The DNA cleavage reaction of topoisomerase II: wolf in sheep's clothing

Topoisomerase II is an essential enzyme that is required for virtually every process that requires movement of DNA within the nucleus or the opening of the double helix. This enzyme helps to regulate DNA under- and overwinding and removes knots and tangles from the genetic material. In order to carry out its critical physiological functions, topoisomerase II generates transient double-stranded breaks in DNA. Consequently, while necessary for cell survival, the enzyme also has the capacity to fragment the genome. The DNA cleavage/ligation reaction of topoisomerase II is the target for some of the most successful anticancer drugs currently in clinical use. However, this same reaction also is believed to trigger chromosomal translocations that are associated with specific types of leukemia. This article will familiarize the reader with the DNA cleavage/ligation reaction of topoisomerase II and other aspects of its catalytic cycle. In addition, it will discuss the interaction of the enzyme with anticancer drugs and the mechanisms by which these agents increase levels of topoisomerase II-generated DNA strand breaks. Finally, it will describe dietary and environmental agents that enhance DNA cleavage mediated by the enzyme.     

DNA abasic lesions in a different light: solution structure of an endogenous topoisomerase II poison

Topoisomerase II is the target for several anticancer drugs that "poison" the enzyme and convert it to a cellular toxin by increasing topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage. In addition to these "exogenous topoisomerase II poisons," DNA lesions such as abasic sites act as "endogenous poisons" of the enzyme. Drugs and lesions are believed to stimulate DNA scission by altering the structure of the double helix within the cleavage site of the enzyme. However, the structural alterations that enhance cleavage are unknown. Since abasic sites are an intrinsic part of the genetic material, they represent an attractive model to assess DNA distortions that lead to altered topoisomerase II function. Therefore, the structure of a double-stranded dodecamer containing a tetrahydrofuran apurinic lesion at the +2 position of a topoisomerase II DNA cleavage site was determined by NMR spectroscopy. Three major features distinguished the apurinic structure ( = 0.095) from that of wild-type ( = 0.077). First, loss of base stacking at the lesion collapsed the major groove and reduced the distance between the two scissile phosphodiester bonds. Second, the apurinic lesion induced a bend that was centered about the topoisomerase II cleavage site. Third, the base immediately opposite the lesion was extrahelical and relocated to the minor groove. All of these structural alterations have the potential to influence interactions between topoisomerase II and its DNA substrate.     

Self-association and DNA binding properties of the human topoisomerase IIA alpha2HTH module

The eukaryotic topoisomerase II is an ubiquitous nuclear enzyme involved in vital cellular functions. It is also the target for some of the most active anticancer drugs. In the various crystal structures of yeast topoisomerase II, the 701-748 segment homologous to the human topoisomerase II alpha 724-771 segment folds into a compact alpha(2)beta(1)alpha(3)talpha(4) conformation, hereafter termed alpha(2)HTH module (helix turn helix (HTH), alpha(3)talpha(4)). The crystal structure of gyrase A has suggested a model wherein HTH is involved in both the enzyme dimerization and the binding to DNA. These two properties were investigated in solution, using the recombinant alpha(2)HTH module of human topoisomerase II alpha and its synthetic components HTH, alpha(4), alpha(3) and turn. The homology-based structure model of human alpha(2)HTH superposed that of yeast in the crystal structure with a rmsd of 1.03 A. Circular dichroism spectra showed that the helical content of human alpha(2)HTH in solution is similar to that of its counterpart within yeast topoisomerase II in the solid state. The chemical cross-linking data indicated that alpha(2)HTH self-associated into dimers while gel mobility shift assays and anisotropy fluorescence titrations demonstrated that alpha(2)HTH, HTH and alpha(4), but not alpha(3), bind efficiently to DNA (dissociation constants of 3.10(-7) M for alpha(2)HTH and alpha(4), of 3.10(-6) M for HTH and of only 1.10(-5) M for alpha(3)). Correlatively, alpha(2)HTH, alpha(4) and HTH, but not alpha(3), were able to inhibit topoisomerase II in DNA relaxation assays, stipulating that alpha(4) is the DNA recognition helix. All suggests that the alpha(2)HTH module once separated from the whole protein conserves a compact conformation, integral to specific dimerization and DNA recognition. The module may thus be used for the search of drugs efficient in hindering topoisomerase II dimerization or binding to DNA.     

