Polyproline II helical structure in protein unfolded states: lysine peptides revisited

The left-handed polyproline II (PPII) helix gives rise to a circular dichroism spectrum that is remarkably similar to that of unfolded proteins. This similarity has been used as the basis for the hypothesis that unfolded proteins possess considerable PPII helical content. It has long been known that homopolymers of lysine adopt the PPII helical conformation at neutral pH, presumably a result of electrostatic repulsion between side chains. It is shown here that a seven-residue lysine peptide also adopts the PPII conformation. In contrast with homopolymers of lysine, this short peptide is shown to retain PPII helical character under conditions in which side-chain charges are heavily screened or even neutralized. The most plausible explanation for these observations is that the peptide backbone favors the PPII conformation to maximize favorable interactions with solvent. These data are evidence that unfolded proteins do indeed possess PPII content, indicating that the ensemble of unfolded states is significantly smaller than is commonly assumed.     

The effect of the polyproline II (PPII) conformation on the denatured state entropy

Polyproline II (PPII) is reported to be a dominant conformation in the unfolded state of peptides, even when no prolines are present in the sequence. Here we use isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to investigate the PPII bias in the unfolded state by studying the binding of the SH3 domain of SEM-5 to variants of its putative PPII peptide ligand, Sos. The experimental system is unique in that it provides direct access to the conformational entropy change of the substituted amino acids. Results indicate that the denatured ensemble can be characterized by at least two thermodynamically distinct states, the PPII conformation and an unfolded state conforming to the previously held idea of the denatured state as a random collection of conformations determined largely by hard-sphere collision. The probability of the PPII conformation in the denatured states for Ala and Gly were found to be significant, approximately 30% and approximately 10%, respectively, resulting in a dramatic reduction in the conformational entropy of folding.     

The hydrodynamic and conformational properties of denatured proteins in dilute solutions

Published data on the characterization of unfolded proteins in dilute solutions in aqueous guanidine hydrochloride are analyzed to show that the data are not fit by either the random flight or wormlike chain models for linear chains. The analysis includes data on the intrinsic viscosity, root‐mean‐square radius of gyration, from small‐angle X‐ray scattering, and hydrodynamic radius, from the translational diffusion coefficient. It is concluded that residual structure consistent with that deduced from nuclear magnetic resonance on these solutions can explain the dilute solution results in a consistent manner through the presence of ring structures, which otherwise have an essentially flexible coil conformation. The ring structures could be in a state of continual flux and rearrangement. Calculation of the radius of gyration for the random‐flight model gives a similar reduction of this measure for chains joined at their endpoints, or those containing loop with two dangling ends, each one‐fourth the total length of the chain. This relative insensitivity to the details of the ring structure is taken to support the behavior observed across a range of proteins.     

Non-random-coil behavior as a consequence of extensive PPII structure in the denatured state

Unfolded proteins may contain a native or nonnative residual structure, which has important implications for the thermodynamics and kinetics of folding, as well as for misfolding and aggregation diseases. However, it has been universally accepted that residual structure should not affect the global size scaling of the denatured chain, which obeys the statistics of random coil polymers. Here we use a single-molecule optical technique—fluorescence correlation spectroscopy—to probe the denatured state of a set of repeat proteins containing an increasing number of identical domains, from 2 to 20. The availability of this set allows us to obtain the scaling law for the unfolded state of these proteins, which turns out to be unusually compact, strongly deviating from random coil statistics. The origin of this unexpected behavior is traced to the presence of an extensive nonnative polyproline II helical structure, which we localize to specific segments of the polypeptide chain. We show that the experimentally observed effects of polyproline II on the size scaling of the denatured state can be well-described by simple polymer models. Our findings suggest a hitherto unforeseen potential of nonnative structure to induce significant compaction of denatured proteins, significantly affecting folding pathways and kinetics.     

