Dissection of the mechanism for the stringent factor RelA

During conditions of nutrient deprivation, ribosomes are blocked by uncharged tRNA at the A site. The stringent factor RelA binds to blocked ribosomes and catalyzes synthesis of (p)ppGpp, a secondary messenger that induces the stringent response. We demonstrate that binding of RelA and (p)ppGpp synthesis are inversely coupled, i.e., (p)ppGpp synthesis decreases the affinity of RelA for the ribosome. RelA binding to ribosomes is governed primarily by mRNA, but independently of ribosomal protein L11, while (p)ppGpp synthesis strictly requires uncharged tRNA at the A site and the presence of L11. A model is proposed whereby RelA hops between blocked ribosomes, providing an explanation for how low intracellular concentrations of RelA (1/200 ribosomes) can synthesize (p)ppGpp at levels that accurately reflect the starved ribosome population.     

Template-independent synthesis of guanosine tetra- and pentaphosphates on ribosomes

It is shown that Escherichia coli ribosomes carrying poly(Lys)-tRNA can form (p)ppGpp in the presence of stringent factor in the absence of the poly(A) template. Template-independent synthesis of (p)ppGpp is suppressed by tetracycline and partially decreases if deacylated tRNA is omitted.     

Purification and properties of stringent factor.

The stringent factor from Escherichia coli is the product of the relA locus. It is the enzyme that catalyzes the synthesis of pppGpp and ppGpp eliciting a pyrophosphate transfer from ATP to the 3'--OH of GTP (or GDP). This protein is responsible for the synthesis of pppGpp and ppGpp in stringent strains in response to an amino acid starvation. In vitro it catalyzes the synthesis of these guanosine compounds in either a ribosome-dependent reaction that requires a particular conformation of the ribosome i.e. the presence of an uncharged tRNA recognizing a codon in the acceptor (A) site of the ribosome or in a ribosome-independent reaction at temperatures under 30 degrees in the presence of only buffer, salts, and substrates. Here we report the purification of the stringent factor to near homogeneity. It is a monomeric protein with a molecular weight of 75,000. The properties of the ribosome-independent reaction are studied and it is shown that the presence of certain acidic proteins, such as the 50 S ribosomal proteins L7 and L12 or casein, or 20% methanol or both stimulates the reaction by creating an environment that together with the low temperature further stabilizes the stringent factor.     

Stringency and relaxation among the halobacteria.

Accumulation of stable RNA and production of guanosine polyphosphates (ppGpp and pppGpp) were studied during amino acid starvation in four species of halobacteria. In two of the four species, stable RNA was under stringent control, whereas one of the remaining two species was relaxed and the other gave an intermediate phenotype. The stringent reaction was reversed by anisomycin, an effect analogous to the chloroamphenicol-induced reversal of stringency in the eubacteria. During the stringent response, neither ppGpp nor pppGpp accumulation took place during starvation. In both growing and starved cells a very low basal level of the two polyphosphates appeared to be present. In the stringent species the intracellular concentration of GTP did not diminish but actually increased during the course of the stringent response. These data demonstrate that (i) wild-type halobacteria can have either the stringent or the relaxed phenotype (all wild-type eubacteria tested have been shown to be stringent); (ii) stringency in the halobacteria is dependent on the deaminoacylation of tRNA, as in the eubacteria; and (iii) in the halobacteria, ppGpp is not an effector of stringent control over stable-RNA synthesis.     

Discrimination between purine and pyrimidine base at the 3' terminus of the tRNA molecule by the stringent factor system from Escherichia coli.

Crude stringent factor, prepared from a mutant strain with low levels of tRNA nucleotidyl transferase, synthesizes little or no (p)ppGpp in the presence of tRNA^Phe-CpC; addition of yeast tRNA nucleotidyl transferase, however, fully restores (p)ppGpp formation, indicating that the complete CCA terminus of the tRNA molecule is a prerequisite in the (p)ppGpp synthesizing reaction. When the terminal purine is replaced by a pyrimidine base as in the case of tRNA^Phe-CpCpC; or when the latter is extended by addition of AMP yielding tRNA^Phe-CpCpCpA, both modified tRNAs are low in stimulating the (p)ppGpp synthesizing reaction. Hence activation of the stringent factor by tRNA requires (i) the terminal purine base and (ii) the precise fitting of the CCA terminus to the acceptor site of the ribosome.     

