Different reactivities of brain and erythrocyte tubulins toward a sulfhydryl group-directed reagent that inhibits microtubule assembly

There is considerable evidence that tubulin exists in multiple isotypes, differing in amino acid sequence and tissue distribution. Little is known, however, about the functional significance of these isotypes. Chicken erythrocyte beta-tubulin has been shown by peptide mapping to differ significantly from chicken brain beta-tubulin (Murphy, D. B., and Wallis, K. T. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 7870-7875). We now find that when the two tubulins, in their native states, are incubated with N,N'-ethylenebis(iodoacetamide) (EBI), a bifunctional sulfhydryl-directed reagent, microtubule assembly by brain tubulin is much more sensitive to inhibition by EBI than is erythrocyte tubulin assembly. The resistance of erythrocyte microtubule assembly to inhibition by EBI is correlated with a low reactivity of erythrocyte tubulin with [14C]EBI. This difference is most marked in the beta subunit which reacts 15 and 17% as well, respectively, with [14C]EBI as do the beta 1 and beta 2 subunits of brain tubulin. Also, erythrocyte beta reacts about 33% as well as does brain beta with iodo[14C]acetamide. These results suggest that a reactive sulfhydryl group, whose oxidation prevents microtubule assembly, is present in brain tubulin but absent or inaccessible in erythrocyte tubulin. Since purified erythrocyte tubulin self-aggregates much more readily than does brain tubulin, it is conceivable that erythrocyte and brain tubulin may differ in that the latter may have its assembly subject to a complex regulation, while erythrocyte tubulin assembly may be regulated by a simpler mechanism.     

The effect of 2-(4-methyl-1-piperazinylmethyl) acrylophenone dihydrochloride on the alkylation of tubulin

2-(4-Methyl-1-piperazinylmethyl) acrylophenone dihydrochloride (MPMAP) is a novel inhibitor of microtubule assembly in vitro and in vivo whose molecular mechanism of action has not been investigated (M. L. Mallevais, A. Delacourte, I. Lesieur, D. Lesieur, M. Cazin, C. Brunet, and M. Luyckx (1984) Biochimie 66, 477-482). We have examined the effect of MPMAP on the alkylation of tubulin by iodo[14C]acetamide and N,N'-ethylenebis(iodoacetamide) (EBI). MPMAP is a very potent inhibitor of tubulin alkylation by iodo[14C]acetamide. MPMAP gives half-maximal inhibition at a concentration of 15 microM. MPMAP also inhibits the alkylation of denatured tubulin and of aldolase, implying that it reacts strongly with sulfhydryl groups. MPMAP does not, however, interfere with formation by EBI of a crosslink between cysteines 239 and 354 in the beta subunit of tubulin, suggesting that these sulfhydryls are located in a cleft in the tubulin molecule.     

Differential colchicine-binding across eukaryotic families: the role of highly conserved Pro268beta and Ala248beta residues in animal tubulin

Colchicine-tubulin interaction, responsible for the disruption of microtubule formation, has immense pharmacological importance but is poorly understood in terms of its biological significance. The interaction is characterized by a marked higher affinity of colchicine for animal tubulins compared to tubulins from plants, fungi and protists. From an analysis of tubulin sequences and colchicine-tubulin crystal structure, we propose that Pro268beta and Ala248beta (270beta and 250beta in the crystal structure 1SA0) in animal tubulin are crucial for the observed differential binding. We also suggest that mediated by the binding of endogenous molecules to the colchicine-binding site, microtubule assembly in eukaryotes may be modulated in a family specific manner.     

Microtubule protein ADP-ribosylation in vitro leads to assembly inhibition and rapid depolymerization.

