Interactions between root and shoot competition vary among species

Understanding how the competition varies with productivity is essential for differentiating among alternative models of plant community organization. Prior attempts to explain shifts in root and shoot competition along gradients have generally assumed an additive interaction between the two competitive forms, using an experimental design which does not fully separate both above‐ and belowground processes. At the most basic level, few field studies have separated root and shoot competition, and we have limited knowledge about both the relative importance of these processes, and how they interact to affect plant growth in the field. Presented here are findings from a field study in which root and shoot competition were experimentally separated by using root exclusion tubes and neighbor tiebacks in an early successional community. Individuals of four species (Abutilon theophrasti, Amaranthus retroflexus, Rumex crispus, and Plantago lanceolata) were grown at two levels of fertilization with full competition, aboveground competition only, belowground competition only, or neither above‐ nor belowground competition. Competition was measured as competitive response, which is the natural log of the relative biomass of a target plant grown with competition compared to growth without competition. In contrast to predictions from current models of productivity‐competition relationships, but in agreement with other experimental studies, there was no change in the strengths or root, shoot, or total competition with a modest increase in productivity. Despite no effect of fertilization on the strength of competition, the form of interaction between root and shoot competition varied both as a function of species identity and fertilization. For both of the rosette forming species, the combined effects of root and shoot competition were less than predicted assuming no interaction (a “negative interaction”), with one species switching from a negative to an additive interaction with fertilization. The fact that fertilization caused a shift in the root‐shoot interaction, but not in the total strength of root and shoot competition, suggests that the root‐shoot interaction is itself a highly labile variable. If root‐shoot interactions are common in natural systems, then simply measuring the strength of one form of competition in no way provides any information about the overall importance of that competitive form to plant growth.     

Partitioning of carbon and nitrogen and the nutrition of root and shoot apex in a nodulated legume

Empirically based models depicting exchanges of C, N, and H₂O in phloem and xylem among organs of nodulated white lupin (Lupinus albus cv Ultra) were constructed for the interval 51 to 58 days after sowing. Information was incorporated on the economy of C, N, and H₂O in plant parts, the solute composition of transport fluids collected at selected sites on the plant, and the photosynthetic inputs, transpirational losses, and translocatory activities of different age groups of leaflets and stem + petiole segments of the shoot. Partitioning of C and N showed preferential transfer of N to the shoot apex, which imported 13 milligrams C per milligram N, compared with 54 milligrams C per milligram N for the nodulated root. Leaves translocated assimilates at a C:N weight ratio of 43 to 59, and older leaves serving the roots produced the translocate most rich in N relative to C. The shoot apex was enriched with N, additional to its intake from leaves, by direct uptake of xylem fluid (C:N ratio, 2.4) and receipt of nitrogenous solutes transferred from xylem to upward-moving phloem streams in upper regions of the stem. The models for flow of N and H₂O indicated that xylem streams passing to leaves were substantially less rich in N than the adjacent stream moving through the body of the stem and that a progressive increase in concentration of N occurred within stem xylem elements from base to top of the shoot. This apparently resulted from an abstraction of N from xylem of departing leaf traces, possibly by xylem transfer cells, and a subsequent feedback of this N to xylem streams passing on up the shoot. Upper leaves and shoot apex, therefore, acquired more N from xylem per unit of H₂O transpired than lower parts of the shoot.     

Efficient shoot and root formation from cotton shoot apices

Successful shoot and root induction were obtained from shoot apices of two cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) genotypes, Nazilli 84S and Çukurova 1518, which are widely planted in Turkey. Plant tissue culture systems were established on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with various plant growth regulators using seven-day-old shoot apices as explants. The shoot apex size was of 2–3 mm; it contained the meristem and unexpanded leaves. Shoot apices were placed on MS plus vitamins and combinations of various plant hormones. The best regeneration responses were obtained for cv. Nazilli 84S (98%) on MS + 0.1 mg/l kinetin (KIN) + 1 g/l polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) and for Çukurova 1518 (94%) on MS + 0.1 mg/l KIN + 2 mg/l NAA + 1 g/l PVP. Including germination, all regeneration and rooting processes lasted only 5 weeks. The shoot apices of both genotypes developed successfully without intervening callus formation, and no significant differences between cultivars were found. All regenerated plants of both genotypes were phenotypically normal and set seeds. This shoot meristem-based rapid regeneration method can also be used in the cases of biolistic and Agrobacterium-mediated transformation.     

