Antigen binding to receptors on immunocompetent cells. II. Thermodynamic and biological implications of the receptor cross-linking requirement for B-cell activation.

If one assumes that receptor cross-linking is a necessary, but not sufficient condition for cellular activation, a number of predictions can be made bearing on the physical chemical properties of the cells selected. In this paper we show that the following response characteristics can be consequences of a cross-linking requirement. (1) Small sparsely haptenated antigens such as DNP₁₀BSA are expected to elicit a response that matures, and such maturation can occur even with antigenic determinant density in excess over the concentration of cellular receptors. (2) There is an optimal concentration for activation of cells with a given affinity, and therefore an optimally immunogenic dose. (3) The optimal dose is relatively insensitive to antigen valence. (4) Increasing valence increases the breadth of the affinity distribution. (5) For supra optimal doses of antigen, unresponsiveness will be preferentially induced in high affinity cells. (6) Small densely haptenated antigens (e.g. DNP₄₀BSA) are not expected to elicit responses that mature as quickly as those that are lightly coupled. (7) Large polymeric antigens are not expected to induce responses that mature. (8) Antigens with low determinant density may induce tolerance in vivo but not in vitro. The predictions are briefly discussed in the context of relevant experimental data.     

Analysis of binding curves in multivalent antigen-heterogeneous antibody systems

The binding of antibodies to N-valent antigens can be utilized to gain information on the antibody affinity distribution, under the assumption, that the formation of each bond occurs as an independent event. The analysis of the most widely used plots of binding data (double reciprocal, Scatchard, Sips and the so-called “avidity” plot) leads to expressions which correlate asymptotical features of the binding curves to the antibody site concentration to the antigen valence and to the affinity moments <K^?1>, <K> and <K²>. Only in the “avidity” plot is the shape of the curve independent of the valence of the antigen, depending merely on the antibody affinity distribution.     

Reversible binding of multivalent antigen in the control of B lymphocyte activation.

A model is proposed describing multiple binding of multivalent antigen to specific receptors of immunocompetent cells. The rate at which these multiple bonds can dissociate and the effective valence of the antigen appear to be of the greatest importance in determining the degree of receptor occupancy at equilibrium. In particular, as antigen concentration decreases, only antigens with high number of determinants per molecule maintain the ability to form multiple bonds even if the dissociation rate is relatively high. Assuming that multiple binding is directly linked to lymphocyte activation, this may result in an inverse relation between antigen valence and ability to induce selection of clones with higher affinities.     

Mechanogenetic Coupling of Hydra Symmetry Breaking and Driven Turing Instability Model

The freshwater polyp Hydra can regenerate from tissue fragments or random cell aggregates. We show that the axis-defining step (“symmetry breaking”) of regeneration requires mechanical inflation-collapse oscillations of the initial cell ball. We present experimental evidence that axis definition is retarded if these oscillations are slowed down mechanically. When biochemical signaling related to axis formation is perturbed, the oscillation phase is extended and axis formation is retarded as well. We suggest that mechanical oscillations play a triggering role in axis definition. We extend earlier reaction-diffusion models for Hydra regrowth by coupling morphogen transport to mechanical stress caused by the oscillations. The modified reaction-diffusion model reproduces well two important experimental observations: 1), the existence of an optimum size for regeneration, and 2), the dependence of the symmetry breaking time on the properties of the mechanical oscillations.     

Natural cytotoxic reactivity of human lymphocytes against a myeloid cell line: characterization of effector cells.

Using a series of techniques to identify and deplete various peripheral blood lymphocyte subpopulations, we studied the cytotoxic reactivity of normal individuals against the myeloid cell line K-562 in a 4-hr 51chromium-release assay. Depletion of lymphocytes bearing complement receptors had a variable, usually negligible effect on cytotoxicity. In contrast, depletion of lymphocytes bearing Fc receptors abrogated target cell lysis. Separation of lymphocytes with high-affinity binding of sheep red blood cells (SRBC) evidenced by rosette formation at 29 degrees C yielded a population of rosette-forming cells containing few cytotoxic cells, whereas separation of total E-RFC under optimal rosetting conditions produced a rosette fraction containing a major proportion of the effector cells. These data indicate that the cytotoxic lymphocyte in this system is Fc receptor positive, largely complement receptor negative, and may possess low density or low affinity receptors for SRBC.     

