COLD TOLERANCE OF MICROARTHROPODS

1. Microarthropods (Acari and Collembola) are dominant components of the terrestrial fauna in the Antarctic. Their cold tolerance, which forms the mainspring of their adaptational strategy, is reviewed against a background of their structure and function, and by comparison with other arthropods. 2. Two species, the isotomid collembolan Cryptopygus antarcticus Willem and the oribatid mite Alaskozetes antarcticus (Michael), are examined in detail, and afford a comparative approach to the mechanisms underlying cold tolerance in insect and arachnid types. 3. All microarthropods appear to be freezing-susceptible (unable to tolerate tissue ice), and they utilize varying levels of supercooling to avoid freezing. Gut contents are considered to be the prime nucleation site in most arthropods when supercooled, particularly for Antarctic species. Moulting also increases individual supercooling ability especially in Collembola, and the activity of ice-nucleating bacteria in cold-hardy arthropods may be important. 4. Sources of ice nucleators are many and varied, originating externally (motes) or internally (ice-nucleating agents). They act either extracellularly (mainly in the haemolymph) to promote freezing in ice-tolerant life stages, or intracellularly in freezing-susceptible forms. Thermal hysteresis proteins, acting colligatively, occur in many arthropods including Collembola; they depress both the freezing point of body fluids and the whole-body supercooling point of freezing- susceptible and freezing-tolerant species. 5. Bimodal supercooling point distributions are a feature of microarthropods and water droplets. Samples of field populations of Antarctic mites and springtails show significant seasonal changes in these distributions, which in some respects are analogous to purely physical systems of water droplets. Supercooling points are confirmed as accurate measures of cold-hardiness and survival for Antarctic species, but not necessarily for other arthropods. The effects of constant sub-zero temperatures approaching the limit of the supercooling ability of arthropods require study. 6. Desiccation and dehydration influence microarthropod physiology in several ways; in Alaskozetes it triggers glycerol synthesis. Glycerol may aid binding of water in severely dehydrated insects, but the relationship of such ‘bound’ water to cold-hardiness is unclear. 7. Sugar alcohols (polyols) and sugars are accumulated as potential cryoprotectants in many arthropods at low temperatures, and antifreeze systems may be single or multi-component in structure. Cryoprotectant synthesis and regulation have been studied principally in insects, and fresh weight concentrations of 0–3-5 M of polyols have been found. Trehalose accumulation may also influence cold-hardiness. 8. Microarthropods fall within the spectrum of cold tolerance observed for arthropods and other invertebrates. No special adaptations are found in Antarctic species, and similar strategies and mechanisms are present in both insects and arachnids. The colonization and maintenance of microarthropod populations of polar land habitats seem not to have required the evolution of any novel features with respect to cold tolerance.     

Role of silicon in enhancing resistance to freezing stress in two contrasting winter wheat cultivars

The main objective of this study was to elucidate the roles of silicon (Si) in enhancing tolerance to freezing stress (?5 °C) in two contrasting wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivars: i.e. cv. Yangmai No. 5, a freezing-susceptible cultivar and cv. Linmai No. 2, a freezing-tolerant cultivar. Shoot dry weight of the freezing-susceptible wheat was significantly lower under freezing stress than in controls, but increased significantly with Si amendment. The freezing treatment did not affect shoot dry weight of the freezing-tolerant cultivar. The leaf water content was considerably decreased by freezing stress in the freezing-susceptible cultivar, but was significantly increased by Si amendment. In contrast, freezing treatment did not significantly reduce leaf water content in the freezing-tolerant cultivar and Si played no role in water retention in this cultivar. The concentrations of H₂O₂ and free proline along with malondialdehyde (MDA) were progressively enhanced by freezing stress in the two wheat cultivars used, but were significantly suppressed by amendment with Si. The major antioxidant enzyme activities and non-enzymatic antioxidants (i.e. glutathione and ascorbic acid) in the leaves of freezing-stressed plants were decreased, but were stimulated significantly by the exogenous Si. The possible mechanisms for Si-enhanced freezing stress may be attributed to the higher antioxidant defense activity and lower lipid peroxidation through water retention in leaf tissues.     

