Regulation of Gene Editing Activity Directed by Single-Stranded Oligonucleotides and CRISPR/Cas9 Systems

Single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides (ssODNs) can direct the repair of a single base mutation in human genes. While the regulation of this gene editing reaction has been partially elucidated, the low frequency with which repair occurs has hampered development toward clinical application. In this work a CRISPR/Cas9 complex is employed to induce double strand DNA breakage at specific sites surrounding the nucleotide designated for exchange. The result is a significant elevation in ssODN-directed gene repair, validated by a phenotypic readout. By analysing reaction parameters, we have uncovered restrictions on gene editing activity involving CRISPR/Cas9 complexes. First, ssODNs that hybridize to the non-transcribed strand direct a higher level of gene repair than those that hybridize to the transcribed strand. Second, cleavage must be proximal to the targeted mutant base to enable higher levels of gene editing. Third, DNA cleavage enables a higher level of gene editing activity as compared to single-stranded DNA nicks, created by modified Cas9 (Nickases). Fourth, we calculated the hybridization potential and free energy levels of ssODNs that are complementary to the guide RNA sequences of CRISPRs used in this study. We find a correlation between free energy potential and the capacity of single-stranded oligonucleotides to inhibit specific DNA cleavage activity, thereby indirectly reducing gene editing activity. Our data provide novel information that might be taken into consideration in the design and usage of CRISPR/Cas9 systems with ssODNs for gene editing.     

A plausible mechanism for gene correction by chimeric oligonucleotides

Self-complementary chimeric oligonucleotides that consist of DNA and 2'-O-methyl RNA nucleotides arranged in a double-hairpin configuration can elicit a point mutation when targeted to a gene sequence. We have used a series of structurally diverse chimeric oligonucleotides to correct a mutant neomycin phosphotransferase gene in a human cell-free extract. Analysis of structure-activity relationships demonstrates that the DNA strand of the chimeric oligonucleotide acts as a template for high-fidelity gene correction when one of its bases is mismatched to the targeted gene. By contrast, the chimeric strand of the oligonucleotide does not function as a template for gene repair. Instead, it appears to augment the frequency of gene correction by facilitating complex formation with the target. In the presence of RecA protein, each strand of a chimeric oligonucleotide can hybridize with double-stranded DNA to form a complement-stabilized D-loop. This reaction, which may take place by reciprocal four-strand exchange, is not observed with oligonucleotides that lack 2'-O-methyl RNA segments. Preliminary sequencing data suggest that complement-stabilized D-loops may be weakly mutagenic. If so, a low level of random mutagenesis in the vicinity of the chimera binding site may accompany gene repair.     

In vivo gene repair of point and frameshift mutations directed by chimeric RNA/DNA oligonucleotides and modified single-stranded oligonucleotides

Synthetic oligonucleotides have been used to direct base exchange and gene repair in a variety of organisms. Among the most promising vectors is chimeric oligonucleotide (CO), a double-stranded, RNA–DNA hybrid molecule folded into a double hairpin conformation: by using the cell’s DNA repair machinery, the CO directs nucleotide exchange as episomal and chromosomal DNA. Systematic dissection of the CO revealed that the region of contiguous DNA bases was the active component in the repair process, especially when the single-stranded ends were protected against nuclease attack. Here, the utility of this vector is expanded into Saccharomyces cerevisiae. An episome containing a mutated fusion gene encoding hygromycin resistance and eGFP expression was used as the target for repair. Substitution, deletion and insertion mutations were corrected with different frequencies by the same modified single-stranded vector as judged by growth in the presence of hygromycin and eGFP expression. A substitution mutation was repaired the most efficiently followed by insertion and finally deletion mutants. A strand bias for gene repair was also observed; vectors designed to direct the repair of nucleotide on the non-transcribed (non-template) strand displayed a 5–10-fold higher level of activity. Expanding the length of the oligo-vector from 25 to 100 nucleotides increases targeting frequency up to a maximal level and then it decreases. These results, obtained in a genetically tractable organism, contribute to the elucidation of the mechanism of targeted gene repair.     