A role for the passage helix in the DNA cleavage reaction of eukaryotic topoisomerase II. A two-site model for enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage.

Eukaryotic topoisomerase II is capable of binding two separate nucleic acid helices prior to its DNA cleavage and strand passage events (Zechiedrich, E. L., and Osheroff, N (1990) EMBO J. 9, 4555-4562). Presumably, one of these helices represents the helix that the enzyme cleaves (i.e. cleavage helix), and the other represents the helix that it passes (i.e. passage helix) through the break in the nucleic acid backbone. To determine whether the passage helix is required for reaction steps that precede the enzyme's DNA strand passage event, interactions between Drosophila melanogaster topoisomerase II and a short double-stranded oligonucleotide were assessed. These studies employed a 40-mer that contained a specific recognition/cleavage site for the enzyme. The sigmoidal DNA concentration dependence that was observed for cleavage of the 40-mer indicated that topoisomerase II had to interact with more than a single oligonucleotide in order for cleavage to take place. Despite this requirement, results of enzyme DNA binding experiments indicated no binding cooperativity for the 40-mer. These findings strongly suggest a two-site model for topoisomerase II action in which the passage and the cleavage helices bind to the enzyme independently, but the passage helix must be present for efficient topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage to occur.     

Human topoisomerase IIalpha rapidly relaxes positively supercoiled DNA: implications for enzyme action ahead of replication forks

Movement of the DNA replication machinery through the double helix induces acute positive supercoiling ahead of the fork and precatenanes behind it. Because topoisomerase I and II create transient single- and double-stranded DNA breaks, respectively, it has been assumed that type I enzymes relax the positive supercoils that precede the replication fork. Conversely, type II enzymes primarily resolve the precatenanes and untangle catenated daughter chromosomes. However, studies on yeast and bacteria suggest that type II topoisomerases may also function ahead of the replication machinery. If this is the case, then positive DNA supercoils should be the preferred relaxation substrate for topoisomerase IIalpha, the enzyme isoform involved in replicative processes in humans. Results indicate that human topoisomerase IIalpha relaxes positively supercoiled plasmids >10-fold faster than negatively supercoiled molecules. In contrast, topoisomerase IIbeta, which is not required for DNA replication, displays no such preference. In addition to its high rates of relaxation, topoisomerase IIalpha maintains lower levels of DNA cleavage complexes with positively supercoiled molecules. These properties suggest that human topoisomerase IIalpha has the potential to alleviate torsional stress ahead of replication forks in an efficient and safe manner.     

Exocyclic DNA lesions stimulate DNA cleavage mediated by human topoisomerase II alpha in vitro and in cultured cells

DNA adducts are mutagenic and clastogenic. Because of their harmful nature, lesions are recognized by many proteins involved in DNA repair. However, mounting evidence suggests that lesions also are recognized by proteins with no obvious role in repair processes. One such protein is topoisomerase II, an essential enzyme that removes knots and tangles from the DNA. Because topoisomerase II generates a protein-linked double-stranded DNA break during its catalytic cycle, it has the potential to fragment the genome. Previous studies indicate that abasic sites and other lesions that distort the double helix stimulate topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage. Therefore, to further explore interactions between DNA lesions and the enzyme, the effects of exocyclic adducts on DNA cleavage mediated by human topoisomerase IIalpha were determined. When located within the four-base overhang of a topoisomerase II cleavage site (at the +2 or +3 position 3' relative to the scissile bond), 3,N(4)-ethenodeoxycytidine, 3,N(4)-etheno-2'-ribocytidine, 1,N(2)-ethenodeoxyguanosine, pyrimido[1,2-a]purin-10(3H)-one deoxyribose (M(1)dG), and 1,N(2)-propanodeoxyguanosine increased DNA scission approximately 5-17-fold. Enhanced cleavage did not result from an increased affinity of topoisomerase IIalpha for adducted DNA or a decreased rate of religation. Therefore, it is concluded that these exocyclic lesions act by accelerating the forward rate of enzyme-mediated DNA scission. Finally, treatment of cultured human cells with 2-chloroacetaldehyde, a reactive metabolite of vinyl chloride that generates etheno adducts, increased cellular levels of DNA cleavage by topoisomerase IIalpha. This finding suggests that type II topoisomerases interact with exocyclic DNA lesions in physiological systems.     