Bovine brain microtubule protein, containing both tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins, undergoes ADP-ribosylation in the presence of [14C]NAD+ and a turkey erythrocyte mono-ADP-ribosyltransferase in vitro. The modification reaction could be demonstrated in crude brain tissue extracts where selective ADP-ribosylation of both the alpha and beta chains of tubulin and of the high molecular weight microtubule-associated protein MAP-2 occurred. In experiments with purified microtubule protein, tubulin dimer, the high molecular weight microtubule-associated protein MAP-2, and another high molecular weight mirotubule-associated protein which may be a MAP-1 species were heavily labeled. Tubulin and MAP-2 incorporated [14C]ADP-ribose to an average extent of approximately 2.4 and 30 mol of ADP-ribose/mol of protein, respectively. Assembly of microtubule protein into microtubules in vitro was inhibited by ADP-ribosylation, and incubation of assembled steady-state microtubules with ADP-ribosyltransferase and NAD+ resulted in rapid depolymerization of the microtubules. Thus, the eukaryotic enzyme can ADP-ribosylate tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins to much greater extents than previously observed with cholera and pertussis toxins, and the modification can significantly modulate microtubule assembly and disassembly.     

Immunofluorescence examination of beta tubulin expression and marginal band formation in developing chicken erythroblasts

Chicken erythrocyte beta tubulin, a tubulin variant with unique biochemical and assembly properties, is found to be specifically contained in two chicken blood cell types--erythrocytes and thrombocytes. The beta tubulin variant is absent or present in low amounts in a variety of white blood cell types and other body tissues, as determined by immunofluorescence microscopy and a semi-quantitative immunoblotting procedure. During differentiation in the marrow the beta tubulin variant appears suddenly in mid-stage erythroblasts at the onset of hemoglobin synthesis, and forming marginal bands are seen in all subsequent polychromatophilic erythroblast stages. The developmental sequence of events in marginal band formation entails microtubule nucleation at the centrosome, followed by microtubule elongation, consolidation of loose parallel microtubules into a compact bundle, and microtubule association with the cell membrane.     

Mutations that encode partially functional beta 2 tubulin subunits have different effects on structurally different microtubule arrays

The testis-specific beta 2 tubulin of Drosophila is required for assembly and function of at least three architecturally different microtubule arrays (Kemphues et al., 1982). Two recessive male-sterile mutations in the B2t locus that encode partially functional, stable, variant forms of beta 2 tubulin cause defects in only certain microtubule-based processes during spermatogenesis. These mutations could thus identify aspects of beta tubulin primary structure critical for function only in specific microtubule arrays. In males carrying the B2t6 mutation, meiotic chromosome segregation and nuclear shaping are normal and flagellar axonemes are formed, but there is a subtle defect in axoneme structure; the outer doublet microtubules fill in with a central core normally seen only in the central pair and accessory microtubules. In homozygous B2t7 males, chromosome movement is usually normal during meiosis but cytokinesis often fails, cytoplasmic microtubules are assembled and nuclear shaping appears to be normal, but the flagellar axoneme lacks structural integrity. In contrast, the B2t8 allele affects a general property of tubulin, the ability to form normal side-to-side association of protofilaments (Fuller et al., 1987), and causes defects in meiosis, axoneme assembly and nuclear shaping. Certain combinations of these beta 2 tubulin mutations show interallelic complementation; in B2t6/B2t8 males functional sperm are produced and both variant subunits are incorporated into mature sperm, in the absence of wild-type beta 2 tubulin. Comparison of the phenotypes of the three partially functional beta 2 tubulin alleles reveals some aspects of tubulin primary structure more important for function in specific subsets of microtubule arrays, and other aspects required for the construction of microtubules in general.     

Developmental and Biochemical Analysis of Chick Brain Tubulin Heterogeneity

Tubulin, isolated from brain tissue of chicks at different stages during late embryonic and early post-hatched development by ion-exchange chromatography and by in vitro microtubule reassembly, was analyzed by high-resolution isoelectric focusing and by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Similar results were obtained with tubulins purified by the two methods. Sixteen isoelectric species of tubulin that differ in apparent net charge under denaturing conditions were detected by isoelectric focusing. By two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the chick brain tubulins were resolved into at least seven forms of alpha and 10 forms of beta tubulin. The number and relative proportions of the multiple brain tubulins were modulated during development. Since there are only four alpha tubulin and four beta tubulin genes in chickens, posttranslational modification of the tubulins must play a prominent role in the heterogeneity. Analysis of isotubulin distributions through cycles of microtubule assembly and disassembly indicated that the tubulins differ very little, if at all, in their capacity to assemble into microtubules. Therefore, the chemical differences that distinguish the multiple tubulins have very little structural impact on the protein surface areas involved in microtubule formation. Partial fractionation of the multiple tubulins during ion-exchange chromatography was observed, suggesting that it may be possible to isolate individual native tubulin variants for biochemical studies.     

