The evolutionary rate of duplicated genes under concerted evolution

The effect of directional selection on the fixation process of a single mutation that spreads in a multigene family by gene conversion is investigated. A simple two-locus model with two alleles, A and a, is first considered in a random-mating diploid population with size N. There are four haplotypes, AA, Aa, aA, and aa, and selection works on the number of alleles A in a diplod (i = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4). Because gene conversion is allowed between the two loci, when the mutation rate is very low, either AA or aa will fix in the population eventually. We consider a situation where a single mutant, A, arises in one locus when a is fixed in both loci. Then, we derive the fixation probability analytically, and the fixation time is investigated by simulations. It is found that gene conversion has an effect to increase the "effective" population size, so that weak selection works more efficiently in a multigene family. With these results, we discuss the effect of gene conversion on the rate of molecular evolution in a multigene family undergoing concerted evolution. We also argue about the applicability of the theoretical results to models of multigene families with more than two loci.     

The evolution of hexapod engrailed-family genes: evidence for conservation and concerted evolution

Phylogenetic analyses imply that multiple engrailed-family gene duplications occurred during hexapod evolution, a view supported by previous reports of only a single engrailed-family gene in members of the grasshopper genus Schistocerca and in the beetle Tribolium castaneum. Here, we report the cloning of a second engrailed-family gene from Schistocerca gregaria and present evidence for two engrailed-family genes from four additional hexapod species. We also report the existence of a second engrailed-family gene in the Tribolium genome. We suggest that the engrailed and invected genes of Drosophila melanogaster have existed as a conserved gene cassette throughout holometabolous insect evolution. In total 11 phylogenetically diverse hexapod orders are now known to contain species that possess two engrailed-family paralogues, with in each case only one paralogue encoding the RS-motif, a characteristic feature of holometabolous insect invected proteins. We propose that the homeoboxes of hexapod engrailed-family paralogues are evolving in a concerted fashion, resulting in gene trees that overestimate the frequency of gene duplication. We present new phylogenetic analyses using non-homeodomain amino acid sequence that support this view. The S. gregaria engrailed-family paralogues provide strong evidence that concerted evolution might in part be explained by recurrent gene conversion. Finally, we hypothesize that the RS-motif is part of a serine-rich domain targeted for phosphorylation.     

Rapid concerted evolution in animal mitochondrial DNA

Recombinational genetic processes are thought to be rare in the uniparentally inherited mitochondrial (mt) DNA molecules of vertebrates and other animals. Here, however, we document extremely rapid concerted microevolution, probably mediated by frequent gene conversion events, of duplicated sequences in the mtDNA control region of mangrove killifishes (Kryptolebias marmoratus). In local populations, genetic distances between paralogous loci within an individual were typically smaller (and often zero) than those between orthologous loci in different specimens. These findings call for the recognition of concerted evolution as a microevolutionary process and gene conversion as a likely recombinational force in animal mtDNA. The previously unsuspected power of these molecular phenomena could greatly impact mtDNA dynamics within germ cell lineages and in local animal populations.     

Gene conversion and concerted evolution in bacterial genomes

Gene conversion is defined as the non-reciprocal transfer of information between homologous sequences. Despite methodological problems to establish non-reciprocity, gene conversion has been demonstrated in a wide variety of bacteria. Besides examples of high-frequency reversion of mutations in repeated genes, gene conversion in bacterial genomes has been implicated in concerted evolution of multigene families. Gene conversion also has a prime importance in the generation of antigenic variation, an interesting mechanism whereby some bacterial pathogens are able to avoid the host immune system. In this review, we analyze examples of bacterial gene conversion (some of them spawned from the current genomic revolution), as well as the molecular models that explain gene conversion and its association with crossovers.     

Duplication,concerted evolution and purifying selection drive the evolution of mosquito vitellogenin genes

Background  

Mosquito vitellogenin (Vtg) genes belong to a small multiple gene family that encodes the major yolk protein precursors required for egg production. Multiple Vtg genes have been cloned and characterized from several mosquito species, but their origin and molecular evolution are poorly understood.     

