Purification of the Chick Eye Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor

Dissociated 8-day chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons will not survive for even 24 h in culture without the addition of specific supplements. One such supplement is a protein termed the ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) which is present at very high concentrations within intraocular tissues that contain the same muscle cells innervated by ciliary ganglionic neurons in vivo. We describe here the purification of chick eye CNTF by a 2 1/2-day procedure involving the processing of intraocular tissue extract sequentially through DE52 ion-exchange chromatography, membrane ultrafiltration-concentration, sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation, and preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gradient electrophoresis. An aqueous extract of the tissue from 300 eyes will yield about 10-20 micrograms of biologically active, electrophoretically pure CNTF with a specific activity of 7.5 X 10(6) trophic units/mg protein. Purified CNTF has an Mr of 20,400 daltons and an isoelectric point of about 5, as determined by analytical gel electrophoresis. In addition to supporting the survival of ciliary ganglion neurons, purified CNTF also supports the 24-h survival of cultured neurons from certain chick and rodent sensory and sympathetic ganglia. CNTF differs from mouse submaxillary nerve growth factor (NGF) in molecular weight, isoelectric point, inability to be inactivated by antibodies to NGF, ability to support the in vitro survival of the ciliary ganglion neurons, and inability to support that of 8-day chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic neurons. Thus, CNTF represents the first purified neuronotrophic factor which addresses parasympathetic cholinergic neurons.     

Blot and culture analysis of neuronotrophic factors in nerve regeneration chamber fluids

The fluid accumulating in silicone nerve regeneration chambers implanted between the cut ends of rat sciatic nerve contains neuronotrophic activities towards embryonic chick ciliary and sympathetic neurons. The blot and culture technique of Carnow et al. was used to determine if part of the neuronotrophic activities is due to ciliary neuronotrophic factor, which supports the survival of both types of neurons in vitro. The technique involves separating the fluid proteins by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, Western transfer, and then culturing of purified neurons on the nitrocellulose blots. After 24 hr surviving neurons are restricted to regions of the blot where neuronotrophic factor is present. Analysis of 1 and 2 day fluids showed that a multitude of factors are present, particularly in the 19–30 kD molecular weight range, with discrete peaks of activity at molecular weights consistent with those reported for ciliary neuronotrophic factor. There were several other peaks of activity present in the fluids in addition to these.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Lawrence Austin     

Antiserum Against Neurite Outgrowth Factor in Chick Gizzard Extract and Its Inhibitory Effect on Neuritic Response in Cultured Ciliary Neurons

Abstract: Antiserum against a neurite outgrowth factor (NOF) of gizzard extract that promotes neurite outgrowth from dissociated ciliary ganglionic neurons (CG neurons) of 8-day-old chick embryo was prepared to determine whether or not the antiserum inhibits neurite outgrowth from cultured neurons or explants of chick and murine tissues. When CG neurons were cultured on a polyornithine-coated well exposed to NOF (NOF-bound POR well), marked neurite outgrowth was observed. When NOF-bound POR wells were exposed to antiserum, neurite outgrowth from CG neurons was gradually inhibited with increasing amounts of antiserum, while exposure to preimmune serum did not prevent neurite outgrowth. Antiserum had no effect on neuronal survival during a 48-h incubation. The diluted antiserum, which produced nearly 100% inhibition of the NOF activity, was almost equally active in suppressing the activity of NOFs in conditioned media (CM) of various chick embryo tissues, but showed much less inhibitory effects on NOFs in CM of murine tissues. The appearance of neurites from explants of spinal cord, dorsal root ganglion, or retina of chick embryo was also inhibited by the antiserum. These results indicate that antiserum against NOF from gizzard extract suppressed the activity of NOFs from various sources, and that there are species differences in NOFs, at least between chick and murine.     

Differential Effects of Nerve Growth Factor and Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor on Catecholamine Storage and Catecholamine Synthesizing Enzymes of Cultured Rat Chromaffin Cells

The effects of nerve growth factor (NGF) and ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) on catecholamine content and in vitro activities of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and phenylethanolamine N-methyltransferase (PNMT) were studied in adrenal chromaffin cells cultured from 8-day-old rats. Both NGF and CNTF enhanced chromaffin cell survival and partially prevented losses of adrenaline during the 4-day culture period in a dose-dependent manner. CNTF was more potent, although cellular levels of adrenaline and noradrenaline were not maintained. NGF did not add to the effect of CNTF. The effect of CNTF on catecholamine storage was not accompanied by changes in the activities of TH and PNMT. In contrast, NGF induced TH but not PNMT activity. These data indicate differences between the mechanisms by which NGF and CNTF affect adrenal chromaffin cells.     