Microtubule assembly in cytoplasmic extracts of Xenopus oocytes and eggs

We have investigated the differences in microtubule assembly in cytoplasm from Xenopus oocytes and eggs in vitro. Extracts of activated eggs could be prepared that assembled extensive microtubule networks in vitro using Tetrahymena axonemes or mammalian centrosomes as nucleation centers. Assembly occurred predominantly from the plus-end of the microtubule with a rate constant of 2 microns.min-1.microM-1 (57 s-1.microM-1). At the in vivo tubulin concentration, this corresponds to the extraordinarily high rate of 40-50 microns.min-1. Microtubule disassembly rates in these extracts were -4.5 microns.min-1 (128 s-1) at the plus-end and -6.9 microns.min-1 (196 s-1) at the minus-end. The critical concentration for plus-end microtubule assembly was 0.4 microM. These extracts also promoted the plus-end assembly of microtubules from bovine brain tubulin, suggesting the presence of an assembly promoting factor in the egg. In contrast to activated eggs, assembly was never observed in extracts prepared from oocytes, even at tubulin concentrations as high as 20 microM. Addition of oocyte extract to egg extracts or to purified brain tubulin inhibited microtubule assembly. These results suggest that there is a plus-end-specific inhibitor of microtubule assembly in the oocyte and a plus-end-specific promoter of assembly in the eggs. These factors may serve to regulate microtubule assembly during early development in Xenopus.     

Identification and characterization of microtubule proteins from myxamoebae of Physarum polycephalum.

Cell extracts of myxamoebae of Physarum polycephalum have been prepared in such a way that they do not inhibit assembly of brain microtubule protein in vitro even at high extract-protein concentration. Co-polymers of these extracts and brain tubulin have been purified to constant stoichiometry and amoebal components identified by radiolabelling. Amoebal tubulin has been identified as having an alpha-subunit, mol.wt. 54 000, which co-migrates with brain alpha-tubulin and a beta-subunit, mol.wt. 50 000, which co-migrates with Tetrahymena ciliary beta-tubulin. Non-tubulin amoebal proteins that co-purify with tubulin during co-polymer formation have been shown to be essential for microtubule formation in the absence of glycerol and appear to be rather more effective than brain microtubule-associated proteins in stimulating assembly. The mitotic inhibitor griseofulvin (7-chloro-2',4,6-trimethoxy-6'-methylspiro[benzofuran-2(3H),1'-cyclohex-2'-ene] -3,4'-dione), which binds to brain microtubule-associated proteins and inhibits brain microtubule assembly in vitro, affected co-polymer microtubule protein in a similar way, but to a slightly greater extent.     

Microtubule assembly and phage morphogenesis: new results and classical paradigms

The classical analyses of phage morphogenesis provide experimental paradigms for dissecting other assembly pathways. A new set of results, derived from examination of the quantitative controls of tubulin levels and microtubule assembly in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, evokes the 'balance of components' hypothesis. These results show that balanced levels of the tubulin proteins are crucial for microtubule assembly. Imbalances leading to excess beta tubulin have far more deleterious consequences than those leading to excess alpha tubulin, including dramatic cellular toxicity, quantitative depolymerization of cellular microtubules, and self-aggregation of the excess beta tubulin. These and other results suggest that beta tubulin may possess a unique ability to interact with a component of microtubule nucleating sites, and provide a rationale for the universal polarity of nucleated microtubules.     