Nearest-neighbour analysis and the prevelance of woody plant competition in South African savannas

Inter- and intra-specific competition has long been regarded as asignificant determinant of the structure and function of woody plantcommunitiesin African savannas. The most widely used approach to detect the presence orabsence of competition has been the use of nearest-neighbour methods. Althoughseveral studies have been published reporting the presence of competition inAcacia dominated communities, less than 20 plots have beensampled across all these studies. Results from broad-leaved communities arevariable, and also based on a small sample number. Consequently, this studysought to assess the prevalence of competition from a large number of savannasites (45), and to identify abiotic and biotic factors characterising siteswithcompetition relative to those without. Using the nearest-neighbour method onlyfour sites (9.3%) indicated the presence of inter-specific competition; twowereAcacia dominated communities (18.2% ofAcacia sites) and two were broad-leaved communities(7.7%).These four sites had a significantly higher mean annual rainfall and fewerwoodyspecies than sites without inter-specific competition. There were alsosignificant relationships between the inter-specific competition index and thedominance index and the number of species at a site. In terms of intra-specificcompetition only ten of the 31 sites tested revealed a significant correlationbetween nearest-neighbour distance and summed canopy volume of the twoneighbours. Seven were for Acacia species (55.6% of theAcacia species comparisons) and three were forbroad-leavedspecies (21.4% of the broad-leaved species comparisons). Sites lacking evidenceof intra-specific competition were at a significantly lower slope position andhad a smaller proportion of small stems. The lower prevalence of competition inSouth African savannas detected in this study using the same method as previousstudies is discussed, and the appropriateness of nearest-neighbour analysis isexamined.     

Partitioning of shoot and root dry matter and carbohydrates in bean plants suffering from phosphorus, potassium and magnesium deficiency

The influence of varied supply of phosphorus (10 and 250 mmolP m^–3) potassium (50 and 2010 mmol K m^–3) and magnesium(20 and 1000 mmol Mg m^–3) on the partitioning of dry matterand carbohydrates (reducing sugars, sucrose and starch) betweenshoots and roots was studied in bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) plantsgrown in nutrient solution over a 12 d period. Shoot and rootgrowth were quite differently affected by low supply of P, K,and Mg. The shoot/root dry weight ratios were 4.9 in the control(sufficient plants), 1.8 in P-deficient, 6.9 in K-deficientand 10.2 in Mg-deficient plants. In primary (source) leaves,but not in trifoliate leaves, concentrations of reducing sugars,sucrose and starch were also differently affected by low nutrientsupply. In primary leaves under K deficiency and, particularlyMg deficiency, the concentrations of sucrose and reducing sugarswere much higher than in control and P-deficient plants. Magnesiumdeficiency also distinctly increased the starch concentrationin the primary leaves. In contrast, in roots, the lowest concenfrationsof sucrose, reducing sugars and starch were found in Mg-deficientplants, whereas the concentrations of sucrose and starch wereparticularly high in P-deficient plants. There was a close relationshipbetween shoot/root dry weight ratios and relative distributionof total carbohydrates (sugars and starch) in shoot and roots.Of the total amounts of carbohyd rates per plant, the followingproportions were parti tioned to the roots: 22.7% in P-deficient,15.7% in control, 3.4% in K-deficient and 0.8% in Mg-deficientplants. The results indicate a distinct role of Mg and K in the exportof photosynthates from leaves to roots and suggest that alterationin photosynthate partitioning plays a major role in the differencesin dry matter distribution between shoots and roots of plantssuffering from mineral nutrient deficiency. Key words: Bean, carbohydrates, magnesium nutrition, phosphorus nutrition, potassium nutrition, shoot/root growth     

Induction of root and shoot formation from root meristems ofPetunia hybrida

Summary A procedure has been developed for the induction of root or shoot formation from root meristems of germinated seeds ofPetunia hybrida. Root formation was obtained on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with a combination of 6-benzylaminopurine (BA) (0–0.5 mg/l) and naphtaleneacetic acid (NAA) (0.05–2.0 mg/l). Induction of predominantly shoot formation was obtained on MS medium containing the following combinations of hormones (in mg/l): 0.05–0.5 NAA and 0.25–2.0 BA. Complete plant formation was obtained after rooting of the shoots on MS medium supplemented with IAA (0–2.0 mg/l) or NAA (0-0.5 mg/l).     

