Procollagen triple helix assembly: an unconventional chaperone-assisted folding paradigm

Fibers composed of type I collagen triple helices form the organic scaffold of bone and many other tissues, yet the energetically preferred conformation of type I collagen at body temperature is a random coil. In fibers, the triple helix is stabilized by neighbors, but how does it fold? The observations reported here reveal surprising features that may represent a new paradigm for folding of marginally stable proteins. We find that human procollagen triple helix spontaneously folds into its native conformation at 30-34 degrees C but not at higher temperatures, even in an environment emulating Endoplasmic Reticulum (ER). ER-like molecular crowding by nonspecific proteins does not affect triple helix folding or aggregation of unfolded chains. Common ER chaperones may prevent aggregation and misfolding of procollagen C-propeptide in their traditional role of binding unfolded polypeptide chains. However, such binding only further destabilizes the triple helix. We argue that folding of the triple helix requires stabilization by preferential binding of chaperones to its folded, native conformation. Based on the triple helix folding temperature measured here and published binding constants, we deduce that HSP47 is likely to do just that. It takes over 20 HSP47 molecules to stabilize a single triple helix at body temperature. The required 50-200 microM concentration of free HSP47 is not unusual for heat-shock chaperones in ER, but it is 100 times higher than used in reported in vitro experiments, which did not reveal such stabilization.     

Hydration dynamics of the collagen triple helix by NMR

The hydration of the collagen-like Ac-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)(6)-NH(2) triple-helical peptide in solution was investigated using an integrated set of high-resolution NMR hydration experiments, including different recently developed exchange-network editing methods. This approach was designed to explore the hydration dynamics in the proximity of labile groups, such as the hydroxyproline hydroxyl group, and revealed that the first shell of hydration in collagen-like triple helices is kinetically labile with upper limits for water molecule residence times in the nanosecond to sub-nanosecond range. This result is consistent with a "hopping" hydration model in which solvent molecules are exchanged in and out of solvation sites at a rate that is not directly correlated to the degree of site localization. The hopping model thus reconciles the dynamic view of hydration revealed by NMR with the previously suggested partially ordered semi-clathrate-like cylinder of hydration. In addition, the nanosecond to sub-nanosecond upper limits for water molecule residence times imply that hydration-dehydration events are not likely to be the rate-limiting step for triple helix self-recognition, complementing previous investigations on water dynamics in collagen fibers. This study has also revealed labile proton features expected to facilitate the characterization of the structure and folding of triple helices in collagen peptides.     

Site-specific targeting of psoralen photoadducts with a triple helix-forming oligonucleotide: characterization of psoralen monoadduct and crosslink formation.

A polypurine tract in the supF gene of bacteriophage lambda (base pairs 167-176) was selected as the target for triple helix formation and targeted mutagenesis by an oligopurine (5'-AGGAAGGGGG-3') containing a chemically linked psoralen derivative (4'-hydroxymethyl-4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen) at its 5' terminus (psoAG10). The thymines at base pairs 166 and 167, a 5'ApT site, were targeted for photomodification. Exposure of the triple helical complex to long wavelength ultraviolet radiation led to the covalent binding of psoAG10 to the targeted region in the supF gene and to the induction of site-specific mutations. We report here experiments to characterize the photomodification of the targeted region of the supF gene in the context of triple helix formation. An electrophoretic mobility-shift assay showed that, at low radiation doses, monoadducts at base pair 166 were the major photoadducts. At higher doses the monoadducts were converted to crosslinks between base pairs 166 and 167. HPLC analysis of enzymatically hydrolyzed photoreaction mixtures was used to confirm the electrophoresis results. A strong strand preference for specific photoadduct formation was also detected.     

Solvent hydrogen-bond network in protein self-assembly: solvation of collagen triple helices in nonaqueous solvents.

