T cell tolerance to self antigens in New Zealand hybrid mice with lupus-like disease

We determined if self-reactive T cells are able to escape thymic tolerance in autoimmune New Zealand mice. T cells utilizing V beta 17a and V beta 11 encoded receptors have been shown to be clonally eliminated in nonautoimmune mice expressing I-E because of their potential self-reactivity. Similarly, V beta 8.1+ and V beta 6+ T cells are tolerized in the thymus of nonautoimmune mice that express Mls-1a. These T cell subsets were quantitated in the lymph nodes and spleens of (NZB x NZW)F1 and (NZB x SWR)F1 mice. In young mice from both autoimmune strains, deletion was similar to that observed in control animals matched for I-Ed and Mls-1a expression. Furthermore, older female autoimmune mice with elevated levels of IgG antinuclear antibodies and severe lupus-like renal disease did not demonstrate evidence of a global tolerance defect. We also found that the levels of residual V beta 17a+ cells in MHC-matched control F1 strains were further reduced by up to 80% in autoimmune (NZB x SWR)F1 mice. The greater in vivo elimination corresponded to an enhanced ability of NZB spleen cells, compared with other H-2d spleen cells, to stimulate V beta 17a+ hybridomas in vitro. The increased stimulation in culture could not be attributed to quantitative differences in I-E Ag expression. The results suggest that autoreactive T cells have been eliminated in these autoimmune mice by normal mechanisms of self-tolerance. Furthermore, the data demonstrate the existence of an NZB minor locus not present in other H-2d strains that influences T cell repertoire and enhances stimulation of T cells potentially reactive to self class II MHC Ag.     

The development of helper T cell precursors in mouse thymus

We have examined the appearance in mouse ontogeny of thymocyte precursors for Ag-specific, MHC-restricted Th. These cells are first detectable at day 18 of fetal life, about 1 day after alpha/beta, TCR-positive cells begin to appear. These early Th precursors are not dependent on the thymus for priming with Ag and MHC, and are L3T4+, Lyt-2-. Thus, these cells already have the phenotype of mature Th. In neonatal F1 animals expressing both IAk and IAb, the appearance of Th precursors restricted by either IAk or IAb is specifically inhibited by treatment of the mice with anti-IAk or anti-IAb antibodies, respectively. These results indicate that cells of mature T cell phenotype and function can arise fairly rapidly from immature, receptor-bearing precursors, once these appear. Moreover the results are in line with those previously obtained in chimeric animal experiments which suggested that specific interaction of TCR on thymocytes with class II alleles in the thymus is required for the subsequent appearance of T cells restricted by those class II alleles.     

The V beta-specific superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B: stimulation of mature T cells and clonal deletion in neonatal mice

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B is known to be a powerful T cell stimulant in mouse and man. In this paper we show that, for mice, this is because the protein in association with major histocompatibility complex class II molecules stimulates virtually all T cells bearing V beta 3 and V beta 8.1, 8.2, and 8.3, and few others. Neonatal mice given the enterotoxin eliminate all mature, and some immature, T cells bearing these V beta s, demonstrating that tolerance to exogenously administered antigen can be caused by clonal deletion of reactive T cells. The enterotoxin shares these "superantigenic" properties with known self-antigens in mice, Mls-1a and Mls-2a, and a B cell-derived product, a shared property that is unlikely to be coincidental or inconsequential.     

T cell receptor-alpha beta lacking the beta-chain V domain can be expressed at the cell surface but prohibits T cell maturation.

A TCR-beta gene lacking V domain sequences (delta V-TCR-beta) was inserted into the germline of mice. Expression of the transgene inhibited endogenous TCR-beta, but not TCR-alpha gene rearrangement and expression. The mutated TCR-beta gene affected alpha beta T cell development: the common thymocyte pool was normal in cell number, with cells expressing CD4 and CD8, but the mature, "CD3bright" population expressing either CD4 or CD8 molecules was reduced by 90%. To help understand these effects on TCR-beta gene rearrangement and T cell development, biosynthesis of the delta V-TCR-beta protein was analyzed in a tumor cell line derived from a transgenic mouse. Despite absence of the V domain, the delta V-TCR-beta chain paired with endogenous TCR-alpha chains and assembled with CD3 gamma, -delta, -epsilon, and -zeta components in the endoplasmatic reticulum, followed by transport through the Golgi complex to the plasma membrane. Therefore, assembly of the complex, and even cell surface expression, may be relevant for allelic exclusion of the TCR-beta gene. In the common thymocyte population, the CD3 components, endogenous TCR-alpha, and the delta V-TCR-beta gene product were expressed at the RNA level, but endogenous TCR-beta was not. The TCR-alpha delta beta/CD3 complex was present at the cell surface at low levels and was functional in terms of anti-CD3-induced Ca2+ mobilization. The observed arrest of alpha beta T cell development at the CD4+8+ thymocyte stage indicates that ligand recognition by the TCR, with contribution of the beta-chain V domain, is not required for transition of CD4-8- thymocytes to the CD4+8+ phenotype, but necessary for entry into the "single positive," CD3bright differentiation stage.     

