Specificity grafting of human antibody frameworks selected from a phage display library: generation of a highly stable humanized anti-CD22 single-chain Fv fragment

A prerequisite for the enrichment of antibodies screened from phage display libraries is their stable expression on a phage during multiple selection rounds. Thus, if stringent panning procedures are employed, selection is simultaneously driven by antigen affinity, stability and solubility. To take advantage of robust pre-selected scaffolds of such molecules, we grafted single-chain Fv (scFv) antibodies, previously isolated from a human phage display library after multiple rounds of in vitro panning on tumor cells, with the specificity of the clinically established murine monoclonal anti-CD22 antibody RFB4. We show that a panel of grafted scFvs retained the specificity of the murine monoclonal antibody, bound to the target antigen with high affinity (6.4-9.6 nM), and exhibited exceptional biophysical stability with retention of 89-93% of the initial binding activity after 6 days of incubation in human serum at 37 degrees C. Selection of stable human scaffolds with high sequence identity to both the human germline and the rodent frameworks required only a small number of murine residues to be retained within the human frameworks in order to maintain the structural integrity of the antigen binding site. We expect this approach may be applicable for the rapid generation of highly stable humanized antibodies with low immunogenic potential.     

New display vector reduces biological bias for expression of antibodies in E. coli

We report the development of a novel phagemid vector, pKM19, for display of recombinant antibodies in single-chain format (scFv) on the surface of filamentous phage. This new vector improves efficacy of selection and reduces the biological bias against antibodies that can be harmful to host bacteria. It is useful for generation of large new antibody libraries, and for the subsequent maturation of antibody fragments. In comparison with commonly used plasmids, this vector is designed to have relatively low expression levels of cloned scFv antibodies due to the amber codon positioned in a sequence encoding for the PhoA leader peptide. Moreover, fusion of antibodies to the carboxy terminal part only of the gene III protein improves display of scFv on bacteriophage surface in this system. Despite the lower antibody expression, the functional test performed with a new scFv library derived from human peripheral blood lymphocytes demonstrates that specific antibodies can be easily isolated from the library, even after the second selection round. The use of the pKM19 vector for maturation of an anti-CEA antibody significantly improves the final results. In our previous work, an analogous selection through the use of a phagemid vector, with antibody expression under the control of a lacP promoter, led to isolation of anti-CEA phage antibodies with improved affinities, which were not producible in soluble form. Probably due to the toxicity for E. coli of that particular anti-CEA antibody, 70% of maturated clones contained suppressed stop codons, acquired during various selection/amplification rounds. The pKM19 plasmid facilitates an efficient maturation process, resulting in selection of antibodies with improved affinity without any stop codons.     

Antibody discovery: phage display

Phage display has proven to be a robust and convenient technology for the selection of high-quality human antibodies from diverse libraries. Besides enabling the identification of antibodies in a fast, high-throughput mode, which allows comprehensive protein expression analyses, phage display has been used to identify a fully human therapeutic antibody presently undergoing the regulatory process for market approval.     

A human scFv antibody generation pipeline for proteome research

The functional decryption of the human proteome is the challenge which follows the sequencing of the human genome. Specific binders to every human protein are key reagents for this purpose. In vitro antibody selection using phage display offers one possible solution that can meet the demand for 25,000 or more antibodies, but needs substantial standardisation and minimalisation. To evaluate this potential, three human, naive antibody gene libraries (HAL4/7/8) were constructed and a standardised antibody selection pipeline was set up. The quality of the libraries and the selection pipeline was validated with 110 antigens, including human, other mammalian, fungal or bacterial proteins, viruses or haptens. Furthermore, the abundance of VH, kappa and lambda subfamilies during library cloning and the E. coli based phage display system on library packaging and the selection of scFvs was evaluated from the analysis of 435 individual antibodies, resulting in the first comprehensive comparison of V gene subfamily use for all steps of an antibody phage display pipeline. Further, a compatible cassette vector set for E. coli and mammalian expression of antibody fragments is described, allowing in vivo biotinylation, enzyme fusion and Fc fusion.     