Topoisomerase II from Chlorella virus PBCV-1 has an exceptionally high DNA cleavage activity

Chlorella virus PBCV-1 topoisomerase II is the only functional type II enzyme known to be encoded by a virus that infects eukaryotic cells. However, it has not been established whether the protein is expressed following viral infection or whether the enzyme has any catalytic features that distinguish it from cellular type II topoisomerases. Therefore, the present study characterized the physiological expression of PBCV-1 topoisomerase II and individual reaction steps catalyzed by the enzyme. Results indicate that the topoisomerase II gene is widely distributed among Chlorella viruses and that the protein is expressed 60-90 min after viral infection of algal cells. Furthermore, the enzyme has an extremely high DNA cleavage activity that sets it apart from all known eukaryotic type II topoisomerases. Levels of DNA scission generated by the viral enzyme are approximately 30 times greater than those observed with human topoisomerase IIalpha. The high levels of cleavage are not due to inordinately tight enzyme-DNA binding or to impaired DNA religation. Thus, they most likely reflect an elevated forward rate of scission. The robust DNA cleavage activity of PBCV-1 topoisomerase II provides a unique tool for studying the catalytic functions of type II topoisomerases.     

Topoisomerase II in multiple drug resistance

Topoisomerase II is a target of alkaloid, anthracycline and related antitumor agents. Two types of multiple drug resistance are associated with these enzymes. In classical (typical) multidrug resistance, inhibitors are actively effluxed from cells by P-glycoprotein. In atypical multidrug resistance, topoisomerase II is either reduced in cellular content or mutated to a form that does not interact with inhibitors. Because cytotoxicity of most antineoplastic topoisomerase II inhibitors is directly related to the number of active topoisomerase II molecules, a reduction in this number leads to resistance. In the topoisomerase II mechanism, through which the DNA linking number is altered, DNA double strands are cleaved, and the termini transiently bound covalently (5) or noncovalently (3) to the enzyme while a second double strand is passed through the break in the first. This transition state complex then decays to enzyme and DNA of altered linking number. Most cytotoxic topoisomerase II inhibitors stabilize these reaction intermediates as ternary complexes, which are converted to lethal lesions when cells attempt to utilize the damaged DNA as templates. Toxicity is related to topoisomerase II content as well as to drug concentration. Thus, multidrug resistance results from either 1) decreasing cellular content of the inhibitor by P-glycoprotein (typical) or 2) decreasing cellular content and/or activity of the target, topoisomerase II, as, for example, when its content or activity is modulated downward by decreased expression, deactivation, or by mutations to the TopII gene, producing an enzyme that reacts poorly with inhibitors (atypical). Mixed types,i.e., both typical and atypical, are known. Attempts to abrogate or prevent both typical and atypical multidrug resistance to topoisomerase II inhibitors have been described.Abbreviations atMDR atypical multidrug resistance - kDa kilodaltons - MDR multidrug resistance - Pgp P-glycoprotein - TOPO II topoisomerase II     

Topoisomerase II antagonism and anticancer activity of coordinated derivatives of [RuCl(2)(C(6)H(6))(dmso)

