Possible demonstration of multipotential nature of embryonic neural retina by clonal cell culture.

The possible multipotential nature of the neural retina of early chick embryos was examined by the technique of clonal cell culture. Cultures were prepared from cells dissociated from freshly excised neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos or from cells harvested from primary highdensity cultures. The following four colony types were obtained: colonies differentiating into “lentoid bodies”; colonies with pigment cells; colonies with both “lentoid bodies” and pigment cells; and colonies comprised entirely of unidentifiable cells. Neuronal differentiation occurred frequently in the early stages of culture (up to about 10 days). In some of these neuronal colonies, “lentoid bodies” and, rarely, both “lentoid bodies” and pigment cells differentiated after a further culture period of up to 30 days. Secondary colonies established from primary colonies after 9–10 days demonstrated that these original colonies fell into four different categories: those giving rise to secondary colonies containing only “lentoid bodies,” those giving rise to pigmented colonies only, those developing both lentoid and pigmented colonies, and finally those which gave rise to secondary colonies of all three types, lentoid, pigmented, and mixed colonies. When primary pigmented colonies were recloned at about 30 days after inoculation, the differentiated pigment cells transdifferentiated into lens. Whether multispecific colonies were really of clonal origin or not is discussed. The possible presence of a multipotent progenitor cell able to give rise to multispecific clones in the neural retina of 3.5-day-old chick embryos is suggested. A sequence of differentiation starting from multipotent neural retinal cells to be terminated with lens through the differentiation of neuronal and pigment cells is hypothetically proposed.     

Expression of Neuronal Specificities in "Transdifferentiating" Cultures of Neural Retina

Cells dissociated from the neural retina of embryonic chick differentiate into lens and pigment cells, when cultured in vitro. Using 3.5-day-old and 8.5-day-old chick embryos, we examined whether neuronal specificities would be expressed in such transdifferentiating cultures of neural retinal cells. The synthesis of acetylcholine and γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and the activity of choline acetyl transferase (CAT) was searched for in these cultures. The synthesis of an appreciable amount of these two putative neurotransmitters was detected in cultures of 3.5-day-old embryonic retinas by about 15 days. The activity of CAT was maximum in 7-day cultures of the 3.5-day-old materials and in 2-day cultures of the 8.5-day-old materials, and then decreased. Concomitant with the decrease of CAT-activity, δ-crystallin became detectable and increased thereafter. CAT-activity changed in parallel with the increase in the number of small neuroblast-like cells in cultures. The results demonstrate that the neuronal specificity identified by the appearance of acetylcholine and GABA and of the enzyme for the synthesis of acetylcholine is expressed in the early period of transdifferentiating cultures, which would later differentiate into lens and pigment cells. The possible mechanisms of the transition from neuronal to non-neuroretinal specificities of the transdifferentiating cultures are discussed.     

DIFFERENTIATION AND TRANSDIFFERENTIATION IN VITRO OF NEURAL RETINA FROM MUTANT CHICKENS WITH HYPERPLASIC LENS EPITHELIUM1)

Mutant chickens, Hy-1 and Hy-2, show abnormalities in growth and differentiation of the lens epithelium. In this study, neural retinal cells (NR cells) from 3.5-day-old embryos of these mutants were cultured, and the differentiation in vitro was compared with the cells of the normal strain. Hy-1 cells in vitro were characterized by a delay in the first appearance of neuronal cells (N-cells) and by excessive production of this cell type at later stages. By contrast, the Hy-2 cells were indistinguishable from the normal cells in the early phase of culturing. In spite of the marked difference of Hy-1 NR cells in neuronal differentiation up to about 7 days in culture, the transdifferentiation of lens and pigmented cells occurred to a similar extent and with the same time schedule as cultures of normal cells. A number of lentoid bodies were formed by about 10 days. The relative composition of the three major classes of crystallins in transdifferentiated lens cells was almost identical between normal and Hy-1 strains. The results were discussed in comparison with the previous results of cell culture of NR of 8-day embryonic mutant chickens, and it was concluded that the process of transdifferentiation in cell culture is different between NR from 3.5-day-old and 8-day-old embryos.     