Forces between type I collagen triple helices are studied in solvents of varying hydrogen-bonding ability. The swelling of collagen fibers in reconstituted films is controlled by the concentration of soluble polymers that are excluded from the fibers and that compete osmotically with collagen for available solvent. The interaxial spacing between the triple helices as a function of the polymer concentration is measured by x-ray diffraction. Exponential-like changes in the spacing with increasing osmotic stress, qualitatively similar to the forces previously found in aqueous solution, are also seen in formamide and ethylene glycol. These are solvents that, like water, are capable of forming three-dimensional hydrogen-bond networks. In solvents that either cannot form a network or have a greatly impaired ability to form a hydrogen-bonded network, strikingly different behavior is observed. A hard-wall repulsion is seen with collagen solvated by ethanol, 2-propanol, and N,N-dimethylformamide. The spacing between helices hardly changes with increasing polymer concentration until the stress exceeds some threshold where removal of the solvent becomes energetically favorable. No solvation of collagen is observed in dimethoxyethane. In solvents with an intermediate ability to form hydrogen-bonded networks, methanol, 2-methoxyethanol, or N-methylformamide, the change in spacing with polymer concentration is intermediate between exponential-like and hard-wall. These results provide direct evidence that the exponential repulsion observed between collagen helices at 0-8-A surface separations in water is due to the energetic cost associated with perturbing the hydrogen-bonded network of solvent molecules between the collagen surfaces.     

Structural insights into charge pair interactions in triple helical collagen-like proteins

The collagen triple helix is the most abundant protein fold in humans. Despite its deceptively simple structure, very little is understood about its folding and fibrillization energy landscape. In this work, using a combination of x-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, we carry out a detailed study of stabilizing pair-wise interactions between the positively charged lysine and the negatively charged amino acids aspartate and glutamate. We find important differences in the side chain conformation of amino acids in the crystalline and solution state. Structures from x-ray crystallography may have similarities to the densely packed triple helices of collagen fibers whereas solution NMR structures reveal the simpler interactions of isolated triple helices. In solution, two distinct types of contacts are observed: axial and lateral. Such register-specific interactions are crucial for the understanding of the registration process of collagens and the overall stability of proteins in this family. However, in the crystalline state, there is a significant rearrangement of the side chain conformation allowing for packing interactions between adjacent helices, which suggests that charged amino acids may play a dual role in collagen stabilization and folding, first at the level of triple helical assembly and second during fibril formation.     

Self-association of collagen triple helic peptides into higher order structures

Interest in self-association of peptides and proteins is motivated by an interest in the mechanism of physiologically higher order assembly of proteins such as collagen as well as the mechanism of pathological aggregation such as beta-amyloid formation. The triple helical form of (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(10), a peptide that has proved a useful model for molecular features of collagen, was found to self-associate, and its association properties are reported here. Turbidity experiments indicate that the triple helical peptide self-assembles at neutral pH via a nucleation-growth mechanism, with a critical concentration near 1 mM. The associated form is more stable than individual molecules by about 25 degrees C, and the association is reversible. The rate of self-association increases with temperature, supporting an entropically favored process. After self-association, (Pro-Hyp-Gly)(10) forms branched filamentous structures, in contrast with the highly ordered axially periodic structure of collagen fibrils. Yet a number of characteristics of triple helix assembly for the peptide resemble those of collagen fibril formation. These include promotion of fibril formation by neutral pH and increasing temperature; inhibition by sugars; and a requirement for hydroxyproline. It is suggested that these similar features for peptide and collagen self-association are based on common lateral underlying interactions between triple helical molecules mediated by hydrogen-bonded hydration networks involving hydroxyproline.     

