Identification of a highly immunogenic mouse breast cancer sub cell line, 4T1-S

Cancer vaccines serve as a promising clinical immunotherapeutic strategy that help to trigger an effective and specific antitumor immune response compared to conventional therapies. However, poor immunogenicity of tumor cells remains a major obstacle for clinical application, and developing new methods to modify the immunogenicity of tumor cells may help to improve the clinical outcome of cancer vaccines. 4T1 mouse breast cancer cell line has been known as poorly immunogenic and highly metastatic cell line. Using this model, we identified a sub cell line of 4T1—designated as 4T1-Sapporo (4T1-S)—which shows immunogenic properties when used as a vaccine against the same line. In 4T1-S-vaccinated mice, subcutaneous injection of 4T1-S resulted in an antitumor inflammatory response represented by significant enlargement of draining lymph nodes, accompanied with increased frequencies of activated CD8 T cells and a subpopulation of myeloid cells. Additionally, 4T1-S vaccine was ineffective to induce tumor rejection in nude mice, which importantly indicate that 4T1-S vaccine rely on T cell response to induce tumor rejection. Further analysis to identify mechanisms that control tumor immunogenicity in this model may help to develop new methods for improving the efficacies of clinical cancer vaccines.     

Reinforcing the immunogenic cell death to enhance cancer immunotherapy efficacy

Immunogenic cell death (ICD) has been a revolutionary modality in cancer treatment since it kills primary tumors and prevents recurrent malignancy simultaneously. ICD represents a particular form of cancer cell death accompanied by production of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) that can be recognized by pattern recognition receptors (PRRs), which enhances infiltration of effector T cells and potentiates antitumor immune responses. Various treatment methods can elicit ICD involving chemo- and radio-therapy, phototherapy and nanotechnology to efficiently convert dead cancer cells into vaccines and trigger the antigen-specific immune responses. Nevertheless, the efficacy of ICD-induced therapies is restrained due to low accumulation in the tumor sites and damage of normal tissues. Thus, researchers have been devoted to overcoming these problems with novel materials and strategies. In this review, current knowledge on different ICD modalities, various ICD inducers, development and application of novel ICD-inducing strategies are summarized. Moreover, the prospects and challenges are briefly outlined to provide reference for future design of novel immunotherapy based on ICD effect.     

Capsaicin as an inducer of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) of immunogenic cell death (ICD) in human bladder cancer cells

Few conventional cytotoxic anticancer therapeutics induce immunogenic cell death (ICD). This means that they induce tumor cells to undergo apoptosis while eliciting the emission of a spatiotemporal-defined combination of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) decoded by the immune system to activate antitumor immunity effective for long-term therapeutic success. The neurotoxin capsaicin (CPS) can induce both cancer cell apoptosis and immune-mediated tumor regression. In the present study, we investigated whether CPS is capable of eliciting the emission of ICD hallmarks in human bladder cancer cell lines undergoing apoptosis. We demonstrated that CPS induces pre- and early apoptotic cell surface exposure of calreticulin (CRT), HSP90, and HSP70 as well as ATP release. Moreover, CRT exposure was prevented by inhibition of endoplasmic reticulum–Golgi traffic by brefeldin A. Furthermore, high-mobility group box 1, HSP90, and HSP70 were passively released at late apoptotic stages. We provide the first evidence that CPS is an inducer of ICD hallmarks, suggesting CPS as a novel potential immunogenic cytotoxic agent.     