Functional homology between E. coli ribosomal protein L11 and B. megaterium protein BM-L11

Summary Ribosomes from the thiostrepton-resistant mutant MJ1 of Bacillus megaterium completely lack a protein designated BM-L11. When assayed in vitro, such ribosomes show an impaired ability to hydrolyse GTP in the presence of the elongation factor EF-G and are unable to support the synthesis of (p)ppGpp in response to the stringent factor. Restoration of both these activities can be achieved by re-addition of either protein BM-L11 or its serological homologue from Escherichia coli, protein L11, implying that these two proteins are related functionally as well as immunologically.     

The flexible N-terminal domain of ribosomal protein L11 from Escherichia coli is necessary for the activation of stringent factor

The stringent response is activated by the binding of stringent factor to stalled ribosomes that have an unacylated tRNA in the ribosomal aminoacyl-site. Ribosomes lacking ribosomal protein L11 are deficient in stimulating stringent factor. L11 consists of a dynamic N-terminal domain (amino acid residues 1-72) connected to an RNA-binding C-terminal domain (amino acid residues 76-142) by a flexible linker (amino acid residues 73-75). In vivo data show that mutation of proline 22 in the N-terminal domain is important for initiation of the stringent response. Here, six different L11 point and deletion-mutants have been constructed to determine which regions of L11 are necessary for the activation of stringent factor. The different mutants were reconstituted with programmed 70 S(DeltaL11) ribosomes and tested for their ability to stimulate stringent factor in a sensitive in vitro pppGpp synthesis assay. It was found that a single-site mutation at proline 74 in the linker region between the two domains did not affect the stimulatory activity of the reconstituted ribosomes, whereas the single-site mutation at proline 22 reduced the activity of SF to 33% compared to ribosomes reconstituted with wild-type L11. Removal of the entire linker between the N and C-terminal domains or removal of the entire proline-rich helix beginning at proline 22 in L11 resulted in an L11 protein, which was unable to stimulate stringent factor in the ribosome-dependent assay. Surprisingly, the N-terminal domain of L11 on its own activated stringent factor in a ribosome-dependent manner without restoring the L11 footprint in 23 S rRNA in the 50 S subunit. This suggests that the N-terminal domain can activate stringent factor in trans. It is also shown that this activation is dependent on unacylated tRNA.     

Characterization of the tRNA and ribosome-dependent pppGpp-synthesis by recombinant stringent factor from Escherichia coli

Stringent factor is a ribosome-dependent ATP:GTP pyrophosphoryl transferase that synthesizes (p)ppGpp upon nutrient deprivation. It is activated by unacylated tRNA in the ribosomal amino-acyl site (A-site) but it is unclear how activation occurs. A His-tagged stringent factor was isolated by affinity-chromatography and precipitation. This procedure yielded a protein of high purity that displayed (a) a low endogenous pyrophosphoryl transferase activity that was inhibited by the antibiotic tetracycline; (b) a low ribosome-dependent activity that was inhibited by the A-site specific antibiotics thiostrepton, micrococcin, tetracycline and viomycin; (c) a tRNA- and ribosome-dependent activity amounting to 4500 pmol pppGpp per pmol stringent factor per minute. Footprinting analysis showed that stringent factor interacted with ribosomes that contained tRNAs bound in classical states. Maximal activity was seen when the ribosomal A-site was presaturated with unacylated tRNA. Less tRNA was required to reach maximal activity when stringent factor and unacylated tRNA were added simultaneously to ribosomes, suggesting that stringent factor formed a complex with tRNA in solution that had higher affinity for the ribosomal A-site. However, tRNA-saturation curves, performed at two different ribosome/stringent factor ratios and filter-binding assays, did not support this hypothesis.     

