Dynamics of Defense Responses and Cell Fate Change during Arabidopsis-Pseudomonas syringae Interactions

Plant-pathogen interactions involve sophisticated action and counteraction strategies from both parties. Plants can recognize pathogen derived molecules, such as conserved pathogen associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) and effector proteins, and subsequently activate PAMP-triggered immunity (PTI) and effector-triggered immunity (ETI), respectively. However, pathogens can evade such recognitions and suppress host immunity with effectors, causing effector-triggered susceptibility (ETS). The differences among PTI, ETS, and ETI have not been completely understood. Toward a better understanding of PTI, ETS, and ETI, we systematically examined various defense-related phenotypes of Arabidopsis infected with different Pseudomonas syringae pv. maculicola ES4326 strains, using the virulence strain DG3 to induce ETS, the avirulence strain DG34 that expresses avrRpm1 (recognized by the resistance protein RPM1) to induce ETI, and HrcC^- that lacks the type three secretion system to activate PTI. We found that plants infected with different strains displayed dynamic differences in the accumulation of the defense signaling molecule salicylic acid, expression of the defense marker gene PR1, cell death formation, and accumulation/localization of the reactive oxygen species, H₂O₂. The differences between PTI, ETS, and ETI are dependent on the doses of the strains used. These data support the quantitative nature of PTI, ETS, and ETI and they also reveal qualitative differences between PTI, ETS, and ETI. Interestingly, we observed the induction of large cells in the infected leaves, most obviously with HrcC^- at later infection stages. The enlarged cells have increased DNA content, suggesting a possible activation of endoreplication. Consistent with strong induction of abnormal cell growth by HrcC^-, we found that the PTI elicitor flg22 also activates abnormal cell growth, depending on a functional flg22-receptor FLS2. Thus, our study has revealed a comprehensive picture of dynamic changes of defense phenotypes and cell fate determination during Arabidopsis-P. syringae interactions, contributing to a better understanding of plant defense mechanisms.     

Flg22‐triggered oxylipin production in Pyropia haitanensis

This study provides evidence that flg22, the most conserved 22‐amino acid peptide in the N‐terminal part of bacterial flagellin can trigger the defense responses of Pyropia haitanensis (Bangiales, Rhodophyta). The defense responses are a chain of events including release of H₂O₂ and free unsaturated fatty acids C20:4, consumption of C18:3, and the chemical or enzymatic oxidation of both C20 and C18 polyunsaturated fatty acids. Oxidized C20 and C18 fatty acids lead to the production of corresponding hydroperoxy and hydroxylated derivatives, such as 9‐hydroperoxy octadecadienoic acid, 8‐hydroperoxy eicosapentaenoic acid, and 8‐hydroxyl eicosapentaenoic acid, which could be further oxidatively metabolized to yield saturated aldehydes and ketone. Changes of three typical hormones jasmonate, methyl jasmonate, and salicylic acid were observed. Contrary to the increase of jasmonate and methyl jasmonate, salicylic acid was decreased. The expression of key enzymes of oxylipin pathway PhLOX and PhLOX2 were upregulated. However, some defense and antioxidant related genes including PhHsp 70, Phsod , and PhRboh were downregulated markedly at the early stage of flg22 challenge. Overall, our results imply that red algae have evolved a similar defense response and may share the conservative‐recognizing receptor for flg22 as in higher plants.     

Mutations in FLS2 Ser-938 Dissect Signaling Activation in FLS2-Mediated Arabidopsis Immunity

