Changes in the stability and biomechanics of P22 bacteriophage capsid during maturation

The capsid of P22 bacteriophage undergoes a series of structural transitions during maturation that guide it from spherical to icosahedral morphology. The transitions include the release of scaffold proteins and capsid expansion. Although P22 maturation has been investigated for decades, a unified model that incorporates thermodynamic and biophysical analyses is not available. A general and specific model of icosahedral capsid maturation is of significant interest to theoreticians searching for fundamental principles as well as virologists and material scientists seeking to alter maturation to their advantage. To address this challenge, we have combined the results from orthogonal biophysical techniques including differential scanning fluorimetry, atomic force microscopy, circular dichroism, and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry. By integrating these results from single particle and population measurements, an energy landscape of P22 maturation from procapsid through expanded shell to wiffle ball emerged, highlighting the role of metastable structures and the thermodynamics guiding maturation. The propagation of weak quaternary interactions across symmetric elements of the capsid is a key component for stability in P22. A surprising finding is that the progression to wiffle ball, which lacks pentamers, shows that chemical and thermal stability can be uncoupled from mechanical rigidity, elegantly demonstrating the complexity inherent in capsid protein interactions and the emergent properties that can arise from icosahedral symmetry. On a broader scale, this work demonstrates the power of applying orthogonal biophysical techniques to elucidate assembly mechanisms for supramolecular complexes and provides a framework within which other viral systems can be compared.     

Characterization of subunit structural changes accompanying assembly of the bacteriophage P22 procapsid

P22 serves as a model for the assembly and maturation of icosahedral double-stranded DNA viruses. The viral capsid precursor, or procapsid, is assembled from 420 copies of a 47 kDa coat protein subunit (gp5) that is rich in beta-strand secondary structure. Maturation to the capsid, which occurs in vivo upon DNA packaging, is accompanied by shell expansion and a large increase in the level of protection against deuterium exchange of amide NH groups. Accordingly, shell maturation resembles the final step in protein folding, wherein domain packing and an exchange-protected core become more fully developed [Tuma, R., Prevelige, P. E., Jr., and Thomas, G. J., Jr. (1998) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 95, 9885-9890]. Here, we exploit recent advances in Raman spectroscopy to investigate the P22 coat protein subunit under conditions which stabilize the monomeric state, viz., in solution at very low concentrations. Under these conditions, the monomer exhibits an elongated shape, as demonstrated by small-angle X-ray scattering. Raman spectra allow the identification of conformation-sensitive marker bands of the monomer, as well as the characterization of NH exchange dynamics for comparison with procapsid and capsid shell assemblies. We show that procapsid assembly involves significant ordering of the predominantly beta-strand backbone. We propose that such ordering may mediate formation of the distinct subunit conformations required for assembly of a T = 7 icosahedral lattice. However, the monomer, like the subunit within the procapsid lattice, exhibits a moderate level of protection against low-temperature NH exchange, indicative of a nascent folding core. The environments and exchange characteristics of key side chains are also similar for the monomeric and procapsid subunits, and distinct from corresponding characteristics of the capsid subunit. The monomer thus represents a compact but metastable folding intermediate along the pathway to assembly of the procapsid and capsid.     

Detection of intermediates and kinetic control during assembly of bacteriophage P22 procapsid

Bacteriophage P22 serves as a model for the assembly and maturation of other icosahedral double-stranded DNA viruses. P22 coat and scaffolding proteins assemble in vitro into an icosahedral procapsid, which then expands during DNA packaging (maturation). Efficient in vitro assembly makes this system suitable for design and production of monodisperse spherical nanoparticles (diameter ≈ 50 nm). In this work, we explore the possibility of controlling the outcome of assembly by scaffolding protein engineering. The scaffolding protein exists in monomer-dimer-tetramer equilibrium. We address the role of monomers and dimers in assembly by using three different scaffolding proteins with altered monomer-dimer equilibrium (weak dimer, covalent dimer, monomer). The progress and outcome of assembly was monitored by time-resolved X-ray scattering, which allowed us to distinguish between closed shells and incomplete assembly intermediates. Binding of scaffolding monomer activates the coat protein for assembly. Excess dimeric scaffolding protein resulted in rapid nucleation and kinetic trapping yielding incomplete shells. Addition of monomeric wild-type scaffold with excess coat protein completed these metastable shells. Thus, the monomeric scaffolding protein plays an essential role in the elongation phase by activating the coat and effectively lowering its critical concentration for assembly.     