Spatial pattern analysis and competition between Acacia karroo trees in humid savannas

It is unclear whether inter-tree competition plays a role in determining the woody plant cover of humid savannas. Spatial point-pattern analysis can give insights to the underlying processes affecting the individuals in a population. We assessed the spatial patterns of Acacia karroo trees from savannas in KwaZulu-Natal, using conventional nearest neighbour analysis and second-order spatial statistics such as Ripley??s K- and L-functions, and the univariate and bivariate O-ring statistics. We predicted that juvenile trees would be spatially aggregated, because of facilitation between shrubs when zones of overlap are relatively small, while adult trees would be regularly spaced because of the effects of density-dependent mortality (i.e. consistent with the honeycomb rippling model). We found that juvenile trees were more aggregated than expected by chance, and the overall spatial distribution of all trees was also found to be aggregated, with no evidence of regularity among large individuals. Nearest neighbour analysis, however, revealed significant positive correlations between the sum of the distances to the four nearest neighbours and the sum of the canopy diameters of the target tree and its four nearest neighbours, indicating the presence of competition. In sum, these findings suggest that competitive interactions between A. karroo trees at these sites are relatively weak, and result in decreased performance (smaller canopy diameters) rather than mortality, thus preventing a regular pattern of tree distribution. We advocate the use of both methods of detecting competitive interactions in the field, especially if the effects of competition are too subtle to result in differential mortality.     

Photoautotrophic shoot and root development for triploid melon

The aim of this investigation was to establish environmental factors which promote growth and photosynthesis of melon (Cucumis melo L.) shoot buds, in vitro, and determine if photoautotrophic shoots had superior root forming ability in photoautotrophic environments. Buds from the triploid melon clone ‘(L-14×B)×L-14’ were observed for 21 days after transfer from a multiplication MS medium with 3% sucrose and 10 μM benzyladenine (BA) to a shoot development medium with 1 μM BA at three levels of sucrose in the medium (0, 1 and 3%), and light (50, 100 and 150 PPF) and CO₂ (500, 1000 and 1500 ppm) in the culture chamber. More shoot buds were observed with 3% sucrose in the medium. Increased light and CO₂ had a positive interaction with shoot proliferation. Fresh and dry weights were greatest at 3% sucrose, 150 PPF light and 1500 ppm CO₂. Shoot buds grew more slowly in sugar-free medium, but fresh and dry weight still doubled over 21 days of culture. Net photosynthetic rates (NPR) of buds were negative after four days in treatment conditions, but became positive after transfer to fresh, sugar-free medium. Two triploid genotypes of melon were (1) grown in vitro with sugar (photomixotrophic) and without sugar (photoautotrophic), (2) rooted in sugar-free media, both in a laboratory controlled environment chamber (in vitro) and a greenhouse acclimatization unit (ex vitro), and (3) compared for subsequent nursery growth in the greenhouse unit. The genotype ‘(L-14×B)×L-14’ produced more shoots than ‘(L-14×B)×Mainstream’ in both photomixotrophic or photoautotrophic conditions. ‘(L-14×B)×L-14’ rooted as well from either photoautotrophic and photomixotrophic shoots but ‘(L-14×B)×Mainstream’ rooted less frequently from photoautotrophic shoots. Seventy-six percent of the shoots in the laboratory controlled environment chamber were able to root photoautotrophically, whereas 47% of the shoots in the greenhouse acclimatization unit were rooted. Between 77% and 88% of plantlets from all treatment combinations survived transfer to the nursery. After growth in the nursery, the sizes of plants (fresh weight, dry weight, leaf area) were the same for either genotype, from either photoautotrophic or photomixotrophic shoots. Nursery plants that had been rooted in the laboratory controlled environment chamber were larger than those rooted in the acclimatization greenhouse chamber. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Short-term control of root: shoot partitioning

We present data showing that the fraction of the available photosynthatepartitioned between the root and the shoot of a barley seedlingis affected by the supply of photosynthate from the source leaf:an increased fraction of the exported photosynthate goes tothe shoot when supply is reduced. Also, if the roots are cooleda short time before reducing the supply of photosynthate, thenthe effect of a reduced supply upon partitioning is reversedwith an increased fraction then going to the root. We concludethat the distribution of available photosynthate between competingsinks is influenced by source supply as well as sink function.The reported source-sink interactions are consistant with thepredictions of a recently pro posed model of source-sink interaction(Minchin et al., 1993). The concept of marginal partitioningis introduced to describe the distribution, between all of thesinks, of a small change in photosynthate supply. Key words: Carbohydrate partitioning, shoot : root ratio, source-sink interactions     

