Physical map of the Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 genome based on a bacterial artificial chromosome library as a platform for genome sequencing and functional analysis

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 is a Gram-negative proteobacterium of the beta subclass; it is a diazotrophic endophyte of graminaceous plants and can provide significant amounts of fixed nitrogen to its host plant Kallar grass. We aimed to obtain a physical map of the Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 chromosome to be directly used in functional analysis and as a part of an Azoarcus sp. BH72 genome project. A bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) library was constructed and analysed. A representative physical map with a high density of marker genes was developed in which 64 aligned BAC clones covered almost the entire genome.     

Azoarcus spp. and their interactions with grass roots

The current knowledge on the divergence within the genus Azoarcus and about interactions with grasses is summarized. Grass-associated members of this genus of diazotrophs have only been isolated from a salt- and flood-tolerant pioneer plant in Pakistan, Kallar grass (Leptochloa fusca (L.) Kunth). Members of these bacteria belong to the beta subclass of the Proteobacteria, most closely related to purple bacteria such as Rhodocyclus purpureus. The isolates from one single host plant showed a surprising divergence, consisting of five groups of Azoarcus distinct at the species level. Molecular diagnostic tests, which are based on 16S ribosomal RNA sequences, allowed preliminary assignment of isolates to Azoarcus by PCR amplification and sequencing of PCR products. Moreover, the moleculer tests enabled us to detect an unculturable strain in Kallar grass roots, stressing that classical cultivation techniques at times fail to detect some groups of the microbial population. Using similar techniques, sequences rooting in the Azoarcus clade were also detected in field-grown rice, indicating that the natural host range might extend to rice. In gnotobiotic laboratory cultures, a member of Azoarcus is able to colonize rice roots endophytically: bacteria invade the roots in the zone of elongation and differentiation, colonize the cortex intra- and inter-cellularly, and penetrate deeply into the vascular system, entering xylem vessels, allowing systemic spreading into the rice shoot. Recently, we detected expression of nitrogenase of Azoarcus cells inside roots of rice seedlings, a result encouraging us to analyze interactions with rice in detail.     

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 as a model for nitrogen-fixing grass endophytes

The availability of nitrogen often limits plant growth in terrestrial ecosystems. The only biological reaction counterbalancing the loss of N from soils or ecosystems is biological nitrogen fixation, the enzymatic reduction of N2 to ammonia. Some gramineous crops such as certain Brazilian sugar cane cultivars or Kallar grass can derive a substantial part of the plant nitrogen from biological nitrogen fixation. Our research on grass-associated diazotrophs focuses on endophytic bacteria, microorganisms that multiply and spread inside plants without causing damage of the host plants or conferring an ecological threat to the plant. This review summarizes the current knowledge on the diazotrophic endophyte Azoarcus sp. BH72, which is capable of colonizing the interior of rice roots, one of the globally most important crops.     

Twitching motility is essential for endophytic rice colonization by the N2-fixing endophyte Azoarcus sp. strain BH72

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72, as an endophyte of grasses, depends on successful host colonization. Type IV pili are essential for mediating the initial interaction with rice roots. In the genome sequence analysis, the pilT gene was identified, which encodes for a putative type IV pilus retraction protein. PilT of Azoarcus sp. BH72 shares high similarity to PilT of the human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 (77% amino acid sequence identity) and contains a predicted nucleotide-binding motif. To gain more insights into the role of the type IV pili in the colonization process of Azoarcus spp., we constructed an insertional mutant of pilT and a deletion mutant of pilA, the major structural component of the pilus structure. The pilT mutant, as the pilin deletion mutant deltapilA, was abolished in twitching motility. Western blot analyses and electron microscopy studies demonstrated an enhanced piliation of the Azoarcus pilT mutant strain compared with the wild type, indicating that, indeed, PilT has a role in pilus retraction. Studies on rice root colonization in gnotobiotic cultures revealed that the establishment of microcolonies on the root surface was strongly reduced in the deltapilA mutant, whereas the surface colonization was reduced by only 50% in the nontwitching pilT mutant. However, endophytic colonization of rice roots was strongly reduced in both mutants. These results demonstrate that the retractile force mediated by PilT is not essential for the bacterial colonization of the plant surface, but that twitching motility is necessary for invasion of and establishment inside the plant. Thus, a novel determinant for endophytic interactions with grasses was identified.     

Global changes in protein composition of N2-fixing-Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 upon diazosome formation.