Characterization and Partial Purification of a Novel Neuronotrophic Factor from Bovine Seminal Vesicle

Extracts from bovine seminal vesicles have been shown to contain high concentrations of nerve growth factor (NGF)-like biological activity and of the NGF protein with properties corresponding to that of NGF from other sources. We now demonstrate that a second neuronotrophic protein, termed seminal vesicle-derived neuronotrophic factor (SVNF), is present in seminal vesicle extracts (SVEs), which could not be distinguished from NGF on the basis of biological activity. SVNF has neuronotrophic activity on NGF target cells like embryonic chicken-sensory and sympathetic neurons, sympathetic neurons, and chromaffin cells from neonatal rats, but it is inactive on embryonic chicken ciliary or neonatal rat nodose ganglion neurons. It also stimulates fiber outgrowth from rat pheochromocytoma (PC 12) cells. In gel filtration chromatography on Biogel A 1.5 m, the activity is eluted with an apparent molecular weight of 40 kilodaltons, and by preparative isoelectric focusing, the isoelectric point was determined to be in the neutral range (6.8-7.8). The biological activity of SVNF, in contrast to that of NGF, is partially retained after preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and can be electrophoretically eluted with an apparent molecular weight of 16-20 kilodaltons. Electrophoretically purified SVNF is not inhibited by antisera to mouse NGF, but its activity is increased greater than 10-fold in the presence of very low concentrations of NGF. For partially purified SVNF, a specific activity of 2.9-5.8 X 10(5) biological units/mg of protein was determined in the presence of subthreshold NGF concentrations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor Stimulates Choline Acetyltransferase Activity in Cultured Chicken Retina Neurons

It has been demonstrated that cultured cholinergic retinal neurons from 8-day-old chicken embryos respond to a polypeptide factor present in retinal cell-conditioned medium (RCM) and in retinal extracts. Compared with control cultures, the activity of acetyl-CoA:choline O-acetyltransferase (EC 2.3.1.6; ChAT) is enhanced more than twofold in neuronal retinal cultures grown for 7 days in the presence of RCM. The present study demonstrates that both ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), which is characterized by its trophic activity on parasympathetic ciliary neurons, and RCM exhibit identical stimulatory effects on ChAT activity in retinal monolayer cultures. Similarly, RCM supports the in vitro survival of ciliary neurons to the same extent as CNTF. The active species in RCM has a molecular weight (20,900 +/- 1,000) identical to that of CNTF, as determined by preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis. The results indicate that cholinergic retinal neurons represent a central neuronal target for CNTF or a closely related protein.     

Cholinergic Neuronotrophic Factors: Fractionation Properties of an Extract from Selected Chick Embryonic Eye Tissues

Abstract: An aqueous extract derived from selected intraocular tissues of 15-day chick embryos contains a soluble macromolecular agent which is capable of ensuring the survival of 8-day chick embryonic ciliary ganglionic neurons in monolayer culture. When this ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) was concentrated using ultrafiltration and subjected to Sephadex G100 and G200 chromatography, activity was detected in most of the eluted fractions. A peak of the most active fractions was eluted in a region corresponding to a molecular weight of 35–40 ± 10³ and contained about 20-30% of the applied protein. CNTF activity bound readily to DE-52 cellulose resin at neutral pH and was eluted with NaCl in a narrow region containing about 20-40% of the applied protein. Gel electrophoretic staining profiles of the active DE52 fraction indicated considerable (but still only partial) simplification in protein composition. While significant CNTF activity losses were incurred in response to each of the above treatments, an active material could be conveniently generated in one working day in milligram amounts having a specific activity of 60,000 trophic units/mg protein. This trophic activity is in the same range as that of the only other known neuronotrophic factor, Nerve Growth Factor.     