FLAGELLIN-SENSING 2 (FLS2) is a leucine-rich repeat/transmembrane domain/protein kinase (LRR-RLK) that is the plant receptor for bacterial flagellin or the flagellin-derived flg22 peptide. Previous work has shown that after flg22 binding, FLS2 releases BIK1 kinase and homologs and associates with BAK1 kinase, and that FLS2 kinase activity is critical for FLS2 function. However, the detailed mechanisms for activation of FLS2 signaling remain unclear. The present study initially identified multiple FLS2 in vitro phosphorylation sites and found that Serine-938 is important for FLS2 function in vivo. FLS2-mediated immune responses are abolished in transgenic plants expressing FLS2_S938A, while the acidic phosphomimic mutants FLS2_S938D and FLS2_S938E conferred responses similar to wild-type FLS2. FLS2-BAK1 association and FLS2-BIK1 disassociation after flg22 exposure still occur with FLS2_S938A, demonstrating that flg22-induced BIK1 release and BAK1 binding are not sufficient for FLS2 activity, and that Ser-938 controls other aspects of FLS2 activity. Purified BIK1 still phosphorylated purified FLS2_S938A and FLS2_S938D mutant kinase domains in vitro. Phosphorylation of BIK1 and homologs after flg22 exposure was disrupted in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants expressing FLS2_S938A or FLS2_D997A (a kinase catalytic site mutant), but was normally induced in FLS2_S938D plants. BIK1 association with FLS2 required a kinase-active FLS2, but FLS2-BAK1 association did not. Hence FLS2-BIK1 dissociation and FLS2-BAK1 association are not sufficient for FLS2-mediated defense activation, but the proposed FLS2 phosphorylation site Ser-938 and FLS2 kinase activity are needed both for overall defense activation and for appropriate flg22-stimulated phosphorylation of BIK1 and homologs.     

Rapid Stimulation of an Oxidative Burst during Elicitation of Cultured Plant Cells : Role in Defense and Signal Transduction

Stimulation of cultured plant cells with elicitors of the defense response leads to the rapid destruction of a variety of water-soluble compounds including indoleacetic acid and certain fluorescent dyes. This destructive activity, which is often vigorously manifested within 5 minutes of elicitor addition, is shown to derive from the rapid production of H₂O₂ and its use by extracellular peroxidases. Because of its speed of appearance, this oxidative burst may qualify as the first induced line of defense against invading pathogens. Since H₂O₂ has been implicated as a second messenger of hormone-stimulated metabolic changes in some animal cells, its possible role in transduction of the defense signal in plants was also examined. Not only did exogenous H₂O₂ alone stimulate phytoalexin production in the plant cell suspension, but inhibition of elicitor-stimulated phytoalexin production was observed upon addition of catalase and other inhibitors of the oxidative burst. Furthermore, for inhibition to occur, the presence of catalase was required during elicitor addition, since if introduction of the enzyme was delayed until 1 hour after addition of the elicitor, no inhibition resulted. These results suggest that H₂O₂ also plays an important role in inducing subsequent defense responses such as phytoalexin production.     

The interplay between MAMP and SA signaling

There are two major modes for plant recognition of biotrophic microbial pathogens. In one mode, plant pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) recognize microbe associated molecular patterns (MAMPs, also called PAMPs), which are molecules such as flg22, a fragment of bacterial flagellin. In the other mode, the products of plant resistance (R) genes recognize pathogen effectors or host proteins modified by effectors. Salicylic acid (SA) -mediated defense responses are an important part of R gene-mediated resistance. It was not clear how these two signaling mechanisms interact with each other. Recently, we reported that treatment with flg22 triggered SA accumulation in Arabidopsis leaves. Disruptions of SA signaling components strongly affected MAMP-triggered gene expression responses. Flg22-triggered resistance to Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 (Pst DC3000) was partly dependent on SA signaling. Our results demonstrated the importance of SA signaling in flg22-triggered resistance and, at the same time, the importance of some other signaling mechanism(s) in this resistance. Here we discuss potential signaling components of flg22-triggered SA accumulation and other signaling mechanisms potentially contributing to flg22-triggered resistance to Pst DC3000.Key words: arabidopsis, expression profiling, MAMP, PAD4, PAMP, salicylic acid (SA), SID2     

Development of a Colorimetric Assay for Determining the Amount of H2O2 Generated in Tobacco Cells in Response to Elicitors and Its Application to Study of the Structure-Activity Relationship of Flagellin-Derived Peptides

