Chemico-structural evolution of linguloid brachiopod shells

Chemico-structures of shells representing all families presently assigned to the Linguloidea have undergone significant transformations since the Early Cambrian. Superficial hemispherical to hemi-ellipsoidal pits on the larval and/or mature shells are interpreted as casts of deformable, membrane-bound vesicles of mucus or rigid vesicles of glycoproteins or GAGs with thickened coats. Flat-bottomed, sub-circular imprints characterize acrotheloids and many acrotretides, and could be impressions of biconvex tablets of apatite like those exocytosed within the primary layer of the obolid ‘Lingulella’? antiquissima, whilst the rhomboidal imprints of the Paterula shell could have held tablets of proteinaceous silica like those of living discinid larvae. The ancestral fabric of the linguloid secondary layer was probably composed of rubbly and virgose sets, but trellised rods of apatite (baculation) are characteristic of most linguloids and also acrotheloids. This condition was suppressed in shells identified as ‘Lingula’ from at least the Early Carboniferous to the present day. In early Palaeozoic acrotretides and lingulellotretids, columnar and camerate fabrics evolved in place of baculation. Baculation in Discinisca tenuis and Glottidia pyramidata is associated with the amino acids glutamic acid, glycine, alanine, arginine and proline which may be components of an organic polymer axial to baculate accretion.     

Ordovician trimerellacean brachiopod shell beds

The large, thick-shelled, inarticulate brachiopod Eodinobolus forms many conspicuous deposits of shells in the Upper Ordovician limestones of central western New South Wales. Both in situ and reworked shell beds arc preserved at recurrent intervals through the successions, in similar facies of both transgressivc and regressive phases of deposition. In situ shell beds arc best developed in transgressivc sequences, with up to four generations of shells exhibited in the individual in situ beds. These monotypic and very low diversity shell beds are interpreted as having formed in marginal marine, quiet water conditions: (1) on the fringes of an offshore island (in part the Molong High of the Tasman Orogen), with the island still providing a fairly continuous supply of terrigenous material: and, (2) after submergence of the island, on the resulting terrigenous-free, major offshore Bahamas-like platform. This may imply that the shell beds developed in different salinity regimes. Possibly Eodinobolus was capable of tolerating a wider than normal range of salinity, from slightly brackish through normal marine, even to marginally hypersaline. However, in both settings, Eodinobolus, in its role as the dominant member of the respective pioneer community, colonized similar substrates in the low energy mud zone. This appears to suggest depositional environments most directly analogous to those of Palaeozoic virgianid pentamerides, and perhaps also comparable with some modern marginal marine oyster and mussel-bed occurrences. ?Ordovician, Brachiopoda, Eodinobolus, palaeoecology, facies, shell beds. New South Wales.     

Intermediary metabolism and shell growth in the brachiopod Terebratalia transversa

