Mesoscale Modeling of Nucleosome-Binding Antibody PL2-6: Mono- versus Bivalent Chromatin Complexes

Interactions of chromatin with bivalent immunoglobin nucleosome-binding antibodies and their monovalent (papain-derived) antigen-binding fragment analogs are useful probes for examining chromatin conformational states. To help interpret antibody-chromatin interactions and explore how antibodies might compete for interactions with chromatin components, we incorporate coarse-grained PL2-6 antibody modeling into our mesoscale chromatin model. We analyze interactions and fiber structures for the antibody-chromatin complexes in open and condensed chromatin, with and without H1 linker histone (LH). Despite minimal and transient interactions at physiological salt, we capture significant differences in antibody-chromatin complex configurations in open fibers, with more intense interactions between the bivalent antibody and chromatin compared to monovalent antigen-binding fragments. For these open chromatin fiber morphologies, antibody binding to histone tails is increased and compaction is greater for bivalent compared to monovalent and antibody-free systems. Differences between monovalent and bivalent binding result from antibody competition with internal chromatin fiber components (nucleosome core and linker DNA) for histone tail (H3, H4, H2A, H2B) interactions. This antibody competition for tail contacts reduces tail-core and tail-linker interactions and increases tail-antibody interactions. Such internal structural changes in open fibers resemble mechanisms of LH condensation, driven by charge screening and entropy changes. For condensed fibers at physiological salt, the three systems are much more similar overall, but some subtle tail interaction differences can be noted. Adding LH results in less-dramatic changes for all systems, except that the bivalent complex at physiological salt shows cooperative effects between LH and the antibodies in condensing chromatin fibers. Such dynamic interactions that depend on the internal structure and complex-stabilizing interactions within the chromatin fiber have implications for gene regulation and other chromatin complexes such as with LH, remodeling proteins, and small molecular chaperones that bind and modulate chromatin structure.     

Hho1p, the linker histone of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is important for the proper chromatin organization in vivo

Despite the existence of certain differences between yeast and higher eukaryotic cells a considerable part of our knowledge on chromatin structure and function has been obtained by experimenting on Saccharomyces cerevisiae. One of the peculiarities of S. cerevisiae cells is the unusual and less abundant linker histone, Hho1p. Sparse is the information about Hho1p involvement in yeast higher-order chromatin organization. In an attempt to search for possible effects of Hho1p on the global organization of chromatin, we have applied Chromatin Comet Assay (ChCA) on HHO1 knock-out yeast cells. The results showed that the mutant cells exhibited highly distorted higher-order chromatin organization. Characteristically, linker histone depleted chromatin generally exhibited longer chromatin loops than the wild-type. According to the Atomic force microscopy data the wild-type chromatin appeared well organized in structures resembling quite a lot the "30-nm" fiber in contrast to HHO1 knock-out yeast.     

Linker histone partial phosphorylation: effects on secondary structure and chromatin condensation

Linker histones are involved in chromatin higher-order structure and gene regulation. We have successfully achieved partial phosphorylation of linker histones in chicken erythrocyte soluble chromatin with CDK2, as indicated by HPCE, MALDI-TOF and Tandem MS. We have studied the effects of linker histone partial phosphorylation on secondary structure and chromatin condensation. Infrared spectroscopy analysis showed a gradual increase of β-structure in the phosphorylated samples, concomitant to a decrease in α-helix/turns, with increasing linker histone phosphorylation. This conformational change could act as the first step in the phosphorylation-induced effects on chromatin condensation. A decrease of the sedimentation rate through sucrose gradients of the phosphorylated samples was observed, indicating a global relaxation of the 30-nm fiber following linker histone phosphorylation. Analysis of specific genes, combining nuclease digestion and qPCR, showed that phosphorylated samples were more accessible than unphosphorylated samples, suggesting local chromatin relaxation. Chromatin aggregation was induced by MgCl₂ and analyzed by dynamic light scattering (DLS). Phosphorylated chromatin had lower percentages in volume of aggregated molecules and the aggregates had smaller hydrodynamic diameter than unphosphorylated chromatin, indicating that linker histone phosphorylation impaired chromatin aggregation. These findings provide new insights into the effects of linker histone phosphorylation in chromatin condensation.     

