Periodicity of DNA folding in higher order chromatin structures.

Each level of DNA folding in cells corresponds to a distinct chromatin structure. The basic chromatin units, nucleosomes, are arranged into solenoids which form chromatin loops. To characterize better the loop organization of chromatin we have assumed that the accessibility of DNA inside these structures is lower than on the outside and examined the size distribution of high mol. wt DNA fragments obtained from cells and isolated nuclei after digestion with endogenous nuclease or topoisomerase II. The largest discrete fragments obtained contain 300 kbp of DNA. Their further degradation proceeds through another discrete size step of 50 kbp. This suggests that chromatin loops contain approximately 50 kbp of DNA and that they are grouped into hexameric rosettes at the next higher level of chromatin structure. Based upon these observations a model by which the 30 nm chromatin fibre can be folded up into compact metaphase chromosomes is also described.     

Higher order chromatin structures in maize and Arabidopsis.

We are investigating the nature of plant genome domain organization by using DNase I- and topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage to produce domains reflecting higher order chromatin structures. Limited digestion of nuclei with DNase I results in the conversion of the >800 kb genomic DNA to an accumulation of fragments that represents a collection of individual domains of the genome created by preferential cleavage at super-hypersensitive regions. The median size of these fragments is approximately 45 kb in maize and approximately 25 kb in Arabidopsis. Hybridization analyses with specific gene probes revealed that individual genes occupy discrete domains within the distribution created by DNase I. The maize alcohol dehydrogenase Adh1 gene occupies a domain of 90 kb, and the maize general regulatory factor GRF1 gene occupies a domain of 100 kb in length. Arabidopsis Adh was found within two distinct domains of 8.3 and 6.1 kb, whereas an Arabidopsis GRF gene occupies a single domain of 27 kb. The domains created by topoisomerase II-mediated cleavage are identical in size to those created by DNase I. These results imply that the genome is not packaged by means of a random gathering of the genome into domains of indiscriminate length but rather that the genome is gathered into specific domains and that a gene consistently occupies a discrete physical section of the genome. Our proposed model is that these large organizational domains represent the fundamental structural loop domains created by attachment of chromatin to the nuclear matrix at loop basements. These loop domains may be distinct from the domains created by the matrix attachment regions that typically flank smaller, often functionally distinct sections of the genome.     

Scatter analysis of discrete-sized chromatin fragments favours a cylindrical organization

Fragments of chromatin containing 23 +/- 2.5 nucleosomes have been fractionated after light nuclease treatment of chicken erythrocyte nuclei. Low-angle scattering measures the total z-average radius of gyration of the already well-defined particles and the shape of scatter curves can be compared with three-dimensional analysis as opposed to cross-section analysis of long chromatin fragments. The data show that the particles are not spherical, have no detectable hole in the center of the structure and are best represented by a solid rod-like shape such as that generated by a coil of nucleosomes with the centre perhaps filled with linker DNA and histone H1/H5. 23 nucleosome fragments, where the DNA is partially fragmented, have near-identical scatter curves to the above-defined intact particles, indicating the primary importance of histone proteins in maintaining the integrity of the chromatin higher-order structure. Neutron scattering shows the radii of gyration to be contrast-independent, which fits in with the model calculations for solenoids. Particles with fragmented DNA and the intact particles, therefore, behave as sections of a solenoidal higher-order structure and possibly are observed as "superbeads' only during the folding and unfolding pathways of nucleosome multimers.     

Disassembly of chromatin into approximately equal to 50 kb units by detergent

Nuclei isolated from higher eukaryotic cell lines were directly analyzed by field inversion gel electrophoresis. Brief incubation of nuclei with ionic detergents yielded a single band between 50-100 kb. The apparent fragment size decreased to approximately equal to 50 kb after proteinase digestion. The latter treatment alone induced less regular, less than or equal to 50 kb fragmentation. DNA extracted from detergent and proteinase-treated nuclei also appeared in a band of about 40 kb. Embedding into agarose plugs did not protect nuclei, as opposed to cells, from detergent-induced fragmentation. The phenomenon is strikingly analogous to the double-strand DNA cleavage reactions mediated by topoisomerase II. Our data are compatible with any of the following interpretations: 1.) regularly spaced protein bridges, probably involving topoisomerase II, maintain or control continuity of chromosomal DNA in certain states of higher eukaryotic cells. 2.) The DNA might become accessible to a putative endonuclease at regularly spaced sites upon detergent treatment of isolated nuclei.     

