Alternative heterocycles for DNA recognition: a 3-pyrazole/pyrrole pair specifies for G.C base pairs

Synthetic ligands comprising three aromatic amino acids, pyrrole (Py), imidazole (Im), and hydroxypyrrole (Hp), specifically recognize predetermined sequences as side-by-side pairs in the minor groove of DNA. To expand the repertoire of aromatic rings that may be utilized for minor groove recognition, three five-membered heterocyclic rings, 3-pyrazolecarboxylic acid (3-Pz), 4-pyrazolecarboxylic acid (4-Pz), and furan-2-carboxylic acid (Fr), were examined at the N-terminus of eight-ring hairpin polyamide ligands. The DNA binding properties of 3-Pz, 4-Pz, and Fr each paired with Py were studied by quantitative DNase I footprinting titrations on a 283 bp DNA restriction fragment containing four 6-bp binding sites 5'-ATNCCTAA-3' (N = G, C, A, or T; 6-bp polyamide binding site is underlined). The pair 3-Pz/Py has increased binding affinity and sequence specificity for G.C bp compared with Im/Py.     

Novel diamino imidazole and pyrrole-containing polyamides: Synthesis and DNA binding studies of mono- and diamino-phenyl-ImPy*Im polyamides designed to target 5'-ACGCGT-3'

Pyrrole- and imidazole-containing polyamides are widely investigated as DNA sequence selective binding agents that have potential use as gene control agents. The key challenges that must be overcome to realize this goal is the development of polyamides with low molar mass so the molecules can readily diffuse into cells and concentrate in the nucleus. In addition, the molecules must have appreciable water solubility, bind DNA sequence specifically, and with high affinity. It is on this basis that the orthogonally positioned diamino/dicationic polyamide Ph-ImPy*Im 5 was designed to target the sequence 5'-ACGCGT-3'. Py* denotes the pyrrole unit that contains a N-substituted aminopropyl pendant group. The DNA binding properties of diamino polyamide 5 were determined using a number of techniques including CD, ΔT(M), DNase I footprinting, SPR and ITC studies. The effects of the second amino moiety in Py* on DNA binding affinity over its monoamino counterpart Ph-ImPyIm 3 were assessed by conducting DNA binding studies of 3 in parallel with 5. The results confirmed the minor groove binding and selectivity of both polyamides for the cognate sequence 5'-ACGCGT-3'. The diamino/dicationic polyamide 5 showed enhanced binding affinity and higher solubility in aqueous media over its monoamino/monocationic counterpart Ph-ImPyIm 3. The binding constant of 5, determined from SPR studies, was found to be 1.5 × 10(7)M(-1), which is ～3 times higher than that for its monoamino analog 3 (4.8 × 10(6)M(-1)). The affinity of 5 is now approaching that of the parent compound f-ImPyIm 1 and its diamino equivalent 4. The advantages of the design of diamino polyamide 5 over 1 and 4 are its sequence specificity and the ease of synthesis compared to the N-terminus pyrrole analog 2.     

Kinetic consequences of covalent linkage of DNA binding polyamides

Polyamides composed of N-methylpyrrole (Py) and N-methylimidazole (Im) subunits can bind in the minor groove of DNA at predetermined sequences with subnanomolar affinity and high specificity. Covalent linkage of polymer subunits using a gamma-aminobutyric acid linker has been shown to increase both the affinity and specificity of polyamides. Using a fluorescence detected stopped-flow assay, we have studied the differences in association and dissociation kinetics of a series of polyamides representing unlinked, hairpin and cyclic analogues of the four ring polyamide ImPyPyPy-beta-Dp. Whereas the large differences seen in the equilibrium association constants between the unlinked and covalently linked polyamides are primarily due to higher association rate constants, discrimination between matched and mismatched sites by each polyamide can be ascribed in large part to differences in their dissociation rate constants. The consequences of this kinetic behavior for future design are discussed.     

