为81.77%,灵敏度为60.12%,特异度为91.47%。(3)宫颈活组织对早期CIN诊断一致性为91.71%,灵敏度为83.33%,特异度为95.47%。(4)阴道镜联合宫颈活组织对早期CIN诊断一致性为96.50%,灵敏度为92.86%,特异度为98.13%。(5)联合检测对早期CIN诊断的一致性、灵敏度和特异度均明显优于阴道镜及宫颈活组织单独检测。结论:阴道镜及宫颈活组织检测对早期CIN具有较好的诊断效果,但联合检测诊断准确率更高,适用于早期CIN临床筛查中。     

"Nonclassic" cytologic signs of cervical condyloma. A case-control study

The association between "nonclassic" cytologic signs of condyloma and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection in women with negative Papanicolaou smears was analyzed via a case-control study. The cytologic signs considered were mild koilocytosis, mild dyskeratosis, binucleation or multinucleation, cleared cytoplasm and nuclear hyperchromatism. The Papanicolaou smears of 166 cases that showed colposcopic and histologic evidence of HPV infection (but whose smears lacked the classic cytologic signs of condyloma) and 166 controls that were negative colposcopically were randomly admixed and blindly reviewed by a panel of cytologists. A significant association to HPV infection was observed for all of the nonclassic signs studied, but multivariate analysis showed a weakly independent association only for mild koilocytosis. The sensitivity (0.46) and the specificity (0.87) of these nonclassic signs were not satisfactory. The utility of selecting women with negative Papanicolaou smears for colposcopy on the basis of these signs is discussed.     

PCR diagnosis of HPV in cervical biopsies of CIN and invasive neoplasia formerly diagnosed as HPV negative

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate whether the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) enhances the diagnosis of human papillomavirus (HPV) in biopsies of the uterine cervix with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) or invasive neoplasia. STUDY DESIGN: Samples of 71 paraffin-embedded cervical tissue blocks from patients seen in the period 1997-1998 were analyzed. Samples were selected according to age (18-60 years old) and an active sexual life and divided in to 3 groups: test (samples with CIN or invasive neoplasia and a negative HPV diagnosis), positive controls (samples with CIN or invasive neoplasia and a positive HPV diagnosis) and negative controls (samples without CIN or invasive neoplasia and a negative HPV diagnosis). Samples were subjected to DNA extraction and PCR for HPV detection. RESULTS: PCR analysis matched the colposcopic and cytopathologic diagnoses in the positive and negative controls. However, 77% of samples in test group were HPV positive. CONCLUSION: CIN, an invasive neoplasm, is associated with the presence of HPV. Colposcopy and cytopathology are efficient but not sufficient to identify HPV. Thus, despite the high cost, PCR can be used as an additional examination, in women with cervical lesions.     

Loop diathermy excision of the cervical transformation zone in patients with abnormal cervical smears.

OBJECTIVE--To determine the efficacy and morbidity of fine loop diathermy excision of the cervical transformation zone as applied to the management of outpatients with abnormal cervical smears. DESIGN--Prospective programme trial with six month follow up. SETTING--Two hospital based colposcopy clinics. PATIENTS--616 Patients aged 16-60 with abnormal cervical smears. INTERVENTIONS--After colposcopic and cytological assessment excision of the cervical transformation zone by fine loop diathermy under local anaesthesia in the outpatient department. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Time to complete the treatment, immediate morbidity in terms of discomfort and bleeding, and cytological and colposcopic findings at six months. RESULTS--Treatment was completed in a mean of 3.47 minutes (SD 1.99). Immediate morbidity was minimal, and histological specimens were adequate in over 90% of cases. Almost two thirds of patients were treated at their first visit to the clinic. 58 Patients (9.4%) failed to attend for follow up at six months and one had had a hysterectomy. Of the 557 patients who attended for colposcopic and cytological follow up at six months, 506 (91%) were normal cytologically and 19 (3.4%) had histologically confirmed persistence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. The overall confirmed failure rate of the technique was 4.4%. CONCLUSION--Loop diathermy excision is an effective treatment with low morbidity and is an appropriate modality for patients with abnormal cervical smears.     

