Reliability of stereotactic biopsy. A model to test the value of diagnoses obtained from small fragments of nervous system tumors

Because of the variability of the structural features of cerebral tumors, the characteristics observed in biopsy samples may not be representative of the whole neoplasm. The reliability of cerebral stereotactic biopsy is therefore greatly debated. In order to test the value of diagnoses based on biopsy samples, the authors compared histological and cytological data obtained from a small fragment of a tumor with the definitive diagnosis obtained from surgical or necropsy specimens. An analysis of 64 cases is reported, where a correct diagnosis from the biopsy sample was achieved in 92.2% of the cases. Neuroglial tumors were more difficult to characterize than other types of intracranial tumors, with an accuracy of 81.5%.     

Differential diagnosis of malignant intrahepatic tumors by ultrasonically guided fine needle aspiration biopsy and by laparoscopic/intraoperative biopsy. A comparative study

Thirty-six cases of ultrasonographically detected liver tumors (28 malignant and 8 benign lesions) were investigated by both fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy and laparoscopic or intraoperative tissue biopsy. The sensitivity of FNA biopsy in detecting a neoplasm was 85.7% while that of tissue biopsy was 82.1%. Specificity was 100% in both methods. A correct histologic diagnosis of the neoplasm could be made on the cytologic smear in only 14 cases (50.0%) due to technical and methodologic difficulties. Endoscopic and intraoperative tissue biopsy yielded sufficient material to make a definite histologic tumor diagnosis in 23 of 28 cases. Additional information on tumor spread and sequelae of liver infiltration was obtained by macroscopic tissue observations in nine cases. These results indicate that FNA biopsy is less sensitive in the classification of primary or secondary liver tumors and that tissue biopsies obtained during laparoscopy or laparotomy are required if a suspected hepatic neoplasm needs to be classified exactly to plan therapy and to establish a prognosis.     

Extraskeletal myxoid chondrosarcoma with intranuclear vacuoles and microtubular aggregates in the rough endoplasmic reticulum. Report of a case with fine needle aspiration and electron microscopy

The findings of fine needle aspiration biopsy cytology, histology, immunohistochemistry and electron microscopy in an extraskeletal myxoid chondrosarcoma of the soft tissue of the thigh detected in a 65-year-old man are described. In addition to the more usual cytologic findings of chondroblasts and pleomorphic mesenchymal cells, this tumor displayed distinctive intranuclear cytoplasmic inclusions and microtubular aggregates in the rough endoplasmic reticulum. Cytologic study made the diagnosis of malignancy, suggesting a myxoid sarcoma; the precise diagnosis was made by the subsequent studies on the resected tumor and resin-embedded samples of the aspirate. The suitability of aspirated material in the differential diagnosis of myxoid soft tissue tumors is discussed.     

Cytology of neuroectodermal tumors of the brain in crush preparations. A review of 56 cases of deep-seated tumors sampled by CT-guided stereotactic needle biopsy

Fifty-six brain tumors of neuroectodermal origin were sampled by computed tomographic stereotactic needle biopsy. Crush preparations prepared from tiny tissue fragments displayed distinctive cytologic characteristics of different tumor types in 77% of the cases. The adjunctival value of crush preparations to frozen section diagnosis is discussed, and the cytologic features of different types of neuroectodermal brain tumors in crush preparations are illustrated.     

Cytologic diagnosis of lung tumors from bronchial brushings of Chinese patients in Hong Kong

In 1,156 single or multiple specimens obtained from fiberoptic bronchoscopy on 1,016 Chinese patients in Hong Kong, a positive diagnosis of malignancy was made on cytologic examination in 288 and a histologic type assigned. On histologic examination of tissue, malignant tumors were diagnosed in 284 cases. The total positive yield by cytology was 88%, and the overall cytologic accuracy in correlation with histology was 73%. Comparing cases typed by cytology and by histology, the diagnostic accuracy of cytology was 83% in squamous-cell carcinoma, 81% in small-cell carcinoma, 69% in adenocarcinoma and 46% in large-cell carcinoma. The detection rate of nonbronchogenic tumors was 50%. Bronchogenic tumors showed a low male:female ratio, 1.96:1, whereas 80% of squamous-cell carcinomas and 45% of adenocarcinomas occurred in males. All seven cases of bronchogenic carcinoma in patients under 40 years of age occurred in males.     