Brain and erythrocyte microtubules from chicken contain different beta-tubulin polypeptides

beta-Tubulin subunits isolated from chicken brain tissue and erythrocytes are distinguishable as unique biochemical species by electrophoretic and peptide mapping procedures. 1) The subunits of beta-tubulin exhibit major differences in electrophoretic mobility on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels that vary according to the pH and ionic strength of the gel. 2) The isoelectric points of urea-denatured beta subunits from brain tissue and erythrocytes are pH 5.1 and 5.4, respectively, whereas those of both alpha subunits are approximately pH 5.2.3) Two-dimensional peptide maps prepared with alpha-chymotrypsin or V8 protease show that alpha-tubulin peptides are indistinguishable, whereas beta-tubulin peptides are very different. Only one-third of the 15 major tyrosine-containing beta-tubulin peptides prepared with alpha-chymotrypsin are common to both beta-tubulin species. The data indicate that the beta-tubulin subunits of brain tissue and erythrocytes are biochemically distinct and may be different gene products. The presence of tubulin variants in brain tissue and erythrocytes may indicate special requirements for microtubule assembly and function in different cell types.     

Direct incorporation of microtubule oligomers at high GTP concentrations

Chick brain microtubule protein consists primarily of a mixture of MAP2:tubulin oligomers and dimeric tubulin. The assembly of this protein is described by a single pseudofirst-order reaction at 20 microM GTP, but by the summation of two pseudofirst-order reactions at 1 mM GTP. The protein contains two GTP-binding species, corresponding to the tubulin dimers and the oligomers, and conditions which alter the dimer: oligomer equilibrium, affect the kinetics of microtubule assembly. The results indicate that the oligomers are only direct assembly intermediates at high GTP concentrations.     

Purification of microtubule protein from beef brain and comparison of the assembly requirements for neuronal microtubules isolated from beef and hog.

The polymerization of microtubule protein from beef brain is inefficient under the same conditions which are optimal for the assembly of microtubules isolated from hog brain (0.1 m piperazine-N,N′-bis(2-ethanesulfonic acid) buffer at pH 6.94). In examining the conditions required for microtubule polymerization in both beef brain extract and purified microtuble protein, it was determined that the pH optimum was pH 6.62 or 0.3 pH unit lower than the reported optimum for hog. Other assembly requirements (ionic strength, Mg²⁺ and nucleotide concentration, temperature) remained essentially the same as for hog. By separating and recombining fractions of tubulin and nontubulin components prepared from beef and hog microtubule protein, the requirement for the reduction in pH was found to be due to the tubulin and not to the microtubule-associated proteins. It was also determined that the efficiency of beef tubulin assembly, as measured by the yield of microtubule polymer, decreased rapidly after slaughter with a half-time of 19 min. Furthermore, when the overall efficiency of polymerization was reduced, the extent of assembly at each cycle of purification by disassembly and assembly was also observed to be depressed. The variations in the requirements for neuronal tubulin assembly in two closely related mammals suggest that the conditions required for assembly of microtubule protein in other tissues and cell types may also be different.     

Assembly of tubulin from cultured cells and comparison with the neurotubulin model

Spontaneous microtubule assembly can be obtained in extracts from a variety of cultured cell lines by including glycerol in the assembly buffer. An analysis of the effects of cultured cell extracts on brain tubulin (neurotubulin) assembly has shown that the extracts contain initiation inhibitors whose effects are diminished by glycerol. By using glycerol during the assembly step, cultured cell tubulin can be purified by assembly-dissassembly procedures. The amount of glycerol necessary for significant spontaneous assembly varies from 1–6 M among the different cell lines and is dependent upon their content of inhibitor. Comparison of the assembly products obtained from NA, C₆ and CHO cells at increasing glycerol concentrations shows that glycerol enhances the purification of tubulin and a polypeptide of molecular weight 49,000 daltons in all three systems. These preparations contain a number of other polypeptides, including a group with gel electrophoretic mobilities characteristic of tau-factor, but lack the high molecular weight microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) which are present in neurotubulin preparations. Phosphocellulose chromatography of NA tubulin removes several proteins from the tubulin and results in a loss of polymerizability. Among three proteins which are completely removed from the inactive tubulin, the most prominent is the 49K protein. This observation and the co-purification of the 49K protein with tubulin through two assembly-disassembly cycles suggest that it is a true MAP. The difference in MAP proteins between brain and tissue culture cells is parallelled by an absence of ring structures in NA tubulin preparations. NA tubulin, however, does form rings when brain MAPs are added. The early steps of NA tubulin assembly differ from those of neurotubulin; no rings are involved, and the first assembly intermediates are straight protofilament bundles. The differences between MAPs from cultured cells and brain and the absence of ring formation in NA tubulin preparations suggest that the assembly model based on neurotubulin is not completely general. A comparison of extracts from CHO cells grown with and without dibutyryl cAMP revealed no differences between the behavior of these extracts in spontaneous tubulin assembly or in mixture experiments with brain tubulin.     