Functional competency of T cell antigen receptors in human thymus

The T cell antigen receptor is likely to play a role in both positive and negative selection in the thymus. Three populations of thymocytes can be distinguished by the level of expression of the CD3-alpha/beta-chain heterodimer of the T cell antigen receptor (CD3/Ti alpha/beta) complex. Cells which fail to express these receptors or express low levels of receptors are contained in a population of thymocytes which express low levels of the CD5 antigen and are predominantly CD4+/CD8+. Thus, these cells appear to be relatively immature phenotypically. In contrast, the cells which express high levels of CD3/Ti alpha/beta co-express high levels of CD5 and are predominantly contained in the more mature single positive cells which express either CD4 or CD8. With the calcium-sensitive dye, Indo-1, and immunofluorescence, we demonstrated that, despite the relative phenotypic immaturity of cells which express low levels of CD3/Ti alpha/beta, these antigen receptors are able to mediate transmembrane signaling when stimulated with CD3 monoclonal antibodies. Although increases in calcium were observed in these CD3/Ti alpha/beta-low expressing cells in response to anti-CD3, no proliferative response was observed, even in the presence of phorbol myristate acetate. Proliferative responses were observed in the more mature cells which express high levels of CD3/Ti alpha/beta. These results suggest that, rather than a defect in the functional capability of the antigen receptor complex to mediate transmembrane signaling events, cellular responses to signals generated by the antigen receptor may differ at various stages of thymocyte development.     

Phenotype, ontogeny, and repertoire of CD4-CD8- T cell receptor alpha beta + thymocytes. Variable influence of self-antigens on T cell receptor V beta usage

We have characterized CD4-CD8- double negative (DN) thymocytes that express TCR-alpha beta and represent a minor thymocyte subpopulation expressing a markedly skewed TCR repertoire. We found that DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes resemble mature T cells in that they (a) are phenotypically CD2hiCD5hiQa2+HSA-, (b) appear late in ontogeny, and (c) are susceptible to cyclosporin A-induced maturation arrest. In addition, we found that DNA sequences 5' to the CD8 alpha gene were demethylated relative to their germline state, suggesting that DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes are derived from cells that had at one time expressed their CD8 alpha gene locus. Because DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes are known to express an unusual TCR repertoire with significant overexpression of V beta 8, we were interested in examining the possible role played by self-Ag in shaping their TCR repertoire. It has been suggested that DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes are derived from potentially self-reactive thymocytes that have escaped clonal deletion by down-regulating their surface expression of CD4 and/or CD8 determinants. However, apparently inconsistent with such an hypothesis, we found that the frequency of DN thymocytes expressing various anti-self TCR (V beta 6, V beta 8.1, V beta 11, V beta 17a) were not increased in strains expressing their putative self-Ag, but instead were either unaffected or significantly reduced in those strains. With regard to V beta 8 expression among DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes, V beta 8 overexpression in DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes appeared to be independent of, and superimposed on, the developmental appearance of the basic DN thymocyte repertoire. Even though V beta 8 overexpression appeared to be generated by a mechanism distinct from that generating the rest of the DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocyte repertoire, we found that super-Ag against which V beta 8 TCR react introduced into the neonatal differentiation environment also significantly reduced, rather than increased, the frequency of DN TCR-alpha beta + V beta 8+ thymocytes. Thus, the present study is consistent with DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes being mature cells derived from CD8+ precursors, and documents that their TCR repertoire can be influenced, at least negatively, by either self-Ag or Ag introduced into the neonatal differentiation environment. However, we found no evidence to support the hypothesis that DN TCR-alpha beta + thymocytes are enriched in cells expressing TCR reactive against self-Ag.     