The impact of liquid-based oral cytology on the diagnosis of oral squamous dysplasia and carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: Even though diagnostic oral exfoliative cytology is a useful, economical and practical tool in the diagnosis of oral dysplasia and carcinoma, it is not yet extensively used. The results of conventional exfoliative and liquid-based diagnostic cytology in oral potentially malignant lesions (PML) are herein reported and compared with the histological diagnosis. METHODS: Either conventional (89) or liquid-based (384) exfoliative cytology was used for the diagnosis of oral dysplasia/carcinoma in 473 subjects and the results were compared with scalpel biopsy histology. Cells were collected using a Cytobrush device for conventional smears and with a dermatological curette for the liquid-based cytology. The 'curette technique' also allowed for the collection of 'accidental' tissue fragments, utilized as microbiopsies. RESULTS: Histological diagnosis was squamous carcinoma in 96 of 473 cases, high-grade dysplasia (oral intraepithelial neoplasia two to three) in 24 and other lesions in 353 cases. The smears in the conventional cytology group were inadequate in 12.4%, with an 85.7% sensitivity and a 95.9% specificity. There were 8.8% of inadequate specimens in the liquid-based cytology group; sensitivity was 95.1% and specificity was 99.0%. CONCLUSIONS: Although conventional cytology is useful when diagnosing oral PML (better sensitivity and predictive positive value if compared with the cervical smear test with similar specificity) and can improve the accuracy of histological diagnosis, liquid-based cytology gives better results, as it not only enhances both sensitivity and specificity, but also provides material for further investigation (AgNORs, DNA, microbiopsies, etc.).     

Non-surgical biopsy in lung cancer: a paradigm shift

Histological subgroups of non-small cell lung cancer have different prognosis and they require different therapeutic approaches. Accordingly, there is a clinical need in this field to supplement conventional pathological diagnostics with protein and genetic biomarkers that can help to recognize patients responsive to these therapies. Methods for subgroup classification and target identification were developed using surgical samples (surgical lung tumor specimens are available only in 20% of all lung cancer cases). The majority of lung cancer patients, however, have tumors that are irresectable at the time of diagnosis. Therefore, their diagnosis is usually based on bronchoscopically removed tissue or needle biopsy samples analyzed mainly by cytology. Because of the growing need for immunohistochemistry and molecular pathology in lung cancer diagnosis, emphasis should be given to diagnostic bronchoscopic procedures providing tissue samples. Combination of the different biopsy techniques (histology, cytology, bronchial brush, BAL, TBNA etc.), embedding the cells (preparing cell blocks) and, moreover, the availability of immunohistochemical and molecular pathological facilities are all required to set up the proper diagnosis and therapeutic strategy in human lung cancer. Strausz J, Tímár J. Non-surgical biopsy in lung cancer: a paradigm shift.     

Aspiration biopsy cytology, mammography and clinical exploration: a modern set up in diagnosis of tumors of the breast.

Six hundred and two mammary tumors were examined clinically, by mammography and cytology, with a histologic checkup following surgical biopsy. There were 247 cases of malignoma and 355 benign cases. The limited reliability of the individual methods is demonstrated, and it is shown that their combined use can improve the diagnosis. More malignomas are detected, and preoperative diagnosis is made more safely. If all three methods yield identical results, as was the case in 50.2% of the malignant and 32.7% of the benign lesions, the probability of diagnostic error is less than one per cent. With a malignoma thus established, surgical treatment may follow immediately, or irradiation can be started. In benign cases a surgical biopsy may be foregone and further developments may be awaited with due provision for regular control. If the three methods yield conflicting or doubtful results, elucidation by surgical biopsy and histology is indicated.     

Stereotaxic cytology of brain tumors. Review of an eight-year experience

The cytologic diagnosis of 312 stereotaxic samplings performed on 292 patients suspected of having a brain tumor over an eight-year period was reviewed. At different depths of the stereotaxic track, biopsy specimens were secured for cytologic and histologic observations. Smears for cytology were stained both by the May-Grünwald-Giemsa and the Papanicolaou methods since each of them disclosed information complementary to the other. Cytology and histology were in good agreement in 87.5% of the cases. Analysis of the data revealed a cytologic sensitivity of 88.8% and a specificity of 81.9%. The main difficulty encountered was differentiating between nonspecific glial hyperplasia and low-grade astrocytoma. To a lesser degree, differentiating metastases from glioblastoma sometimes was a problem. Stress is laid on the reliability of this type of cytology, its great help when sectioning of unfit specimens makes histologic evaluation hazardous, and its obvious importance when craniotomy is not desirable but a precise pathologic diagnosis is necessary for therapeutic decision. The stereotaxic procedure is briefly reviewed, and the main cytologic findings for the principal lesions encountered are illustrated and discussed.     