Juvenile Terebratalia transversa (Brachiopoda) metabolize carbohydrates in the anterior-most marginal mantle at a rate of 0.46 μM glucose/g/hr (in vitro incubation of mantle in C¹⁴-glucose in a carrying medium of 10^-3 M non-radioactive glucose). The rate declines to 0.18μM glucose/g/hr in full-grown specimens. Carbohydrate metabolism in the marginal (anterior-most) mantle averages approximately 3.7 times greater than metabolism in (a portion of the ‘posterior’) mantle situated between the coelomic canals and the marginal mantle. This ratio remains constant in specimens of all sizes (i.e. an ontogenetic trend in the ratio is absent at p≤ 0.05). Organic acids are not detectable within the mantle (HPLC techniques) even after simulated anoxia (N₂ bubbling during mantle incubation). Glucose metabolism in vitro declines in both the marginal and ‘posterior’ mantles during anoxia and the metabolic ratio between marginal/‘posterior’ mantles becomes 1/1. We found no difference (at p≤ 0.05) in mean metabolic activity or in sue-related metabolic trends among populations from depths ranging between mean sea level and 70 m. However, the activity within the ‘posterior’ mantle was more variable in specimens from 70 m than in those from shallower habitats (10 m - mean sea level). The size of the specimens analyzed was most variable in the groups obtained from the shallowest habitats and least variable at 70 m depth. Our results may help define the energetics of fossil as well as living brachiopod shell growth. Brachiopod shell growth is known to be very slow relative to that of bivalves and our results indicate that this is a result of the animals' slow metabolism. The inflation of the valves in T. transversa is, in part, a function of the high ratio of intermediary metabolism in the marginal vs‘posterior’ mantle (i.e. parallels the relative growth rates at the shell margin vs‘posterior’ areas). We found that the bivalve, Chlamys hastata, which is commonly associated with T. transversa, has a lower ratio of metabolic activities in the ventral/dorsal mantle areas than the brachiopod has in the anterior/posterior. The difference produces a flatter shell in the bivalve in accord with allometric principles. The higher metabolic rate in the marginal vs‘posterior’ brachiopod mantle and its more pronounced decline with anaerobiosis is reflected in the greater definition of growth increments in the outer shell layer. Our results do not support recent generalizations that correlate shell thickness of a wide variety of invertebrates inversely with metabolic rate. Growth rate as determined from width of shell growth increments is a better index of metabolic rate. Although the genetic basis of glucose metabolism is unknown, the observed metabolic variability is consistent with suggestions that populations of marine organisms living in stable offshore environments are genetically more variable but morphologically more uniform than populations from shallow water. Furthermore, our results support suggestions that bivalved molluscs and brachiopods are very different metabolically, but the data are neutral with respect to theories of competitive exclusion of the two taxa throughout geologic history.     

Mineral phase in linguloid brachiopod shell: Lingula adamsi

The linguloid brachiopod shell family has been the focus of several studies because of the similarity in the composition of the mineral phase of these shells to that of human bone. However, ultrastructural features of Lingula shells have not yet been fully demonstrated at high magnification using Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and Electron Diffraction. Ultrastructural characterization of the mineral phase in Lingula shells will improve our understanding of the biomineralization processes and mineral/organic interaction in more complex systems such as in bone or in other human mineralized tissues. In this study, the mineral phase of Lingula adamsi was characterized using a combination of ultrastructural and crystallographic techniques. The results showed that L. adamsi shells consist of apatite crystals of varying size, shape, and orientation in different areas of the shell. The c-axis of apatite was parallel to the shell surface and crystals were organized in different laminae. Compared to trabecular bovine bone, L. adamsi shells demonstrated a higher crystallinity and a lower amount of carbonate and organic compounds. This study therefore demonstrated how dissimilar organic matrix between L. adamsi shell and trabecular bone can modify the ultrastructural characteristics of apatite crystals in these two biomineralized tissues.     

Earliest ontogeny of Early Palaeozoic Craniiformea: implications for brachiopod phylogeny

Popov, L.E., Bassett, M.G., Holmer, L.E., Skovsted, C.B. & Zuykov, M.A. 2010: Earliest ontogeny of Early Palaeozoic Craniiformea: implications for brachiopod phylogeny. Lethaia, Vol. 43, pp. 323–333. Well preserved specimens of the Early Palaeozoic craniiform brachiopods Orthisocrania and Craniops retain clear evidence of a lecithotrophic larval stage, indicating the loss of planktotrophy early in their phylogeny. The size of the earliest mineralized dorsal shell was <100 μm across, and the well preserved shell structure in these fossil craniiforms allows their earliest ontogeny to be compared directly with that of living Novocrania, in which the first mineralized dorsal shell (metamorphic shell) is secreted only after settlement of the lecithotrophic larvae. Immediately outside this earliest shell (early post‐metamorphic or brephic shell) and in the rest of the dorsal valve the primary layer in both fossil and living craniiforms has characteristic radially arranged laths, which are invariably lacking in the earliest dorsal shell. The ventral valve of the fossil specimens commonly preserves traces of an early attachment scar (cicatrix), which is equal in size to the dorsal metamorphic shell, and the brephic post‐metamorphic ventral valve also has a primary shell with radially arranged laths. However, a primary shell with radial laths is completely lacking in the ventral valve of living Novocrania, indicating that heterochrony may have been involved in the origin of the encrusting mode of life in living craniids; the entire ventral valve of Recent craniids (with the possible exception of Neoancistrocrania) may correspond to the earliest attachment scar of some fossil taxa such as Orthisocrania. It is also probable that the unique absence of an inner mantle lobe as well as the absence of lobate cells in Novocrania could be the result of heterochronic changes. The dorsal valve of both fossil and living craniiforms has a marked outer growth ring, around 500 μm across, marking the transition to the adult, and a significant change in regime of shell secretion. The earliest craniiform attachment is considered to be homologous to the unique attachment structures described recently in polytoechioids (e.g. Antigonambonites) and other members of the strophomenate clade. However, unlike the craniiforms, polytoechioids and strophomenates all have planktotrophic larvae, and planktotrophy is most probably a plesiomorphic character for all Brachiopoda. □Brachiopoda, Craniiformea, Early Palaeozoic, ontogeny, phylogeny.     