Thermodynamics of oligonucleotide triple helices

Understanding of the cellular role of nucleic acid triple helices and utilization of triple helix forming oligonucleotides in biotechnology, diagnostics, and therapeutics depend on development of an understanding of triple helix formation as a function of the nucleic acid components and solution conditions. This article reviews developments in nucleic acid triple helix thermodynamics with emphasis on the thermal and thermodynamic stability and their dependence on solution conditions. Special emphasis is placed on the construction and interpretation of state diagrams as a means of characterizing the complex behavior of triple helix forming oligonucleotides. Recent developments, which strive to overcome some of the limitations imposed by the natural nucleotide bases and sugar-phosphate backbone, are reviewed from a thermodynamic perspective. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biopoly 44: 241–256, 1997     

The structure of bacteriophage T4 gene product 9: the trigger for tail contraction.

BACKGROUND: The T4 bacteriophage consists of a head, filled with double-stranded DNA, and a complex contractile tail required for the ejection of the viral genome into the Escherichia coli host. The tail has a baseplate to wh?ch are attached six long and six short tail fibers. These fibers are the sensing devices for recognizing the host. When activated by attachment to cell receptors, the fibers cause a conformational transition in the baseplate and subsequently in the tail sheath, which initiates DNA ejection. The baseplate is a multisubunit complex of proteins encoded by 15 genes. Gene product 9 (gp9) is the protein that connects the long tail fibers to the baseplate and triggers the tail contraction after virus attachment to a host cell. RESULTS: The crystal structure of recombinant gp9, determined to 2.3 A resolution, shows that the protein of 288 amino acid residues assembles as a homotrimer. The monomer consists of three domains: the N-terminal domain generates a triple coiled coil; the middle domain is a mixed, seven-stranded beta sandwich with a topology not previously observed; and the C-terminal domain is an eight-stranded, antiparallel beta sandwich having some resemblance to 'jelly-roll' viral capsid protein structures. CONCLUSIONS: The biologically active form of gp9 is a trimer. The protein contains flexible interdomain hinges, which are presumably required to facilitate signal transmission between the long tail fibers and the baseplate. Structural and genetic analyses show that the C-terminal domain is bound to the baseplate, and the N-terminal coiled-coil domain is associated with the long tail fibers.     

Exclusion of RNA strands from a purine motif triple helix.

Research concerning oligonucleotide-directed triple helix formation has mainly focused on the binding of DNA oligonucleotides to duplex DNA. The participation of RNA strands in triple helices is also of interest. For the pyrimidine motif (pyrimidine.purine.pyrimidine triplets), systematic substitution of RNA for DNA in one, two, or all three triplex strands has previously been reported. For the purine motif (purine.purine.pyrimidine triplets), studies have shown only that RNA cannot bind to duplex DNA. To extend this result, we created a DNA triple helix in the purine motif and systematically replaced one, two, or all three strands with RNA. In dramatic contrast to the general accommodation of RNA strands in the pyrimidine triple helix motif, a stable triplex forms in the purine motif only when all three of the substituent strands are DNA. The lack of triplex formation among any of the other seven possible strand combinations involving RNA suggests that: (i) duplex structures containing RNA cannot be targeted by DNA oligonucleotides in the purine motif; (ii) RNA strands cannot be employed to recognize duplex DNA in the purine motif; and (iii) RNA tertiary structures are likely to contain only isolated base triplets in the purine motif.     

Stalled folding mutants in the triple beta-helix domain of the phage P22 tailspike adhesin

The trimeric bacteriophage P22 tailspike adhesin exhibits a domain in which three extended strands intertwine, forming a single turn of a triple beta-helix. This domain contains a single hydrophobic core composed of residues contributed by each of the three sister polypeptide chains. The triple beta-helix functions as a molecular clamp, increasing the stability of this elongated structural protein. During folding of the tailspike protein, the last precursor before the native state is a partially folded trimeric intermediate called the protrimer. The transition from the protrimer to the native state results in a structure that is resistant to denaturation by heat, chemical denaturants, and proteases. Random mutations were made in the region encoding residues 540-548, where the sister chains begin to wrap around each other. From a set of 26 unique single amino acid substitutions, we characterized mutations at G546, N547, and I548 that retarded or blocked the protrimer to native trimer transition. In contrast, many non-conservative substitutions were tolerated at residues 540-544. Sucrose gradient analysis showed that protrimer-like mutants had reduced sedimentation, 8.0 S to 8.3 S versus 9.3 S for the native trimer. Mutants affected in the protrimer to native trimer transition were also destabilized in their native state. These data suggest that the folding of the triple beta-helix domain drives transition of the protrimer to the native state and is accompanied by a major rearrangement of polypeptide chains.     