Alternative heterocycles for DNA recognition: an N-methylpyrazole/N-methylpyrrole pair specifies for A.T/T.A base pairs

Side-by-side pairs of three five-membered rings, N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im), and N-methylhydroxy-pyrrole (Hp), have been demonstrated to distinguish each of the four Watson Crick base pairs in the minor groove of DNA. However, not all DNA sequences targeted by these pairing rules achieve affinities and specificities comparable to DNA binding proteins. We have initiated a search for new heterocycles which can expand the sequence repetoire currently available. Two heterocyclic aromatic amino acids. N-methylpyrazole (Pz) and 4-methylthiazole (Th), were incorporated into a single position of an eight-ring polyamide of sequence ImImXPy-gamma-lmPyPyPy-beta-Dp to examine the modulation of affinity and specificity for DNA binding by a Pz/Py pair and or a Th/Py pair. The X/Py pairings Pz/Py and Th/Py were evaluated by quantitative DNase I footprint titrations on a DNA fragment with the four sites 5'-TGGNCA-3' (N=T, A, G, C). The Pz/Py pair binds T.A and A.T with similar affinity to a Py/Py pair but with improved specificity. disfavoring both G.C and C.G by about 100-fold. The Th/Py pair binds poorly to all four Watson Crick base pairs. These results demonstrate that in some instances new heterocyclic aromatic amino acid pairs can be incorporated into imidazole-pyrrole polyamides to mimic the DNA specificity of Py/Py pairs which may be relevant as biological criteria in animal studies become important.     

Structural effects of DNA sequence on T.A recognition by hydroxypyrrole/pyrrole pairs in the minor groove

Synthetic polyamides composed of three types of aromatic amino acids, N-methylimidazole (Im), N-methylpyrrole (Py) and N-methyl-3-hydroxypyrrole (Hp) bind specific DNA sequences as antiparallel dimers in the minor groove. The side-by-side pairings of aromatic rings in the dimer afford a general recognition code that allows all four base-pairs to be distinguished. To examine the structural consequences of changing the DNA sequence context on T.A recognition by Hp/Py pairs in the minor groove, crystal structures of polyamide dimers (ImPyHpPy)(2) and the pyrrole counterpart (ImPyPyPy)(2) bound to the six base-pair target site 5'-AGATCT-3' in a ten base-pair oligonucleotide have been determined to a resolution of 2.27 and 2.15 A, respectively. The structures demonstrate that the principles of Hp/Py recognition of T.A are consistent between different sequence contexts. However, a general structural explanation for the non-additive reduction in binding affinity due to introduction of the hydroxyl group is less clear. Comparison with other polyamide-DNA cocrystal structures reveals structural themes and differences that may relate to sequence preference.     

Synthesis and DNA binding properties of 1-(3-aminopropyl)-imidazole-containing triamide f-Im(∗)PyIm: A novel diamino polyamide designed to target 5'-ACGCGT-3'

A novel diamino/dicationic polyamide f-Im(?)PyIm (5) that contains an orthogonally positioned aminopropyl chain on an imidazole (Im(?)) moiety was designed to target 5'-ACGCGT-3'. The DNA binding properties of the diamino polyamide 5, determined by CD, ΔT(M), DNase I footprinting, SPR, and ITC studies, were compared with those of its monoamino/monocationic counterpart f-ImPyIm (1) and its diamino/dicationic isomer f-ImPy(?)Im (2), which has the aminopropyl group attached to the central pyrrole unit (Py(?)). The results gave evidence for the minor groove binding and selectivity of polyamide 5 for the cognate sequence 5'-ACGCGT-3', and with strong affinity (K(eq)=2.3×10(7)M(-1)). However, the binding affinities varied according to the order: f-ImPy(?)Im (2)>f-ImPyIm (1)?f-Im(?)PyIm (5) confirming that the second amino group can improve affinity, but its position within the polyamide can affect affinity.     