Cytotoxic immunotherapy strategies for cancer: mechanisms and clinical development

Traditional therapies for cancer include surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation. Chemotherapy has widespread systemic cytotoxic effects against tumor cells but also affects normal cells. Radiation has more targeted local cytotoxicity but is limited to killing cells in the radiation field. Immunotherapy has the potential for systemic, specific killing of tumor cells. However, if the immune response is specific to a single antigen, tumor evasion can occur by down-regulation of that antigen. An immunotherapy approach that induces polyvalent immunity to autologous tumor antigens can provide a personalized vaccine with less potential for immunologic escape. A cytotoxic immunotherapy strategy creates such a tumor vaccine in situ. Immunogenic tumor cell death provides tumor antigen targets for the adaptive immune response and stimulates innate immunity. Attraction and activation of antigen presenting cells such as dendritic cells is important to process and present tumor antigens to T cells. These include cytotoxic T cells that kill tumor cells and T cells which positively and negatively regulate immunity. Tipping the balance in favor of anti-tumor immunity is an important aspect of an effective strategy. Clinically, immunotherapies may be most effective when combined with standard therapies in a complimentary way. An example is gene-mediated cytotoxic immunotherapy (GMCI) which uses an adenoviral vector, AdV-tk, to deliver a cytotoxic and immunostimulatory gene to tumor cells in vivo in combination with standard therapies creating an immunostimulatory milieu. This approach, studied extensively in animal models and early stage clinical trials, is now entering a definitive Phase 3 trial for prostate cancer.     

Hypothesis on the possible relevance of the immunogenic cell death in the treatment of gestational trophoblastic neoplasms

The genetic background and the antigenic landscape of cancer cells play a critical role in the response to immunotherapies. A high tumor antigenicity, together with an increased adjuvanticity potentially induced by a peculiar type of cell death, namely immunogenic cell death (ICD), could foster the response to immunogenic therapies. The gestational trophoblastic neoplasm (GTN) is a one-of-a-kind cancer in the oncological landscape due to its exclusive genomic makeup. The prognosis of GTN is significantly better than non-gestational trophoblastic neoplasm (nGTN). Due to its peculiar genetic inheritance, GTN potentially constitutes a singular archetype in the immuno-oncological field.     

Hypothesis on the possible relevance of the immunogenic cell death in the treatment of gestational trophoblastic neoplasms

The genetic background and the antigenic landscape of cancer cells play a critical role in the response to immunotherapies. A high tumor antigenicity, together with an increased adjuvanticity potentially induced by a peculiar type of cell death, namely immunogenic cell death (ICD), could foster the response to immunogenic therapies. The gestational trophoblastic neoplasm (GTN) is a one-of-a-kind cancer in the oncological landscape due to its exclusive genomic makeup. The prognosis of GTN is significantly better than non-gestational trophoblastic neoplasm (nGTN). Due to its peculiar genetic inheritance, GTN potentially constitutes a singular archetype in the immuno-oncological field.     

Molecular characteristics of immunogenic cancer cell death

Apoptotic cell death is initiated by a morphologically homogenous entity that was considered to be non-immunogenic and non-inflammatory in nature. However, recent advances suggest that apoptosis, under certain circumstances, can be immunogenic. In particular, some characteristics of the plasma membrane, acquired at preapoptotic stage, can cause immune effectors to recognize and attack preapoptotic tumor cells. The signals that mediate the immunogenicity of tumor cells involve elements of the DNA damage response (such as ataxia telangiectasia mutated and p53 activation), elements of the endoplasmic reticulum stress response (such as eukaryotic initiation factor 2alpha phosphorylation), as well as elements of the apoptotic response (such as caspase activation). Depending on the signal-transduction pathway, tumor cells responding to chemotherapy or radiotherapy can express 'danger' and 'eat me' signals on the cell surface (such as NKG2D ligands, heat-shock proteins and calreticulin) or can secrete/release immunostimulatory factors (such as cytokines and high-mobility group box 1) to stimulate innate immune effectors. Likewise, the precise sequence of such events influences the 'decision' of the immune system to mount a cognate response or not. We therefore anticipate that the comprehension of the mechanisms governing the immunogenicity of cell death will have a profound impact on the design of anticancer therapies.     