Multiscale structure of calcite fibres of the shell of the brachiopod Terebratulina retusa

The shells of rhynchonelliform brachiopods have an outer (primary) layer of acicular calcite and an inner (secondary) layer of calcite fibres which are parallel to the shell exterior. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) reveals that these fibres are composed of large triangular nanogranules of about 600-650 nm along their long axis. The nanogranules are composites of organic and inorganic components. As the shell grows, the fibres elongate with the calcite c-axis perpendicular to the fibre axis as demonstrated by electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD). Thus, despite being a composite structure comprising granules that are themselves composites, each fibre is effectively a single crystal. The combination of AFM and EBSD reveals the details of the structure and crystallography of these fibres. This knowledge serves to identify those aspects of biological control that must be understood to enable comprehension of the biological control exerted on the construction of these exquisite biomineral structures.     

The nature of siliceous mosaics forming the first shell of the brachiopod Discinisca

The juvenile shell of the brachiopod Discinisca consists of a mosaic of micrometer-sized siliceous tablets embedded in a chitinous substrate. The first-formed tablets are secreted on glycocalyx by a newly differentiated collective of outer epithelial cells. They are mainly rhombic but may also be ellipsoidal, discoidal, or deformed and sporadically overlap one another. On the surrounding juvenile shell, secreted by an incipient outer mantle lobe, the tablets are nearly all perfect rhombic plates in rhombic arrays. Their constant size, arrangement, and centripetal crystallization suggest intracellular assembly. The tablets, which are normally bilamellar, consist of discrete aggregates of crystalline spherules of silica in rhombic arrays within an organic matrix of fibrous protein and, presumably, a soluble polysaccharide(s). Mosaic secretion ceases at about the time when juveniles settle on the sea bed, which more or less coincides with the secretion of a ring of lamellae around the mosaic, induced by rapid advances and retractions of the outer mantle lobe prior to deposition of the organophosphatic mature shell. Energy dispersion X-ray analyses of pelagic and newly settled juveniles show that phosphatic secretion, even in the site of the first-formed outer epithelial collective, does not begin until all siliceous secretion has ceased.     

The ideal hydrodynamic form of the concavo‐convex productide brachiopod shell

Shiino, Y & Suzuki, Y. 2011: The ideal hydrodynamic form of the concavo‐convex productide brachiopod shell. Lethaia, Vol. 44, pp. 329–343. Water‐flume experiments were performed to determine whether the concavo‐convex Permian brachiopod Waagenoconcha imperfecta was hydrodynamically adapted for feeding. The generation of passive currents inside the valves was observed experimentally. The use of four transparent, hollow polyhedron models, each differing in a single morphological feature, permitted observation of the currents inside the valves and allowed evaluation of the hydrodynamic significance of the ears and the prominent geniculated trail. Regardless of the direction of ambient flow, only the approximate‐imitation model generated a stable flow pattern consisting of inhalation from the ear gapes and exhalation from the anterior trail gape; models lacking or with small changes in these morphological features failed to generate stable flow patterns. The stable flow pattern was probably maintained by a pressure difference between the posterior lower ear gapes (maximum pressure) and the anterior trail gape (minimum pressure). Notably, bilaterally rotating internal currents formed parallel to the brachial ridges; such flow patterns would facilitate the capture of food particles by the animal via tentacles on its lophophore, which is most likely were located on the brachial ridges. Our results demonstrate that the immobile brachiopod W. imperfecta, an animal incapable of widely opening its valves, probably fed on the passive internal currents generated by its shell form. This unique valve morphology appears to be perfectly adapted from a hydrodynamic point of view. □Biomechanics, ecomorphology, evolution, morphological disparity, Productidina, suspension feeder.     