Preferential recognition of I.T base-pairs in the initiation of excision-repair by hypoxanthine-DNA glycosylase.

Double-stranded synthetic oligonucleotides with a centrally located dIMP residue in a 5'-32P-labeled strand were employed as substrates for hypoxanthine-DNA glycosylase. The enzyme activity was monitored by the generation of a piperidine-sensitive site in the labeled oligonucleotide. The enzyme was purified approximately 5000-fold from calf thymus. The purified enzyme removed efficiently a hypoxanthine base residue from an I.T base pair, but 15-20 times more slowly from an I.C base pair. Similar results were obtained with oligonucleotides in which the deoxyinosine residue was placed in different surrounding nucleotide sequences. The enzyme had no detectable activity on mismatched G.T, A.G or A.C base pairs. The data indicate that hypoxanthine-DNA glycosylase participates in the repair of deaminated adenine residues in DNA.     

Reaction parameters of targeted gene repair in mammalian cells

Targeted gene repair uses short DNA oligonucleotides to direct a nucleotide exchange reaction at a designated site in a mammalian chromosome. The widespread use of this technique has been hampered by the inability of workers to achieve robust levels of correction. Here, we present a mammalian cell system in which DLD-1 cells bearing integrated copies of a mutant eGFP gene are repaired by modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides. We demonstrate that two independent clonal isolates, which are transcribed at different levels, are corrected at different frequencies. We confirm the evidence of a strand bias observed previously in other systems, wherein an oligonucleotide designed to be complementary to the nontranscribed strand of the target directs a higher level of repair than one targeting the transcribed strand. Higher concentrations of cell oligonucleotides in the electroporation mixture lead to higher levels of correction. When the target cell population is synchronized into S phase then released before electroporation, the correction efficiency is increased within the entire population. This model system could be useful for pharmacogenomic applications of targeted gene repair including the creation of cell lines containing single-base alterations.     

Isolation of antibodies against different protein conformations using immunoaffinity chromatography

Physiological effects of DNA bases other than A, G, C, and T as well as ways of removal of such bases from genomes are studied intensely. Methods for targeted insertion of modified bases into DNA, therefore, are highly demanded in the fields of DNA repair and epigenetics. This article describes efficient procedures for incorporation of modified DNA bases into a plasmid-borne enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene. The procedure exploits excision of a stretch of 18 nt from either the transcribed or nontranscribed DNA strand with the help of the sequence-specific nicking endonucleases Nb.Bpu10I and Nt.Bpu10I. The excised single-stranded oligonucleotide is then swapped for a synthetic DNA strand containing a desired base modification. Base modifications that form Watson-Crick-type base pairs were efficiently incorporated into plasmid DNA by a straightforward strand exchange, which was achieved by local melting in the presence of large excesses of the synthetic oligonucleotides and reannealing followed by ligation. Base modifications that cause significant distortions of the normal DNA structure, such as thymine glycol and uracil mispaired with guanine, failed to produce high yields of direct strand exchange but could still be incorporated very efficiently when the excised fragment was depleted in an intermediate step.     

The synaptic complex of RecA protein participates in hybridization and inverse strand exchange reactions

RecA protein catalyzes strand exchange between homologous single-stranded and double-stranded DNAs. In the presence of ATPgammaS, the post-strand exchange synaptic complex is a stable end product that can be studied. Here we ask whether such complexes can hybridize to or exchange with DNA, 2'-OMe RNA, PNA, or LNA oligonucleotides. Using a gel mobility shift assay, we show that the displaced strand of a 45 bp synaptic complex can hybridize to complementary oligonucleotides with different backbones to form a four-stranded (double D-loop) joint that survives removal of the RecA protein. This hybridization reaction, which confirms the single-stranded character of the displaced strand in a synaptic complex, might initiate recombination-dependent DNA replication if it occurs in vivo. We also show that either strand of the heteroduplex in a 30 bp synaptic complex can be replaced with a homologous DNA oligonucleotide in a strand exchange reaction that is mediated by the RecA filament. Consistent with the important role that deoxyribose plays in strand exchange, oligonucleotides with non-DNA backbones did not participate in this reaction. The hybridization and strand exchange reactions reported here demonstrate that short synaptic complexes are dynamic structures even in the presence of ATPgammaS.     

