PrlA and PrlG suppressors reduce the requirement for signal sequence recognition.

Selection for suppressors of defects in the signal sequence of secretory proteins has led most commonly to identification of prlA alleles and less often to identification of prlG alleles. These genes, secY/prlA and secE/prlG, encode integral membrane components of the protein translocation system of Escherichia coli. We demonstrate that an outer membrane protein, LamB, that lacks a signal sequence can be exported with reasonable efficiency in both prlA and prlG suppressor strains. Although the signal sequence is not absolutely required for export of LamB, the level of export in the absence of prl suppressor alleles is exceedingly low. Such strains are phenotypically LamB-, and functional LamB can be detected only by using sensitive infectious-center assays. Suppression of the LamB signal sequence deletion is dependent on normal components of the export pathway, indicating that suppression is not occurring through a bypass mechanism. Our results indicate that the majority of the known prlA suppressors function by an identical mechanism and, further, that the prlG suppressors work in a similar fashion. We propose that both PrlA and PrlG suppressors lack a proofreading activity that normally rejects defective precursors from the export pathway.     

Kinetic analysis of lamB mutants suggests the signal sequence plays multiple roles in protein export

We have developed a quantitative assay to measure the rate of processing of precursor LamB into mature protein and have used this assay to characterize 10 previously isolated and 3 new lamB signal sequence mutants. The data suggest that the LamB signal sequence serves a complex function. Our assay has revealed five types of signal sequence defect: 1) a strong kinetic defect resulting from alteration of the secondary structure in the putative alpha-helical region in the hydrophobic core, 2) a strong, or 3) a weak kinetic defect due to placement of a charged residue in the hydrophobic core, 4) decreased synthesis of LamB, and 5) both a decrease in synthesis and a strong kinetic defect. The effect of an extragenic suppressor, prlA4 on the rate of processing pLamB containing signal sequence mutations was also examined and compared to the rates in wild-type strains. It was found that prlA4 increases the rate of processing in some, but not all, mutants having a kinetic defect while having no effect on the decreased synthesis seen in mutants of types 4 and 5.     

Inhibition and resumption of processing of the staphylokinase in some Escherichia coli prlA suppressor mutants

Escherichia coli strains carrying certain prlA mutations (prlA4 and prlA401) could not support the processing and export of staphylokinase, resulting in the accumulation of the precursor form under high-level synthesis conditions. In order to clarify the cause of the defect in the structure of staphylokinase, we constructed signal peptide mutations of sak which suppressed the processing defect in the prlA4 cells by site-directed mutagenesis. The processing defect was suppressed when glycine or asparagine was introduced in place of the serine residue at position 17 from the amino terminus of the signal peptide. Substitutions of glycine for the leucine residue at position 15 and for the serine residue at position 19 were also effective. Other mutations we constructed had no suppression activity. Taking account of the correlation between the suppression activity and the parameter value of each substituted amino acid for the beta-turn probability, we predict that the staphylokinase signal peptide requires a more bending structure at the end of the hydrophobic core to act efficiently in the prlA4 cells than in the prl+ cells and that a function of the PrlA protein necessary to recognize the staphylokinase signal peptide has become deficient through the prlA4 mutation.     

Export of maltose-binding protein species with altered charge distribution surrounding the signal peptide hydrophobic core in Escherichia coli cells harboring prl suppressor mutations.

It is believed that one or more basic residues at the extreme amino terminus of precursor proteins and the lack of a net positive charge immediately following the signal peptide act as topological determinants that promote the insertion of the signal peptide hydrophobic core into the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli cells with the correct orientation required to initiate the protein export process. The export efficiency of precursor maltose-binding protein (pre-MBP) was found to decrease progressively as the net charge in the early mature region was increased systematically from 0 to +4. This inhibitory effect could be further exacerbated by reducing the net charge in the signal peptide to below 0. One such MBP species, designated MBP-3/+3 and having a net charge of -3 in the signal peptide and +3 in the early mature region, was totally export defective. Revertants in which MBP-3/+3 export was restored were found to harbor mutations in the prlA (secY) gene, encoding a key component of the E. coli protein export machinery. One such mutation, prlA666, was extensively characterized and shown to be a particularly strong suppressor of a variety of MBP export defects. Export of MBP-3/+3 and other MBP species with charge alterations in the early mature region also was substantially improved in E. coli cells harboring certain other prlA mutations originally selected as extragenic suppressors of signal sequence mutations altering the hydrophobic core of the LamB or MBP signal peptide. In addition, the enzymatic activity of alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) fused to a predicted cytoplasmic domain of an integral membrane protein (UhpT) increased significantly in cells harboring prlA666. These results suggest a role for PrlA/SecY in determining the orientation of signal peptides and possibly other membrane-spanning protein domains in the cytoplasmic membrane.     

