Performance of small-scale CHO perfusion cultures using an acoustic cell filtration device for cell retention: characterization of separation efficiency and impact of perfusion on product quality

Several small-scale Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) suspension cultures were grown in perfusion mode using a new acoustic filtration system. The separation performance was evaluated at different cell concentrations and perfusion rates for two different CHO cell lines. It was found that the separation performance depends inversely on the cell concentration and perfusion rate. High media flow rates as well as high cell concentrations resulted in a significant drop in the separation performance, which limited the maximal cell concentration achievable. However, packed cell volumes of 10% to 16% (corresponding to 3 to 6. 10(7) cells/mL) could be reached and were maintained without additional bleeding after shifting the temperature to 33 degrees C. Perfusion, up to 50 days, did not harm the cells and did not result in a loss of performance of the acoustic filter as often seen with other perfusion systems. Volumetric productivities in perfusion mode were 2- to 12-fold higher for two cell lines producing two different glycoproteins when compared to fed-batch or batch processes using the same cell lines. Product concentrations were in the range of 20% to 80% of batch or fed-batch culture, respectively. In addition, using the protease-sensitive product rhesus thrombopoietin, we could show that cultivation in perfusion mode drastically reduced proteolysis when compared to a batch culture without addition of protease inhibitors such as leupeptin.     

Cell separator operation within temperature ranges to minimize effects on Chinese hamster ovary cell perfusion culture

A cell retention device that provides reliable high-separation efficiency with minimal negative effects on the cell culture is essential for robust perfusion culture processes. External separation devices generally expose cells to periodic variations in temperature, most commonly temperatures below 37 degrees C, while the cells are outside the bioreactor. To examine this phenomenon, aliquots of approximately 5% of a CHO cell culture were exposed to 60 s cyclic variations of temperature simulating an acoustic separator environment. It was found that, for average exposure temperatures between 31.5 and 38.5 degrees C, there were no significant impacts on the rates of growth, glucose consumption, or t-PA production, defining an acceptable range of operating temperatures. These results were subsequently confirmed in perfusion culture experiments for average exposure temperatures between 31.6 and 38.1 degrees C. A 2(5-1) central composite factorial design experiment was then performed to systematically evaluate the effects of different operating variables on the inlet and outlet temperatures of a 10L acoustic separator. The power input, ambient temperature, as well as the perfusion and recycle flow rates significantly influenced the temperature, while the cell concentration did not. An empirical model was developed that predicted the temperature changes between the inlet and the outlet of the acoustic separator within +/-0.5 degrees C. A series of perfusion experiments determined the ranges of the significant operational settings that maintained the acoustic separator inlet and outlet temperatures within the acceptable range. For example, these objectives were always met by using the manufacturer-recommended operational settings as long as the recirculation flow rate was maintained above 15 L day(-1) and the ambient temperature was near 22 degrees C.     

Scaleup of spinfilter perfusion bioreactor for mammalian cell retention

A spinning cylindrical filter, known as a spinfilter, permits the mammalian cell bioreactor operation at high perfusion rates leading to very high cell densities (10(7) mL(-1)). Filter screens with openings (25 mum) slightly larger than the average cell size have been used to retain single cells in suspension over a long period of operation without clogging. We have previously shown why it is necessary to optimize the rotational speed of the spinfilter in order to achieve efficient cell retention and avoid potential screen clogging. Effects of bulk mixing and perfusion rate on screen fouling and cell retention were also investigated. Based on this analysis, in this article, we suggest strategies for scaleup of spinfilters. Experimental data from 12- and 175-L (working volume) bioreactors is shown in support of the scaleup analysis. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Optimization of an acoustic cell filter with a novel air-backflush system