Genetic spell‐checking: gene editing using single‐stranded DNA oligonucleotides

Single‐stranded oligonucleotides (ssODNs) can be used to direct the exchange of a single nucleotide or the repair of a single base within the coding region of a gene in a process that is known, generically, as gene editing. These molecules are composed of either all DNA residues or a mixture of RNA and DNA bases and utilize inherent metabolic functions to execute the genetic alteration within the context of a chromosome. The mechanism of action of gene editing is now being elucidated as well as an understanding of its regulatory circuitry, work that has been particularly important in establishing a foundation for designing effective gene editing strategies in plants. Double‐strand DNA breakage and the activation of the DNA damage response pathway play key roles in determining the frequency with which gene editing activity takes place. Cellular regulators respond to such damage and their action impacts the success or failure of a particular nucleotide exchange reaction. A consequence of such activation is the natural slowing of replication fork progression, which naturally creates a more open chromatin configuration, thereby increasing access of the oligonucleotide to the DNA template. Herein, how critical reaction parameters influence the effectiveness of gene editing is discussed. Functional interrelationships between DNA damage, the activation of DNA response pathways and the stalling of replication forks are presented in detail as potential targets for increasing the frequency of gene editing by ssODNs in plants and plant cells.     

A tolerance of DNA heterology in the mammalian targeted gene repair reaction

Targeted gene repair consists of at least two major steps, the pairing of an oligonucleotide to a site bearing DNA sequence complementarity followed by a nucleotide exchange reaction directed by the oligonucleotide. In this study, oligonucleotides with different structures were designed to target a stably integrated (mutant) enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene and used to direct the repair of a single base mutation. We show that the efficiency of correction is influenced by the degree of DNA sequence homology existing between the oligonucleotide and target gene. Correction is reduced when a heterologous stretch of DNA sequence is placed in the center of the oligonucleotide and the mismatched base pair is then formed near the terminus. The negative impact of heterology is dependent on the type of DNA sequence inserted and on the size of the heterologous region. If the heterologous sequence is palindromic and adopts a secondary structure, the negative impact on the correction frequency is removed, and wild-type levels of repair are restored. Although differences in the efficiency of correction are observed in various cell types, the effect of structural changes on gene repair is consistent. These results reveal the existence of a directional-specific repair pathway that relies on the pairing stability of a bilateral complex and emphasize the importance of sequence homology between pairing partners for efficient catalysis of gene repair.     

Regulation of targeted gene repair by intrinsic cellular processes

Targeted gene alteration (TGA) is a strategy for correcting single base mutations in the DNA of human cells that cause inherited disorders. TGA aims to reverse a phenotype by repairing the mutant base within the chromosome itself, avoiding the introduction of exogenous genes. The process of how to accurately repair a genetic mutation is elucidated through the use of single‐stranded DNA oligonucleotides (ODNs) that can enter the cell and migrate to the nucleus. These specifically designed ODNs hybridize to the target sequence and act as a beacon for nucleotide exchange. The key to this reaction is the frequency with which the base is corrected; this will determine whether the approach becomes clinically relevant or not. Over the course of the last five years, workers have been uncovering the role played by the cells in regulating the gene repair process. In this essay, we discuss how the impact of the cell on TGA has evolved through the years and illustrate ways that inherent cellular pathways could be used to enhance TGA activity. We also describe the cost to cell metabolism and survival when certain processes are altered to achieve a higher frequency of repair.     