Quick and Simple Detection Technique to Assess the Binding of Antimicrotubule Agents to the Colchicine-Binding Site

Development of antimitotic binding to the colchicine-binding site for the treatment of cancer is rapidly expanding. Numerous antimicrotubule agents are prepared every year, and the determination of their binding affinity to tubulin requires the use of purified tubulins and radiolabeled ligands. Such a procedure is costly and time-consuming and therefore is limited to the most promising candidates. Here, we report a quick and inexpensive method that requires only usual laboratory resources to assess the binding of antimicrotubules to colchicine-binding site. The method is based on the ability of N,N'-ethylene-bis(iodoacetamide) (EBI) to crosslink in living cells the cysteine residues at position 239 and 354 of β-tubulin, residues which are involved in the colchicine-binding site. The β-tubulin adduct formed by EBI is easily detectable by Western blot as a second immunoreacting band of β-tubulin that migrates faster than β-tubulin. The occupancy of colchicine-binding site by pertinent antimitotics inhibits the formation of the EBI: β-tubulin adduct, resulting in an assay that allows the screening of new molecules targeting this binding site.     

Translation of beta-tubulin mRNA in vitro generates multiple molecular forms

We describe the in vitro expression and characterization of the isolated beta-tubulin subunit in rabbit reticulocyte lysates and compare its assembly and chromatographic properties with that of the isolated alpha-subunit and the tubulin heterodimer. The beta-tubulin polypeptides, derived from a single chicken beta-tubulin cDNA, were found in three distinct molecular forms: a multimeric or lysate-associated form, beta I (Mr approximately 180,000); the free beta-subunit beta II (Mr approximately 55,000); and the hybrid heterodimer alpha(rabbit) beta(chick), beta III (Mr approximately 80,000-100,000). The hybrid heterodimers were 100% assembly competent, whereas beta-tubulin in the "associated" beta I and the monomeric beta II forms displayed only approximately 70 +/- 15 and 25 +/- 10% competence, respectively, in coassembly assays with bovine brain tubulin. This reduced functionality was not a consequence of diminished beta-subunit stability or protein denaturation. By comparing the elution positions of the three beta forms, the monomeric alpha-subunit, and tubulin dimer purified from bovine brain, we demonstrate that anion-exchange columns (Mono-Q) interact preferentially with the alpha-subunit and chromatograph tubulin dimer on the basis of alpha-subunit isotype. The rate of exchange of the free beta-subunit into bovine tubulin dimer was followed chromatographically. The exchange was slow at 4 degrees C and rapid at 37 degrees C where it is essentially complete in 40 min in the presence of 2.5 mg/ml bovine microtubule protein. Exogenous GTP, a potent effector of microtubule assembly, binds exchangeably to beta II and enhances the recovery of this form from the Mono-Q column, suggesting that GTP binding may occur at identical sites in the isolated beta-subunit and in the tubulin heterodimer.     

Tubulin oligomers and microtubule oscillations. Antagonistic role of microtubule stabilizers and destabilizers

Several types of non-equilibrium phenomena have been observed in microtubule polymerization, including dynamic instability, assembly overshoot and oscillations. They can be interpreted in terms of interactions between tubulin subunits (= alpha, beta heterodimers), microtubules, and a third state, oligomers, which represent intermediates between microtubule disassembly and the regeneration of assembly-competent subunits by GTP. Here we examine the role of oligomers by varying conditions that stabilize or destabilize microtubules and/or oligomers. By varying their ratio one can drive tubulin assembly either into steady-state microtubules or oligomers. These regimens of assembly conditions are separated by a region where microtubules oscillate. The oscillations can be simulated by computer modelling, based on a reaction scheme involving the three states of tubulin and nucleotide exchange on tubulin subunits, but not on microtubules or oligomers.     