A ciliary neuronotrophic factor from peripheral nerve and smooth muscle which is not retrogradely transported

We have found that a CNTF-like molecule which supports ciliary and sympathetic neurons is not retrogradely transported in either sympathetic or parasympathetic nerves. The factor has an apparent M_r of 21 kDa, a pI of 4.9, and is present in peripheral nerves and smooth muscle of the chick. Our experiments indicate that CNTF-like activity does not accumulate on the distal side of ligated chickexpansor nerves. In contrast, there is a clear accumulation of NGF. The activity further differs from NGF in that it is not removed from a smooth muscle of the chick wing by innervating sympathetic fibers. Transection of these fibers does not lead to an accumulation of ciliary activity in theexpansor secundariorum muscle, suggesting that neurons do not actively deplete the muscle of factor by retrograde transport. Finally, recombinant CNTF or semi-purified preparations of CNTF-like activity labelled with¹²⁵I were not transported to the ciliary ganglion of chicks following injection of biologically active material into the eye. Our results suggest either that endogenous CNTF does not act as a survival factorin vivo, or that retrograde transport is not a property inherent to all neuronotrophic molecules.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Lawrence Austin     

Characterization of Chick Gizzard Extract That Promotes Neurite Outgrowth in Cultured Ciliary Neurons

Abstract: Chicken gizzard extract contains a macromolecule(s) that promotes the neurite outgrowth of dissociated neurons from the ciliary ganglia (CG) of chick embryos. The factor in gizzard extract was partially purified and estimated to be about 12S (M.W. 200,000-300,000) on sucrose density gradient centrifugation. The neurite outgrowth of CG neurons by the factor strictly depends on the embryonal age. The maximal neurite outgrowth was observed when CG neurons were dissociated from the embryos younger than 10 days. After that time the response of CG neurons to the factor rapidly declined and was almost lost at day 14. The amount of factor in the gizzard began to increase rapidly from 12-day-old embryo and reached the maximal level at day 16, and thereafter a fairly steady level was maintained. When CG neurons were co-cultured with rat myotubes, the ratio of muscle cells with synaptic responses (miniature end-plate potentials) was significantly higher in the presence of gizzard factor than its absence. The results suggest that this factor acts as an external signal on CG neurons to form synaptic connections in vivo.     

Rat sciatic nerve schwann cell microcultures: Responses to mitogens and production of trophic and neurite-promoting factors

During embryonic development and in response to injury, the growing axons of peripheral neurons may influence the migration and proliferation of Schwann cells which, in return, may present neurons with a critical supply of factors required for neuronal survival, growth and differentiation. The identification and characterization of agents influencing the proliferation of Schwann cells as well as Schwann cell production of factors affecting neurons is greatly facilitated by the use of in vitro techniques. We describe here a simplified method of obtaining large numbers of purified neonatal rat sciatic nerve Schwann cells for use in generating large numbers of replicate microcultures. We then illustrate the use of these microcultures to examine Schwann cell: i) morphology and survival; ii) proliferation; and iii) production of neuronotrophic and neurite-promoting activities. We report that rat Schwann cells in microculture proliferate in response to serum, laminin and fibronectin, cholera toxin, and chick embryo parasympathetic ciliary neurons. Also, extracts of Schwann cell microcultures contain independently regulated activities which support the survival and neurite outgrowth of peripheral ganglionic neurons.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Paola S. Timiras     

Cholinergic neuronotrophic factors: VI. Age-dependent requirements by chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons

During development, ciliary ganglionic neurons become postmitotic and extend neurites in apparent independence of the presence of their future intraocular innervation targets. After reaching their peripheral innervation territory, however, these neurons become target dependent and about half of them die. We have previously reported that chick embryo intraocular target tissues contain a ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), which can be extracted and partially purified in a soluble form and which ensures near-total survival of 8-day chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons in monolayer cultures. In this study we have dissociated and cultured ciliary ganglia from embryonic Day (ED) 5 through 14, and examined dependence and responsiveness of their neurons to exogenously added CNTF. Two cell classes (dark and bright) could be distinguished by phase microscopy and differentially counted in cell dissociates from ED7–14, but not in ED5–6 ones. Dark cell number per ganglion increased from 6000 to 78,000 over this developmental time period. In contrast, bright cells (putative neurons) declined from a maximum of about 10,000 to 6000, suggesting a correlation with the expected neuronal cell death in vivo. Dissociated cells from ED5–14 ganglia were seeded on a polyornithine substratum coated with neurite promoting factor, cultured for 24 hr with or without added CNTF, and numerically examined for survival and neuritic development. Cultures from ED7–14 ganglia showed two cell categories: (i) flat nonneuronal elements dramatically increased in number with ganglionic age (thereby correlating with the increasing number of dark cells in the dissociates) and (ii) large, bright cells (often displaying neurite outgrowth) decreased in number in parallel with bright cell number in the dissociate. The survival of these neuronal elements was strictly dependent on exogenously added CNTF between ED7 and 10, but became progressively independent with older ages. ED14 neurons (fully capable of surviving for 24 hr without added CNTF) continued to require CNTF for neurite extension, thus displaying retained sensitivity to this factor. Although the ED5–6 cultures contained well-recognizable flat cells, the dominant category comprised cells with variable morphology, practically all of which exhibited neurite-like processes. Both the survival and neurite extension of these cells, which we tentatively interpret as immature neurons were independent of the presence of added CNTF.     