Earliest ontogeny of the Silurian orthotetide brachiopod Coolinia and its significance for interpreting strophomenate phylogeny

Well‐preserved juvenile specimens of the orthotetide brachiopod Coolinia pecten (Linnaeus, 1758 ) from the Silurian of Gotland, Sweden, demonstrate evidence of a planktotrophic larval habit. Larval shell morphology indicates the absence of a pedicle sheath: this character is otherwise typical of derived billingsellides, strophomenides and productides, which form the conventional strophomenide clade. The presence of a rudimentary colleplax structure in the larval shell of Colinia suggests instead a phylogenetic link to chiliate brachiopods and the enigmatic genus Salanygolina. This relationship suggests an early divergence of rhynchonellate and strophomenate brachiopods.     

Geometric shell growth and mode of life of a Devonian chonetoidean brachiopod

Morphological and statistical analysis of the chonetoid species Kentronetes variabilis from the Lower Devonian (Lochkovian) of the Argentine Precordillera demonstrate ontogenetic changes and allometric relationships between characters. A special study was made of spine distribution, morphology, and growth, compared to valve growth. The first, inner, developed spines (pairs 1–1'and 2–2') continued to grow after development of the following outer pairs. The spacing of spines, their diameter, and the density of growth rings vary from beak to posterolateral margins following a specific 2ⁿ geometric growth factor, compared to the regular, almost linear growth of the valves, attested by growth lines. The linear growth rate of outer spines (pairs 3–3'and 4–4') can be 6–8 times more rapid than that of the shell on the valve margin. Ontogenetic changes in spine morphology are interpreted as a response to changes in the mode of life.     

Theoretical approach to the functional optimisation of spiriferide brachiopod shell: Optimum morphology of sulcus

Evidence suggests that biological forms that provide physiological and autecological functions have evolved to adapt to environmental conditions and to optimise requisite morpho-functions. We examined whether shell morphology is functionally optimised to generate passive feeding flow in the Devonian spiriferide brachiopod Paraspirifer bownockeri. This study was based on quantitative results from a computational fluid dynamics simulation and the Lagrangian multiplier method. We estimated the optimum development of the ventral median shell depression, which is called the sulcus, by minimising the pressure difference along the gape. This estimation was made under the constraint that the number of spiral flow rotations must be greater than one, which is effective for spiriferide feeding because of its alignment with the spiral lophophore. During mathematical optimisation, the equation resulted in a suitable flow velocity of approximately 0.1 m/s. At this velocity, the pressure difference was minimised, regardless of sulcus development. The constraint equation showed that the number of spiral flow rotations increased with sulcus development. The optimal solution was similar to the original sulcus form of Paraspirifer under an ambient flow of approximately 0.1 m/s. This result suggests that the variation of shell outline in spiriferids could provide a variety of preferential conditions for ambient flow and that the flow intensity could be adjusted by sulcus development to generate a robust passive feeding flow along the spiral feeding organs.     

Earliest ontogeny of Middle Ordovician rhynchonelliform brachiopods (Clitambonitoidea and Polytoechioidea): implications for brachiopod phylogeny

New data on the earliest ontogeny of Mid-Ordovician Baltoscandian clitambonitoid ( Apomatella , Neumania and Oslogonites ) and polytoechioid ( Antigonambonites and Raunites ) brachiopods reveal significant differences in the life history of the taxa belonging to these two superfamilies. The Polytoechioidea and probably other members of the Billingsellida had planktotrophic larvae, in which the dorsal and ventral mantle lobes formed separately and without reversion. The 'pedicle sheath' in Antigonambonites is secreted by a section of modified ventral mantle and thus this 'pedicle' is not homologous within the pedicle of rhynchonellate brachiopods. It is likely that polytoechioids and other members of the strophomenate clade had the same type of ontogeny and mode of attachment. In contrast, the ontogeny and mode of attachment of clitambonitoids are similar to that of recent rhynchonellates: their mantle lobes and both valves formed simultaneously, and the pedicle most likely formed from the larval pedicle lobe. Evidence for the lecithotrophic nature of clitambonitoid larva is discussed. This confirms that the Clitambonitoidea, unlike the Polytoechioidea, represents an ingroup within the Rhynchonellata.     