Arabidopsis thaliana avoids freezing by supercooling

Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. has been described as a freezing-tolerant species based on freezing-resistance assays. Nonetheless, this type of experiment does not discriminate between freezing-tolerance and freezing-avoidance mechanisms. The purpose of this paper was to determine which of these two freezing-resistance mechanisms is responsible for freezing resistance in A. thaliana. This was achieved by comparing the thermal properties (ice-nucleation temperature and the freezing temperature) of leaves and the lethal temperature to 10, 50 and 90% of the plants (LT10, LT50, and LT90, respectively). Two wild-type genotypes were used (Columbia and Ler) and their mutants (esk-1 and frs-1, respectively), which differ in their freezing resistance. This study's results indicated that the mutant esk-1, described as a freezing-tolerant species showed freezing tolerance only after a cold-acclimation period. The mutant frs-1, described as freezing sensitive, presented freezing avoidance. Both wild genotypes presented LT50 similar to or higher than the ice-nucleation temperature. Thus, the main freezing-resistance mechanism for A. thaliana is avoidance of freezing by supercooling. No injury of the photosynthetic apparatus was shown by measuring the maximal photochemical efficiency (Fv/Fm) and pigments (chlorophyll and carotenoid) during cold acclimation in all genotypes. During cold acclimation, Columbia and esk-1 increased total soluble carbohydrates in leaves. esk-1 was the only genotype that presented freezing tolerance after cold acclimation. This feature could be related to an increase in sugar accumulation in the apoplast.     

A molecular marker to select for freezing tolerance in Gramineae

Summary We isolated, and expressed in Escherichia coli, a gene (Wcs120) that is strongly induced during cold acclimation of wheat. The gene product was purified and used to produce antibodies. Immunoblotting experiments with the anti-WCS120 antibody identified several cold-induced proteins named FTMs for Freezing Tolerance Markers since they are associated with the development of freezing tolerance. This protein family was found to be coordinately regulated specifically by low temperature, highly hydrophilic, stable to boiling, and to have a pI above 6.5. The accumulation kinetics during the acclimation period indicated a positive correlation with the capacity of each genotype to develop freezing tolerance. Accumulation of the proteins was higher in the freezing-tolerant genotype than in the less tolerant one. In addition, their accumulation was more pronounced in the crown and leaf tissues compared with roots, confirming a relationship to the capacity of the different tissues to develop freezing tolerance. Analysis of different species (eight monocots and four dicots) indicated that this protein family is specific for freezing-tolerant cereals. The antibody did not cross-react with any of the non-cereal species examined. The anti-FTMs antibody represents a potential tool for breeders to select for freezing tolerance traits in the Gramineae.     

Differentiation of freezing tolerance and vernalization responses in Cruciferae exposed to a low temperature

High levels of freezing tolerance were induced in leaves of different Cruciferae species including Brassica napus, Arabidopsis thaliana, Barbarea vulgaris, Thlaspi arvenses and Descurainia sophia by low-temperature acclimation. Concomitantly, the amount of total RNA doubled in these three species. Analyses of methylation patterns and dosage of rRNA genes were carried out to determine whether or not alterations occur in this DNA during development of freezing tolerance. Hybridizations of Southern transfers with an rDNA probe revealed two additional EcoRI sites in purified DNA isolated from freezing-tolerant leaves of winter B. napus cv Jet Neuf and D. sophia (both of which require low temperatures for vernalization), but not in isolates of A. thaliana or spring B. napus cv Topas. An increase of rDNA cistrons was also observed in both B. napus cv Jet Neuf and D. sophia but not in A. thaliana or B. napus cv Topas upon cold acclimation. These results suggest that low temperature induced amplification of rDNA and the differential methylation of EcoRI sites may possibly be related to the vernalization process but may not be related to the development of freezing tolerance. However, the higher activity of RNA polymerase (2.5 times more) observed upon cold acclimation may explain the concomitant increase in total RNA and may be related to the development of freezing tolerance in the Cruciferae.     