The strictly respiratory, diazotrophic bacterium Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 fixes nitrogen under microaerobic conditions. In empirically optimized batch cultures at nanomolar O2 concentrations in the presence of proline, cells can shift into a state of higher activity and respiratory efficiency of N2 fixation in which intracytoplasmic membrane stacks (diazosomes) related to N2 fixation are formed. Induction of intracytoplasmic membranes is most pronounced in coculture of Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 with an ascomycete originating from the same host plant, Kallar grass. To initiate studies on function of diazosomes and regulation of their formation, diazosome-containing bacteria were compared with respect to composition or total cellular and membrane proteins with diazosome-free cells fixing nitrogen under standard conditions. In two-dimensional protein gels, we detected striking differences in protein patterns upon diazosome formation: (i) 7.3% of major proteins disappeared, and only 73% of the total proteins of control cells were detectable, indicating that diazosome-containing cells have a more specialized metabolism; (ii) nine new proteins appeared and five proteins increased in concentration, designated DP1 to DP 15; and (iii) five new major membrane proteins (MP1 to MP6) were detected, indicating that membranes might have specialized functions. N-terminal amino acid sequence analysis of DP1 to DP4 allowed us to preliminarily identify DP4 as the glnB gene product P(II), an intracellular signal transmitter known to be involved in the regulation of nitrogen metabolism. According to its electrophoretic mobility, it might be uridylylated in diazosome-free cells but not in diazosome-containing cells, or it may represent a second, not identical P(II) protein. Oligonucleotides deduced from N-terminal sequences of DP1 and DP4 specifically hybridized to chromosomal DNA of Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 in Southern hybridizations.     

Root-Zone-Specific Oxygen Tolerance of Azospirillum spp. and Diazotrophic Rods Closely Associated with Kallar Grass

The effect of oxygen on N₂-dependent growth of two Azospirillum strains and two diazotrophic rods closely associated with roots of Kallar grass (Leptochloa fusca) was studied. To enable precise comparison, bacteria were grown in dissolved-oxygen-controlled batch and continuous cultures. Steady states were obtained from about 1 to 30 μM O₂, some of them being carbon limited. All strains needed a minimum amount of oxygen for N₂-dependent growth. Nitrogen contents between 10 and 13% of cell dry weight were observed. The response of steady-state cultures to increasing O₂ concentrations suggested that carbon limitation shifted to internal nitrogen limitation when N₂ fixation became so low that the bacteria could no longer meet their requirements for fixed nitrogen. For Azospirillum lipoferum Rp5, increase of the dilution rate resulted in decreased N₂ fixation in steady-state cultures with internal nitrogen limitation. Oxygen tolerance was found to be strain specific in A. lipoferum with strain Sp59b as a reference organism. Oxygen tolerance of strains from Kallar grass was found to be root zone specific. A. halopraeferens Au 4 and A. lipoferum Rp5, predominating on the rhizoplane of Kallar grass, and strains H6a2 and BH72, predominating in the endorhizosphere, differed in their oxygen tolerance profiles. Strains H6a2 and BH72 still grew and fixed nitrogen in steady-state cultures at O₂ concentrations exceeding those which absolutely inhibited nitrogen fixation of both Azospirillum strains. It is proposed that root-zone-specific oxygen tolerance reflects an adaptation of the isolates to the microenvironments provided by the host plant.     

Preferential occurrence of diazotrophic endophytes, Azoarcus spp., in wild rice species and land races of Oryza sativa in comparison with modern races

Several diazotrophic species of Azoarcus spp. occur as endophytes in the pioneer plant Kallar grass. The purpose of this study was to screen Asian wild rice and cultivated Oryza sativa varieties for natural association with these endophytes. Populations of culturable diazotrophs in surface-sterilized roots were characterized by 16S rDNA sequence analysis, and Azoarcus species were identified by genomic fingerprints. A. indigens and Azoarcus sp. group C were detected only rarely, whereas Azoarcus sp. group D occurred frequently in samples of flooded plants: in 75% of wild rice, 80% of land races of O. sativa from Nepal and 33% of modern cultivars from Nepal and Italy. The putatively endophytic populations of diazotrophs differed with the rice genotype. The diversity of cultured diazotrophs was significantly lower in wild rice species than in modern cultivars. In Oryza officinalis (from Nepal) and O. minuta (from the Philippines), Azoarcus sp. group D were the predominant diazotrophic putative endophytes in roots. In contrast, their number was significantly lower in modern cultivars of O. sativa, whereas numbers and diversity of other diazotrophs, such as Azospirillum spp., Klebsiella sp., Sphingomonas paucimobilis, Burkholderia sp. and Azorhizobium caulinodans, were increased. In land races of O. sativa, the diazotrophic diversity was equally high; however, Azoarcus sp. was found in high apparent numbers. Similar differences in populations were also observed in a culture-independent approach comparing a wild rice (O. officinalis) and a modern-type O. sativa plant: in clone libraries of root-associated nitrogenase (nifH) gene fragments, the diazotrophic diversity was lower in the wild rice species. New lineages of nifH genes were detected, e.g. one deeply branching cluster within the anf (iron) nitrogenases. Our studies demonstrate that the natural host range of Azoarcus spp. extends to rice, wild rice species and old varieties being preferred over modern cultivars.     