Topoisomerase II poisoning and anticancer activity by the organometallic compound [RuCl(2)(C(6)H(6))(dmso)] was shown by us in an earlier study [Biochemistry 38 (1999) 4382]. Since high concentrations of this complex were required to achieve either effects, we have synthesized four derivatives of this complex in which the dimethyl sulphoxide group on the ruthenium atom was replaced with pyridine, 3-aminopyridine, p-aminobenzoic acid, and aminoguanidine. Three of these molecules showed enhanced potency of topoisomerase II poisoning and consequently also showed higher anticancer activity in breast and colon carcinoma cells in vitro. Detailed analysis of the molecular action of these compounds on topoisomerase II activity was carried out using the classical relaxation and cleavage activity of the enzyme, which revealed that the compounds poison topoisomerase II by freezing the enzyme and enzyme-cleaved DNA in a ternary "cleavage complex". The cleavage complex is implicated in the anti-neoplastic activity of these compounds. DNA interaction studies showed that these compounds interact with DNA in much the same way as [RuCl(2)(C(6)H(6))(dmso)], by external binding of the DNA helix. This is unlike most other topoisomerase II poisons, which predominantly interact with DNA through intercalation with the double helix.     

Dissecting the cell-killing mechanism of the topoisomerase II-targeting drug ICRF-193

Topoisomerase II is an essential enzyme that is targeted by a number of clinically valuable anticancer drugs. One class referred to as topoisomerase II poisons works by increasing the cellular level of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA breaks, resulting in apoptosis. Another class of topoisomerase II-directed drugs, the bis-dioxopiperazines, stabilizes the conformation of the enzyme where it attains an inactive salt-stable closed clamp structure. Bis-dioxopiperazines, similar to topoisomerase II poisons, induce cell killing, but the underlying mechanism is presently unclear. In this study, we use three different biochemically well characterized human topoisomerase IIalpha mutant enzymes to dissect the catalytic requirements needed for the enzyme to cause dominant sensitivity in yeast to the bis-dioxopirazine ICRF-193 and the topoisomerase II poison m-AMSA. We find that the clamp-closing activity, the DNA cleavage activity, and even both activities together are insufficient for topoisomerase II to cause dominant sensitivity to ICRF-193 in yeast. Rather, the strand passage event per se is an absolute requirement, most probably because this involves a simultaneous interaction of the enzyme with two DNA segments. Furthermore, we show that the ability of human topoisomerase IIalpha to cause dominant sensitivity to m-AMSA in yeast does not depend on clamp closure or strand passage but is directly related to the capability of the enzyme to respond to m-AMSA with increased DNA cleavage complex formation.     

Human topoisomerase IIalpha possesses an intrinsic nucleic acid specificity for DNA ligation. Use of 5' covalently activated oligonucleotide substrates to study enzyme mechanism

Despite the importance of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA ligation to the essential physiological functions of the enzyme, the mechanistic details of this important reaction are poorly understood. Because topoisomerase II normally does not release cleaved DNA molecules prior to ligation, it is not known whether all of the nucleic acid specificity of its cleavage/ligation cycle is embodied in DNA cleavage or whether ligation also contributes specificity to the enzyme. All currently available ligation assays require that topoisomerase II cleave the initial DNA substrate before rejoining can be monitored. Consequently, it has been impossible to examine the specificity of DNA ligation separately from that of scission. To address this issue, a cleavage-independent topoisomerase II DNA ligation assay was developed. This assay utilizes a nicked oligonucleotide whose 5'-phosphate terminus at the nick has been activated by covalent attachment to the tyrosine mimic, p-nitrophenol. Human topoisomerase IIalpha and enzymes with active-site mutations that abrogated cleavage activity ligated the activated nick by catalyzing the direct attack of the terminal 3'-OH on the activated 5'-phosphate. Results with different DNA sequences indicate that human topoisomerase IIalpha possesses an intrinsic nucleic acid specificity for ligation that parallels its specificity for DNA cleavage.     

Base mutation analysis of topoisomerase II-idarubicin-DNA ternary complex formation. Evidence for enzyme subunit cooperativity in DNA cleavage.

