Cell cooperation in abolition of tolerance of xenogeneic tumor.

Thymectomized, lethally irradiated mice reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow cells are tolerant to xenogeneic Yoshida ascites sarcoma (YAS). The tolerance was abolished by an injection of syngeneic normal spleen, thymus, or lymph node cells given simultaneously with YAS. Allogeneic and semiallogeneic spleen cells were ineffective. The YAS-rejecting mice produced specific anti-tumor antibodies. The serum of these mice transferred to tolerant T-cell-deficient mice protected the latter from inoculated YAS cells. These serum-protected mice were not able to resist the reinoculum of the tumor cells as the mice restored with lymphoid cells did. The latter mice rejected the YAS at the time when donor cells were practically absent in their lymphoid tissue. The low effective ratio of injected syngeneic lymphoid to tumor cells, efficiency of injected thymus cells, and other data led to the conclusion that transferred lymphoid cells did not act directly on tumor cells but through cooperation with host lymphoid cells. The cooperation of donor T- and host B-lymphocytes enabled the activation of the latter, and YAS cells were rejected.     

Studies of delayed hypersensitivity to L. Monocytogenes in mice: nature of cells involved in passive transfers

C3Hf/Umc mice were immunized by an intravenous injection of a sublethal dose of live Listeria monocytogenes. The animals developed delayed-type hypersensitivity (DH) concomitant with infectious immunity to this organism. Delayed hypersensitivity could be transferred to normal lethally irradiated mice with spleen cells from immune animals. The immune cells cells responsible for transfer of adoptive immunity were susceptible to in vitro cytolytic action of anti-theta iso-antibody and complement, since such treatment rendered these cells incapable of further passive transfer of specific immunity to Listeria. The acquired DH to Listeria persisted in mice after 900 R lethal irradiation, provided normal syngeneic bone marrow cells were also administered, thus indicating the persistance of a cell population in the immune irradiated mice, resistant to effects of radiation. The radio resistant nature of this immune cell population was further demonstrated by passive transfer with spleen cells, derived from preimmunized lethally irradiated mice to normal syngeneic mice or to lethally irradiated nonimmunized hosts reconstituted with normal bone marrow which then responded to antigenic challenge with DH.Treatment of the immune radio resistant spleen cells in vitro with anti-theta and complement eliminated passive transfers of DH by these cells; however, this effect was less obvious than similar treatment of the immune, nonirradiated, spleen cells.     

Properties of reticulum cell sarcomas in SJL/J mice: II. Fate of labeled tumor cells in normal and irradiated syngeneic mice

Transplantable reticulum cell sarcoma (RCS) cells were labeled with ³H-uridine or ³H-thymidine in vitro and injected intravenously into normal and irradiated syngeneic SJL/J mice. RCS cells exhibited typical B cell migration characteristics in peripheral lymphoid organs in both normal and irradiated recipients, localizing in follicles in a pattern resembling that of labeled normal bone marrow cells. However, over the first 72 hr after transfer, RCS cells diluted their label much less in irradiated than in normal recipients, reflecting their inability to proliferate in the irradiated hosts. The presence of unlabeled tumor cells did not significantly affect the distribution of labeled normal bone marrow or lymph node cells in the recipients. Thus, RCS fails to grow in irradiated recipients in spite of undisturbed homing characteristics and in the absence of any evidence of cytotoxic influences from the host.     

Effect of selective T cell depletion of host and/or donor bone marrow on lymphopoietic repopulation, tolerance, and graft-vs-host disease in mixed allogeneic chimeras (B10 + B10.D2----B10)

