Evidence for interactions between helices 5 and 8 and a role for the interdomain loop in tetracycline resistance mediated by hybrid Tet proteins

An interdomain hybrid Tet protein consisting of a class C alpha domain and a class B beta domain (Tet(C/B)) lacks detectable efflux ability and provides only minimal levels of resistance to tetracycline (Tc) (3 microg/ml) compared with intact class B (256 microg/ml) and class C (64 microg/ml). Twenty-one independently isolated mutants of the Tet(C/B) protein with increased Tc resistance were generated by random chemical mutagenesis. Nine mutants with a Glu substitution for Gly-152 in helix 5 of the class C alpha domain produced a resistance of 48 microg/ml, whereas another 9 with an Asp replacement of Gly-247 in helix 8 of the class B beta domain mediated resistance at 32 microg/ml. The third type of mutation, found in 3 mutants expressing 24 microg/ml resistance, was a S202F replacement in the putative interdomain cytoplasmic loop of Tet(C/B). The latter underscores a previously unappreciated function of the interdomain cytoplasmic loop. All three types of Tet(C/B) mutant proteins were expressed in amounts comparable with that of the original protein and demonstrated restored energy-dependent efflux of tetracycline. Site-directed mutational analysis demonstrated that a Gly-247 to Asn mutation could also facilitate Tc resistance by the Tet(C/B) hybrid, and a negatively charged side chain at position 152 was required for Tet(C/B) activity. These mutations appear to promote the necessary functional interactions between the interclass domains that do not occur in the Tet(C/B) hybrid protein and suggest a direct association between helix 5 and helix 8 in the function of Tet efflux proteins.     

Tet protein domains interact productively to mediate tetracycline resistance when present on separate polypeptides

Both domains, alpha and beta, of the cytoplasmic membrane-localized Tet proteins encoded by the tet gene family (classes A through E) are required for resistance to tetracycline (Tcr) in gram-negative bacteria. Two inactive proteins, each containing a mutation in the opposite domain, are capable of complementation to produce Tcr. Similarly, inactive hybrid proteins expressed by interdomain gene hybrids constructed between tet(B) and tet(C) [tet(B) alpha/(C) beta and tet(C) alpha/(B) beta] together produce significant Tcr via trans complementation (R.A. Rubin and S. B. Levy, J. Bacteriol. 172:2303-2312, 1990). A derivative of tet(B) was constructed to express the two domains of Tet(B) as separate polypeptides, neither containing intact the central, hydrophilic interdomain region. Cells harboring this tet(B) mutant expressed Tcr at about 20% the level conferred by intact tet(B). As expected, no detectable amount of a full-length Tet protein was expressed. A polypeptide corresponding to the alpha domain was observed. Interdomain hybrids between tet(B) and tet(C) containing a frameshift at the fusion junction, designed to result in expression of each of the four domains on separate polypeptides, showed trans complementation without production of detectable full-length proteins. Levels of Tcr were greater than or equal to those previously observed in complementations using full-length hybrid proteins. These results strongly suggest that polypeptides harboring individual alpha and beta domains, lacking an intact interdomain region, can interact productively in the cell to confer Tcr.     

Second-site suppressor mutations of inactivating substitutions at gly247 of the tetracycline efflux protein, Tet(B)

An Asp or Asn substitution for Gly247 in transmembrane helix 8 (TM-8) of Tet(B), the tetracycline efflux protein, eliminated tetracycline resistance. Second site suppressor mutations which partially restored resistance were located in TM-5, -8, -10, or -11 or in cytoplasmic loop 8-9 or loop 10-11. These results indicate physical proximity or functional relationships between TM-8 and these other regions of Tet(B).     