Amber suppression relaxes stringent control by elongating stringent factor

Summary Efficient expression of an amber suppressing tRNA Su⁺7, relaxes E. coli's stringent response to amino acid starvation. This suppressor tRNA interferes with the accumulation of (p)ppGpp rather than the cell's ability to respond to it, and this appears to be independent of which amino acid is withdrawn.Isogenic UAA- or UGA-reading derivatives of Su⁺7 do not relax their hosts, but all other UAG suppressors tested also show the control effect. In fact, the extent of relaxation induced by a given amber suppressor is directly proportional to its suppressor efficiency. Suppressor tRNAs do not directly effect relaxation because when Su⁺7 expression is induced with IPTG, it takes twice as long to achieve full relaxation as it takes to reach the maximum level of Su⁺7 accumulation. This suggests that the tRNA does not affect relaxation directly but rather causes the accumulation of a secondary effector.The nature of this secondary effector was determined using antibodies to stringent factor. In Su⁺7-bearing cells, half of the stringent factor antigen migrates on SDS polyacrylamide gels as if it is about 30 amino acids longer than the wild type protein. The ratio of elongated to wild type stringent factor is directly correlated with the amber suppressor efficiency of the cell's resident Su⁺ tRNA. When half the cell's stringent factor is elongated, it can make half as much (p)ppGpp in response to amino acid starvation. When a second gene for stringent factor is introduced to these cells, the amount of wild type stringent factor is doubled and stringency is restored, confirming that the effect on the stringent factor gene product is sufficient to explain the tRNA effect on stringent control.Non-Standard Abbreviations TCA Trichloroacetic acid - IPTG Isopropyl--D-thiogalactopyranoside - EMS Ethyl methane sulfonate - Kd Kilodalton - SDS Sodium dodecyl sulfate This work was taken from the doctoral thesis of L.B. submitted to the University of Colorado, 1981     

Effect of variation of charged and uncharged tRNA(Trp) levels on ppGpp synthesis in Escherichia coli.

We introduced into a stringent Escherichia coli tryptophan auxotroph a plasmid bearing the tRNA(Trp) gene under the control of an inducible promoter. This allows us to manipulate the total concentration of tRNA(Trp) in the cell according to whether and when inducer is added to the culture. We also manipulated the concentration of Trp-tRNA(Trp) in vivo since the strain used bears a mutation in the Trp-tRNA synthetase affecting the Km for tryptophan, such that varying the exogenous concentration of tryptophan led to variation in the level of Trp-tRNA(Trp) in the cell. With this system, we found that the signal eliciting ppGpp synthesis during a stringent response triggered by tryptophan limitation did not depend on the absolute concentration of either charged or uncharged tRNA(Trp) but rather depended on a decline in the ratio of charged/uncharged tRNA(Trp). In addition, we found that the amplitude of the response, once triggered by tryptophan limitation, was determined by the total concentration of tRNA(Trp) present in the cell (which is mostly uncharged at that point in time). However, excess uncharged tRNA(Trp) did not amplify ppGpp synthesis triggered by limitation of a different amino acid. These data provide in vivo support for the in vitro-derived model of ppGpp synthesis on ribosomes.     

Activation of transcription by guanosine 5'-diphosphate,3'-diphosphate, transfer ribonucleic acid, and novel protein from Escherichia coli.

A protein factor TFms) that is required for ppGpp to stimulate RNA synthesis has been purified from an eluate of crude ribosomes. TFms also has the capacity to stimulate RNA synthesis without ppGpp present. Under standard conditions the action TFms and ppGpp requires uncharged tRNA. TFms and ppGpp act at inhibition to promote the formation of rifampicin-resistant or polytrI)-resistant preinitiation complexes. In the presence of rifampicin or poly(rI), tRNA is no longer required. With lambdah80dlacPs DNA as template, ppGpp together with TFms stimulated gal RNA synthesis to a much greater extent than total RNA synthesis. The stimulation of both lac and gel RNA synthesis was increased in the presence of cyclic AMP receptor and cyclic AMP.     