Reconstitution of lethally irradiated mice with a mixture of T cell-depleted syngeneic plus T cell-depleted allogeneic bone marrow (B10 + B10.D2----B10) leads to the induction of mixed lymphopoietic chimerism, excellent survivals, specific in vivo transplantation tolerance to subsequent donor strain skin grafts, and specific in vitro unresponsiveness to allogeneic donor lymphoid elements as assessed by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) proliferative and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) cytotoxicity assays. When B10 recipient mice received mixed marrow inocula in which the syngeneic component had not been T cell depleted, whether or not the allogeneic donor marrow was treated, they repopulated exclusively with host-type cells, promptly rejected donor-type skin allografts, and were reactive in vitro to the allogeneic donor by CML and MLR assays. In contrast, T cell depletion of the syngeneic component of the mixed marrow inocula resulted in specific acceptance of allogeneic donor strain skin grafts, whether or not the allogeneic bone marrow was T cell depleted. Such animals were specifically unreactive to allogeneic donor lymphoid elements in vitro by CML and MLR, but were reactive to third party. When both the syngeneic and allogeneic marrow were T cell depleted, variable percentages of host- and donor-type lymphoid elements were detected in the mixed reconstituted host. When only the syngeneic bone marrow was T cell depleted, animals repopulated exclusively with donor-type cells. Although these animals had detectable in vitro anti-host (B10) reactivity by CML and MLR and reconstituted as fully allogeneic chimeras, they exhibited excellent survival and had no in vivo evidence for graft-vs-host disease. In addition, experiments in which untreated donor spleen cells were added to the inocula in this last group suggest that the presence of T cell-depleted syngeneic bone marrow cells diminishes graft-vs-host disease and the mortality from it. This system may be helpful as a model for the study of alloresistance and for the identification of syngeneic cell phenotypes, which when present prevent engraftment of allogeneic marrow.     

In vivo natural antitumor resistance against murine EL-4 lymphoma cells in lethally irradiated syngeneic C57Bl/6 mice

Natural resistance has been detected in lethally irradiated C57Bl/6 (B6) mice inoculated intravenously with the ascites form of a syngeneic B6 leukemia. EL-4 cells were injected into lethally irradiated (800 R) B6 mice and tumor cell proliferation was evaluated by 125IUdR uptake in different organs 4 days after the challenge. Differential growth of lymphoma cells was observed when young mice were injected as compared with older mice and when mice were treated with agents known to interfere with natural resistance (e.g., poly(I:C), FLV-P, carrageenan, cyclophosphamide, high doses of irradiated cells). Similar results were obtained by measuring rapid clearance of 125IUdR-labeled EL-4 cells from lungs of intact B6 mice. In vivo cold competition studies, employing EL-4 and several other tumor lines of the same or different haplotype, showed that only EL-4 and RBL-5 cells were capable of inhibiting syngeneic resistance against EL-4 tumor. On the contrary, YAC-1 lymphoma cells, the most susceptible target to natural killer-mediated cytotoxicity in vitro, did not compete. These results suggest that EL-4 cells express membrane determinants not detectable on normal H-2b parental bone marrow cells and are susceptible to natural resistance against hemopoietic tumor cells in lethally irradiated syngeneic B6 mice.     

Autoaggressive immunocompetent cells in the bodies of mice at remote periods following irradiation]

Lethally irradiated DBA/l mice or (C57Bl X DBA/l1 F1 hybrid mice were injected with therapeutically effective doses of isologous bone marrow cells; simultaneously syngeneic lymph node cells from either intact (control) animals or mice survived after sublethal irradiation were transplanted. In control the viability of the recipients was not affected by the presence of lymphoid cells in the mixed transplant. In contrast, the beneficial action of the bone marrow cells was abolished (killing-effect) by the lymphoid cells from mice sacrificed 6 to 12 months after the irradiation (600--700 r). The manifestation of the killing-effect depended on the number of the transplanted lymphoid cells and on the dose of the bone marrow cells in the transplant. The killing-effect was not revealed when the lymphoid cells were obtained from the donors on the 30th day after irradiation. The results suggest the autosensitization of the organism at the late postirradiation periods.     