Upregulation of jasmonate-inducible defense proteins and differential colonization of roots of Oryza sativa cultivars with the endophyte Azoarcus sp

The endophyte Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 expresses nitrogenase (nif) genes inside rice roots. We applied a proteomic approach to dissect responses of rice roots toward bacterial colonization and jasmonic acid (JA) treatment. Two sister lineages of Oryza sativa were analyzed with cv. IR42 showing a less compatible interaction with the Azoarcus sp. resulting in slight root browning whereas cv. IR36 was successfully colonized as determined by nifHi::gusA activity. External addition of JA inhibited colonization of roots and caused browning in contrast to the addition of ethylene, applied as ethephon (up to 5 mM). Only two of the proteins induced in cv. IR36 by JA were also induced by the endophyte (SalT, two isoforms). In contrast, seven JA-induced proteins were also induced by bacteria in cv. IR42, indicating that IR42 showed a stronger defense response. Mass spectrometry analysis identified these proteins as pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins (Prb1, RSOsPR10) or proteins sharing domains with receptorlike kinases induced by pathogens. Proteins strongly induced in roots in both varieties by JA were identified as Bowman-Birk trypsin inhibittors, germinlike protein, putative endo-1,3-beta-D-glucosidase, glutathion-S-transferase, and 1-propane-1-carboxylate oxidase synthase, peroxidase precursor, PR10-a, and a RAN protein previously not found to be JA-induced. Data suggest that plant defense responses involving JA may contribute to restricting endophytic colonization in grasses. Remarkably, in a compatible interaction with endophytes, JA-inducible stress or defense responses are apparently not important.     

Radial gas diffusion from roots of rice (Oryza sativa L.) and Kallar grass (Leptochloa fusca L. Kunth), and effects of inoculation withAzospirillum brasilense Cd

Cortical root air space (aerenchyma) helps rice and Kallar grass to survive flooding conditions. The dependence of the oxygen concentration in the rhizosphere on the root aerenchyma volume, the plant age,-species and plant respiration is described. Additionally diffusional effects of different types of gases are evaluated. Inoculation of the rhizosphere with the micro-aerobically N₂-fixing microorganismAzospirillum brasilense Cd brought about an increased oxygen concentration in the rhizosphere by the factor 3.3 for rice and 5.3 for Kallar grass. This effect is thought to be due to enhanced root cell wall permeability probably caused by IAA-like phytohormones released by the bacteria.     

Flagella mediate endophytic competence rather than act as MAMPS in rice-Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 interactions

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 is an endophytic betaproteobacterium able to colonize rice roots without induction of visible disease symptoms. BH72 possesses one polar flagellum. The genome harbors three copies of putative fliC genes, generally encoding the major structural protein flagellin. It is not clear whether, in endophytic interactions, flagella mediate endophytic competence or act as MAMPs (microbe-associated molecular patterns) inducing plant defense responses. Therefore, possible functions of the three FliC proteins were investigated. Only fliC3 was found to be highly expressed in pure culture and in association with rice roots and to be required for bacterial motility, suggesting that it encodes the major flagellin. Endophytic colonization of rice roots was significantly reduced in the in-frame deletion mutant, while the establishment of microcolonies on the root surface was not affected. Moreover, an elicitation of defense responses related to FliC3 was not observed. In conclusion, our data support the hypothesis that FliC3 does not play a major role as a MAMP but is required for endophytic colonization in the Azoarcus-rice interaction, most likely for spreading inside the plant.     