Antigen modulation of the secondary immune response. VI. Contribution of cells recruited from precursor pool to expression of memory.

The adoptive transfer system has been used extensively to study the ability of antigen triggered memory cells to become antibody forming cells and/or to proliferate and expand the memory cell population. Selective antigen triggering of the memory cells for low and high affinity antibody formation has also been studied in this way. One of the main counter-arguments to the interpretation of these data is that the presence of antigen in the adoptive host may lead to recruitment of new memory cells from either a host or donor precursor population. In this paper we examined the contribution of both host and donor precursor cells to the total antibody response in adoptive secondary recipients. The following donor-host combinations were used in which the recipients were given 1 mg fluid antigen intravenously: (A) normal (non-immune) donors to normal irradiated recipients; (B) normal donors to carrier primed irradiated recipients; (C) carrier primed donors to normal irradiated recipients; (D) normal donors to carrier primed recipients with challenge and subsequent transfer to additional carrier primed recipients; (E) carrier primed donor to normal recipients to carrier primed recipients; (F) repeat of B and C above with multiple antigen administration; (G) purified immune (DNP-BGG) donor T cells mixed with normal B cells transferred to normal irradiated recipients. In most cases recruitment was seen but this represented less than 4% of the responses seen with immune cells. Thus we conclude that this level of recruitment does not compromise the use of the adoptive transfer system for studying selective antigen triggering of memory cells.     

Molecular and cellular aspects of immunologic tolerance.

This review seeks to explain the most exciting recent data concerning the nature of self/non-self discrimination by the immune system in a manner accessible to a biochemical readership. The nature of recognition in the two great lymphocyte families, B cells and T cells, is described with special emphasis on the nature of the ligands recognized by each. The history of the field of immunologic tolerance is surveyed, as are the key experiments on conventional mice which provided a conceptual framework. This suggested that tolerance was essentially due to 'holes' in the recognition repertoires of both the T and B cell populations so that lymphocytes competent to react to self antigens were not part of the immunologic dictionary. There were essentially two ways to achieve this situation. On the one hand, self antigens might 'catch' developing lymphocytes early in their ontogeny and delete the cell, a process of clonal abortion. On the other hand, self antigens might signal lymphocytes (particularly immature cells) in a negative manner, reducing or abolishing their capacity for later responses, without causing death. This process is referred to as clonal anergy. Evidence for both processes exists. Special emphasis is placed on a wave of experimentation beginning in 1988 which imaginatively uses transgenic mouse technology to study tolerance. Transgenic manipulations can produce mice which synthesize foreign antigens in a constitutive and/or inducible manner, sometimes only in specific locations; mice which possess T or B lymphocytes almost all expressing a given receptor of known specificity; and mice which are an immunologic time bomb in that the antigen is present and so too are lymphocytes all endowed with receptors for that antigen. These experiments have vindicated the possibility of both clonal abortion and clonal anergy in both T and B cell populations, the choice of which phenomenon occurs depending on a number of operational circumstances. For T cell tolerance, clonal abortion occurs if the self antigenic determinant concerned is present within the thymus; if not, clonal anergy is more likely. For B cell tolerance, the strength of the negative signal and therefore the choice between abortion and anergy depends on the molar concentration of the self antigen, the capacity for multivalent presentation to a B cell, and the affinity of the B cell's receptor for the antigen in question. Some B cells with low affinity for self antigens certainly escape censorship and remain capable of secreting low affinity anti-self antibodies, which however do no harm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Membrane dynamics of lymphocyte interaction with antigen and tolerogen.

The principle of hapten-specific carrier-dependent immunologic tolerance was used to study the in vivo and in vitro interaction of lymphocyte membrane receptors with antigen (DNP-KLH) and tolerogen (DNP-MGG). Direct fluorescent techniques were employed to illustrate the binding of tolerogeu and antigen to the same population of lymphoid cells and the subsequent in vivo and in vitro events related to capping and regeneration of membrane receptors.     

Reactivity of human lymphocytes to aggregated and nonaggregated PPD-tuberculin

PPD-tuberculin was adsorbed to bentonite and the effect of this preparation on induction of DNA synthesis in cultures of human lymphocytes was compared to that of ordinary soluble PPD. At high PPD concentrations the two preparations gave rise to comparable responses. At lower concentrations the bentonite-PPD always stimulated stronger lymphocyte responses than soluble PPD. Lymphocytes exposed to bentonite-PPD became activated earlier than cells confronted with soluble PPD. It is suggested that the findings are caused by a more efficient interaction between particle-bound as compared to soluble antigen and lymphocytes having low affinity receptors for the antigen.     