恶性肿瘤胸腹水细胞学检验的探讨

目的探讨胸腹水细胞学检验在恶性肿瘤细胞诊断中的应用价值。方法回顾我院2014年1月~2016年6月376例胸腹水脱落细胞学的检验结果,分析胸腹水细胞学检验在恶性肿瘤诊断中的应用价值。结果 376例胸腹水脱落细胞学检验患者中,发现疑似肿瘤细胞3例,恶性肿瘤细胞74例,病理组织学证实恶性肿瘤患者79例,胸腹水细胞学检验的正确率高达97.47%,假阴性率为2.53%,假阳性率为0%。结论胸腹水脱落细胞学检验在恶性肿瘤诊断中具有重要的临床价值,值得临床推广。     

Transthoracic fine needle aspiration biopsy in pulmonary lesions. Updated results

An investigation was carried out on 271 patients who underwent transthoracic fine needle aspiration biopsy ( FNAB ) for suspected pulmonary lesions in a four-year period; 80% of them had a malignant tumor. The histologic control of the cytologic diagnoses made on the transthoracic FNAB was possible in over 50% of the cases. The sensitivity and predictive value for positive results were, respectively, 0.890 and 0.995, whereas the typing accuracy verified in 58 cases on the surgical specimen was 0.76. The comparison of the data obtained from the most recent case material with that of early observations confirmed the high sensitivity of transthoracic FNAB in the detection and characterization of malignant lesions in the lungs. The sensitivity was almost identical for primary tumors, 0.90, and metastatic disease, 0.88. Furthermore, over the years the data showed an improvement in the results due to the experience gained, the combined use of cytology and histology and the application of histochemical methods. More sophisticated methods, such as immunocytochemistry and electron microscopy, were essential to the final diagnosis in only a few cases.     

Brushing cytology of the upper gastrointestinal tract. Obsolete or not?

The merit of brushing cytology of the upper gastrointestinal tract has been questioned since it appears to duplicate biopsy. To determine its value, the reports on all endoscopic biopsy and cytology specimens from a one-year period were reviewed. The 683 procedures included 481 in which only a histologic biopsy sample was obtained, 47 in which only a cytologic brushing sample was obtained and 155 in which both types of samples were obtained ("combined specimens"). Among the 155 combined specimens, 4 of the confirmed malignancies were detected by histology only while 2 were detected by cytology only. A diagnosis of suspicious or positive for malignancy was made for 20% of the combined specimens as compared to less than 5% of the biopsy-only or brushing-only specimens. While 15% of the specimens that included a brushing sample (either alone or with biopsy) showed fungal infections, only 1.2% of the biopsy-only specimens did. It appears that the clinicians at this hospital tend to use brushing in combination with biopsy when either a malignancy or a fungal infection is suspected. Other empiric advantages of endoscopic brushing cytology include its rapid turn-around time, minimal invasiveness and good recognition of lymphoid cells. The selective use of brushing cytology should increase the probability of detecting malignancies and fungal infections without any increased risk or discomfort to the patients.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of bone tumors

OBJECTIVE: To study the role of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the diagnosis of bone tumors and its impact on therapeutic decisions. STUDY DESIGN: A group of 122 cases of bone tumor were evaluated by FNAC. Detailed diagnoses were compared with the available histology. RESULTS: Diagnostic accuracy of FNAC was 90.5% in this study. FNAC could differentiate between various round cell tumors such as Ewing's sarcoma and myeloma, among various giant cell-rich lesions of bone and between the benign and malignant chondroid bone tumors. Some uncommon variants were also correctly diagnosed. In metastatic bone tumors, the source of primary malignancy could not be indicated in the majority (52.9%) because of the poorly differentiated morphology. Osteoid or osteoid-like material was demonstrable in 63.6% cases of osteogenic sarcoma. A case of chondroblastic osteogenic sarcoma that was reported as chondrosarcoma was the only diagnostic error in the study. FNAC obviated the need of open biopsy in 63.8% patients, and therapeutic decisions were made according to the cytologic diagnoses. CONCLUSION: FNAC plays an important role in the early diagnosis of bone tumors by its accuracy, ease of use and rapidity and is helpful in making the therapeutic decisions.     