Multimodal immunogenic cancer cell death as a consequence of anticancer cytotoxic treatments

Apoptotic cell death generally characterized by a morphologically homogenous entity has been considered to be essentially non-immunogenic. However, apoptotic cancer cell death, also known as type 1 programmed cell death (PCD), was recently found to be immunogenic after treatment with several chemotherapeutic agents and oncolytic viruses through the emission of various danger-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs). Extensive studies have revealed that two different types of immunogenic cell death (ICD) inducers, recently classified by their distinct actions in endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, can reinitiate immune responses suppressed by the tumor microenvironment. Indeed, recent clinical studies have shown that several immunotherapeutic modalities including therapeutic cancer vaccines and oncolytic viruses, but not conventional chemotherapies, culminate in beneficial outcomes, probably because of their different mechanisms of ICD induction. Furthermore, interests in PCD of cancer cells have shifted from its classical form to novel forms involving autophagic cell death (ACD), programmed necrotic cell death (necroptosis), and pyroptosis, some of which entail immunogenicity after anticancer treatments. In this review, we provide a brief outline of the well-characterized DAMPs such as calreticulin (CRT) exposure, high-mobility group protein B1 (HMGB1), and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) release, which are induced by the morphologically distinct types of cell death. In the latter part, our review focuses on how emerging oncolytic viruses induce different forms of cell death and the combinations of oncolytic virotherapies with further immunomodulation by cyclophosphamide and other immunotherapeutic modalities foster dendritic cell (DC)-mediated induction of antitumor immunity. Accordingly, it is increasingly important to fully understand how and which ICD inducers cause multimodal ICD, which should aid the design of reasonably multifaceted anticancer modalities to maximize ICD-triggered antitumor immunity and eliminate residual or metastasized tumors while sparing autoimmune diseases.     

Dendritic cells and innate defense against tumor cells

Tumor growth results from a delicate balance between intrinsic dysregulation of oncogenes, tumor suppressor and stability genes counteracted by extrinsic defenses composed of immune cells shaping tumor immunogenicity. Although immune subversion might be the ultimate outcome of this process, a complex network of cellular interactions take place eventually leading to tumor specific cognate immune responses. The links between innate and cognate antitumor immunity eliciting protective T cell responses are instigated by cytokines, chemokines and damage associated molecular patterns. The intricate differentiation pathway whereby dendritic cells could undergo an efficient maturation program in the tumor microenvironment appears crucial. We will discuss the role of innate effectors and cancer therapies in the process of defense against tumor cells.     

Crosstalk between ER stress and immunogenic cell death

Preclinical and clinical findings suggest that tumor-specific immune responses may be responsible – at least in part – for the clinical success of therapeutic regimens that rely on immunogenic cell death (ICD) inducers, including anthracyclines and oxaliplatin. The molecular pathways whereby some, but not all, cytotoxic agents promote bona fide ICD remain to be fully elucidated. Nevertheless, a central role for the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response has been revealed in all scenarios of ICD described thus far. Hence, components of the ER stress machinery may constitute clinically relevant druggable targets for the induction of ICD. In this review, we will summarize recent findings in the field of ICD research with a special focus on ER stress mechanisms and their implication for cancer therapy.     

The Achilles’ heel of cancer: targeting tumors via lysosome-induced immunogenic cell death

Interest in the lysosome’s potential role in anticancer therapies has recently been appreciated in the field of immuno-oncology. Targeting lysosomes triggers apoptotic pathways, inhibits cytoprotective autophagy, and activates a unique form of apoptosis known as immunogenic cell death (ICD). This mechanism stimulates a local and systemic immune response against dead-cell antigens. Stressors that can lead to ICD include an abundance of ROS which induce lysosome membrane permeability (LMP). Dying cells express markers that activate immune cells. Dendritic cells engulf the dying cell and then present the cell’s neoantigens to T cells. The discovery of ICD-inducing agents is important due to their potential to trigger autoimmunity. In this review, we discuss the various mechanisms of activating lysosome-induced cell death in cancer cells specifically and the strategies that current laboratories are using to selectively promote LMP in tumors.Subject terms: Cancer immunotherapy, Immunotherapy, Tumour immunology, Apoptosis, Adaptive immunity     