Increasing worldwide demand for mammalian cell production capacity will likely be partially satisfied by a greater use of higher volumetric productivity perfusion processes. An important additional component of any perfusion system is the cell retention device that can be based on filtration, sedimentation, and/or acoustic technologies. A common concern with these systems is that pumping and transient exposure to suboptimal medium conditions may damage the cells or influence the product quality. A novel air-backflush mode of operating an acoustic cell separator was developed in which an injection of bioreactor air downstream of the separator periodically returned the captured cells to the reactor, allowing separation to resume within 20 s. This mode of operation eliminated the need to pump the cells and allows the selection of a residence time in the separator depending on the sensitivity of the cell line. The air-backflush mode of operating a 10L acoustic separator was systematically tested at 10(7) cells/mL to define reliable ranges of operation. Consistent separation performance was obtained for wide ranges of cooling airflow rates from 0 to 15 L/min and for backflush frequencies between 10 and 40 h(-1). The separator performance was optimized at a perfusion rate of 10 L/day to obtain a maximum separation efficiency of 92 +/- 0.3%. This was achieved by increasing the power setting to 8 W and using duty cycle stop and run times of 4.5 and 45 s, respectively. Acoustic cell separation with air backflush was successfully applied over a 110 day CHO cell perfusion culture at 10(7) cells/mL and 95% viability.     

Comparison of fluidized bed and ultrasonic cell-retention systems for high cell density mammalian cell culture

Economically viable biopharmaceutical production is to a high degree dependent on high product yields and stable fermentation systems that are easy to handle. In the current study we have compared two different fermentation systems for the production of recombinant protein from CHO cells. Both systems are fully scaleable and can be used for industrial high cell density bioprocesses. As a model cell line we have used a recombinant CHO cell line producing the enzyme arylsulfatase B (ASB). CHO cells were cultivated as adherent cell culture attached on Cytoline macroporous microcarrier (Amersham Biosciences, Sweden) using a Cytopilot Mini fluidized bed bioreactor (FBR, Vogelbusch-Amersham Biosciences, Austria) and as suspension culture using a stirred tank bioreactor equipped with a BioSep ultrasonic resonator based cell separation device (Applikon, The Netherlands). Both systems are equally well-suited for stable, long-term high cell density perfusion cell culture and provide industrial scalability and high yields. For products such as the recombinant ASB, high perfusion rates and therefore short product bioreactor residence times may be of additional benefit.     

Potential of cell retention techniques for large-scale high-density perfusion culture of suspended mammalian cells

This review focuses on cultivation of mammalian cells in a suspended perfusion mode. The major technological limitation in the scaling-up of these systems is the need for robust retention devices to enable perfusion of medium as needed. For this, cell retention techniques available to date are presented, namely, cross-flow filters, hollow fibers, controlled-shear filters, vortex-flow filters, spin-filters, gravity settlers, centrifuges, acoustic settlers, and hydrocyclones. These retention techniques are compared and evaluated for their respective advantages and potential for large-scale utilization in the context of industrial manufacturing processes. This analysis shows certain techniques have a limited range of perfusion rate where they can be implemented (most microfiltration techniques). On the other hand, techniques were identified that have shown high perfusion capacity (centrifuges and spin-filters), or have a good potential for scale-up (acoustic settlers and inclined settlers). The literature clearly shows that reasonable solutions exist to develop large-scale perfusion processes.     

An on-line method for the reduction of fouling of spin-filters for animal cell perfusion cultures

The main limitation in the use of spin-filters during perfusion cultures of animal cells was revealed to be filter fouling. This phenomenon involves cell-sieve interactions as well as cell attachment to, and growth on, the filter surface. The cell attachment effect has been analysed in the present study during long-term perfusion simulations with CHO animal cells. It was demonstrated that at low filter acceleration, below 6.2 m/s2, a high perfusion rate of 25 cm/h induced rapid filter pore clogging within 3 days, whereas increasing the filter acceleration to 25 m/s2 increased filter longevity from 3 to 25 days, for filters with a pore size of 8.5 microm. Increasing the filter pore size to 14.5 microm improved filter longevity by 84% with less viable and dead cell deposits on the filter surface. However, it was demonstrated that filter longevity was not necessarily dependent on the amount of cell deposit on the filter surface. In the second part of this study, ultrasonic technology was used to reduce filter fouling. Filter vibration, induced by a piezo actuator, improved filter longevity by 113% during CHO cells perfusion cultures.     

