Failure prediction of the total hip prosthesis system

The mechanical failure of the prosthesis-cement-femur system is analyzed by using a two-dimensional finite element model. The strain energy density (SED) criterion is applied to locate potential failure sites in the PMMA and prosthesis stem for five different prosthesis positions.

Medial and lateral failure sites in the proximal regions of the cement are found to be the most sensitive to prosthesis position. According to the SED criterion, these are the weakest regions of the cement. Additional bilateral failure sites are also located at the distal end of the prosthesis, but are less likely to fail. The overall structural integrity of the total hip system is found to be adequate for the ideal case considered herein. In practice, the combination of energy concentration coupled with imperfections such as voids and cracks in the cement are potential sites of failure initiation.

On the basis of clinical evidence on cement and prosthesis stem fracture, local reductions in the cement elastic modulus were introduced into the finite element model in order to model cement defects. The bilateral reduction of modulus by 40% in the cement adjacent to the distal portion of the prosthesis stem can lead to an increase of the strain energy density by 19%.     

Shape optimal design of the stem of a cemented hip prosthesis to minimize stress concentration in the cement layer

An optimal shape of the metal stem of a cemented total hip prosthesis minimizing stress concentration in the cement layer was searched for. A gradient projection method of numerical optimization and a finite element method of stress analysis were employed. A two-dimensional model of the femoral part of a total hip prosthesis was derived equivalent to a simplified three-dimensional axisymmetric model. The result of the stress analysis of the two-dimensional model compared favorably with that of the three-dimensional axisymmetric model. Using this two-dimensional model, an optimal shape of the stem, minimizing stress concentration in the cement layer, was obtained by a gradient projection method and the shape was checked again by the three-dimensional finite element analysis. The resulting optimal shape of the stem profile was in good agreement with conventional ones, except in the proximal region where a significant amount of stress reduction in the cement layer was achieved by tapering the stem to the limit that the stem still could withstand the increased stem stress.     

Three-dimensional finite element analysis of glenoid replacement prostheses: a comparison of keeled and pegged anchorage systems

Glenoid component loosening is the dominant cause of failure in total shoulder arthroplasty. It is presumed that loosening in the glenoid is caused by high stresses in the cement layer. Several anchorage systems have been designed with the aim of reducing the loosening rate, the two major categories being "keeled" fixation and "pegged" fixation. However, no three-dimensional finite element analysis has been performed to quantify the stresses in the cement or to compare the different glenoid prosthesis anchorage systems. The objective of this study was to determine the stresses in the cement layer and surrounding bone for glenoid replacement components. A three-dimensional model of the scapula was generated using CT data for geometry and material property definition. Keeled and pegged designs were inserted into the glenoid, surrounded by a 1-mm layer of bone cement. A 90 deg arm abduction load with a full muscle and joint load was applied, following van der Helm (1994). Deformations of the prosthesis, stresses in the cement, and stresses in the bone were calculated. Stresses were also calculated for a simulated case of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in which bone properties were modified to reflect that condition. A maximum principal stress-based failure model was used to predict what quantity of the cement is at risk of failure at the levels of stress computed. The prediction is that 94 percent (pegged prosthesis) and 68 percent (keeled prosthesis) of the cement has a greater than 95 percent probability of survival in normal bone. In RA bone, however, the situation is reversed where 86 percent (pegged prosthesis) and 99 percent (keeled prosthesis) of the cement has a greater than 95 percent probability of survival. Bone stresses are shown to be not much affected by the prosthesis design, except at the tip of the central peg or keel. It is concluded that a "pegged" anchorage system is superior for normal bone, whereas a "keeled" anchorage system is superior for RA bone.     