Ribosome display: next-generation display technologies for production of antibodies in vitro

Antibodies represent an important and growing class of biologic research reagents and biopharmaceutical products. They can be used as therapeutics in a variety of diseases. With the rapid expansion of proteomic studies and biomarker discovery, there is a need for the generation of highly specific binding reagents to study the vast number of proteins encoded by the genome. Display technologies provide powerful tools for obtaining antibodies. Aside from the preservation of natural antibody repertoires, they are capable of exploiting diversity by DNA recombination to create very large libraries for selection of novel molecules. In contrast to in vivo immunization processes, display technologies allow selection of antibodies under in vitro-defined selection condition(s), resulting in enrichment of antibodies with desired properties from large populations. In addition, in vitro selection enables the isolation of antibodies against difficult antigens including self-antigens, and this can be applied to the generation of human antibodies against human targets. Display technologies can also be combined with DNA mutagenesis for antibody evolution in vitro. Some methods are amenable to automation, permitting high-throughput generation of antibodies. Ribosome display is considered as representative of the next generation of display technologies since it overcomes the limitations of cell-based display methods by using a cell-free system, offering advantages of screening larger libraries and continuously expanding new diversity during selection. Production of display-derived antibodies can be achieved by choosing one of a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell-based expression systems. In the near future, cell-free protein synthesis may be developed as an alternative for large-scale generation of antibodies.     

Ribosome display: next-generation display technologies for production of antibodies in vitro

Antibodies represent an important and growing class of biologic research reagents and biopharmaceutical products. They can be used as therapeutics in a variety of diseases. With the rapid expansion of proteomic studies and biomarker discovery, there is a need for the generation of highly specific binding reagents to study the vast number of proteins encoded by the genome. Display technologies provide powerful tools for obtaining antibodies. Aside from the preservation of natural antibody repertoires, they are capable of exploiting diversity by DNA recombination to create very large libraries for selection of novel molecules. In contrast to in vivo immunization processes, display technologies allow selection of antibodies under in vitro-defined selection condition(s), resulting in enrichment of antibodies with desired properties from large populations. In addition, in vitro selection enables the isolation of antibodies against difficult antigens including self-antigens, and this can be applied to the generation of human antibodies against human targets. Display technologies can also be combined with DNA mutagenesis for antibody evolution in vitro. Some methods are amenable to automation, permitting high-throughput generation of antibodies. Ribosome display is considered as representative of the next generation of display technologies since it overcomes the limitations of cell-based display methods by using a cell-free system, offering advantages of screening larger libraries and continuously expanding new diversity during selection. Production of display-derived antibodies can be achieved by choosing one of a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell-based expression systems. In the near future, cell-free protein synthesis may be developed as an alternative for large-scale generation of antibodies.     

Emerging trends in the synthesis and improvement of hapten-specific recombinant antibodies

A key requirement for successful immunotherapeutic and immunodiagnostic applications is the availability of antibodies with high affinity and specificity. In the past, polyclonal antibodies from hyperimmunized animals or monoclonal antibodies from hybridoma cell lines were used extensively and profitably in medicine and immunotechnology. Antibody-based diagnostics, such as immunoassays, are also widely accepted because of their high sensitivity and ease of use as compared to conventional chromatographic techniques. While immunoassays have been used to monitor organic chemical contaminants such as pesticides, food preservatives, antibiotics in agricultural and food industries, hapten-specific antibodies with the desired affinity and specificity are generally difficult to obtain. With the advent of recombinant DNA technology, antibody genes can be amplified and selected through phage display, cell surface display, or cell-free display systems. A particularly useful feature common to all these display systems is the linking of the phenotype and genotype of antibodies during selection. This allows easy co-selection of the desired antibodies and their encoding genes based on the binding characteristics of the displayed antibodies. The selected antibody DNA can be further manipulated for high-level expression, post-translation modification, and/or affinity and specificity improvement to suit their particular applications. Several hapten-specific antibodies, which were successfully selected and engineered to high specificity and affinity using display technologies, have been found to be amenable to conventional immunoassay development. In this review, we will examine different formats of immunoassays designed for hapten identification and various display technologies available for antibody selection and improvement.     

Selection of phage antibodies by binding affinity. Mimicking affinity maturation.