Intramolecular triple helix as a model for regular polyribonucleotide (CAA)n

The regular (CAA)_n polyribonucleotide, as well as the omega leader sequence containing (CAA)-rich core, have recently been shown to form cooperatively melted and compact structures. In this report, we propose a structural model for the (CAA)_n sequence in which the polyribonucleotide chain is folded upon itself, so that it forms an intramolecular triple helix. The triple helix is stabilized by hydrogen bonding between bases thus forming coplanar triads, and by stacking interactions between the base triads. A distinctive feature of the proposed triple helix is that it does not contain the canonical double-helix elements. The difference from the known triple helices is that Watson-Crick hydrogen bond pairings do not take place in the interactions between the bases within the base triads.     

Crystal structure of human type III collagen Gly991-Gly1032 cystine knot-containing peptide shows both 7/2 and 10/3 triple helical symmetries

Type III collagen is a critical collagen that comprises extensible connective tissue such as skin, lung, and the vascular system. Mutations in the type III collagen gene, COL3A1, are associated with the most severe forms of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. A characteristic feature of type III collagen is the presence of a stabilizing C-terminal cystine knot. Crystal structures of collagen triple helices reported so far contain artificial sequences like (Gly-Pro-Pro)(n) or (Gly-Pro-Hyp)(n). To gain insight into the structural properties exhibited by the natural type III collagen triple helix, we synthesized, crystallized, and determined the structure of a 12-triplet repeating peptide containing the natural type III collagen sequence from residues 991 to 1032 including the C-terminal cystine knot region, to 2.3A resolution. This represents the longest collagen triple helical structure determined to date with a native sequence. Strikingly, the Gly(991)-Gly(1032) structure reveals that the central non-imino acid-containing region adopts 10/3 superhelical properties, whereas the imino acid rich N- and C-terminal regions adhere to a 7/2 superhelical conformation. The structure is consistent with two models for the cystine knot; however, the poor density for the majority of this region suggests that multiple conformations may be adopted. The structure shows that the multiple non-imino acids make several types of direct intrahelical as well as interhelical contacts. The looser superhelical structure of the non-imino acid region of collagen triple helices combined with the extra contacts afforded by ionic and polar residues likely play a role in fibrillar assembly and interactions with other extracellular components.     

Chemical modification of pyrimidine TFOs: effect on i-motif and triple helix formation

In order to form more stable triple helical structures or to prevent their degradation in cells, oligonucleotide analogs are routinely used, either in the backbone or among the bases. The target sequence chosen for this study is a 16-base-long oligopurine-oligopyrimidine region present in the human neurotrophin 4/5 gene. Seven different chemical modifications were tested for their effect on (i) triple helix formation and (ii) i-DNA stability. i-DNA is a tetrameric structure involving hemiprotonated C x C+ base pairs, which may act as a competing structure for triplex formation, especially in the case of a cytosine-rich third strand. At acid pH, oligophosphoramidates formed the most stable triple helix, whereas oligonucleotides including 5-propynyl-dU formed a stable i-motif which precluded triplex formation. Only two candidates stabilized triple helices at neutral pH: oligonucleotides with phosphoramidate linkage and phosphodiester oligonucleotides containing 5-methyl-dC and 5-propynyl-dU.     