An 82-Kilodalton Membrane Protein that Inhibits the Activity of Neurite Outgrowth Factor

Neurite outgrowth factor (NOF), an extracellular matrix glycoprotein of 700 kilodaltons (kDa), promoted neurite outgrowth from cultured ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons of chicken embryo. A fraction solubilized with Nonidet P-40 of chicken gizzard muscle membranes inhibited the neurite-promoting activity of NOF in a dose-dependent manner, but not that of laminin. Binding of CG neurons to the substratum and their survival were not affected by the extract. The inhibitory activity of the extract was abolished by treatment with trypsin or heat. The molecular size was determined to be about 82 kDa by ligand blotting. The active component was partially purified by column chromatography. It is suggested that this molecule interacts with the domain of NOF responsible for its neurite-promoting activity and may modulate NOF activity during development in vivo.     

Purification of a Ciliary Neurotrophic Factor from Bovine Heart

A neurotrophic factor that promotes the survival of cholinergic parasympathetic ciliary neurons has been purified approximately 20,000-fold from bovine cardiac tissue under nondenaturing conditions using heparin-affinity chromatography. Up to 22 micrograms of purified factor having a specific activity of 4 X 10(5) trophic units/mg can be obtained from 250 g of heart muscle. Sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gels of the purified material show a broad band that is sometimes resolvable into a closely spaced pair of bands of 22 and 23 kilodaltons. Partially purified factor can be resolved into two peaks of activity (pI 5.6 and 5.0) by high-resolution anion-exchange chromatography and chromatofocusing, although these procedures have not proved useful as purification methods because of the large losses of activity incurred. It is likely that these two peaks represent the two bands seen on SDS-polyacrylamide gels. The bovine cardiac factor(s) differs from similar factors purified from chick optic tissues and pig brain in that it is irreversibly denatured by SDS.     

The in vitro biological effect of nerve growth factor is inhibited by synthetic peptides.

Nerve growth factor (NGF)1 is a neurotrophic polypeptide that acts via specific receptors to promote the survival and growth of neurons. To delineate the NGF domain(s) responsible for eliciting biological activity, we synthesized small peptides corresponding to three regions in NGF that are hydrophilic and highly conserved. Several peptides from mouse NGF region 26-40 inhibited the neurite-promoting effect of NGF on sensory neurons in vitro. Inhibition was sequence-specific and could be overcome by increasing the concentration of NGF. Moreover, peptide actions were specific for NGF-mediated events in that they failed to block the neurotrophic activity of ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) or phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA). In spite of the inhibition of NGF activity, peptides did not affect the binding of radiolabeled NGF. These studies define one region of NGF that may be required for neurotrophic activity.     

Human Skeletal Muscle Cells Synthesise a Neuronotrophic Factor Reactive with Spinal Neurons

Retrograde trophic influences originating in the skeletal musculature have been postulated to be involved in regulating survival and differentiation of embryonic motor neurons and reactive terminal sprouting of mature motor fibres. We have previously described the use of a quantitative immunoassay for neurofilament protein to bioassay in vitro the cell-type-specific neuronotrophic activity of nerve growth factor (NGF) on sensory ganglion neurons. In the present study, the effect of media conditioned by adult human muscle cells (MCM) on the in vitro development of chicken spinal neurons has been studied using a similar approach. Significant increases in neurofilament protein levels in 7-day chicken embryonic spinal cord cultures were found with doses of MCM protein as low as 0.4 microgram/ml, with a dose-response relationship yielding maximal and half-maximal effects at 4 and 1 microgram/ml, respectively. Maximal increases in neurofilament protein levels were associated with an approximate two-fold increase in neuronal cell survival. MCM also induced increases in choline acetyltransferase activity in chick spinal cord cultures. In both the absence and presence of NGF, MCM did not increase neurofilament protein expression in primary cultures of sensory neurons.     