Inhibition of erythroid cell growth by allogeneic murine lymphocytes. Evidence for a synergism between lymph node cells and thymocytes

Murine lymphoid cells from thymus and lymph nodes were tested for synergistic response in a graft-vs-host test. The test is based on the principle that allogeneic lymphocytes inhibit erythroid cell proliferation in the spleens of irradiated mice infused with syngeneic bone marrow cells.I was observed that mixtures of thymocytes and lymph node cells from the same parental strain yielded graft-vs-host responses in irradiated F₁-hybrids higher than expected by summing the responses of the two cell populations tested separately. A similar synergistic response was obtained using mixtures of thymocytes and lymph node cells obtained from the two parental strains of the hybrid, whereas such an effect was not detected using mixtures of lymph node cells or mixtures of thymocytes from the two parental strains. Nor could synergy be demonstrated between parental strain lymph node cells and thymocytes syngeneic with the bone marrow target cells. Thymocytes obtained from one parental strain which were injected into its irradiated F₁-hybrid transformed into a population of sensitized cells in the spleens of the recipients. This transformation was suppressed by the simultaneous injection of lymph node cells from the second parental strain. Since there is a synergistic immune response by such cell mixtures it is concluded that thymocytes may enhance the graft-vs-host response of lymph node cells. Parental strain thymocytes and lymph node cells, the latter being specifically immunologically tolerant to the bone marrow target cells, failed to give a synergistic response indicating that thymocytes do not transform unresponsive lymphocytes into responsive, but rather enhance the reactivity of existing, specifically responsive cells.The results thus show that thymocytes may enhance the response of lymph node cells in this specific graft-vs-host assay.     

Papers to appear in forthcoming issues

Tolerance to the TNP haptenic determinant was induced by a single intravenous injection of trinitrophenylated syngeneic cells. Syngeneic spleen or thymus cells were capable of acting as carriers for tolerance induction while syngeneic bone marrow cells were not. Syngeneic spleen cells depleted of θ-positive and adherent cells were also suitable carriers for tolerance induction. Sonicated haptenated spleen cells, but not sonicated haptenated bone marrow cells induced tolerance. The ability of haptenated cells to induce tolerance was not correlated with their localization in lymphoid organs. Furthermore, cells recovered from the spleens of lethally irradiated animals reconstituted with bone marrow cells 1 week previously were incapable of inducing tolerance after hapten-modification. However, after 3 weeks, spleen cells from bone marrow-reconstituted mice had acquired the ability to induce tolerance. These results suggest that only certain types of syngeneic cells have the ability to act as carriers for tolerance induction; merely being syngeneic, and therefore presumably nonimmunogenic, is not sufficient to permit the cell to act as a carrier for tolerance induction.     

Studies on the recovery from tolerance to tumor antigens

Summary The present study investigates the potential of bone marrow cells from mice tolerant to tumor antigens to repopulate tumor-specific effector T cells. C3H/He mice were inoculated i.v. with 10⁶ 10000 R X-irradiated syngeneic X5563 plasmacytoma tumor cells three times at 4-day intervals. This regimen abrogated the ability of spleen cells from these mice to develop anti-X5563 cytotoxic and in vivo protective (tumor-neutralizing) T cell-mediated immunity as induced by i.d. inoculation of viable X5563 cells followed by surgical resection of the tumor. Since such suppression was induced in a tumor-specific way, this represented a state of antitumor tolerance. When bone marrow cells from normal or X5563-tolerant mice were transferred i.v. into 950 R X-irradiated syngeneic C3H/He mice, both groups of recipient mice generated anti-X5563 tumor immunity over a similar time course and to almost the same degree. Anti-X5563 tumor immunity induced in (C3H/He×C57BL/6) F1 mice which had been transferred with bone marrow cells from normal or X5563-tolerant C3H/He mice were mediated by T cells expressing the Ly phenotype of C3H/He, but not of C57BL/6, excluding the possibility that the antitumor effector cells were derived from recipient mice. It was also demonstrated that C3H/He mice which had been reconstituted with normal marrow were rendered tolerant when the tolerance regimen was started 7 weeks, but not 1 week after the bone marrow reconstitution. These results indicate that bone marrow cells from antitumor tolerant mice are not rendered tolerant to the tumor but can provide the potential to repopulate antitumor CTL and in vivo protective effector T cells.This work was supported by the Special Project Cancer-Bioscience from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan Abbreviations used: MHC, major histocompatibility complex; CTL, cytotoxic T lymphocytes; TNP, trinitrophenyl; C, complement; TNBS; trinitrobenzene sulfonate; MMC, mitomycin C     

Suppressive Effect by Cooperation of Splenic and Peritoneal Adherent Cells on Generation of Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes

When spleen cells primed in vivo against allogeneic lymphoid cells were used as responder cells in secondary mixed lymphocyte cultures, a high degree of cytotoxicity was generated even in the absence of splenic adherent cells. However, removal of adherent cells from such primed responder spleen cells reduced the cytotoxicity to some extent. On the other hand, when these responder cells were transferred into the peritoneal cavity of irradiated syngeneic mice together with antigenic cells, unseparated responder cells generated a lower degree of cytotoxicity than did adherent cell-depleted responder cells. In an in vitro system, peritoneal adherent cells also suppressed the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes by unseparated responders; however they augmented the cytotoxic T lymphocyte generation by adherent cell-depleted responders. These adherent cell populations with augmenting activity became inhibitory when they coexisted. The mechanism of this inhibitory action remains unclear.     

Regulation of cell-mediated cytotoxicity. II. Synergism of two types of thymus dependent cells in vivo.

Sublethal (500 rads) doses of radiation given to mice before the intravenous injection of allogeneic spleen cells induced the development of an increased cell-mediated cytotoxicity (CMC) of the recipients' spleen cells. The effector cells from the irradiated animals were shown to carry the θ alloantigenic marker and to be capable of transferring adoptive immunity in vivo. On the other hand, irradiation of mice with the same dose before the administration of skin or tumor allografts induced a suppression of CMC. The response of irradiated mice treated with tumor allografts was restored with small numbers of spleen or lymph node cells from syngeneic or semi-allogeneic F₁ hybrid donors. With the use of the appropriate cytotoxic alloantisera, it was demonstrated that the majority of the effector cells generated in the spleens of mice restored with semiallogeneic cells were of host origin. These results demonstrate that the precursors of the cytotoxic lymphocytes are radioresistant and indicate that for their stimulation some radiosensitive T cells are necessary to amplify their reaction to nonlymphoid allografts. Allogeneic lymphoid cells, on the other hand, supply a stimulus which does not require the intervention of such amplifier cells. In this case, irradiation induces a stronger CMC response probably by inactivating radiosensitive cells with suppressor activity.     

Mitogenic factor from inbred guinea pigs. II. Properties of the factor

Thymectomized adult rats which have been heavily irradiated and reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow cells rapidly regain the ability to defend themselves against a primary infection with the intracellular bacterial parasite, Listeria monocytogenes. They do so by a cell-mediated immunological mechanism as evidenced by the protective immunity transferred adoptively by thoracic duct lymphocytes or peritoneal exudate cells from donors infected with this organism. But peritoneal exudate cells from thymus-derived donors convey only a fraction of the immunity transmitted by exudate cells from similarly infected intact rats. Since thymectomized irradiated animals can mobilize their cellular defenses more effectively when they are injected with a modest number of thoracic duct lymphocytes, an effect that cannot be duplicated with a massive infusion of bone marrow, it is argued that thymusdependent lymphocytes or T cells have an influential role in the development of cellular resistance to infection.     

Expression of a 16,000 molecular weight antigen on human suppressor T lymphocytes

When SJL mice are irradiated and reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow (XBM) they support growth of transplantable reticulum cell sarcoma to approximately 60% of that in normal mice. The ability to support RCS growth gradually improves with time after irradiation and reaches 90% of normal by 8–12 weeks. However, if the mice are thymectomized 4 weeks prior to treatment (Tx-XBM) they initially show 50% which increases to only 65% of growth in normal mice after 12 weeks. The ability of lymphoid cells from these mice to proliferate in vitro in response to irradiated RCS cells is normal 4 weeks after treatment in XBM, but remains <10% of normal in Tx-XBM mice. Nude mice of SJL background also show greatly diminished RCS growth. It is concluded that T cells promote RCS growth in vivo possibly via their tendency to proliferate upon exposure to RCS.     