Topoisomerase II cleavage in chromatin

We have examined the effect of the anti-tumor drug VM-26 on purified Drosophila topoisomerase II, and used this drug to map (putative) topoisomerase II cleavage sites in chromatin. These studies indicate that VM-26 interferes with the strand breakage-rejoining catalytic cycle. VM-26 appears to stabilize the topoisomerase-II-cleavable complex and markedly enhances the formation of double-strand breaks in naked DNA. VM-26 also stimulates the formation of double-strand breaks in isolated Drosophila nuclei. Analysis of the parameters of the VM-26-stimulated cleavage reaction in nuclei strongly suggests that the double-strand scissions are generated by endogenous topoisomerase II. Finally, we have examined the distribution of (putative) cleavage sites for endogenous topoisomerase II in the chromatin of the 87A7 heat shock locus and the histone repeat unit. We have found that there are prominent VM-26-induced cleavage products from the 5' ends of the 87A7, the two heat shock protein 70 genes, and in the intergenic spacer separating these genes. Moreover, the pattern of VM-26-induced cleavage products is altered in nuclei prepared from heat-shocked cells. In the case of the histone repeat unit, only minor VM-26-induced cleavage products are observed in nuclei (in spite of the fact that experiments on naked DNA indicate that the histone repeat contains many major cleavage sites for purified topoisomerase II). These findings suggest that the nucleoprotein organization of different DNA segments may be important in determining whether specific sites are accessible to endogenous topoisomerase II in nuclei.     

Perturbation of chromatin structure in the region of the adult beta-globin gene in chicken erythrocyte chromatin

An EcoRI chromatin fragment containing the adult beta-globin gene and flanking sequences, isolated from chicken erythrocyte nuclei, sediments at a reduced rate relative to bulk chromatin fragments of the same size. We show that the specific retardation cannot be reversed by adding extra linker histones to native chromatin. When the chromatin fragments are unfolded either by removing linker histones or lowering the ionic strength, the difference between globin and bulk chromatin fragments is no longer seen. The refolded chromatin obtained by restoring the linker histones to the depleted chromatin, however, exhibits the original sedimentation difference. This difference is therefore due to a special property of the histone octamers on the active gene that determines the extent of its folding into higher-order structure. That it is not due to the differential binding of linker histones in vitro is shown by measurements of the protein to DNA ratios using CsCl density-gradients. Both before and after selective removal of the linker histones, the globin gene fragment and bulk chromatin fragments exhibit only a marginal difference in buoyant density. In addition, we show that cleavage of the EcoRI fragment by digestion at the 5' and 3' nuclease hypersensitive sites flanking the globin gene liberates a fragment from between these sites that sediments normally. We conclude that the hypersensitive sites per se are responsible for the reduction in sedimentation rate. The non-nucleosomal DNA segments appear to be too long to be incorporated into the chromatin solenoid and thus create spacers between separate solenoidal elements in the chromatin, which can account for its hydrodynamic behaviour.     

Different conformations of ribosomal DNA in active and inactive chromatin in Xenopus laevis

The chromatin structure of the ribosomal DNA in Xenopus laevis was studied by micrococcal nuclease digestions of blood, liver and embryonic cell nuclei. We have found that BglI-restricted DNA from micrococcal nuclease-digested blood cell nuclei has an increased electrophoretic mobility compared to the undigested control. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of liver cell nuclei causes a very slight shift in mobility, only in the region of the spacer containing the "Bam Islands". In contrast, the mobility of ribosomal DNA in chromatin of embryonic cells, under identical digestion conditions, remains unaffected by the nuclease activity. Denaturing gels or ligase action on the nuclease-treated DNA abolishes the differences in the electrophoretic mobility. Ionic strength and ethidium bromide influence the relative electrophoretic migration of the two DNA fragment populations, suggesting that secondary structure may play an important role in the observed phenomena. In addition, restriction analysis under native electrophoretic conditions of DNA prepared from blood, liver and embryonic cells shows that blood cell DNA restriction fragments always have a faster mobility than the corresponding fragments of liver and embryo cell DNA. We therefore propose that nicking activity by micrococcal nuclease modifies the electrophoretic mobility of an unusual DNA conformation, present in blood cell, and to a lesser extent, in liver cell ribosomal chromatin. A possible function for these structures is discussed. The differences of the ribosomal chromatin structures in adult and embryonic tissues may reflect the potential of the genes to be expressed.     

Cell cycle control of higher-order chromatin assembly around naked DNA in vitro.