Differentiation of lens and pigment cells in cultures of neural retinal cells of early chick embryos

Dissociated cells of neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos (stages 20–21) were cultured as a monolayer in order to examine their differentiation in vitro. These cells started to grow actively soon after inoculation and formed a confluent sheet within which neuroblast-like cells with long cytoplasmic processes were differentiated by 8 days. At about 16 days the differentiation of both lentoid bodies and foci of pigment cells was observed, while neuronal structure disappeared. The numbers of lentoid bodies and foci of pigmented cells continued to increase up to 30 days, when primary cultures were terminated. The increase in δ-crystallin content, as measured by quantitative immunoelectrophoresis assay using rabbit antiserum against δ-crystallin, was consistent with the increase in the number of lentoid bodies in cultures. The amount of α-crystallin per culture, estimated by the same technique as above, reached a maximum at 16 days and decreased slightly during further culture. The differentiation of both lentoid bodies and pigment cells was observed also in cultures of the second generation. The results demonstrate that cells of the undifferentiated neuroepithelium of 3.5-day-old embryonic retinas can achieve at least three differentiations, neuronal, lens, and pigment cells, in vitro. We discuss several differences between the present results and the previous ones from in vitro cultures of 8- to 9-day-old embryonic neural retinas.     

EFFECTS OF CULTURE MEDIA ON THE "FOREIGN" DIFFERENTIATION OF LENS AND PIGMENT CELLS FROM NEURAL RETINA IN VITRO

Neural retinal cells of 3.5-day-old quail embryos were cultured as a monolayer to examine their potentials for differentiation in vitro. The "foreign" differentiation into lentoid and pigment cells was much affected by the choice of medium (Eagle's MEM and Ham's F–12); in Eagle's MEM, neural retinal cells differentiated extensively into lentoid bodies and pigment cells, as previously reported in cultures of chick neural retinal cells, while in Ham's F–12, though the cells proliferated as well as in Eagle's MEM, the "foreign" differentiation is inhibited. When primary cultures were transferred to secondary cultures, the occurrence of "foreign" differentiation did not depend on the medium used for the primary culturing, but wholly on the medium used for secondary cultures. This difference in differentiation in two different media was quantitatively substantiated by measuring the amounts of α-, δ-crystallins and melanins of cultured cells.     

Differentiation of Lens and Pigment Cells in Cultures of Brain Cells of Chick Embryos

Dissociated cells of brains (tel- and diencephalons) of 3.5-day-old chick embryos were cultivated in vitro under the cell culture conditions which are known to be permissive for neural retinal cells (NR cells) to transdifferentiate into lens and/or pigmented epithelial cells (PE cells). The differentiation of lentoid bodies (LBs) with lens-specific (δ-crystallin and PE cells with melanin granules was observed in such brain cultures.
LBs appeared in two different phases, i. e., 2–3 days and 16–30 days of cultivation, and after 40 days of culture these structures were formed in all 60 culture dishes. Sometimes, LBs were observed in foci of PE cells formed during earlier stages of brain cultures. When similar brain cultures were prepared with older embryos of 5-, 8.5-, 14-, and 16-days of incubation, no differentiation of lens and PE cells was observed.     

Transdifferentiation of "lentoid" structures in cultures derived from pigmented epithelium was inhibited by collagen.

Cells from pigmented retina of 8- to 9-day-old chick embryos were cultured under two different conditions: on noncoated (NS) or collagen-coated (CS) substrates. Although cells on CS seemed to start dividing 2 to 3 days earlier than those on NS, their early growth rates were basically similar. Cells on CS stopped growing after attaining confluency and formed a monolayer, while cells on NS continued to grow after confluency and overlapped each other. In early growth phase, cells on both substrates became depigmented. Cells became repigmented earlier on CS than on NS. The average melanin content of cells in confluent cultures on CS was two to three times higher than that of cells on NS. By Day 30 “lentoid bodies” were formed only in cultures on NS. Immunoelectrophoretic tests showed the presence of all crystallins (α-, β-, and δ) in cultures on NS but not in cultures on CS. It is concluded that a collagen substrate inhibits “transdifferentiation” of pigmented retinal cells into lens during cell culture.     

A DEMONSTRATION OF LENS FORMING-CELLS IN NEURAL RETINA IN CLONAL CELL CULTURE

Clonal cultures with 1,000–3,000 cells were prepared from cells harvested from high density cultures of neural retina of 8-day-old chick embryos. About 1.14% and 0.31% of inoculated cells developed into recogniziable colonies in Eagle's MEM and in Ham's F-12 supplemented with fetal calf serum respectively. Of these colonies, lentoid bodies of authentic lens nature were differentiated in 10% and 33.52% in MEM and F-12 respectively. Cells harvested from high density cultures of the anterior and posterior portions of the neural retina were clonally cultured. Plating efficiency was much higher in the anterior cells than in the posterior ones and clonies with lentoid differentiation were developed only in clonal cultures of the anterior cells.     