DNA sequence-dependent contributions of core histone tails to nucleosome stability: differential effects of acetylation and proteolytic tail removal

Modulation of nucleosome stability in chromatin plays an important role in eukaryotic gene expression. The core histone N-terminal tail domains are believed to modulate the stability of wrapping nucleosomal DNA and the stability of the chromatin filament. We analyzed the contribution of the tail domains to the stability of nucleosomes containing selected DNA sequences that are intrinsically straight, curved, flexible, or inflexible. We find that the presence of the histone tail domains stabilizes nucleosomes containing DNA sequences that are intrinsically straight or curved. However, the tails do not significantly contribute to the free energy of nucleosome formation with flexible DNA. Interestingly, hyperacetylation of the core histone tail domains does not recapitulate the effect of tail removal by limited proteolysis with regard to nucleosome stability. We find that acetylation of the tails has the same minor effect on nucleosome stability for all the selected DNA sequences. A comparison of histone partitioning between long donor chromatin, acceptor DNA, and free histones in solution shows that the core histone tails mediate internucleosomal interactions within an H1-depleted chromatin fiber amounting to an average free energy of about 1 kcal/mol. Thus, such interactions would be significant with regard to the free energies of sequence-dependent nucleosome positioning. Last, we analyzed the contribution of the H2A/H2B dimers to nucleosome stability. We find that the intact nucleosome is stabilized by 900 cal/mol by the presence of the dimers regardless of sequence. The biological implications of these observations are discussed.     

Linker DNA destabilizes condensed chromatin.

The contribution of the linker region to maintenance of condensed chromatin was examined in two model systems, namely sea urchin sperm nuclei and chicken red blood cell nuclei. Linkerless nuclei, prepared by extensive digestion with micrococcal nuclease, were compared with Native nuclei using several assays, including microscopic appearance, nuclear turbidity, salt stability, and trypsin resistance. Chromatin in the Linkerless nuclei was highly condensed, resembling pyknotic chromatin in apoptotic cells. Linkerless nuclei were more stable in low ionic strength buffers and more resistant to trypsin than Native nuclei. Analysis of histones from the trypsinized nuclei by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that specific histone H1, H2B, and H3 tail regions stabilized linker DNA in condensed nuclei. Thermal denaturation of soluble chromatin preparations from differentially trypsinized sperm nuclei demonstrated that the N-terminal regions of histones Sp H1, Sp H2B, and H3 bind tightly to linker DNA, causing it to denature at a high temperature. We conclude that linker DNA exerts a disruptive force on condensed chromatin structure which is counteracted by binding of specific histone tail regions to the linker DNA. The inherent instability of the linker region may be significant in all eukaryotic chromatins and may promote gene activation in living cells.     

30 nm chromatin fibre decompaction requires both H4-K16 acetylation and linker histone eviction

The mechanism by which chromatin is decondensed to permit access to DNA is largely unknown. Here, using a model nucleosome array reconstituted from recombinant histone octamers, we have defined the relative contribution of the individual histone octamer N-terminal tails as well as the effect of a targeted histone tail acetylation on the compaction state of the 30 nm chromatin fiber. This study goes beyond previous studies as it is based on a nucleosome array that is very long (61 nucleosomes) and contains a stoichiometric concentration of bound linker histone, which is essential for the formation of the 30 nm chromatin fiber. We find that compaction is regulated in two steps: Introduction of H4 acetylated to 30% on K16 inhibits compaction to a greater degree than deletion of the H4 N-terminal tail. Further decompaction is achieved by removal of the linker histone.     

Detection of interactions between nucleosome arrays mediated by specific core histone tail domains

The core histone tail domains play important roles in different stages of chromatin condensation. The tails are required for folding nucleosome arrays into secondary chromatin structures such as the approximately 30 nm diameter chromatin fiber and for mediating fiber-fiber interactions important for formation of tertiary chromatin structures. Crosslinking studies have demonstrated that inter-nucleosomal tail-DNA contacts appear in conjunction with salt-induced folding of nucleosome arrays into in higher order chromatin structures. However, since both folding of nucleosome arrays and fiber-fiber interactions take place simultaneously in >2-3 mM MgCl(2) such inter-nucleosome interactions may reflect short range (intra-array) or longer range (inter-array) interactions. Here, we describe a novel technique to specifically identify inter-array interactions mediated by the histone tail domains. In addition, we describe a new method for the preparation of H3/H4 tetramers.     

Linker histone tails and N-tails of histone H3 are redundant: scanning force microscopy studies of reconstituted fibers.

