Effect of frost nights and day and night temperature during dormancy induction on frost hardiness, tolerance to cold storage and bud burst in seedlings of Norway spruce

For trees, the ability to obtain and maintain sufficient levels of frost hardiness in late autumn, winter and spring is crucial. We report that temperatures during dormancy induction influence bud set, frost hardiness, tolerance to cold storage, timing of bud burst and spring frost hardiness in seedlings of Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.). Bud set occurred later in 12°C than in 21°C, and later in cool nights (7°C) than in constant temperature. One weekly frost night (−2.5°C) improved frost hardiness. Cool nights reduced frost hardiness early, but improved hardiness later during cold acclimation. Buds and stems were slightly hardier in 21°C than in 12°C, while needles were clearly hardier in 12°C. Cold daytime temperature, cool nights and one weekly frost night improved cold storability (0.7°C). Seedlings receiving high daytime temperatures burst buds later, and were less injured by light frost some days after bud burst.     

Deep supercooling enabled by surface impregnation with lipophilic substances explains the survival of overwintering buds at extreme freezing

The frost survival mechanism of vegetative buds of angiosperms was suggested to be extracellular freezing causing dehydration, elevated osmotic potential to prevent freezing. However, extreme dehydration would be needed to avoid freezing at the temperatures down to ?45°C encountered by many trees. Buds of Alnus alnobetula, in common with other frost hardy angiosperms, excrete a lipophilic substance, whose functional role remains unclear. Freezing of buds was studied by infrared thermography, psychrometry, and cryomicroscopy. Buds of A. alnobetula did not survive by extracellular ice tolerance but by deep supercooling, down to ?45°C. An internal ice barrier prevented ice penetration from the frozen stem into the bud. Cryomicroscopy revealed a new freezing mechanism. Until now, supercooled buds lost water towards ice masses that form in the subtending stem and/or bud scales. In A. alnobetula, ice forms harmlessly inside the bud between the supercooled leaves. This would immediately trigger intracellular freezing and kill the supercooled bud in other species. In A. alnobetula, lipophilic substances (triterpenoids and flavonoid aglycones) impregnate the surface of bud leaves. These prevent extrinsic ice nucleation so allowing supercooling. This suggests a means to protect forestry and agricultural crops from extrinsic ice nucleation allowing transient supercooling during night frosts.     

Critically reduced frost resistance of Picea abies during sprouting could be linked to cytological changes

Frost resistance of sprouting Picea abies shoots is insufficient for survival of naturally occurring late frosts. The cellular changes during sprouting appeared to be responsible for frost damage as frost events that damaged sprouting shoots did not damage older needles and stems. Whilst resting buds showed initial frost damage at ?15.0°C, 20 days later, current year’s growth was damaged at ?5.6°C. The decrease in frost resistance in sprouting shoots of P. abies was accompanied by a significant reduction of the cellular solute concentration, indicated by much less negative Ψ_oSAT values (increase from ?2.8 to ?1.2 MPa). ψ_oSAT decreased again after the final cell volume was reached and cell wall thickening began. After bud break, ice nucleation temperature increased from ?4.7°C to ?1.5°C. This increase was probably caused by the loss of bud scales, the onset of expansion growth of the central cylinder and the development of vascular tissue permitting the spread of ice from the stem into the growing needles. The onset of mesophyll cell wall thickening coincided with the lowest frost resistances. Cell wall thickening caused an increase in the modulus of elasticity, ε, indicating a decrease in tissue elasticity and after that frost resistance increased again. Metabolic and cytological changes that evidently leave little leeway for frost hardening are responsible for the low frost resistance in current year’s growth of P. abies. This low frost resistance will be significant in the future as the risk of frost damage due to earlier bud break is anticipated to even further increase.     

The freezing characteristics of cauliflower curd

Cultivar differences in frost resistance and the heritable nature of resistance were demonstrated using seedling cauliflower plants. Such cultivar differences were not however expressed in the curd. Selection for frost resistance in cauliflower should therefore use whole plant screening techniques. Curd material when frozen as isolated florets, supercooled over the range – 1°C to – 12°C and the mean freezing point of all curds tested was -6°C to -7.25°C (overall mean -6.44°C). Curd florets which supercooled but did not freeze were completely undamaged, whereas freezing always led to cell damage and death observed as water-soaking of the floret surface and measured using an electrical conductivity method. The large range of freezing points measured suggests a range of active ice nucleators either on or within the florets. When curds were frozen intact the ability of florets to supercool was severely restricted which was attributed to the seeding of freezing by the internal growth of ice crystals. A crop protection strategy needs to identify and control or modify warm temperature nucleators in cauliflower curd.     