THE MECHANISM OF COMPLEMENT FIXATION

1. Complement fixation is obtained in every antigen-antibody reaction involving the presence or formation of a heterogeneous phase (red cells, bacteria, precipitate). 2. The physical constants of fixation (temperature coefficient, velocity, quantitative relationships between the reactants) are those commonly associated with adsorption processes, and are the same in the three types of fixation studied. 3. All the in vitro immune reactions involve an aggregation of immune-serum globulins upon the surface of the antigen. It has been shown that the "fixation" of complement is an adsorption by the aggregates so formed; whether these aggregates are visible as a flocculent precipitate (e.g., sheep serum vs. anti-serum) or concentrated as a surface film on a cellular antigen (sensitized cells; agglutinated bacteria), the reaction is fundamentally the same. 4. As yet, it is unknown whether this adsorption is determined by the physical state of the precipitate, and thus, differs only quantitatively from that by Kaolin, charcoal, normal bacteria, heat-denatured proteins, etc.; or whether the comparatively enormous avidity of these aggregates for complement is due to a specific chemical affinity.     

Relative ligand binding to small or large aggregates measured by scanning correlation spectroscopy.

Cell surface receptors transduce signals, required to produce cellular activity, that may be mediated by ligand-induced receptor aggregation. Several receptor systems exhibit both low and high ligand affinities and some models of receptor activation associate receptor clusters with high or low ligand binding affinity. In the present work succinyl concanavalin A, which binds with both high and low affinity to receptors, was studied on 3T3 Swiss mouse fibroblasts, where preaggregation of receptors has been postulated. Scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy measurements were used to determine the relationship between the degree of ligand binding and the state of receptor aggregation. Correlation analysis of fluorescence fluctuations across the cell surface reveal that the variance of the fluctuations (quantitated by g[0]) increased when the ligand concentration was varied from 0.33 to 67 mg/L. The g(0) values reached a plateau at concentrations greater than approximately 10 mg/L. These data are incompatible with homogeneous receptor distributions or equal affinity receptor binding but are compatible with a partly aggregated receptor system with high affinity binding to small aggregates, and low affinity binding to large aggregates. Computer simulated scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy experiments confirm that background fluorescence from the cell does not account for the experimentally observed effects.     

Lymphocyte alpha-actinin. Relationship to cell membrane and co-capping with surface receptors

Mouse spleen lymphocytes synthesize a protein which comigrates with skeletal muscle alpha-actinin on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and is immunoprecipitated by an antibody directed against skeletal muscle alpha-actinin. Mouse lymphocyte alpha-actinin is present in membrane fractions, and is immunoprecipitated from lymphocyte detergent lysates by an antiserum made against these purified membranes. The anti- alpha-actinin activity of this antiserum is not adsorbed after incubation with fixed intact lymphocytes. Lymphocyte alpha-actinin does not bind concanavalin A and it is inaccessible to lactoperoxidase- catalyzed surface iodination. Double immunofluorescence shows that alpha-actinin moves concurrently along the cell membrane with redistributed surface immunoglobulins and Thy-1 antigen, and remains associated up to 30 min with surface aggregates of these receptors. Our results suggest that lymphocyte alpha-actinin, as defined by molecular weight and cross reactivity with the antibody against the muscle protein, (a) is associated with the cell membrane, (b) is not expressed at the cell surface, and (c) participates in the movement of surface receptors.     

Periodate-induced lymphocyte transformation. 3. Effects of temperature and pH

The optimum conditions for sodium periodate induced lymphocyte transformation occur at low concentrations of NaIO₄, low temperature, pH between 6 and 7.5, and with short periods of exposure to the NaIO₄. Exposures for prolonged times at elevated temperatures or to NaIO₄ at pH above 7.5 result in diminished responses. The finding of maximum lymphocyte response under these conditions is compatible with the proposal that the triggering event in NaIO₄ transformation of lymphocytes is the oxidation and cleavage of the two terminal carbon atoms of sialic acid. Exposure of lymphocytes to NaIO₄ under conditions of higher temperature, higher pH or longer exposure times does not significantly reduce their ability to respond to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) or pokeweed mitogen (PWM). This finding suggests that these mitogens have different target sites from that of NaIO₄ or that they are acting on different populations of lymphocytes.     