Quantitative and qualitative adjustment of thymic T cell production by clonal expansion of premigrant thymocytes

In normal mice, single-positive thymocytes proliferate before being exported into the peripheral T cell pool. We measured the in vivo proliferation rates of mature thymocytes in several TCR transgenic mice. Different monoclonal TCR transgenic single-positive thymocytes proliferated at different rates in a given MHC context. Conversely, mature thymocytes expressing a given TCR, generated in mice of different MHC haplotypes, also showed different rates of proliferation. In p59(fyn)-deficient mice, the proliferation rate of mature thymocytes was diminished. Thus, premigrant thymocyte expansion is TCR mediated and depends on TCR affinity for self peptide/MHC ligands. In addition, we show that mature thymocyte expansion is clonotypic, increases the daily thymic T cell output, and modifies the TCR repertoire of newly produced T cells.     

A T cell receptor V beta segment that imparts reactivity to a class II major histocompatibility complex product

We have identified in mice an allele of a new T cell receptor V beta gene, V beta 17a, whose product is bound by the monoclonal antibody KJ23a. Over 90% of T cell hybridomas prepared from V beta 17a+ T cells of SWR mice respond to allogeneic forms of the IE class II MHC protein, indicating that V beta 17a has an appreciable affinity for IE regardless of the other components of the T cell receptor. These results suggest a bias in the germ-line T cell receptor repertoire toward recognition of MHC proteins and indicate that the V beta portion of the receptor may form the most important contact points with MHC ligands.     

Extrathymic tolerance of mature T cells: clonal elimination as a consequence of immunity

The mechanism by which T lymphocytes are tolerized to self or foreign antigens is still controversial. Clonal deletion is the major mechanism of tolerance for immature thymocytes; for mature T cells, tolerance is considered to reflect anergy rather than deletion, and to be a consequence of defective presentation of antigen. This paper documents a novel form of tolerance resulting when mature T cells encounter antigen in immunogenic form. Evidence is presented that exposure of mature T cells to Mlsa antigens in vivo leads to specific tolerance and disappearance of Mlsa-reactive V beta 6+ T cells. Surprisingly, the clonal elimination of V beta 6+ cells is preceded by marked expansion of these cells. Thus, tolerance induction can be the end result of a powerful immune response. These data raise important questions concerning the relationship of tolerance and memory.     

Clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells at the early stage of T cell development in thymus of radiation bone marrow chimeras

Sequential appearance of T cell subpopulations occurs in the thymocytes of irradiated C3H/He mice (H-2k, Mls-1b2a, Thy-1.2) after transplantation with bone marrow cells of AKR/J mice (H-2k, Mls-1a2b, Thy-1.1) (AKR----C3H chimeras). The donor-derived thymocytes of AKR----C3H chimeras on day 14 after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) contained a large number of blastlike CD4+CD8+ cells which represent relatively immature thymocytes, whereas those on day 21 after BMT consisted of small sized CD4+,CD8+ cells which represent a great part in normal thymocytes. To define the developmental stage at which clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells occurs in adult thymus, we followed the fate of V beta 6- or V beta 11-bearing T cells in the donor-derived thymocytes at the early stage of AKR----C3H chimeras. Mature thymocytes expressing high intensity of V beta 6 or V beta 11, which are involved in recognition of Mls-1a or MHC I-E gene products, respectively, were deleted from the donor-derived thymocytes on day 21. Immature thymocytes expressing low intensity of V beta 6 in CD3low thymocyte fraction decreased in proportion, whereas those expressing low intensity of V beta 11 rather increased in proportion in the donor-derived thymocytes of AKR----C3H chimeras from day 14 to day 21 after BMT. These results suggest that the clonal deletion of V beta 6-positive cells occurs just at the stage of immature CD3lowCD4+CD8+ cells, whereas the clonal deletion of V beta 11-positive cells may begin at the transitional stage from CD3lowCD4+CD8+ cells to CD3high single positive cells. Timing of negative selection of thymocytes may vary in distinct T cells capable of recognizing different self-Ag.     

Developmental regulation of alpha beta T cell antigen receptor expression results from differential stability of nascent TCR alpha proteins within the endoplasmic reticulum of immature and mature T cells.