Expression of recombinant alpha and beta tubulins from the yew Taxus cuspidata and analysis of the microtubule assembly in the presence of taxol

Taxol was originally isolated from the yew Taxus brevifolia. Because taxol inhibits the depolymerization of microtubules, the presence of a self-resistance mechanism in Taxus spp. was hypothesized. The cloning of the cDNA for alpha and beta tubulins from Taxus cuspidata and those from the human embryonic kidney cell line HEK293T revealed that the ²⁶Asp, ³⁵⁹Arg, and ³⁶¹Leu residues in the human beta tubulin, which are important for taxol binding, were replaced with Glu, Trp, and Met in the beta tubulin of T. cuspidata, respectively. The microtubule assembly of the recombinant alpha and beta tubulins was monitored turbidimetrically, and the results clearly demonstrated that the microtubule from T. cuspidata is less sensitive to taxol than that from HEK293T cells. The Taxus microtubule composed of the wild-type alpha tubulin and the beta tubulin with the E26D mutation restored the sensitivity to taxol. We thus postulated that the mutation identified in the beta tubulin of T. cuspidata plays a role in the self-resistance of this species against taxol.     

Erythrocyte microtubule assembly in vitro. Determination of the effects of erythrocyte tau, tubulin isoforms, and tubulin oligomers on erythrocyte tubulin assembly, and comparison with brain microtubule assembly

Two tubulin variants, isolated from chicken brain and erythrocytes and known to have different peptide maps and electrophoretic properties, are demonstrated to exhibit different assembly properties in vitro: 1) erythrocyte tubulin assembles with greater efficiency (lower critical concentration, greater elongation rate) but exhibits a lower nucleation rate than brain tubulin, and 2) erythrocyte tubulin readily forms oligomers whose presence significantly retards the rate of elongation, suggesting that tubulin oligomers may also be important for determining the rate of assembly and the length of microtubules in erythrocytes. Erythrocyte tubulin isolated by cycles of in vitro assembly-disassembly is also demonstrated to contain a 67-kDa tau factor that greatly enhances microtubule nucleation but has little effect on elongation rates or critical concentration. Immunofluorescence microscopy with tau antibody indicates that tau is specifically associated with marginal band microtubules, suggesting that it may be important for determining microtubule function in vivo.     

Brain t-complex polypeptide 1 (TCP- 1) related to its natural substrate beta1 tubulin is decreased in Alzheimer's disease.

The t-complex polypeptide 1 is a selective molecular chaperone in tubulin biogenesis, by that nascent tubulin subunits are bound to t-complex polypeptide 1 and released in assembly competent forms. In neurodegenerative diseases with Alzheimer pathology cytoskeletal proteins are deficient and aggregated. Therefore we examined t-complex polypeptide 1 as represented by the zeta subunit and its specific substrate beta 1 tubulin represented by a truncated product in six brain regions of nine patients with Alzheimer's disease, nine patients with Down syndrome and nine controls. We used 2 dimensional electrophoresis with in-gel-digestion and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ ionization- mass spectrometry for the separation and identification of human brain t-complex polypeptide 1 and beta 1 tubulin. When t-complex polypeptide I was related to its natural and specific substrate beta 1 tubulin, the ratio was significantly decreased in the temporal, frontal, parietal cortex and in thalamus of patients with Alzheimer's disease. In Down syndrome the t-complex polypeptide 1/beta 1 tubulin ratio was significantly increased in frontal and parietal cortex suggesting a different mechanism for aggregation of microfilament proteins e.g. beta 1 tubulin. Relatively decreased molecular chaperoning of beta 1 tubulin by t-complex polypeptide 1 may lead to misfolded tubulin aggregating and accumulating in plaques and tangles, a hallmark of Alzheimer's disease. Our contribution provides first clues for a mechanism of microtubular accumulation in Alzheimer's disease and challenges further studies on different chaperones and chaperonins in the brain of patients with neurodegenerative diseases.