Mammalian cell retention in a spinfilter perfusion bioreactor

A spinning cylindrical filter is often used to retain mammalian cells in a continuous perfusion bioreactor. This device, known as a spinfilter, has typically been with pore size smaller than the cell particles (single cells or aggregates) in order to achieve cell separation. For single cells in suspension, such an operation cannot be sustained over a long period of time because of clogging of the filter surface. Recently, screens with openings larger than the average cell size have been used to reduce the incidence of clogging. In this article, we have investigated how the screen size affects cell retention. We also showed why it is necessary to optimize the rotational speed of the spinfilter in order to achieve cell retention and reduce screen clogging. Effects of bulk mixing and perfusion rate on screen fouling cell retention, and cell washout were also investigated. (c) 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Influence of flow rate and scaffold pore size on cell behavior during mechanical stimulation in a flow perfusion bioreactor

Mechanically stimulating cell-seeded scaffolds by flow-perfusion is one approach utilized for developing clinically applicable bone graft substitutes. A key challenge is determining the magnitude of stimuli to apply that enhances cell differentiation but minimizes cell detachment from the scaffold. In this study, we employed a combined computational modeling and experimental approach to examine how the scaffold mean pore size influences cell attachment morphology and subsequently impacts upon cell deformation and detachment when subjected to fluid-flow. Cell detachment from osteoblast-seeded collagen-GAG scaffolds was evaluated experimentally across a range of scaffold pore sizes subjected to different flow rates and exposure times in a perfusion bioreactor. Cell detachment was found to be proportional to flow rate and inversely proportional to pore size. Using this data, a theoretical model was derived that accurately predicted cell detachment as a function of mean shear stress, mean pore size, and time. Computational modeling of cell deformation in response to fluid flow showed the percentage of cells exceeding a critical threshold of deformation correlated with cell detachment experimentally and the majority of these cells were of a bridging morphology (cells stretched across pores). These findings will help researchers optimize the mean pore size of scaffolds and perfusion bioreactor operating conditions to manage cell detachment when mechanically simulating cells via flow perfusion.     

High-density perfusion culture of insect cells with a biosep ultrasonic filter

The baculovirus/insect cell expression system has provided a vital tool to produce a high level of active proteins for many applications. We have developed a very high-density insect cell perfusion process with an ultrasonic filter as a cell retention device. The separation efficiency of the filter was studied under various operating conditions. A cell density of over 30 million cells/mL was achieved in a controlled perfusion bioreactor and cell viability remained greater than 90%. Sf9 cells from a high-density culture and a spinner culture were infected with two recombinant baculoviruses expressing genes for the production of human chitinase and monocyte-colony inhibition factor. The protein yield on a cell basis from infecting high-density Sf9 cells was the same as or higher than that from the spinner Sf9 culture. Virus production from the high-density culture was similar to that from the spinner culture. The results show that the ultrasonic filter did not affect insect cells' ability to support protein expression and virus production following infection with baculovirus. The potential applications of the high-density perfusion culture for large-scale protein expression from Sf9 cells are also highlighted.     

Production of a self-activating CBM-factor X fusion protein in a stable transformed Sf9 insect cell line using high cell density perfusion culture

Factor Xa is a serine protease, whose high selectivity can be used to cleave protein tags from recombinant proteins. A fusion protein comprised of a self-activating form of factor X linked to a cellulose-binding module, saCBMFX, was produced in a stable transformed Sf9 insect cell line. The activity of the insect cell produced saCBMFX was higher than the equivalent mammalian cell produced material. A 1.5 l batch fermentation reached a maximum cell concentration of 1.6 × 10⁷ cells ml⁻¹ and a final saCBMFX concentration of 4 mg l⁻¹. The production of saCBMFX by this cell line was also analyzed in a 1.5 l perfusion system using an ultrasonic filter as a cell-retention device for flow rates up to 3.5 l day⁻¹. The cell-retention efficiency of an air backflush mode of acoustic filter operation was greater than 95% and eliminated the need to pump the relatively shear sensitive insect cells. In the perfusion system over 4 × 10⁷ Sf9 cells ml⁻¹ were obtained with a viability greater than 80%. With a doubling of viable cell concentration from 1.5 to 3 × 10⁷ cells ml⁻¹ the saCBMFX production rate was doubled to 6 mg l⁻¹ day⁻¹. The saCBMFX volumetric productivity of the perfusion system was higher than the batch fermentations (0.6 mg l⁻¹ day⁻¹) by an order of magnitude.     