3D finite element model of meniscectomy: changes in joint contact behavior

The goal of this study is to quantify changes in knee joint contact behavior following varying degrees of the medial partial meniscectomy. A previously validated 3D finite element model was used to simulate 11 different meniscectomies. The accompanying changes in the contact pressure on the superior surface of the menisci and tibial plateau were quantified as was the axial strain in the menisci and articular cartilage. The percentage of medial meniscus removed was linearly correlated with maximum contact pressure, mean contact pressure, and contact area. The lateral hemi-joint was minimally affected by the simulated medial meniscectomies. The location of maximum strain and location of maximum contact pressure did not change with varying degrees of partial medial meniscectomy. When 60% of the medial meniscus was removed, contact pressures increased 65% on the remaining medial meniscus and 55% on the medial tibial plateau. These data will be helpful for assessing potential complications with the surgical treatment of meniscal tears. Additionally, these data provide insight into the role of mechanical loading in the etiology of post-meniscectomy osteoarthritis.     

The effect of three-dimensional shape optimization on the probabilistic response of a cemented femoral hip prosthesis

Probabilistic analyses allow the effect of uncertainty in system parameters on predicted model performance measures to be determined. Furthermore, using performance functions to describe a failure event, the probability of failure can be quantified. The effect of three-dimensional prosthesis shape optimization on the probabilistic response and failure probability of a cemented hip prosthesis system is investigated. Random variables include joint and muscle loading, cortical and cancellous bone and PMMA bone cement elastic properties, and strength parameters describing failure of the bone cement and the prosthesis-bone cement interface. Several performance functions describing the bone cement and prosthesis-cement interface are used to compute the probability of failure. When evaluated deterministically, most performance functions indicated a safe design, with the exception of interface tensile failure. However, when evaluated probabilistically, finite probabilities of failure were computed, some significant. The most likely mode of failure before shape optimization was prosthesis-bone cement interface tensile failure with a predicted probability of failure of 97.9%. Deterministic prosthesis shape optimization reduced the probability of failure for all performance functions and reduced prosthesis-bone cement interface tensile failure by 31.7%. Probability sensitivity factors indicate that the uncertainty in the joint loading, cement strength, and implant-cement interface strength have the greatest effect on the computed probability of failure. Implant shape optimization results in a more robust implant design that is less sensitive to uncertainties in joint loading, which cannot be easily controlled, and more sensitive to cement and interface properties, which are easier to modify.     

A three-dimensional non-linear finite element study of the effect of cement-prosthesis debonding in cemented femoral total hip components.

A three-dimensional non-linear finite element analysis of a cemented femoral component in which the component was partially debonded from the cement mantle was used to assess the effects of debonding on stresses in the cement. Three cases of partial cement-metal debonding were modelled with debonding of the proximal portion of the implant down to a horizontal plane which was 35, 62.5, or 82.5 mm below the prosthesis collar. Each situation was studied under loads simulating both gait and stairclimbing. Also, complete debonding between the implant and the surrounding cement mantle was modeled for loads simulating gait. Under stair climbing loads with partial cement-mental debonding, hoop stresses of 13-18 MPa were observed in the cement at the cement-metal interface at the proximal postero-medial corner of the implant. Similarly, in stair climbing, the maximum principal stresses in the cement were also adjacent to the proximal postero-medial region of the implant. These stresses were compressive and increased from 15 MPa with fully bonded interfaces to 48 MPa with debonding down to 82.5 mm below the prosthesis collar. Under gait loads, complete debonding caused high compressive stresses up to 34.9 MPa in the cement distal to the prosthesis tip. Thus, cement failure subsequent to prosthesis debonding is likely in the proximal region in a partially debonded implant due to stair climbing loads and is likely below the prosthesis tip in a fully debonded implant due to gait loading.     