Gene duplication in the evolution of the two complementing domains of gram-negative bacterial tetracycline efflux proteins

The resistance of Gram- bacteria to the broad-spectrum antibiotic tetracycline (Tc) results from energy-dependent drug efflux mediated by the tet gene product, the cytoplasmic membrane Tet protein. Amino acid (aa) sequences deduced from total tet nucleotide sequences of three different resistance determinants (classes A, B and C) indicate that the protein products [Tet(A), Tet(B), and Tet(C)] share a common ancestor. Hydropathic analysis of Tet sequences predicts twelve transmembrane segments in each protein, with six occurring in each half of the molecule. More importantly, the linear distributions of these segments in the N- and C-terminal halves are nearly identical, suggesting that the two halves of each Tet protein are related by a process of tandem gene duplication and divergence. Indeed, a variable but significant conservation of sequence was detected among the N- and C-terminal halves for all possible comparisons of the three proteins. Such conservation was not observed within other prokaryotic integral membrane proteins or when other prokaryotic proteins were compared to Tet halves. Similarity, both in sequence and in predicted transmembrane structural organization, strongly suggests that a common ancestor of Tet(A), Tet(B), and Tet(C) arose by duplication of a gene reading frame specifying a transmembrane protein of approximately 200 aa residues. The two halves of Tet proteins correspond to the two domains, alpha and beta, which have distinct, complementary roles in Tc efflux. Nevertheless, selective constraints to function in the cytoplasmic membrane have apparently led to maintenance of similar patterns of secondary structural organization in these complementary domains.     

Interdomain hybrid Tet proteins confer tetracycline resistance only when they are derived from closely related members of the tet gene family

Inner membrane Tet proteins encoded by tet genes in gram-negative bacteria mediate resistance to tetracycline (Tcr) by directing its export. Total sequences for class A, B, and C tet genes demonstrate that their products have a common ancestor, with Tet(A) and Tet(C) being more closely related (78% identical) than either is to Tet(B) (45% identical). The N- and C-terminal halves of Tet(B) and Tet(C) appear to comprise separate domains, and trans-complementation observed between tetracycline sensitive mutants in either domain of Tet(B) suggests separate but interactive functions for these domains. In this present study, interdomain hybrid genes were constructed to express hybrid tet products whose N- and C-terminal halves were derived from different family members [Tet(A/C), Tet(B/C), and Tet(C/B)]. Tet(A/C) specified a level of Tcr comparable to wild-type Tet(C) and 60% that of Tet(A), indicating that domains from these closely related tet products can function in cis. Although neither Tet(B/C) nor Tet(C/B) hybrids conferred significant Tcr, cells producing both of these types of hybrid proteins expressed substantial Tcr, indicating that productive interactions can occur in trans between Tet(B/C) and Tet(C/B). Taken together, these results suggest that highly specific interactions between the N- and C-terminal domains are necessary for Tcr and do not occur in individual hybrids derived from the more distant relatives, Tet(B) and Tet(C). This requirement for specific interactions suggests that N- and C-terminal domains have coevolved in each member of the Tet family.     

Tet(L) and tet(K) tetracycline-divalent metal/H+ antiporters: characterization of multiple catalytic modes and a mutagenesis approach to differences in their efflux substrate and coupling ion preferences

The Tet(L) protein encoded in the Bacillus subtilis chromosome and the closely related Tet(K) protein from Staphylococcus aureus plasmids are multifunctional antiporters that have three cytoplasmic efflux substrates: a tetracycline-divalent metal (TC-Me(2+)) complex that bears a net single positive charge, Na+, and K+. Tet(L) and Tet(K) had been shown to couple efflux of each of these substrates to influx of H+ as the coupling ion. In this study, competitive cross-inhibition between K+ and other cytoplasmic efflux substrates was demonstrated. Tet(L) and Tet(K) had also been shown to use K+ as an alternate coupling ion in support of Na+ or K+ efflux. Here they were shown to couple TC-Me(2+) efflux to K+ uptake as well, exhibiting greater use of K+ as a coupling ion as the external pH increased. The substrate and coupling ion preferences of the two Tet proteins differed, especially in the higher preference of Tet(K) than Tet(L) for K+, both as a cytoplasmic efflux substrate and as an external coupling ion. Site-directed mutagenesis was employed to test the hypothesis that some feature of the putative "antiporter motif," motif C, of Tet proteins would be involved in these characteristic preferences. Mutation of the A157 in Tet(L) to a hydroxyamino acid resulted in a more Tet(K)-like K+ preference both as coupling ion and efflux substrate. A reciprocal S157A mutant of Tet(K) exhibited reduced K+ preference. Competitive inhibition among substrates and the parallel effects of the single mutation upon K+ preference, as both an efflux substrate and coupling ion, are compatible with a model in which a single translocation pathway through the Tet(L) and Tet(K) transporters is used both for the cytoplasmic efflux substrates and for the coupling ions, in an alternating fashion. However, the effects of the A157 and other mutations of Tet(L) indicate that even if there are a shared binding site and translocation pathway, some elements of that pathway are used by all substrates and others are important only for particular substrates.     