Antitumor drugs, such as anthracyclines, interfere with mammalian DNA topoisomerase II by forming a ternary complex, DNA-drug-enzyme, in which DNA strands are cleaved and covalently linked to the enzyme. In this work, a synthetic 36-bp DNA oligomer derived from SV40 and mutated variants were used to determine the effects of base mutations on DNA cleavage levels produced by murine topoisomerase II with and without idarubicin. Although site competition could affect cleavage levels, mutation effects were rather similar among several cleavage sites. The major sequence determinants of topoisomerase II DNA cleavage without drugs are up to five base pairs apart from the strand cut, suggesting that DNA protein contacts involving these bases are particularly critical for DNA site recognition. Cleavage sites with adenines at positions -1 were detected without idarubicin only under conditions favouring enzyme binding to DNA, showing that these sites are low affinity sites for topoisomerase II DNA cleavage and/or binding. Moreover, the results indicated that the sequence 5'-(A)TA/(A)-3' (the slash indicates the cleaved bond, parenthesis indicate conditioned preference) from -3 to +1 positions constitutes the complete base sequence preferred by anthracyclines. An important finding was that mutations that improve the fit to the above consensus on one strand can also increase cleavage on the opposite strand, suggesting that a drug molecule may effectively interact with one enzyme subunit only and trap the whole dimeric enzyme. These findings documented that DNA recognition by topoisomerase II may occur at one or the other strand, and not necessarily at both of them, and that the two subunits can act cooperatively to cleave a double helix.     

Yeast recombination pathways triggered by topoisomerase II-mediated DNA breaks

Topoisomerase II is a ubiquitous enzyme that removes knots and tangles from the genetic material by generating transient double-strand DNA breaks. While the enzyme cannot perform its essential cellular functions without cleaving DNA, this scission activity is inherently dangerous to chromosomal integrity. In fact, etoposide and other clinically important anticancer drugs kill cells by increasing levels of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA breaks. Cells rely heavily on recombination to repair double-strand DNA breaks, but the specific pathways used to repair topoisomerase II-generated DNA damage have not been defined. Therefore, Saccharomyces cerevisiae was used as a model system to delineate the recombination pathways that repair DNA breaks generated by topoisomerase II. Yeast cells that expressed wild-type or a drug-hypersensitive mutant topoisomerase II or overexpressed the wild-type enzyme were examined. Based on cytotoxicity and recombination induced by etoposide in different repair-deficient genetic backgrounds, double-strand DNA breaks generated by topoisomerase II appear to be repaired primarily by the single-strand invasion pathway of homologous recombination. Non-homologous end joining also was triggered by etoposide treatment, but this pathway was considerably less active than single-strand invasion and did not contribute significantly to cell survival in S.cerevisiae.     

Flexibility at Gly-194 is required for DNA cleavage and relaxation activity of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

The proposed mechanism of type IA DNA topoisomerase I includes conformational changes by the single enzyme polypeptide to allow binding of the G strand of the DNA substrate at the active site, and the opening or closing of the "gate" created on the G strand of DNA to the passing single or double DNA strand(s) through the cleaved G strand DNA. The shifting of an alpha helix upon G strand DNA binding has been observed from the comparison of the type IA DNA topoisomerase crystal structures. Site-directed mutagenesis of the strictly conserved Gly-194 at the N terminus of this alpha helix in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I showed that flexibility around this glycine residue is required for DNA cleavage and relaxation activity and supports a functional role for this hinge region in the enzyme conformational change.     