High diagnostic accuracy of cytologic smears of central nervous system tumors. A 15-year experience based on 4,172 patients

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the diagnostic accuracy and current role of intraoperative cytologic smears of central nervous system tumors. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of 4,172 patients operated on during 1985-1999, with 3,541 intraoperative smears performed during open procedures and 631 during stereotactic biopsies. RESULTS: Complete correlation with the final diagnosis was achieved in a mean of 89.8% (range, 83-93.7% per year). Diagnostic accuracy increased to 95% on average (range, 91.5-96.7% per year) when cases of partial correlation, mainly due to grading deviations, were included. The most accurate intraoperative diagnoses were obtained in cases of meningioma (97.9%), metastasis (96.3%) and glioblastoma (95.7%). A significant reduction in diagnostic accuracy was observed in cases of oligodendroglioma (80.9%) and ependymoma (77.7%). Besides diagnosis and grading, smear cytology provided resection guidance in cases of well-delineated tumors. CONCLUSION: Intraoperative smears in neurosurgery are easy to obtain and inexpensive and have high diagnostic accuracy. In addition to stereotactic biopsy procedures, intraoperative smears permit reliable intraoperative guidance during lesion targeting and resection.     

Salivary duct carcinoma of the parotid gland: report of a rare case with a comparative study of aspiration cytology and histomorphology

BACKGROUND: Salivary duct carcinomas affecting primarily the parotid gland are extremely rare (0.2-2% of all salivary gland tumors). These carcinomas are considered to be of high grade malignancy, with mortality in up to 70% of cases. They usually affect elderly males and less often young adults. Despite the fact that the histomorphologic characteristics of this tumor are always necessary for its classification, several authors have reported that the cytopathologic approach, using fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology, can establish the final diagnosis. The aim of this paper is to present a rare case of salivary duct carcinoma of the parotid gland with no typical microscopic findings that was diagnosed by FNA cytology through a combination of techniques on biopsy material. CASE: A 56-year-old male presented with a right parotid mass measuring 6 cm in diameter. The mass appeared to expand subcutaneously and infiltrate the skin of the neck region. Biopsy material from both the mass and skin was obtained using FNA and processed with conventional, cell block and liquid-based cytology techniques. A core biopsy was also performed on the mass for histologic evaluation. CONCLUSION: The findings were consistent with a salivary duct carcinoma of the parotid gland and were confirmed by the histologic report. FNA cytology combined with such techniques as liquid-based cytology provides the potential for the final diagnosis. Liquid-based cytology can improve the cellular morphology of the material and allows immunocytochemistry and other diagnostic techniques. The application of such techniques is significantly restricted by conventional processing; thus, combining liquid-based cytology with other techniques expands the boundaries of cytology as a diagnostic test.     

Significance of endoscopic biopsy and cytology in the diagnosis of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma

We have tested the role and significance of histology combined with cytology in the diagnosis of esophageal squamous cell carcinomas. Biopsy specimens and samples for cytological smear were taken by a fiberoptic flexible endoscope. In order to minimise the loss of biological sample, the residue from the brush was removed with rinsing fluid. From 1973 to 2005 we examined 820 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the esophagus. Endoscopic biopsy yielded positive result in 97.2%. Cytology performed in 724 patients turned out to be positive in 90.3%. Both examinations were conducted in 648 patients (79%), and yielded positive result in 572 patients (88.3%). Negative biopsy result was obtained in 22 patients, however, 14 of them had positive cytological diagnosis. Both biopsy and cytology were negative in 8 cancer patients (1%). No complication was observed with either diagnostic technique. In our material cancer was diagnosed in 776 patients by histology. However, in a further 14 of 22 patients with negative histology, cancer was detected by cytology. This means that the presence of cancer was also confirmed on the basis of morphological features in 790 cases, i.e. in 96.3% of the patients. Our results show that the combined use of biopsy and cytology in malignant tumours yields high diagnostic accuracy. Since abrasion exfoliate cytology is a quick and useful diagnostic measure it should be a routine examination in the evaluation of abnormal changes in the esophageal mucosa. The examination of the rinsing fluid of the sampling brush, introduced by us, yielded additional diagnostic information.     