Overproduction and purification of the Tn10-specified inner membrane tetracycline resistance protein Tet using fusions to β-galactosidase

Tetracycline resistance in the Enterobacteriaceae is mediated by a number of genetically related, usually plasmid-borne, determinants which specify an efflux system involving an inner membrane protein, Tet. Attempts to overproduce the Tn10 (Class B)-encoded Tet in Escherichia coli by cloning the structural gene tet downstream of the lambda PL promoter under regulation by temperature-sensitive lambda repressor cI857 were unsuccessful; induction at 42 degrees C resulted in filamentous, non-viable cells containing little detectable overproduction of the protein. However, cells containing tet fused to lacZ were resistant to tetracycline at 30 degrees C and synthesized modest amounts of a large fusion protein when induced at 42 degrees C. Fusion of the N-terminal half or the first 38 amino acids of tet to lacZ did lead to increased production of fusion proteins. Fusions could be purified by size or by LacZ immunoaffinity or substrate-affinity chromatography. In the latter method, selected detergents were required to counteract nonspecific binding of Tet to the adsorbant. Amino acid sequencing of the N-terminus of Tet-LacZ fusion proteins indicated that most molecules were blocked at this terminus. The sequence of an unblocked subpopulation was consistent with that expected from the nucleotide sequence. A collagen peptide linker, genetically placed between tet and lacZ, allowed recovery of purified Tet protein after collagenase treatment of the purified fusion protein.     

Novel tetracycline resistance determinant isolated from an environmental strain of Serratia marcescens

Resistances to tetracycline and mercury were identified in an environmental strain of Serratia marcescens isolated from a stream highly contaminated with heavy metals. As a step toward addressing the mechanisms of coselection of heavy metal and antibiotic resistances, the tetracycline resistance determinant was cloned in Escherichia coli. Within the cloned 13-kb segment, the tetracycline resistance locus was localized by deletion analysis and transposon mutagenesis. DNA sequence analysis of an 8.0-kb region revealed a novel gene [tetA(41)] that was predicted to encode a tetracycline efflux pump. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the TetA(41) protein was most closely related to the Tet(39) efflux protein of Acinetobacter spp. yet had less than 80% amino acid identity with known tetracycline efflux pumps. Adjacent to the tetA(41) gene was a divergently transcribed gene [tetR(41)] predicted to encode a tetracycline-responsive repressor protein. The tetA(41)-tetR(41) intergenic region contained putative operators for TetR(41) binding. The tetA(41) and tetR(41) promoters were analyzed using lacZ fusions, which showed that the expression of both the tetA(41) and tetR(41) genes exhibited TetR(41)-dependent regulation by subinhibitory concentrations of tetracycline. The apparent lack of plasmids in this S. marcescens strain, as well as the presence of metabolic genes adjacent to the tetracycline resistance locus, suggested that the genes were located on the S. marcescens chromosome and may have been acquired by transduction. The cloned Tet 41 determinant did not confer mercury resistance to E. coli, confirming that Tet 41 is a tetracycline-specific efflux pump rather than a multidrug transporter.     