Combinatorial mutagenesis of the lamB gene: residues 41 through 43, which are conserved in Escherichia coli outer membrane proteins, are informationally important in maltoporin structure and function.

A new strategy for combinatorial mutagenesis was developed and applied to residues 40 through 60 of LamB protein (maltoporin), with the aim of identifying amino acids important for LamB structure and function. The strategy involved a template containing a stop codon in the target sequence and a pool of random degenerate oligonucleotides covering the region. In vitro mutagenesis followed by selection for function (Dex+, ability to utilize dextrins) corrected the nonsense mutation and simultaneously forced incorporation of a random mutation(s) within the region. The relative importance of each residue within the target was indicated by the frequency and nature of neutral and deleterious mutations recovered at each position. Residues 41 through 43 in LamB accepted few neutral substitutions, whereas residues 55 through 57 were highly flexible in this regard. Consistent with this finding was that the majority of defective mutants were altered at residues 41 to 43. Characterization of these mutants indicated that the nature of residues 41 to 43 influenced the amount of stable protein in the outer membrane. These results, as well as the conserved nature of this stretch of residues among outer membrane proteins, suggest that residues 41 to 43 of LamB play an important role in the process of outer membrane localization.     

Expression of secreted insulin-like growth factor-1 in Escherichia coli

The synthesis, processing and secretion of insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1 or somatomedin-C) fused to LamB and OmpF secretion leader sequences in Escherichia coli have been investigated. Expression and secretion of IGF-1 was achieved. The major portion of this secreted IGF-1 accumulated in the periplasmic space as insoluble aggregates. A small amount of IGF-1 was found folded in its native conformation in the medium. The lamB and ompF signal sequences were fused to the 5' coding sequence of IGF-1. Fusion of the lamB signal sequence directly to IGF-1 (lamB-IGF-1) resulted in accumulation of 16-20 micrograms/A550/ml of correctly processed IGF-1 in the periplasmic space. The processing efficiency of LamB-IGF-1 and OmpF-IGF-1 was enhanced in an E. coli strain bearing a prlA4 mutation. Amino acid sequence analysis of IGF-1 secreted into the periplasm and exported into the medium confirmed the precise removal of the LamB or OmpF signal sequence. IGF-1 synthesized in E. coli was demonstrated to be active in a cell proliferation bioassay.     

Genetic mapping of starch- and Lambda-receptor sites in maltoporin: identification of substitutions causing direct and indirect effects on binding sites by cysteine mutagenesis

Cysteine mutagenesis was used to test the proximity of 16 residues to protein-ligand interaction sites in maltoporin (LamB protein). LamB protein with additional cysteines was incorporated into the outer membrane of Escherichia coli except with a Ser-30----Cys substitution. Phage Lambda and starch binding was assayed before and after incubation of mutants with six thiol-specific reagents. Four categories of mutation were recognized on the basis of phenotype and modification for each of the Lambda- and starch binding sites. The thiol modification experiments helped to clarify whether the phenotype of a mutation was due to a substitution at the binding site or an indirect perturbation of the structure. This study suggests that the cysteine mutagenesis/thiol modification approach may be usefully applied to the operational mapping of surface-accessible binding sites or epitopes.     

Linker mutagenesis in the gene of an outer membrane protein of Escherichia coli, lamB

In order to identify sequences involved in the localization of LamB, an outer membrane protein from E coli K12, mutagenesis by linker insertion has been performed on a lamB gene copy carried on a plasmid devised for this purpose. An analysis of the first set of 16 clones constructed by this technique shows that, in these clones, the lamB protein is altered either by frameshift mutations leading to abnormal COOH terminal (usually premature termination) or by in-phase deletions or small insertions. Except for two in-phase linker insertions, which only slightly changed the behavior of the protein, the modified proteins are either toxic to cell growth or unstable. In all cases examined so far, the modified proteins were in the outer membrane. We suggest that toxicity is due to incorrect folding, which leads to disruption of the outer membrane. The nature of the genetic alterations leads to the hypothesis that the first 183 amino acids of the LamB mature protein contain, together with the signal sequence, all the instructions needed for proper localization.     