The tolerance of black currant flowers to induced frosts

Flower buds on potted plants of 17 varieties of black currant were frosted to -3.3, -4.5 and -5.2 °C between the grape stage and full flower in 1979 and 1980. In all varieties more flower buds died after the -5.2 °C frosts and at full flower, and less after the -3.3 °C frosts and at the grape stage. Varieties related to Ben More and Ojebyn tolerated the -4.5 °C frosts until after first flower while Baldwin and Magnus became susceptible at the grape stage. Seabrooks Black, Greens Black and Ben Lomond and its relatives were intermediate. In both years flower buds tolerated frosts to similar growth stages but in 1980 the varieties flowered about 2 wk earlier than in 1979 and suffered more frost damage at full flower. The frosted plants had slightly larger fruits than the unfrosted ones in 1979. The immature fruit drop was similar in frosted and unfrosted plants in both years except when it was increased after -5.2 °C in 1980. It is pointed out that for reliable cropping, varieties should flower late as well as tolerate spring frosts and that tests of frost tolerance should be done for at least three growth stages.     

Abscisic acid content at defined levels of bud dormancy and frost tolerance in two contrasting populations of Picea abies grown in a phytotron

Seedlings of a southern (Romanian) and a northern (Swedish) population of Picea abies were cultivated under continuous light and 20°C for 10 weeks. To arrest growth, induce terminal bud dormancy and promote frost tolerance the seedlings were then exposed to 16 h nights for 12 weeks, with gradually lower temperature during the last 6 weeks. Samples for estimating the abscisic acid content of the needles were taken just before the onset of the night treatment, at day 3 of the treatment, and then with one, and later 2 week, intervals. From the second week onwards (third week for frost tolerance) bud dormancy and frost tolerance were assessed at the same time as abscisic acid (ABA) determinations. Phosphate-buffered saline extracts were purified on mini-columns (in some cases immunoaffinity colums) and quantified by HPLC. The degree of dormancy was estimated by transferring the seedlings to growth conditions and determining the number of days until growth was resumed. The frost tolerance of the needles exposed to –10°C and –20°C was classified in 6 classes. The frost tolerance of the terminal buds was estimated as the number of seedlings that showed some growth after 6 weeks in growth conditions. The night treatment rapidly induced terminal bud dormancy in both populations, but the release of dormancy occurred earlier in the northern population. The needles and the terminal buds became highly frost tolerant more rapidly in the northern than in the southern population and before the temperature decrease. The degree of dormancy began to decline before full frost tolerance was obtained in the southern population and this decline continued in both populations, while frost tolerance remained at a high level. The southern population showed a transient peak in ABA content at day 3. Although the ABA content of the northern population was lower than in the southern before the 16-h night treatment, it increased in the northern population during the treatment period, in particular after the temperature decrease.     

Does climatic warming increase the risk of frost damage in northern trees?

Abstract. The effect of climatic warming on the timing of bud burst and the subsequent risk of frost damage on trees in central Finland was assessed with the aid of a computer model, 73 years of temperature data and a climatic scenario corresponding to doubled level of atmospheric CO₂. In general, climatic warming hastened bud burst, due to ontogenetic development during warm spells in autumn, winter and spring. During the years with the warmest winters in the scenario conditions: (a) bud burst took place during mid-winter; and (2) depending on the year, the trees were subsequently exposed to temperatures between −27 and −10°C. This finding suggests that the risk of frost damage to trees will be increased if the predicted climatic warming occurs. Because of the assumptions used in the model, the results are not conclusive, but they do point out the importance of further experimental studies on genetic and environmental regulation of timing of bud burst in trees.     