TetZ, a new tetracycline resistance determinant discovered in gram-positive bacteria, shows high homology to gram-negative regulated efflux systems

The complete nucleotide sequence of the tetracycline resistance plasmid pAG1 from the gram-positive soil bacterium Corynebacterium glutamicum 22243 (formerly Corynebacterium melassecola 22243) was determined. The R-plasmid has a size of 19,751 bp and contains at least 18 complete open reading frames. The resistance determinant of pAG1 revealed homology to gram-negative tetracycline efflux and repressor systems of Tet classes A through J. The highest levels of amino acid sequence similarity were observed to the transmembrane tetracycline efflux protein TetA(A) and to the tetracycline repressor TetR(A) of transposon Tn1721 with 64 and 56% similarity, respectively. This is the first time a repressor-regulated tet gene has been found in gram-positive bacteria. A new class of tetracycline resistance and repressor proteins, termed TetA(Z) and TetR(Z), is proposed.     

Mutations in the central cavity and periplasmic domain affect efflux activity of the resistance-nodulation-division pump EmhB from Pseudomonas fluorescens cLP6a

The EmhABC efflux system in Pseudomonas fluorescens cLP6a is homologous to the multidrug and solvent efflux systems belonging to the resistance-nodulation-division (RND) family and is responsible for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon transport, antibiotic resistance, and toluene efflux. To gain a better understanding of substrate transport in RND efflux pumps, the EmhB pump was subjected to mutational analysis. Mutagenesis of amino acids within the central cavity of the predicted three-dimensional structure of EmhB showed selective activity towards antibiotic substrates. An A384P/A385Y double mutant showed increased susceptibility toward rhodamine 6G compared to the wild type, and F386A and N99A single mutants showed increased susceptibility to dequalinium compared to the wild type. As well, the carboxylic acid side chain of D101, located in the central cavity region, was found to be essential for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon transport and resistance to all antibiotic substrates of EmhB. Phenylalanine residues located within the periplasmic pore domain were also targeted for mutagenesis, and the F325A and F281A mutations significantly impaired efflux activity for all EmhB substrates. One mutation (A206S) in the outer membrane protein docking domain increased antibiotic resistance and toluene tolerance, demonstrating the important role of this domain in transport activity. These data demonstrate the roles of the central cavity and periplasmic domains in the function of the RND efflux pump EmhB.     

Decreased function of the class B tetracycline efflux protein Tet with mutations at aspartate 15, a putative intramembrane residue.

The aspartate 15 residue within the first predicted intramembrane helix of the tetracycline efflux protein Tet has been conserved in four tetracycline resistance determinants from gram-negative bacteria. Its replacement in class B Tet by tyrosine, histidine, or asparagine resulted in a 60 to 85% loss of tetracycline resistance and a similar loss of tetracycline-proton antiport. The tyrosine and histidine substitutions lowered the Vmax of the efflux system by some 90% but did not alter the Km. The asparagine substitution raised the Km over 13-fold, while the Vmax was equal to or greater than that of the wild type. Therefore, although the nature of its role is unclear, aspartate 15 is important for normal Tet function.     

The tetracycline resistance protein Tet(o) perturbs the conformation of the ribosomal decoding centre

Tet(o) is an elongation factor-like protein found in clinical isolates of Campylobacter jejuni that confers resistance to the protein-synthesis inhibitor tetracycline. Tet(o) interacts with the 70S ribosome and promotes the release of bound tetracycline, however, as shown here, it does not form the same functional interaction with the 30S subunit. Chemical probing demonstrates that Tet(o) changes the reactivity of the 16S rRNA to dimethyl sulphate (DMS). These changes cluster within the decoding site, where C1214 is protected and A1408 is enhanced to DMS reactivity. C1214 is close to, but does not overlap, the primary tetracycline-binding site, whereas A1408 is in a region distinct from the Tet(o) binding site visualized by cryo-EM, indicating that Tet(o) induces long-range rearrangements that may mediate tetracycline resistance. Tetracycline enhances C1054 to DMS modification but this enhancement is inhibited in the presence of Tet(o) unlike the tetracycline-dependent protection of A892 which is unaffected by Tet(o). C1054 is part of the primary binding site of tetracycline and A892 is part of the secondary binding site. Therefore, the results for the first time demonstrate that the primary tetracycline binding site is correlated with tetracycline's inhibitory effect on protein synthesis.     