Complete genome of the mutualistic, N2-fixing grass endophyte Azoarcus sp. strain BH72

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72, a mutualistic endophyte of rice and other grasses, is of agrobiotechnological interest because it supplies biologically fixed nitrogen to its host and colonizes plants in remarkably high numbers without eliciting disease symptoms. The complete genome sequence is 4,376,040-bp long and contains 3,992 predicted protein-coding sequences. Genome comparison with the Azoarcus-related soil bacterium strain EbN1 revealed a surprisingly low degree of synteny. Coding sequences involved in the synthesis of surface components potentially important for plant-microbe interactions were more closely related to those of plant-associated bacteria. Strain BH72 appears to be 'disarmed' compared to plant pathogens, having only a few enzymes that degrade plant cell walls; it lacks type III and IV secretion systems, related toxins and an N-acyl homoserine lactones-based communication system. The genome contains remarkably few mobile elements, indicating a low rate of recent gene transfer that is presumably due to adaptation to a stable, low-stress microenvironment.     

Plant-bacteria interactions with special emphasis on the kallar grass association

Kallar grass is a highly salt-tolerant grass grown as a pioneer plant on alkaline, salt-affected soils in Pakistan. Nitrogen-fixing bacteria and kallar grass were found to be in close association, which was even root-zone specific: rhizoplane and endorhizosphere were colonized by two different populations. Among theAzospirillum isolates originating from the root surface, some were of a new species, now namedA. halopraeferens. To study plant-bacterium interactions, this natural kallar grass association was chosen. The possible role of bacterial chemotaxis and oxygen tolerance are discussed.     

Augmented rates of respiration and efficient nitrogen fixation at nanomolar concentrations of dissolved O2 in hyperinduced Azoarcus sp. strain BH72.

Azoarcus sp. strain BH72 is an aerobic diazotrophic bacterium that was originally found as an endophyte in Kallar grass. Anticipating that these bacteria are exposed to dissolved O2 concentrations (DOCs) in the nanomolar range during their life cycle, we studied the impact of increasing O2 deprivation on N2 fixation and respiration. Bacteria were grown in batch cultures, where they shifted into conditions of low pO2 upon depletion of O2 by respiration. During incubation, specific rates of respiration (qO2) and efficiencies of carbon source utilization for N2 reduction increased greatly, while the growth rate did not change significantly, a phenomenon that we called "hyperinduction." To evaluate this transition from high- to low-cost N2 fixation in terms of respiratory kinetics and nitrogenase activities at nanomolar DOC, bacteria which had shifted to different gas-phase pO2s in batch cultures were subjected to assays using leghemoglobin as the O2 carrier. As O2 deprivation in batch cultures proceeded, respiratory Km (O2) decreased and Vmax increased. Nitrogenase activity at nanomolar DOC increased to a specific rate of 180 nmol of C2H4 min-1 mg of protein-1 at 32 nM O2. Nitrogenase activity was proportional to respiration but not to DOC in the range of 12 to 86 nM O2. Respiration supported N2 fixation more efficiently at high than at low respiratory rates, the respiratory efficiency increasing from 0.14 to 0.47 mol of C2H4 mol of O2 consumed-1. We conclude that (i) during hyperinduction, strain BH72 used an increasing amount of energy generated by respiration for N2 fixation, and (ii) these bacteria have a high respiratory capacity, enabling them to develop ecological niches at very low pO2, in which they may respire actively and fix nitrogen efficiently at comparatively high rates.     

Association of nitrogen-fixing,plant-growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) with kallar grass and rice

Leptochloa fusca (L.) Kunth (kallar grass) has previously been found to exhibit high rates of nitrogen fixation. A series of experiments to determine the level of biological nitrogen fixation using N isotopic dilution were carried out in nutrient solution and saline soil. These studies indicated an agronomically significant amount of nitrogen being fixed in soil. Kallar grass has a similar growth habitat to rice. Therefore similar studies were carried out with rice after isolating various diazotrophs from the roots which were also screened for their ability to produce auxin (IAA). Five such strains namely Azospirillum lipoferum N-4, Azospirillum brasilense Wb-3, Azoarcus K-1, Pseudomonas 96-51, Zoogloea Ky-1 were selected for inoculating two rice varieties i.e. NIAB-6 and BAS-370 under aseptic laboratory conditions. The nitrogen fixed was quantified using the N isotopic dilution method. Variety BAS-370 had nearly 70% nitrogen derived from atmosphere (Ndfa) when inoculated with Azospirillum N-4. Similar studies with the mixed inoculum using N fertilizer in the micro plots indicated that nearly 29% of plant nitrogen was derived from the atmosphere.     