Plants exhibit various defense responses after recognizing elicitor molecules derived from pathogenic microorganisms and host plants. In this study, we developed an improved colorimetric assay for quantifying the generation of H₂O₂ in plant cells, one of the defense responses, to evaluate elicitor activity quantitatively. H₂O₂ is detected using a dye, N-(carboxymethylaminocarbonyl)-4,4′-bis(dimethylamino)-diphenylamine sodium salt (DA-64), which can be measured by conventional spectrometers in a highly sensitive and quantitative manner. Using this method, we successfully measured the elicitor activity of flagellin-derived peptides in cultured tobacco cells, and identified several structural features of the peptides important for the elicitor activity. The results suggest that the structural factors required for expression of the elicitor activity differ slightly among plant species. The efficient and sensitive assay developed in this study should be useful not only for studying structure-activity relationships, but also for the screening of novel compounds that can induce defense responses.     

Role of salicylic acid in induction of plant defense system in chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)

Salicylic acid (SA), a plant hormone plays an important role in induction of plant defense against a variety of biotic and abiotic stresses through morphological, physiological and biochemical mechanisms. A series of experiments were carried out to evaluate the biochemical response of the chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) plants to a range of SA concentrations (1, 1.5, and 2 mM). Water treated plants were maintained as control. Activities of peroxidase (POD) and polyphenol oxidase (PPO) were evaluated and amounts of total phenols, hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂), and proteins were calculated after 96 h of treatment. Plants responded very quickly to SA at 1.5 mM and showed higher induction of POD and PPO activities, besides the higher accumulation of phenols, H₂O₂ and proteins. Plants treated with SA at 2 mM showed phytotoxic symptoms. These results suggest that SA at 1.5 mM is safe to these plants and could be utilized for the induction of plant defense.     

Both the Extracellular Leucine-Rich Repeat Domain and the Kinase Activity of FLS2 Are Required for Flagellin Binding and Signaling in Arabidopsis

In Arabidopsis, activation of defense responses by flagellin is triggered by the specific recognition of the most conserved domain of flagellin, represented by the peptide flg22, in a process involving the FLS2 gene, which encodes a leucine-rich repeat serine/threonine protein kinase. We show here that the two fls2 mutant alleles, fls2-24 and fls2-17, which were shown previously to confer insensitivity to flg22, also cause impaired flagellin binding. These features are rescued when a functional FLS2 gene is expressed as a transgene in each of the fls2 mutant plants, indicating that FLS2 is necessary for flagellin binding. The point mutation of the fls2-17 allele lies in the kinase domain. A kinase carrying this missense mutation lacked autophosphorylation activity when expressed in Escherichia coli. This indicates that kinase activity is required for binding and probably affects the stability of the flagellin receptor complex. We further show that overexpression of the kinase-associated protein phosphatase (KAPP) in Arabidopsis results in plants that are insensitive to flagellin treatment, and we show reduced flg22 binding in these plants. Furthermore, using the yeast two-hybrid system, we show physical interaction of KAPP with the kinase domain of FLS2. These results suggest that KAPP functions as a negative regulator of the FLS2 signal transduction pathway and that the phosphorylation of FLS2 is necessary for proper binding and signaling of the flagellin receptor complex.     

Requirement of vesicle-associated membrane protein 721 and 722 for sustained growth during immune responses in Arabidopsis

Extracellular immune responses to ascomycete and oomycete pathogens in Arabidopsis are dependent on vesicle-associated secretion mediated by the SNARE proteins PEN1 syntaxin, SNAP33 and endomembrane-resident VAMP721/722. Continuous movement of functional GFP-VAMP722 to and from the plasma membrane in non-stimulated cells reflects the second proposed function of VAMP721/722 in constitutive secretion during plant growth and development. Application of the bacterium-derived elicitor flg22 stabilizes VAMP721/722 that are otherwise constitutively degraded via the 26S proteasome pathway. Depletion of VAMP721/722 levels by reducing VAMP721/722 gene dosage enhances flg22-induced seedling growth inhibition in spite of elevated VAMP721/722 abundance. We therefore propose that plants prioritize the deployment of the corresponding secretory pathway for defense over plant growth. Interstingly, VAMP721/722 specifically interact in vitro and in vivo with the plasma membrane syntaxin SYP132 that is required for plant growth and resistance to bacteria. This suggests that the plant growth/immunity-involved VAMP721/722 form SNARE complexes with multiple plasma membrane syntaxins to discharge cue-dependent cargo molecules.     