Biomechanical evaluation of porous biodegradable scaffolds for revision knee arthroplasty

Tibial bone defect is a critical problem for revision knee arthroplasty. Instead of using metallic spacer or cement, biodegradable scaffolds could be an alternative solution. A numerical model of a revision knee arthroplasty was thus developed to estimate the mechanical resistance of the scaffold in this demanding situation. The tibia, scaffold, and prosthesis were represented by simplified parameterised geometries. The maximal gait cycle force was applied asymmetrically to simulate a critical loading. Several parameters were analysed: 1) inter-individual variability, 2) cortical bone stiffness, 3) cortical bone thickness, 4) prosthesis fixation quality, and 5) scaffold thickness. The calculated scaffold strain was compared to its experimental ultimate strain. Among the tested parameters, failure was only predicted with scaffold thickness below 5 mm. This study suggests that biodegradable bone scaffolds could be used to fill bone defects in revision knee arthroplasty, but scaffold size seems to be the limiting factor.     

Pre-clinical validation of a new partially cemented femoral prosthesis by synergetic use of numerical and experimental methods

The present work reports the pre-clinical validation of an innovative partially cemented femoral prosthesis called cement-locked uncemented (CLU) prosthesis. The inventors of the device under investigation claimed that, when compared to a comparable fully cemented stem, the new stem would present various advantages. Two previous experimental studies confirmed that primary stability and stress shielding were comparable to those of cemented stems. Aim of the present study was to investigate if the remaining claims were confirmed as well. A complete finite element model of the bone-implant complex was created from CT data. The model was validated against in vitro measurements of bone surface strains as well as against primary stability measurements. The peak stresses predicted in the CLU cement mantle were not found significantly lower than those reported in other studies on fully cemented stems. However, once the cement inlet geometry is optimised and the associated stress risers are eliminated, the CLU cement mantle should be subjected to much lower stresses. The stress induced in the stems by both load cases was well below the fatigue limit of the Ti6Al4V alloy. Finite element models predicted for all load cases relative motion between cement and metal lower than 60 microm. This amplitude may be fully accommodated by elastic deformations of the cement micro-ridges. The experimental and numerical results showed the validity of the new fixation concept, although a further optimisation of the geometry of the cement pockets is needed in order to further reduce the stresses in the cement.     

Modelling heat transfer in a bone-cement-prosthesis system

The heat transfer in a general bone-cement-prosthesis system was modelled. A quantitative understanding of the heat transfer and the polymerization kinetics in the system is necessary because injury of the bone tissue and the mechanical properties of the cement have been suggested to be effected by the thermal and chemical history of the system. The mathematical model of the heat transfer was based on first principles from polymerization kinetics and heat transfer, rather than certain in vitro observed properties, which has been the common approach. Our model was valid for general three-dimensional geometries and an arbitrary bone cement consisting of an initiator and monomer. The model was simulated for a cross-section of a hip with a potential femoral stem prosthesis and for a cement similar to Palacos R. The simulations were conducted by using the finite element method. These simulations showed that this general model described an auto accelerating heat production and a residual monomer concentration, which are two phenomena suggested to cause bone tissue damage and effect the mechanical properties of the cement.     

Pelvic stresses in vitro--II. A study of the efficacy of metal-backed acetabular prostheses

Six embalmed human cadaveric hemi-pelves with their associated proximal femurs have been tested in vitro using 25 strain-gauge rosettes on each hemi-pelvis. Loads were applied up to 2.5 kN and principal stresses were computed from the principal strain data. Acetabular prostheses, cemented in place upon a cartilage-devoid but intact subchondral bone-plate, showed little change in stress-patterns when compared with the normal data, regardless of whether or not the component employed metal-backing. The use of 30 anchoring holes of 6.4 mm diameter, in the intact subchondral bone-plate, had little effect upon the stress-patterns, regardless of whether metal-backing was employed upon the prosthesis. When the subchondral bone-plate was removed, there were notable changes in the stress-pattern in the periacetabular region and on the medial wall of pelvis. The metal-backed prosthesis did not produce such notable changes as its plastic counterpart, when the subchondral bone-plate was removed. The use of a plastic prosthesis cemented in a Protrusio ring, in an acetabulum devoid of subchondral bone, produced notable changes in the stress-patterns in the whole periacetabular region and on the medial wall.     