Survival and repair of surgical and natural shell damage in the articulate brachiopod Terebratulina retusa (Linnaeus)

Living specimens of Terebratulina retusa from the Firth of Lorn, Scotland, were surgically damaged by drilling 2 mm diameter holes or narrow slits one cm long in the anterior portion of one valve, by bevelling the anterior margin of both valves, or by amputation of the anterior third of one valve. These injuries to the shell and mantle simulated the type of repaired shell damage seen in Paleozoic species, i.e., scalloped, divoted, cleft, and embayed valves. Less than ten percent of the 200 damaged specimens survived until the 25th week after surgery. Specimens of T. retusa showed the ability to repair drill holes, slits, and bevelled anterior shell regions, but not the most severe damage, i.e., amputations of the anterior third of one valve. Shell‐repair was initiated in the fourth week after surgery by the development of a membrane across the wound. The development of caeca in the new shell layer secreted to plug the drill holes became apparent by the eighth week. The punctate pattern was complete in the new, translucent shell material of bevelled and drilled specimens by the 25th week following surgery. Failure of any specimens to survive amputation of the anterior portion of a valve for more than seven weeks after surgery, and the absence of initiation of the repair process, suggests that terebratulids do not have the tolerance for, nor the ability to repair, the severe injuries (embayed valves) which were sustained and mended by extinct strophomenids.     

First experience with using a series of generalized golden proportions for studying the shell of brachiopod and mollusks

Symmetry of shells of clams (Veneridae: Katelysia, Venus, Periglypta; Fimbriidae: Corbis fimbriata) and brachioipods (Cancrinella undata, Echinoconhus punctatus, Reticulatia inflatiformis and Neophricodothyris waageni) was studied geometrically with spiral symmetry and connected mathematical methods (complex proportions and Fibonacci numbers). Location regularity of the elements of concentrical sculpture connected with shell growth is interpreted as unrolling of logarithmic spiral in the process of growth. Correlations of radius of sculpture circles were studied with the raw of generalized golden sections of V.I. Korobko and G.N. Primak. The discovered regularities of circles location being similar to some peculiarities of phyllotaxis are governed by the rules of the raw of generalized golden sections. Two spiral folds could keep correspondence between the increase in mass of growing animal and the increase in intensity of water drawing by ciliate apparatus.     

Structure of the brachiopod lophophore

Data on the development, structure, and functional morphology of the brachiopod lophophore are analyzed. The common origin of the tentacle apparatus in Lophophorata from the postoral ciliary band of the larva is shown. The brachiopod lophophore is based on the brachial axis consisting of the brachial fold running along the row of tentacles. The brachial axis may be attached to the brachial (dorsal) mantle lobe (trocholophe, schizolophe, and ptycholophe lophophores) or extend freely into the mantle cavity to form coiling brachia (spirolophe, zygolophe, and plectolophe lophophores). The circulation of water flows through the mantle cavity in the brachiopods with attached and free lophophores is described. A new hypothesis on the sorting of particles suspended in water during filtration is proposed.     