Structure and assembly of the capsid of bacteriophage P22.

Identification of the genes and proteins involved in phage P22 formation has permitted a detailed analysis of particle assembly, revealing some unexpected aspects. The polymerization of the major coat protein (gene 5 product) into an organized capsid is directed by a scaffolding protein (gene 8 product) which is absent from mature phage. The resulting capsid structure (prohead) is the precursor for DNA encapsidation. All of the scaffolding protein exits from the prohead in association with DNA packaging. These molecules then recycle, directing further rounds of prohead assembly. The structure of the prohead has been studied by electron microscopy of thin sections of phage infected cells, and by low angle X-ray scattering of concentrated particles. The results show that the prohead is a double shell structure, or a ball within a shell. The inner ball or shell is composed of the scaffolding protein while the outer shell is composed of coat protein. The conversion from prohead to mature capsid is associated with an expansion of the coat protein shell. It is possible that the scaffolding protein molecules exit through the capsid lattice. When DNA encapsidation within infected cells is blocked by mutation, scaffolding protein is trapped in proheads and cannot recycle. Under these conditions, the rate of synthesis of gp8 increases, so that normal proheads continue to form. These results suggest that free scaffolding protein negatively regulates its own further synthesis, providing a coupling between protein synthesis and protein assembly.     

Conformational states of the bacteriophage P22 capsid subunit in relation to self-assembly

The formation of closed icosahedral capsids from a single species of coat protein subunit requires that the subunits assume different conformations at different lattice positions. In the double-stranded DNA bacteriophage P22, formation of correctly dimensioned capsids is mediated by interaction between coat protein subunits and scaffolding protein. Raman spectroscopy has been employed to compare the conformations of coat protein subunits which have been polymerized to form capsids in the presence and absence of the of scaffolding protein display a Raman spectrum characterized by a broad amide I band centered at 1665 cm-1 with a discernible shoulder near 1653 cm-1, and a broad amide III profile centered at 1238 cm-1 but asymmetrically skewed to higher frequency. These spectral features indicate that the protein conformation in procapsid shells is rich in beta-sheet secondary structure but contains also a significant distribution of alpha-helix. When biologically active, purified subunits assemble in the absence of scaffolding protein, they form polydisperse multimers lacking the proper dimensions of procapsid closed shells. We designate these multimers as "associated subunits" (AS). The Raman spectrum of associated subunits indicates a narrower distribution of secondary structure. The associated subunits are characterized by a sharper and more intense Raman amide I band at 1666 cm-1, with no prominent amide I shoulder of lower frequency. An analogous narrowing of the Raman amide III profile is also observed for AS particles, with an accompanying shift of the amide III band center to 1235 cm-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Visualization of the maturation transition in bacteriophage P22 by electron cryomicroscopy

Large-scale conformational transitions are involved in the life-cycle of many types of virus. The dsDNA phages, herpesviruses, and adenoviruses must undergo a maturation transition in the course of DNA packaging to convert a scaffolding-containing precursor capsid to the DNA-containing mature virion. This conformational transition converts the procapsid, which is smaller, rounder, and displays a distinctive skewing of the hexameric capsomeres, to the mature virion, which is larger and more angular, with regular hexons. We have used electron cryomicroscopy and image reconstruction to obtain 15 A structures of both bacteriophage P22 procapsids and mature phage. The maturation transition from the procapsid to the phage results in several changes in both the conformations of the individual coat protein subunits and the interactions between neighboring subunits. The most extensive conformational transformation among these is the outward movement of the trimer clusters present at all strict and local 3-fold axes on the procapsid inner surface. As the trimer tips are the sites of scaffolding binding, this helps to explain the role of scaffolding protein in regulating assembly and maturation. We also observe DNA within the capsid packed in a manner consistent with the spool model. These structures allow us to suggest how the binding interactions of scaffolding and DNA with the coat shell may act to control the packaging of the DNA into the expanding procapsids.     