Signal sequence mutations as tools for the characterization of LamB folding intermediates

lamBA23DA25Y and lamBA23YA25Y tether LamB to the inner membrane by blocking signal sequence processing. We isolated suppressors of lamBA23DA25Y and lamBA23YA25Y, all of which mapped within the LamB signal sequence. Most interesting were mutations that changed an amino acid with a strong positive charge to an amino acid with no charge. Further characterization of two such suppressors revealed that they produce functional LamB that is localized to the outer membrane with its entire signal sequence still attached. Biochemical analysis shows that mutant LamB monomer chases into an oligomeric species with properties different from those of wild-type LamB trimer. Because assembly of mutant LamB is slowed, these mutations provide useful tools for the characterization of LamB folding intermediates.     

Role of a disulfide bond in the thermal stability of the LamB protein trimer in Escherichia coli outer membrane

In order to understand the unusual heat resistance of LamB protein (the outer membrane component of the maltose transport system in Escherichia coli and its receptor for bacteriophage lambda), we investigated the role of its 2 cysteinyl residues. Our studies show that Cys22 and Cys38 form an intrasubunit disulfide bond which contributes to the heat stability of the LamB protein trimer. Physical evidence for the disulfide was obtained by using site-directed mutagenesis to convert Asn36 to Met, which allowed cyanogen bromide cleavage between the 2 cysteines. Upon reduction one of the N36M fragments migrated as two pieces, resolved by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Other mutagenized LamB proteins, in which 1 or both Cys residues were converted to Ser, exhibited a sharp loss of thermal stability. In contrast to wild-type LamB protein trimer, which does not dissociate to monomers even after 60 min at 100 degrees C, only 10-15% of the mutant LamB proteins remain trimeric after boiling 10 min. The disulfide bond in LamB protein is not required for its transport function, since both mutagenized LamB protein and N-ethylmaleimide-labeled LamB protein exhibit normal uptake of sugars in proteoliposomes. Finally, the disulfide bond must not be between subunits of the LamB trimer since reversible dissociation of trimer is achieved by low pH or denaturants in the absence of reducing agent.     

A previously unidentified gene in the spc operon of Escherichia coli K12 specifies a component of the protein export machinery

The gene prlA codes for a factor that appears to function in the export of proteins in Escherichia coli. This conclusion is based on the finding that mutations altering the prlA gene product restore export of envelope proteins with defective signal sequences. Previous results showed that the prlA gene lies in an operon (spc) known to code for ten different ribosomal proteins. Our studies show that the prlA gene lies promoter-distal to the last known ribosomal protein gene in this operon. Evidence from gene fusions constructed in vitro suggests that prlA codes for a protein containing at least 300 amino acids. Thus a heretofore unidentified protein specified by a gene within the spc operon appears to be a component of the cellular protein export machinery.     

PrlA suppressor mutations cluster in regions corresponding to three distinct topological domains.

The SecY protein of Escherichia coli and its homologues in other organisms, are integral components of the cellular protein translocation machinery. Suppressor mutations that alter SecY (the prlA alleles) broaden the specificity of this machinery and allow secretion of precursor proteins with defective signal sequences. Twenty-five prlA alleles have been characterized. These suppressor mutations were found to cluster in regions corresponding to three distinct topological domains of SecY. Based on the nature and position of the prlA mutations, we propose that transmembrane domain 7 of SecY functions in signal sequence recognition. Results suggest that this interaction may involve a right-handed supercoil of alpha-helices. Suppressor mutations that alter this domain appear to prevent signal sequence recognition, and this novel mechanism of suppression suggests a proofreading function for SecY. We propose that suppressor mutations that alter a second domain of SecY, transmembrane helix 10, also affect this proof-reading function, but indirectly. Based on the synthetic phenotypes exhibited by double mutants, we propose that these mutations strengthen the interaction with another component of the translocation machinery, SecE. Suppressor mutations were also found to cluster in a region corresponding to an amino-terminal periplasmic domain. Possible explanations for this unexpected finding are discussed.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of the greasy slide aromatic residues within the LamB (maltoporin) channel of Escherichia coli: effect on ion and maltopentaose transport