Freezing tolerance, cold acclimation and oxidative stress in potato. Paraquat tolerance is related to acclimation but is a poor indicator of freezing tolerance

Potato is a species commonly cultivated in temperate areas where the growing season may be interrupted by frosts, resulting in loss of yield. Cultivated potato, Solanum tuberosum, is freezing sensitive, but it has several freezing-tolerant wild potato relatives, one of which is S. commersonii. Our study was aimed to resolve the relationship between enhanced freezing tolerance, acclimation capacity and capacity to tolerate active oxygen species. To be able to characterize freezing tolerant ideotypes, a potato population (S1), which segregates in freezing tolerance, acclimation capacity and capacity to tolerate superoxide radicals, was produced by selfing a somatic hybrid between a freezing-tolerant Solanum commersonii (LT₅₀=-4.6°C) and -sensitive S. tuberosum (LT₅₀=-3.0°C). The distribution of non-acclimated freezing tolerance (NA-freezing tolerance) of the S1 population varied between the parental lines and we were able to identify genotypes, having significantly high or low NA-freezing tolerance. When a population of 25 genotypes was tested both for NA-freezing and paraquat (PQ) tolerance, no correlation was found between these two traits (R = 0.02). However, the most NA-freezing tolerant genotypes were also among the most PQ tolerant plants. Simultaneously, one of the NA-freezing sensitive genotypes (2022) (LT₅₀=-3.0°C) was observed to be PQ tolerant. These conflicting results may reflect a significant, but not obligatory, role of superoxide scavenging mechanisms in the NA-freezing tolerance of S. commersonii. The freezing tolerance after cold acclimation (CA-freezing tolerance) and the acclimation capacity (AC) was measured after acclimation for 7 days at 4/2°C. Lack of correlation between NA-freezing tolerance and AC (R =-0.05) in the S1 population points to independent genetic control of NA-freezing tolerance and AC in Solanum sp. Increased freezing tolerance after cold acclimation was clearly related to PQ tolerance of all S1 genotypes, especially those having good acclimation capacity. The rapid loss of improved PQ tolerance under deacclimation conditions confirmed the close relationship between the process of cold acclimation and enhanced PQ tolerance. Here, we report an increased PQ tolerance in cold-acclimated plants compared to non-acclimated controls. However, we concluded that high PQ tolerance is not a good indicator of actual freezing tolerance and should not be used as a selectable marker for the identification of a freezing-tolerant genotype.     

Expression of freezing tolerance in the interspecific F1 and somatic hybrids of potatoes

 The expression of freezing tolerance was examined in interspecific F₁ and somatic hybrids of potatoes using 20 species and 34 different combinations between hardy and sensitive species. In the field, the frost tolerance of hybrids resembled either that of the hardy parent, the sensitive parent, or the parental mean, depending on the species combination and the genomic ratio (ratio of the number of sets of chromosomes contributed from each parent). Similar phenomena were observed when the non-acclimated freezing tolerance (NA) and the acclimation capacity (ACC) (two independent genetic components of freezing tolerance) were evaluated separately under controlled environments. In general, the expression level of freezing tolerance was higher in hybrids with more genomes contributed from the hardy parent than from the sensitive parent. In addition, the effectiveness or combining ability of genes conferring freezing tolerance from the hardy species also showed some influence on the expression of freezing tolerance. All three parameters, namely NA, ACC and acclimated freezing tolerance (AA) (NA plus ACC), were significantly correlated to the frost tolerance exhibited in the field. This indicates that the controlled freezing test used in this study could provide a good estimate of field performance. The implications of these results in breeding for freezing tolerance in potatoes are discussed. Received: 21 July 1998 / Accepted: 29 September 1998     

The genetic architecture of freezing tolerance varies across the range of Arabidopsis thaliana

The capacity to tolerate freezing temperatures limits the geographical distribution of many plants, including several species of agricultural importance. However, the genes involved in freezing tolerance remain largely unknown. Here, we describe the variation in constitutive freezing tolerance that occurs among worldwide accessions of Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that although plants from high latitudes tend to be more freezing tolerant than plants from low latitudes, the environmental factors that shape cold adaptation differ across the species range. Consistent with this, we found that the genetic architecture of freezing tolerance also differs across its range. Conventional genome‐wide association studies helped identify a priori and other promising candidate genes. However, simultaneously modelling climate variables and freezing tolerance together pinpointed other excellent a priori candidate genes. This suggests that if the selective factor underlying phenotypic variation is known, multi‐trait mixed models may aid in identifying the genes that underlie adaptation.     