Computational simulation of the statistical properties of unfolded proteins

A simple Monte Carlo method was used to generate ensembles of simulated polypeptide conformations that are restricted only by steric repulsion. The models used for these simulations were based on the sequences of four real proteins, ranging in size from 26 to 268 amino acid residues, and included all non-hydrogen atoms. Two sets of calculations were performed, one that included only intra-residue steric repulsion terms and those between adjacent residues, and one that included repulsion terms between all possible atom pairs, so as to explicitly account for the excluded volume effect. Excluded volume was found to increase the average radius of gyration of the chains by 20-40%, with the expansion factor increasing with chain length. Contrary to recent suggestions, however, the excluded volume effect did not greatly restrict the distribution of dihedral angles or favor native-like topologies. The average dimensions of the ensembles calculated with excluded volume were consistent with those measured experimentally for unfolded proteins of similar sizes under denaturing conditions, without introducing any adjustable scaling factor. The simulations also reproduced experimentally determined effective concentrations for the formation of disulfide bonds in reduced and unfolded proteins. The statistically generated ensembles included significant numbers of conformations that were nearly as compact as the corresponding native proteins, as well as many that were as accessible to solvent as a fully extended chain. On the other hand, conformations with as much buried surface area as the native proteins were very rare, as were highly extended conformations. These results suggest that the overall properties of unfolded proteins can be usefully described by a random coil model and that an unfolded polypeptide can undergo significant collapse while losing only a relatively small fraction of its conformational entropy.     

NMR structural and dynamic characterization of the acid-unfolded state of apomyoglobin provides insights into the early events in protein folding

Apomyoglobin forms a denatured state under low-salt conditions at pH 2.3. The conformational propensities and polypeptide backbone dynamics of this state have been characterized by NMR. Nearly complete backbone and some side chain resonance assignments have been obtained, using a triple-resonance assignment strategy tailored to low protein concentration (0.2 mM) and poor chemical shift dispersion. An estimate of the population and location of residual secondary structure has been made by examining deviations of (13)C(alpha), (13)CO, and (1)H(alpha) chemical shifts from random coil values, scalar (3)J(HN,H)(alpha) coupling constants and (1)H-(1)H NOEs. Chemical shifts constitute a highly reliable indicator of secondary structural preferences, provided the appropriate random coil chemical shift references are used, but in the case of acid-unfolded apomyoglobin, (3)J(HN,H)(alpha) coupling constants are poor diagnostics of secondary structure formation. Substantial populations of helical structure, in dynamic equilibrium with unfolded states, are formed in regions corresponding to the A and H helices of the folded protein. In addition, the deviation of the chemical shifts from random coil values indicates the presence of helical structure encompassing the D helix and extending into the first turn of the E helix. The polypeptide backbone dynamics of acid-unfolded apomyoglobin have been investigated using reduced spectral density function analysis of (15)N relaxation data. The spectral density J(omega(N)) is particularly sensitive to variations in backbone fluctuations on the picosecond to nanosecond time scale. The central region of the polypeptide spanning the C-terminal half of the E helix, the EF turn, and the F helix behaves as a free-flight random coil chain, but there is evidence from J(omega(N)) of restricted motions on the picosecond to nanosecond time scale in the A and H helix regions where there is a propensity to populate helical secondary structure in the acid-unfolded state. Backbone fluctuations are also restricted in parts of the B and G helices due to formation of local hydrophobic clusters. Regions of restricted backbone flexibility are generally associated with large buried surface area. A significant increase in J(0) is observed for the NH resonances of some residues located in the A and G helices of the folded protein and is associated with fluctuations on a microsecond to millisecond time scale that probably arise from transient contacts between these distant regions of the polypeptide chain. Our results indicate that the equilibrium unfolded state of apomyoglobin formed at pH 2.3 is an excellent model for the events that are expected to occur in the earliest stages of protein folding, providing insights into the regions of the polypeptide that spontaneously undergo local hydrophobic collapse and sample nativelike secondary structure.     

High-pressure SAXS study of folded and unfolded ensembles of proteins

A structural interpretation of the thermodynamic stability of proteins requires an understanding of the structural properties of the unfolded state. High-pressure small-angle x-ray scattering was used to measure the effects of temperature, pressure, denaturants, and stabilizing osmolytes on the radii of gyration of folded and unfolded state ensembles of staphylococcal nuclease. A set of variants with the internal Val-66 replaced with Ala, Tyr, or Arg was used to examine how changes in the volume and polarity of an internal microcavity affect the dimensions of the native state and the pressure sensitivity of the ensemble. The unfolded state ensembles achieved for these proteins with high pressure were more compact than those achieved at high temperature, and were all very sensitive to the presence of urea and glycerol. Substitutions at the hydrophobic core detectably altered the conformation of the protein, even in the folded state. The introduction of a charged residue, such as Arg, inside the hydrophobic interior of a protein could dramatically alter the structural properties, even those of the unfolded state. The data suggest that a charge at an internal position can interfere with the formation of transient hydrophobic clusters in the unfolded state, and ensure that the pressure-unfolded form of a protein occupies the maximum volume possible. Only at high temperatures does the radius of gyration of the unfolded state ensemble approach the value for a statistical random coil.     