We have developed an in vitro system in which higher-order chromatin structures are assembled around naked DNAs in a cell cycle-dependent manner. Membrane-free soluble extracts specific to interphase and mitotic states were prepared from Xenopus eggs. When high molecular weight DNA is incubated with interphase extracts, fluffy chromatin-like structures are assembled. In contrast, mitotic extracts produce highly condensed chromosome-like structures. Immunofluorescence studies show that a monoclonal antibody MPM-2, which recognizes a class of mitosis-specific phosphoproteins, stains the "core" or "axis" of condensed mitotic chromatin but not interphase chromatin. By adding mitotic extracts, interphase chromatin structures are synchronously converted into the condensed state. The increasingly condensed state of chromatin correlates with the appearance and structural rearrangements of the MPM-2-stained structures. These results suggest that mitosis-specific phosphoproteins recognized by MPM-2 may be directly involved in the assembly of the chromosome scaffold-like structures and chromatin condensation. Although both extracts promote nucleosome assembly at the same rate, topoisomerase II (topo II) activity is four to five times higher in mitotic extracts compared with interphase extracts. The addition of a topo II inhibitor VM-26 into mitotic assembly mixtures disturbs the organization of the MPM-2-stained structures and affects the final stage of chromatin condensation. This in vitro system should be useful for identifying cis- and trans-acting elements responsible for higher-order chromatin assembly and its structural changes in the cell cycle.     

Mitotic chromatin condensation in vitro using somatic cell extracts and nuclei with variable levels of endogenous topoisomerase II

We report the development of a new method for producing mitotic extracts from tissue culture cells. These extracts reproducibly promote the condensation of chromatin in vitro when incubated with purified interphase nuclei. This condensation reaction is not species specific, since nuclei from chicken, human, and hamster cell lines all undergo chromatin condensation upon incubation with the extract. We have used this extract to investigate the role of DNA topoisomerase II (topo II) in the chromosome condensation process. Chromatin condensation does not require the presence of soluble topo II in the mitotic extract. However, the extent of formation of discrete chromosome-like structures correlates with the level of endogenous topo II present in the interphase nuclei. Our results further suggest that chromatin condensation in this extract may involve two processes: chromatin compaction and resolution into discrete chromosomes.     

Topoisomerase II: a fitted mechanism for the chromatin landscape

The mechanism by which type-2A topoisomerases transport one DNA duplex through a transient double-strand break produced in another exhibits fascinating traits. One of them is the fine coupling between inter-domainal movements and ATP usage; another is their preference to transport DNA in particular directions. These capabilities have been inferred from in vitro studies but we ignore their significance inside the cell, where DNA configurations markedly differ from those of DNA in free solution. The eukaryotic type-2A enzyme, topoisomerase II, is the second most abundant chromatin protein after histones and its biological roles include the decatenation of newly replicated DNA and the relaxation of polymerase-driven supercoils. Yet, topoisomerase II is also implicated in other cellular processes such as chromatin folding and gene expression, in which the topological transformations catalysed by the enzyme are uncertain. Here, some capabilities of topoisomerase II that might be relevant to infer the enzyme performance in the context of chromatin architecture are discussed. Some aspects addressed are the importance of the DNA rejoining step to ensure genome stability, the regulation of the enzyme activity and of its putative structural role, and the selectively of DNA transport in the chromatin milieu.     

Effect of in vivo histone hyperacetylation on the state of chromatin fibers.

We evaluated the contribution of in vivo histone acetylation to the folding of chromatin into its higher-order structures. We have compared high-order folding patterns of hyperacetylated vs. unmodified chromatin in living green monkey kidney cells (CV1 line) using intercalator chloroquine diphospate to induce alterations in the twist of internucleosomal linker DNA. We have shown that histone hyperacetylation induced by antibiotic Trichostatin A significantly alters intercalator-mediated chromatin folding pattern.     

Mapping of sequence-specific chromatin proteins by a novel method: topoisomerase I on Tetrahymena ribosomal chromatin

DNA derived from the 5' spacers of the rRNA genes from Tetrahymena has unusual electrophoretic properties. These properties made it possible to devise a simple electrophoretic procedure for isolating specific rDNA spacer fragments from preparations of total nuclear DNA, enabling us to study DNA modifications at the level of unfractionated nuclei. We have employed the method to study the distribution of topoisomerase I binding sites on the r-chromatin (ribosomal chromatin) of Tetrahymena at the DNA sequence level. The presence of topoisomerase I in situ was detected by its ability to introduce single-strand cleavages into DNA. The positions of the cleavages were determined on DNA sequencing gels after isolation of the fragments. Topoisomerase I binding in r-chromatin is sequence specific and cleavage is confined to a 16 base-pair conserved sequence element previously determined to be a high-affinity binding site for topoisomerase I in vitro. The high degree of sequence specificity may be of important functional significance, as we find a similar sequence specificity with enzymes isolated from five evolutionarily distant species, indicating that preference for the 16 base-pair element is an intrinsic property of eukaryotic type I topoisomerases.     