Identification of valid reference genes for the normalization of RT qPCR gene expression data in human brain tissue

Background

Transfection of cells with gene-specific, single-stranded oligonucleotides can induce the targeted exchange of one or two nucleotides in the targeted gene. To characterize the features of the DNA-repair mechanisms involved, we examined the maximal distance for the simultaneous exchange of two nucleotides by a single-stranded oligonucleotide. The chosen experimental system was the correction of a hprt-point mutation in a hamster cell line, the generation of an additional nucleotide exchange at a variable distance from the first exchange position and the investigation of the rate of simultaneous nucleotide exchanges.

Results

The smaller the distance between the two exchange positions, the higher was the probability of a simultaneous exchange. The detected simultaneous nucleotide exchanges were found to cluster in a region of about fourteen nucleotides upstream and downstream from the first exchange position.

Conclusion

We suggest that the mechanism involved in the repair of the targeted DNA strand utilizes only a short sequence of the single-stranded oligonucleotide, which may be physically incorporated into the DNA or be used as a matrix for a repair process.     

The Influence of Local DNA Sequence and DNA Repair Background on the Mutational Specificity of 1-Nitroso-8-Nitropyrene in Escherichia Coli: Inferences for Mutagenic Mechanisms

We have examined the mutational specificity of 1-nitroso-8-nitropyrene (1,8-NONP), an activated metabolite of the carcinogen 1,8-dinitropyrene, in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli strains which differ with respect to nucleotide excision repair (+/- delta uvrB) and MucA/B-mediated error-prone translesion synthesis (+/- pKM101). Several different classes of mutation were recovered, of which frameshifts, base substitutions, and deletions were clearly induced by 1,8-NONP treatment. The high proportion of point mutations (> 92%) which occurred at G.C sites correlates with the percentage of 1,8-NONP-DNA adducts which occur at the C(8) position of guanine. The most prominent frameshift mutations were -(G.C) events, which were induced by 1,8-NONP treatment in all strains, occurred preferentially in runs of guanine residues, and whose frequency increased markedly with the length of the reiterated sequence. Of the base substitution mutations G.C-->T.A transversions were induced to the greatest extent by 1,8-NONP. The distribution of the G.C-->T.A transversions was not influenced by the nature of flanking bases, nor was there a strand preference for these events. The presence of plasmid pKM101 specifically increased the frequency of G.C-->T.A transversions by a factor of 30-60. In contrast, the -(G.C) frameshift mutation frequency was increased only 2-4-fold in strains harboring pKM101 as compared to strains lacking this plasmid. There was, however, a marked influence of pKM101 on the strand specificity of frameshift mutation; a preference was observed for -G events on the transcribed strand. The ability of the bacteria to carry out nucleotide excision repair had a strong effect on the frequency of all classes of mutation but did not significantly influence either the overall distribution of mutational classes or the strand specificity of G.C-->T.A transversions and -(G.C) frameshifts. Deletion mutations were induced in the delta uvr, pKM101 strain. The endpoints of the majority of the deletion mutations were G.C rich and contained regions of considerable homology. The specificity of 1,8-NONP-induced mutation suggests that DNA containing 1,8-NONP adducts can be processed through different mutational pathways depending on the DNA sequence context of the adduct and the DNA repair background of the cell.     