Morphologies and conformation transition of lentinan in aqueous NaOH solution

Molecular morphologies and conformation transition of lentinan, a beta-(1-->3)-D-glucan from Lentinus edodes, were studied in aqueous NaOH solution by atomic force microscopy (AFM), viscometry, multiangle laser light scattering, and optical rotation measurements. The results revealed that lentinan exists as triple-helical chains and as single random-coil chains at NaOH concentration lower than 0.05M and higher than 0.08M, respectively. Moreover, the dramatic changes in weight-average molecular weight Mw, radius of gyration [s2](1/2), intrinsic viscosity [eta], as well as specific optical rotation at 589 nm [alpha]589 occurred in a narrow range of NaOH concentration between 0.05 and 0.08M NaOH, indicating that the helix-coil conformation transition of lentinan was carried out more easily than that of native schizophyllan and scleroglucan, and was irreversible. For the first time, we confirmed that the denatured lentinan molecule, which was dissolved in 0.15M NaOH to be disrupted into single coil chains, could be renatured as triple helical chain by dialyzing against abundant water in the regenerated cellulose tube at ambient temperature (15 degrees C). In view of the AFM image, lentinan in aqueous solution exhibited the linear, circular, and branched species of triple helix compared with native linear schizophyllan or scleroglucan.     

Secondary-structure analysis of denatured proteins by vacuum-ultraviolet circular dichroism spectroscopy

To elucidate the structure of denatured proteins, we measured the vacuum-ultraviolet circular dichroism (VUVCD) spectra from 260 to 172 nm of three proteins (metmyoglobin, staphylococcal nuclease, and thioredoxin) in the native and the acid-, cold-, and heat-denatured states, using a synchrotron-radiation VUVCD spectrophotometer. The circular dichroism spectra of proteins fully unfolded by guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) were also measured down to 197 nm for comparison. These denatured proteins exhibited characteristic VUVCD spectra that reflected a considerable amount of residual secondary structures. The contents of alpha-helices, beta-strands, turns, poly-L-proline type II (PPII), and unordered structures were estimated for each denatured state of the three proteins using the SELCON3 program with Protein Data Bank data and the VUVCD spectra of 31 reference proteins reported in our previous study. Based on these contents, the characteristics of the four types of denaturation were discussed for each protein. In all types of denaturation, a decrease in alpha-helices was accompanied by increases in beta-strands, PPII, and unordered structures. About 20% beta-strands were present even in the proteins fully unfolded by GdnHCl in which beta-sheets should be broken. From these results, we propose that denatured proteins constitute an ensemble of residual alpha-helices and beta-sheets, partly unfolded (or distorted) alpha-helices and beta-strands, PPII, and unordered structures.     

Distinct circular dichroism spectroscopic signatures of polyproline II and unordered secondary structures: Applications in secondary structure analyses

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a valuable method for defining canonical secondary structure contents of proteins based on empirically‐defined spectroscopic signatures derived from proteins with known three‐dimensional structures. Many proteins identified as being “Intrinsically Disordered Proteins” have a significant amount of their structure that is neither sheet, helix, nor turn; this type of structure is often classified by CD as “other”, “random coil”, “unordered”, or “disordered”. However the “other” category can also include polyproline II (PPII)‐type structures, whose spectral properties have not been well‐distinguished from those of unordered structures. In this study, synchrotron radiation circular dichroism spectroscopy was used to investigate the spectral properties of collagen and polyproline, which both contain PPII‐type structures. Their native spectra were compared as representatives of PPII structures. In addition, their spectra before and after treatment with various conditions to produce unfolded or denatured structures were also compared, with the aim of defining the differences between CD spectra of PPII and disordered structures. We conclude that the spectral features of collagen are more appropriate than those of polyproline for use as the representative spectrum for PPII structures present in typical amino acid‐containing proteins, and that the single most characteristic spectroscopic feature distinguishing a PPII structure from a disordered structure is the presence of a positive peak around 220nm in the former but not in the latter. These spectra are now available for inclusion in new reference data sets used for CD analyses of the secondary structures of soluble proteins.     