Cadmium is a catalytic inhibitor of DNA topoisomerase II

Cadmium (Cd²⁺) is a highly toxic and carcinogenic metal that is an environmental and occupational hazard. DNA topoisomerase II is an essential nuclear enzyme and its inhibition can result in the formation of genotoxic and recombinogenic DNA double strand breaks. In this study we showed that cadmium chloride strongly inhibited the DNA decatenation activity of human topoisomerase IIα in the low micromolar concentration range and that its inhibitory effects were reduced by glutathione. Because the activity of topoisomerase II is strongly inhibited by thiol-reactive compounds this result suggested that cadmium may be binding to critical topoisomerase II cysteine thiols. Cadmium, however, did not stabilize DNA-topoisomerase II covalent complexes, as measured by the lack of formation of DNA double strand breaks. Hence, it is not likely to be a topoisomerase II poison. Consistent with the idea that cadmium cytotoxicity may be modulated by glutathione levels, buthionine sulfoximine pretreatment to decrease glutathione levels resulted in a greatly increased cadmium-induced cytotoxicity in K562 cells. The results of this study suggest that cadmium may exert some of its cell growth inhibitory, and possibly its toxicity and carcinogenicity, by inhibiting topoisomerase IIα through reaction with critical cysteine thiols.     

Structural basis for specificity in the poxvirus topoisomerase

Although smallpox has been eradicated from the human population, it is presently feared as a possible agent of bioterrorism. The smallpox virus codes for its own topoisomerase enzyme that differs from its cellular counterpart by requiring a specific DNA sequence for activation of catalysis. Here we present crystal structures of the smallpox virus topoisomerase enzyme bound both covalently and noncovalently to a specific DNA sequence. These structures reveal the basis for site-specific DNA recognition, and they explain how catalysis is likely activated by formation of a specific enzyme-DNA interface. Unexpectedly, the poxvirus enzyme uses a major groove binding alpha helix that is not present in the human enzyme to recognize part of the core recognition sequence and activate the enzyme for catalysis. The topoisomerase-DNA complex structures also provide a three-dimensional framework that may facilitate the rational design of therapeutic agents to treat poxvirus infections.     

Stimulated activity of human topoisomerases IIalpha and IIbeta on RNA-containing substrates.

Eukaryotic topoisomerase II is a dimeric nuclear enzyme essential for DNA metabolism and chromosome dynamics. Central to the activities of the enzyme is its ability to introduce transient double-stranded breaks in the DNA helix, where the two subunits of the enzyme become covalently attached to the generated 5'-ends through phosphotyrosine linkages. Here, we demonstrate that human topoisomerases IIalpha and IIbeta are able to cleave ribonucleotide-containing substrates. With suicide substrates, which are partially double-stranded molecules containing a 5'-recessed strand, cleavage of both strands was stimulated approximately 8-fold when a ribonucleotide rather than a deoxyribonucleotide was present at the scissile phosphodiester of the recessed strand. The existence of a ribonucleotide at the same position in a normal duplex substrate also enhanced topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage, although to a lesser extent. The enzyme covalently linked to the 5'-ribonucleotide in the cleavage complex efficiently performed ligation, and ligation occurred equally well to acceptor molecules terminated by either a 3'-ribo- or deoxyribonucleotide. Besides the enhanced topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage of ribonucleotide-containing substrates, cleavage of such substrates could be further stimulated by ATP or antitumor drugs. In conclusion, the observed in vitro activities of the human topoisomerase II isoforms indicate that the enzymes can operate on RNA or RNA-containing substrates and thus might possess an intrinsic RNA topoisomerase activity, as has previously been demonstrated for Escherichia coli topoisomerase III.     

Role of the divalent cation in topoisomerase II mediated reactions

The effects of magnesium ions on interactions between Drosophila melanogaster topoisomerase II and its substrates were assessed by a number of kinetic and binding assays. Results indicated that the divalent cation plays two distinct functions in promoting enzyme-substrate interactions. One class of magnesium ions participates directly in enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage reactions. A second class of magnesium ions participates directly in topoisomerase II mediated ATPase reactions and functions by providing the enzyme with a magnesium-ATP substrate. In contrast, the divalent cation did not affect the quaternary structure of the enzyme, was not required for the site-specific binding of topoisomerase II to DNA, and did not affect the enzyme's ability to discern the topological state of its nucleic acid substrate.