Stimulus secretion coupling in vitro: a rapid perfusion apparatus for monitoring efflux of transmitter substances from tissue samples.

An apparatus for monitoring efflux rates of specific substances from cellular preparations is described. Tissue samples (homogenates, subcellular fractions, small tissue slices, cell suspensions etc.) are placed on a filter, perfused with several different media sequentially and aliquots of the perfusate collected at intervals of 5 sec. Under maximum perfusion rates, the changeover in perfusion media is completed in less than 1 sec, produces no detectable disturbance of the sample and allows only minimal mixing of the different media. The apparatus has been used successfully to study stimulus secretion coupling during release of the neurotransmitter [¹⁴C]γ-aminobutyric acid from synaptosomes.     

Optimizing performance of semi‐continuous cell culture in an ambr15™ microbioreactor using dynamic flux balance modeling

The ambr bioreactors are single‐use microbioreactors for cell line development and process optimization. With operating conditions for large‐scale biopharmaceutical production properly scaled down, microbioreactors such as the ambr15? can potentially be used to predict the effect of process changes such as modified media or different cell lines. While there have been some recent studies evaluating the ambr15? technology as a scale‐down model for fed‐batch operations, little has been reported for semi‐continuous or continuous operation. Gassing rates and dilution rates in the ambr15? were varied in this study to attempt to replicate performance of a perfusion process at the 5 L scale. At both scales, changes to metabolite production and consumption, and cell growth rate and therapeutic protein production were measured. Conditions were identified in the ambr15? bioreactor that produced metabolic shifts and specific metabolic and protein production rates that are characteristic of the corresponding 5 L perfusion process. A dynamic flux balance (DFB) model was employed to understand and predict the metabolic changes observed. The DFB model predicted trends observed experimentally, including lower specific glucose consumption and a switch from lactate production to consumption when dissolved CO₂ was maintained at higher levels in the broth. © 2017 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 34:420–431, 2018     

The effects of alternating tangential flow (ATF) residence time,hydrodynamic stress,and filtration flux on high-density perfusion cell culture

In this study, we investigated the effects of alternating tangential flow (ATF) cell separation on high-density perfusion cultures. We have developed methods to estimate theoretical residence times of cells in the ATF system and discovered that long residence times (above 75 s) correlate with decreased growth, metabolism, and productivity. We have calculated energy dissipation rates in the ATF transfer line and filter and empirically studied the impacts of increased exchange rates on cell culture, determining that increased hydrodynamic stress can lead to decreased cell size, lactate production, and specific productivity. Finally, we have conducted experiments to understand the relationship between filtration fluxes and ATF membrane fouling, finding that at fluxes above 60 L·m^–2·day ^–1, protein sieving coefficients see significant rates of decrease (greater than 1% per day). While most of these studies have been conducted with one cell line at one target viable cell density (40 million cells/ml), the general, directional knowledge arising from this study should be applicable to other conditions and programs, ultimately leading to more robust and well-designed perfusion processes.     

Separation of viable and nonviable animal cell using dielectrophoretic filter

Selective separation of cells using dielectrophoresis (DEP) has recently been studied and methods have been proposed. However, these methods are not applicable to large‐scale separation because they cannot be performed efficiently. In DEP separation, the DEP force is effective only when it is applied close to the electrodes. Utilizing a DEP filter is a solution for large‐scale separation. In this article, the separation efficiency for viable and nonviable cells in a DEP filter was examined. The effects of an applied AC electric field frequency and the gradient of the squared electric field intensity on a DEP velocity for the viable and nonviable animal cells (3‐2H3 cell) were discussed. The frequency response of the DEP velocity differed between the viable and the nonviable cells. We deducted an empirical equation that can be used as guiding principle for the DEP separation. The results indicate that the viable and the nonviable cells were separated using the DEP filter, and the best operating conditions such as the applied voltage and the flow rate were discussed. © 2010 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Optical analysis of perfusion bioreactor cell concentration in an acoustic separator