Cold hardiness in various organs and tissues of Rhododendron species and the supercooling ability of flower buds as the most susceptible organ

The freezing resistance of various organs and tissues was determined in 24 Rhododendron species (mainly Subgenus Tsutsutsi) having different ecological distributions. The order of hardiness for organ or tissue is as follows: leaf bud > wood ≧ bark > flower bud, and the flower bud is characterized as the most cold-susceptible organ. The relationship of killing temperature (KT) to northern distribution was the most significant in leaf buds compared to other organs and tissues. KTs of leaf buds for the most hardy species were ?45 °C (or below) and those for the most tender species were about ?23 °C, while KTs of flower buds were about ?28 °C for the former and ?16 °C for the latter. Although KTs of flower buds native to southwestern Japan were well correlated with the exothermic temperature distribution (ETD) of florets, those in the more northern species were generally lower than ETDs. The supercooling ability of flower buds appears to be sufficient to avoid the freezing stress since the extreme minimum temperature (EMT) at the northern limit of natural distribution for each tree species examined was not lower than the KT and ETD of the flower buds.     

Frost in a future climate: modelling interactive effects of warmer temperatures and rising atmospheric [CO2] on the incidence and severity of frost damage in a temperate evergreen (Eucalyptus pauciflora)

Although plants are more susceptible to frost damage under elevated atmospheric [CO₂], the importance of frost damage under future, warmer climate scenarios is unknown. Accordingly, we used a model to examine the incidence and severity of frost damage to snow gum (Eucalyptus pauciflora) in a sub‐alpine region of Australia for current and future conditions using the A2 IPCC elevated CO₂ and climate change scenario. An existing model for predicting frost effects on E. pauciflora seedlings was adapted to include effects of elevated [CO₂] on acclimation to freezing temperatures, calibrated with field data, and applied to a study region in Victoria using climate scenario data from CSIRO's Global Climate Model C‐CAM for current (1975–2004) and future (2035–2064) 30 years climate sequences. Temperatures below 0 °C were predicted to occur less frequently while the coldest temperatures (i.e. those below ?8 °C) were almost as common in the future as in the current climate. Both elevated [CO₂] and climate warming affected the timing and rates of acclimation and de‐acclimation of snow gum to freezing temperatures, potentially reducing the length of time that plants are fully frost tolerant and increasing the length of the growing season. Despite fewer days when temperatures fall below 0 °C in the future, with consequently fewer damaging frosts with lower average levels of impact, individual weather sequences resulting in widespread plant mortality may still occur. Furthermore, delayed acclimation due to either warming or rising [CO₂] combined with an early severe frost could lead to more frost damage and higher mortality than would occur in current conditions. Effects of elevated [CO₂] on frost damage were greater in autumn, while warming had more effect in spring. Thus, frost damage will continue to be a management issue for plantation and forest management in regions where frosts persist.     

Does ice crystal formation in buds explain growth disturbances in boron-deficient Norway spruce?

Loss of apical dominance in boron-deficient trees has been suggested to be due to frost damage of terminal buds and leaders. Excessive nitrogen (N) supply can exacerbate boron (B) deficiency by the dilution-effect. N may also have direct effects on winter hardiness. We studied frost hardening of buds of Norway spruce (Picea abies L. Karst.) in healthy-looking trees and in trees with growth disturbances. The effect of B and N on frost hardiness was studied in a factorial fertilisation experiment during cold acclimation. Frost hardiness was determined by differential temperature analysis (DTA) and scoring of visual damage. In a DTA profile of apical buds with a piece of stem, low-temperature exotherm (LTE) predicted bud injury, while two of the observed high-temperature exotherms and two of the observed intermediate-temperature exotherms were non injurious. Appearance of LTE followed changes in air temperature. The risk of frost damage was not affected by fertilisation treatments or previously observed growth disturbances. However, when the bud structure was deformed by severe B deficiency, the supercooling ability disappeared. Such buds are probably killed by freezing in nature and therefore, frost damage may play a secondary role in the development of growth disturbances.     