The thermodynamics of polyamide-DNA recognition: hairpin polyamide binding in the minor groove of duplex DNA

Crescent-shaped synthetic ligands containing aromatic amino acids have been designed for specific recognition of predetermined DNA sequences in the minor groove of DNA. Simple rules have been developed that relate the side-by-side pairings of Imidazole (Im) and Pyrrole (Py) amino acids to their predicted target DNA sequences. We report here thermodynamic characterization of the DNA-binding properties of the six-ring hairpin polyamide, ImImPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp (where gamma = gamma-aminobutyric acid, beta = beta-alanine, and Dp = dimethylaminopropylamide). Our data reveal that, at 20 degrees C, this ligand binds with a relatively modest 1.8-fold preference for the designated match site, 5'-TGGTA-3', over the single base pair mismatch site, 5'-TGTTA-3'. By contrast, we find that the ligand exhibits a 102-fold greater affinity for its designated match site relative to the double base pair mismatch site, 5'-TATTA-3'. These results demonstrate that the energetic cost of binding to a double mismatch site is not necessarily equal to twice the energetic cost of binding to a single mismatch site. Our calorimetrically measured binding enthalpies and calculated entropy data at 20 degrees C reveal the ligand sequence specificity to be enthalpic in origin. We have compared the DNA-binding properties of ImImPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp with the hairpin polyamide, ImPyPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp (an Im --> Py "mutant"). Our data reveal that both ligands exhibit high affinities for their designated match sites, consistent with the Dervan pairing rules. Our data also reveal that, relative to their corresponding single mismatch sites, ImImPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp is less selective than ImPyPy-gamma-PyPyPy-beta-Dp for its designated match site. This result suggests, at least in this case, that enhanced binding affinity can be accompanied by some loss in sequence specificity. Such systematic comparative studies allow us to begin to establish the thermodynamic database required for the rational design of synthetic polyamides with predictable DNA-binding affinities and specificities.     

Binding of hairpin pyrrole and imidazole polyamides to DNA: relationship between torsion angle and association rate constants

N-methylpyrrole (Py)-N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamides are small organic molecules that bind to DNA with sequence specificity and can be used as synthetic DNA-binding ligands. In this study, five hairpin eight-ring Py–Im polyamides 1–5 with different number of Im rings were synthesized, and their binding behaviour was investigated with surface plasmon resonance assay. It was found that association rate (k_a) of the Py–Im polyamides with their target DNA decreased with the number of Im in the Py–Im polyamides. The structures of four-ring Py–Im polyamides derived from density functional theory revealed that the dihedral angle of the Py amide carbonyl is 14∼18°, whereas that of the Im is significantly smaller. As the minor groove of DNA has a helical structure, planar Py–Im polyamides need to change their conformation to fit it upon binding to the minor groove. The data explain that an increase in planarity of Py–Im polyamide induced by the incorporation of Im reduces the association rate of Py–Im polyamides. This fundamental knowledge of the binding of Py–Im polyamides to DNA will facilitate the design of hairpin Py–Im polyamides as synthetic DNA-binding modules.     

DNA minor-groove recognition by 3-methylthiophene/pyrrole pair

Hairpin polyamides are synthetic oligomers, which fold and bind to specific DNA sequences in a programmable manner. Internal side-by-side pairings of the aromatic amino acid residues 1-methyl-1H-pyrrole (Py), 1-methyl-1H-imidazole (Im), and 3-hydroxy-1-methyl-1H-pyrrole (Hp) confer the ability to distinguish between all four Watson-Crick base pairs in the minor groove of B-form DNA. In a broad search to expand the heterocycle repertoire, we found that when 3-methylthiophene (Tn), which presents a S-atom to the minor groove, is paired with Py, it exhibits a modest threefold specificity for TA>AT presumably by shape-selective recognition. In this study, we explore the scope and limitations of this lead by incorporating multiple Tn residues within a single hairpin polyamide. It was found that hairpin polyamides containing more that one Tn/Py pair exhibit lowered affinities and specificities for their match sites. It appears that little deviation is permissible from the parent five-membered ring 1-methyl-1H-pyrrole-2-carboxamide scaffold for DNA recognition.     