Full reconstitution of the immune deficiency in scid mice with normal stem cells requires low-dose irradiation of the recipients

Mice homozygous for an autosomal recessive mutation for the scid gene exhibit a defect that specifically impairs lymphoid differentiation but not myelopoiesis. Such mice can be cured of their lymphoid deficiency by grafts with normal bone marrow, although full reconstitution of lymphoid function is seldom obtained. Long-term bone marrow cultures (LTBMC) are devoid of all mature B and pre-B cells but contain lymphoid stem cells. We therefore reconstituted scid mice with LTBMC cells to study the kinetics of B lymphocyte reconstitution in normal and irradiated (4 Gy) scid recipients and in irradiated (9.5 Gy) co-isogenic C.B-17 mice. Detectable colony-forming B cells rapidly increased in the spleen and bone marrow of irradiated C.B-17 and irradiated scid recipients, reaching normal levels between 4 and 6 wk post-grafting. Unirradiated scid recipients showed limited reconstitution in spleen and very poor reconstitution in bone marrow. Unirradiated scid recipients also had relatively few surface Ig+ cells in spleen or bone marrow, whereas both groups of irradiated recipients had normal numbers between 4 and 6 wk post-reconstitution. Normal levels of cytotoxic T cell activity by 8 wk after reconstitution were observed only in the irradiated C.B-17 and irradiated scid recipients. Analysis of mice reconstituted with cells from LTBMC indicates that these cultures contain lymphoid stem cells with significant proliferative and self-renewal potential, and that full reconstitution of lymphoid function requires prior irradiation of the scid recipient.     

Effect of tumor immunity on the distribution of labeled lymphoid cells in tumor-challenged mice

The distribution of ⁵¹Cr-labeled lymphoid cells from normal mice and mice immunized against a tumor were compared after intravenous inoculation of the labeled cells into normal syngeneic recipients. Spleen cell preparations from immune donors contained increased percentages of spleen and bone marrow-seeking cells, thus suggesting expansion of these cell populations when immunity to a tumor exists. Homing of labeled normal cells in tumor cell-injected normal animals was somewhat different from that seen in tumor cell-inoculated mice that were immunized against the tumor. In the latter case, accumulations of lymph node and spleen cells in recipient lymph nodes and bone marrow were consistently lower. In contrast, lymphoid cells from animals immunized against the tumor were found to accumulate in virtually the same percentages in lymphoid organs of normal and immune recipients. The behavior of lymphoid cell populations from thymus or bone marrow that consist mainly of precursor cells was unaffected by presence of malignancy and/or tumor immunity.     

Regulation of the in vitro anamnestic antibody response by cyclic AMP. II. Antigen-dependent enhancement by exogenous prostaglandins of the E series.

The spleen cells from CFW/D mice injected with dimethylbenzanthracene-induced leukemia virus exhibited a progressive decline in the in vitro response to heterologous erythrocyte antigens in parallel with tumor growth. Cell transfer experiments revealed that this immunodepressed state may involve a B-cell defect rather than extrinsic factors in the cellular environment since: (i) nonresponsiveness could be transferred to irradiated non-tumor-bearing mice with spleen cells, and (ii) T cells from tumorbearing mice cooperated with normal bone marrow cells, but bone marrow from tumorbearing mice did not cooperate with normal T cells. In addition, T cells from the thymic tumor could cooperate with normal bone marrow cells upon transfer to irradiated recipients. TL 485-2 cells, a T-cell line derived from the tumor, could be specifically activated with SRBC thereby indicating that the virus transformed T cells were immunocompetent. Suppressor cells, which appeared in the spleen concomitant with immunodepression and tumor development, may directly raise B-cell thresholds for T-dependent triggering signals since the antibody response of spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice could be restored by adding agents such as LPS, 2 mercaptoethanol, or T cells exogenously preactivated in normal animals. The suppressor cell could be enriched by adherence to plastic and was removed by treatment with carbonyl iron. In addition, it was unlikely that the suppressor cell was a virus-infected cell since transformed, virus-infected cells from the tumor or TL 485-2 cells were not suppressive when added to spleen cells in vitro but rather resulted in a marked, polyclonal enhancement of the PFC response. The interaction of TL 485-2 cells and normal spleen cells resulted in the release of a stimulatory factor which increased DNA synthesis in resting cells as well as increasing PFC. The role of these enhancing factors and suppressor cells in controlling tumor growth remains to be elucidated.     