The mechanisms responsible for organizing linear arrays of nucleosomes into the three-dimensional structure of chromatin are still largely unknown. In a companion paper (Leuba, S. H., et al. 1998. Biophys. J. 74:2823-2829), we study the contributions of linker histone domains and the N-terminal tail of core histone H3 to extended chromatin fiber structure by scanning force microscopy imaging of mildly trypsinized fibers. Here we complement and extend these studies by scanning force microscopy imaging of selectively reconstituted chromatin fibers, which differ in subtle but distinctive ways in their histone composition. We demonstrate an absolute requirement for the globular domain of the linker histones and a structural redundancy of the tails of linker histones and of histone H3 in determining conformational stability.     

Hho1p,the linker histone of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is important for the proper chromatin organization in vivo

Despite the existence of certain differences between yeast and higher eukaryotic cells a considerable part of our knowledge on chromatin structure and function has been obtained by experimenting on Saccharomyces cerevisiae. One of the peculiarities of S. cerevisiae cells is the unusual and less abundant linker histone, Hho1p. Sparse is the information about Hho1p involvement in yeast higher-order chromatin organization. In an attempt to search for possible effects of Hho1p on the global organization of chromatin, we have applied Chromatin Comet Assay (ChCA) on HHO1 knock-out yeast cells. The results showed that the mutant cells exhibited highly distorted higher-order chromatin organization. Characteristically, linker histone depleted chromatin generally exhibited longer chromatin loops than the wild-type. According to the Atomic force microscopy data the wild-type chromatin appeared well organized in structures resembling quite a lot the “30-nm” fiber in contrast to HHO1 knock-out yeast.     

A model for chromatin opening: stimulation of topoisomerase II and restriction enzyme cleavage of chromatin by distamycin.

Histone H1 preferentially and cooperatively binds scaffold-associated regions (SARs) in vitro via specific interactions with the numerous short A + T-rich tracts (A-tracts) contained in these sequences. Selective titration of A-tracts by the oligopeptide distamycin abolishes this interaction and results in a redistribution of H1. Similarly, treatment of intact cells and isolated nuclei with distamycin specifically enhances cleavage of internucleosomal linkers of SARs by topoisomerase II and restriction enzymes. The increased accessibility of these linkers is thought to result from the unfolding (or opening) of the chromatin fiber and to be due to a reduced occupancy by histone H1. Chromatin extraction and H1 assembly experiments support this view. We discuss a model whereby open, H1-depleted chromatin regions may be generated by titration of A-tracts by putative distamycin analogues; this local opening may spread to adjacent regions assuming highly cooperative H1-H1 interactions in chromatin.     

The H3 tail domain participates in multiple interactions during folding and self-association of nucleosome arrays

The core histone tail domains play a central role in chromatin structure and epigenetic processes controlling gene expression. Although little is known regarding the molecular details of tail interactions, it is likely that they participate in both short-range and long-range interactions between nucleosomes. Previously, we demonstrated that the H3 tail domain participates in internucleosome interactions during MgCl(2)-dependent condensation of model nucleosome arrays. However, these studies did not distinguish whether these internucleosome interactions represented short-range intra-array or longer-range interarray interactions. To better understand the complex interactions of the H3 tail domain during chromatin condensation, we have developed a new site-directed cross-linking method to identify and quantify interarray interactions mediated by histone tail domains. Interarray cross-linking was undetectable under salt conditions that induced only local folding, but was detected concomitant with salt-dependent interarray oligomerization at higher MgCl(2) concentrations. Interestingly, lysine-to-glutamine mutations in the H3 tail domain to mimic acetylation resulted in little or no reduction in interarray cross-linking. In contrast, binding of a linker histone caused a much greater enhancement of interarray interactions for unmodified H3 tails compared to "acetylated" H3 tails. Collectively these results indicate that H3 tail domain performs multiple functions during chromatin condensation via distinct molecular interactions that can be differentially regulated by acetylation or binding of linker histones.     

Toward convergence of experimental studies and theoretical modeling of the chromatin fiber

Understanding the structural organization of eukaryotic chromatin and its control of gene expression represents one of the most fundamental and open challenges in modern biology. Recent experimental advances have revealed important characteristics of chromatin in response to changes in external conditions and histone composition, such as the conformational complexity of linker DNA and histone tail domains upon compact folding of the fiber. In addition, modeling studies based on high-resolution nucleosome models have helped explain the conformational features of chromatin structural elements and their interactions in terms of chromatin fiber models. This minireview discusses recent progress and evidence supporting structural heterogeneity in chromatin fibers, reconciling apparently contradictory fiber models.