The use of cytospin monolayer technique in the cytological diagnosis of vulval and anal disease

This pilot study investigated the use of the non-invasive cytospin monolayer technique in the diagnosis and screening of neoplastic and non-neoplastic vulval disease. Twenty-three patients (age range 34-86 years) attending a vulval disease clinic had brush cytology performed. The samples were prepared with a cytospin monolayer technique and the slides Papanicolaou-stained. Subsequent cytological interpretation and diagnosis were performed without knowledge of the clinical history and correlated with follow-up biopsy histopathology from each patient. Twenty-eight cytospin samples were analysed in total, of which 11 (39%) contained dyskaryotic cells which were assessed and a predicted VIN/AIN grade given. Ten of 11 samples (91%) reported as dyskaryotic had VIN/AIN on biopsy histology. One of 11 samples (9%) was reported as containing occasional squamous cells with borderline nuclear features and, although the corresponding biopsy did not show VIN, basal atypia was reported. One patient had features suggesting invasive carcinoma on cytology which was verified on subsequent biopsy. The 15 cases in which no dyskaryotic cells were identified did not show VIN or AIN on subsequent histology. Two cases were acellular and considered inadequate for cytological interpretation. The cytospin monolayer technique allows the diagnosis of neoplastic from non-neoplastic vulval disease. It is a quick, inexpensive and non-invasive method that may have a role in diagnosis, screening and surveillance of patients.     

Stereotaxy and thalamic masses. Survey of 44 cases

Thalamic masses are generally considered inoperable; little is known of the precise nature of these lesions. Stereotactic biopsy was performed in 44 patients, with no mortality and low morbidity (only 1 case of transitory hemiparesis). The stereotactic biopsy (minimum 5 specimens taken along the major axis of the lesion) showed that the majority of the young patients (less than 40 years) had low-grade glial neoplasms (grade I-II astrocytomas or oligodendrogliomas), while in older patients highly malignant tumors prevailed. Beside the neoplasms in the children and adults, we found granulomas, abscesses, infarcts, hemorrhages and glioses. Present neuroradiological methods cannot establish a final correct diagnosis in thalamic lesions, so stereotactic biopsy is recommended. A follow-up of 1-6 years is presented for 7 patients who underwent stereotactic 125I brachytherapy.     

Liquid-based endometrial cytology: cyto-histological correlation in a population of 917 women

OBJECTIVE: Liquid-based cytology, because of its capacity to reduce the obscuring factors and to provide thin-layer specimens, represents an opportunity to reevaluate endometrial cytology. In order to assess the utility of the liquid-based method in endometrial diagnosis, we evaluated its accuracy in comparison with histology. METHODS: Nine hundred and seventeen women scheduled for hysteroscopy were enrolled in the study. After providing informed consent, all the women proceeded sequentially to hysteroscopy, endometrial cytology and then biopsy endometrial sampling. RESULTS: Cyto-histological correlations were possible in 519 cases (57%): in 361 (39%) cases the biopsy was inadequate, in 15 (2%) the cytology was inadequate, and in 22 (2%) both were inadequate. At biopsy 25 (3%) women had adenocarcinoma, 5 (1%) had adenomatous atypical hyperplasia and 21 (2%) had simple non atypical hyperplasia. At cytology two adenocarcinomas and one adenomatous atypical hyperplasia were underrated as atypical hyperplasias and as non-atypical hyperplasia; two simple non-atypical hyperplasias were reported as negative; and eight cases were false positive (non-atypical hyperplasia at cytology, negative at biopsy). In our population, the cytology provided sufficient material more often than biopsy (P < 0.04). Sensitivity was estimated at 96%, specificity at 98%, positive predictive value at 86% and negative predictive value at 99%. CONCLUSIONS: We concluded that endometrial cytology may be an efficient diagnostic method. It could be applied to selected patients solely or in association with ultrasonography. The combination of these two noninvasive procedures may improve their diagnostic accuracy and reduce unnecessary hysteroscopies, thereby producing benefits for women and society.