Reassortment and concerted evolution in banana bunchy top virus genomes

The nanovirus Banana bunchy top virus (BBTV) has six standard components in its genome and occasionally contains components encoding additional Rep (replication initiation protein) genes. Phylogenetic network analysis of coding sequences of DNA 1 and 3 confirmed the two major groups of BBTV, a Pacific and an Asian group, but show evidence of web-like phylogenies for some genes. Phylogenetic analysis of 102 major common regions (CR-Ms) from all six components showed a possible concerted evolution within the Pacific group, which is likely due to recombination in this region. The CR-M of additional Rep genes is close to that of DNA 1 and 2. Comparison of tree topologies constructed with DNA 1 and DNA 3 coding sequences of 14 BBTV isolates showed distinct phylogenetic histories based on Kishino-Hasegawa and Shimodaira-Hasegawa tests. The results of principal component analysis of amino acid and codon usages indicate that DNA 1 and 3 have a codon bias different from that of all other genes of nanoviruses, including all currently known additional Rep genes of BBTV, which suggests a possible ancient genome reassortment event between distinctive nanoviruses.     

Ubiquitin genes as a paradigm of concerted evolution of tandem repeats

Summary Ubiquitin is remarkable for its ubiquitous distribution and its extreme protein sequence conservation. Ubiquitin genes comprise direct repeats of the ubiquitin coding unit with no spacers. The nucleotide sequences of several ubiquitin repeats from each of humans, chicken,Xenopus, Drosophila, barley, and yeast have recently been determined. By analysis of these data we show that ubiquitin is evolving more slowly than any other known protein, and that this (together with its gene organization) contributes to an ideal situation for the occurrence of concerted evolution of tandem repeats. By contrast, there is little evidence of between-cluster concerted evolution. We deduce that in ubiquitin genes, concerted evolution involves both unequal crossover and gene conversion, and that the average time since two repeated units within the polyubiquitin locus most recently shared a common ancestor is approximately 38 million years (Myr) in mammals, but perhaps only 11 Myr inDrosophila. The extreme conservatism of ubiquitin evolution also allows the inference that certain synonymous serine codons differing at the first two positions were probably mutated at single steps.     

Copy correction and concerted evolution in the conservation of yeast genes

The yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and other members of the genus Saccharomyces are descendants of an ancient whole-genome duplication event. Although most of the duplicate genes have since been deleted, many remain, and so there are many pairs of related genes. We have found that poorly expressed genes diverge rapidly from their paralog, while highly expressed genes diverge little, if at all. This lack of divergence of highly expressed paralogous gene pairs seems to involve gene correction: one member of the pair “corrects” the sequence of its twin, and so the gene pair evolves as a unit. This correction presumably involves gene conversion and could occur via a reverse-transcribed cDNA intermediate. Such correction events may also occur in other organisms. These results support the idea that copies of poorly expressed genes are preserved when they diverge to take on new functions, while copies of highly expressed genes are preserved when they are needed to provide additional gene product for the original function.     

Rapid and concerted evolution of repeat units in a balbiani ring gene

The Balbiani ring (BR) genes in the midge Chironomus, a genus belonging to Diptera, code for large secretory proteins, used to construct the larval tube. The 15-23-kb long core block in each gene consists of an array of tandemly arranged approximately 200-bp long repeat units, where a single repeat unit is composed of a constant and a subrepeat region. In order to investigate the evolutionary fate of highly repetitive coding DNA, the BR1γ core block in Chironomus pallidivittatus was characterized and compared to the orthologous core block in the sibling species Chironomus tentans. We find that the 75-100 repeat units in the BR1γ core block have evolved in an unusual fashion. In all repeat units the constant regions display an expected high degree of homology between the two species, 94% at the nucleotide level. In contrast, the subrepeat regions in all repeat units have diverged concertedly, both as to length, number and sequence of the subrepeats. The observed changes in all repeat units of the core block probably have occurred after speciation of C. pallidivittatus and C. tentans. These findings demonstrate that a tandemly reiterated coding sequence can rapidly and concertedly convert into a related sequence, much in the same way as has been described for satellite DNA.     