Sequence-specific DNA binding by long hairpin pyrrole–imidazole polyamides containing an 8-amino-3,6-dioxaoctanoic acid unit

With the aim of improving aqueous solubility, we designed and synthesized five N-methylpyrrole (Py)–N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamides capable of recognizing 9-bp sequences. Their DNA-binding affinities and sequence specificities were evaluated by SPR and Bind-n-Seq analyses. The design of polyamide 1 was based on a conventional model, with three consecutive Py or Im rings separated by a β-alanine to match the curvature and twist of long DNA helices. Polyamides 2 and 3 contained an 8-amino-3,6-dioxaoctanoic acid (AO) unit, which has previously only been used as a linker within linear Py–Im polyamides or between Py–Im hairpin motifs for tandem hairpin. It is demonstrated herein that AO also functions as a linker element that can extend to 2-bp in hairpin motifs. Notably, although the AO-containing unit can fail to bind the expected sequence, polyamide 4, which has two AO units facing each other in a hairpin form, successfully showed the expected motif and a K_D value of 16 nM was recorded. Polyamide 5, containing a β-alanine–β-alanine unit instead of the AO of polyamide 2, was synthesized for comparison. The aqueous solubilities and nuclear localization of three of the polyamides were also examined. The results suggest the possibility of applying the AO unit in the core of Py–Im polyamide compounds.     

DNA sequence recognition of thiazole-containing cross-linked polyamides can be favored

The binding ability of cross-linked thiazolated polyamides (containing the base sequence-reading elements thiazole(Th)-pyrrole(Py)-pyr-role(Py) and thiazole(Th)-imidazole(Im)-pyrrol(Py) to various DNA dodecamers has been investigated. CD titration experiments at high salt concentration demonstrate that the dimers with a heptanediyl linker (C7 dimer) show a significantly higher sequence specificity than their corresponding monomers. The dimer of Th-Py-Py primarily prefers binding to pure AT sequences and that of Th-Im-Py to the dodecamer sequences containing a GC pair within the central sequence (e.g. AACGTT). Surprisingly, the sequence binding ability is strongly influenced by the presence of a T-A step: e.g. Th-Py-Py has a similar affinity to the sequences TTTAAA and ATCGTA; likewise Th-Im-Py shows a preference for these sequences. The CD results correlate with footprinting data. Related biochemical studies on the effect of polyamides on DNA gyrase activity in vitro show that the C7 dimers most effectively inhibit the enzyme activity compared with the monomers and the natural reference minor groove binder distamycin. The highest inhibitory potency is observed for the Th-Py-Py-dimer. The role of the T-A step in binding of the cross-linked dimer to the minor groove is discussed in light of the sequence recognition of the TATA box binding protein.     

Comparative analysis of DNA alkylation by conjugates between pyrrole–imidazole hairpin polyamides and chlorambucil or seco-CBI

We investigated sequence-specific DNA alkylation using conjugates between the N-methylpyrrole (Py)-N-methylimidazole (Im) polyamide and the DNA alkylating agent, chlorambucil, or 1-(chloromethyl)-5-hydroxy-1,2-dihydro-3H-benz[e]indole (seco-CBI). Polyamide–chlorambucil conjugates 1–4 differed in the position at which the DNA alkylating chlorambucil moiety was bound to the Py–Im polyamide. High-resolution denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) revealed that chlorambucil conjugates 1–4 alkylated DNA at the sequences recognized by the Py–Im polyamide core moiety. Reactivity and sequence specificity were greatly affected by the conjugation position, which reflects the geometry of the alkylating agent in the DNA minor groove. Polyamide–seco-CBI conjugate 5 was synthesized to compare the efficacy of chlorambucil with that of seco-CBI as an alkylating moiety for Py–Im polyamides. Denaturing PAGE analysis revealed that DNA alkylation activity of polyamide–seco-CBI conjugate 5 was similar to that of polyamide–chlorambucil conjugates 1 and 2. In contrast, the cytotoxicity of conjugate 5 was superior to that of conjugates 1–4. These results suggest that the seco-CBI conjugate was distinctly active in cells compared to the chlorambucil conjugates. These results may contribute to the development of more specific and active DNA alkylating agents.     