Variation in freezing tolerance,water content and carbohydrate metabolism of floral buds during deacclimation of contrasting blackcurrant cultivars

As a result of climate change, temperature patterns are expected to become increasingly irregular with longer and more frequent episodes of unseasonable warm spells during the winter season. Warm spells may promote premature loss of freezing tolerance and bud burst in woody perennials, thereby increasing the risk of tissue damage by subsequent frosts. This study investigated the variation in kinetics of deacclimation and bud break and associated changes in carbohydrate metabolism and water status in floral buds of six blackcurrant (Ribes nigrum) cultivars in response to a simulated warm spell (16/11 °C day/night). In three of the cultivars, the rate of deacclimation showed an almost logarithmic course, whereas the other three cultivars exhibited greater deacclimation resistance and a sigmoid deacclimation pattern. The timing and rate of bud development, and their relationship with deacclimation varied greatly amongst cultivars, indicating genotypic variation in time-dependent responses of freezing tolerance and bud break to warm temperatures. In all six cultivars, deacclimation and growth resumption were strongly associated with rehydration. In contrast, changes in carbohydrate metabolism were mostly associated with deacclimation. Evaluation of phenological responses of the same cultivars under field conditions showed that cultivars which were fast flushing in response to an experimental warm spell also exhibited early bud break under natural conditions, indicating that cultivar differences in phenological responses are consistent under different temperature conditions.     

The effect of LAB 173711 and ethephon on time of flowering and cold hardiness of peach flower buds

Peach flowers are often killed during bloom by spring frosts. LAB 173711, a compound with abscisic (ABA)-like activity, and ethephon delayed flowering in peach trees. In greenhouse experiments, LAB 173711, at concentrations of 10^?3–10^?2 M, was most effective in delaying bloom when applied after a 5°C cold storage period, rather than before the dormancy breaking treatment. In contrast, ethephon delayed bloom most effectively when applied before 5°C cold storage; ethephon caused flower bud abscission when treatments were made after the chilling requirement had been satisfied. In field experiments, ethephon delayed flowering by 6–7 days, which reduced bud injury after a spring frost during bloom. No flower bud injury was found on ethephon-treated trees after temperatures of ?4.3°C; whereas without ethephon 25% of the flower buds were frost damaged. LAB 173711 delayed the time to 50% bloom by 2–3 days. However, this was not long enough to avoid low-temperature injury to the flower buds.     

A chamber for the simulation of radiation freezing of plants

Frost injury to plants can occur following episodic radiation frosts. In the UK this is particularly important to spring sown crops such as potatoes. Most laboratory based frost studies simulate freezing using either conductive or convective freezing chambers. Such frost tests do not simulate overnight freezing events adequately. A freezing chamber based on radiative cooling is described which mimics overnight radiative freezing. The chamber is rectangular in design (1 m × lm × 2 m high) with a radiative cooling plate at the top of the chamber cooled to -40°C to -45°C using HFC coolants, which acts as a cold black body. The sides of the chamber are also cooled to variable temperatures down to -5°C in order to prevent the chamber walls radiating to the plant material during testing. Using thermocouples to measure air temperature and plant temperature the chamber has been characterised to simulate the radiative cooling conditions found in the UK during autumn and spring. Exotherm detection upon plant freezing is simplified by virtue of the reduction in temperature fluctuation normally experienced at the plant surface during natural freezing. Radiation frosts and subsequent frost damage to potatoes have been recorded in the temperature range -4°C to –5°C. The equipment is recommended for studies of frost damage to plants normally caused by episodic radiation frost events.     

Cytokinins in Populus×robusta: Changes during Chilling and Bud Burst

Cytokinin levels in sap and vegetative buds of Populus×robusta Schneid have been determined during chilling and bud burst. From non-detectable levels in December and January, parallel increases in cytokinin levels occur in sap and buds during February and March, both in material from the field and that held at 2°C in the dark. The maximum in the sap occurs two weeks prior to natural bud burst, and 3 weeks, prior to the maximum attained in the buds. Excised twigs, forced to bud burst, show a similar pattern. The role of roots as a possible source of cytokinins is discussed. Partition chromatography on Sephadex LH-20 indicates that at least 5 cytokinins are present in buds, two of which have similar elution volumes to zeatin and zeatin riboside-The main activity in the sap is confined to a zeatin riboside-like component.     