Conformation and cooperative order-disorder transition in aqueous solutions of β-1,3-d-glucan with different degree of branching varied by the Smith degradation

β-1,3-d -glucan with different degrees of branching were obtained by selectively and gradually removing side chains from schizophyllan, a water-soluble triple helical polysaccharide, using the Smith degradation. Size exclusion chromatography combined with a multi-angle light scattering detection was performed in aqueous 0.1 M NaCl. The degree of branching decreased after the Smith degradation, while the molar mass distributions were almost unchanged. The molecular conformation of the Smith-degraded β-1,3-d -glucan was analyzed on the basis of the molar mass dependency of the radius gyration, and found to be comparable to the original triple helix of schizophyllan. Differential scanning calorimetry in deuterium oxide–hexadeuterodimethylsulfoxide mixtures was performed to investigate the effects of the degree of branching on the cooperative order-disorder transition. Removal of side chains affects both the transition temperature and transition enthalpy. The ordered structure is formed by the residual side chains in the triplex unit, so that the linear cooperative system of the triplex is maintained after the Smith degradation.     

Contribution of alpha helix formation in human plasma apolipoproteins to their enthalpy of association with phospholipids.

The human plasma apolipoproteins, apo-A-II and apo-C-III, assocaite with phospholipid with a concurrent increase in alpha helical structure of the apoprotein and an exothermic enthalpy of association. A linear correlation of the increase in alpha helical structure and the exothermic enthalpy of association gave a value of -1.3 kcal/mol of amino acid residues converted from a random coil to an alpha helical structure. This value is very close to that of alpha helix formation by charged polyamino acids (-1.2 kcal/mol) and suggests that amino acid side chains contribute little or no heat to the random coil leads to alpha helix transition in the plasma apolipoproteins. In the absence of a change in alpha helix in the apolipoproteins studied here, the enthalpy of association is practically nil, suggesting that alpha helix formation is a major enthalpic contribution to the total free energy of lipid-apolipoprotein association.     

Salmon calcitonin and amyloid beta: two peptides with amyloidogenic capacity adopt different conformational manifolds in their unfolded states

The molecular conformations of salmon calcitonin in aqueous solution have been investigated by exploiting the different influences of excitonic coupling on the amide I band profile in the isotropic and anisotropic Raman, FTIR, and vibrational circular dichroism spectra of a polypeptide. The N-terminal loop, caused by a disulfide bridge between cysteines at positions 1 and 7, was modeled by performing a conformational search by molecular mechanics calculations. The remaining part of the peptide chain was modeled as a mixture of three sequences containing different fractions of residues adopting poly-l-proline II (PPII), extended beta-strand, and alpha-helix-like conformations. This yielded an excellent reproduction of the experimentally observed amide I' band profiles. A comparison with recent data on the beta-amyloid fragment Abeta(1)(-)(28) revealed a lower PPII content and more conformational heterogeneity for calcitonin. Thus, our results underscore the notion that individual structural propensities of amino acid residues give rise to structural differences between the unfolded states of even long peptide chains, at variance with expectations based on a random or statistical coil model.     

Random coil structures in bacterial proteins. Relationships of their amino acid compositions to flanking structures and corresponding genic base compositions

In this study we classified regions of random coil into four types: coil between alpha helix and beta strand, coil between beta strand and alpha helix, coil between two alpha helices and coil between two beta strands. This classification may be considered as natural. We used 610 3D structures of proteins collected from the Protein Data Bank from bacteria with low, average and high genomic GC-content. Relatively short regions of coil are not random: certain amino acid residues are more or less frequent in each of the types of coil. Namely, hydrophobic amino acids with branched side chains (Ile, Val and Leu) are rare in coil between two beta strands, unlike some acrophilic amino acids (Asp, Asn and Gly). In contrast, coil between two alpha helices is enriched by Leu. Regions of coil between alpha helix and beta strand are enriched by positively charged amino acids (Arg and Lys), while the usage of residues with side chains possessing hydroxyl group (Ser and Thr) is low in them, in contrast to the regions of coil between beta strand and alpha helix. Regions of coil between beta strand and alpha helix are significantly enriched by Cys residues. The response to the symmetric mutational pressure (AT-pressure or GC-pressure) is also quite different for four types of coil. The most conserved regions of coil are “connecting bridges” between beta strand and alpha helix, since their amino acid content shows less strong dependence on GC-content of genes than amino acid contents of other three types of coil. Possible causes and consequences of the described differences in amino acid content distribution between different types of random coil have been discussed.     

A Raman optical activity study of rheomorphism in caseins, synucleins and tau. New insight into the structure and behaviour of natively unfolded proteins.