Clinal variation in freezing tolerance among natural accessions of Arabidopsis thaliana

Low temperature represents a form of abiotic stress that varies predictably with latitude and altitude and to which organisms have evolved multiple physiological responses. Plants provide an especially useful experimental system for investigating the ecological and evolutionary dynamics of tolerance to low temperature because of their sessile lifestyle and inability to escape ambient atmospheric conditions. Here, intraspecific variation in freezing tolerance was investigated in Arabidopsis thaliana by conducting freezing tolerance assays on 71 accessions collected from across the native range of the species. Assays were performed at multiple minimum temperatures and on both cold-acclimated and non-cold-acclimated individuals. Considerable variation in freezing tolerance was observed among accessions both with and without a prior cold-acclimation treatment, suggesting that differences among accessions in cold-acclimation capacity as well as differences in intrinsic physiology contribute to variation in this phenotype. A highly significant positive relationship was observed between freezing tolerance and latitude of origin of accessions, consistent with a major role for natural selection in shaping variation in this phenotype. Clinal variation in freezing tolerance in A. thaliana coupled with considerable knowledge of the underlying genetics and physiology of this phenotype should allow evolutionary genetic analysis at multiple levels.     

Differential resistance to freezing and spatial distribution in a chemically polymorphic plant Thymus vulgaris

Secondary compounds play multiple ecological roles. In this study, we present novel experimental evidence of differential tolerance to freezing temperatures among chemotypes of a chemically polymorphic plant, Thymus vulgaris. Non‐phenolic chemotypes showed a significantly better survival and re‐growth after early‐winter freezing (?10° in early December) than phenolic chemotypes. Comparison of temperature data (1971–2002) at a phenolic and non‐phenolic site showed that whereas early‐winter freezing occurred in 6 years in the non‐phenolic site they never occurred at the phenolic site. Observations of trichome morphology (where the essential oil is stocked) with and without intense freezing indicate that non‐phenolic chemotypes may escape any negative effects of freezing by releasing their essential oil into the atmosphere during severe freezing. The correlation between tolerance of freezing and local temperature regimes strongly suggests that differential freezing resistance is a key ingredient of the distribution of thyme chemotypes in space.     

Mechanisms of cryoprotection in freezing tolerant animal systems

The theoretical mechanisms of freezing protection afforded by the natural occurrence of glycerol in an adult, freezing-tolerant insect have been considered in light of recent findings. While unequivocal identification of the specific site or sites of action of glycerol is yet obscured in a maze of interactions, it is apparent that a multicellular system (organism) that naturally possesses glycerol in high, nonlethal concentrations, that can maintain activity in the presence of tissue ice, that can survive frequent and prolonged freeze-thaw encounters, and finally, that can regulate cryoprotectant levels in the presence of changing environmental conditions should be a major focus of future studies.The carabid beetle, Pterostichus brevicornis has been found to regulate glycerol levels in response to fluctuating ambient temperatures even while frozen. Hemolymph freezing points and whole-body supercooling points correlated well with changes in glycerol. Freezing and supercooling points decreased 0.9 ° C per 4 g/100 ml increase in glycerol.An interpretation of the data accumulated on insect studies and integrated with data from other multicellular systems supports the theory that a single site of freezing concept as applied to considerations of cryoprotection and cryoinjury may not be realistic. Each level of events occurring during the freezing process in glycerolated and nonglycerolated animal systems has been discussed. There appears little room for speculative separation and isolation of the site of action for the events of freezing (and thawing) represent a continuum with changes in each parameter directly dependent upon the entire sequence.     

Environmental regulation and physiological basis of freezing tolerance in woody plants

Cold acclimation of plants is a complex process involving a number of biochemical and physiological changes. The ability to cold acclimate is under genetic control. The development of freezing tolerance in woody plants is generally triggered by non-freezing low temperatures but can also be induced by mild drought or exogenous abscisic acid, as well as by short photoperiod. In nature, the extreme freezing tolerance of woody plants is achieved during sequential stages of cold acclimation the first of which is initiated by short photoperiods and non-freezing low temperatures, and the second by freezing temperatures. Although recent breakthroughs have increased our knowledge on the physiological molecular basis of freezing tolerance in herbaceous species, which acclimate primarily in response to non-freezing low temperatures, very little is known about cold acclimation of woody plants. This article attempts to review our current understanding of the physiological aspects that underline cold acclimation in woody plants.     