Sequence specific and high affinity recognition of 5'-ACGCGT-3' by rationally designed pyrrole-imidazole H-pin polyamides: thermodynamic and structural studies

Imidazole (Im) and Pyrrole (Py)-containing polyamides that can form stacked dimers can be programmed to target specific sequences in the minor groove of DNA and control gene expression. Even though various designs of polyamides have been thoroughly investigated for DNA sequence recognition, the use of H-pin polyamides (covalently cross-linked polyamides) has not received as much attention. Therefore, experiments were designed to systematically investigate the DNA recognition properties of two symmetrical H-pin polyamides composed of PyImPyIm (5) or f-ImPyIm (3e, f=formamido) tethered with an ethylene glycol linker. These compounds were created to recognize the cognate 5'-ACGCGT-3' through an overlapped and staggered binding motif, respectively. Results from DNaseI footprinting, thermal denaturation, circular dichroism, surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration microcalorimetry studies demonstrated that both H-pin polyamides bound with higher affinity than their respective monomers. The binding affinity of formamido-containing H-pin 3e was more than a hundred times greater than that for the tetraamide H-pin 5, demonstrating the importance of having a formamido group and the staggered motif in enhancing affinity. However, compared to H-pin 3e, tetraamide H-pin 5 demonstrated superior binding preference for the cognate sequence over its non-cognates, ACCGGT and AAATTT. Data from SPR experiments yielded binding constants of 1.6x10(8)M(-1) and 2.0x10(10)M(-1) for PyImPyIm H-pin 5 and f-ImPyIm H-pin 3e, respectively. Both H-pins bound with significantly higher affinity (ca. 100-fold) than their corresponding unlinked PyImPyIm 4 and f-ImPyIm 2 counterparts. ITC analyses revealed modest enthalpies of reactions at 298 K (DeltaH of -3.3 and -1.0 kcal mol(-1) for 5 and 3e, respectively), indicating these were entropic-driven interactions. The heat capacities (DeltaC(p)) were determined to be -116 and -499 cal mol(-1)K(-1), respectively. These results are in general agreement with DeltaC(p) values determined from changes in the solvent accessible surface areas using complexes of the H-pins bound to (5'-CCACGCGTGG)(2). According to the models, the H-pins fit snugly in the minor groove and the linker comfortably holds both polyamide portions in place, with the oxygen atoms pointing into the solvent. In summary, the H-pin polyamide provides an important molecular design motif for the discovery of future generations of programmable small molecules capable of binding to target DNA sequences with high affinity and selectivity.     

Structure of a beta-alanine-linked polyamide bound to a full helical turn of purine tract DNA in the 1:1 motif

Polyamides composed of N-methylpyrrole (Py), N-methylimidazole (Im) and N-methylhydroxypyrrole (Hp) amino acids linked by beta-alanine (beta) bind the minor groove of DNA in 1:1 and 2:1 ligand to DNA stoichiometries. Although the energetics and structure of the 2:1 complex has been explored extensively, there is remarkably less understood about 1:1 recognition beyond the initial studies on netropsin and distamycin. We present here the 1:1 solution structure of ImPy-beta-Im-beta-ImPy-beta-Dp bound in a single orientation to its match site within the DNA duplex 5'-CCAAAGAGAAGCG-3'.5'-CGCTTCTCTTTGG-3' (match site in bold), as determined by 2D (1)H NMR methods. The representative ensemble of 12 conformers has no distance constraint violations greater than 0.13 A and a pairwise RMSD over the binding site of 0.80 A. Intermolecular NOEs place the polyamide deep inside the minor groove, and oriented N-C with the 3'-5' direction of the purine-rich strand. Analysis of the high-resolution structure reveals the ligand bound 1:1 completely within the minor groove for a full turn of the DNA helix. The DNA is B-form (average rise=3.3 A, twist=38 degrees ) with a narrow minor groove closing down to 3.0-4.5 A in the binding site. The ligand and DNA are aligned in register, with each polyamide NH group forming bifurcated hydrogen bonds of similar length to purine N3 and pyrimidine O2 atoms on the floor of the minor groove. Each imidazole group is hydrogen bonded via its N3 atom to its proximal guanine's exocyclic amino group. The important roles of beta-alanine and imidazole for 1:1 binding are discussed.     