Rational design of switched triple helix-forming oligonucleotides: Extension of sequences for triple helix formation

A rational design by means of molecular mechanics has been carried out in an effort to extend the range of double-helical DNA sequences that could be recognized by triple helix-forming oligonucleotides. The DNA target is composed of alternating, adjacent fragments of oligopurine·oligopyrimidine sequences, instead of a long stretch of polypurine·polypyrimidine sequence used for canonical triple helix formation. Based on the combination of different triple helix motifs in eitherHoogsteen orreverse Hoogsteen configuration, mini-triple helices can be formed at each oligopurine·oligopyrimidine part of the target sequence with either parallel or antiparallel orientation with respect to the purine strand. As the adjacent purine target sequences are located in the complementary strands, the third strand oligonucleotides can be joined together through a natural phosphodiester backbone at the junctions in either a 5-3 or a 3-5 polarity. There are six distinct junction steps. Molecular modeling was aimed at optimizing the cooperative binding of the so-called switched triple helix-forming oligonucleotides by choosing appropriate nucleotide(s) at the junction between two adjacent minitriple helices. A comprehensiveswitch code describing the rules for forming switched triple helices has been established. Its practical applications in extending DNA recognition by this new generation of tailor-made triple helix-forming oligonucleotides are discussed.     

Streptococcal Scl1 and Scl2 proteins form collagen-like triple helices

The collagens are a family of animal proteins containing segments of repeated Gly-Xaa-Yaa (GXY) motifs that form a characteristic triple-helical structure. Genes encoding proteins with repeated GXY motifs have also been reported in bacteria and phages; however, it is unclear whether these prokaryotic proteins can form a collagen-like triple-helical structure. Here we used two recently identified streptococcal proteins, Scl1 and Scl2, containing extended GXY sequence repeats as model proteins. First we observed that prior to heat denaturation recombinant Scl proteins migrated as homotrimers in gel electrophoresis with and without SDS. We next showed that the collagen-like domain of Scl is resistant to proteolysis by trypsin. We further showed that circular dichroism spectra of the Scl proteins contained features characteristic of collagen triple helices, including a positive maximum of ellipticity at 220 nm. Furthermore the triple helices of Scl1 and Scl2 showed a temperature-dependent unfolding with melting temperatures of 36.4 and 37.6 degrees C, respectively, which resembles those seen for collagens. We finally demonstrated by electron microscopy that the Scl proteins are organized into "lollipop-like" structures, similar to those seen in human proteins with collagenous domains. This implies that the repeated GXY tripeptide motif is a structural indicator of collagen-like triple helices in proteins from such phylogenetically distant sources as bacteria and humans.     

Collagen triple helix formation can be nucleated at either end

The directional dependence of folding rates for rod-like macromolecules such as parallel alpha-helical coiled-coils, DNA double-helices, and collagen triple helices is largely unexplored. This is mainly due to technical difficulties in measuring rates in different directions. Folding of collagens is nucleated by trimeric non-collagenous domains. These are usually located at the COOH terminus, suggesting that triple helix folding proceeds from the COOH to the NH(2) terminus. Evidence is presented here that effective nucleation is possible at both ends of the collagen-like peptide (Gly-Pro-Pro)(10), using designed proteins in which this peptide is fused either NH(2)- or COOH-terminal to a nucleation domain, either T4-phage foldon or the disulfide knot of type III collagen. The location of the nucleation domain influences triple-helical stability, which might be explained by differences in the linker sequences and the presence or absence of repulsive charges at the carboxyl-terminal end of the triple helix. Triple helical folding rates are found to be independent of the site of nucleation and consistent with cis-trans isomerization being the rate-limiting step.     