Chaperone-rich cell lysates, immune activation and tumor vaccination

We have utilized a free-solution-isoelectric focusing technique (FS-IEF) to obtain chaperone-rich cell lysates (CRCL) fractions from clarified tumor homogenates. The FS-IEF technique for enriching multiple chaperones from tumor lysate is relatively easy and rapid, yielding sufficient immunogenic material for clinical use. We have shown that tumor-derived CRCL carry antigenic peptides. Dendritic cells (DCs) uptake CRCL and cross-present the chaperoned peptides to T cells. Tumor-derived CRCL induce protective immune responses against a diverse range of murine tumor types in different genetic backgrounds. When compared to purified heat shock protein 70 (HSP70), single antigenic peptide or unfractionated lysate, CRCL have superior ability to activate/mature DCs and are able to induce potent, long lasting and tumor specific T-cell-mediated immunity. While CRCL vaccines were effective as stand-alone therapies, the enhanced immunogenicity arising from CRCL-pulsed DC as a vaccine indicates that CRCL could be the antigen source of choice for DC-based anti-cancer immunotherapies. The nature of CRCL's enhanced immunogenicity may lie in the broader antigenic peptide repertoire as well as the superior immune activation capacity of CRCL. Exongenous CRCL also supply danger signals in the context of apoptotic tumor cells and enhance the immunogenicity of apoptotic tumor cells, leading to tumor-specific T cell dependent long-term immunity. Moreover, CRCL based vaccines can be effectively combined with chemotherapy to treat cancer. Our findings indicate that CRCL have prominent adjuvant effects and are effective sources of tumor antigens for pulsing DCs. Tumor-derived CRCL are promising anti-cancer vaccines that warrant clinical research and development.     

Mapping of SJL/J reticulum cell sarcoma tumor-associated Ia antigens by T cell hybridomas: characterization of tumor-specific and shared epitopes detected on IE+ allogeneic cells

Previous studies have suggested that reticulum cell sarcoma (RCS) tumor cells of SJL/J (IA + IE-) mice express neospecificities that are related to antigenic specificities characteristic of IE+ allogeneic cells. These neospecificities have also been suggested to play a role in the strong syngeneic antitumor proliferative response as well as in regulating RCS growth in vivo. The present studies characterize four RCS tumor-specific T cell hybridoma clones prepared from the fusion of BW5147 thymoma with T cells derived from lymph nodes of tumor-bearing mice. Upon stimulation, these hybridomas secrete IL 2 in the supernatant. Two hybridomas responded to RCS to IE+k and to IE+d allogeneic cells, respectively, and the other two hybridomas were tumor specific. The specificity of these hybridomas was assessed by response to both spontaneous and transplantable RCS lines and failure to stimulate a response by either normal or LPS-induced B cell blasts from the host SJL/J cells. The epitopes recognized by the T cell hybridomas were examined by the ability of several monoclonal antibodies to inhibit the IL 2-induced response by the T cell hybridomas. Antibodies directed against the IABs polypeptide of the IA hybrid molecule blocked the antitumor response by all four hybridomas. However, the response to allogeneic IE+ cells was not blocked by anti-IAs antibody but was blocked by antibodies directed against either the IAk,d or IEk,d hybrid molecules or the corresponding alpha- or beta-chains. The response to both RCS and allogeneic cells was blocked by monoclonal antibodies directed against L3T4 antigens on the T cells. Based on the exquisite specificity of the T cell receptors, the results here demonstrate that RCS tumor cells express on their surface both tumor-specific I-A-associated epitopes and Ia-associated antigenic specificities that are shared with IE+ allogeneic cells. The present studies of adapting T cell hybridomas and blocking antibodies proved useful to characterize and map distinct tumor-associated epitopes on the surface of tumor cells. These findings, when combined with structural studies, should help unravel the molecular complexity of tumor-associated antigens.     