Early signaling through the Arabidopsis pattern recognition receptors FLS2 and EFR involves Ca2+‐associated opening of plasma membrane anion channels

The perception of microbes by plants involves highly conserved molecular signatures that are absent from the host and that are collectively referred to as microbe‐associated molecular patterns (MAMPs). The Arabidopsis pattern recognition receptors FLAGELLIN‐SENSING 2 (FLS2) and EF‐Tu receptor (EFR) represent genetically well studied paradigms that mediate defense against bacterial pathogens. Stimulation of these receptors through their cognate ligands, bacterial flagellin or bacterial elongation factor Tu, leads to a defense response and ultimately to increased resistance. However, little is known about the early signaling pathway of these receptors. Here, we characterize this early response in situ, using an electrophysiological approach. In line with a release of negatively charged molecules, voltage recordings of microelectrode‐impaled mesophyll cells and root hairs of Col‐0 Arabidopsis plants revealed rapid, dose‐dependent membrane potential depolarizations in response to either flg22 or elf18. Using ion‐selective microelectrodes, pronounced anion currents were recorded upon application of flg22 and elf18, indicating that the signaling cascades initiated by each of the two receptors converge on the same plasma membrane ion channels. Combined calcium imaging and electrophysiological measurements revealed that the depolarization was superimposed by an increase in cytosolic calcium that was indispensable for depolarization. NADPH oxidase mutants were still depolarized upon elicitor stimulation, suggesting a reactive oxygen species‐independent membrane potential response. Furthermore, electrical signaling in response to either flg22 or elf 18 critically depends on the activity of the FLS2‐associated receptor‐like kinase BAK1, suggesting that activation of FLS2 and EFR lead to BAK1‐dependent, calcium‐associated plasma membrane anion channel opening as an initial step in the pathogen defense pathway.     

Exogenous hydrogen peroxide enhanced the thermotolerance of Festuca arundinacea and Lolium perenne by increasing the antioxidative capacity

Heat stress is one of the most detrimental environment stresses for plants. Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) is produced quickly in response to various stresses and likely plays a positive role in transmitting stress signal in organisms. This investigation addressed whether an exogenous H₂O₂ application would affect the heat response of turfgrasses and induce acclimation. Tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea cv. Barlexas) and perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne cv. Accent), two important cool-season turfgrasses and forages, were sprayed with 10 mM H₂O₂ before they were treated with heat stress (38/30 °C, day/night) and compared with plants maintained at control temperatures (26/15 °C, day/night). Prior to the initiation of heat stress, H₂O₂ pretreatment increased the activities of guaiacol peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT), ascorbate peroxidase (APX), glutathione reductase (GR) and glutathione-dependent peroxidase (GPX) and the ascorbate and glutathione pool, and it decreased the GSH/GSSG ratio. During the heat stress process, pretreated plants from both grasses exhibited higher turfgrass quality and relative water content, and they experienced lower oxidative damage and H₂O₂ levels. Moreover, the activities of APX, GR, GPX and glutathione-S-transferase increased significantly in response to H₂O₂ pretreatment under heat stress. These results suggested that H₂O₂ most likely participated in the transduction of redox signaling and induced the antioxidative defense system, including various enzymatic and nonenzymatic H₂O₂ scavengers. The scavengers played important roles in improving the thermotolerance of tall fescue and perennial ryegrasses.     

