Effect of Conditioning Treatments on the Survival of Radopholus similis at High Temperatures

Heat treatments are an environmentally safe method for eliminating quarantine pests from tropical foliage. Conditioning heat treatments can induce thermotolerance against subsequent and otherwise phytotoxic temperatures in tropical foliage, allowing heat treatments to be even more effective. However, if thermotolerance is also induced in nematodes of quarantine significance like Radopholus similis, heat treatments would be rendered ineffective. A lethal thermal death point (LT_99.9) was established for R. similis by recording mortality at 25 (control temperature), 43°C, 45°C, 47°C, or 49°C after a 0, 1-, 2-, 4-, 6-, 8-, 10-, 12-, or 15-minute exposure. In a second experiment, nematodes were conditioned at 35, 40, or 45°C for 0, 15, 30, 60, 120, and 180 minutes, allowed to rest for 3 hours, and then challenged at 47°C for 5 minutes. No nematodes survived the challenge heat treatment; rather, nematode mortality was hastened by the conditioning treatment itself. In a third experiment, R. similis inside anthurium roots were conditioned at 25°C or 40°C for 15 minutes and then treated at 45°C for up to 8 minutes. Mortality of conditioned and unconditioned nematodes was similar (P > 0.1). Conditioning treatments increase plant thermotolerance but do not induce thermotolerance in R. similis. Heat treatments have promise as disinfection protocols for quarantines.     

Characterization of the heat shock response in cultured sugarcane cells : I. Physiology of the heat shock response and heat shock protein synthesis

Effect of heat shock on the growth of cultured sugarcane cells (Saccharum officinarum L.) was measured. Heat shock (HS) treatment at 36 to 38°C (2 hours) induced the development of maximum thermotolerance to otherwise nonpermissive heat stress at 54°C (7 minutes). Optimum thermotolerance was observed 8 hours after heat shock. Development of thermotolerance was initiated by treatments as short as 30 minutes at 36°C. Temperatures below 36°C or above 40°C failed to induce maximum thermotolerance. In vivo labeling revealed that HS at 32 to 34°C induced several high molecular mass heat shock proteins (HSPs). A complex of 18 kilodalton HSPs required at least 36°C treatment for induction. The majority of the HSPs began to accumulate within 10 minutes, whereas the synthesis of low molecular mass peptides in the 18 kilodalton range became evident 30 minutes after initiation of HS. HS above 38°C resulted in progressively decreased HSP synthesis with inhibition first observed for HSPs larger than 50 kilodaltons. Analysis of two-dimensional gels revealed a complex pattern of label incorporation including the synthesis of four major HSPs in the 18 kilodalton range and continued synthesis of constitutive proteins during HS.     

Temperature characteristics and adaptive potential of wheat ribosomes

The translational efficiency of wheat ribosomes was studied as a function of an in vivo temperature pretreatment of wheat seedlings (Triticum aestivum L.). Ribosomes were isolated from heat-pretreated (36°C) and reference (4°C, 20°C) wheat seedlings. The efficiency of the ribosomes in translating polyuridylic acid was assayed. Ribosomes from heat-pretreated seedlings exhibit a threefold enhanced incorporation rate of phenylalanine as compared to ribosomes from wheat seedlings adapted to 20 or 4°C. This difference develops within 24 hours after onset of the heat treatment of seedlings following a 3 hour lag phase. The temperature induced changes can be traced back to the cytoplasmic ribosomes, since cycloheximide inhibits translation almost completely. Thermal inactivation of ribosomes occurs at 45°C, irrespective of the temperature pretreatment of the wheat seedlings. Specific differences in the yield of ribosomes, in the polyribosomal profiles, and in the apparent Arrhenius' activation energy of protein synthesis were observed depending on the age and the temperature pretreatments. The results presented here are considered an important molecular correlation to phenotypical temperature adaptation of in vivo protein synthesis in wheat (M Weidner, C Mathée, FK Schmitz 1982 Plant Physiol 69: 1281-1288).     