Cytosolic proline is required for basal freezing tolerance in Arabidopsis

The amino acid proline accumulates in many plant species under abiotic stress conditions, and various protective functions have been proposed. During cold stress, however, proline content in Arabidopsis thaliana does not correlate with freezing tolerance. Freezing sensitivity of a starchless plastidic phosphoglucomutase mutant (pgm) indicated that localization of proline in the cytosol might stabilize the plasma membrane during freeze–thaw events. Here, we show that re-allocation of proline from cytosol to vacuole was similar in the pyrroline-5-carboxylate synthase 2–1 (p5cs2–1) mutant and the pgm mutant and caused similar reduction of basal freezing tolerance. In contrast, the starch excess 1–1 mutant (sex1-1) had even lower freezing tolerance than pgm but did not affect sub-cellular localization of proline. Freezing sensitivity of sex1-1 mutants affected primarily the photosynthetic electron transport and was enhanced in a sex1-1::p5cs2–1 double mutant. These findings indicate that several independent factors determine basal freezing tolerance. In a pgm::p5cs2–1 double mutant, freezing sensitivity and proline allocation to the vacuole were the same as in the parental lines, indicating that the lack of cytosolic proline was the common cause of reduced basal freezing tolerance in both mutants. We conclude that cytosolic proline is an important factor in freezing tolerance of non-acclimated plants.     

Expression of a cold-responsive Lt-Cor gene and development of freezing tolerance during cold acclimation in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.).

Time-courses of the development of freezing tolerance and the expression of a cold-responsive gene wlt10 were monitored during cold acclimation in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Bioassay showed that cold acclimation conferred much higher freezing tolerance on a winter cultivar than a spring cultivar. Northern blot analysis showed that the expression of wlt10 encoding a novel wheat member of a cereal-specific LT-COR protein family was specifically induced by low temperature. A freezing-tolerant winter cultivar accumulated the mRNA more rapidly and for a longer period than a susceptible spring cultivar. The increase in the amount of mRNA was temporary but the peak occurred at the time when the maximum level of freezing tolerance was attained. The mRNA accumulated more in the leaves than in the roots, and different light/dark regimes modulated the level of mRNA accumulation. Genomic Southern blot analyses using the nulli-tetrasomic series showed that the wlt10 homologues were located on the homologous group 2 chromosomes.     

QTL mapping of freezing tolerance: links to fitness and adaptive trade‐offs

Local adaptation, defined as higher fitness of local vs. nonlocal genotypes, is commonly identified in reciprocal transplant experiments. Reciprocally adapted populations display fitness trade‐offs across environments, but little is known about the traits and genes underlying fitness trade‐offs in reciprocally adapted populations. We investigated the genetic basis and adaptive significance of freezing tolerance using locally adapted populations of Arabidopsis thaliana from Italy and Sweden. Previous reciprocal transplant studies of these populations indicated that subfreezing temperature is a major selective agent in Sweden. We used quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping to identify the contribution of freezing tolerance to previously demonstrated local adaptation and genetic trade‐offs. First, we compared the genomic locations of freezing tolerance QTL to those for previously published QTL for survival in Sweden, and overall fitness in the field. Then, we estimated the contributions to survival and fitness across both field sites of genotypes at locally adaptive freezing tolerance QTL. In growth chamber studies, we found seven QTL for freezing tolerance, and the Swedish genotype increased freezing tolerance for five of these QTL. Three of these colocalized with locally adaptive survival QTL in Sweden and with trade‐off QTL for overall fitness. Two freezing tolerance QTL contribute to genetic trade‐offs across environments for both survival and overall fitness. A major regulator of freezing tolerance, CBF2, is implicated as a candidate gene for one of the trade‐off freezing tolerance QTL. Our study provides some of the first evidence of a trait and gene that mediate a fitness trade‐off in nature.