Initiation of P22 procapsid assembly in vivo

The procapsids of all double-stranded DNA phages have a unique portal vertex, which is the locus of DNA packaging and DNA injection. Procapsid assembly is also initiated at this vertex, which is defined by the presence of a cyclic dodecamer of the portal protein. Assembly of the procapsid shell of phage P22 requires the gene 5 coat protein and the gene 8 scaffolding protein. We report here that removal of gene product (gp) 1 portal protein of P22 by mutation does not slow the rate of polymerization of coat and scaffolding subunits into shells, indicating that the portal ring is dispensable for shell initiation. Mutant scaffolding subunits specified by tsU172 copolymerize with coat subunits into procapsids at restrictive temperature, and also correctly autoregulate their synthesis. However, the shell structures formed from the temperature-sensitive scaffolding subunits fail to incorporate the portal ring and the three minor DNA injection proteins. This mutation identifies a domain of the scaffolding protein specifically involved in organization of the portal vertex. The results suggest that it is a complex of the scaffolding protein that initiates procapsid assembly and organizes the portal ring.     

Kinetic and calorimetric evidence for two distinct scaffolding protein binding populations within the bacteriophage P22 procapsid

A wide variety of viruses require the transient presence of scaffolding proteins to direct capsid assembly. In the case of bacteriophage P22, a model in which the scaffolding protein selectively stabilizes on-pathway growing intermediates has been proposed. The stoichiometry and thermodynamics of binding of the bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein within the procapsid were analyzed by light scattering and isothermal titration calorimetry. Calorimetric experiments carried out between 10 and 37 degrees C were consistent with the presence of at least two distinct populations of binding sites, in agreement with kinetic evidence obtained by a light scattering assay. Binding to the high-affinity sites occurred at 20 degrees C with a stoichiometry of approximately 60 scaffolding molecules per procapsid and an apparent K(d) of approximately 100-300 nM and was almost completely enthalpy-driven. For the second binding population, precise fitting of the data was impossible due to small heats of binding, but the thermodynamics of binding were clearly distinct from the high-affinity phase. The heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)()) of binding was large for the high-affinity sites and negative for both sets of sites. Addition of sodium chloride (1 M) greatly reduced the magnitude of the apparent DeltaH, in agreement with previous evidence that electrostatic interactions play a major role in binding. A mutant scaffolding protein that forms covalent dimers (R74C/L177I) bound only to the high-affinity sites. These data comprise the first quantitative measurements of the energetics of the coat protein/scaffolding protein interaction.     

Structural basis of bacteriophage lambda capsid maturation

1. Download : Download high-res image (409KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

ATP-Dependent localization of the herpes simplex virus capsid protein VP26 to sites of procapsid maturation

The herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) capsid shell is composed of four major polypeptides, VP5, VP19c, VP23, and VP26. VP26, a 12-kDa polypeptide, is associated with the tips of the capsid hexons formed by VP5. Mature capsids form upon angularization of the shell of short-lived, fragile spherical precursors termed procapsids. The cold sensitivity and short-lived nature of the procapsid have made its isolation and biochemical analysis difficult, and it remains unclear whether procapsids contain bound VP26 or whether VP26 is recruited following shell angularization. By indirect immunocytochemical analysis of virally expressed VP26 and by direct visualization of a transiently expressed VP26-green fluorescent protein fusion, we show that VP26 fails to specifically localize to intranuclear procapsids accumulated following incubation of the temperature-sensitive HSV mutant tsProt.A under nonpermissive conditions. However, following a downshift to the permissive temperature, which allows procapsid maturation to proceed, VP26 was seen to concentrate at intranuclear sites which also contained epitopes specific to mature, angularized capsids. Like the formation of these epitopes, the association of VP26 with maturing capsids was blocked in a reversible fashion by the depletion of intracellular ATP. We conclude that unlike the other major capsid shell proteins, VP26 is recruited in an ATP-dependent fashion after procapsid maturation begins.     