The alpha beta T cell antigen receptor (TCR) that is expressed on most T lymphocytes is a multisubunit transmembrane complex composed of at least six different proteins (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, epsilon and zeta) that are assembled in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and then transported to the plasma membrane. Expression of the TCR complex is quantitatively regulated during T cell development, with immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes expressing only 10% of the number of surface alpha beta TCR complexes that are expressed on mature T cells. However, the molecular basis for low TCR expression in developing alpha beta T cells is unknown. In the present study we report the unexpected finding that assembly of nascent component chains into complete TCR alpha beta complexes is severely impaired in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes relative to their mature T cell progeny. In particular, the initial association of TCR alpha with TCR beta proteins, which occurs relatively efficiently in mature T cells, is markedly inefficient in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, even for a matched pair of transgenic TCR alpha and TCR beta proteins. Inefficient formation of TCR alpha beta heterodimers in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes was found to result from the unique instability of nascent TCR alpha proteins within the ER of immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, with nascent TCR alpha proteins having a median survival time of only 15 min in CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, but > 75 min in mature T cells. Thus, these data demonstrate that stability of TCR alpha proteins within the ER is developmentally regulated and provide a molecular basis for quantitative differences in alpha beta TCR expression on immature and mature T cells. In addition, these results provide the first example of a receptor complex whose expression is quantitatively regulated during development by post-translational limitations on receptor assembly.     

Diversity, rearrangement, and expression of murine T cell gamma genes

Although the T cell gamma genes are similar in many respects to T cell receptor alpha and beta genes, earlier studies suggested that only a single gamma variable (V gamma) gene is expressed in mature T cells. We report the isolation and characterization of three new rearranged V gamma genes from murine fetal thymocytes. Although each of the new V gamma gene rearrangements is present in fetal thymocytes, two of them are undetectable in mature T cells. The levels of mRNA corresponding to each type of V gamma gene rearrangement in mature T cells are dramatically diminished compared with those in fetal thymocytes, although the abundance of two of the rearranged genes is increased in mature T cells. Our results demonstrate that there is significant expressed variability of gamma genes in immature T cells. Furthermore, the dynamics of gamma gene rearrangement and expression support the idea that gamma genes function in immature T cells.     

Selective stimulation of thymocyte precursors mediated by specific cytokines. Different CD3+ subsets are generated by IL-1 versus IL-2.

The sequence of activation signals that stimulate proliferation, differentiation, and selection of mature T cell subsets from immature, dull-CD5+/CD4-, CD8- double negative (bCD5), (dCD5/DN) thymocytes are still unclear. However, it is likely that cytokines play integral roles in these events. Here we report that IL-1, in the presence of Con A, supports the proliferation and differentiation of highly purified dCD5/DN precursors into bright-CD5+ DN, CD2- lymphocytes with an apparently mature phenotype. These cells express CD3 and preferentially express the products of two TCR gene families, V beta 8 and V beta 6, whose expression is dependent on the allelic expression of the Mls-1 locus. Experiments, using DN thymocytes mixed with purified dCD5 subset of DN cells from a congenic strain of mice (i.e., expressing two different alleles of CD5) have shown that the cells that are stimulated by IL-1 and comitogen are derived from the immature dCD5 subset and not from the mature bCD5 cells contained within the DN subset. In contrast, IL-2 with the co-mitogen stimulates three- to fourfold higher levels of proliferation, from the same purified immature precursor population, and nearly a twofold increase in cell yield. However, the cells that were generated from precursor thymic cells stimulated with IL-2 represent a completely different T cell subset compared to IL-1-generated cells; these IL-2-stimulated cells express comparable levels of CD3, but also express substantial levels of CD2 and the TCR-gamma/delta, and a subset expresses CD8. These data suggest that these two TCR-alpha/beta and TCR-gamma/delta subsets of mature thymocytes use different cytokines and therefore possibly different stromal interactions to initiate differentiation.     

Clonogenic potential of murine CD4+8+ thymocytes. Direct demonstration using a V beta 6-specific proliferative stimulus in Mlsa mice

Although considerable indirect evidence supports the hypothesis that CD4+8+ thymocytes are developmental intermediates in the generation of mature (CD4+8- or CD4-8+) T cells, the ability of these cells to proliferate in vitro has been highly controversial. We demonstrate here that a fraction of purified murine CD4+8+ thymocytes can be induced to proliferate in response to immobilized anti-TCR mAb. To exclude possible proliferation by trace mature T cell contaminants, we have exploited our recent finding that in Mlsa mice mature V beta 6-bearing thymic T cells are virtually absent (less than or equal to 0.5%) due to clonal deletion, whereas V beta 6 +CD4+8+ thymocytes are present in much higher numbers (approximately 3%). Proliferation of sorted CD4+8+ thymocytes from Mlsa mice was therefore induced at limiting dilution with immobilized anti-V beta 6 mAb to select against any contaminating mature T cells. Under optimal culture conditions, the frequency of CD4+8+ thymocytes proliferating specifically to anti-V beta 6 mAb (1/1000) was higher than those obtained for purified CD4-8+ (1/2000) or CD4+8- (1/5000) subsets, thus demonstrating directly that a proportion (in this case 3%) of CD4+8+ thymocytes are potentially clonable. During culture, V beta 6 +CD4+8+ thymocytes gave rise to a mixture of phenotypically "immature" (CD4-8-) and "mature" (CD4-8+) T cells. This system should be valuable for further analysis of the elusive CD4+8+ thymocyte subset.     