Influence of resin cement rigidity on the stress distribution of resin-bonded fixed partial dentures

The mechanical properties of the adhesive cement used in resin-bonded fixed partial dentures (RBFPD) can modify the clinical performance of the rehabilitation. The goal of this study was to evaluate the influence of the elastic modulus of different cements on the stress distribution in RBFPD using finite element analysis. For that an anterior 3-unit prosthesis was modeled based in a stereolithography file. The model was meshed with tetrahedral elements and materials considered isotropic, linearly elastic and homogeneous. The force applied to the palatal area of the lateral incisor (pontic) at 45° was 100?N. The cements used presented 7 different elastic modulus (E): 2, 6, 10, 14, 18, 22 or 26?GPa. The total deformation, von-Mises stress and maximum principal stress criteria were used to calculate the results. The lower tensile stress occurred in the cement layer with E?=?2?GPa [25.6 (canine) and 16.32?MPa (incisor)]. For the prosthesis, the model with the lower tensile stress [287 (canine) and 248?MPa (incisor)] occurred when the cement presented E?=?26?GPa.

In this way, the stress concentration may have its magnitude modified depending on the stiffness of the cement. Since more flexible cements concentrate less tensile stress in its structure, but allow an increased displacement of the prosthesis, which is friable and rigid and ends up concentrating more tensile stress at its connector. In that way the clinician should avoid the use of adhesive cement with lower elastic modulus due to it increases the stress concentration in the ceramic.     

Contact forces in several TKA designs during squatting: A numerical sensitivity analysis

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is a very successful procedure, but pain or difficulties during activities still persist in patients. Patient outcomes in TKA surgery can be affected by implant design, alignment or patient-related anatomical factors. This paper presents a numerical sensitivity analysis of several TKA types: a fixed bearing, posterior stabilized prosthesis, a high flexion fixed bearing guided motion prosthesis, a mobile bearing prosthesis and a hinge prosthesis. Each prosthesis was virtually implanted on the same cadaver leg model and it underwent a loaded squat, in 10s, between 0° and 120°, similar to several previous experimental tests performed on knee kinematics simulators. The aim of this examination was to investigate the sensitivity of the patello-femoral (PF) and tibio-femoral (TF) contact forces to patient-related anatomical factors, and component position in the different implant types. The following parameters were used for the sensitivity study: the proximo-distal patellar position, the patellar component tilting, the tibial component position and orientation, the locations of the medial and lateral collateral ligaments with respect to femur and tibia and the patellar tendon length. The sensitivity analysis showed that PF contact forces are mostly affected by patella height (increases up to 67% for one TKA type in patella-alta configuration), by an anterior tibial component translation (increases up to 30%), and by patellar component tilting (increases up to 29%); TF contact forces are mostly affected by the anterior displacement of the insertion points of the medial collateral ligament with respect to the reference position (increases up to 48%).     

The determinants of change in tibial plateau bone area in osteoarthritic knees: a cohort study

Bone is integral to the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis (OA). Whether the bone area of the tibial plateau changes over time in subjects with knee OA is unknown. We performed a cohort study to describe this and identify factors that might influence the change. One hundred and twenty-six subjects with knee OA underwent baseline knee radiography and magnetic resonance imaging on their symptomatic knee. They were followed up with a repeatmagnetic resonance image of the same knee approximately 2 years later. The bone area of the tibial plateau was measured at baseline and follow-up. Risk factors assessed at baseline were tested for their association with change in tibial plateau bone area over time. One hundred and seventeen subjects completed the study. The medial and lateral tibial plateau bone areas increased by 2.2 ± 6.9% and 1.5 ± 4.3% per year, respectively. Being male (P = 0.001), having a higher body mass index (P = 0.002), and having a higher baseline grade of medial joint-space narrowing (P = 0.01) were all independently and positively associated with an increased rate of enlargement of bone area of the medial tibial plateau. A larger baseline bone area of the medial tibial plateau was inversely associated with the rate of increase of that area (P < 0.001). No factor examined affected the rate of increase of the bone area of the lateral tibial plateau. In subjects with established knee OA, tibial plateau bone area increases over time. The role of subchondral bone change in the pathogenesis of knee OA will need to be determined but may be one explanation for the mechanism of action of risk factors such as body mass index on knee OA.     