Properties of condensed chromatin in barley nuclei

A method for isolation and purification of intact nuclei from barley leaves was developed and several properties of the chromatin were studied. The dense structure of the main part of the chromatin does not alter the accessibility of the DNA to nucleases. 60% of the nuclear DNA can be degraded by micrococcal endonuclease. Nevertheless the solubility of the chromatin fragments depends on the extent of nuclease digestion; solubilisation occurring only when the major part of the internucleosomal DNA was degraded (30% of digestion). Electron microscopic observations suggest that this was due to particularly dense organization of the chromatin in situ. The possible physiological meaning of some of these properties are discussed.     

Histone acetylation: a switch between repressive and permissive chromatin. Second in review series on chromatin dynamics

The organization of eukaryotic chromatin has a major impact on all nuclear processes involving DNA substrates. Gene expression is affected by the positioning of individual nucleosomes relative to regulatory sequence elements, by the folding of the nucleosomal fiber into higher-order structures and by the compartmentalization of functional domains within the nucleus. Because site-specific acetylation of nucleosomal histones influences all three aspects of chromatin organization, it is central to the switch between permissive and repressive chromatin structure. The targeting of enzymes that modulate the histone acetylation status of chromatin, in synergy with the effects mediated by other chromatin remodeling factors, is central to gene regulation.     

Endogenous degradation of rat liver chromatin studied by agar gel electrophoresis of nuclei

Direct agar gel electrophoresis of incubated rat liver nuclei revealed that most of the chromatin is rapidly converted to stable, large fragments, showing identical electrophoretic mobility. Short and long term incubation gave the same results. The analysis of deproteinized DNA under nondenaturing as well as denaturing conditions showed, however, a correlation between the DNA size pattern and the time of incubation. Our data on the persistance of large and uniform in size chromatin fragments despite the presence of cleaved DNA in them may indicate naturally footprinted regions of chromatin, implying most probably some strong ordered interaction of chromatin constituents. It seems that some substantial unknown features of higher order structure of chromatin are preserved in rat liver nuclei isolated and digested under the experimental conditions used.     

Intra- and inter-nucleosome interactions of the core histone tail domains in higher-order chromatin structure

Eukaryotic chromatin is a hierarchical collection of nucleoprotein structures that package DNA to form chromosomes. The initial levels of packaging include folding of long strings of nucleosomes into secondary structures and array–array association into higher-order tertiary chromatin structures. The core histone tail domains are required for the assembly of higher-order structures and mediate short- and long-range intra- and inter-nucleosome interactions with both DNA and protein targets to direct their assembly. However, important details of these interactions remain unclear and are a subject of much interest and recent investigations. Here, we review work defining the interactions of the histone N-terminal tails with DNA and protein targets relevant to chromatin higher-order structures, with a specific emphasis on the contributions of H3 and H4 tails to oligonucleosome folding and stabilization. We evaluate both classic and recent experiments determining tail structures, effect of tail cleavage/loss, and posttranslational modifications of the tails on nucleosomes and nucleosome arrays, as well as inter-nucleosomal and inter-array interactions of the H3 and H4 N-terminal tails.     

Association between DNA cleavage during apoptosis and regions of chromatin replication

We have addressed the association between the site of DNA cleavage during apoptosis and DNA replication. DNA double strand breaks were introduced into chromatin containing pulse labeled nascent DNA by the induction of apoptosis or autocleavage of isolated nuclei. The location of these breaks in relation to nascent DNA were revealed by Bal 31 exonuclease digestion at the cut sites. Our data show that Bal31 accessible cut sites are directly linked to regions enriched in nascent DNA. We suggest that these regions coincide with the termini of replication domains, possibly linked by strong DNA-matrix interactions with biophysically defined topological structures of 0.5 - 1.3 Mbp in size. The 50 kbp fragments that are commonly observed as products of apoptosis are also enriched in nascent DNA within internal regions but not at their termini. It is proposed that these fragments contain a subset of replicon DNA that is excised during apoptosis through recognition of their weak attachment to the nuclear matrix within the replication domain.J. Cell. Biochem. 70:604-615, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.