Positive selection of the T cell repertoire: where and when does it occur?

The T cell repertoire is shaped by both positive and negative influences. T lymphocytes that express the V beta 6 variable region are positively selected in the thymus by cells expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II E molecules. To identify these cells, we have quantitated V beta 6+ T lymphocytes in a set of transgenic mice showing variant patterns of E expression in the thymus. We demonstrate that class II molecules must be expressed on epithelial cells of the cortex for positive selection to occur. Using a direct assay of unmanipulated thymocytes, we show that positive selection is manifest only as a rather late event in thymocyte differentiation, after the maturation of cortical double-positives into single-positives.     

T cell tolerance to Mlsa encoded antigens in T cell receptor V beta 8.1 chain transgenic mice.

To study T cell tolerance, transgenic mice were generated that expressed the Mlsa-reactive T cell receptor (TCR) beta chain V beta 8.1 (cDNA) under the control of the H-2Kb promoter/immunoglobulin heavy chain enhancer on approximately 90% of peripheral T cells. In transgenic mice bearing Mlsa, thymocytes expressing the TCR at a high density were deleted and the percentage of Thy 1.2+ lymph node cells was reduced. The CD4/CD8 ratio of mature T cells was reversed in Mlsa and Mlsb transgenic mice independent of the H-2. RNA analysis and immunofluorescence with TCR V beta-specific antibodies revealed that expression of endogenous TCR beta genes was suppressed. Both Mlsa and Mlsb TCR beta chain transgenic mice mounted a T-cell-dependent IgG response against viral antigens, whereas the capacity to generate alloreactive and virus-specific cytotoxic T cells was impaired in TCR beta chain transgenic Mlsa, but not in transgenic Mlsb mice.     

The immunocompetence of murine stromal cell-associated thymocytes

Thymocyte subpopulations that associate in vivo with distinct nonlymphoid cells of the thymus have been isolated, and their immunocompetence was analyzed. Previous studies have indicated that greater than 95% of such cells bear a surface antigen phenotype representative of immature thymocytes, and are among the earliest thymic compartments repopulated by bone marrow-derived cells after lethal and sub-lethal irradiation. Stromal cell-associated thymocytes may be activated in vivo because they proliferate well in vitro with no additional stimulus, and show little increase in proliferation with the addition of T cell mitogens or allogeneic spleen cells. Stromal cell-associated T cells contain cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors that are indistinguishable from mature peripheral T cells by the parameters of self tolerance, alloreactivity, H-2 restriction, and stringency of self H-2 preference. CTL precursor frequencies and the cytotoxic activity of cells further separated on the basis of high levels of Thy-1 expression argue against the possibility that stromal cell-associated CTL activity is due solely to contaminating mature lymphocytes. Our data suggest that stromal cell-associated thymocytes represent an intermediate subpopulation of thymocytes that is functionally mature and that expresses an immature surface phenotype. Furthermore, the imposition of self tolerance and MHC restriction specificity appears to be tightly associated with the acquisition of immunocompetence in these thymocyte subpopulations.     

Characterization of a new minor lymphocyte stimulatory system. I. Cluster of self antigens recognized by "I-E-reactive" V beta s, V beta 5, V beta 11, and V beta 12 T cell receptors for antigen.

In the mouse, two sets of V beta gene products have been shown to be associated with T cell recognition of endogenous self Ag. One of these is the set of V beta associated with T cell reactivities to stimulatory Mls gene products, Mlsa (V beta 6, V beta 8.1, V beta 9) or Mlsc (V beta 3); another is the set of V beta, such as V beta 5, V beta 11, V beta 12, or V beta 17a, which were originally found to be related to I-E recognition. Although the Mls system has been well characterized, little is known about the nature of the ligands for the second set of V beta. In this work, we describe the evidence that the natural ligand or ligands of V beta 5, V beta 11, and V beta 12 may be novel Mls determinants that are recognized by naive T cells at a high precursor frequency and function as the ligand for clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells by negative selection. However, surprisingly, unlike the conventional Mls system, in which all V beta associated with Mlsa recognition or Mlsc recognition are uniformly deleted in those animals expressing the relevant Mls type, expression of these three V beta segregates independently among strains. Based on these observations, the nature of T cell recognition for this new Mls gene product(s) is discussed.