Beta-adrenergic-receptor-mediated suppression of interleukin 2 receptors in human lymphocytes

Adrenergic receptor agonists are known to attenuate the proliferative response of human lymphocytes after activation; however, their mechanism of action is unknown. Since expression of interleukin 2 (IL-2) receptors is a prerequisite for proliferation, the effect of beta-adrenergic receptor agonists on lymphocyte IL-2 receptors was studied on both mitogen-stimulated lymphocytes and IL-2-dependent T lymphocyte cell lines. In both cell types the beta-adrenergic receptor agonist isoproterenol blocked the expression of IL-2 receptors, as determined with the IL-2 receptor anti-TAC antibody. To determine the effect of beta-adrenergic agonists on expression of the high affinity IL-2 receptors, [125I]IL-2 binding studies were performed at concentrations selective for high affinity sites. No significant effect of beta-adrenergic agonists on high affinity IL-2 receptor sites could be detected. The data demonstrate that beta-adrenergic receptor agonists down-regulate IL-2 receptors primarily affecting low affinity sites.     

Studies on the regulation of igm immune response. VII. changes in the affinity of antibodies and cell receptors after immunization with the T-cell independent antigen DNP-Ficoll.

A/J-mice immunized by a single injection with DNP21-Ficoll respond on the humoral level exclusively with IgM antibodies. The intrinsic association constants (K0) of IgM anti-DNP to monovalent hapten E-DNP-L-lysine are within the range of 105-106 M-1 and do not change significantly during the immune response. On the other hand, the functional association constants (KF) of pentameric IgM to multivalent DNP-T4 bacteriophage increase from 1010 M-1 at 3rd day up to 1012 M-1 at 8th day. Subsequently, a decrease of KF to 1011 M-1 can be observed. This rise and fall of the affinity of IgM antibodies of multivalent DNP-conjugate can be detected at the cellular level also by inhibition of plaque formation. The concentration of DNP15-BSA needed for 50% inhibition of plaque formation (I50) decreases from second day to 8 th day by 4 orders, which represents a strong increase of functional affinity. In contrast, the I50 of E-DNP-L-lysine slightly decreases only until day 4 and does not change until day 21. the inhibition of rosette formation by mono- and multivalent ligands was used to study the affinity of lymphocyte receptors. In the course of immunization antigen-binding cells carrying receptors with increasingly higher affinity for multivalent DNP-conjugates occur. These results are discussed with regard to the importance of functional affinity of lymphocyte receptors for the antigen-driven selection of high affinity anti-DNP-cell clones producing IgM antibodies.     

The polyvalent protease inhibitor, trasylol, inhibits DNA synthesis of mouse lymphocytes by an indirect mechanism.

By the use of incorporation of radiolabeled thymidine, uridine, and leucine into mouse lymphocytes, the inhibitory effect of the protease inhibitor, trasylol, on antigenor mitogen-induced lymphocyte triggering was studied in vitro. DNA synthesis, as well as RNA and protein syntheses, were effectively inhibited by 0.3–2.5 × 10^?7 mol of trasylol when responses were induced by homologous antigen, allogeneic cells, phytohemagglutinin, or endotoxic lipopolysaccharide of Escherichia coli. The inhibitory effect of trasylol was reversible. On the contrary, DNA synthesis by nonadherent spleen cells was hardly inhibited by the inhibitor when the cells were stimulated with a relatively large amount of concanavalin A. Antigen-induced DNA synthesis by non-adherent lymph node cells was enhanced by the culture supernatant of macrophages. This helping effect of macrophage supernatant was effectively inhibited either by soluble or insoluble trasylol. These results suggest that the inhibitory action of trasylol on lymphocyte triggering may operate indirectly to interfere with the helping action of macrophages on lymphocytes.     