人工髋关节置换术在320例股骨头缺血性坏死中的治疗体会

目的：探讨人工髋关节置换术在治疗股骨头缺血性坏死（ANFH）中的临床疗效。方法：选择2007年2月-2011年2月我院收治的320例（340髋）股骨头缺血性坏死患者,均采用人工髋关节置换术对患者进行治疗,其中160例（172髋）患者应用骨水泥型假体进行治疗,另外160例（168）患者采用非骨水泥型假体进行治疗。采用Harris评分对患者手术前后的髋关节功能情况进行评价,并比较骨水泥治疗组和非骨水泥治疗组的临床疗效。结果：患者均获得随访,随访时间为3～18个月。全部患者手术后的Harris评分明显高于手术前,差异有统计学意义（P〈0．05）。骨水泥治疗组和非骨水泥治疗组在术后出血量、术后Harris评分及住院时间方面的差异无统计学意义（P〉0．05）,但非骨水泥治疗组的并发症发生率明显低于骨水泥治疗组（P〈0．05）。结论：采用人工髋关节置换术治疗ANFH疗效显著,能明显改善患者的生活质量,骨水泥型假体与非骨水泥型假体的治疗效果相当,应根据患者的具体情况进行合理的选择。     

Proximal femoral surface strain gauge analysis of a new epiphyseal prosthesis

This paper describes a new type of proximal femoral, replacement arthroplasty and its preliminary, pre-clinical, evaluation. The prosthesis was designed as a replacement for the femoral capital epiphysis. It comprises a thin, metal, articular shell and an underlying ‘epiphyseal’ replacement which is modulus-matched to adjacent proximal femoral bone. Surface strain gauge analysis of the proximal femur under conditions simulating static single leg stance demonstrated that the new prosthesis maintains an essentially normal femoral strain distribution. It is hoped that selective load transmissions across the prosthesis-bone interface should result in less post-implantation proximal bone resorption.     

人工髋关节置换术在320 例股骨头缺血性坏死中的治疗体会

目的：探讨人工髋关节置换术在治疗股骨头缺血性坏死（ANFH）中的临床疗效。方法：选择2007 年2 月-2011 年2 月我院收 治的320 例（340 髋）股骨头缺血性坏死患者,均采用人工髋关节置换术对患者进行治疗,其中160 例（172 髋）患者应用骨水泥型 假体进行治疗,另外160 例（168）患者采用非骨水泥型假体进行治疗。采用Harris评分对患者手术前后的髋关节功能情况进行评 价,并比较骨水泥治疗组和非骨水泥治疗组的临床疗效。结果：患者均获得随访,随访时间为3～18 个月。全部患者手术后的 Harris评分明显高于手术前,差异有统计学意义（P<0.05）。骨水泥治疗组和非骨水泥治疗组在术后出血量、术后Harris 评分及住 院时间方面的差异无统计学意义（P>0.05）,但非骨水泥治疗组的并发症发生率明显低于骨水泥治疗组（P<0.05）。结论：采用人工 髋关节置换术治疗ANFH疗效显著,能明显改善患者的生活质量,骨水泥型假体与非骨水泥型假体的治疗效果相当,应根据患者 的具体情况进行合理的选择。     