Interaction of heat and salt shock in cultured tobacco cells

Cultured tobacco cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. var Wisconsin-38) developed tolerance to otherwise nonpermissive 54°C treatment when heat-shocked at 38°C (2 h) but not at 42°C. Heat-shocked cells (38°C) exhibited little normal growth when the 54°C stress came immediately after heat shock and normal growth when 54°C stress was administered 8 hours after heat shock. Heat shock extended the length of time that the cells tolerated 54°C. Tobacco cells developed tolerance to otherwise lethal 2% NaCl treatment when salt-shocked (1.2% NaCl for 3 hours). The time course for salt tolerance development was similar to that of thermotolerance. Heat-shocked cells (38°C) developed tolerance of nonpermissive salt stress 8 hours after heat shock. Alternatively, cells heat-shocked at 42°C exhibited immediate tolerance to lethal salt stress followed by a decline over 8 hours. Radioactive methionine incorporation studies demonstrated synthesis of heat shock proteins at 38°C. The apparent molecular weights range from 15 to 115 kilodaltons with a protein complex in the 15 to 20 kilodalton range. Synthesis of heat shock proteins appeared to persist at 42°C but with large decreases in incorporation into selected heat shock protein. During salt shock, the synthesis of normal control proteins was reduced and a group of salt shock proteins appeared 3 to 6 h after shock. Similarities between the physiology and salt shock proteins/heat shock proteins suggest that both forms of stress may share common elements.     

Thermal Tolerance of Zymomonas mobilis: Temperature-Induced Changes in Membrane Composition

The membrane composition of Zymomonas mobilis changed dramatically in response to growth temperature. With increasing temperature, the proportion of vaccenic acid declined with an increase in myristic acid, the proportion of phosphatidylcholine and cardiolipin increased with decreases in phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylglycerol, and the phospholipid/protein ratio of the membrane declined. These changes in membrane composition were correlated with changes in thermal tolerance and with changes in membrane fluidity. Cells grown at 20°C were more sensitive to inactivation at 45°C than were cells grown at 30°C, as expected. However, cells grown at 41°C (near the maximal growth temperature for Z. mobilis) were hypersensitive to thermal inactivation, suggesting that cells may be damaged during growth at this temperature. When cells were held at 45°C, soluble proteins from cells grown at 41°C were rapidly lost into the surrounding buffer in contrast to cells grown at lower temperatures. The synthesis of phospholipid-deficient membranes during growth at 41°C was proposed as being responsible for this increased thermal sensitivity.     

A class of soybean low molecular weight heat shock proteins : immunological study and quantitation

Two major polypeptides of the 15- to 18-kilodalton class of soybean (Glycine max) heat shock proteins (HSPs), obtained from an HSP-enriched (NH₄)₂SO₄ fraction separated by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, were used individually as antigens to prepare antibodies. Each of these antibody preparations reacted with its antigen and cross-reacted with 12 other 15- to 18-kilodalton HSPs. With these antibodies, the accumulation of the 15- to 18-kilodalton HSPs under various heat shock (HS) conditions was quantified. The 15- to 18-kilodalton HSPs began to be detectable at 35° C, and after 4 hours at 40° C they had accumulated to a maximum level of 1.54 micrograms per 100 micrograms of total protein in soybean seedlings and remained almost unchanged up to 24 hours after HS. Accumulation of the HSPs was reduced at temperatures higher than 40° C. At 42.5° C the HSPs were reduced to 1.02 micrograms per 100 micrograms, and at 45° C they were hardly detectable. A brief HS at 45° C (10 minutes), followed by incubation at 28° C, which also induced HSP synthesis, resulted in synthesis of this class of HSPs at levels up to 1.06 micrograms per 100 micrograms of total protein. Taking into consideration the previous data concerning the acquisition of thermotolerance in soybean seedlings, our estimation indicates that the accumulation of the 15- to 18-kilodalton HSPs to 0.76 to 0.98% of total protein correlated well with the establishment of thermotolerance. Of course, other HSPs, in addition to this group of proteins, may be required for the development of thermotolerance.     