Birth-and-death evolution of protein-coding regions and concerted evolution of non-coding regions in the multi-component genomes of nanoviruses

Genomes of the four plant viruses of the genus Nanovirus consist of multiple circular single-stranded DNA components, each of which encodes a single protein. Protein phylogenies supported the hypothesis that faba bean necrotic yellows virus (FBNYV) and milk vetch disease virus (MDV) are sister taxa; that subterranean clover stunt virus (SCSV) branched next; and that banana bunchy top virus (BBTV) is an outgroup to the three other species. The phylogeny of replication (Rep) proteins indicate that this small viral multi-gene family has evolved by a process of duplication and subsequent loss of Rep-encoding genome components, analogous to the "birth-and-death" process of evolution which has been described in eukaryotic multi-gene families. By contrast, repeated recombinational events between components were found to have homogenized the non-coding portions of several components encoding unrelated components. For example, as result of recent recombination a portion of the non-coding region is virtually identical among SCSV components 1, 3, 4, 5, and 7. Thus, there is a process of concerted evolution of non-coding regions of Nanovirus genome components, which raises the possibility that certain non-coding regions are subject to functional constraint.     

Organization and concerted evolution of the ampliconic Y-chromosomal TSPY genes from cattle

The Y-chromosomal gene TSPY (testis-specific protein Y-encoded) is probably involved in early spermatogenesis and has a variable copy number in different mammalian species. Analysis of bovine BAC clones leads to an estimate of 90 TSPY loci on the bovine Y chromosome. Half of these loci (TSPY-M1 and TSPY-M2) contain a single copy, while the other loci (TSPY-C) contain a cluster of three, possibly four, truncated pseudogenes. Fluorescence in situ hybridization indicated that the TSPY loci are located mainly on the short arm (Yp). The TSPY genes appear to account for about 2.5% of the Y chromosome and contain several published bovine Y-chromosomal microsatellites. The homology of TSPY and the major Y-chromosomal repetitive elements BRY.2 from cattle and OY.1 from sheep (80-85% similarity) further illustrates how the Y chromosome is shaped by rearrangements and horizontal spreading of the most abundant sequences. A comparison of TSPY-M1 sequences from different BAC clones and from related bovine species suggests concerted evolution as one of the mechanisms of the rapid evolution of the mammalian Y chromosome.     

Extensive concerted evolution of rice paralogs and the road to regaining independence

Many genes duplicated by whole-genome duplications (WGDs) are more similar to one another than expected. We investigated whether concerted evolution through conversion and crossing over, well-known to affect tandem gene clusters, also affects dispersed paralogs. Genome sequences for two Oryza subspecies reveal appreciable gene conversion in the approximately 0.4 MY since their divergence, with a gradual progression toward independent evolution of older paralogs. Since divergence from subspecies indica, approximately 8% of japonica paralogs produced 5-7 MYA on chromosomes 11 and 12 have been affected by gene conversion and several reciprocal exchanges of chromosomal segments, while approximately 70-MY-old "paleologs" resulting from a genome duplication (GD) show much less conversion. Sequence similarity analysis in proximal gene clusters also suggests more conversion between younger paralogs. About 8% of paleologs may have been converted since rice-sorghum divergence approximately 41 MYA. Domain-encoding sequences are more frequently converted than nondomain sequences, suggesting a sort of circularity--that sequences conserved by selection may be further conserved by relatively frequent conversion. The higher level of concerted evolution in the 5-7 MY-old segmental duplication may reflect the behavior of many genomes within the first few million years after duplication or polyploidization.     