Purified proteins acting on cultured chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons

Chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons in dissociated monolayer culture have been used to examine molecular requirements for neuronal survival and neurite growth. These neurons will rapidly die in vitro unless supplied with an adequate level of ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), and even in the presence of CNTF they will not vigorously extend neurites on polyornithine substrata unless supplied with appropriate amounts of polyornithine-binding neurite-promoting factors (PNPFs). Recent work on the purification and partial characterization of embryonic chick eye CNTF and rat schwannoma PNPF is reviewed, and in vitro responses of ciliary ganglion neurons to other purified proteins such as laminin, fibronectin, insulin, and nerve growth factor are mentioned.     

Nerve growth-promoting activity in the chick embryo: quantitative aspects

Nerve growth-promoting activity in organ extracts from the chick embryo was titrated using ganglia explanted to a collagen gel. Fibre outgrowth responses evoked in ciliary, sympathetic and spinal ganglia were well correlated. At embryonic day 8, 66% of the activity was localized in the yolk sac, 19% to the chorioallantois and the remaining 15% was widespread in the embryo. At day 18, total activity had increased 27-fold, the carcass now accounting for 90%. In parallel, the embryo extracts also promoted survival and neurite extension in dissociated ganglionic neurons seeded at low density in the gel. It is suggested that the observed effects are due to one active substance widely distributed in the embryo and increasing in amount during development. The substance has a molecular weight of over 10,000 and is distinct from nerve growth factor (NGF). A function of it may be to regulate axonal growth and survival of autonomic and sensory neurons.     

Ionic behaviors and neuronal survival in developing ganglia. III. Studies with embryonic chick sympathetic neurons

We have shown in the past that (1) Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) controls the Na⁺,K⁺-pump in its ganglionic neuronal targets and (2) the NGF requirement for pump control is developmentally regulated in the chick embryo dorsal root ganglion. We report here that NGF is fully competent to insure the control of intracellular Na⁺ concentrations (as expression of pump control) in intact chick sympathetic ganglia and enriched suspensions of sympathetic neurons from embryonic day 8 (E8) through 13. At later stages (E13–E18), NGF becomes less and less required for that control as the neurons gain a self-sustained ionic pump competence. In monolayer cultures of enriched sympathetic neurons, an increasing neuronal survival in the absence of NGF occurs. These data demonstrate that the ability of developing sympathetic neurons to survive without NGF increases with the same temporal pattern as does their independence from NGF for ionic pump control, stressing the importance of ionic events for neuronal survival.     

Stage-dependent stimulation of neurite outgrowth exerted by nerve growth factor and chick heart in cultured embryonic ganglia

The ability of embryonic chick heart to elicit neuritic outgrowth in different ganglia was tested to examine (1) whether stimulative activity is possessed by the heart only at specific stages and (2) whether the ability of the ganglionic neurons to respond is limited to certain periods of development. As an assay, ganglia were explanted into thin collagen gels with ventricular tissue placed at a distance of about 1 mm. Neuritic outgrowth was measured after 2 days. Control ganglia and ganglia cultured with added nerve growth factor (NGF) were also scored. Four types of tested ganglia, including the ciliary ganglion, showed a peak in neuritic outgrowth when cultured with heart of embryonic Day 18, at about which age the heart becomes sympathetically innervated in ovo. No age-related size differences that could account for this temporal pattern were found among the heart explants when measuring their protein content. A peak in neuronal susceptibility to heart tissue was evident in the 6-day ciliary ganglion and in the 8-day paravertebral, Remak, and spinal ganglia, roughly coinciding with the onset of fibre outgrowth in ovo. Neurite extension is concluded to have been triggered by a factor spread from the heart explants and being distinct from the mouse type of NGF since anti-NGF did not at any stage block the events and since added NGF at all stages failed to evoke neurite formation in the ciliary ganglia. A testable hypothesis is that this factor regulates the growth of sympathetic and possibly parasympathetic and sensory fibres in the developing chick heart.     

Expression of recombinant human nerve growth factor in Escherichia coli.

Nerve growth factor (NGF) is a neurotrophic factor for basal forebrain cholinergic neurons and may be of benefit in neurodegenerative diseases of humans. A method is described to obtain significant amounts of biologically active recombinant human NGF (rhNGF) in one step. RhNGF was expressed in E. coli and the majority of the protein accumulated in inclusion bodies. It was immunoprecipitated by a serum against mouse NGF. Solubilization of the inclusion bodies was done in 3M guanidine HCl and renaturation was effected by dilution and air oxidation in the presence of 6 microM CuSO4. Recoveries were 10-12 micrograms of rhNGF per ml of bacterial suspension. Its biological activity was tested in a bioassay system employing sympathetic chick embryo ganglia and was inhibited by the monoclonal antibody 27/21 against mouse NGF.