Cancer chemotherapy: not only a direct cytotoxic effect, but also an adjuvant for antitumor immunity

Treatment of metastatic cancer mainly relies on chemotherapy. Chemotherapeutic agents kill tumor cells by direct cytotoxicity, thus leading to tumor regression. However, emerging data focus on another side of cancer chemotherapy: its antitumor immunity effect. Although cancer chemotherapy was usually considered as immunosuppressive, some chemotherapeutic agents have recently been shown to activate an anticancer immune response, which is involved in the curative effect of these treatments. Cancer development often leads to the occurrence of an immune tolerance that prevents cancer rejection by the immune system and hinders efficacy of immunotherapy. Cancer cells induce proliferation and local accumulation of immunosuppressive cells such as regulatory T cells and immature myeloid cells, and prevent the maturation of dendritic cells and their capacity to present tumor antigens to T lymphocytes. Many anticancer cytotoxic agents interfere with the molecular and cellular mechanisms leading to tumor-induced tolerance. They can restore an efficient immune response that contributes to the therapeutic effects of chemotherapy. These findings open a novel field of investigations for future clinical trial design, taking into account the immunostimulatory capacity of chemotherapeutic agents, and using them in combined chemo-immunotherapy strategies when tumor-induced tolerance is overcome.     

Tumor stress, cell death and the ensuing immune response

A cornucopia of physiological and pathological circumstances including anticancer chemotherapy and radiotherapy can induce cell death. However, the immunological consequences of tumor cell demise have remained largely elusive. The paradigm opposing 'apoptosis versus necrosis' as to their respective immunogenicity does not currently hold to predict long-term immunity. Moreover, the notion that tumor cells may be 'stressed' before death to be recognized by immune cells deserves to be underlined. 'Eat-me', 'danger' and 'killing' signals released by stressed tumor under the pressure of cytotoxic compounds may serve as links between the chemotherapy-elicited response of tumor cells and subsequent immune responses. This review will summarize the state-of-the-art of cancer immunity and describe how tumor cell death dictates the links between innate and acquired immunity.     

Molecular mechanisms of ATP secretion during immunogenic cell death

The immunogenic demise of cancer cells can be induced by various chemotherapeutics, such as anthracyclines and oxaliplatin, and provokes an immune response against tumor-associated antigens. Thus, immunogenic cell death (ICD)-inducing antineoplastic agents stimulate a tumor-specific immune response that determines the long-term success of therapy. The release of ATP from dying cells constitutes one of the three major hallmarks of ICD and occurs independently of the two others, namely, the pre-apoptotic exposure of calreticulin on the cell surface and the postmortem release of high-mobility group box 1 (HMBG1) into the extracellular space. Pre-mortem autophagy is known to be required for the ICD-associated secretion of ATP, implying that autophagy-deficient cancer cells fail to elicit therapy-relevant immune responses in vivo. However, the precise molecular mechanisms whereby ATP is actively secreted in the course of ICD remain elusive. Using a combination of pharmacological screens, silencing experiments and techniques to monitor the subcellular localization of ATP, we show here that, in response to ICD inducers, ATP redistributes from lysosomes to autolysosomes and is secreted by a mechanism that requires the lysosomal protein LAMP1, which translocates to the plasma membrane in a strictly caspase-dependent manner. The secretion of ATP additionally involves the caspase-dependent activation of Rho-associated, coiled-coil containing protein kinase 1 (ROCK1)-mediated, myosin II-dependent cellular blebbing, as well as the opening of pannexin 1 (PANX1) channels, which is also triggered by caspases. Of note, although autophagy and LAMP1 fail to influence PANX1 channel opening, PANX1 is required for the ICD-associated translocation of LAMP1 to the plasma membrane. Altogether, these findings suggest that caspase- and PANX1-dependent lysosomal exocytosis has an essential role in ATP release as triggered by immunogenic chemotherapy.     