Biphasic Thermal Inactivation Kinetics in Salmonella enteritidis PT4

The thermal inactivation kinetics of Salmonella enteritidis PT4 between 49 and 60°C were investigated. Using procedures designed to eliminate methodological artifacts, we found that the death kinetics deviated from the accepted model of first-order inactivation. When we used high-density stationary-phase populations and sensitive enumeration, the survivor curves at 60°C were reproducibly biphasic. The decimal reduction time at 60°C (D_60°C) of the tail subpopulation was more than four times that of the majority population. This difference decreased with decreasing temperature; i.e., the survivor curves became more linear, but the proportion of tail cells remained a constant proportion of the initial population, about 1 in 10⁴ to 10⁵. Z plots (log D versus temperature) for the two populations showed that the D values coincided at 51°C, indicating that the survivor curves should be linear at this temperature, and this was confirmed experimentally. Investigations into the nature of the tails ruled out genotypic differences between the populations and protection due to leakage from early heat casualties. Heating of cells at 59°C in the presence of 5 or 100 μg of chloramphenicol per ml resulted in reductions in the levels of tailing. These reductions were greatest at the higher chloramphenicol concentration. Our results indicate that de novo protein synthesis of heat shock proteins is responsible for the observed tailing. Chemostat-cultured cells heated at 60°C also produced biphasic survivor curves in all but one instance. Cells with higher growth rates were more heat sensitive, but tailing was comparable with batch cultures. Starved cells (no dilution input) displayed linear inactivation kinetics, suggesting that during starvation a rapid heat shock response cannot be initiated.     

Characterization of the Heat Shock Response in Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis

The heat shock response in Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis was characterized with respect to synthesis of a unique set of proteins induced by thermal stress. A shift in temperature from 30 to 42°C was sufficient to arrest the growth of L. lactis subsp. lactis, but growth resumed after a shift back to 30°C. Heat shock at 50°C reduced the viable cell population by 10³; however, pretreatment of the cells at 42°C made them more thermoresistant to exposure at 50°C. The enhanced synthesis of approximately 13 proteins was observed in cells labeled with ³⁵S upon heat shock at 42°C. Of these heat shock-induced proteins, two appeared to be homologs of GroEL and DnaK, based on their molecular weights and reactivity with antiserum against the corresponding Escherichia coli proteins. Therefore, we conclude that L. lactis subsp. lactis displays a heat shock response similar to that observed in other mesophilic bacteria.     

Heat shock proteins in maize

The pattern of protein synthesis in roots of 3-day-old maize seedlings (Zea mays L.) is rapidly and dramatically altered when the incubation temperature is raised from 25 to 40°C. One-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate gels reveal that although synthesis of the proteins observed at 25°C continues at 40°C, a new set of `heat shock proteins' (hsp) is induced within 20 minutes of the temperature transition. The hsp have molecular weights of 87, 85, 79, 78, 77, 72, 70, 27, 22, and 18 kilodaltons. The 10 hsp are visible on autoradiograms but not on stained gels, suggesting that the proteins do not accumulate to any great extent.

The induction of the hsp is transitory. With prolonged high temperature treatment, the synthesis of hsp continues for 4 hours in excised roots and for 8 hours in the roots of intact seedlings before declining sharply. Coincident to the decline in synthesis of the 10 hsp is the gradual increase in intensity of three new polypeptides having molecular weights of 62, 49.5, and 19 kilodaltons. These proteins begin to appear about the time that synthesis of the other 10 hsp becomes maximal.

Shifting the temperature back to 25°C also causes a decline in synthesis of hsp, but this decline occurs more rapidly than that seen during prolonged heat shock. A decrease in hsp synthesis becomes apparent 2 hours after the roots are returned to 25°C.

Shifting the temperature from 25 to 45°C results in a pattern of protein synthesis different from that observed after a shift to 40°C. Normal protein synthesis continues, except four proteins, which are produced in small amounts at lower temperatures, show greatly enhanced synthesis at 45°C. These proteins have apparent molecular weights of 83, 81, 68, and 65 kilodaltons. Also, the 10 hsp listed above are not synthesized. It is suggested that at least two distinct high-temperature responses are present in maize, which may reflect the metabolic changes generated at different elevated temperatures.

     

Corn mitochondrial protein synthesis in response to heat shock

Corn (Zea mays L., W23(N), OH43(N), and reciprocal single cross hybrid) seedling mitochondria respond to a 10°C temperature shift (27-37°C) by incorporating a greater amount of [³⁵S]methionine into acid-insoluble material than mitochondria incubated at the original growing temperature (27°C). This increase is in part manifested in the enhanced synthesis of a 52 kilodaltons protein. At both temperatures mitochondria of two inbreds and their reciprocal hybrids synthesize normal (N) cytoplasm proteins sensitive to chloramphenicol and insensitive to cyclohexamide treatment. The 52 kilodaltons protein is found in the supernatants of pelleted (15,000g, 5 min) mitochondria after heat shock. The role of this protein in the heat shock response is discussed in light of the implication of mitochondria as the primary cellular target to temperature stress.     