Effect of auxins and ectomycorrhizal elicitors on wall-bound proteins and enzymes of spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] cells

Summary Elicitors of the ectomycorrhizal fungus Hebeloma crustuliniforme and auxins (IAA, NAA and 2,4-D) were tested for their effects on apoplastic proteins and enzymes of suspension cultured cells of Picea abies (L.) Karst. The ectomycorrhizal elicitor increased the amount of some ionically wall-bound proteins (36, 28, 24, 21 kDa) and decreased the amount of others (61, 22 kDa). The elicitor triggered an H₂O₂ burst and enhanced the peroxidase (EC 1.11.1.7) activity of the Picea cells by increasing one of the two wall-bound peroxidase isoforms. Auxins significantly suppressed the elicitor induction of peroxidase but did not influence the elicitor-triggered H₂O₂ burst. The elicitors and auxin did not change the amount and the pattern of wall-bound invertase isoforms (EC 3.2.1.26) of spruce cells. However, auxin reduced the uptake of glucose by spruce cells and increased the acidification of the cell culture medium. Since Hebeloma lacks apoplastic invertase as well as a sucrose uptake system, utilization of plant-derived sucrose depends on the apoplastic plant invertase activity. Although the host invertase is constitutive, the fungus might be able to increase this invertase activity within a mycorrhiza by lowering the pH of the interface towards the pH optimum of the enzyme via the action of auxin. This fungus-released hormone could increase the H⁺ extrusion of plant cells by activation of the plant membrane H⁺-ATPases. Additionally, an auxin-dependent suppression of glucose uptake by cortical root cells could improve the glucose supply for the fungus. Furthermore, the fungal auxin might suppress the elicitor induced formation of defense enzymes, such as peroxidase.     

Comparative Biochemistry of the Oxidative Burst Produced by Rose and French Bean Cells Reveals Two Distinct Mechanisms

Cultured cells of rose (Rosa damascena) treated with an elicitor derived from Phytophthora spp. and suspension-cultured cells of French bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) treated with an elicitor derived from the cell walls of Colletotrichum lindemuthianum both produced H₂O₂. It has been hypothesized that in rose cells H₂O₂ is produced by a plasma membrane NAD(P)H oxidase (superoxide synthase), whereas in bean cells H₂O₂ is derived directly from cell wall peroxidases following extracellular alkalinization and the appearance of a reductant. In the rose/Phytophthora spp. system treated with N,N-diethyldithiocarbamate, superoxide was detected by a N,N′-dimethyl-9,9′-biacridium dinitrate-dependent chemiluminescence; in contrast, in the bean/C. lindemuthianum system, no superoxide was detected, with or without N,N-diethyldithiocarbamate. When rose cells were washed free of medium (containing cell wall peroxidase) and then treated with Phytophthora spp. elicitor, they accumulated a higher maximum concentration of H₂O₂ than when treated without the washing procedure. In contrast, a washing treatment reduced the H₂O₂ accumulated by French bean cells treated with C. lindemuthianum elicitor. Rose cells produced reductant capable of stimulating horseradish (Armoracia lapathifolia) peroxidase to form H₂O₂ but did not have a peroxidase capable of forming H₂O₂ in the presence of reductant. Rose and French bean cells thus appear to be responding by different mechanisms to generate the oxidative burst.     

The involvement of peroxidases in soybean seedlings’ defense against infestation of cowpea aphid

Changes in the level of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) and activity of peroxidases towards phenolic substrates (EC 1.11.1.7) such as pyrogallol (PPX), syringaldazine (SPX) and guaiacol (GPX), and cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase (cAPX, EC 1.11.1.11) in response to infestation of cowpea aphid (Aphis craccivora Koch) were analyzed in soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr. cv. “Nam Dan”) at the V3 stage (first two trifoliate leaves fully developed, third trifoliate leaf unrolled) for 96 h post-infestation (hpi). Influence of A. craccivora at a varied population size (10, 20 and 30 individuals per each soybean plant) caused a burst of H₂O₂ generation in the aphid-infested leaves at 12 hpi. Paralleling the H₂O₂ accumulation, peroxidase activity in all the infested plants remarkably increased and was significantly higher than that observed in controls (uninfested plants). The cascade of enzymes induced was continuously overlapped by the early enhancement of SPX within 6–24 hpi, an expression of cAPX (12–48 hpi) followed by an accumulation of GPX (24–72 hpi) and PPX (24–96 hpi). The differential induction of SPX, GPX, PPX and cAPX resulted in a rapid reduction of H₂O₂ content in aphid-infested leaves, and the activity of peroxidase was closely correlated with the intensity of A. craccivora infestation around the defined points of time at which the activity of each enzyme reached the maximum level. The increase in activity of peroxidases matched their function as controlling accumulation of H₂O₂ and detoxifying this reactive oxygen product when soybean plants were challenged with cowpea aphid. Furthermore, peroxidases could directly deter cowpea aphid feeding through other functions such as the anti-nutritive and/or toxicological defenses and/or limiting the penetration of aphid stylets into plant tissues via participating to strengthen and reinforce the cell wall barrier. These results indicated that peroxidases may be some elements of the defense system that increased the resistance of G. max cv. “Nam Dan” to infestation of A. craccivora.     