Ribosomal DNA in the grasshopper Podisma pedestris: escape from concerted evolution

Eukaryote nuclear ribosomal DNA (rDNA) typically exhibits strong concerted evolution: a pattern in which several hundred rDNA sequences within any one species show little or no genetic diversity, whereas the sequences of different species diverge. We report a markedly different pattern in the genome of the grasshopper Podisma pedestris. Single individuals contain several highly divergent ribosomal DNA groups. Analysis of the magnitude of divergence indicates that these groups have coexisted in the Podisma lineage for at least 11 million years. There are two putatively functional groups, each estimated to be at least 4 million years old, and several pseudogene groups, many of which are transcribed. Southern hybridization and real-time PCR experiments show that only one of the putatively functional types occurs at high copy number. However, this group is scarcely amplified under standard PCR conditions, which means that phylogenetic inference on the basis of standard PCR would be severely distorted. The analysis suggests that concerted evolution has been remarkably ineffective in P. pedestris. We propose that this outcome may be related to the species' exceptionally large genome and the associated low rate of deletion per base pair, which may allow pseudogenes to persist.     

The 1.688 repetitive DNA of Drosophila: concerted evolution at different genomic scales and association with genes

Concerted evolution leading to homogenization of tandemly repeated DNA arrays is widespread and important for genome evolution. We investigated the range and nature of the process at chromosomal and array levels using the 1.688 tandem repeats of Drosophila melanogaster where large arrays are present in the heterochromatin of chromosomes 2, 3, and X, and short arrays are found in the euchromatin of the same chromosomes. Analysis of 326 euchromatic and heterochromatic repeats from 52 arrays showed that the homogenization of 1.688 repeats occurred differentially for distinct genomic regions, from euchromatin to heterochromatin and from local arrays to chromosomes. We further found that most euchromatic arrays are either close to, or are within introns of, genes. The short size of euchromatic arrays (one to five repeats) could be selectively constrained by their role as gene regulators, a situation similar to the so-called "tuning knobs."     

Characterization of the cow stomach lysozyme genes: Repetitive DNA and concerted evolution

Cow stomach lysozyme genes have evolved in a mosaic pattern. The majority of the intronic and flanking sequences show an amount of sequence difference consistent with divergent evolution since duplication of the genes 40–50 million years ago. In contrast, exons 1, 2, and 4 and immediately adjacent intronic sequences differ little between genes and show evidence of recent concerted evolution. Exon 3 appears to be evolving divergently. The three characterized genes vary from 5.6 to 7.9 kilobases in length. Different distributions of repetitive DNA are found in each gene, which accounts for the majority of length differences between genes. The different distributions of repetitive DNA in each gene suggest the repetitive elements were inserted into each gene after the duplications that give rise to these three genes and provide additional support for divergent evolution for the majority of each gene. The observation that intronic and flanking sequences are evolving divergently suggests that the concerted evolution events involved in homogenizing the coding regions of lysozyme genes involve only one exon at a time. This model of concerted evolution would allow the shuffling of exon-sized pieces of information between genes, a phenomenon that may have aided in the early adaptive evolution of stomach lysozyme.Deceased July 21, 1991 Correspondence to: D.M. Irwin     

Diversifying selection and concerted evolution of a type IV secretion system in Bartonella

We have studied the evolution of a type IV secretion system (T4SS), in Bartonella, which is thought to have changed function from conjugation to erythrocyte adherence following a recent horizontal gene transfer event. The system, called Trw, is unique among T4SSs in that genes encoding both exo- and intracellular components are located within the same duplicated fragment. This provides an opportunity to study the influence of selection on proteins involved in host-pathogen interactions. We sequenced the trw locus from several strains of Bartonella henselae and investigated its evolutionary history by comparisons to other Bartonella species. Several instances of recombination and gene conversion events where detected in the 2- to 5-fold duplicated gene fragments encompassing trwJIH, explaining the homogenization of the anchoring protein TrwI and the divergence of the minor pilus protein TrwJ. A phylogenetic analysis of the 7- to 8-fold duplicated gene coding for the major pilus protein TrwL displayed 2 distinct clades, likely representing a subfunctionalization event. The analyses of the B. henselae strains also identified a recent horizontal transfer event of almost the complete trwL region. We suggest that the switch in function of the T4SS was mediated by the duplication of the genes encoding pilus components and their diversification by combinatorial sequence shuffling within and among genomes. We suggest that the pilus proteins have evolved by diversifying selection to match a divergent set of erythrocyte surface structures, consistent with the trench warfare coevolutionary model.     