Photosynthetic and respiratory rates of two psychrophilic diatoms

The photosynthetic rates in two psychrophilic diatoms, Chaetoceros sp. strain K3-10 and Nitzschia sp. K3-3 for cells grown at 0°C were 8 to 10 microliters O₂ evolved per milligram dry weight per hour, and 10-fold higher, about 80 for cells grown at 10°C. The respiration rates followed the same pattern, with a value of around 1 microliter dark uptake per milligram dry weight per hour for both organisms grown at 0°C, and 6 to 10 for cells grown at 10°C. When cells grown at 0°C were immediately shifted to 10°C or cells grown at 10°C were shifted to 0°C, the respiratory rates quickly adapted to values characteristic of cells grown at the shift temperature. On the other hand, the light-saturated rate of O₂ evolution showed much less immediate adaptation, especially on the up shift, 0° to 10°C. The chlorophyll a content of 0°C grown cells was about 0.5% of dry weight, in 10°C grown cells 1.3% (strain K3-10) and 2.2% (strain K3-3). In addition to a diminished chlorophyll a content in 0°C grown cells, there seemed proportionally (by absorbance and calculation) less c to a than in 10°C grown cells. The relative fluorescence excitation spectra of 680-nm emission also showed a lower contribution by both chlorophyll c and fucoxanthin in 0°C grown cells of Chaetoceros sp. strain K3-10 as compared to 10°C grown cells. The data at hand suggest that in psychrophilic diatoms continuously growing at 0°C there may be problems associated with synthesis of an effective accessory pigment system, and as a working hypothesis it is suggested this is related to restriction of synthesis of one or several accessory pigment proteins.     

Proteasome Inhibitors Cause Induction of Heat Shock Proteins and Trehalose, Which Together Confer Thermotolerance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

An accumulation in cells of unfolded proteins is believed to be the common signal triggering the induction of heat shock proteins (hsps). Accordingly, in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, inhibition of protein breakdown at 30°C with the proteasome inhibitor MG132 caused a coordinate induction of many heat shock proteins within 1 to 2 h. Concomitantly, MG132, at concentrations that had little or no effect on growth rate, caused a dramatic increase in the cells’ resistance to very high temperature. The magnitude of this effect depended on the extent and duration of the inhibition of proteolysis. A similar induction of hsps and thermotolerance was seen with another proteasome inhibitor, clasto-lactacystin β-lactone, but not with an inhibitor of vacuolar proteases. Surprisingly, when the reversible inhibitor MG132 was removed, thermotolerance decreased rapidly, while synthesis of hsps continued to increase. In addition, exposure to MG132 and 37°C together had synergistic effects in promoting thermotolerance but did not increase hsp expression beyond that seen with either stimulus alone. Although thermotolerance did not correlate with hsp content, another thermoprotectant trehalose accumulated upon exposure of cells to MG132, and the cellular content of this disaccharide, unlike that of hsps, quickly decreased upon removal of MG132. Also, MG132 and 37°C had additive effects in causing trehalose accumulation. Thus, the resistance to heat induced by proteasome inhibitors is not just due to induction of hsps but also requires a short-lived metabolite, probably trehalose, which accumulates when proteolysis is reduced.     

Indirect Measurement of the Lag Time Distribution of Single Cells of Listeria innocua in Food

The distribution of log counts at a given time during the exponential growth phase of Listeria innocua measured in food samples inoculated with one cell each was applied to estimate the distribution of the single-cell lag times. Three replicate experiments in broth showed that the distribution of the log counts is a linear mapping of the distribution of the detection times measured by optical density. The detection time distribution reflects the lag time distribution but is shifted in time. The log count distribution was applied to estimate the distributions of the lag times in a liquid dairy product and in liver paté after different heat treatments. Two batches of ca. 100 samples of the dairy product were inoculated and heated at 55°C for 45 min or at 62°C for 2 min, and an unheated batch was incubated at 4°C. The final concentration of surviving bacteria was ca. 1 cell per sample. The unheated cells showed the shortest lag times with the smallest variance. The mean and the variance of the lag times of the surviving cells at 62°C were greater than those of the cells treated at 55°C. Three batches of paté samples were heated at 55°C for 25 min, 62°C for 81 s, or 65°C for 20 s. A control batch was inoculated but not heated. All paté samples were incubated at 15°C. The distribution of the lag times of the cells heated at 55°C was not significantly different from that of the unheated cells. However, at the higher temperatures, 62°C and 65°C, the lag duration was longer and its variance greater.     