A bicellular mechanism in the immune response to chemically defined antigens. 3. Interaction of thymus and bone marrow-derived cells

The role of thymus and bone marrow-derived cells in the in vitro response to the dinitrophenyl (DNP) determinant was studied using the millipore filter well technique for spleen organ cultures. Antibodies to DNP were assayed by the technique of inactivation of DNP-coupled T-4 bacteriophage. It was found that spleens of mice total-body irradiated at 750 R, treated with bone marrow and thymus cells after exposure and immunized against rabbit serum albumin (RSA) were able to produce antibodies to DNP when challenged in vitro with DNP-RSA. Such a response was not produced by spleen explants from x-irradiated mice treated with either thymus or bone marrow cells. Neither were antibodies to DNP produced by spleens of animals repopulated with thymus and bone marrow cells, but not immunized with the carrier. This carrier effect was manifested when the irradiated mice were treated with RSA and thymus cells 6–8 days before administration of the bone marrow cells. Yet, such an effect was not observed when the RSA and bone marrow cells were given 6–8 days before injection of the thymus cells. Thus, the thymus-derived cells appear to play the role of cells sensitive to the carrier (RSA), whereas the bone marrow seems to be involved in the production of antibodies.     

Lack of relationship of transplantation immunogenicity in C3H/He mammary carcinomas,with lymphoid hyperplasia and radiation-induced growth enhancement

Summary The therapeutic use of (a) radiation-inactivated tumor cells, (b) Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG), and (c) heparinized plasma from normal mice to reduce radiation-induced impairment of existing antitumor resistance was investigated in female C3H/He hosts of syngeneic mammary carcinoma implants. The mice, which had been moderately presensitized 50 days before challenge, were given 300 rad whole-body irradiation at various times up to the day of challenge and 3 days after. Irradiated presensitized and irradiated unsensitized animals were maximally immunodepressed 1–2 weeks after exposure. The levels of resistance seen in unirradiated presensitized and in unirradiated unsensitized controls were recovered by irradiated presensitized and by irradiated unsensitized mice in about 3 and 4 weeks, respectively. Repeated injections of radiation-inactivated tumor cells were most effective in supporting the immune status of irradiated mice and in promoting an early recovery. Injections of BCG had only an insignificant effect. Injections of normal plasma was effective in reducing the immune suppression but did not promote an earlier recovery.     

Thymus dependency of cells involved in transfer of delayed hypersensitivity to listeria monocytogenes in mice

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DH) to Listeria antigens was induced in inbred C3Hf/Umc mice by intravenous injection of a sublethal dose of viable Listeria monocytogenes. Bone marrow, spleen, and lymph node cells from the immune mice were capable of passive transfer of DH to syngeneic neonatally thymectomized or lethally (900 R) irradiated recipients. Immune thymus cells as well as immune serum were ineffective in transferring DH to irradiated animals. In vitro treatment with antitheta isoantibody (anti-θ) and complement abolished the capacity of spleen and bone marrow cells from immune donors to transfer DH to irradiated hosts, indicating the thymus dependency of this cell population. The results with bone marrow indicate the existence of a small, but biologically significant, thymus-dependent population in this tissue.     

Radiation-induced alterations in murine lymphocyte homing patterns: I. Radiolabeling studies

In vitro X-irradiation of ⁵¹Cr-labeled spleen, lymph node, bone marrow, or thymus cells was found to alter their subsequent in vivo distribution significantly in syngeneic BDF₁ mice. Irradiated cells demonstrated an increased distribution to the liver and a significantly lower retention in the lungs. Cells going to the lymph nodes or Peyer's patches showed a significant exposure-dependent decrease in homing following irradiation. Irradiated lymph node cells homed in greater numbers to the spleen and bone marrow, while irradiated cells from other sources showed no preferential distribution to the same tissues. Sampling host tissues at various times after irradiation and injection did not demonstrate any return to normal patterns of distribution. The alterations in lymphocyte homing observed after in vitro irradiation appear to be due to the elimination of a selective population of lymphocytes or membrane alterations of viable cells, and the detection of these homing changes is in turn dependent upon the relative numbers of various lymphoid subpopulations which are obtained from different cell sources. Radiation-induced alterations in the normal homing patterns of lymphoid cells may thus be of considerable importance in the evaluation of subsequent functional assays in recipient animals.