Sequence and evolution of cattle MHC class I cDNAs: concerted evolution has not taken place in cattle

To explore genetic mechanisms responsible for major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I evolution in the artiodactyls, we cloned and sequenced MHC class I cDNAs from a Bos taurus bull heterozygous for cattle MHC (BoLA) class I serological specificities w2 and w30. Four unique cDNAs were found, indicating the presence of at least two MHC class I loci. Analysis of these four cDNAs and all previously published BoLA cDNA sequences suggested that there may be three cattle MHC class I loci. Additionally, comparison of all of the BoLA class I cDNAs to MHC class I cDNAs of other artiodactyls showed that some of the BoLA class I cDNAs were more similar to certain sheep cDNAs than they were to other cattle cDNAs. These data indicate that each BoLA class I locus has evolved independently after an ancestral gene duplication event and that inter-locus segmental exchange o or concerted evolution has not occurred rapidly enough to cause extensive divergence between the orthologous MHC class I loci of sheep and cattle.The nucleotide sequence data reported in this paper have been submitted to the GenBank nucleotide sequence database and have been assigned the accession numbers L02832–L02835. Correspondence to: T. L. Garber at the present address.     

Monitoring the rate and dynamics of concerted evolution in the ribosomal DNA repeats of Saccharomyces cerevisiae using experimental evolution

Concerted evolution describes the unusual evolutionary pattern exhibited by certain repetitive sequences, whereby all the repeats are maintained in the genome with very similar sequences but differ between related species. The pattern of concerted evolution is thought to result from continual turnover of repeats by recombination, a process known as homogenization. Approaches to studying concerted evolution have largely been observational because of difficulties investigating repeat evolution in an experimental setting with large arrays of identical repeats. Here, we establish an experimental evolution approach to look at the rate and dynamics of concerted evolution in the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) repeats. A small targeted mutation was made in the spacer of a single rDNA unit in Saccharomyces cerevisiae so we could monitor the fate of this unit without the need for a selectable marker. The rate of loss of this single unit was determined, and the frequency of duplication was also estimated. The results show that duplication and deletion events occur at similar rates and are very common: An rDNA unit may be gained or lost as frequently as once every cell division. Investigation of the spatial dynamics of rDNA turnover showed that when the tagged repeat unit was duplicated, the copy predominantly, but not exclusively, ended up near to the tagged repeat. This suggests that variants in the rDNA spread in a semiclustered fashion. Surprisingly, large deletions that remove a significant fraction of total rDNA repeats were frequently found. We propose these large deletions are a driving force of concerted evolution, acting to increase homogenization efficiency over-and-above that afforded by turnover of individual rDNA units. Thus, the results presented here enhance our understanding of concerted evolution by offering insights into both the spatial and temporal dynamics of the homogenization process and suggest an important new aspect in our understanding of concerted evolution.     

ITS sequence variation and concerted evolution in the natural hybrid species Malus toringoides

The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of nuclear ribosomal DNA (nrDNA) is one of the most used molecular characters in plant systematics. Our previous studies based on morphological analysis and ITS sequence variation suggested that Malus toringoides (Rehd.) Hughes is derived from hybridization between M. transitoria (Batal.) Schneid. and M. kansuensis (Batal.) Schneid. To further understand the variation pattern of ITS sequences in M. toringoides, and to elucidate the evolutionary processes that affect ITS sequence variation after hybridization, we sampled 99 accessions from multiple populations of the hybrid and parental species, and then obtained totally 254 ITS sequences by cloning and sequencing. Our ITS variation data demonstrates three outcomes of ITS repeats after hybrid speciation. ～ 27–41% of M. toringoides have only M. transitoria type ITS sequence, ～ 40–70% have M. transitoria type ITS sequence plus one or two chimeric ITS sequences generated by recombination between parental ITS sequences, and six accessions retain both parental type ITS sequences. The plausible evolutionary processes that created the observed ITS variations were inferred to be the joint actions of recombination, concerted evolution, pseudogenization and backcrossing. Our study provides further understandings of the variation model of ITS repeats after hybridization as well as the evolution of M. toringoides after its hybrid speciation.