Evaluation of the mutagenic potential of the principal DNA adduct of acrolein

Acrolein is produced extensively in the environment by incomplete combustion of organic materials, and it arises endogenously in humans as a metabolic by-product. Acrolein reacts with DNA at guanine residues to form the exocyclic adduct, 8-hydroxypropanodeoxyguanosine (HOPdG). Acrolein is mutagenic, and a correlation exists between HOPdG levels in Salmonella typhimurium treated with acrolein and a resultant increase in mutation frequency. Site-specifically modified oligonucleotides were used to explore the mutagenic potential of HOPdG in Escherichia coli strains that were either wild-type for repair or deficient in nucleotide excision repair or base excision repair. Oligonucleotides modified with HOPdG were inserted into double-stranded bacteriophage vectors using the gapped-duplex method or into single-stranded bacteriophage vectors and transformed into SOS-induced E. coli strains. Progeny phage were analyzed by oligonucleotide hybridization to establish the mutation frequency and the spectrum of mutations produced by HOPdG. The correct base, dCMP, was incorporated opposite HOPdG in all circumstances tested. In contrast, in vitro lesion bypass studies showed that HOPdG causes misincorporation opposite the modified base and is a block to replication. The combination of these studies showed that HOPdG is not miscoding in vivo at the level of sensitivity of these site-specific mutagenesis assays.     

A RecA homologue in Ustilago maydis that is distinct and evolutionarily distant from Rad51 actively promotes DNA pairing reactions in the absence of auxiliary factors

Two RecA homologues have been identified to date in Ustilago maydis. One is orthologous to Rad51 while the other, Rec2, is structurally quite divergent and evolutionarily distant. DNA repair and recombination proficiency in U. maydis requires both Rec2 and Rad51. Here we have examined biochemical activities of Rec2 protein purified after overexpression of the cloned gene. Rec2 requires DNA as a cofactor to hydrolyze ATP and depends on ATP to promote homologous pairing and DNA strand exchange. ATPgammaS was found to substitute for ATP in all pairing reactions examined. With superhelical DNA and a homologous single-stranded oligonucleotide as substrates, Rec2 actively promoted formation and dissociation of D-loops. When an RNA oligonucleotide was substituted it was found that R-loops could also be formed and utilized as primer/template for limited DNA synthesis. In DNA strand exchange reactions using oligonucleotides, we found that Rec2 exhibited a pairing bias that is opposite that of RecA. Single-stranded oligonucleotides were activated for DNA strand exchange when attached as tails protruding from a duplex sequence due to enhanced binding of Rec2. The results indicate that Rec2 is competent, and in certain ways even better than Rad51, in the ability to provide the fundamental DNA pairing activity necessary for recombinational repair. We propose that the emerging paradigm for homologous recombination featuring Rad51 as the essential catalytic component for strand exchange may not be universal in eukaryotes.     

Nuclease activity of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Mre11 functions in targeted nucleotide alteration

Oligonucleotides can be used to direct site-specific changes in genomic DNA through a process in which mismatched base pairs in the oligonucleotide and the target DNA are created. The mechanism by which these complexes are developed and resolved is being studied by using Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a model system. Genetic analyses have revealed that in all likelihood the reaction occurs in two phases: DNA pairing and DNA repair. While the former phase involves strand assimilation, the latter phase likely involves an endonucleolytic processing step that leads to joint resolution. In this study, we established the importance of a functioning MRE11 gene in the overall reaction, as yeast strains deficient in MRE11 exhibited severely reduced activity. The activity could be rescued by complementation with wild-type MRE11 genes but not with MRE11 alleles lacking the nuclease function. Taken together, the data suggest that Mre11 provides nuclease activity for targeted nucleotide exchange, a process that could be used to reengineer yeast genes.     

Targeted gene repair and its application to neurodegenerative disorders

Synthetic DNA oligonucleotides can direct the exchange of single nucleotides within coding regions of mammalian genes by hybridizing to their complementary sequence in the chromosome and creating a recombination joint structure with a single mismatched base pair. Inherent DNA repair processes recognize the mismatch and resolve it using the DNA sequence of the oligonucleotide vector as the template. This gene surgery approach can be used to repair mutations or to disrupt tri-nucleotide repeats in dysfunctional genes responsible for neurological disorders.     