We describe a process, based on display of antibodies on the surface of filamentous bacteriophage, for selecting antibodies either by their affinity for antigen or by their kinetics of dissociation (off-rate) from antigen. For affinity selection, phage are mixed with small amounts of soluble biotinylated antigen (less than 1 microgram) such that the antigen is in excess over phage but with the concentration of antigen lower than the dissociation constant (Kd) of the antibody. Those phage bound to antigen are then selected using streptavidin-coated paramagnetic beads. The process can distinguish between antibodies with closely related affinities. For off-rate selection, antibodies are preloaded with biotinylated antigen and diluted into excess unlabelled antigen for variable times prior to capture on streptavidin-coated paramagnetic beads. To mimic the affinity maturation process of the immune system, we introduced random mutations into the antibody genes in vitro using an error-prone polymerase, and used affinity selection to isolate mutants with improved affinity. Starting with a small library (40,000 clones) of mutants (average 1.7 base changes per VH gene) of the mouse antibody B1.8, and using several rounds of affinity selection, we isolated a mutant with a fourfold improved affinity to the hapten 4-hydroxy-5-iodo-3-nitrophenacetyl-(NIP)-caproic acid (mutant Kd = 9.4(+/- 0.3) nM compared with B1.8 Kd = 41.9(+/- 1.6) nm). The relative increase in affinity of the mutant is comparable to the increase seen in the anti-4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl/NIP-caproic acid murine secondary immune response.     

An anti-leukemic single chain Fv antibody selected from a synthetic human phage antibody library

The display of human antibody repertoire on the cell surface of the filamentous bacteriophage has offered a novel strategy for selecting antibodies to a diverse range of purified targets. However, the selection of antibodies with biological functions has not yet been fully investigated. To select phage antibodies with therapeutic potential, a synthetic human single chain Fv (scFv) phage antibody library was panned on whole premyelocytic leukemia cell line (HL60). Phages binding to common receptors and undesirable phages were subtracted by incubating the library with human glioma cells. High affinity binding phages to HL60 cells were enriched by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. After the 6th round of selection, 50% of the selected phage antibodies showed significant binding to HL60 cells, whereas none of the analyzed phage antibodies bound to human pre-B cells (Nalm-6). In addition to binding, one scFv antibody inhibited HL60 cell proliferation by 90% compared to irrelevant scFv antibodies. Taken together the data demonstrate that specific scFv antibodies with biological functions can be isolated by using whole cells as affinity matrix.     

Enrichment of a single clone from a high diversity library of phage-displayed antibodies by panning with Anopheles gambiae (Diptera: Culicidae) midgut homogenate

A high diversity library of recombinant human antibodies was selected on complex antigen mixtures from midguts of female Anopheles gambiae Giles. The library of phage-displayed single chain variable region fragment constructs, derived from beta-lymphocyte mRNA of na?ve human donors, was repeatedly selected and reamplified on the insoluble fraction of midgut homogenates. Five rounds of panning yielded only one midgut-specific clone, which predominated the resulting antibody panel. In A. gambiae, the epitope was found throughout the tissues of females but was absent from the midgut of males. The cognate antigen proved to be detergent soluble but very sensitive to denaturation and could not be isolated or identified by Western blot of native electrophoresis gels or by immunoprecipitation. Nevertheless, immunohistology revealed that this sex-specific epitope is associated with the lumenal side of the midgut. Severe bottlenecking may limit the utility of phage display selection from na?ve libraries for generating diverse panels of antibodies against complex mixtures of antigens from insect tissues. These results suggest that the selection of sufficiently diverse antibody panels, from which mosquitocidal or malaria transmission-blocking antibodies can be isolated, may require improved selection methods or specifically enriched pre-immunized libraries.     

Phage display-derived human antibodies in clinical development and therapy

Over the last 3 decades, monoclonal antibodies have become the most important class of therapeutic biologicals on the market. Development of therapeutic antibodies was accelerated by recombinant DNA technologies, which allowed the humanization of murine monoclonal antibodies to make them more similar to those of the human body and suitable for a broad range of chronic diseases like cancer and autoimmune diseases. In the early 1990s in vitro antibody selection technologies were developed that enabled the discovery of “fully” human antibodies with potentially superior clinical efficacy and lowest immunogenicity.