High temperature-induced thermotolerance in pollen tubes of tradescantia and heat-shock proteins

Growing pollen tubes of Tradescantia paludosa are protected from inhibition of growth at 41°C by a prior exposure to gradually increasing temperatures. Heat shock proteins (hsps) are not synthesized by pollen tubes as determined by labeling with [³⁵S]methionine and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, during either a heat shock at 41°C or a gradual temperature increase to 41°C. A comparison after two-dimensional electrophoresis of silver-stained spots and radioactive spots after autoradiography of an extract of ungerminated pollen mixed with a trace amount of [³⁵S]methionine-labeled vegetative tissue heat shocked at 41°C to act as a hsps marker, indicates that the majority, if not all, of the major hsps are not present in the pollen grain at anthesis. The type of thermotolerance seen with pollen tubes can thus be achieved without the presence or the new synthesis of the hsps.     

Effects of Above-Optimum Growth Temperature and Cell Morphology on Thermotolerance of Listeria monocytogenes Cells Suspended in Bovine Milk

The thermotolerances of two different cell forms of Listeria monocytogenes (serotype 4b) grown at 37 and 42.8°C in commercially pasteurized and laboratory-tyndallized whole milk (WM) were investigated. Test strains, after growth at 37 or 42.8°C, were suspended in WM at concentrations of approximately 1.5 × 10⁸ to 3.0 × 10⁸ cells/ml and were then heated at 56, 60, and 63°C for various exposure times. Survival was determined by enumeration on tryptone-soya-yeast extract agar and Listeria selective agar, and D values (decimal reduction times) and Z values (numbers of degrees Celsius required to cause a 10-fold change in the D value) were calculated. Higher average recovery and higher D values (i.e., seen as a 2.5- to 3-fold increase in thermotolerance) were obtained when cells were grown at 42.8°C prior to heat treatment. A relationship was observed between thermotolerance and cell morphology of L. monocytogenes. Atypical Listeria cell types (consisting predominantly of long cell chains measuring up to 60 μm in length) associated with rough (R) culture variants were shown to be 1.2-fold more thermotolerant than the typical dispersed cell form associated with normal smooth (S) cultures (P ≤ 0.001). The thermal death-time (TDT) curves of R-cell forms contained a tail section in addition to the shoulder section characteristic of TDT curves of normal single to paired cells (i.e., S form). The factors shown to influence the thermoresistance of suspended Listeria cells (P ≤ 0.001) were as follows: growth and heating temperatures, type of plating medium, recovery method, and cell morphology. Regression analysis of nonlinear data can underestimate survival of L. monocytogenes; the end point recovery method was shown to be a better method for determining thermotolerance because it takes both shoulders and tails into consideration. Despite their enhanced heat resistance, atypical R-cell forms of L. monocytogenes were unable to survive the low-temperature, long-time pasteurization process when freely suspended and heated in WM.     

Characteristics of Mesophilic Bacteria Isolated during Thermophilic Composting of Sewage Sludge

The degree of inactivation by UV irradiation was different between vegetative cells and spores of bacteria isolated from sewage sludge composting at 60°C. By using this property, a method to estimate the spore ratio of a mixture of vegetative cells and spores was presented. This UV irradiation method was applied to the estimation of the spore ratio of sewage sludge compost samples collected at several stages of composting. The spore ratio of mesophilic bacteria in the samples obtained at the thermophilic stage of 60°C was 40% at most. The vegetative form of mesophilic bacteria showed a thermotolerance property at 60°C by forming colonies but showed no respiratory activity at that temperature.     