Identification of additional coat-scaffolding interactions in a bacteriophage P22 mutant defective in maturation

Scaffolding proteins play a critical role in the assembly of certain viruses by directing the formation and maturation of a precursor capsid. Using electron cryomicroscopy difference mapping, we have identified an altered arrangement of a mutant scaffolding within the bacteriophage P22 procapsid. This mutant scaffolding allows us to directly visualize scaffolding density within the P22 procapsid. Based on these observations we propose a model for why the mutant prevents scaffolding release and capsid maturation.     

Handedness of the herpes simplex virus capsid and procapsid

The capsid of herpes simplex virus has an icosahedral surface lattice with a nonskew triangulation number, T=16. Nevertheless, the proteins arrayed on this lattice necessarily have an intrinsic handedness. We have determined the handedness of both the herpes simplex virus type 1 capsid and its precursor procapsid by a cryoelectron microscopic tilting method.     

Molecular rearrangements involved in the capsid shell maturation of bacteriophage T7

Maturation of dsDNA bacteriophages involves assembling the virus prohead from a limited set of structural components followed by rearrangements required for the stability that is necessary for infecting a host under challenging environmental conditions. Here, we determine the mature capsid structure of T7 at 1 nm resolution by cryo-electron microscopy and compare it with the prohead to reveal the molecular basis of T7 shell maturation. The mature capsid presents an expanded and thinner shell, with a drastic rearrangement of the major protein monomers that increases in their interacting surfaces, in turn resulting in a new bonding lattice. The rearrangements include tilting, in-plane rotation, and radial expansion of the subunits, as well as a relative bending of the A- and P-domains of each subunit. The unique features of this shell transformation, which does not employ the accessory proteins, inserted domains, or molecular interactions observed in other phages, suggest a simple capsid assembling strategy that may have appeared early in the evolution of these viruses.     

Coat protein fold and maturation transition of bacteriophage P22 seen at subnanometer resolutions

Bacteriophage P22 is a prototypical biological machine used for studying protein complex assembly and capsid maturation. Using cryo-EM, we solved the structures of P22 before and after the capsid maturation at 8.5 A and 9.5 A resolutions, respectively. These structures allowed visualization of alpha-helices and beta-sheets from which the capsid protein fold is derived. The capsid fold is similar to that of the coat protein of HK97 bacteriophage. The cryo-EM shows that a large conformational change of the P22 capsid during maturation transition involves not only the domain movement of individual subunits, but also refolding of the capsid protein.     

Domain structures and roles in bacteriophage HK97 capsid assembly and maturation

Head assembly in the double-stranded DNA coliphage HK97 involves initially the formation of the precursor shell Prohead I from approximately 420 copies of a 384-residue subunit. This is followed by proteolytic removal of residues 2-103 to create Prohead II, and then reorganization and expansion of the shell lattice and covalent cross-linking of subunits make Head II. Here, we report and structurally interpret solution Raman spectra of Prohead I, Prohead II, and Head II particles. The Raman signatures of Prohead I and Prohead II indicate a common alpha/beta fold for residues 104-385, and a strongly conserved tertiary structure. The Raman difference spectrum between Prohead I and Prohead II demonstrates that the N-terminal residues 2-103 (Delta-domain) form a predominantly alpha-helical fold devoid of beta-strand. The conformation of the Delta-domain in Prohead I thus resembles that of the previously characterized scaffolding proteins of Salmonellaphage P22 and Bacillus phage phi29 and suggests an analogous architectural role in mediating the assembly of a properly dimensioned precursor shell. The Prohead II --> Head II transition is accompanied by significant reordering of both the secondary and tertiary structures of 104-385, wherein a large increase occurs in the percentage of beta-strand (from 38 to 45%), and a marginal increase is observed in the percentage of alpha-helix (from 27 to 31%). Both are at the expense of unordered chain segments. Residue environments affected by HK97 shell maturation include the unique cysteine (Cys 362) and numerous tyrosines and tryptophans. The tertiary structural reorganization is reminiscent of that observed for the procapsid --> capsid transformation of P22. The Raman signatures of aqueous and crystalline Head II reveal no significant differences between the crystal and solution structures.     