Nuclear extracts promote gene correction and strand pairing of oligonucleotides to the homologous plasmid

We compared strand pairing and gene correction activities between different constructs of oligonucleotides, using homologous supercoiled DNA and eukaryotic nuclear extracts. The RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotide was more efficient in strand pairing and gene correction than its DNA-DNA homolog. Single-stranded deoxyoligonucleotides showed similar strand pairing and correction activity to the modified RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotides, whereas single-stranded ribooligonucleotides did not show either activity. However, the correlations were not always linear, suggesting that only a fraction of the joint molecules may be processed to cause the final gene correction. Several mammalian extracts with markedly different in vitro activity showed the similar amounts of the joint molecules. These results led us to conclude that strand pairing is a necessary event in gene correction but may not be the rate-limiting step. Furthermore, depletion of HsRad51 protein caused large decreases in both strand-pairing and functional activities, whereas supplementation of HsRad51 produced only a slight increase in the repair activity, indicating that HsRad51 participates in the strand pairing, but subsequent steps define the frequency of gene correction. In addition, we found that the structure and stability of intermediates formed by single-stranded deoxyoligonucleotides and RNA-DNA chimeric oligonucleotides were different, suggesting that they differ in their mechanisms of gene repair.     

Repair of specific base pair mismatches formed during meiotic recombination in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Heteroduplexes formed between DNA strands derived from different homologous chromosomes are an intermediate in meiotic crossing over in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and other eucaryotes. A heteroduplex formed between wild-type and mutant genes will contain a base pair mismatch; failure to repair this mismatch will lead to postmeiotic segregation (PMS). By analyzing the frequency of PMS for various mutant alleles in the yeast HIS4 gene, we showed that C/C mismatches were inefficiently repaired relative to all other point mismatches. These other mismatches (G/G, G/A, T/T, A/A, T/C, C/A, A/A, and T/G) were repaired with approximately the same efficiency. We found that in spores with unrepaired mismatches in heteroduplexes, the nontranscribed strand of the HIS4 gene was more frequently donated than the transcribed strand. In addition, the direction of repair for certain mismatches was nonrandom.     

The mutation frequency of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxodG) situated in a multiply damaged site: comparison of a single and two closely opposed 8-oxodG in Escherichia coli

A multiply damaged site (MDS) is defined as > or =2 lesions within a distance of 10-15 base pairs (bp). MDS generated by ionizing radiation contain oxidative base damage, and in vitro studies have indicated that if the base damage is <3bp apart, repair of one lesion is inhibited until repair of the lesion in the opposite strand is completed. Inhibition of repair could result in an increase in the mutation frequency of the base damage. We have designed an assay to determine whether a closely opposed lesion causes an increase in adenine insertion opposite an 8-oxodG in bacteria. We have positioned the MDS (an 8-oxodG in the transcribed strand and a second 8-oxodG immediately 5' to this lesion in the non-transcribed strand) within the firefly luciferase coding region. During two rounds of replication, insertion of adenine opposite the 8-oxodG in the transcribed (T) or non-transcribed (NT) strand results in a translation termination codon at position 444 or 445, respectively. The truncated luciferase protein is inactive. We have generated double-stranded oligonucleotides that contain no damage, each single 8-oxodG or the MDS. Each double-stranded molecule was ligated into the reporter vector and the ligation products transformed into wild-type or Mut Y-deficient bacteria. The plasmid DNA was isolated and sequenced from colonies that did not express luciferase activity. In wild-type bacteria, we detected a translation stop at a frequency of 0.15% (codon 444) and 0.09% (codon 445) with a single 8-oxodG in the T or NT strand, respectively. This was enhanced approximately 3-fold when single lesions were replicated in Mut Y-deficient bacteria. Positioning an 8-oxodG in the T strand within the MDS enhanced the mutation frequency by approximately 2-fold in wild-type bacteria and 8-fold in Mut Y-deficient bacteria, while the mutation frequency of the 8-oxodG in the NT strand increased by 6-fold in Mut Y-deficient bacteria. This enhancement of mutation frequency supports the in vitro MDS studies, which demonstrated the inability of base excision repair to completely repair closely opposed lesions.