The possibility of lens formation in explants of the retina and pigment epithelium of the eye in chick embryos

Undissociated tissue explants of the retina and retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) of 3,5-, 4-, 5- and 8-day-old chick embryos were cultured in vitro. After 7 days in culture, lentoids were observed in explants of either retina or RPE from 3,5-, 4- and 5-day-old embryos. As demonstrated by immunohistochemistry, these lentoids contained specific chick lens proteins (alpha-, beta- and delta-crystallins). No crystallin-containing cells were found in eye tissue explants from 8-day-old embryos. However, when 5-bromo-deoxyuridine (25 microM) was introduced into the medium at the beginning of culturing (for 12 h), large eosinophilic cells containing alpha-, beta- and delta-crystallins were detected in retinal explants of the 8-day old embryos. Thus, retina and RPE of 3,5-5-day-old chick embryos are capable of lens differentiation after explantation in vitro without dissociation into individual cells. This capacity is lost during development.     

THE DIFFERENTIATION OF PIGMENT CELLS IN CULTURES OF CHICK EMBRYONIC NEURAL RETINAE

Neural retinal cells of 8–9 day-old chick embryos were differentiated into pigment cells in the conditions of cell culture for about 25 days. The increase of pigment cells in vitro was semi-quantitatively shown, by counting the number of black foci of pigmented cells per plate throughout the culture period. The increase paralleled the increase in the activity of tyrosinase. The addition of a small number of pigment cells freshly dissociated from tapeta to the cultures of neural retinae did not increase the number of black foci in vitro . Electron microscopic observations revealed the morphological differences of melanin granules between those in pigment cells of the neural retinal cultures and those in cultured tapetum cells. It was discussed that pigment cells appearing in the neural retinal cultures were derived from neural retinal cells, but not from contaminated cells of the tapetum.     

Can Once Neuronally Differentiated Cells of Neural Retina Be Lentoidogenic in Cell Culture?*

Cells dissociated from neural retina of 3.5-day-old chick embryos transdifferentiated extensively into lens cells under the conditions of a cell culture for 3 to 4 weeks. In early satges of cell culture by about 10 days, cultures consisted of small round cells often with cytoplasmic processes(N-cells) and flattened epithelial cells (E-cells). Only N-cells were stained with a fluorescent dye Merocyanine 540. When cells harvested from early cultures were separated into two fractions by centrifugation in Percoll gradient, the specific activity of choline acetyltransferase was much higher in the fraction consisting mainly of N-cells than in other fraction mainly of E-cells. Continuous daily observations as well as cinematographic observations of living cultures indicate that lentoid bodies were often formed in the locations where clusters of N-cells had been found in early stages of culturing. The possibility of transdifferentiation of N-cell clusters into lentoid bodies is discussed.     

COMPARISON OF NEURONAL AND LENS PHENOTYPE EXPRESSION IN THE TRANSDIFFERENTIATING CULTURES OF NUERAL RETINA WITH DIFFERENT CULTURE MEDIA*

The effects of three different culture media (Eagle's MEM, F-12 and L-15) on the transdifferentiation of 8-day chick embryonic neural retina into lens cells, were examined with respect to the expression of two phenotypes. One type referred to neuronal specificity (as represented by the level of cholineacetyl-transferase, CAT, activity) and the other to lens specificity (as represented by content of α-and δ-crystallin). In 7-day cell cultures before the visible differentiation of lentoid bodies, CAT activity was detected in all media. But, its level was about 9 times higher in cultures with L-15 than in those with MEM and 3 times higher than in F-12. In 26-day cultures, CAT activity was practically undetectable. The production of α-and δ-crystallin was detected in cultures at 26 days. There were quantitative differences in the crystallin content with different media, and it was highest in cultures with L-15. The results indicate that conditions most favourable to the maintenance of the neuronal specificity in cell cultures of neural retina, can also support the most extensive transdifferentiation. The possibility of direct transdifferentiation of once neuronally specified cells into lens cells in cultures with L-15 has been suggested to explain the present results.     