A peroxiredoxin cDNA from Taiwanofungus camphorata: role of Cys31 in dimerization

Peroxiredoxins (Prxs) play important roles in antioxidant defense and redox signaling pathways. A Prx isozyme cDNA (TcPrx2, 745 bp, EF552425) was cloned from Taiwanofungus camphorata and its recombinant protein was overexpressed. The purified protein was shown to exist predominantly as a dimer by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrolysis in the absence of a reducing agent. The protein in its dimeric form showed no detectable Prx activity. However, the protein showed increased Prx activity with increasing dithiothreitol concentration which correlates with dissociation of the dimer into monomer. The TcPrx2 contains two Cys residues. The Cys⁶⁰ located in the conserved active site is the putative active peroxidatic Cys. The role of Cys³¹ was investigated by site-directed mutagenesis. The C31S mutant (C³¹ → S³¹) exists predominantly as a monomer with noticeable Prx activity. The Prx activity of the mutant was higher than that of the corresponding wild-type protein by nearly twofold at 12 μg/mL. The substrate preference of the mutant was H₂O₂ > cumene peroxide > t-butyl peroxide. The Michaelis constant (K _M) value for H₂O₂ of the mutant was 0.11 mM. The mutant enzyme was active under a broad pH range from 6 to 10. The results suggest a role of Cys³¹ in dimerization of the TcPrx2, a role which, at least in part, may be involved in determining the activity of Prx. The C³¹ residue does not function as a resolving Cys and therefore the TcPrx2 must follow the reaction mechanism of 1-Cys Prx. This TcPrx2 represents a new isoform of Prx family.     

BAK1‐mediated phosphorylation of canonical G protein alpha during flagellin signaling in Arabidopsis

Heterotrimeric G proteins consisting of Gα, Gβ and Gγ are conserved signaling hubs in eukaryotes. Without analogs to canonical animal G protein‐coupled receptors, plant cells are thought to use RGS1 and a yet unknown mechanism to regulate the activity of Gα. Meanwhile, the exact role of canonical Gα in plant innate immunity remains controversial. Here, we report multiple immune deficiencies in the null allele of Arabidopsis Gα (GPA1) in response to bacterial flg22 elicitor, clarifying a positive regulatory role of GPA1 in flg22 signaling. We also detect overall increased phosphorylation of GPA1 but reduced phosphorylation at Thr¹⁹ upon flg22 elicitation. Interestingly, flg22 could not induce phosphorylation of GPA1^T19A and GPA1^T19D, suggesting that the dynamic Thr¹⁹ phosphorylation is required for GPA1 to respond to flg22. Moreover, flg22‐induced GPA1 phosphorylation is largely abolished in the absence of BAK1 in vivo, and BAK1 could phosphorylate GPA1 but not GPA1^T19A in vitro at the phosphorylation sites identified in vivo, suggesting BAK1 is likely the kinase for GPA1 phosphorylation in response to flg22. Furthermore, the T19A mutation could promote flg22‐induced association, rather than dissociation, between GPA1 and RGS1. Taken together, our findings shed new insights into the function and regulation of GPA1 in Arabidopsis defense signaling.