The chain register in heterotrimeric collagen peptides affects triple helix stability and folding kinetics

Collagen type IV is a highly specialized form of collagen found only in basement membranes, where it provides mechanical stability and structural integrity to tissues and organs, and binding sites for cell adhesion. In its ubiquitous form, collagen type IV consists of two alpha1 chains and one alpha2 chain, whose internal alignment within the triple helix seems to exert a strong influence on the binding affinity to alpha1beta1 integrin receptor. This has been assessed recently using two synthetic collagen peptides that contain the cell adhesion epitope of collagen type IV and are assembled into the most plausible alpha1alpha2alpha1' and alpha2alpha1alpha1' registers. In the present study, the effects of the chain register on the stability of the triple helix and the folding kinetics of these collagen peptides were investigated by CD spectroscopy and microcalorimetry. The results revealed a multi-domain structural organization for both trimers, with an unexpected strong effect of the chain alignment on the conformational stability. Molecular dynamics simulations served to rationalize more properly the experimental results.     

Collagen structure: the Madras triple helix and the current scenario

This year marks the 50th anniversary of the coiled-coil triple helical structure of collagen, first proposed by Ramachandran's group from Madras. The structure is unique among the protein secondary structures in that it requires a very specific tripeptide sequence repeat, with glycine being mandatory at every third position and readily accommodates the imino acids proline/hydroxyproline, at the other two positions. The original structure was postulated to be stabilized by two interchain hydrogen bonds, per tripeptide. Subsequent modeling studies suggested that the triple helix is stabilized by one direct inter chain hydrogen bond as well as water mediated hydrogen bonds. The hydroxyproline residues were also implicated to play an important role in stabilizing the collagen fibres. Several high resolution crystal structures of oligopeptides related to collagen have been determined in the last ten years. Stability of synthetic mimics of collagen has also been extensively studied. These have confirmed the essential correctness of the coiled-coil triple helical structure of collagen, as well as the role of water and hydroxyproline residues, but also indicated additional sequence-dependent features. This review discusses some of these recent results and their implications for collagen fiber formation.     

Antigenic Properties of Bacteriophage φ29 Structural Proteins

Serological methods and electron microscopy were used to study the structural proteins of the small Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage phi29. This virus has a large number of fibers attached at both ends of its prolate head. A complex neck assembly is comprised of 12 symmetrically arranged appendages as the outer component. Head fibers, neck appendages, and the head surface bind anti-phi29 antibodies. Immune sera absorbed with defective lysates of suppressor-sensitive (sus) mutants have been used to determine the genetic control of neck appendages production. Studies on the serum-blocking power of lysates defective in different tail components showed that appendages contain the main serum-blocking protein. This finding suggests an essential role of the neck appendages in phage adsorption or DNA injection.     

Comprehensive analysis of all triple helical repeats in beta-spectrins reveals patterns of selective evolutionary conservation

The spectrin superfamily (spectrin, alpha-actinin, utrophin and dystrophin) has in common a triple helical repeating unit of ~106 amino acid residues. In spectrin, alpha and beta chains contain multiple copies of this repeat. beta-spectrin chains contain the majority of binding activities in spectrin and are essential for animal life. Canonical beta-spectrins have 17 repeats; beta-heavy spectrins have 30. Here, the repeats of five human beta-spectrins, plus beta-spectrins from several other vertebrates and invertebrates, have been analysed. Repeats 1, 2, 14 and 17 in canonical beta are highly conserved between invertebrates and vertebrates, and repeat 8 in some isoforms. This is consistent with conservation of critical functions, since repeats 1, 2 and 17 bind alpha-spectrin. Repeats 1 of beta-spectrins are not always detected by SMART or Pfam tools. A profile hidden Markov model of beta-spectrin repeat 1 detects alpha-actinins, but not utrophin or dystrophin. Novel examples of repeat 1 were detected in the spectraplakins MACF1, BPAG1 and plectin close to the actin-binding domain. Ankyrin binds to the C-terminal portion of repeat 14; the high conservation of this entire repeat may point to additional, undiscovered ligand-binding activities. This analysis indicates that the basic triple helical repeat pattern was adapted early in the evolution of the spectrin superfamily to encompass essential binding activities, which characterise individual repeats in proteins extant today.