Synthesis and biophysical evaluation of minor-groove binding C-terminus modified pyrrole and imidazole triamide analogs of distamycin

Five polyamide derivatives with rationally modified C-terminus moieties were synthesized and their DNA binding specificity and affinity determined. A convergent approach was employed to synthesize polyamides containing an alkylaminopiperazine (4 and 5), a truncated piperazine (6), or an alkyldiamino-C-terminus moiety (7 and 8) with two specific objectives: to investigate the effects of number of potential cationic centers and steric bulk at the C-terminus. CD studies confirmed that compounds 4, 5, 7, and 8 bind in the minor groove of DNA. The alkylpiperazine containing compounds (4 and 5) showed only moderate binding to DNA with DeltaT(m) values of 2.8 and 8.3 degrees C with their cognate sequence, respectively. The alkyldiamino compounds (7 and 8) were more impressive producing a DeltaT(m) of >17 and >22 degrees C, respectively. Compound 6 (truncated piperazine) did not stabilize its cognate DNA sequence. Footprints were observed for all compounds (except compound 6) with their cognate DNA sequence using DNase I footprinting, with compound 7 producing a footprint of 0.1 microM at the expected 5'-ACGCGT-3' site. SPR analysis of compound 7 binding to 5'-ACGCGT-3', 5'-ACCGGT-3', and 5'-AAATTT-3' produced binding affinities of 2.2x10(6), 3.3x10(5), and 1x10(5)M(-1), respectively, indicating a preference for its cognate sequence of 5'-ACGCGT-3'. These results are in good agreement with the footprinting data. The results indicate that steric crowding at the C-terminus is important with respect to binding. However, the number of cationic centers within the molecule may also play a role. The alkyldiamino-containing compounds (7 and 8) warrant further investigation in the field of polyamide research.     

Molecular recognition of DNA base pairs by the formamido/pyrrole and formamido/imidazole pairings in stacked polyamides

Polyamides containing an N-terminal formamido (f) group bind to the minor groove of DNA as staggered, antiparallel dimers in a sequence-specific manner. The formamido group increases the affinity and binding site size, and it promotes the molecules to stack in a staggered fashion thereby pairing itself with either a pyrrole (Py) or an imidazole (Im). There has not been a systematic study on the DNA recognition properties of the f/Py and f/Im terminal pairings. These pairings were analyzed here in the context of f-ImPyPy, f-ImPyIm, f-PyPyPy and f-PyPyIm, which contain the central pairing modes, –ImPy– and –PyPy–. The specificity of these triamides towards symmetrical recognition sites allowed for the f/Py and f/Im terminal pairings to be directly compared by SPR, CD and ΔT_M experiments. The f/Py pairing, when placed next to the –ImPy– or –PyPy– central pairings, prefers A/T and T/A base pairs to G/C base pairs, suggesting that f/Py has similar DNA recognition specificity to Py/Py. With –ImPy– central pairings, f/Im prefers C/G base pairs (>10 times) to the other Watson–Crick base pairs; therefore, f/Im behaves like the Py/Im pair. However, the f/Im pairing is not selective for the C/G base pair when placed next to the –PyPy– central pairings.