T cell immunity induced by live, necrotic, and apoptotic tumor cells

The rules that govern the engagement of antitumor immunity are not yet fully understood. Ags expressed by tumor cells are prone to induce T cell tolerance unless the innate immune system is activated. It is unclear to what extent tumors engage this second signal link by the innate immune system. Apoptotic and necrotic (tumor) cells are readily recognized and phagocytosed by the cells of the innate immune system. It is unknown how this affects the tumor's immunogenicity. Using a murine melanoma (B16m) and lymphoma (L5178Y-R) model, we studied the clonal sizes and cytokine signatures of the T cells induced by these tumors in syngeneic mice when injected as live, apoptotic, and necrotic cells. Both live tumors induced a type 2 CD4 cell response characterized by the prevalent production of IL-2, IL-4, and IL-5 over IFN-gamma. Live, apoptotic, and necrotic cells induced CD4 (but no CD8) T cells of comparable frequencies and cytokine profiles. Therefore, live tumors engaged the second signal link, and apoptotic or necrotic tumor cell death did not change the magnitude or quality of the antitumor response. A subclone of L5178Y-R, L5178Y-S cells, were found to induce a high-frequency type 1 response by CD4 and CD8 cells that conveyed immune protection. The data suggest that the immunogenicity of tumors, and their characteristics to induce type 1 or type 2, CD4 or CD8 cell immunity is not primarily governed by signals associated with apoptotic or necrotic cell death, but is an intrinsic feature of the tumor itself.     

Immunogenicity of subcellular fractions and molecular species of MuLV-induced tumors

Summary YBA, a Moloney virus-induced leukemia in CBA mice, and a relatively weak immunogenic tumor, was screened for the presence of immunogenic antigens. The tumor was subjected to homogenization and subcellular fractionation on sucrose gradients; the immunogenic subcellular fractions underwent further separation by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). The immunogenicity of the subcellular fractions and the SDS-PAGE-isolated molecular species were tested by (their) subcutaneous injection into syngeneic mice and examination of their splenocytes examined against tumor cell and normal cell targets by the chromium release cell-mediated lympholysis assay. Tumor cell homogenates were also separated by SDS-PAGE and tested for immunogenicity without prior fractionation.Splenocytes from mice that had received injections of certain SDS-PAGE-isolated epitopes derived from YBA tumor homogenate or its light and heavy subcellular fractions generated effective cytotoxic responses against YBA target cells after 6 days in vitro cultivation. In contrast, intact YBA tumor cells or non-separated tumor homogenates failed to induce an efficient cytotoxic response. The effector cells induced with the immunogenic SDS-PAGE-isolated epitopes of YBA tumor were specific, since they cytolysed the homologous target cells more efficiently than unrelated target cells or syngeneic normal cells. The activity of these effector cells was affected by varying the effector : target ratio. Augmentation of the cytotoxic responses was obtained when the splenocytes of mice immunized with SDS-PAGE-isolated epitopes of YBA tumor were restimulated in vitro, with the homologous neoplastic cells.Immunogenic SDS-PAGE epitopes were isolated from YAC tumor also (YAC is a Moloney-induced tumor of A mice). The effector cells induced with these separated epitopes were characterized as thymus-derived cells and not as natural killer cells.The results suggest that (1) the molecular repertoire of YBA and YBA tumors contain immunogens that can induce a specific antitumor cell-mediated response; (2) the isolated molecular species injected are more efficient immunogens than the entire, unseparated homogenate sample or a dose of 10⁸ intact inactivated tumor cells; and (3) the gel matrix may be responsible for the enhanced cell-mediated response induced against the weakly immunogenic tumor.