Results from modeling of B-Cell receptors binding to antigen

In the late 80's, Dintzis et al. conducted an experiment which showed that T-Cell independent activation of B-cells needs high-valence antigen and happens only in a narrow range of antigen concentration. These experiments were believed to be explained by the “immunon” theory that requires that a minimum number of receptors need to be cross-linked to activate a cell. However, the immunon theory does not take into account receptor dynamics and cannot explain the lack of immune response at high antigen concentration or low antigen valence. We propose instead a simple, new mechanism for the T-Cell independent activation of B-Cell, which includes receptor endocytosis. Our model focuses on the fact that for the majority of antigens where the B-Cell is activated with T-Cell help, the kinetic parameters for binding, unbinding and endocytosis must be tuned so that there is an equilibrium between the number of receptors bound on the surface of the B-Cell and the number of antigen-bound receptors endocytosed. This equilibrium mechanism is probably generic and will also occur even when the B-Cell is activated by antigen without T-Cell help. By computer modeling, we show that if we accept this hypothesis of the requirement for equilibrium between the two mechanisms of binding and endocytosis, then we can explain both the valence cutoff and the low and high zone tolerance seen in the Dintzis experiment.     

Kinetics of cell detachment: peeling of discrete receptor clusters.

Clustering of cell surface adhesion receptors is an essential step in the development of focal contacts, specialized cell-substrate attachment sites where receptors are simultaneously linked to extracellular ligand and cytoskeletal proteins. Previously, we examined the effect of receptor clustering on attachment strength. Here, we employ the numerical methodology developed by Dembo and colleagues (Dembo, M., D.C. Torney, K. Saxman, and D. Hammer. 1988. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. 234:55-83) to investigate the kinetics of cell detachment when receptors are clustered into discrete patches. We show that the membrane peeling velocity decreases if receptors are clustered within a patch located inside the contact region. Peeling of clusters is influenced by the chemistry and mechanics of receptor-ligand bonds within the patch. Detachment is also prohibited if the applied tension equals the critical tension of the patch, unless the patch length is small compared with the boundary length over which membrane bending occurs, in which case the patch will peel. Peeling of these short patches only occurs when the mechanical stiffness of clustered bonds is within an optimal range. We compare our model predictions with experimental measurements of T lymphocyte detachment from ICAM-1 substrates. We demonstrate that if discrete patches of receptors are present, detachment occurs through intervals of slow and fast peeling, similar to the dynamics of T lymphocyte peeling, indicating that clustering of LFA-1 receptors is one possible explanation for the observed detachment kinetics in this system.     

Antigen modulation of the immune response: IV. Selective triggering of antibody production and memory cell proliferation

When memory cells are transferred to syngeneic irradiated recipients and then challenged at various times after transfer, a precipitous decline in the ability of these cells to mount a secondary response is seen. Using this model we have investigated some of the influences which antigen can exert on the memory cell population. The results indicate that antigen may: 1) either stimulate the memory cells to proliferate and form new memory cells or stimulate memory cells to become antibody forming cells and 2) selectively trigger the memory cells for low or high affinity antibody production. This selective antigen triggering appeared to depend upon its concentration: high dose antigen challenge led to the production of large amounts of lower affinity antibody but stimulated less memory cell proliferation while low dose challenge showed just the opposite. Control experiments indicated that recruitment of new memory cells from a virgin precursor population was not responsible for these observations. Our results thus suggest that an asymmetrical division of memory cells is occurring in which antigen can exert selective influences in much the same way as seen with virgin precursor cells.     

Matrix vesicles in aging cartilage.

The calcification process that occurs in aging has been studied with the electron microscope in costal and tracheal cartilage of rats and in human costal cartilage. In these tissues, the early stage of the calcification process is induced and regulated by matrix vesicles in the same way as it occurs in epiphyseal cartilage, bone, and dentine. However, the spreading of inorganic substance from vesicles into the surrounding matrix is frequently impaired in aged cartilage, either because of a too low concentration of calcium ions, or because the structure of the cartilage matrix is not suitable for inorganic substance deposition. This shows that matrix vesicles have a calcium affinity and calcium-binding potentiality greater than that of other components of the cartilage matrix. Most matrix vesicles are produced by "Verd?mmerung der Zellen." This degenerative process of the chondrocytes leads also to the formation of pericellular halos consisting of aggregates of amorphous substance and thin filaments. Part of the material that forms these aggregates seems to be produced by disruption of matrix vesicles. Within this disruptive material, thick collagen fibrils can be formed. Moreover, this material seems capable of inducing calcification. These findings suggest that matrix vesicles, by releasing their content into the matrix, can be involved in some way in collagen formation, and that the released material maintains the calcium affinity and calcium-binding property it has within the vesicles.