Effect of interface conditions on the behaviour of a Freeman hip endoprosthesis

The femoral element of a total hip replacement is a composite structure of two, or perhaps three, components — the endoprosthesis, the bone and, where present, the cement. The interfacial conditions are such that complete structural continuity does not necessarily obtain. That this is so has often been suspected due to the observed loosening which can occur in vivo. In modelling the system, typically for finite element analysis, it has usually been considered to be monolithic, such that tensile and shear stresses could be transmitted across the interfaces as well as the normal compressive stress. Here the femoral component of a Freeman hip replacement is considered, implanted without bone cement, and analyses are carried out under monolithic, i.e. fully bonded, and non-bonded assumptions. Simultaneously the effect of retaining the neck of the femur, one of the features of using this particular prosthesis, is also examined.     

Stress analysis of the proximo-medial femur after total hip replacement

Stress-induced bone loss in the proximo-medial femur has been identified as a factor leading to loosening in the artificial hip joint. In an effort to develop a quantitative understanding of the stress distribution that causes bone loss, axial and hoop stresses in the medial calcar of the femur have been determined after total hip replacement, using finite element stress analysis. Stress distributions for a high and a low Young's modulus prosthesis material are compared for both collared and uncollared prosthesis designs. The use of a low-modulus material, and of a collar, are predicted to be advantageous, giving rise to proximo-medial stress patterns similar to those of the normal, intact femur.     

Detecting condylar contact loss using single-plane fluoroscopy: A comparison with in vivo force data and in vitro bi-plane data

Knee contact mechanics play an important role in knee implant failure and wear mechanics. Femoral condylar contact loss in total knee arthroplasty has been reported in some studies and it is considered to potentially induce excessive wear of the polyethylene insert.Measuring in vivo forces applied to the tibial plateau with an instrumented prosthesis is a possible approach to assess contact loss in vivo, but this approach is not very practical. Alternatively, single-plane fluoroscopy and pose estimation can be used to derive the relative pose of the femoral component with respect to the tibial plateau and estimate the distance from the medial and lateral parts of the femoral component towards the insert. Two measures are reported in the literature: lift-off is commonly defined as the difference in distance between the medial and lateral condyles of the femoral component with respect to the tibial plateau; separation is determined by the closest distance of each condyle towards the polyethylene insert instead of the tibia plateau.In this validation study, lift-off and separation as measured with single-plane fluoroscopy are compared to in vivo contact forces measured with an instrumented knee implant. In a phantom study, lift-off and separation were compared to measurements with a high quality bi-plane measurement.The results of the in vivo contact-force experiment demonstrate a large discrepancy between single-plane fluoroscopy and the in vivo force data: single-plane fluoroscopy measured up to 5.1 mm of lift-off or separation, whereas the force data never showed actual loss of contact. The phantom study demonstrated that the single-plane setup could introduce an overestimation of 0.22 mm±±0.36 mm. Correcting the out-of-plane position resulted in an underestimation of medial separation by −0.20 mm±±0.29 mm.In conclusion, there is a discrepancy between the in vivo force data and single-plane fluoroscopic measurements. Therefore contact loss may not always be determined reliably by single plane fluoroscopy analysis.     

Stress analysis and failure prediction in the proximal femur before and after total hip replacement

An investigation was performed to determine the effects of the presence of two lengths of proximal Müller prosthesis on predicted failure loads, as compared to those for an intact femur. Three-dimensional stresses in a bone/cement/prosthesis system were determined using finite element methods, with both isotropic and transversely isotropic material properties used for the diaphyseal cortex. Significant increases in prosthesis stem stresses were found when the transversely isotropic material properties were employed in the diaphyseal cortex. This leads to the conclusion that accurate anisotropic material properties for bone are essential for precise stress determination and optimum design in prosthetic implants. Failure loads were also predicted for vertical compression and axial torque, similar to available experimental conditions, and were within the range of the experimental failure data found in the literature. The technique developed herein can be used to systematically assess existing as well as future implant designs, taking into account the complex three-dimensional interaction effects of the overall bone/cement/prosthesis system.