Crystallin synthesis in lens differentiation in cultures of neural retinal cells of chick embryos.

Dissociated cells of neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos differentiated into “lentoid bodies” within about 10–12 days when cultured in vitro. Protein synthesis of these cultured cells was studied with the use of SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, affinity chromatography, and autoradiography combined with immunological techniques. Incorporation of [¹⁴C]leucine into total proteins, α-crystallin, and δ-crystallin was estimated after increasing times of culture up to about 30 days. Isotope incorporation into δ-crystallin was detected at 9 days, and it increased sevenfold after another 17 days. α-Crystallin was also first detected at 9 days, but its relative content reached a maximum at 12 days and then decreased gradually. The ratio of δ-crystallin synthesis to total protein synthesis increased up to 40% at 26 days, while that of α-crystallin synthesis remained 3% throughout the culture period. These results show that lens differentiation from neural retinal cells is associated with the preferential synthesis of lens crystallins, particularly of δ-crystallin.     

Neural retinal regeneration in the anuran amphibian Xenopus laevis post-metamorphosis: transdifferentiation of retinal pigmented epithelium regenerates the neural retina

In urodele amphibians like the newt, complete retina and lens regeneration occurs throughout their lives. In contrast, anuran amphibians retain this capacity only in the larval stage and quickly lose it during metamorphosis. It is believed that they are unable to regenerate these tissues after metamorphosis. However, contrary to this generally accepted notion, here we report that both the neural retina (NR) and lens regenerate following the surgical removal of these tissues in the anuran amphibian, Xenopus laevis, even in the mature animal. The NR regenerated both from the retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cells by transdifferentiation and from the stem cells in the ciliary marginal zone (CMZ) by differentiation. In the early stage of NR regeneration (5-10 days post operation), RPE cells appeared to delaminate from the RPE layer and adhere to the remaining retinal vascular membrane. Thereafter, they underwent transdifferentiation to regenerate the NR layer. An in vitro culture study also revealed that RPE cells differentiated into neurons and that this was accelerated by the presence of FGF-2 and IGF-1. The source of the regenerating lens appeared to be remaining lens epithelium, suggesting that this is a kind of repair process rather than regeneration. Thus, we show for the first time that anuran amphibians retain the capacity for retinal regeneration after metamorphosis, similarly to urodeles, but that the mode of regeneration differs between the two orders. Our study provides a new tool for the molecular analysis of regulatory mechanisms involved in retinal and lens regeneration by providing an alternative animal model to the newt, the only other experimental model.     

pp60c-src expression in transdifferentiating cultures of embryonic chick neural retina cells

Chick embryo neural retinal cells transdifferentiate extensively into lens cells when cultured in Eagle's MEM containing horse and fetal calf sera (FHMEM). Such cultures express elevated levels of pp60c-src-associated tyrosine kinase activity relative to parallel cultures prevented from transdifferentiating by the addition of supplementary glucose (FHGMEM) or replacement of MEM by medium 199 (F199). Northern blotting and in vitro translation studies suggest that c-src mRNA levels are only slightly higher in late transdifferentiating (FHMEM) cultures as compared to parallel blocked (FHGMEM or F199) cultures. By immunocytochemical staining, we show that pp60c-src protein is largely localized in cell groups undergoing conversion into lens (i.e. expressing delta crystallin) in late FHMEM cultures. Initial studies of pp60c-src in chick lens tissues during development indicate that higher kinase activity is found in the epithelial cells relative to mature lens fibres. Thus pp60c-src may be expressed both during the differentiation of lens cells in vivo and during the transdifferentiation of neural retina cells into lens in vitro.     

Induction of retinal regeneration in vivo by growth factors

We have previously reported that basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) can induce retinal regeneration in the stage 22-24 chicken embryo. The present study was undertaken to identify the cellular source of the regenerate and to determine whether other growth factors also elicit regeneration in this animal model. Polymer implants containing bFGF were inserted into eyes of chicken embryos immediately after extirpation of the neural retina. The retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) was left intact. Evaluation by light microscopy revealed that in bFGF-treated eyes the new neural retina arose by transdifferentiation of the entire RPE layer. Differentiation of the new neural retina occurred in a sequence similar to that of normal development but proceeded in a reverse (vitread) direction. All retinal laminae had differentiated by Day 15. However, the regenerate displayed reversed polarity, with photoreceptors closest to the lens. The RPE, pecten, and optic nerve were absent. Focal areas of degeneration in the retinal regenerate became evident for the first time on Day 10. Retinal regeneration was also observed after treatment with higher doses of acidic fibroblast growth factor, but not with nerve growth factor-beta, transforming growth factor-beta 1, insulin, or insulin-like growth factors I or II. These results raise the possibility that FGFs may play a role in retinal differentiation during development.     