Antibody phage display is the first and most widely used of the in vitro selection technologies. It has proven to be a robust, versatile platform technology for the discovery of human antibodies and a powerful engineering tool to improve antibody properties. As of the beginning of 2016, 6 human antibodies discovered or further developed by phage display were approved for therapy. In 2002, adalimumab (Humira®) became the first phage display-derived antibody granted a marketing approval. Humira® was also the first approved human antibody, and it is currently the best-selling antibody drug on the market. Numerous phage display-derived antibodies are currently under advanced clinical investigation, and, despite the availability of other technologies such as human antibody-producing transgenic mice, phage display has not lost its importance for the discovery and engineering of therapeutic antibodies.

Here, we provide a comprehensive overview about phage display-derived antibodies that are approved for therapy or in clinical development. A selection of these antibodies is described in more detail to demonstrate different aspects of the phage display technology and its development over the last 25 years.     

Recombinant human monoclonal antibodies. Basic principles of the immune system transferred to E. coli.

To produce human monoclonal antibodies in bacteria, a gene repertoire of IgM variable regions was isolated from human peripheral B lymphocytes by the polymerase chain reaction. Alternatively, synthetic antibody genes with random hypervariable regions are being generated that may provide libraries of even higher complexity. For the selection of specific monoclonal antibodies from these libraries, we have developed two E. coli vector systems that facilitate the surface display of an antibody physically linked to its own gene. The phagemid pSEX encodes a fusion protein of an antigen binding domain (Fv-antibody) with the docking protein (pIII) of filamentous phages. Specific antibody genes can therefore be enriched by antigen affinity chromatography. The plasmid pAP1 encodes a fusion protein of an Fv-antibody with a bacterial cell-wall protein. Bacteria carrying this plasmid express functional Fv-antibodies tightly bound to their surface. This should enable the selection of single cells with a fluorescence-assisted cell sorter (FACS) using labeled antigen or by adsorption to immobilized antigen. These vectors permit three major principles of the antibody response to be mimicked in E. coli: 1. Generation of a highly complex antibody repertoire; 2. Clonal selection procedures for library screening; and 3. The possibility of increasing a given affinity by repeated rounds of mutation and selection.     

Identification of CD4 and transferrin receptor antibodies by CXCR4 antibody-guided Pathfinder selection.

To generate human antibodies against CXCR4, a seven-transmembrane chemokine receptor and a principal coreceptor for HIV-1, several rounds of Pathfinder and Step-back selection from a large phage display antibody library were performed on Jurkat cells. A mAb against CXCR4 or biotinyated phage antibodies were used as guide molecules. Over 100 pan-Jurkat-cell-positive antibodies were characterized, but none were CXCR4 specific. However, several antibodies against CD4 and the transferrin receptor were identified. Our results indicate that, although Pathfinder and Step-back selection can be used to select phage antibodies on whole cells, the successful selection of certain targets is still complex and limited. The reason is probably, in part, due to the inaccessibility of the targeted extracellular structures and the range of the horseradish peroxidase-labeled guide molecule. Refinements of these techniques are required to improve target specificity and selectivity.     

Antibodies in proteomics II: screening,high-throughput characterization and downstream applications

There are many ways in which the use of antibodies and antibody selection can be improved and developed for high-throughput characterization. Standard protocols, such as immunoprecipitation, western blotting and immunofluorescence, can be used with antibody fragments generated by display technologies. Together with novel approaches, such as antibody chips and intracellular immunization, these methods will yield useful proteomic data following adaptation of the protocols for increased reliability and robustness. To date, most work has focused on the use of standard, well-characterized commercial antibodies. Such protocols need to be adapted for broader use, for example, with antibody fragments or other binders generated by display technologies, because it is unlikely that traditional approaches will provide the required throughput.     

The rabbit antibody repertoire as a novel source for the generation of therapeutic human antibodies

The rabbit antibody repertoire, which in the form of polyclonal antibodies has been used in diagnostic applications for decades, would be an attractive source for the generation of therapeutic human antibodies. The humanization of rabbit antibodies, however, has not been reported. Here we use phage display technology to select and humanize antibodies from rabbits that were immunized with human A33 antigen which is a target antigen for the immunotherapy of colon cancer. We first selected rabbit antibodies that bind to a cell surface epitope of human A33 antigen with an affinity in the 1 nm range. For rabbit antibody humanization, we then used a selection strategy that combines grafting of the complementarity determining regions with framework fine tuning. The resulting humanized antibodies were found to retain both high specificity and affinity for human A33 antigen.     