Role of the scaffolding protein in P22 procapsid size determination suggested by T = 4 and T = 7 procapsid structures.

Assembly of bacteriophage P22 procapsids requires the participation of approximately 300 molecules of scaffolding protein in addition to the 420 coat protein subunits. In the absence of the scaffolding, the P22 coat protein can assemble both wild-type-size and smaller size closed capsids. Both sizes of procapsid assembled in the absence of the scaffolding protein have been studied by electron cryomicroscopy. These structural studies show that the larger capsids have T = 7 icosahedral lattices and appear the same as wild-type procapsids. The smaller capsids possess T = 4 icosahedral symmetry. The two procapsids consist of very similar penton and hexon clusters, except for an increased curvature present in the T = 4 hexon. In particular, the pronounced skewing of the hexons is conserved in both sizes of capsid. The T = 7 procapsid has a local non-icosahedral twofold axis in the center of the hexon and thus contains four unique quasi-equivalent coat protein conformations that are the same as those in the T = 4 procapsid. Models of how the scaffolding protein may direct these four coat subunit types into a T = 7 rather than a T = 4 procapsid are presented.     

Penton release from P22 heat-expanded capsids suggests importance of stabilizing penton-hexon interactions during capsid maturation

Bacteriophage assembly frequently begins with the formation of a precursor capsid that serves as a DNA packaging machine. The DNA packaging is accompanied by a morphogenesis of the small round precursor capsid into a large polyhedral DNA-containing mature phage. In vitro, this transformation can be induced by heat or chemical treatment of P22 procapsids. In this work, we examine bacteriophage P22 morphogenesis by comparing three-dimensional structures of capsids expanded both in vitro by heat treatment and in vivo by DNA packaging. The heat-expanded capsid reveals a structure that is virtually the same as the in vivo expanded capsid except that the pentons, normally present at the icosahedral fivefold positions, have been released. The similarities of these two capsid structures suggest that the mechanism of heat expansion is similar to in vivo expansion. The loss of the pentons further suggests the necessity of specific penton-hexon interactions during expansion. We propose a model whereby the penton-hexon interactions are stabilized through interactions of DNA, coat protein, and other minor proteins. When considered in the context of other studies using chemical or heat treatment of capsids, our study indicates that penton release may be a common trend among double-stranded DNA containing viruses.     

Novel second-site suppression of a cold-sensitive defect in phage P22 procapsid assembly

The DNA packaging portal of the phage P22 procapsid is formed of 12 molecules of the 90,000 dalton gene 1 protein. The assembly of this dodecameric complex at a unique capsid vertex requires scaffolding subunits. The mechanism that ensures the location of the 12-fold symmetrical portal at only one of the 12 5-fold vertices of an icosahedral virus capsid presents a unique assembly problem, which, in some viruses, is solved by the portal also acting as initiator of procapsid assembly. Phage P22 procapsids, however, are formed in the absence of the portal protein. The 1-csH137 mutation prevents the incorporation of the portal protein into procapsids. In a mixed infection with cs+ phage, the mutant subunits are able to form functional portals, suggesting that the cold-sensitivity does not affect portal-portal interactions, but affects the interaction of portal subunits with some other molecular species involved in the initiation of portal assembly. Interestingly, the cs defect is suppressed by temperature-sensitive folding mutations at four sites in the P22 tailspike gene 9. The suppression is allele-specific; other tailspike tsf mutations fail to suppress the cs defect. Translation through a suppressor site is required for suppression. This observation is unexpected, since analysis of nonsense mutations in this gene indicates that it is not required for procapsid assembly. Examination of the nucleic acid sequences in the neighborhood of each of the suppressor sites shows significant sequence similarity with the scaffolding gene translational initiation region on the late message. This supports a previously proposed model, in which procapsid assembly is normally initiated in a region on the late messenger RNA that includes the gene 8 start site. By this model, the suppressor mutations may be acting through protein-RNA interactions, changing sequences that identify alternative or competing sites at which the mutant portal subunits may be organized for assembly into the differentiated vertex of the phage capsid.