The casein milk proteins and the brain proteins alpha-synuclein and tau have been described as natively unfolded with random coil structures, which, in the case of alpha-synuclein and tau, have a propensity to form the fibrils found in a number of neurodegenerative diseases. New insight into the structures of these proteins has been provided by a Raman optical activity study, supplemented with differential scanning calorimetry, of bovine beta- and kappa-casein, recombinant human alpha-, beta- and gamma-synuclein, together with the A30P and A53T mutants of alpha-synuclein associated with familial cases of Parkinson's disease, and recombinant human tau 46 together with the tau 46 P301L mutant associated with inherited frontotemporal dementia. The Raman optical activity spectra of all these proteins are very similar, being dominated by a strong positive band centred at approximately 1318 cm(-1) that may be due to the poly(l-proline) II (PPII) helical conformation. There are no Raman optical activity bands characteristic of extended secondary structure, although some unassociated beta strand may be present. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed no thermal transitions for these proteins in the range 15-110 degrees C, suggesting that the structures are loose and noncooperative. As it is extended, flexible, lacks intrachain hydrogen bonds and is hydrated in aqueous solution, PPII helix may impart a rheomorphic (flowing shape) character to the structure of these proteins that could be essential for their native function but which may, in the case of alpha-synuclein and tau, result in a propensity for pathological fibril formation due to particular residue properties.     

Random coil chemical shifts in acidic 8 M urea: Implementation of random coil shift data in NMRView

Studies of proteins unfolded in acid or chemical denaturant can help in unraveling events during the earliest phases of protein folding. In order for meaningful comparisons to be made of residual structure in unfolded states, it is necessary to use random coil chemical shifts that are valid for the experimental system under study. We present a set of random coil chemical shifts obtained for model peptides under experimental conditions used in studies of denatured proteins. This new set, together with previously published data sets, has been incorporated into a software interface for NMRView, allowing selection of the random coil data set that fits the experimental conditions best.     

Host-guest scale of left-handed polyproline II helix formation

Despite the clear importance of the left-handed polyproline II (PPII) helical conformation in many physiologically important processes as well as its potential significance in protein unfolded states, little is known about the physical determinants of this conformation. We present here a scale of relative PPII helix-forming propensities measured for all residues, except tyrosine and tryptophan, in a proline-based host peptide system. Proline has the highest measured propensity in this system, a result of strong steric interactions that occur between adjacent prolyl rings. The other measured propensities are consistent with backbone solvation being an important component in PPII helix formation. Side chain to backbone hydrogen bonding may also play a role in stabilizing this conformation. The PPII helix-forming propensity scale will prove useful in future studies of the conformational properties of proline-rich sequences as well as provide insights into the prevalence of PPII helices in protein unfolded states.     

Is There or Isn't There? The Case for (and Against) Residual Structure in Chemically Denatured Proteins

ABSTRACT

First raised some 60 years ago, the question of whether chemically denatured proteins are fully unfolded has, in recent years, seen significantly renewed interest. This increased attention has been spurred, in large part, by new spectroscopic and computational approaches that suggest even the most highly denatured polypeptides contain significant residual structure. In contrast, the most recent scattering results uphold the long-standing view that chemically denatured proteins adopt random coil configurations. Here we review the evidence both for and against residual structure in chemically denatured proteins, and attempt to reconcile these seemingly contradictory observations.     

The effect of salt and temperature on the conformational changes of P1LEA‐22, a repeat unit of plant Late Embryogenesis Abundant proteins

The effect of choline chloride on the conformational dynamics of the 11‐mer repeat unit P1LEA‐22 of group 3 Late Embryogenesis Abundant (G3LEA) proteins was studied. Circular dichroism data of aqueous solutions of P1LEA‐22 revealed that the peptide favors a polyproline II (PPII) helix structure at low temperature, with increasing temperature promoting a gain of unstructured conformations. Furthermore, increases in sample FeCl₃ or choline chloride concentrations causes a gain in PPII helical structure at low temperature. The potential role of PPII structure in intrinsically disordered and G3LEA proteins is discussed, including its ability to easily access other secondary structural conformations such as α‐helix and β‐sheet, which have been observed for dehydrated G3LEA proteins. The observed effect of FeCl₃ and choline chloride salts on P1LEA‐22 suggests favorable cation interactions with the PPII helix, supporting ion sequestration as a G3LEA protein function. As choline chloride is suggested to improve salt tolerance and protect cell membrane in plants at low temperature, our results support adoption of the PPII structure as a possible damage‐preventing measure of Late Embryogenesis Abundant proteins.