Differential regulation of opposing RelMtb activities by the aminoacylation state of a tRNA.ribosome.mRNA.RelMtb complex

Rel(Mtb) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis is responsible for the intracellular regulation of (p)ppGpp and the consequent ability of the organism to survive long-term starvation, indicating a possible role in the pathogenesis of tuberculosis. Purified Rel(Mtb) is a dual-function enzyme carrying out ATP: GTP/GDP/ITP 3'-pyrophosphoryltransferase and (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase reactions. Here we show that in the absence of biological regulators, Rel(Mtb) simultaneously catalyzes both transferase and hydrolysis at the maximal rate for each reaction, indicating the existence of two distinct active sites. The differential regulation of the opposing activities of Rel(Mtb) is dependent on the ratio of uncharged to charged tRNA and the association of Rel(Mtb) with a complex containing tRNA, ribosomes, and mRNA. A 20-fold increase in the k(cat) and a 4-fold decrease in K(ATP) and K(GTP) from basal levels for transferase activity occur when Rel(Mtb) binds to a complex containing uncharged tRNA, ribosomes, and mRNA (Rel(Mtb) activating complex or RAC). The k(cat) for hydrolysis, however, is reduced 2-fold and K(m) for pppGpp increased 2-fold from basal levels in the presence of the Rel(Mtb) activating complex. The addition of charged tRNA to this complex has the opposite effect by inhibiting transferase activity and activating hydrolysis activity. Differential control of Rel(Mtb) gives the Mtb ribosomal complex a new regulatory role in controlling cellular metabolism in response to stringent growth conditions that may be present in the dormant Mtb lesion.     

Dependence of RelA-mediated (p)ppGpp formation on tRNA identity

The bacterial stringent response is a cellular response to amino acid limitations and is characterized by the accumulation of the alarmone polyphosphate guanosine ((p)ppGpp). A key molecular event leading to (p)ppGpp synthesis is the binding of a deacylated tRNA to the vacant A-Site of a ribosome. The resulting ribosomal complex is recognized by and activates RelA, the (p)ppGpp synthetase. Activated RelA catalyzes (p)ppGpp formation until the deacylated tRNA passively dissociates from the ribosomal A-Site. In this report, we have investigated a novel role for the identity of A-Site bound tRNA in RelA-mediated (p)ppGpp synthesis. A comparison in the stimulation of RelA activity was made using ribosome complexes with either a tightly or weakly binding deacylated tRNA occupying the A-Site. In vitro analysis reveals that ribosome complexes formed with tight binding tRNA(Val) stimulate RelA activity at lower concentrations than that required for ribosome complexes formed with the weaker binding tRNA(Phe). The data suggest that the recovery from the stringent response may be dependent on the identity of the amino acid that was initially limiting for the bacteria.     

The interaction of guanosine 5'-diphosphate, 2' (3')-diphosphate with the bacterial elongation factor Tu

The unusual nucleotide guanosine tetraphosphate, ppGpp, which appears following amino acid starvation in “stringent” strains of bacteria binds to the elongation factor EFTu with a dissociation constant of about 8 × 10^?9m. ppGpp binds competitively with GDP and GTP, and EFTs catalyzes the exchange reaction of ppGpp with EFTu · GDP. ppGpp binds to EFTu about 50 times more tightly than does GTP, and, in the absence of elongation factor EFTs, it will effectively inhibit the formation of the ternary complex Phe-tRNA · EFTu · GTP. However, in the presence of EFTs there is rapid equilibration between EFTu · GTP and EFTu · ppGpp which allows EFTu to be rapidly and extensively incorporated into the stable ternary complex. A preliminary estimate of the constant for the dissociation of Phe-tRNA from the ternary complex is 10^?810^?9m. ppGpp inhibits the enzymatic binding of Phe-tRNA to ribosomes; however, EFTs reverses this inhibition. ppGpp moderately inhibits phenylalanine polymerization even in the presence of EFTs. This inhibition probably involves an interaction of ppGpp with elongation factor G, the translocation factor. It appears that in the intact cell ppGpp would not be an effective inhibitor of EFTu, and that little EFTu · ppGpp can exist in the cell.     