Induction of complex intracytoplasmic membranes related to nitrogen fixation in Azoarcus sp. BH72

We report the discovery of novel subcellular structures related to bacterial nitrogen fixation in the strictly respiratory diazotrophic bacterium Azoarcus sp. BH72, which was isolated as an endophyte from Kallar grass. Nitrogenase is derepressed under microaerobic conditions at O₂ concentrations in the micromolar range. With increasing O₂ deprivation, bacteria can develop into a hyperinduced state, which is characterized by high specific rates of respiration and efficient nitrogen fixation at approximately 30 nM O₂. Ultrastructural analysis of cells in the course of hyperinduction revealed that complex intracytoplasmic membrane systems are formed, which consist of stacks of membranes and which are absent under standard nitrogen-fixing conditions. The iron protein of nitrogenase was highly enriched on these membranes, as evidenced by immunohistochemical studies. Membrane deficiency in NifH/K⁻ mutants, a deletion mutant in the nifK gene and the character of NH₄⁺-grown cells suggested, in concert with the membrane localization of nitrogenase, that these structures are specialized membranes related to nitrogen fixation. We propose the term 'diazosomes' for them. Development of intracytoplasmic membranes coincides with the appearance of a high-molecular-mass form of the iron protein of nitrogenase, which was detectable in membrane fractions. Mutational analysis, and determination of the N-terminal amino acid sequence indicate that the nifH gene product is covalently modified by a mechanism probably different from adenosine diphosphoribosylation. Development of diazosomes in nitrogen-fixing cells can be induced in pure cultures and in co-culture with a fungus isolated from the rhizosphere of Kallar grass.     

Endophytic colonization and in planta nitrogen fixation by a Herbaspirillum sp. isolated from wild rice species.

Nitrogen-fixing bacteria were isolated from the stems of wild and cultivated rice on a modified Rennie medium. Based on 16S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) sequences, the diazotrophic isolates were phylogenetically close to four genera: Herbaspirillum, Ideonella, Enterobacter, and Azospirillum. Phenotypic properties and signature sequences of 16S rDNA indicated that three isolates (B65, B501, and B512) belong to the Herbaspirillum genus. To examine whether Herbaspirillum sp. strain B501 isolated from wild rice, Oryza officinalis, endophytically colonizes rice plants, the gfp gene encoding green fluorescent protein (GFP) was introduced into the bacteria. Observations by fluorescence stereomicroscopy showed that the GFP-tagged bacteria colonized shoots and seeds of aseptically grown seedlings of the original wild rice after inoculation of the seeds. Conversely, for cultivated rice Oryza sativa, no GFP fluorescence was observed for shoots and only weak signals were observed for seeds. Observations by fluorescence and electron microscopy revealed that Herbaspirillum sp. strain B501 colonized mainly intercellular spaces in the leaves of wild rice. Colony counts of surface-sterilized rice seedlings inoculated with the GFP-tagged bacteria indicated significantly more bacterial populations inside the original wild rice than in cultivated rice varieties. Moreover, after bacterial inoculation, in planta nitrogen fixation in young seedlings of wild rice, O. officinalis, was detected by the acetylene reduction and (15)N(2) gas incorporation assays. Therefore, we conclude that Herbaspirillum sp. strain B501 is a diazotrophic endophyte compatible with wild rice, particularly O. officinalis.     

Attachment,colonization and proliferation ofAzospirillum brasilense andEnterobacter spp. on root surface of grasses

Root colonization studies, employing immunofluorescence and using locally isolated strains, showed thatEnterbacter sp. QH7 andEnterobacter agglomerans AX12 attached more readily to the roots of most plants compared withAzospirillum brasilense JM82. Heat treatment of either root or inoculum significantly decreased the adsorption of bacteria to the root surface. Kallar grass and rice root exudates sustained the growth ofA. brasilense JM82,Enterobacter sp. QH7 andE. agglomerans AX12 in Hoagland and Fahraeus medium. All the strains colonized kallar grass and rice roots in an axenic culture system. However, in studies involving mixed cultures,A. brasilense JM82 was inhibited byEnterobacter sp. QH7 in kallar grass rhizosphere and the simultaneous presence ofEnterobacter sp. QH7 andE. agglomerans AX12 suppressed the growth ofA. brasilense JM82 in rice rhizosphere. The bacterial colonization pattern changed from dispersed to aggregated within 3 days of inoculation. The colonization sites corresponded mainly to the areas where root mucigel was present. The area around the point of emergence of lateral roots usually showed maximum colonization.