Automated monitoring of cell concentration in perfusion bioprocesses facilitates the maintenance of constant cell specific perfusion rates. However, most on-line measuring devices are relatively complex and foul as the culture progresses. A simple external optical sensor was developed using the transparent glass walls of acoustic separators for automated optical analysis of their contents. For each measurement, the separator was filled by an automated pumping system with triplicate representative bioreactor samples that were optically analyzed and the device returned to perfusion operation within approximately 1 or 2 min. Chinese hamster ovary cell concentrations, ranging from 5 x 10(5) to 2 x 10(7) cells/mL, were highly correlated (R(2) = 0.99) with the 90 degrees scattered light response. Since the device was operated externally, it did not complicate bioreactor sterilization or cleaning. Viability was not optically analyzed, but this information was not required between manual samples of a properly operated perfusion process. Using single-point recalibration based on routine off-line samples, this external optical system remained effective during a 4-month perfusion run, thus providing a non-invasive and easily maintained on-line cell concentration monitoring system to improve the control of perfusion bioreactors.     

Artificial capillary perfusion cell culture: metabolic studies.

Glucose, lactic-acid, and oxygen metabolism of BHK and L929 cells on artificial capillary perfusion units have been studied using several different modes of perfusion. After 7 to 10 days, cells planted in the extracapillary compartment of culture units containing 80 to 150 fibers reached populations that used 0.073 +/- 0.025 mumol per min glucose and 0.76 +/- 0.26 microliter per min oxygen and excreted 0.078 +/- 0.038 mumol per min lactic acid. From these data it is estimated that these units contain approximately 2 x 10(7) cells. The metabolic rate of cultures perfused through the capillaries or through the extracapillary compartment was not affected significantly by change in flow rate except at perfusion flow rates less than or equal to 0.05 ml per min. The cell population, as measured by metabolic activity, did not increase significantly when the serum content of the medium was less than or equal to 1%. No major differences were found in glucose utilization rates of equal numbers of cells on artificial capillaries, on short-term suspension culture, or as monolayers in plastic flasks. Artificial capillary perfusion may provide a simple system for studying metabolism of mammalian cells in culture.     

An integrated process for mammalian cell perfusion cultivation and product purification using a dynamic filter

In the present work, a dynamic filter was employed to develop an integrated perfusion/purification process. A recombinant CHO cell line producing a human anti-HIV IgG was employed in the experiments. In the first part of this work, the dynamic filter was fitted with conventional microfiltration membranes and tested as a new external cell retention device for perfusion cultivations. The filter was connected to a running perfusion bioreactor and operated for approximately 400 h at an average cell concentration of 10 million cells mL(-)(1), whereby cell viability remained above 90% and no problems of sterility were experienced. In the second part of this work, the dynamic filter was employed to simultaneously carry out cell separation and product purification, using membrane adsorbers containing Protein A affinity ligands. An automated system was built, which integrated the features of an automated perfusion bioreactor and of a liquid chromatography system. The IgG was continuously adsorbed onto the affinity membranes and was periodically recovered through elution cycles. After connection of the filter, the system was operated for approximately 300 h, whereby three elution cycles were carried out. No progressive increase in transmembrane pressure was observed, indicating no membrane fouling problems, and the IgG was recovered practically free of contaminants in a 14-fold concentrated form, indicating that the integrated, one-step perfusion/purification process developed during this work is a promising alternative for the production of biologicals derived from mammalian cells.     

Selective removal of ammonia from animal cell culture broth

Serum-free perfusion cultures of hybridoma TO-405 cells were carried out in spinner flasks coupled with zeolite A-3 packed beads. Ammonia was selectively removed from the culture broth by passing cell free permeate from ceramic cross flow filtration, through the zeolite packed bed. Ammonia concentration in the culture broth was effectively maintained between 1 to 4 mmol/l which was below the inhibitory concentration for cell growth. Maximum cell density levels of 10⁷ cells/ml as well as improved percentage cell viability higher than in serum-supplemented cultures were feasible in this system.The possible effects of shear stress, generated by variation of the flow rates of the broth through the ceramic filter module, on the growth of the hybridoma cells were investigated. Backwashing, by reversing the direction of the permeate, was found necessary to prolong the life of the filter. Variation of the flow rates of the broth through the ceramic module between 0.29 m/s to 0.59 m/s did not cause immediate cell damage but growth was repressed at the higher flow rate.This study also showed that glutamine appears to be one of the factors limiting the growth of the hybridoma cells.