In vitro analysis of cellular metaplasia from pigmented epithelial cells to lens phenotypes: a unique model system for studying cellular and molecular mechanisms of "transdifferentiation"

Pigmented epithelial cells (PECs) were dissociated from eyes of 8- to 9-day-old chick embryos and were cultured in EdF medium (Eagle's MEM supplemented with dialyzed fetal bovine serum) containing phenylthiourea (PTU) and testicular hyaluronidase (HUase). The PECs rapidly lost melanosomes as they proliferated and dedifferentiated in culture. These dedifferentiated PECs (dePECs) which did not manifest any identifiable specificity could be directed to one of two different differentiated phenotypes; viz., lens or pigment cells, depending upon subsequent culture conditions. Almost all dePECs began to synthesize melanin and redifferentiated to PECs by Day 10 of culture with EdF medium containing ascorbic acid (AsA). In contrast, the sister population of dePECs, when cultured at extremely high cell density with EdF medium containing PTU, HUase and AsA, synthesized delta-crystallin which is specific for lens. This transdifferentiation into lens cells occurred by Day 15 of culture. Using this culture system we are able to produce a homogeneous cell population with the potential for synchronous differentiation into either lens or pigment cell phenotype. The system is useful for studying mechanisms involved in cellular metaplasia.     

Developmental decline in DNA repair in neural retina cells of chick embryos: persistent deficiency of repair competence in a cell line derived from late

Neural retinas of 6-day-old chick embryos synthesize DNA and are able to carry out DNA excision repair. However, in contrast to the situation in human cells, the maximum rate of repair induced by N-acetoxy acetylaminofluorene (AAAF) is no greater than that induced by methyl methanesulfonate (MMS). With advancing differentiation of the retina in the embryo, cell multiplication and DNA synthesis decline and cease, and concurrently the cells lose the ability to carry out DNA excision repair. Thus, in 15-16-day embryos, in which the level of DNA synthesis is very low, DNA repair is barely detectable. If retinas from 14-day embryos are dissociated with trypsin and the cell suspension is plated in growth- promoting medium, DNA synthesis is reinitiated; however, in these cultures there is no detectable repair of MMS-induced damage, and only low levels of repair are observed after treatment with AAAF. A cell line was produced, by repeated passaging of these cultures, in which the cell population reached a steady state of DNA replication. However, the cell population remained deficient in the ability to repair MMS-induced damage. This cell line most likely predominantly comprises cells of retino-glial origin. Possible correlations between deficiency in DNA repair mechanisms in replicating cells and carcinogenesis in neural tissues are discussed.     

Transdifferentiation of ocular tissues in larval Xenopus laevis

Transdifferentiation phenomena offer a useful opportunity to study experimentally the mechanisms on which cell phenotypic stability depends. The capacities of vertebrate eye tissues to reprogram cell differentiation are well known in avian and mammalian embryos, and in larval and adult newt. From research into the capacity of anuran eye tissues to reprogram differentiation into a new pathway, considerable data have accumulated concerning the transdifferentiative capacities of eye tissues in larval Xenopus laevis. This work reviews the data concerning the transdifferentiative phenomena of eye tissues in that species and, based on these, aims to establish the extent of our knowledge about the mechanism controlling these processes. In larval Xenopus laevis the outer cornea can regenerate a lens by a lens-transdifferentiation process triggered and substained by a factor(s), probably of a protein nature, produced by the neural retina. In a normal eye phenotypic stability of the outer cornea is guaranteed by the presence of the inner cornea and lens, which prevent the spread of retinal factor(s). The stimulus for lens transdifferentiation of the outer cornea can be supplied by other tissues as well, but this capacity is not widely distributed. The iris and retinal pigmented epithelium can transdifferentiate into neural retina if isolated from the surrounding tissues and implanted in the vitreous chamber. As for lens transdifferentiation of the outer cornea, retinal transdifferentiation of the iris can be stimulated by certain nonocular tissues as well.