Acquired tetracycline and/or macrolide-lincosamides-streptogramin resistance in anaerobes

In general bacterial antibiotic resistance is acquired on mobile elements such as plasmids, transposons and/or conjugative transposons. This is also true for many antibiotic resistant anaerobic species described in the literature. Of the 23 different tetracycline resistant efflux genes identified, tet(B), tet(K), tet(L), and tetA(P) have been found in anaerobic species and six of the ten tetracycline resistant genes coding for ribosomal protection proteins, tet(M), tet(O), tetB(P), tet(Q), tet(W), and tet(32), have been identified in anaerobes. There are now three enzymes which inactivate tetracycline, of which the tet(X) has been identified in Bacteroides though is not functional under anaerobic growth conditions. A similar situation exists with the genes conferring macrolide-lincosamide-streptogramin (MLS) resistance. Of the 26 rRNA methylase MLS resistant genes characterized, five genes; erm(B), erm(C), erm(F), erm(G), and erm(Q), have been identified in anaerobes. In contrast, no genes coding for MLS resistant efflux proteins or inactivating enzymes have been described in anaerobic species. This mini-review will summarize what is known about tetracycline and MLS resistance in genera with anaerobic species and the mobile elements associated with acquired tetracycline and/or MLS resistance genes.     

Deletion mutagenesis of Tn10 Tet repressor — localization of regions important for dimerization and inducibility in vivo

The gene for the Tn 10 Tet repressor (TetR) was subjected to deletion mutagenesis. Screening for a transdominant operator-binding negative phenotype yielded 10 mutants with internal deletions. Three deletions extend from residue D5 to residues L41, W75, or Q76, respectively, and two contain deletions of the α-helix-turn-α-helix DNA-binding motif. Five deletions range from residue K84 to residues between R87 and K98. Since residues from the N-terminus up to position 98 are not necessary for dimerization, this must take place in the C-terminal half of the protein. Ability to dimerize was probed by introducing ochre non-sense codons (oc) at residues G138, H151, E159, l174, or K202. Koc202 shows wild-type in vivo operator-binding and inducibility by tetracycline indicating that the six C-terminal residues of TetR are not important for activity. Mutants with longer C-terminal truncations are inactive and not transdominant. They show reduced steady-state protein levels and are probably impaired in folding and degraded in vivo . Two mutants (Δ151–166, Δ164–166) with deletions in a region variable in primary structure and length among Tet repressers from different resistance determinants bind tet operator efficiently, but are not inducibie by tetracycline. This result indicates that these residues are not important for dimer formation in the operator-binding form.     

A threonine to alanine exchange at position 40 of Tet repressor alters the recognition of the sixth base pair of tet operator from GC to AT.

The tet operators of two naturally evolved tetracycline resistance determinants differ by a G.C to A.T transition at the sixth base pair. This mutation prevents heterologous recognition of these tet operators by their respective two Tet repressor proteins. The amino acid side chains responsible for this sequence-specific distinction of operators were determined. For this purpose in vitro recombinants of the two tetR genes were constructed. Restriction sites were introduced by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis in both genes followed by the exchange of different coding segments between them. The encoded chimeric Tet repressor proteins were expressed and their operator recognition specificity was scored in vivo. Exchanging gradually smaller coding segments led finally to a single amino acid exchange in both genes at position 40 of the primary structures. Each Tet repressor containing Thr at this position recognizes the G.C operator while those with Ala recognize the A.T operator regardless of the rest of the sequences. This result demonstrates clearly that the amino acid 40 of Tet repressor contacts and recognizes base pair 6 of tet operator. Sterical interference of the large Thr side chain with the methyl group of A.T and a possible involvement of the hydroxyl in hydrogen bonding to the operator are discussed as the molecular basis of this differentiation between A.T and G.C base pairs.     