A comparative study in morphometric grading of transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder

To overcome the considerable observer inconsistency in the histologic grading of transitional cell carcinomas, the value of four different morphometric grading methods was investigated in 61 tumors of the bladder. Only two methods showed satisfactory reproducibility. Both methods, one based on random nuclear sampling and the other on selective nuclear sampling, showed an increase in the mean and standard deviation of the nuclear area with higher tumor grades (P less than .00001). Morphometric classification of the learning set (44 cases) was in agreement with the unequivocally assessed histologic grade in 35 cases (79.5%) using random sampling and in 38 cases (86.4%) using selective sampling. By reducing the grading classes to "low" (grades 1 and 2) and "high" (grade 3) and by introducing a classification probability threshold (0.80), an accurate morphometric classification was achieved in 38 cases (86.4%) using random sampling and in 41 cases (93.2%) using selective sampling. Of the 17 cases with histologic grading discrepancies, all 10 low-grade tumors (with discrepancies of grade 1 versus grade 2) were correctly classified as low-grade carcinomas by both of the morphometric methods; in the remaining 7 cases, with low-versus-high discrepancies (grade 2 versus grade 3), the selective method yielded better correlation with the tumor stage and clinical follow-up. It is concluded that morphometric classification is an acceptable alternative for histologic grading by pathologists, provided that the reproducibility of the method is confirmed. Although both random and selective sampling yielded satisfactory classifications, the selective method gave more reliable results as confirmed by the clinical behavior.     

Cytology of microinvasive squamous-cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix

The cervical cytology in 53 cases with histologically confirmed microinvasive squamous-cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix was studied. The smears were originally correctly diagnosed as showing microinvasion in 42% of the cases and were underinterpreted in 45%. On review, four of the underdiagnosed smears did show features of microinvasion. The depth of invasion did not have much influence on the cellular features. The patients underdiagnosed by cytology showed a tendency to have a smaller surface lesion and to have a history of a prior cervical manipulation within four weeks of the cytologic examination. The mean age of the overdiagnosed cases was distinctly higher than that of other cases. The colposcopic diagnosis correlated well with the cytologic diagnosis; both diagnostic modalities were considered to reflect well the change within the surface epithelium but to be less sensitive in recognizing the subtle changes of early invasion.     

Outcome analysis of 4 years' follow-up of patients referred for colposcopy with one smear showing mild dyskaryosis

Objective: To assess the 4‐year outcome of patients after one smear showing mild dyskaryosis with respect to smear regression rate, prevalence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and the effect of age. Methods: Retrospective analysis of patients diagnosed with initial mildly dyskaryotic smear during the year 2000 with a follow‐up period of 48 months. These women had not had any previous abnormal smears. Settings: Cytopathology Department and Colposcopy Unit, King’s College Hospital, London, UK. Results: We identified 524 patients of whom 375 patients with complete follow‐up data are included. The age range was 19–67 years with a median of 29 years. There were 207 patients aged 35 years or less (55%). At 6 months, 258 smears were performed and 47.8% of them were negative (95% CI: 41.6–54.0%). The total number of negative follow‐up smears in the first year was 198 out of a total of 397 smears performed (50%). This proportion has significantly increased between 1 and 4 years’ follow‐up to 67.5% (RR: 1.24; 95% CI: 1.14–1.35). Over the 4‐year period, 791 smears were performed and 477 were negative (60.3%; 95% CI: 56.9–63.7%). Of the 477 negative smears there were only 61 smears (12.8%; 95% CI: 10–16%), in 54 patients (14%; 95% CI: 11–18%) that reverted back to low‐grade cytological abnormality. In only one case the repeat smear showed high‐grade abnormality after initial negative follow‐up; however, on biopsy, histology showed CIN I. Out of the 375 patients, 70 required treatment with excisional biopsy (19%; 95% CI: 15.0–22.9%). Histology confirmed high‐grade CIN in only 41 cases giving a prevalence of 11% (95% CI: 8.1–14.5%). There were no cases of microinvasive or invasive cancer detected. Age (≤35 years versus >35 years) did not significantly affect either cytological or histological outcome. Conclusion: Sixty per cent of follow‐up smears after initial mild dyskaryosis subsequently became negative; of them 87.2% remained negative over the 4 year follow‐up. Treatment was only required in 19% of patients, with 11% prevalence of high‐grade CIN. Age did not affect the outcome. These results are reassuring and indicate that colposcopic referral may not be necessary after only one mildly dyskaryotic smear.     