Heat stress enhances phytohemagglutinin synthesis but inhibits its transport out of the endoplasmic reticulum

In this study we examined the effect of heat stress (up to 6 hours at 43°C) on the biosynthesis and transport of phytohemagglutinin (PHA) in cotyledons of developing seeds of the common bean, Phaseolus vulgaris. Heat stress resulted in a decrease of total protein synthesis and an enhancement of the synthesis of heat shock proteins and PHA. Pulse chase experiments showed that a considerable proportion of the newly synthesized PHA was present in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)/Golgi fraction and did not readily chase-out. Analysis with endoglycosidase H showed that the oligosaccharide sidechains of PHA were almost entirely in the high mannose configuration, indicating that most of the newly synthesized PHA was in the ER. However, some of the PHA became fucosylated at 43°C, indicating fucosyltransferase activity. That the biosynthesis and secretion of fucosyl-containing cell wall polymers proceeded normally at 43°C provided evidence that certain Golgi functions (i.e. transport to the cell wall) remained unaffected by heat stress. The ER obtained from these heat stress cotyledons had a greater density (1.16 g· cm⁻³ at 43°C instead of 1.14 g·cm⁻³ at 22°C) in sucrose gradients. Ultrastructural observations showed that the width of the lumen of the ER cisternae had increased from 20 nanometers at 22°C to 60 to 80 nanometers at 43°C; the lumen was filled with electrondense material presumed to be protein. The experiments are interpreted as evidence that heat stress imposes a block in the transport of PHA out of the ER. Whether heat stress affects the ER itself or alters the conformation of PHA, thereby preventing its transport, is not clear.     

Acquisition of Thermotolerance in Soybean Seedlings : Synthesis and Accumulation of Heat Shock Proteins and their Cellular Localization

When soybean Glycine max var Wayne seedlings are shifted from a normal growth temperature of 28°C up to 40°C (heat shock or HS), there is a dramatic change in protein synthesis. A new set of proteins known as heat shock proteins (HSPs) is produced and normal protein synthesis is greatly reduced. A brief 10-minute exposure to 45°C followed by incubation at 28°C also results in the synthesis of HSPs. Prolonged incubation (e.g. 1-2 hours) at 45°C results in greatly impaired protein synthesis and seedling death. However, a pretreatment at 40°C or a brief (10-minute) pulse treatment at 45°C followed by a 28°C incubation provide protection (thermal tolerance) to a subsequent exposure at 45°C. Maximum thermoprotection is achieved by a 2-hour 40°C pretreatment or after 2 hours at 28°C with a prior 10-minute 45°C exposure. Arsenite treatment (50 micromolar for 3 hours) also induces the synthesis of HSP-like proteins, and also provides thermoprotection to a 45°C HS; thus, there is a strong positive correlation between the accumulation of HSPs and the acquisition of thermal tolerance under a range of conditions.

During 40°C HS, some HSPs become localized and stably associated with purified organelle fractions (e.g. nuclei, mitochondria, and ribosomes) while others do not. A chase at 28°C results in the gradual loss over a 4-hour period of the HSPs from the organelle fractions, but the HSPs remain selectively localized during a 40°C chase period. If the seedlings are subjected to a second HS after a 28°C chase, the HSPs rapidly (complete within 15 minute) relocalize in the organelle fractions. The relative amount of the HSPs which relocalize during a second HS increases with higher temperatures from 40°C to 45°C. Proteins induced by arsenite treatment are not selectively localized with organelle fractions at 28°C but become organelle-associated during a subsequent HS at 40°C.

     

Effects of Pulsed Electric Fields on Inactivation Kinetics of Listeria innocua

The effects of pulsed electric field (PEF) treatment and processing factors on the inactivation kinetics of Listeria innocua NCTC 11289 were investigated by using a pilot plant PEF unit with a flow rate of 200 liters/h. The electric field strength, pulse length, number of pulses, and inlet temperature were the most significant process factors influencing the inactivation kinetics. Product factors (pH and conductivity) also influenced the inactivation kinetics. In phosphate buffer at pH 4.0 and 0.5 S/m at 40°C, a 3.0-V/μm PEF treatment at an inlet temperature of 40°C resulted in ≥6.3 log inactivation of strain NCTC 11289 at 49.5°C. A synergistic effect between temperature and PEF inactivation was also observed. The inactivation obtained with PEF was compared to the inactivation obtained with heat. We found that heat inactivation was less effective than PEF inactivation under similar time and temperature conditions. L. innocua cells which were incubated for a prolonged time in the stationary phase were more resistant to the PEF treatment, indicating that the physiological state of the microorganism plays a role in inactivation by PEF. Sublethal injury of cells was observed after PEF treatment, and the injury was more severe when the level of treatment was increased. Overall, our results indicate that it may be possible to use PEF in future applications in order to produce safe products.