The 3D-structure of the maltooligosaccharide-specific LamB-channel of Escherichia coli (also called maltoporin) is known from X-ray crystallography. The 3D structure suggests that a number of aromatic residues (Y6, Y41, W74, F229, W358 and W420) within the channel lumen are involved in carbohydrate and ion transport. All aromatic residues were replaced by alanine-scanning mutagenesis. Furthermore, LamB mutants were created in which two, three, four, five and all six aromatic residues were replaced to study their effects on ion and maltopentaose transport through LamB. The purified mutant proteins were reconstituted into lipid bilayer membranes and the single-channel conductance of the mutants was studied in conductance experiments. The results suggest that all aromatic residues provide some steric hindrance for ion transport through LamB. Highest impact is provided by Y6 and Y41 that are localized opposite Y118, which form the central constriction of the LamB channel. Stability constants for binding of maltopentaose to the mutant channels were measured using titration experiments with the carbohydrate. The mutation of one or several aromatic residue(s) led to a substantial decrease of the stability constant of binding. The highest effect was observed when all aromatic residues were replaced by alanine because no binding of maltopentaose could be detected in such a case. However, binding was again possible when Y118 was replaced by tryptophan. The carbohydrate-induced block of the channel function could be used also for the study of current noise through the different mutant LamB-channels. The analysis of the power density spectra of some of the mutants allowed the evaluation of the on-rate and off-rate constants (k1 and k(-1)) of carbohydrate binding to the binding site inside the channels. The results suggest that both on-rate and off-rate constants were affected by the mutations. For most mutants, k1 decreased and k(-1) increased. The possible influence of the aromatic residues of the greasy slide on carbohydrate and ion transport through LamB is discussed.     

Genetic analysis of sequences in maltoporin that contribute to binding domains and pore structure.

Maltoporin (LamB protein) is a maltodextrin transport protein in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli with binding sites for bacteriophage lambda and maltosaccharides. Binding of starch by bacteria was found to inhibit swarming of Escherichia coli in soft agar plates; the inhibition was dependent on the maltodextrin affinity of maltoporin. On the basis of this observation, chemotactic cell-sorting techniques were developed for the isolation and analysis of mutants with an altered starch-binding phenotype. Fifteen lamB mutations generated by hydroxylamine and linker mutagenesis, as well as spontaneous mutations, were analyzed. The effects of the mutations on starch and lambda-binding, as well as transport specificity, were assayed. Mutations that affect residues near 8 to 18, 74 to 82, and 118 to 121 were found to affect starch binding and maltodextrin-selective functions strongly, confirming and extending previous results with substitutions at these regions. Substitutions and insertions in two previously undefined regions in the protein, in or near residues 194 and 360, also resulted in defects in maltodextrin-specific functions and indicate that C-terminal parts of the protein also contribute to the discontinuous binding and pore domains. There was a detectable transport defect in all binding-affected mutants, and one mutation caused near-total pore blocking towards both maltose and nonmaltoside. The highly discontinuous phage lambda-binding site was affected by mutations near residues 9 and 10 and 194, as well as previously established regions near residues 18, 148 to 165, 245 to 259, and 380 to 400. The significance of these mutations is discussed in the context of a model of the functional topology of maltoporin. The additional role of regions near residues 10 and 120 in maltoporin assembly, as well as starch binding, was suggested by the temperature-sensitive biogenesis of maltoporin in strains with one- or two-codon insertion at these sites.     

A new suppressor of a lamB signal sequence mutation, prlZ1, maps to 69 minutes on the Escherichia coli chromosome.

Reversion analysis has been employed to isolate suppressors that restore export of a unique LamB signal sequence mutant. The mutation results in a substitution of Arg for Met at position 19, which prevents LamB export to the outer membrane and leads to a Dex- phenotype. Unlike other LamB signal sequence mutants utilized for reversion analysis, LamB19R becomes stably associated with the inner membrane in an export-specific manner. In this study, Dex+ revertants were selected and various suppressors were isolated. One of the extragenic suppressors, designated prlZ1, was chosen for further study. prlZ1 maps to 69 min on the Escherichia coli chromosome. The suppressor is dominant and SecB dependent. In addition to its effect on lamB19R, prlZ1 suppresses the export defect of signal sequence point mutations at positions 12, 15, and 16, as well as several point mutations in the maltose-binding protein signal sequence. prlZ1 does not suppress deletion mutations in either signal sequence. This pattern of suppression can be explained by interaction of a helical LamB signal sequence with the suppressor.     