Off-rate screening for selection of high-affinity anti-drug antibodies

The rapidly increasing number of therapeutic antibodies in clinical development and on the market requires corresponding detection reagents for monitoring the concentration of these drugs in patient samples and as positive controls for measurement of anti-drug antibodies. Phage display of large recombinant antibody libraries has been shown to enable the rapid development of fully human anti-idiotypic antibodies binding specifically to antibody drugs, since the in vitro panning approach allows for incorporation of suitable blockers to drive selection toward the paratope of the drug. A typical bottleneck in antibody generation projects is ranking of the many candidates obtained after panning on the basis of antibody binding strength. Ideally, such method will work without prior labeling of antigens and with crude bacterial lysates. We developed an off-rate screening method of crude Escherichia coli lysates containing monovalent Fab fragments obtained after phage display of the HuCAL PLATINUM® antibody library. We used the antibody drugs trastuzumab and cetuximab as antigen examples. Using the Octet® RED384 label-free sensor instrument we show that antibody off rates can be reliably determined in crude bacterial lysates with high throughput. We also demonstrate that the method can be applied to screening for high-affinity antibodies typically obtained after affinity maturation.     

The rescue by phage display of human fabs to gp120 HIV-1 glycoprotein using EBV transformed lymphocytes

Human hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies in a stable manner are difficult to develop. The main difficulties are the restricted techniques for B-cell immortalization, the low number of sensitized B cells in peripheral blood, and the impossibility, for ethical reasons, to immunize humans with most antigens. Phage display has proved to be a powerful method for the generation of recombinant antibody fragments. This technology relies on the construction of recombinant Fab or scFv libraries and their display on phage M13. In order to rescue unstable B-cell clones secreting human antibodies we set up a method for the selection by phage display of human IgG fragments from Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-transformed clones and applied it to the selection by phage display of Fabs directed against HIV-1 gp120, using a seropositive blood sample. The approach combines B-cell transformation by EBV of peripheral blood lymphocytes from a seropositive donor, preselection of specific IgG anti-gp120 producing clones, and the construction of a targeted human antibody library. In this library the percentage of heavy and light chain coding sequences expressed in Escherichia coli, amplified by a set of specific 5′ primers for different antibody germ lines, was similar to that observed with the original untransformed B-cell sample. One round of panning was sufficient for the rescue of three Fabs specific for HIV-1 gp120 protein, which proves the efficiency of this technique.     

Mining human antibody repertoires

Human monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have become drugs of choice for the management of an increasing number of human diseases. Human antibody repertoires provide a rich source for human mAbs. Here we review the characteristics of natural and non-natural human antibody repertoires and their mining with non-combinatorial and combinatorial strategies. In particular, we discuss the selection of human mAbs from naïve, immune, transgenic and synthetic human antibody repertoires using methods based on hybridoma technology, clonal expansion of peripheral B cells, single-cell PCR, phage display, yeast display and mammalian cell display. Our reliance on different strategies is shifting as we gain experience and refine methods to the efficient generation of human mAbs with superior pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties.Key words: human monoclonal antibodies, B cells, hybridoma technology, display technologies, antibody libraries, antibody engineering     

Selecting and screening recombinant antibody libraries

During the past decade several display methods and other library screening techniques have been developed for isolating monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) from large collections of recombinant antibody fragments. These technologies are now widely exploited to build human antibodies with high affinity and specificity. Clever antibody library designs and selection concepts are now able to identify mAb leads with virtually any specificity. Innovative strategies enable directed evolution of binding sites with ultra-high affinity, high stability and increased potency, sometimes to a level that cannot be achieved by immunization. Automation of the technology is making it possible to identify hundreds of different antibody leads to a single therapeutic target. With the first antibody of this new generation, adalimumab (Humira, a human IgG1 specific for human tumor necrosis factor (TNF)), already approved for therapy and with many more in clinical trials, these recombinant antibody technologies will provide a solid basis for the discovery of antibody-based biopharmaceuticals, diagnostics and research reagents for decades to come.