Partitioning average competition and extreme-genotype effects in genetically diverse infections

Competition between parasite genotypes in genetically diverse infections is widespread. However, experimental evidence on how genetic diversity influences total parasite load is variable. Here we use an additive partition equation to quantify the negative effect of inter-genotypic competition on total parasite load in diverse infections. Our approach controls for extreme-genotype effects, a process that can potentially neutralise, or even reverse, the negative effect of competition on total parasite load. A single extreme-genotype can have a disproportionate effect on total parasite load if it causes the highest parasite load in its single-infection, while increasing its performance in diverse relative to single infections. We show that in theory such disproportionate effects of extreme-genotypes can lead to a higher total parasite load in diverse infections than expected, even if competition reduces individual parasite performance on average. Controlling for the extreme-genotype effect is only possible if the competition effect on total parasite load is measured appropriately as the average difference between the realised number of each parasite genotype in mixed infections and the expected number based on single infection parasite loads. We apply this approach to sticklebacks that were experimentally infected with different trematode genotypes. On average, genetically diverse infections had lower parasite loads than expected from single-infection results. For the first time we demonstrate that competition between co-infecting genotypes per se caused the parasite load reduction, while extreme-genotype effects were not significant. We thus suggest that to correctly quantify the effect of competition alone on total parasite load in genetically diverse infections, the extreme-genotype effect has to be controlled for.     

Distribution of cadmium in shoot and root tissues1

Maize and pea plants were treated with 0.0 (control), 0.01 or0.05 mM Cd in the growing medium for 11 d. Although the totalCd concentration was similar in shoot and root tissues of bothspecies, pea plants showed more severe toxic symptoms. The freshweight and percentage of water content of root and shoot decreasedconcomitantly to Cd supply. High Cd levels were found in thecell-wall fraction (Fraction I) and in Fraction IV (soluble)of maize plants, whereas Cd-treated pea accumulated more Cdin the soluble fraction. The protein concentration of FractionIV of pea shoot and root significantly increased upon treatmentwith 0.05 mM Cd, whereas maize showed no effect. Furthermore,a previously not visible protein ({small tilde}12 kDa), appearedin Fraction IV of pea root grown with the highest Cd supply.Cadmium treatment, in general, notably enhanced the concentrationsof 2-thiobarbituric acid reactive material (lipid peroxidationproducts) in pea fractions, presumably due to Cd-induced oxidativestress. Key words: Cadmium sensitivity, tissue fractions, stress, Pisum sativum, Zea mays     

The effects of environmental heterogeneity on root growth and root/shoot partitioning

AIMS: The purpose of this Botanical Briefing is to stimulate reappraisal of root growth, root/shoot partitioning, and analysis of other aspects of plant growth under heterogeneous conditions. SCOPE: Until recently, most knowledge of plant growth was based upon experimental studies carried out under homogeneous conditions. Natural environments are heterogeneous at scales relevant to plants and in forms to which they can respond. Responses to environmental heterogeneity are often localized rather than plant-wide, and not always predictable from traditional optimization arguments or from knowledge of the ontogenetic trends of plants growing under homogeneous conditions. These responses can have substantial impacts, both locally and plant-wide, on patterns of resource allocation, and significant effects on whole-plant growth. Results from recent studies are presented to illustrate responses of plants, plant populations and plant communities to nutritionally heterogeneous conditions. CONCLUSIONS: Environmental heterogeneity is a constant presence in the natural world that significantly influences plant behaviour at a variety of levels of complexity. Failure to understand its effects on plants prevents us from fully exploiting aspects of plant behaviour that are only revealed under patchy conditions. More effort should be invested into analysis of the behaviour of plants under heterogeneous conditions.     

Regulation of the soybean-Rhizobium nodule symbiosis by shoot and root factors

The availability of soybean mutants with altered symbiotic properties allowed an investigation of the shoot or root control of the relevant phenotype. By means of grafts between these mutants and wild-type plants (cultivar Bragg and Williams), we demonstrated that supernodulation as well as hypernodulation (nitrate tolerance in nodulation and lack of autoregulation) is shoot controlled in two mutants (nts382 and nts1116) belonging most likely to two separate complementation groups. The supernodulation phenotype was expressed on roots of the parent cultivar Bragg as well as the roots of cultivar Williams. Likewise it was shown that non-nodulation (resistance to Bradyrhizobium) is root controlled in mutant nod49. The shoot control of nodule initiation is epistatically suppressed by the non-nodulation, root-expressed mutation. These findings suggest that different plant organs can influence the expression of the nodulation phenotype.     