Direct and indirect effects of episodic frost on plant growth and reproduction in subalpine wildflowers

Frost is an important episodic event that damages plant tissues through the formation of ice crystals at or below freezing temperatures. In montane regions, where climate change is expected to cause earlier snow melt but may not change the last frost‐free day of the year, plants that bud earlier might be directly impacted by frost through damage to flower buds and reproductive structures. However, the indirect effects of frost mediated through changes in plant–pollinator interactions have rarely been explored. We examined the direct and pollinator‐mediated indirect effects of frost on three wildflower species in southwestern Colorado, USA, Delphinium barbeyi (Ranunculaceae), Erigeron speciosus (Asteraceae), and Polemonium foliosissimum (Polemoniaceae), by simulating moderate (?1 to ?5°C) frost events in early spring in plants in situ. Subsequently, we measured plant growth, and upon flowering measured flower morphology and phenology. Throughout the flowering season, we monitored pollinator visitation and collected seeds to measure plant reproduction. We found that frost had species‐specific direct and indirect effects. Frost had direct effects on two of the three species. Frost significantly reduced flower size, total flowers produced, and seed production of Erigeron. Furthermore, frost reduced aboveground plant survival and seed production for Polemonium. However, we found no direct effects of frost on Delphinium. When we considered the indirect impacts of frost mediated through changes in pollinator visitation, one species, Erigeron, incurred indirect, negative effects of frost on plant reproduction through changes in floral traits and pollinator visitation, along with direct effects. Overall, we found that flowering plants exhibited species‐specific direct and pollinator‐mediated indirect responses to frost, thus suggesting that frost may play an important role in affecting plant communities under climate change.     

Summer frost resistance and freezing patterns measured in situ in leaves of major alpine plant growth forms in relation to their upper distribution boundary

Summer frost resistance and ice nucleation temperatures for 33 alpine plant species were measured in situ to avoid the shortcomings of laboratory tests. Species were selected to investigate the relationship between plant stature and upper distribution boundary, and frost resistance and freezing patterns. The species tested in situ were on average 1.1 K (± 0.2, SE) frost hardier than in laboratory tests. Frost resistance (LT₅₀) ranged from ?4.5 to ?14.6 °C and appeared insufficient to protect against air temperature minima, corroborating reports of natural frost damage. All species tolerated extracellular ice formation (recorded at ?1.9 ± 0.2 °C; E1). Initial frost damage occurred at average temperatures 4.9 K below E1. In 64% of the species a second exotherm (E2) and frost damage were recorded between ?3.7 and ?9.4 °C. In the highest ranging species E2 was not detectable. Frost resistance increased with increasing upper distribution boundary (0.4 K per 100 m), corresponding well with the altitudinal decrease in air temperature minima. No relationship between plant stature and frost resistance was found. Graminoids were significantly frost hardier than other growth forms. Frost survival at high altitudes will depend not only on altitudinal increase in frost resistance but also on freezing avoidance strategies, snow cover protection and a high recuperation capacity.     

The after-effects of temperature and irradiance during early growth of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus L. var. oleifera, cv. Górczański) seedlings on the progress of their cold acclimation

Experiments performed under controlled conditions showed that level of PPFD (photosynthetic photon flux density) during early seedlings growth (preceding cold acclimation at +2 °C) was not the key factor for the development of frost resistance. It did not modify the beneficial effects of prehardening (Rapacz 1997, in this issue) at moderately low (+12 °C) day temperature. Now I have shown that the increase of PPFD may replace to some extent prehardening in the development of frost resistance. It was particularly seen in non-prehardened plants, which had been grown under warm-day (+20 °C) conditions. Prehardening performed under controlled conditions, as well as seedlings growth under natural autumn conditions in the field, allowed to maintain a high net-photosynthesis rate at chilling temperatures. A net-photosynthesis rate during cold acclimation at +2 °C corresponded well with higher frost resistance. As a result, seedlings non subjected to prehardening and grown before cold acclimation under low PPFD acclimated better, if the cold treatment was applied only at nights (+20/2 °C day/night). Only under such conditions the photosynthetic rate was sufficiently high to allow plants to reach a higher level of frost resistance. All other plants acclimated better when they were exposed to the hardening temperature continuously during days and nights (+2/2 °C day/night).     