Novel prlA alleles defective in supporting staphylokinase processing in Escherichia coli

A class of prlA (secY) alleles of Escherichia coli (prlA4-1 and prlA401) which specifically block the export of staphylokinase has been identified (T. Iino and T. Sako, J. Biol. Chem. 263:19077-19082, 1988; T. Sako and T. Iino, J. Bacteriol. 170:5389-5391, 1988). To determine more precisely the region in PrlA (SecY) effective for the blockage of processing of the staphylokinase precursor, additional prlA mutants which failed to support processing of the staphylokinase precursor were isolated. Two of the five mutant alleles isolated (secY121 and secY161) complemented the temperature sensitivity of a secY24 strain and had no detectable effect on the processing of endogenous secretory proteins of E. coli. In addition, a staphylokinase mutant having glycine in place of serine at position 17 in its signal sequence relieved the detrimental effect of these mutations. All of these characteristics indicate that these two alleles resemble the prlA4-1 and prlA401 alleles. On the other hand, the remaining three mutant alleles (secY47, secY105, and secY112) had no significant PrlA activity. The mutations of secY121 and secY161 were mapped very close to those of prlA4-1 and prlA401 in the presumed transmembrane segment 7 of PrlA. These results indicate that transmembrane segment 7 of PrlA plays a crucial role in the recognition of the staphylokinase signal sequence.     

The PrlA and PrlG phenotypes are caused by a loosened association among the translocase SecYEG subunits.

prlA mutations in the gene encoding the SecY subunit of the membrane domain of the Escherichia coli preprotein translocase confer many phenotypes: enhanced translocation rates, increased affinity for SecA, diminished requirement for functional leader sequences, reduced proton-motive force (PMF) dependence of preprotein translocation and facilitated translocation of preproteins with folded domains. We now report that both prlA and prlG mutations weaken the associations between the SecY, SecE and SecG subunits of the translocase. This loosened association increases the initiation of translocation by facilitating the insertion of SecA with its bound preprotein but reduces the stimulatory effect of the PMF during the initial step of translocation. Furthermore, the originally isolated prlA4 mutant, which possesses a particularly labile SecYEG complex, acquired a secondary mutation that restored the stability while conserving the flexibility of the complex. Combinations of certain prlA and prlG mutations, known to cause synthetic lethality in vivo, dramatically loosen subunit association and lead to complete disassembly of SecYEG. These findings underscore the importance of the loosened SecYEG association for the Prl phenotypes. We propose a model in which each of the PrlA and PrlG phenotypes derive from this enhanced SecYEG conformational flexibility.     

Sucrose transport through maltoporin mutants of Escherichia coli.

Maltoporin (LamB) and sucrose porin (ScrY) reside in the bacterial outer membrane and facilitate the passive diffusion of maltodextrins and sucrose, respectively. To gain further insight into the determinants of solute specificity, LamB mutants were designed to allow translocation of sucrose, which hardly translocates through wild-type LamB. Three LamB mutants were studied. (a) Based on sequence and structure alignment of LamB with ScrY, two LamB triple mutants were generated (R109D, Y118D,D121F; R109N,Y118D,D121F) to mimic the ScrY constriction. The crystal structure of the first of these mutants was determined to be 3.2 A and showed an increased ScrY-like cross-section except for D109 that protrudes into the channel. (b) Based on this crystal structure a double mutant was generated by truncation of the two residues that obstruct the channel most in LamB (R109A,Y118A). Analysis of liposome swelling and in vivo sugar uptake demonstrated substantial sucrose permeation through all mutants with the double alanine mutant performing best. The triple mutants did not show a well-defined binding site as indicated by sugar-induced ion current noise analysis, which can be explained by remaining steric interference as deduced from the crystal structure. Binding, however, was observed for the double mutant that had the obstructing residues truncated to alanines.     

Signal sequence processing is required for the assembly of LamB trimers in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli.

Proteins destined for either the periplasm or the outer membrane of Escherichia coli are translocated from the cytoplasm by a common mechanism. It is generally assumed that outer membrane proteins, such as LamB (maltoporin or lambda receptor), which are rich in beta-structure, contain additional targeting information that directs proper membrane insertion. During transit to the outer membrane, these proteins may pass, in soluble form, through the periplasm or remain membrane associated and reach their final destination via sites of inner membrane-outer membrane contact (zones of adhesion). We report lamB mutations that slow signal sequence cleavage, delay release of the protein from the inner membrane, and interfere with maltoporin biogenesis. This result is most easily explained by proposing a soluble, periplasmic LamB assembly intermediate. Additionally, we found that such lamB mutations confer several novel phenotypes consistent with an abortive attempt by the cell to target these tethered LamB molecules. These phenotypes may allow isolation of mutants in which the process of outer membrane protein targeting is altered.