Molecular ecology of tetracycline resistance: development and validation of primers for detection of tetracycline resistance genes encoding ribosomal protection proteins

Phylogenetic analysis of tetracycline resistance genes encoding the ribosomal protection proteins (RPPs) revealed the monophyletic origin of these genes. The most deeply branching class, exemplified by tet and otrA, consisted of genes from the antibiotic-producing organisms Streptomyces rimosus and Streptomyces lividans. With a high degree of confidence, the corresponding genes of the other seven classes (Tet M, Tet S, Tet O, Tet W, Tet Q, Tet T, and TetB P) formed phylogenetically distinct separate clusters. Based on this phylogenetic analysis, a set of PCR primers for detection, retrieval, and sequence analysis of the corresponding gene fragments from a variety of bacterial and environmental sources was developed and characterized. A pair of degenerate primers targeted all tetracycline resistance genes encoding RPPs except otrA and tet, and seven other primer pairs were designed to target the specific classes. The primers were used to detect the circulation of these genes in the rumina of cows, in swine feed and feces, and in swine fecal streptococci. Classes Tet O and Tet W were found in the intestinal contents of both animals, while Tet M was confined to pigs and Tet Q was confined to the rumen. The tet(O) and tet(W) genes circulating in the microbiota of the rumen and the gastrointestinal tract of pigs were identical despite the differences in animal hosts and antibiotic use regimens. Swine fecal streptococci uniformly possessed the tet(O) gene, and 22% of them also carried tet(M). This population could be considered one of the main reservoirs of these two resistance genes in the pig gastrointestinal tract. All classes of RPPs except Tet T and TetB P were found in the commercial components of swine feed. This is the first demonstration of the applicability of molecular ecology techniques to estimation of the gene pool and the flux of antibiotic resistance genes in production animals.     

Saturation mutagenesis of the Tn10-encoded tet operator O1. Identification of base-pairs involved in Tet repressor recognition

Saturation mutagenesis of Tn10-encoded tet operator O1 was performed by chemical synthesis of 30 sequence variants yielding all possible point mutations of an operator half side. Their effect on Tet repressor binding was scored by an in-vivo repressor titration system. Tet repressor affinities of selected operator mutants were further characterized in vitro by dissociation rate measurements. The O1 sequence spans 19 base-pairs. Out of these, all 18 palindromic base-pairs are involved in Tet repressor recognition. The central base-pair does not contribute to sequence-specific binding of Tet repressor. At position 1 a pyrimidine residue is sufficient for maximal affinity to the repressor. At positions 2, 3 and 4, each mutation reduces repressor binding at least tenfold. Mutations at positions 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 result in less drastic reductions of Tet repressor binding. Differential effects of mutations at a given position are used to deduce the chemical functions contacted by Tet repressor. The T.A to A.T transversion at position 9 increases Tet repressor affinity slightly, while all other mutations decrease repressor binding. The increased affinity of the wild-type tet operator O2 compared to wild-type O1 results from the addition of two favorable transversions at positions +/- 9 and an unfavorable T.A to C.G transition at position -7. Deletion or palindromic doubling of the central base-pair of the O1 palindrome reveals that the wild-type spacing of both operator half sides is crucial for efficient Tet repressor binding.     

Analysis of tetracycline resistance encoded by transposon Tn10: deletion mapping of tetracycline-sensitive point mutations and identification of two structural genes

Deletions in the tet genes derived from Tn10 were formed from different tet::Tn5 insertion mutations by removing DNA sequences located between a HindIII site in Tn5 and a HindIII site adjacent to the tet genes. Tetracycline-sensitive point mutations were mapped in recombination tests with the deletions and were thus aligned with the genetic and physical map of the tet region. Plasmids carrying point mutations were tested for complementation with derivatives of pDU938, a plasmid carrying cloned tet genes derived from Tn10 which had been inactivated by Tn5 insertions. Complementation occurred between promoter-proximal tet point mutations and distal tet::Tn5 insertions, suggesting the existence of two structural genes, tetA and tetB. These results, together with the analysis of polypeptides in minicells harboring pDU938tet::Tn5 mutants, suggested that tetA and tetB are expressed coordinately in an operon. The tetB gene encodes the previously characterized 36,000-dalton cytoplasmic membrane TET protein, but the product of tetA was not identified. Point mutations in either tetA or tetB led to the defective expression of the resistance mechanism involving tetracycline efflux. It is suggested that the tetA and tetB products interact cooperatively in the membrane to express resistance.