The protegulum and juvenile shell of a Recent articulate brachiopod: patterns of growth and chemical composition

Patterns of shell formation and the chemical composition of the shell deposited during early post-larval life were investigated in laboratory-reared cultures of the Recent articulate brachiopod Terebraralia transversa (Sowerby). A non-hinged protegulum averaging 148 pm in length is secreted by the mantle within a day after larval metamorphosis. The inner surface of the protegulum exhibits finely granular, non-fibrous material. A rudimentary periostracum constitutes the outer layer of the primordial shell. and concentrically arranged growth lines are lacking. By four days post-metamorphosis, a brephic type of juvenile shell develops from periodic additions of shell material to the anterior and lateral edges of the protegulum. Imbricated secondary fibers occur throughout the inner layer of the newly formed juvenile shell, and a rudimentary hinge apparatus is present posteriorly. The external surface of the shell exhibits concentric growth lines anterior to the caudally situated protegulum, and unbranched punctae begin to form in the subperiostracal region of the shell. At 23 days post-metamorphosis, the shell weighs an average of 1.7 μg and measures 318 μm in length. Electron microprobe analyses reveal that the protegulum is calcified. Minor amounts of sulfur, magnesium, iron, chlorine, aluminum, and silicon are also present in protegula and juvenile shells. Based on electron diffraction data, the mineral phase of juvenile shells consists of calcite, and protegula also appear to contain calcite.     

Molecular phylogeny of protobranch bivalves and systematic implications of their shell microstructure

Higher systematics and evolutionary history of Protobranchia, a subclass of Bivalvia, have long been controversial due to paucity of prominent shell characters and difficulties in collecting live material for diverse taxa. Here, we evaluate the reliability of shell microstructure for protobranch higher systematics by reconstructing a molecular phylogeny of the subclass. Relationships were assessed using the nuclear (18S rRNA, 28S rRNA and histone H3) and mitochondrial (16S rRNA and cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1) gene sequences from 89 in-group species. Maximum likelihood reconstruction with the nuclear markers recognized five superfamilies (Nuculoidea, Solemyoidea, Manzanelloidea, Nuculanoidea and Sareptoidea) as the in-group clades of the monophyletic Protobranchia. Sareptoidea is herein redefined to comprise Sarepta and Setigloma in the sole family Sareptidae, whereas Pristigloma and its monotypic Pristiglomidae are transferred from this superfamily to Nuculanoidea, both in the order Nuculanida. Mapping of shell microstructure characters on the tree confirmed their conservativeness at superfamily level when only living species were taken into account. The Nuculoidea have shells with the outer prismatic and middle/inner nacreous structures; Solemyoidea are characterized by either the radially elongate simple prismatic structure or the reticulate structure in the outer shell layer; Manzanelloidea, Nuculanoidea and Sareptoidea have shells of homogeneous, fibrous prismatic and/or fine complex crossed lamellar structures, all of which lack large structural units. Our Bayesian time calibration, on the contrary, suggested frequent loss of nacre in the Paleozoic and Mesozoic history of Protobranchia, at least once each in Nuculoidea, Manzanelloidea, Solemyoidea and Sareptoidea in the Paleozoic, and perhaps multiple times in Nuculanoidea by the Mesozoic.     

Mantle canals on brachiopod interareas and their significance in brachiopod classification

Wright, A.D. 1994 10 15: Mantle canals on brachiopod interareas and their significance in brachiopod classification.
Mantle canals have been located on the internal surface of the interareas in several clitambonitacean brachiopod genera. This indicates that, in contrast to the cardinal areas of Recent terebratulides and rhynchonellides, these surfaces were lined with mantle, with no fusion of the mantle lobes at the lateral ends of the hinge line, and the coelomic cavity confined to a median zone at the posterior of the shell. The discovery provides additional support for the view of Jaanusson (1971; Smiths. Contr. Paleobiol. 3 ) that the Beecher (1891) classification has considerable merit, and indicates that the calcareous brachiopods may be subdivided into the three subclasses Craniformea, Protremata and Telotremata. Brachiopoda, classification, Clitambonitacea, interareas, mantle canals, Protremata .     

Supraordinal brachiopod classification

Three controversial problems of brachiopod supraordinal classification are discussed: the position of brachiopods in the classification of Metazoa, their classification at phylum and class level, and the classification of the articulate brachiopods. The position of brachiopods in the system of Metazoa remains uncertain. There are no strong reasons for changing the traditional division of the phylum Brachiopoda into the classes Inarticulata and Articulata. The class Articulata is divided into the subclasses Orthata, Strophomenata, Spiriferata, and Terebratulata.