Effect of thawing time, cooling rate and boron nutrition on freezing point of the primordial shoot in norway spruce buds

BACKGROUND: Effects of cooling rates on bud frost hardiness have been studied but there is little information on bud responses to thawing. Since the cell wall pore size has been found to increase with boron (B) deficiency, B deficiency may affect the supercooling ability of buds in winter. METHODS: The effects of duration of thawing time and rate of cooling on bud frost hardiness of Norway spruce (Picea abies) were studied in a B fertilization trial in February 2003 and March 2005. Frost hardiness of apical buds was determined by differential thermal analysis (DTA) and visual scoring of damage. KEY RESULTS: In 2003, the freezing point of primordial shoots of buds (T(f)), i.e. the low-temperature exotherm (LTE), was, on average, -39 degrees C when buds were thawed for less than 3 h and the T(f) increased to -21 degrees C after 18 h of thawing. During the first 4 h of thawing, the rate of dehardening was 6 degrees C h(-1). In 2005, buds dehardened linearly from -39 degrees C to -35 degrees C at a rate of 0.7 degrees C h(-1). In 2003, different cooling rates of 1-5 degrees C h(-1) had a minor effect on T(f) but in 2005 with slow cooling rates T(f) decreased. In both samplings, at cooling rates of 2 and 1 degrees C h(-1), T(f) was slightly higher in B-fertilized than in non-fertilized trees. By contrast, at very short thawing times in 2003, T(f) was somewhat lower in B-fertilized trees. CONCLUSIONS: There was little evidence of reduced frost hardiness in trees with low B status. This study showed that buds deharden rapidly when exposed to above-freezing temperatures in winter, but if cooled again they reharden more slowly. According to this study, rapid dehardening of buds has to be taken into account in assessments of frost hardiness.     

Low-temperature resistance in Polylepis tarapacana, a tree growing at the highest altitudes in the world

The Polylepis tarapacana forests found in Bolivia are unique with respect to their altitudinal distribution (4200–5200 m). Given the extreme environmental conditions that characterize these altitudes, this species has to rely on distinct mechanisms to survive stressful temperatures. The purpose of this study was to determine low‐temperature resistance mechanisms in P. tarapacana. Tissue was sampled for carbohydrate and proline contents and micro‐climatic measurements were made at two altitudes, 4300 and 4850 m, during both the dry cold and wet warm seasons. Supercooling capacity (?3 to ?6 °C for the cold dry and ?7 to ?9 °C for the wet warm season) and injury temperatures (?18 to ?23 °C for both seasons), determined in the laboratory, indicate that P. tarapacana is a frost‐tolerant species. On the other hand, an increase in supercooling capacity, as the result of significant increase in total soluble sugar and proline contents, occurs during the wet warm season as a consequence of higher metabolic activity. Hence, P. tarapacana, a frost‐tolerant species during the colder unfavourable season, is able to avoid freezing during the more favourable season when minimum night‐time temperatures are not as extreme.     

Evergreen alpine shrubs have high freezing resistance in spring,irrespective of snowmelt timing and exposure to frost: an investigation from the Snowy Mountains,Australia

Over winter, alpine plants are protected from low-temperature extremes by a blanket of snow. Climate change predictions indicate an overall reduction in snowpack and an earlier thaw; a situation which could expose the tips of shrubs which extend above the snowpack to freezing events in early spring, and cause foliar frost damage during the onset of physiological activity. We assessed the photosynthetic responses of freezing-damaged shrub leaves from an assay of freezing temperatures in the Snowy Mountains in south-eastern Australia, using chlorophyll fluorometery ex situ. We sampled leaves that were exposed early during the spring thaw and leaves that were buried in snow for up to two extra weeks, from four evergreen shrub species at monthly intervals following the period of snowmelt. Freezing resistance (estimated from LT₅₀) was poorest at the earliest spring sampling time, in both exposed above-snow and protected below-snow foliage in all species. Protected foliage in early spring had lower freezing resistance than exposed foliage, but not significantly so. By the third sampling time, freezing resistance was significantly better in the lower protected foliage (LT₅₀ of ? 14) compared with the upper exposed foliage (LT₅₀ of ? 10) in one species. Over the course of spring, freezing resistance improved significantly in all species, with LT₅₀ values of between ? 10 and ? 15 °C by the third sampling time, which is lower than the minimum air temperatures recorded at that time (> ? 5 °C). The results indicate that the dominant evergreen shrub species in this area may only be susceptible to freezing events very early in spring, before a period of frost-hardening occurs after snowmelt. Later in spring, these alpine shrubs appear frost hardy, thus further perpetuating the positive feedbacks surrounding shrub expansion in alpine areas.