Genetics and physiology of the rel system of Bacillus subtilis

Summary Stringent factor (ATP:GTP-3 pyrophosphotransferase) has been purified from wild type Bacillus subtilis and it has been shown that guanosine tetra- and pentaphosphate (ppGpp and pppGpp) are synthesized in vitro in the presence of ribosomes, unacylated tRNA and its specific codon, as has been demonstrated in Escherichia coli. relA, the genetic determinant for the stringent factor, has been mapped on the B. subtilis chromosome by transduction and is found between aroD and leu.The relC locus, defined by mutations which were originally selected by resistance to thiostrepton, has been mapped adjacent to spoOH in the order cysA, spoOH, relC, rif.Stringent factor and ribosomes are functional for the in vitro synthesis of (p)ppGpp in early stages of sporulation (up to at least 4 h). This contradicts the findings of other laboratories.     

Involvement of the N Terminus of Ribosomal Protein L11 in Regulation of the RelA Protein of Escherichia coli

Amino acid-deprived rplK (previously known as relC) mutants of Escherichia coli cannot activate (p)ppGpp synthetase I (RelA) and consequently exhibit relaxed phenotypes. The rplK gene encodes ribosomal protein L11, suggesting that L11 is involved in regulating the activity of RelA. To investigate the role of L11 in the stringent response, a derivative of rplK encoding L11 lacking the N-terminal 36 amino acids (designated 'L11) was constructed. Bacteria overexpressing 'L11 exhibited a relaxed phenotype, and this was associated with an inhibition of RelA-dependent (p)ppGpp synthesis during amino acid deprivation. In contrast, bacteria overexpressing normal L11 exhibited a typical stringent response. The overexpressed 'L11 was incorporated into ribosomes and had no effect on the ribosome-binding activity of RelA. By several methods (yeast two-hybrid, affinity blotting, and copurification), no direct interaction was observed between the C-terminal ribosome-binding domain of RelA and L11. To determine whether the proline-rich helix of L11 was involved in RelA regulation, the Pro-22 residue was replaced with Leu by site-directed mutagenesis. The overexpression of the Leu-22 mutant derivative of L11 resulted in a relaxed phenotype. These results indicate that the proline-rich helix in the N terminus of L11 is involved in regulating the activity of RelA.     

ELISA analyses of malate dehydrogenases from nonsulfur purple phototrophic bacteria

Abstract The accumulation of ppGpp in three streptococci starved for isoleucine was studied via HPLC analysis of cell extracts prepared from mechanically disrupted bacteria. Starvation was achieved either by reduction of isoleucine in the growth medium or the addition of pseudomonic acid. The results indicate that while both treatments produced a physiological response similar to that described for stringent strains of other bacteria, in the streptococci, stringency was not necessarily coupled with ppGpp.     

Ability of modified forms of phenylalanine tRNA to stimulate guanosine pentaphosphate synthesis by the stringent factor-ribosome complex of E. coli

tRNA(Phe) of E. coli, modified at its 4-thiouridine ((4)Srd) and 3-(3-amino-3-carboxypropyl)uridine (nbt(3)Urd) residues, was tested for its ability to induce (p)ppGpp synthesis. The (4)Srd residue was derivatized with the p-azido-phenacyl group, cross-linked to Cyd(13), and the borohydride reduction product of the cross-link was prepared. The nbt(3)Urd residue was derivatized with the N-(4-azido-2-nitrophenyl)glycyl group. None of these derivatives had more than a minor effect on the affinity of the tRNA for the stringent factor-ribosome complex, and no effect at all on the maximum velocity of (p)ppGpp synthesis, either at 2 or 82 mM NH(4)Cl. These two regions of the tRNA which are on opposite faces of the tRNA molecule do not appear to be structurally important for recognition by the stringent factor-ribosome complex. They may provide useful sites, therefore, for the introduction of photoaffinity or fluorescent probes with which to study tRNA-stringent factor recognition.