Chemical root to shoot signaling under drought

Chemical signals are important for plant adaptation to water stress. As soils become dry, root-sourced signals are transported via the xylem to leaves and result in reduced water loss and decreased leaf growth. The presence of chemical signals in xylem sap is accepted, but the identity of these signals is controversial. Abscisic acid (ABA), pH, cytokinins, a precursor of ethylene, malate and other unidentified factors have all been implicated in root to shoot signaling under drought. This review describes current knowledge of, and advances in, research on chemical signals that are sent from roots under drought. The contribution of these different potential signals is discussed within the context of their role in stress signaling.     

Nitrogen in shoot litter,root litter and root exudates from nitrogen-fixingAlnus incana

Summary A pot experiment withAlnus incana (L.) Moench growing in sand was set up to compare the amounts of nitrogen released from plants shoot litter with that released below ground as root litter and/or root exudation. No nitrogen fixation by free-living microorganisms was found in the sand and the increased nitrogen content of the plant + soil system was therefore due to nitrogen fixation byFrankia in the alder root-nodules. Most of the nitrogen released from the plants was in the nitrogen-rich leaf and other shoot litter. Only small amounts of nitrogen were found in the drainage water from the pots and were recorded as increased nitrogen content of the sand.     

Tillage and N fertilization effects on maize root growth and root:shoot ratio

Two methods for estimating the size of the maize (Zea mays l.) root system from soil cores taken in the field were compared. The spatially weighed block method of estimation accounted for variation in root density by using 18 samples per plant which varied in distance from plant and soil depth. This method was compared to an estimation which averaged all of the 18 samples together. Both methods gave surprisingly similar estimates for total root growth. Increased root growth in the surface soil layers, due to tillage and N fertilization, did not impact on the estimation of total root growth. Total root length remained unchanged or increased with N fertilization, while root weight remained the same or decreased. Root mass per length decreased with N fertilization. The estimated size of the root system was used to calculate root:shoot weight ratios. The largest root:shoot ratio was found in the vegetative stage and decreased throughout the rest of the season. In this field experiment, the estimated size of the root system at 8 weeks after planting was not significantly different from the size at silking or harvest. Nitrogen fertilization significantly decreased the root:shoot weight ratio. However, tillage did not significantly change the ratio.     

Partitioning of carbon in split root systems of barley: effect of temperature of the root

The time-course of partitioning of recently fixed photosynthateto a barley root was followed during a step change in the temperatureof the root. The induced change in partitioning had a responsetime of about 1 h, whilst the change in respiratory loss fromthe root of labelled and unlabelled CO was much faster. Theseobservations suggest that while a sudden temperature changehas an immediate effect upon the metabolic rate of the rootsit is not the metabolic rate as such which influences import(sink strength). The reported temperature responses are consistentwith the supposition that the size of the cytosolic pool ofsugar in the root, which is supplied directly by phloem importand used as a substrate for root metabolism, appears to controlimport into the root. Key words: Carbon partitioning, temperature, barley, Hordeum vulgare L., roots     

Aphid-induced reduction of shoot and root growth in Douglas-fir seedlings

1. The short‐ and long‐term effects of photosynthate removal by sap‐sucking herbivores on plant growth were examined by experimentally manipulating densities of an aphid Cinara pseudotsugae (Wilson) on 2‐year‐old Douglas‐fir seedlings Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco under greenhouse conditions. An 18‐week test was conducted to determine short‐term effects. Effects of long‐term aphid feeding were examined by exposing seedlings to aphid feeding for two consecutive growing seasons. A third experiment evaluated the extent of recovery during 1 year following a single season of aphid feeding. At least 35 seedlings were used in each test. 2. Volume and dry weight of both shoots and roots decreased significantly with increasing aphid feeding in all three experiments. 3. The most significant and severe aphid effect was reduced root tissue density, suggesting carbohydrate depletion due to translocation from roots to shoots. 4. There was no sign of recovery, of either root or shoot growth, during the year following one season of feeding. 5. The results of this study indicate that short‐term feeding by aphids can affect plant growth and structure for a relatively long time.