Feasibility of cytology-based cervical cancer screening in rural Cameroon

OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence of cervical cancer and its precursors in a rural population in Cameroon and to evaluate the feasibility of a cytology-based screening program in such areas. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective study was conducted in the rural town of Bafang. Following an advocacy campaign, 750 women were recruited. After a clinical examination, all women had a Pap smear with the Cervex Brush. Each sample had two preparations, conventional and liquid based. The conventional smears were interpreted in Bafang. Cytologically abnormal cases, those with clinical inflammation and/or macroscopic cervical lesions, had a colposcopic examination and directed biopsy. HSIL and colposcopically abnormal cases were treated with large loop excision of the transformation zone (LLETZ). The liquid-based preparations and histopathology were performed in Geneva and the results sent to Cameroon for patient follow-up. RESULTS: Mean age and parity of the women screened were 43.7 years and 7.8, respectively. The conventional smears showed 3.6% cervical abnormalities: 2% (15/740) ASCUS/LSIL and 1.6% (12/740) HSIL. The liquid-based preparations showed 12.6% (91/722) cervical abnormalities: 10.1% (73/722) ASCUS/LSIL and 2.5% (18/722) HSIL. Fifty percent of samples in both preparations showed evidence of inflammation. Histology was performed on 64 colposcopically directed punch biopsies and LLETZ specimens. The histologic diagnoses agreed with the cytologic findings in 60% (14/23) of conventional smears and 85% (12/14) of liquid-based preparations. CONCLUSION: There is a high rate of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia in the unscreened rural population of Cameroon. The situation is complicated by a high rate of cervical infection. A population-based cytologic screening program for cervical cancer would not be feasible in rural Cameroon because of high cost, low quality and limited technical facilities. Rural Africa requires an algorithm using a simple, low-cost technique of mass screening and an improved cytology service only to triage selected patients.     

Overexpression of HER2/neu oncoprotein in cytologic specimens

OBJECTIVE: To assess the rate of HER2/neu overexpression in cytologic specimens by immunocytochemistry (ICC) and compare these results in matched surgical specimens by immunohistochemistry (IHC) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), when available. STUDY DESIGN: All cytologic specimens processed for HER2/neu evaluation by ICC (72 cases) and available corresponding histologic specimens (16 cases) were retrieved from our files. ICC was applied to previously Papanicolaou stained, routine fine needle aspirations specimens (64 cases) and cytocentrifuged, alcohol-fixed, fluid specimens (8 cases). FISH was performed on 6 histologic specimens. RESULTS: Overexpression of HER2/neu was seen in 7/22 breast cancers (31.8%), 3/18 pulmonary adenocarcinomas (16.6%), 2/5 colorectal adenocarcinomas (40%), 1/2 adenocarcinomas of the biliary system (50%), 1/3 thyroid papillary carcinomas (33.3%) and 1/3 prostate adenocarcinomas (33.3%). Sixteen cases had IHC in matched histologic specimens: 14 (87.5%) cases were concordant (11 negative and 3 positive in both specimens), 1 case was negative in the cytologic specimen and positive in the histologic specimen (with no amplification by FISH), and 1 case was positive in the cytologic specimen and negative in the histologic specimen (not informative by FISH). CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that overexpression of HER2/neu oncoprotein can be successfully detected in routine cytologic specimens, providing a simple, fast and cost-effective method of selecting patients for specific treatment.